Milwaukee Barrel Grip Jigsaw (2737B-20) vs. Milwaukee D-Handle Jigsaw (2737-20) Tool Duel Episode #5
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ม.ค. 2019
- Today we are putting the Milwaukee M18 Fuel Barrel grip jig saw up against the Milwaukee M18 Fuel D Handle jigsaw to help you decide which may fit your needs best
Buy Here!
Barrel Grip Saw homedepot.sjv.io/2jVqg
M18 FUEL 18-Volt Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless Barrel Grip Jig Saw (Tool Only) up against the
Power to cut hard materials, including hardwoods and metals
Features 6 speed settings 0-3500 strokes per minute
Compatible with over 175+ tools on the M18 Platform
Milwaukee M18 D Handle Jig Saw homedepot.sjv.io/2jVqg
The M18 FUEL Brushless Cordless D-Handle Jig Saw combines power, blade speed and precision, to provide the highest quality cuts in a wide variety of materials. The M18 FUEL D-Handle Jig saw leverages the POWERSTATE Brushless Motor and REDLINK PLUS Intelligence to provide higher blade speed than corded jig saws at 3500 strokes per minute for clean controlled cuts with minimized chipping or bucking. Leveraging the M18 REDLITHIUM XC 5.0 Ah battery the M18 FUEL D-Handle Jig Saw provides up to 105 lin. ft. of cutting in laminated particle board, delivering all day productivity with less trips to the charger. The saw features tool-less blade change, tool free bevel adjust with detents at 0, 15, 30, and 45 as well as an LED light and on/off blower to keep the cut line visible while cutting.
POWERSTATE brushless motor: increased SPM and the power to cut hard materials, including hardwoods and metals
REDLINK PLUS intelligence: the most advanced system of cordless power tool electronics, provides optimized performance and overload protection using total system communication between tool, battery and charger
REDLITHIUM battery technology: superior pack construction, electronics and performance deliver more work per charge and more work over pack life than any battery on the market
4-position orbital cutting provides versatility for application specific cutting
Tool free shoe bevel with positive stops allows for quick and accurate shoe adjustment with detents at 0, 15, 30 and 45
Variable speed trigger between 0 and 3500 strokes per minute, providing precise control for clean cuts with less chipping
On/off cut line blower keeps the cut line clear of debris and allows user to turn off blower when using dust extraction
LED light illuminates the cut line
Accepts T-shank jig saw blades
Includes dust cover and dust extraction tube
Includes non-marring shoe cover for protection of finished surfaces
Compatible with over 175 plus tools on the M18 platform
Compatible with all M18 batteries
Something to note, the D handle is a safer design. Hands off = tool off, since you have to hold the trigger for it to operate.
Here I go again watching tool reviews knowing I don’t need more.... BUT I WANT MORE
Hahaha 🤣👊
Good review and if you check Amazon, you'd see many bad reviews for the D handle saw such as lever loosening while working, angle not holding when doing straight cuts, other incidents (Mine had a pin guide issue also so now I must not apply too much force, else, something else would get damaged in the mechanics and I need to hold the
lever while working to keep on the line.) and I'm now considering Hilti or Festool brand because when going threw
hard wood, many tools would have issues. Five stars for communication, tech. skill, experience for you⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Nice side by side, but I’m a barrel grip person all day long!!
I think a lot of people are going to go with the barrel grip too broski
Yeah, I agree. Not have to pull that trigger helps too. I think each one have their different advantages.
Bevel is better on d handle but the auto is better on the barrel having both wouldn't be bad
What is the diff or the purpose for having two different model? What’s the benefit of barrel grip over d?
You like holding long shafts huh? Hahaha
This is an excellent review! Thanks for taking the time and giving me what I needed to make the right choice for my needs.
Very informative, thanks for posting this comparison. I like both but the on/off trigger mechanism on the barrel grip would take some getting used to.
Here’s a scenario which I know is not something an experienced tool user would see. If the blade snags and causes the tool to jump out of thin gauge flexible sheet metal like that on a van roof. Instead of instinctively releasing pressure on the trigger I might fumble for that switch. This is a common occurrence with rookie tool users tackling their first conversion, by not applying enough downward force to a flexible panel with RPM too low.
I use the barrel grip exclusively for coping with a Collins coping foot installed. D handle for most other applications. Love both!
After reading the comments and taking in the fact that I only ever use a D handle bevel for odd exterior under cutting situations, I will go for the Barrel for my finishing work and I still have a old Gen1 D Handle.
This was a great tool review, thanks so much. I have both saws.
The D Handle! Great tool, got it last month. I was deciding between the both tools when I was first looking for a jigsaw. Now I've seen this video I've made the right choice. My brother has the old barrel grip great tool to, but not comfortable in the hand and you need plenty of operating room for it, "to long" that's why I went with the D Handle. Thanks for the video.
Thanks for the comment!
Good review and if you check Amazon, you'd see many bad reviews for the D handle saw such as lever loosening while working, angle not holding when doing straight cuts, other incidents (Mine had a pin guide issue also so now I must not apply too much force, else, something else would get damaged in the mechanics and I need to hold the
lever while working to keep on the line.) and I'm now considering Hilti or Festool brand because when going threw
hard wood, many tools would have issues. Five stars for communication, tech. skill, experience for you⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Just picked up the Milwaukee D handle today at Home Depot. $199. I got a free 5 amp XC deal with it. I chose the D handle because I already have a "corded" Bosch barrel I bought over 20 years ago. Can't wait to see how it feels to use a cordless jig saw.
I’ve been using a jigsaw regularly for the past 10 years and I don’t know if I’ve ever used the bevel function on one. For me the barrel grip is so much more ergonomic. Particularly when making curved cuts which, let’s be honest, is the main reason we break this tool out of the tool chest. D handle has some nice features though.
For the D handle Milwaukee (12v), the lever has a tendency to loosen and if going threw hardwood doing curves or beveling, it's going to put much trauma on any tool not capable of handling it so Festool or Hilti brand has a better tool with more features to hold the blade, for example, while cutting.
great video... perfect comparison... I do not mind the allen wrench adjustment at all.. I think that actually sold the barrel grip for me!
I love the control of the d handle I've been back and forth with each. Bought a new barrel grip now it's my spare with my new d handle taking pole position. I use a jig a lot fitting kitchens.
That VS sounds beautiful!
Thanks for the review, I was about to push the order button on the barrel grip but wanted to watch a comparison video first. Barrel grip FTW!
Haha, glad it helped Greg 👊
They need the variable speed thumbwheel on the D handle.
for my use I would choose the D handle saw. I am also an old school person and have used a D handle jigsaw all my life and it is hard to change when you are 70 years old.
I wanted the barrel grip but bought the D handle and love it.
Both awesome saws, but like I said in the video, I love the feel of the D Handle
Thumbs up on the video man thanks. I'm looking to get one and I was debating between the 2 and im looking to get the D-grip one much better
I have the D handle. One thing I notice about those who own the Barrel handle - perhaps it's muscle memory, but they tend to stroke the tool while using and their eyes roll back in their head when nearing the end of a cut.
🤣🤣
I’ve only used a D handle, need to try barrel grip at some point.
Excellent comparison! D handle seems to be a much more versatile tool, more compact, variable speed with the trigger, quicker bevel adjustment. Now, I am not one to use a jig all the time, so I am debating whether or not to get the M12 jig vs the M18 D Jig. Love the features of the M18, but the weight and maneuverability of the M12 seems appealing. Most likely I will probably get both.
Good review and if you check Amazon, you'd see many bad reviews for the D handle saw such as lever loosening while working, angle not holding when doing straight cuts, other incidents (Mine had a pin guide issue also so now I must not apply too much force, else, something else would get damaged in the mechanics and I need to hold the
lever while working to keep on the line.) and I'm now considering Hilti or Festool brand because when going threw
hard wood, many tools would have issues. Five stars for communication, tech. skill, experience for you⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Was considering the barrel grip.....the Allen key bevel adjustment stopped that consideration dead in its tracks. Definitely a deal breaker! Thanks for the video!
I like both they both would have a place good video never give up bro you have an amazing attitude never back down never give up
Thanks TC, appreciate the kind words bro!
Thanks for the review. I am going to buy the D-Handle. Mainly because of the grip of the handle fits me better than the barrel type. And two, I like the variable speed trigger as opposed to the "volume controle" speed control of the barrel saw. As for the bevel, I never use a bevel on a jigsaw. But that's just me.
Awesome. Glad it helped Johnny!
Good review and if you check Amazon, you'd see many bad reviews for the D handle saw such as lever loosening while working, angle not holding when doing straight cuts, other incidents (Mine had a pin guide issue also so now I must not apply too much force, else, something else would get damaged in the mechanics and I need to hold the
lever while working to keep on the line.) and I'm now considering Hilti or Festool brand because when going threw
hard wood, many tools would have issues. Five stars for communication, tech. skill, experience for you⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I would go with the D -Handle.
1 -The variable speed trigger is gives you better control while cutting, you can feel the material and adjust the speed instantly, instead of stopping it turn the SPM dial and start cutting again or counting on Auto. Also the trigger ensures that when you are not holding the tool it will stop. There is no chance to bump the switch as the Barrel Grip.
2 -The grip is better, as you can wrap you fingers around the tool handle that is better to control the tool with one hand. One can easily lift the tool when done cutting
I think that both tools have the same durability as, I believe, they have the same motor inside.
Thanks for the video :)
Great comment, thanks Ivan!
Does the D handle actúa have a variable speed trigger though? Websites are conflicting
It does
Good review and if you check Amazon, you'd see many bad reviews for the D handle saw such as lever loosening while working, angle not holding when doing straight cuts, other incidents (Mine had a pin guide issue also so now I must not apply too much force, else, something else would get damaged in the mechanics and I need to hold the
lever while working to keep on the line.) and I'm now considering Hilti or Festool brand because when going threw
hard wood, many tools would have issues. Five stars for communication, tech. skill, experience for you⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Great review. Both look great. Im a D handle guy. I like the trigger. Power at my finger tip.
I will take the metal bolt to adjust the shoe angle over a plastic lever every time. Also Ithink the auto start would be handy and the rolling variable speed switch. Sometimes, a variable trigger can be hard to maintain its settings. Especially if doing tight radius while switching hand positions. Thanks for this review. I had the D handle in my cart, know I'm definitely going with the barrel version.
Hey nice rev. Im wondering now which one to buy.. still dont know.. both of them looks really cool. Auto feat in barrel one looks pretty usefull.
So helpful thanks
Thanks for the review, I decided I’m gonna go with the D handle due to the variable speed trigger, sometimes my blade will get caught and it’s nice to give it a quick blip of the trigger to get it unstuck. I also like to check sometimes and blip the trigger to make sure it doesn’t hit anything before I start cutting. I also like the compactness of the d handle, easier to cut in tighter spaces, plus I have used the bevel a few times and I like that it’s quick adjust and has detents for angles. Thanks again!!
I've had issues with the lever loosening ("D" handle.)on the milwaukee one with the hand lever and as you may have already seen, it got bad reviews on Amazon and as for the other one with the Allen key screw, it performed better.
Thanks for sharing
nonetheless.
I am old school. I choose the barrel grip. The bevel disadvantage vs the D handle is not an issue for me as I rarely if ever cut a bevel with my jigsaw.
I don't think a lot of people use the bevel either Armindo. If that not an issue, then the barrel grip is definitely the way to go. Thanks for the comment!
I like the Double DD handles
I like the feel of the Barrel Grip, gives me better control having my hand closer to the work. But I prefer the bevel level of the D-Grip.
i know im asking randomly but does anybody know of a way to log back into an instagram account..?
I was dumb forgot the password. I would appreciate any tips you can give me.
@Cristiano Langston Thanks for your reply. I got to the site on google and I'm in the hacking process atm.
Seems to take quite some time so I will get back to you later with my results.
@Cristiano Langston It worked and I actually got access to my account again. I am so happy:D
Thanks so much, you saved my account!
@Esteban Nicolas no problem =)
A up brother hope all is well
I would always go for the barrel grip. I got a barrel grip festool jigsaw and I’d be lost without it love it mate 😊
Good review. I’ll go with the barrel grip.
Thanks Herman, and yeah I think the Barrel is going to take this one
I like barrel grip but i do prefer the variable speed trigger. However i havent experienced the auto feature so i cant judge
How well does the two of them cut through 16 guage steel or stainless steel sheet metal or thicker?
I just picked up the d handle today first day of 2020
I was going to buy the barrel grip but I still as of yet have not. I was kind of disappointed in it not having a variable speed trigger and easy bevel change like the D-Handle, so I’ve been using my ancient electric Skil d-handle that I bought years ago. I may eventually buy it but I’m holding off for now!
Good review and if you check Amazon, you'd see many bad reviews for the D handle saw such as lever loosening while working, angle not holding when doing straight cuts, other incidents (Mine had a pin guide issue also so now I must not apply too much force, else, something else would get damaged in the mechanics and I need to hold the
lever while working to keep on the line.) and I'm now considering Hilti or Festool brand because when going threw
hard wood, many tools would have issues. Five stars for communication, tech. skill, experience for you⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
When doing a side by side, you should do each category with showing both. What's the barrel grips weight?
Is that lock switch on the D handle only like a safety switch or can you use it to keep the tool on?
Dont like the bevel feature on the barrel loses points with me and that is why I went with the d handle
I like the d handle better because of the adjustment on the pistol grip one plus it’s already in the stores I would have to special order the pistol grip
Evidently, everyone just wants the barrel grip. You can hack the BOGO deals to get the D-handle for $100, but there is no deal on the barrel grip. Milwaukee realized they can't sell the D-handle for the same price as the barrel grip.
can anyone recommend an edge guide for these jigsaws? thanks guys!
I was going to buy the barrel grip at first but now I'm conflicted. Both have nice features that the other one is missing. What's really conflicting for me, is the fact that the bevel feature is something I use quite a bit, and the reason I started looking at these, is to replace my current corded cheap bosch jigsaw, which requires a flat head screwdriver to adjust the bevel. Also I hate having to hold the trigger down, so that's a negative for the D-handle.
I decided to go for the barrel grip version, mainly because it would just seem more intuitive to push down and forward being closer to the saw/object, compared to your hand being higher up with the D-handle. It just seems (as a beginner) that with the D-handle you're mainly pushing down and it would be more awkward to push forward at the same time, also because you're higher up with your hand.
If your deciding factor is the trigger, the D-handle version has a lock button next to the trigger itself for longer cuts :)
I might pick up the barrel style down the road for some of its features but if I need to do bevel cuts I will just use my d handle I think the d handle wins this tool dual
As soon as I seen the bevel adjustment on the barrel grip it killed it for me. I'll be getting the d handle
I think Ill get both. Regular base plate on the d handle, and a collins coping foot on the barrel grip.
Good review and if you check Amazon, you'd see many bad reviews for the D handle saw such as lever loosening while working, angle not holding when doing straight cuts, other incidents (Mine had a pin guide issue also so now I must not apply too much force, else, something else would get damaged in the mechanics and I need to hold the
lever while working to keep on the line.) and I'm now considering Hilti or Festool brand because when going threw
hard wood, many tools would have issues. Five stars for communication, tech. skill, experience for you⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I couldn't decide so I have both of them
Any idea if these saws will work with the 18v red lithium 3.0Ah? Rather not have to go out and buy more batteries!
I got the M12 and relly like it a lot ! but Im going for the Fuel D handle ! on My Xmas List!
I like the barrel jigsaw better. The “A” feature makes it easier to use rather than the trigger for speed. Can live with the more difficult way of adjusting the angle.
I think the auto (A) feature is awesome. I think a lot will agree with you on that one Jack
Went to Barrel Grip (DeWalt DCS335) cordless from a nice corded Bosch D-Handle Jig Saw. The barrel grip is much easier to control and feel no issues holding onto it. I like it much better. I don't miss the variable speed trigger and actually prefer on and off now. Speed can be adjusted with the toggle switch, but I pretty run it on max (7) all the time with no oscillation as it gives a very nice cut in wood.
Barrel grip for me as I prefer the auto speed function and more maneuverability for turns, if I cut more angles in my wood definitely the d handle but I never use angles with my jigsaw
Yep deal breaker - they just went back ten years with the Allen key adjust
i was sold on the barrel grip until i saw that.
Good review and if you check Amazon, you'd see many bad reviews for the D handle saw such as lever loosening while working, angle not holding when doing straight cuts, other incidents (Mine had a pin guide issue also so now I must not apply too much force, else, something else would get damaged in the mechanics and I need to hold the
lever while working to keep on the line.) and I'm now considering Hilti or Festool brand because when going threw
hard wood, many tools would have issues. Five stars for communication, tech. skill, experience for you⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Check out the Collins coping foot for thr barrel grip. Very nice
The angle adjustment lever on my M12 jigsaw has always been a little loose so that it doesn't hold the angle very straight at all.
I would prefer the allen wrench system that the barrel grip M18 jigsaw has.
And yes that would be a deal breaker for for me.
M18 has same issue
Good review and if you check Amazon, you'd see many bad reviews for the D handle saw such as lever loosening while working, angle not holding when doing straight cuts, other incidents (Mine had a pin guide issue also so now I must not apply too much force, else, something else would get damaged in the mechanics and I need to hold the
lever while working to keep on the line.) and I'm now considering Hilti or Festool brand because when going threw
hard wood, many tools would have issues. Five stars for communication, tech. skill, experience for you⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
You forgot to mention that the barrel grip works way better with a coping foot for coping baseboard, chair railing and especially crown.
I have used a 28V barrel grip jigsaw for over 10 years. While the tool has been reliable, the lever adjust for the bevel keeps comming loose. It is a powerful machine all told, but getting an 18V version with an allen key adjustment instead of a lever, is a major plus for me.
Ok. Good to know it’s just a garbage design. My 12v does the same thing
D-handle...can't get the foot to stay at zero. yes, the detent pin is set. yes, the lever is locked. Feels like the lever does not "clamp"
will a 12ah battery interfere with the dust collector?
Milwaukee M18 fuel vs dewalt 20v XR brushless vs XR brushed- look faced with D-hand jigsaw
I have the barrel grip and I have a better feel and control when I’m using it for coping with the Collins coping foot.
Jason Babila I’m still waiting on my coping foot, dang postal service!! 🤣🤣
🧐🤔 I got mine through Amazon within a week.
I’ve got the D handle. As much at cutting bevels on the fly is handy without the Allen key, I find it VERY annoying how loose the bevel paddle is. Sometimes the bevel lock just flies open for no reason and if you aren’t careful you can bevel a cut without meaning to.
Barrel grip all the way. Great video
Thanks Brad!
Does the barrel grip have a blower?
the d handle is now significantly cheaper than barrel grip and i’m debating how much up side down cutting i do because that changing bevel with key is a possible deal breaker, guess the d handle doesn’t have that speed dial? just trigger? hmmmmmm idk
How load DB rating are these?
you would think with all the fancy electronics that they could put a variable switch on the barrel grip, with a switch so it can change back to on/off.
Bummer!! that’s a deal breaker for me. I pretty much use the bevel feature all the time on the previous Gen D-handle Milwaukee. The quick release lever is a awesome feature. Bummer they didn’t integrate it into the barrel grip.
How do you remove the battery
I have the "D" grip and although I have limited use of/for it I love the features. I have no problems with the "D"
I do want to thank you for the detailed comparison. I didn't know about all the Pros & Cons of the Barrel Grip. 👍🏼
Thanks for the comment Redd!!!
Good review and if you check Amazon, you'd see many bad reviews for the D handle saw such as lever loosening while working, angle not holding when doing straight cuts, other incidents (Mine had a pin guide issue also so now I must not apply too much force, else, something else would get damaged in the mechanics and I need to hold the
lever while working to keep on the line.) and I'm now considering Hilti or Festool brand because when going threw
hard wood, many tools would have issues. Five stars for communication, tech. skill, experience for you⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
@@adrewdio2694 Try The Milwaukee Repair Center first.
They are great at fixing issues in a timely manner.
Its also the cheapest solution instead of purchasing a whole new tool first step.
Im on the fence with the barrel grip as id like the Is variable trigger. The auto feature is nice but.....idk
Hey, nice review there Sir, those Milwaukee's look powerful.. God bless
Hi J 17! Yeah buddy, they are awesome, awesome tools
just bought a barrow grip... never own one, i know i will enjoy it....
I love them both but have to go with D handle.
Every 4th cut with my older 12v Milwaukee, I’m noticing that the bevel lock has come lose and I’m just floating around. So, the bevel lock is more of a deal breaker than the Allen key
I had the same issue with my m12 jig . There's a screw to adjust it and tighten it up. That's how I fixed mine
Wow, the difference in beveling is insane. Was thinking of getting the barrel grip, but you saved me on that one!
I just bought the dewalt barrel grip. Not a fan of the D handle & I did not want to deal with taking the shoe off & using an Allen wrench for beveling
Look like the barrel fan boy are out on this one. I have used D handle extensively. Nothing here to change my mind.
I actually really like the D handle as well Frank
You sound like the type that loves the "D"
How loud is it?
Can you do a Dewalt tool duel when the barrel handle comes out?
Sure will try Rick!
Thanks!
The milwaulkee is different to the metabo.
The d handle on the metabo has a narrower base than the barrel grip. Also angle adjustment is opposite. The d handle has an Allen key to adjust angle whilst the barrel grip has a lever to change angle. For the metabo I like the barrel grip. I do have the d handle.
As for milkwaulkee I like the barrel grip.
Shame milwaulkee should make the base plate wider for the barrel grip.
I own both of them ,and I like both of them. Each of them has its own purpose.
Good review and if you check Amazon, you'd see many bad reviews for the D handle saw such as lever loosening while working, angle not holding when doing straight cuts, other incidents (Mine had a pin guide issue also so now I must not apply too much force, else, something else would get damaged in the mechanics and I need to hold the
lever while working to keep on the line.) and I'm now considering Hilti or Festool brand because when going threw
hard wood, many tools would have issues. Five stars for communication, tech. skill, experience for you⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The barrel grip kit is £407 here in UK vs £309 for D-handle at time of writing this. Gone with the D handle for that alone.
Barrel grip Allen wrench is a total deal breaker.
Your the coolest trz
Haha, thanks Daniel, and back at you buddy! 👊
I really like the barrel grip, I’m sure Milwaukee will just add the lever to adjust this next year, but even if they wait I’d still get the barrel grip.
Yeah been using the barrel grip a lot lately. Really starting to like it better now. Thanks for the comment!
Good review and if you check Amazon, you'd see many bad reviews for the D handle saw such as lever loosening while working, angle not holding when doing straight cuts, other incidents (Mine had a pin guide issue also so now I must not apply too much force, else, something else would get damaged in the mechanics and I need to hold the
lever while working to keep on the line.) and I'm now considering Hilti or Festool brand because when going threw
hard wood, many tools would have issues. Five stars for communication, tech. skill, experience for you⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I want that D-handle kit in a bad way. I hope to be able to get it next month or shortly after. I look every day to see if it went on sale...lol
I really do like the D-handle. Hope they go on sale Jeff
Got both, so simple )
I wish I would’ve got the D handle. I have the barrel grip and it sucks. When you’re cutting and you want to stop you have to press the on/off button vs just stop pulling the trigger on the d handle.
Personal choice, barrel grip, it just flows better in my opinion...
I had that barrel grip and returned it. Didn't like how you couldn't stop mid cut without reaching for that button. The button is not easily accessible either. The D handle is so much better to use.
The bevel control on the barrel grip is the deal maker for Me to be honest. I have a m12 jigsaw and hate it due to the lever coming loose constantly and causing the shoe to tilt without me wanting it to
Thanks; same here and I've been trying to explain that to someone but she cursed me out, but I didn't care.
I had same issue but I just tightened the screw holding the lever and never had the issue again
You said in the D handel video that there is no blade eject. I have the barrel grip and my blade eject. They are the same machine the D handel and barrel grip
I think I got a bag one. I had a few people tell me that they had the blade eject, but mine is q dud
Barrel grip because control is everything. I don’t like to sand afterward due to a wide cut.
thi was a great viedoonjigsaws
Like you, I’m old school the “D” grip is the better choice for me.
I make similar videos I'm learning from your tool reviews !