Ningning’s such a flexible singer!! From low to high sounds, from deeper/fuller to sweeter tones, incredible!! Wish she (and Giselle) had longer clips but that just shows she can often nail the part on the first try.
That just means Ning does not need to take so long in the recording booth like the other members even tho she has the most parts.. She easily does the things told by the producer... Easy peasy for her... That maybe they don't have much clips cuz she records fast😎🔥
I think this video proves that the producers have to stick to their vision of the song..so thats why the free spirited and stylisation like Giselle struggle to show her colour in their songs even though shes trying so hard to put it out..
Vocal fry demands severe training that they don't have to preserve their voice. Reminder if the song doesn't call for it don't bother as it can harm the singer more than you think and knowing that they aren't even trained to do so. Vocal fry demands the singer go lower and that's mostly a classical trait and they aren't trained classically to achieve that. Don't bother putting up a fight, you know nothing by the sounds of it.
@@li9931 I can't believe you are trying to victimize her in this She has less time because she has less takes, that means she did well and didn't need to do it again, like what??? You wanted them to show her going home after or...? She even has the most lines, with Ning Ning, in this song, she got the hairstyle that catches the eye the most, looks fabulous, got to show her vocal and rap, she was the center for A LOT of this song And yet... I see so many solo stans complaining over the dumbest things, she should be praised for having less time if anything, this song was made for her she got the tone of it so fast. Her solo stans try to make her a victim so often that they don't even praise her (meanwhile ignoring what Ning Ning and Karina go through) Have some sense, praise her, don't pull her back when she's doing so well.
I just love how Giselle explains the song as always. Her explanation makes me fall in love with the song. Totally get the mood! Also when she sings the part like a whiplash i can really feel it
여성 디렉터님 너무 좋아요 곡에 대한 이해도와 멤버들의 실력도 잘 알고 믿고 계셔서 더 맛깔나게 만들어주시는 거 너무 감사하고 대단하세요🖤 멤버들이랑 케미도 넘 좋아요🥹 팬심 다 빼고 그냥 뭔가 저기서 같이 일하고 싶다 하게 된달까요🤣 이번 곡도 너무 세련 되고 미감 미쳤오용 모든 회사 분들 에스파 멤버들 다 고생하셨어요🖤🖤🖤🖤
Karina's aura and her energetic vibe on that day was exuding so much confidence. On top of that, she was nailing down all her lines and looking that pretty with glasses on even made the producers confused and scared lol 😂
Winter describes this really well in that it sounds simple but really isn't. The beauty of the vocals in this song is the subtlety of tone delivery, intonation and accuracy in pronunciation on the delivery of each word on each beat. It really is a 'less is more' type of song. Delivering simple words with colour isn't as easy as people think. If it was easy, it would just sound like monotone reading of lyric to a beat. Nice work AESPA.
hearing aespa recording their raw vocals is a must bcs it's so satisfying, like girlie have visuals, coolest concept, and amazing vocals, how a complete package!
Yesss. I don't really listen to a lot of Aespa but Winter's voice for this song really stood out to me. And now seeing what a perfectionist she is in this is making me a fan lol.
I LIVE for Giselle's sass and Ning Ning's absolute snark and chic control of her voice! SM really hit the GOLD MINE with Aespa - They are SO BEAUTIFUL AND TALENTED! They completely dominated this year - I really hope the award shows recognize their efforts more! WE LOVE YOU QUEENS!
All the ladies are all perfectionists! But Ning Ning made it like this song is easy peasy! Winter stressing out but made it wonderfully, Karina is so hyper, and Giselle's suggestions to add more color and vibe to the song. 👌👏😘😍🥰🤩
@@Analou13 I know but everytime this person above sprung out like mole in winter praising part section and saying ningning this that like she is this person's daughter or what. Always and other members are nothing. This person always give unnecessary hype to ning ning. Yeah she is talented but other also should get their praises. Others are also not less than ning ning. Even I am huge winter fan but also I praise other members talent. If that person want to praise then comment in ning ning section and don't degrade other members. That person is always delusion for ning ning like someday she will be president or queen of a nation. Is She participating in election or what?
when i first heard Whiplash, i was like "this doesn't really do justice to their vocals" but after keep repeating it, dudeeeee i'm telling you. the technics are next level 🥲
Karina is great at catching the song vibes, following instruction, and have so much fun time doing the recording the producers are laughing with her. Sunshine girl 😊
![[R(ae)cord] aespa 에스파 ‘Armageddon’ Recording Behind The Scenes](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TDeVyISAt6Y/mqdefault.jpg)
![[R(ae)cord] aespa 에스파 ‘Armageddon’ Recording Behind The Scenes](/img/tr.png)
![[R(ae)cord] 미니 5집 ‘Whiplash’ 많이 사랑해 주세요⚙️ | 에스파 ‘위플래시’ MV 비하인드 (aespa ‘Whiplash’ MV Behind)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XScl_HVu2es/mqdefault.jpg)
바로 레코딩 풀어버리는 스엠의 자신감 ......... ㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷ
아니 다시와보니 댓글 무슨 일 ㅠㅠ 이 댓글 봐주겠지 에깅이들 너무 사랑해 유지민 김민정 애리 닝이줘
앞으로도 마니마니 노래해주고 활동도 해줘 항상 응원할게 - 올해 3년차 마이 -
👍👍👍👍
Frrr
👍🏻👍🏻
솔직히 내가 관계자라도 자랑하고 싶을듯
맞잖아
스엠은 이게 맞아
아직까지는 아이돌 근본 회사는 스엠.
올해는 진심 에스파의해였음.. 걸그룹 원탑이다 진짜
ㄹㅇ 진짜 휘몰아쳤음 그냥 걸그룹 표본임 뭐라 더 할 말이 없음
대상 안 타면 세상이 날 억까하는 느낌일 듯
cap
ㄹㅇ...
아이돌 원탑임,,,진심
역시 실력이 있으니 자신있게 바로 레코딩 공개하는게 너무 멋짐....
ㄹ이랑 비교된당ㅋㅋ
꼬옥 칭찬댓에 비교답글은 꼭 있네
@@bbyee4060비교 하지 마세요 이럴수록 에스파 욕먹이는 겁니다
@@honamsun7 엔믹스는 음반이 넘아쉬움 ㅜ 진짜 실력 짱짱이들인데
@@honamsun7ㄹㅇ
aespa's vocals aren't just about power, they have great techniques. It's not dull, it's so nice to listen to.
Sm train very well their artist they the better vocalist
Yes
Ningning’s such a flexible singer!! From low to high sounds, from deeper/fuller to sweeter tones, incredible!! Wish she (and Giselle) had longer clips but that just shows she can often nail the part on the first try.
Fr 🎀✨
That just means Ning does not need to take so long in the recording booth like the other members even tho she has the most parts.. She easily does the things told by the producer... Easy peasy for her... That maybe they don't have much clips cuz she records fast😎🔥
ningning barely needs guidance. she's genius. aespa is truly a group with gems. i love you aespa
the cut to winter standing against the wall like she’s in time out has me crying
Minjeong so cute🫠
_Yeah!_
Where she's facing the wall with her head leaning? lol 😂
difference between her and karina
@frz3rbRnotaku1 10:40
This is why giselle is the backbone of aespa, she supports the other members so well and really adds color and style
I think this video proves that the producers have to stick to their vision of the song..so thats why the free spirited and stylisation like Giselle struggle to show her colour in their songs even though shes trying so hard to put it out..
holy glaze
아니 여자 디렉터가 진짜 일잘한다 핵심만 딱딱 집어줌
진심요!!!!!!!! 곡이랑 멤버들의 역량을 더 높여주시는 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 멤버들의 실력을 잘 아시고 믿고 곡에 대한 이해도도 엄청 높으신게 잘보여요ㅠㅠㅠ 거기다 케미도 너무 좋고🥰🥰 여성 디렉님 많이 나와주세용
@@hjkl-z2x어휴 ㅉ
@@hjkl-z2x 아니 진심 어쩌라는거지..ㅋㅋㅋ
@@hjkl-z2x누가 둘이 비교하자고 함? 혼자 왜 이래 ㅋㅋ
@@hjkl-z2x 남자들은 왜이럴까 진짜 개복치노
I loved to hear Ningning experimenting more with lots of rapping using lots of vocal fry.
she was really feeling this song
Your comment geeting blue search???
is this Katriinka reference? Haha
whiplash is truly ningning's era, both in terms of vocals and styling. i feel she is most confident this era!!
Vocal fry demands severe training that they don't have to preserve their voice.
Reminder if the song doesn't call for it don't bother as it can harm the singer more than you think and knowing that they aren't even trained to do so.
Vocal fry demands the singer go lower and that's mostly a classical trait and they aren't trained classically to achieve that.
Don't bother putting up a fight, you know nothing by the sounds of it.
멤버들 보컬이 지금 완전 정점인듯 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그냥 부드럽고 쫀득하고 와일드하고 다 하네ㅋㅋ
0:01 닝닝
6:48 윈터
18:58 카리나
28:32 지젤
thank you❤❤
Thank you From El Salvador
I am really obsessed with Karina's vocal tone. It's so unique like the best I've ever heard
broooo i cant with her voice, the switch up in it are insane
she's too perfect
Me too, I always have a type for this kind of tone.
IKRRRR ITS SO CRISPY AND CHIC AND SASSY AND POWERFUL, WE STAN A VOCAL KWEEN
IKR! It's like, whenever she open her mouth, the only word and tone that come out is "PERFECT! PERFECT! PERFECT!"
26:19 이 파트 녹음하는 거 들을수록 이게 오토튠이 아니라 100% 본인 목소리라는 게 너무 신기하다 진짜..
NOBODY TOUCHING AESPA'S VOCAL PROWESS AND SKILL. They are the moment!
Ok
dude why tf you’re everywhere i saw a few shorts the replies are ALLL same by the same acc it’s so fkin weird for some reason
@@sushiirolll FOR REALLLL
how to block someone on youtube please
OK❤
26:25 확성기 댄 거 같은 효과가 쌩목소리로도 나는구나 개좋다
카리나 음색 진짜 유니크해서 너무 좋음
보컬이 비주얼급임ㅋㅋ
진심 소름돋음 실력이 너무 좋아서
헐 그냥 마이크에 가까이 대고 불러서 그런건 줄 알았는데
효과음같은데 아닌가
Giselle is such a *vocal genius* . The way her voice changing in the rap and vocal parts is just amazing !!
And they just give her 6 minutes in the whole video ☠️
@@li9931💀💀
Agreed! She always adds spice to the song and it really gives the song personality and flow!
@@li9931 But she served all of the music video.
@@li9931 I can't believe you are trying to victimize her in this
She has less time because she has less takes, that means she did well and didn't need to do it again, like what??? You wanted them to show her going home after or...?
She even has the most lines, with Ning Ning, in this song, she got the hairstyle that catches the eye the most, looks fabulous, got to show her vocal and rap, she was the center for A LOT of this song
And yet... I see so many solo stans complaining over the dumbest things, she should be praised for having less time if anything, this song was made for her she got the tone of it so fast.
Her solo stans try to make her a victim so often that they don't even praise her (meanwhile ignoring what Ning Ning and Karina go through)
Have some sense, praise her, don't pull her back when she's doing so well.
28:40 다 좋은데 지젤 목소리 나오자마자 좋아서 경악함.. 이건 진짜 지젤 노래다
지젤 진짜 쫀딕함+힙함 원탑..개핫걸임
빈밷~.. 이부분 처도름
뭔가 찹쌀떡처럼 제일 찰짐... 느낌 잘 살림 지젤
진짜 딕션이 찹쌀떡같음 겁나 쫀득해
제 노랜데요
다들 곡 작업 참여 한 뒤로 녹음할 때 이건 어떤지 하면서 의견내는 게 더 많아져서 넘 보기 좋다 자기만의 색깔에 대해 점점 알아가는 것 같아서 내가 다 뿌듯해
Giselle's tone of voice really suits whiplash, her pronunciation is perfect
이걸 바로 주네 갓스파 기세대로 쭉 가자
I just love how Giselle explains the song as always. Her explanation makes me fall in love with the song. Totally get the mood!
Also when she sings the part like a whiplash i can really feel it
윈터 디렉터분이 잘했다고 해도 자기가 아쉬우니까 계속 해보는거 넘 좋다 완벽함을 추구하는게 거기다 디렉터분도 윈터가 뭘 아쉬워 하는지 아니까 바로바로 피드백 주면서 완성된게 너무 조타
이번 음원 듣고 좀 놀랐네요 작곡가들이 사실 게임음악이나 영화예고편음악 만드는 애들인데 진짜 잘 뽑은 것 같아요. 24시간 들어도 안지겨움
아 그래서…. 뭔가 알고 들으니까 진짜 게임이나 해외 액션영화 액션장면에서 나올 것 같네요
애들 클래스 ㄷㄷ 이정도 퀄이면 존대가 저절로 나오지 않나 ㅋ
작곡가보고 애들이라고 부르는 클라스...
@@Haemalgm저정도는….. 괜찮은 것 같은데.. 업계에서도 자주 써요.. 보통 엄청난 대가가 아닌 이상 굳이 존칭써가며 존대하고 그러진 않는데
@@Haemalgm
여성 디렉터님 너무 좋아요 곡에 대한 이해도와 멤버들의 실력도 잘 알고 믿고 계셔서 더 맛깔나게 만들어주시는 거 너무 감사하고 대단하세요🖤 멤버들이랑 케미도 넘 좋아요🥹 팬심 다 빼고 그냥 뭔가 저기서 같이 일하고 싶다 하게 된달까요🤣 이번 곡도 너무 세련 되고 미감 미쳤오용 모든 회사 분들 에스파 멤버들 다 고생하셨어요🖤🖤🖤🖤
Karina's aura and her energetic vibe on that day was exuding so much confidence. On top of that, she was nailing down all her lines and looking that pretty with glasses on even made the producers confused and scared lol 😂
영상이 실력으로 꽉꽉 차있음.. 너무 좋음..
민정이 이렇게 어려워하고 헤메는거 첨보는 것 같다 신기해 정말 아무렇지 않게 항상 잘 해내는 것 같은데 뒤엔 항상 저런 노력이 있어,,, 멋진녀성
보컬 레이어링은 최고 수준이며 음표는 완벽하게 맞고 보컬은 안정적입니다. 당신은 정말 보컬의 원더 에스파입니다!
Why did u say this same comment in English and Korean?
@@enxamor This guy used a translator
@@호옹 probably
@@enxamorbecause his goal is to spam as many comments as possible
@@doublethenun yeah
스엠 가수들은 노래하는거 진짜 좋아함ㅋㅋ
실력이 탄탄하니 그냥 뭘해도 우리 하고싶은거 한다 이런 컨셉 너무 좋아
뻔하디뻔한 이지리스닝? 스엠에겐 어울리지 않아 함부로 타협하지는 않지
위플래시가 스엠곡에서 처음으로 티저와 괴리감이 안드는 곡이었음
그래서 소름이었다
😂😂
소시부터 레벨 에스파... 까지 레코딩 영상 다보는데... 진짜 에셈 애들은 레코딩 할때 긴장을 안해... 오히려 의견도 하면서 즐기는게 보여ㅎㅎ
10:54 느끼?싶었는 과하지않게 딱1t넣네 천재인가
32:32 찢었다 에리야....이번 곡 진짜 다 잘 어울리는데 특히 지젤이 그냥 미쳤음 요즘 감다살 미쳤다 SM 이렇게만 계속 해줘요
역대급 A&R 아니예요?? 우리 애스파 이렇게 잘디렉해줘서 감사해요 ㅠㅠ
에스파입니다
윈터 파트는 진짜 노래하기도 어려운 파트같은데 음색부터 보컬까지 진심 고결하게 느껴짐 분위기랑 톤이랑 발음까지 세세하게 디렉터님이랑 피드백하며 결과물 뽑이내는게 진짜 가수다...
sm은 실력으로 깔 수가 없음 진짜 기본기 탄탄한 사람만 살아남을 수 있는 ㅠ 너무 잘해ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Winter describes this really well in that it sounds simple but really isn't. The beauty of the vocals in this song is the subtlety of tone delivery, intonation and accuracy in pronunciation on the delivery of each word on each beat. It really is a 'less is more' type of song. Delivering simple words with colour isn't as easy as people think. If it was easy, it would just sound like monotone reading of lyric to a beat. Nice work AESPA.
모든 멤이 올해 하이커리어 찍었지만 그 중에서도 애리가 진짜…… 미친거같음…. 헤메코도 헤메콘데… 모든 노래에서 진짜 음색이…. 보컬 올라오는게 너무너무 좋아서 소름돋음…. ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 사랑해……
Although Giselle is not as praised as other members, but she did insanely amazing this comeback ❤️
She is pretty ❤❤
she's sooo talented ❤️
no, actually she received a lot of praise on this comeback
@@aeribuani mean this video 😅
So far I’ve seen more compliments than she normally gets she definitely deserves it ❤
21:11 IM SO OBSESSED WITH KARINA’S VOICE LIKE IT SOUNDS THE EXACT SAME LIKE THE SONG AND HER VOICE IS SO ADDICTING I WISH I HAD HER VOICE-
15:10 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ여기 너무 웃기다ㅋㅋㅋ 디렉터님의 무조건적 믿음
디렉있고 다시 부를 때마다 더 좋아지는게 느껴짐 ㄷㄷ 좋은 실력과 그걸 더 이끌어내는 디렉팅의 완벽한 합작이다
Ningning vibing 2:47
Karina vibing 22:20
Giselle - hiding from camera 😭
And then there's Winter 10:40 15:44 16:41 17:33
Winter is effortlessly funny in those clips. She's like a child in time out
rethinking life choices 😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
hearing aespa recording their raw vocals is a must bcs it's so satisfying, like girlie have visuals, coolest concept, and amazing vocals, how a complete package!
Winter's voice tho😭😭 how is that a voice without an autotune u gotta be kidding me
Yesss. I don't really listen to a lot of Aespa but Winter's voice for this song really stood out to me. And now seeing what a perfectionist she is in this is making me a fan lol.
@@bl00dFairyagree
Her tone sounds exactly the same as with autotune..Such a sweet and unique voice .. It's pleasing to listen to her .
Literally obsessed with vocals of *winter* 🎀✨
대 황 에 스 파
4세대 걸그룹 중 감히 누가 에스파에 견줄 수 있을까 올해 활동으로 4세대 탑티어 입지를 단단히 굳혀버렸네 자랑스럽다
@reporve887 뉴진스럽네;;
@reporve887뉴진스가 연초 유명아이돌들 없는 비수기때 달성한 Ditto 최장기간 1위기록을 라이벌 그룹들 다 컴백한 성수기때 에스파가 최장기간 1위기록을 깼는데 ㅋㅋㅋ 민천지들 뉴진스럽네 ㅉㅉ
@@namchulkim7326저거 뉴진스팬아닐듯 괜히 싸워서 좋을거없음
@reporve887싸패토끼단은 진짜 아무데나 시비걸고다니네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 니네 글로벌 성적은 르세라핌한테 따였고 국내성적은 에스파한테 따였어요.. 세계최초 국정감사돌 ㄷㄷ
@@Psyxho_KalguksuBunny관종인데 싸패토끼단이라니 ㅋ 말 예쁘게 쓰세요
올해 활동으로 에스파라는 그룹의 이미지와 이름을 제대로 각인 시킨 것 같네요.. 위 플래시 활동 화이팅!!
아니.. 닝이는 또 왜케 잘해… 완전 원샷원킬인데.. 보컬 위플래시랑 찰떡이야..
I LIVE for Giselle's sass and Ning Ning's absolute snark and chic control of her voice! SM really hit the GOLD MINE with Aespa - They are SO BEAUTIFUL AND TALENTED! They completely dominated this year - I really hope the award shows recognize their efforts more! WE LOVE YOU QUEENS!
All the ladies are all perfectionists! But Ning Ning made it like this song is easy peasy! Winter stressing out but made it wonderfully, Karina is so hyper, and Giselle's suggestions to add more color and vibe to the song. 👌👏😘😍🥰🤩
But winter is the miss perfectionist. She always checks and reviews her every details both while singing and dancing.
everything is easy for ningning lol
@@mypearlb5208 I think for you. And your delusional thought 😂😂
@@itachiuchiha5419They're not delusional? She nails alot of things with ease and is talented.
@@Analou13 I know but everytime this person above sprung out like mole in winter praising part section and saying ningning this that like she is this person's daughter or what. Always and other members are nothing. This person always give unnecessary hype to ning ning. Yeah she is talented but other also should get their praises. Others are also not less than ning ning. Even I am huge winter fan but also I praise other members talent. If that person want to praise then comment in ning ning section and don't degrade other members. That person is always delusion for ning ning like someday she will be president or queen of a nation. Is She participating in election or what?
Winter's vocals is sooo addicting. Her vocal tone is angelic and soothing. how can someone singing that smooth without autotune???
when i first heard Whiplash, i was like "this doesn't really do justice to their vocals"
but after keep repeating it, dudeeeee i'm telling you. the technics are next level 🥲
Fr
What Winter said is so true
이런 녹음 비하인드씬도 다 콘텐츠가 된다는게 새삼 대단하다 싶네요. 신선하고 좋습니다~
Karina is great at catching the song vibes, following instruction, and have so much fun time doing the recording the producers are laughing with her. Sunshine girl 😊
매번 느끼지만 디렉팅도 진짜 아무나 하는게 아니구나… 디렉팅 의도가 뭔지 우리는 모르겠으나 입력하면 찰떡같이 알아듣고 산출 되는게 왕 신기함ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 디렉팅도…멤바들도… 실력 짱짱…
17:33 (혼나는 거 아님) 너무 귀여운거 아닌가요!!
GISELLEEEE WITH DIM LIGHTS IN EVERY RECORDING THEY HAVE IS THE MOOD SETTER
Winter's voice is like a drug soooooo addictive ❤️👏🏽
agree
유지민 잔뜩 신났네ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 녹음실이 이렇게 분위기 좋은거 첨봄 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 귀ㅕㅇ워
SMってアーティストの実力に誇りを持ってるところが好き
何においてもaespaが最強すぎて時代作ってる
It’s not a normal thing that automatically we can watch with subtitles… thank u and love you alllllllllxxx, and the song is sooo amazing!!!!!!! ❤
영상 업로드 속도 실화냐... 감사합니다 감오합니다 감육합니다 사랑합니다 오랑합니다 육랑합니다
진짜 4세대 여돌들 중 제일 잘하는 것 같음
그리고 ㄹㅇ 목소리 톤이 미쳤어
어제 에스파 팬튜브 개설했어요!!
많은 관심 부탁드립니다 🥰
엔믹스... 키오라... 베이비몬스터...
ㄹㅇ 톤이 사기같음 튠을 안 깔았는데 음색이 너무 유니크함
@@Haemalgm키오라가 아니고 키오프입니다.
@@Haemalgm그냥 넘어가주세용 그분들 잘하는거 다 아는 사실이니까
THE LAYERING OF VOCALS ARE TOP NOTCH, THE NOTES ARE PERFECTLY HIT AND THEIR VOCLAS ARE STABLE; Really the vocal wonder you are aespa!
It's beautiful to see the professionalism of the k-pop industry, and the care they have for the processes of each production.
녹음 비하인드 보고 듣고 싶어서 에스파 맨날 컴백해주면 좋겠음(?) ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
무대도 뮤비도 미치게 좋지만 녹음실 에스파는 그저 갓갓갓갓 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
メンバーの能力の高さは勿論、ディレクターの方やスタッフさんが沢山褒めてくれたり意見ちゃんと聞いて本人が納得するまで付き合ってくれるのが良すぎる…そんでもって本当に皆うますぎる。そんままじゃん…最高だ。まさにaespaって曲だね。
This the first time we see Ningning record first, the song really does fit her the most. But they all sound great of course
닝닝 마지막 음 끄는거..? 라고 해야 되나 그거 미쳤음 너무 좋아
진짜 자랑스럽다…
에스파 파면실력으로 보답해주니..❤
스엠 조은 점...
모든 그룹 모든 멤버가 노래를 잘하니까 레코딩 비하인드를 막 30분 40분씩 풀어줌... 너무 좋당
THEY HIT HIGH NOTES PERFECTLY, THEIR LAYERING IS SO DETAILED AND VOCALS STABLE IN EVERY NOTES; Now that is our vocal wonder aespa!
Winters vocals are just sublime~ She can make her voice melt into every genre it's crazy!
the way karina shined in the song with only one proper line is legendary 💙 queen behaviour indeed
Ningning is so mesmerizing, I love her vocal tone and swag rap parts in this song!~ she's doing amazing
Ning sings so fluedly. She sings like its so easy broo...She's a profesional
에스파는 이렇게 실력도 좋구...얼굴도 이쁘고 그렇니까 라이브도 자신감있게 할 수 있는거 같음.
29:25 끝음 끄는 거 너무 좋음..
원래도 잘했는데 모든 멤버가 매컴백마다 실력이 더 늘어오는게 진짜 호감
aespa has the best 4 girls that have super multitalents. I love their nice vocals 💯🖤✨
디렉 진짜 잘보신다...팬도 아닌데 에스파 노래 나올때마다 디렉 보는거 재밌어서 레코딩 찾아봄
카리나 저음은 가히 독보적이다 항상 짜릿해 늘 새로워
Winter has angelic vocals💕🧚
If I am a producer, Ning will be my fave singer❤ she absorbs everything soooo fast❤ that you barely need to correct her and do a lot of takes❤
좀만 볼까 했는데 언제 34분짜리를 다 봤지... 소통 잘 되고 의욕적이고 디렉팅 바로바로 소화하니까 보는 내가 개운하닼ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 에스파 멋있어😊
지젤 극락파트가 괜히 나오는게 아닌 것 같움.. 어떻게 하면 더 예쁠 것 같다, 뭐는 별로였고 뭐는 좋았던 것 같다 함서 자기가 내는 소리 중에 뭐가 예쁘게 잘 쓰일지를 너무 잘 아는 듯ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅇㅈ
디렉팅 분위기 넘 좋다!!!
확실히 전성기를 맞이하고 있는 에스파!
본업 잘하는 가수 만나 마이들도 얼마나 행복할까🙂
이야~ 바로 레코딩 올려주는거 봐~ 역시 라이브는 에스파다❤
멤버들 목소리 톤이 진짜 너무 좋다,, 닝닝 2:03 이 파트 넘 쥬음
댓글 쭉 보는데 언급 안되는 멤버가 없음 어떻게 네명이 다 잘해 ㄷㄷ 대 에스파
윈터 진짜 대박이다 음색 너무 이쁨 팬도 아닌데 보게되네
omg, I can't handle how adorable ningning with her cute little cat sounds >
디렉해주시는 분들 부터가 즐겁게 하는게 느껴진다 멤버들이 넘넘 잘해서😊
おお公開早いね。エスパちゃんのレコーディング大好き。歌を自由自在に楽しめる実力があるのよね✨
와 카리나 진짜 보컬 점점 더더더 잘함
They are really talented and I'm proud to be their fan
Winter has always been my favorite voice in aespa. Her tone is unique and captivating.
The way Karina sang Unforgettable, just wow❤️🔥🩵
I AGREEEEEEEEEEE
frrr she belted tf outta that part
26:07
26:12 here!
aespaメンバーの音楽性の高さには毎回驚かされる……消化能力高すぎる