Obey doesn't mean Follow! You cannot follow a dead person. There are those who say Hadiths are a secondary revelation, and there are those who say just Words words and actions of the prophet. So many issues with both of those beliefs. Before I answer I would like to know your opinions. I wonder why all these scholars act as though they don't understand Arabic or Quran. They play the same games as Anti-Islamic (Islamophobes) media's used to do. They twist the Ayahs (verses) of Allah and pluck the ayah out of context to prove their point. Now I don't see much of the differences between Anti-Islamic groups and Sectarians.
A person caught in the cusp of a cult will never be allowed to see the light of truth. Whereas the truth will open itself to any challenge because it has no threats 😊
They are Blind Believers who just heard a certain thing many times from many people - the result of hearsay is a Firqa/Sect - a group sticking together and confirming their beliefs with each other.
Ironically I was just watching this video a few days back, I actually use to like Mufti Menk and I kinda still do for some reason but I was flabbergasted when he said that the 59:7 is talking about the hadith because of my many debates with traditionalists I am very familiar with this ayah as it is one of the most quoted ayah by them trying to prove we have to follow the hadith. I guess I wasn't expected someone like Menk to be so out right dishonest. Also makes me chuckle every time one of these scholars say authentic hadith and then try justify the whole thing about weak and fabricated narrations. First of all every scholar has his own view about which hadith is weak, fabricated and which is not, there is no consensus even among themselves about this and then everyday one previous sahih is declared dhaif or moudu or vice versa. Also why are all of these so called know dhaif and moudu narrations still left in the books and being printed till today as they are. And just for arguments sake lets say I agree with you, but how can I base the majority of my deen and subsequently my akhira on something that has so much blasphemy, contradiction and by your own admission peppered with fake and dubious narrations! Unlike the one book which has no contradictions.
One of my friend sent me this video link to prove his argument. Poor guy didn't know I will do a video. 🤣😂I used to be a great fan of Mufti Menk. But I have stopped watching him long time ago. But I didn't know he was going against the Muslims (Quran alone). He called for war, all the scholars did by their lie. What is see is that they are working for saitan. Why else they would mistranslate ayahs? As if he does't know the differences between Obey And Follow. He is repeating it again and again. He is a charming person. But a lier! and a slave of saitan. Sorry to say that. Maybe without knowledge, or with! only Allah will know. If we can follow a book with contradiction then we can follow the Bible and Hindu vedas as well. If a book got contradictions and lie in it (da'if) then we gotta reject the whole book. It is the fundamental principle the scholars use, but not with Hadiths.
@@kshnell8 You are already a worshipper when you love all with all your heart and seeking for knowledge. You are connected with him 24/7. When you think about him, study about him, reading about him, talking about him, you are worshipping him.
It's like talking to a brick wall. I had a conversation in the comment section of The Impactful Scholars video about hadith authenticity with another person, where i merely asked to be shown in the quran where we must follow the companions and their narrations. Thats what i asked. What i got was everything from being called a kafir to been given a day to day life story of Abu Hurayra🤣🤣. They just spew out the same nonsense they hear from their ulema and scholars, yet when you ask the direct question, there is no direct answers. Its pathetic.
@@YasirAddaee Alhamdulillahh, I thank Allahh finding your channel and thank you daring to tell the truth about Allahh’s book. Here in Indonesia so many blind followers included my own family, it is sad 😢. So many muslims playing God , they judged other to them i am going to hell because I don’t wear hijab just dress decent 😊 But now, since I know little more about my religion doesn’t bother me anymore. I only care about my creator judgment 😊
A couple of interesting verses //Quran 8.22 Indeed, the worst of living creatures in the sight of Allāh are the deaf and dumb who do not use reason// //Quran 17.36 Do not follow what you have no knowledge of. Indeed, all will be called to account for hearing, sight, and intellect.//
@@YasirAddaee so unfortunate that critical thinking and simple question asking is so foreign to the scholars. So many people being misguided on their shoulders 🫤
@@salihtaysi yeah. People ask me questions when i tell them to watch a video on a related subject they dont want that either. Amazing. People act as though they are enchanted by these scholars. When sunnis are attacking others it's okay, when we reply with little bit of force they say "why do you insult him, why don't you contact him and explain" as if these scholars will listen to anyone. Mufti Menk is one of the most arrogant one. I have him on my Twitter even when he wasn't that famous. They won't let you form critical thinking.
" Blessed is the man who walketh not in the counsel of the ungodly , nor standeth in the way of sinners , nor sitteth in the seat of the scornful . ( 1) But his delight is in the law ( salat) doth meditate day and night . ( 2) And he shall be like a tree planted by the rivers of water , that bringeth forth his fruits in his season ; His leaf also shall not wither , and whatsoever he doeth shall prosper . ( 3 ) The ungodly are not so but are like the chaff which the wind drives away . ( 4 ) Therefore the ungodly shall not stand in the judgment, nor sinners in the congregation of the righteous. ( 5) For the Lord knoweth the way of the righteous, but the way of the ungodly shall perish ." (6 ) The Book of Psalms
@@adrianabonitaaziz I have about 16 different bibles. I do like some of the verses in the bible. "Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind." and there are many verses that are great. those who are truly seeking the truth will find it.
@Yāsir Ad-Da'ee Because of the Quran , I can read it with a certain heart . Yes , there are many wonderful stuff in the Bible. I let the Quran judge it for me . The Quran is the criterion.
Brother Yasir I thank you from the bottom of my heart for speaking the truth and uphold the glorious book of Allah. Unfortunately muslims( most of us rely on mullah and moulvi) have no knowledge of qur'an and rely on them. We believe whatever coming from their mouth is true. Interestingly when the quote in Arabic, 99% percent audience consciously or un consciously thinks that these are the aya they are uttering, infact there are the hadith in Arabic. I am trying with little effort to convince my fellow muslim friends and neighbors to read the quraan over and over. Allah swt will open our heart to understand it's verses. Aameen. Please keep up the good work. Allahbwoll make it easy for you inshaAllah.
Thank you. Study the Quran as much as you can, and follow the Quran as much as you can. Everything else will come from Allah. Guidance comes from Allah. What's not in the Quran, that's not in Islam. If you follow the Quran as much as you understand even if you follow based on your understanding if they are wrong Allah will accept your deeds. For true Muslims, salvation can be achieved by rejecting all forms of shirk, including hadith books and other written works.
Exactly,if Allah says obey the messenger and obey Allah meaning if we don't obey the Messenger, we are denying His message which is the Quran ,may Allah bless you
@@YasirAddaee It's not that Rasuulu-LLaahi and Nabii’u-LLaahi Muḥammad ﷺ and his companions are dead but the so-called Aḥaadiiṯ are collections of hearsays that have absolutely whatsoever no connections to Muḥammad ﷺ and his companions! And the same goes The Tawraat and The Injiil of The Qurʼaan that are like The Qurʼaan are Allaah's words and certainly not human hearsays written down called The Bibles that are in-line with the Aḥaadiiṯ, altogether humanity is humanity's Dilemma!
@@samantarmaxammadsaciid5156 I am having bit hard to understand what you are trying to say. If you watch my videos you will understand I reject Hadiths and likes of it as a whole. I don't accept them, and I don't waste my time on them anymore. I have wasted over 25 years on them. As for Torah and Injeel we don't need to focus on them at all. I have studied Torah, Misnah, Gemorah and Talmud, bible (new testaments) cover to cover. they are pointless wasting our time on them. Our goal should be to study the Quran much deeper and try our best to understand it as Allah wanted us to understand. Allah sent the Quran for the whole of mankind, So we don't need scholars to explain the Quran from their assumptions. If you study the Quran with context you will understand without any issues.
@@YasirAddaee Thanks for replying! It's that since you mentioned we cannot follow because he's dead (I don't remember the exact words), I just thought it's not he's dead that is problem to us but the transmission of the information related to him and his companions that were composed much later dates without ever verifiably meeting the claimed chain of peoples that they were quoting, that's all! In order to understand the Qurʼaan, in my opinion, it is best to understand the Qurʼaanic creation of Aadam and his Zawj (= his Pair / Couple) = a singular masculine noun for both the masculinity and the femininity; in other words, Aadam and his Zawj is altogether one body of the contrastive duality of Aadam until Aadam obeyes Aš-Šayṭaan (the Distant one) and then becomes two separate and parallel individuals of Male and Female (the actual and first time that the femininity became a separate bodily female) in the Earth Jannat, of the first creation as opposed to this earth of Ad-Dunyaa = the Nearer / Lower (Life) (Nearer = by directing our hearts towards our Creator Allaah; Lower = by directing towards our inner unmanaged desires of our inner Aš-Šayṭaan) by way of the natural selection of the natural evolution! In other words, the study of the Qur’aan is the study of Allaah's creation alongside of understanding our actual ourselves and our physical universe!
Yes, I only agree with Mufti menk when he says: "following the Qur'an is following the prophet Muhammad (a.s)". The biggest sickness the Muslims have today is that they SEPERATE what Allah has revealed from the Messenger! This is the greatest misguidance!
Thank you. My friend sent me the link to this video to prove his point. He didn't know I would make a video out it. I am planning to do all the scholars one by one. *إنْ شاء الله* All who are misguiding people.
He wont, these people are arrogant. I have messaged him on twitter never replied. I did that for two years. when i was a sunni i have tried to contact him for many years asking questions. never got replies.
@@ghazalafarrukh1345 See this is their job, their income is based on peoples following and donations. So if they go against the Sunni teachings everything will go away. I have never seen a single scholar who left Sunni faith and started the Quran alone's teaching. Even those who left still hold some of the parts of Sunni teachings.
In surah 39 verse 23 Allāh SWT says AlQuran is Ahsanal Hadith, Allāh SWT best hadith. In surah 31 verse 6 Allāh SWT that any other hadees is nonsense that will mislead us. Check the Arabic text in both verses.
Yes, these scholars are repeaters. They were programmed to think and speak one way, that's the only way they can think. He used to be my favourite scholar a long time ago. His Quran recital is amazing. May Allah guide him to the right path.
So glad to see more and more people are waking up and engaging in critical thinking. To start with they never distinguish between Rasool (messenger) and Nabi (prophet). Once it is differentiated, a lot could be unravelled. But, nay, they just love the "people of the grave". And follow he said, she said, who said....ofcourse there may be some truth in gossip....😂 MM is so earnest in convincing...but, alas the argument doesn't hold.
People don't like to question their faith, they love the easy way out. Thinking is hard. So they leave it to their scholars. Their scholars hate thinking as well, they love to follow their imams of the past and their teachers. Once they come out with their degrees their ego gets in their way to understanding things clearly.
//Quran 31.6 And of the people is he who buys the *lahw’al Hadith* to mislead from the way of Allāh without knowledge and who takes it in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment. 31.7 And when Our verses are recited to him, he turns away arrogantly as if he had not heard them, as if there was in his ears deafness. So give him tidings of a painful punishment.//
In surah 43 verse 43 Allāh SWT ordered Muhammad to follow the Revelation. In verse 44 Again Allāh SWT ordered Muhammad to follow only Al-Qur’ān and also his followers to follow Al-Qur’ān. What is the matter with him and his ilk that they can't understand. Chapter 18 v 57 applies to these types.
They just follow assumptions, they are far away from the truth. They are too lazy to ponder upon the Quran. And this is how they can make money. If they just preach the Quran many won't follow them. Their income is based on their made up stories, hadiths and fiqh
This person saying with the way brother addressed Mufti Menk is disrespectfully, what? How can you respect these so called scholars that mislead the whole umah, take the verses of the Quran out of context, I use to like to listen to them,but since I started reasoning, I do not bother to listen to any of them anymore. They will have to answer allah ( SWT ) on the day of judgement. None of them deserve any respect. What is veeery painfully, is that the majority of the umah put them on a pedestal sad.
Yasir Ad-Daee is so clear and contextually concise, but Menk and his ilk chooses to be "deaf dumb and blind". I hope and pray they have a change of mind and heart.
Jazakallah Brother… I was expecting a video from you for a long long time. This is just another mind clearing video…. an eye opener… BTW, have you seen Sam Gerrans, Benjamin Bilal, Omar Zaid videos???
@@shuaibSamadAli68 I am a world traveller, in this day and age people believe in flat earth is stupidity. Also its unscientific. but i don't have a problem if people like to believe that.
These people are bereft of consistency, logic and honesty. 59:7 taken out of context. Is that the best he can do? His facial expressions are very telling too. Meanwhile, whilst your beard is shorter and less impressive than mufti 😜 your grammar knowledge and emphasis of the singular/plural words is much appreciated as a student of the Quran. Thank you Sir!
Menk want to elevate Mohamad to d level wd Allah. He wanted to let people knew that Allah has given Mohamad d authority to make his own judgment aside from d Qur-an. He wanted to follow hadith as other source aside from d Qur-an, w/c s strictly fobidden by Allah. Ds s d main reason why Mohamad did not allow his sahaba to write anything of him, while he was still alive, he did not want any writings to circulate other than d Qur-an
"We" are following in the footsteps of Christians who elevated Prophet Isa to such a level they literally tuned him into god and this is what we are doing and some have already done it. It is no wonder when the west first encountered Muslims they called us Mohammedans because they saw us worship Mohammad instead of Allah.
U cant change the message of the other messengers . Quraan clarifies that. Corrupting books does not change the message . As allah message through his prophets is devine. A muslim is one who obeys the commands of allah . Allahs commands are sent to mankind through his prophets . And not the molvis
@@reynoldfranks4332 See you are confused with the message and the book. I am talking about books. not The message of Allah. I have read the Bible cover to cover and I have over 16 different bibles. I have read Talmud, Tanakh. I am not denying the message of Allah. I am saying their books are corrupted, and Quran is clear about it. Also they have written books with their own hands and attributed to Allah just like the Sunnis and Shias. my dear brother my statement is very clear.
Lol prove me wrong! What am i confused according to this video? Are you trying to tell me Quran doesn't have the Ayah i actually pointed out? The problem with you is that you hate criticizing your god Mufti menk. Fear Allah. Watch the video again and prove me wrong instead of commenting generally without proper knowledge and just with blind faith.
ToadY is the first time in all these years where i have heard someone say all we need us quran. I am interested to learn more. Since im dyslexic i learn and grasp things slowly. They need to be explained over and over again to me un different ways. But it seems good. Also i would like other youtubers chanella who also teach this. As this is all new to me. And i want me and my household to understand
Beware of scholars who are attached to nation states,. There are plenty of sincere scholars from all schools, Shia and Sunni,. But most tote 👜 a geopolitical aim and have guidelines they have to follow,. I keep getting recommendations for your videos,. I am a Shia, but I like free thinkers so i will just blind faith sub,. And peep your stuff out when time allows Wa Salam 😊😎😇
Thank you. Think about your position. You believe in the Quran 100%, Sunnis Believer in the Quran 100%, we Quran alone followers Believe in the Quran 100%. So where is our dividing point? Your Hadiths, and Their Hadiths. If both of you give up hadiths we all will be united. Allah will ask us about what he revealed not what your scholars say. By following whatever your scholars are saying, you are obeying them. Surah 33:66-68. Thank you again for watching my videos. WaSalaamu Alikkum
YASIR Ad dee MASHHA ALLAH WHAT A AN INSPIRING LECTURE TO EXPOSE MUFTI AND DR ZAKIR ON MY WISH IF YOU GIVE A LECTURE FROM QURAN C4 V150 ( يريدون ان يفرقوا بين الله ورسوله ) THIS ONE VERSE IS SUFFICIENT TO KNOW ABOUT ( اطيو الله واطيو الرسول
The subject of women is a very sensitive issue, i cannot be wrong even a bit. So i have to do lots of research before I post anything like that. I have never had any videos on women. I will work on it *إنْ شاء الله*. I will get to it eventually. Salafies are mushriks! ignorant beyond remedy whether they are women or men. The Salafi groups think they are following their companions. But they are not. Islamic history is a bogus history! just story.
@@YasirAddaee Brother two things. One I wish you would keep the insults to a minimum in the videos and comments, I'm not the sensitive type and curse like a sailor in real life and have no issues with cursing at all. But when we insult or mock, this just drives people away or shut downs whatever reasoning they have left in them in trying to receive the message. Second I would love to listen to your journey as to how you got here. It seems like you have devoted a lot of time to traditonalist religion before you had a change of heart. I know my journey was also hard and sometimes scary too. And even today I am called kafir, jahanami, murtad and what not believing and following only the Quran. And and one extra thing. Keep on doing what you are doing, today not too many people might listen to what you have to say but slowly and surely this will change and I see more and more people waking up from the "matrix of traditional Islam" and taking red pill instead of the blue.
@Yaser Ad-Daee. Subject matter and Quranic scholarship aside, my objection is about the bad language and abuse with which you addressed Mufti Menk. If you have read the Quran and if you obey it, you are required to address your opponents with respect and civility. The Quran commands that when you speak with others about religion you need to be respectful. I think you owe an apology to the Mufti. I am not a follower or a fan of the Mufti. I am speaking as an objective Muslim and not as a sectarian. Much of what you say makes sense but how you say it is not good. I hope you would not take this in a wrong way.
No i will never say sorry to a saitan like him, he is insulting us and calling us a kafir in so many words, and he is twisting the words of Allah. He is an enemy of Allah and us. So No! I don't care. This man is not a human, he is a saitan! You love him, you worship him, I don't care. Don't tell me how I should treat saitan.
So when the Quran tells you to seek the people of knowledge. Which could it possibly be 🤔 Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and his companions?🤔 I mean who could those people be? brother don't go in this direction. Imagine living your life and passed away at the age of 70, 80 or 90. As Allah commanded you to seek knowledge. In what circumstances would you be displeased by the hadith even if it has its own contradiction? The quran only has 114 chapters. And it's very easy to finish it. At a very young age. What other relevant knowledge what Allah want you to gain afterwards? Sure, those can be passionate. Making horrible claims that It's multiple revelations When the Quran says one revelation, one book. Which I agree. But we both know it is the closest thing we can do in getting knowledge, as you agreed that being attached to the Quran. it will lead you in following prophet Muhammad peace be upon him. So to summarize this comment because I know you don't like long paragraphs. When the Quran tells you to seek the people of knowledge, who could it possibly be? And no, it's not a good excuse to say that they passed away so therefore there's no reason to follow them💀 For example, My math teacher can pass away but I would still need his files to get educated. In what sense What I not gain knowledge if he passed away? If I'm going to be tested by the math class? It doesn't make any sense. Besides Allah will ask you on the day of judgment. What did you do with your knowledge and your spare time? If so far you lived all your life being skeptical. That's not good at all whatsoever. And you know it. I'd rather gain multiple knowledge even if it isn't beneficial to me, as it is sinful to waste time On irrelevant things. Hadith is not irrelevant because it is the only closest way to reach our beloved prophet peace be be upon. And so what if Those scholars made a huge mistake. That has its own conflict with the Quran? Who says you'll get caught in the crossfire? That is a mistake on the scholars. Not you, and they will be held accounted for it, so Don't worry about their judgment. You need to worry about yours.
Just because you are ignorant doesn't mean everyone else is just ignorant and foolish as you are. If you like to be a mushrik even after Allah revealed the Book to us, then in Qiyamah you will be informed on what you differ. You are a Quran rejector without even trying to understand!. Study the Quran first, then we can have a conversation.
@@YasirAddaee What am I ignorant of? I'm taking this insight from the Quran The Quran commands you To seek knowledge, and also seek the people of knowledge. So far you've touched on the obey fallacy direction. But what about the seeking direction? But either way those are two commands. So far, and it's not valid if you're always skeptical. Which you have every right to be.
@@DestinyKay-gw8ge Just because you misunderstood something because you are a Musrhik who worships your scholars like a Hindu. That doesn't mean I have to be a Mushrik like you. Let me try this. This is your statement right? "The Quran commands you To seek knowledge, and also seek the people of knowledge." Now where in the Quran it says this? Let's break down 1 thing at a time. I am trying to be very nice here! If you show your Mushrik Arrogance You can take it with someone else. I have no respect for most Mushriks. Let me give you a chance to have civilized arguments. What I hate about Arrogant mushriks is that they throw around statements but they won't give you reference. When we give reference they will try to move on to other subjects. So anytime you argue something you should learn to give reference!
@@DestinyKay-gw8ge Another thing is that you don't have any proper argument for this video, everything you said got nothing to do with this video and you couldn't even make a valid argument to this video. And you got the audacity to argue with me. Not only you. Your god mufti menk won't be able to argue.
@@YasirAddaee I see you have been debating with a lot of these "mush" days. But There's no need to take it out on me as I acknowledge the contradiction of multiple revelations claimed by scholars when the Quran says one Revelation. I thought this was simple. But I'll grant you for your experiences and encounters. But anyway In the Quran, Allah encourages Muslims to seek knowledge and guidance from the people of knowledge. One verse that highlights this is Surah Al-Anbiya, verse 7: "And We sent not before you, [O Muhammad], except men to whom We revealed [the message], so ask the people of the message if you do not know." This verse emphasizes the importance of seeking knowledge and guidance from those who have been entrusted with the message of Islam.
Menk is supposed to understand Arabic but in this talk of his he deliberately misconstrued the verse where Allāh SWT refers to booty to be distributed. In the verse below when Muhammad was asked to bring another Qur'an or to change somethings in Al-Qur’ān Allāh SWT orders Muhammad to say he cannot change anything abd he follows only Al-Qur’ān. Check hhe Arabic text. People who go to ulooms don't want to let go of the idle tales they were taught because they will realize that they wasted years of their lives learning nonsense. Shame. AlQuran chapter 10 verse 15. But when Our Clear ayât are rehearsed unto them, those who rest not their hope on their meeting with Us, Say: "Bring us a Qur'an other than this, or change this," Say: "It is not for me, of my own accord, to change it: I follow naught but what is revealed unto me: if I were to disobey my Rabb, I should myself fear the penalty of a Great Day (to come)." Clear as daylight. He follows only Al-Qur’ān.
Seems like you didn't watch the video. You are too quick to comment. Bloody troll. Watch the whole damn video. Quraniya people? if you learn to give respect you will get respect. I hate Arrogant, Ignorant Hadith thumping, scholars worshipping, camel urine-drinking Mushriks. We are not Quraniya. We are Muslims (Submitted ones) If you don't know something you should ask humbly. If you have asked humbly i would have explained to you about Zakat. I have videos on Fasting and your Mushrik Prayers. Go watch them before you spew your ignorance just like your god mufti menk. Mufti menk is an idiot mushrik. You people are blindly worshipping him.
Yeah! they don't like when we form our own thoughts and reasonings. They don't like it when we try to understand the Qur'an ourselves. How else can they make money? Followers are their life source.
@Yāsir Ad-Da'ee In fact mushriks don't like a person who understands the Quran . They mock the person , like , you are not a scholar and you don't speak Arabic !
@@adrianabonitaaziz They always say that, i have been insulted so much. I don't care. They say I don't even know to pronounce Arabic properly. You are not an Arab. you are Indian or Pakistani things like that. They can say whatever they want. They are racist and ignorant. I tell them If Arabs can understand why many Arabs are converting to Christianity and other religions? If they can understand the Quran as is, they shouldn't be converting. There is a Saudi Arabian Murthad youtube channel is there. He attacks islam. If knowing Arabic is the only thing you need to understand Quran then they will never leave islam.
Just here yourself out. Absolute nonsense, abject and stubborn ignorance coming from your mouth. How do you follow the Quran without following the explanation and authentic teachings of the prophet
Fool! I don't grow them, it grows. No wonder Mushriks are like cattle. You are a great example. Learn to think. So anyone who got a beard following the hadiths? So Hindus with beards are following your saitan books (Hadith books)? Amazing.
you can message me on Telegram @MicroKhan since i am in dubai right now, voice calls might not work. just message me. In few weeks I will be heading to Canada where voice calls will work.
Obey doesn't mean Follow! You cannot follow a dead person. There are those who say Hadiths are a secondary revelation, and there are those who say just Words words and actions of the prophet. So many issues with both of those beliefs. Before I answer I would like to know your opinions.
I wonder why all these scholars act as though they don't understand Arabic or Quran. They play the same games as Anti-Islamic (Islamophobes) media's used to do. They twist the Ayahs (verses) of Allah and pluck the ayah out of context to prove their point. Now I don't see much of the differences between Anti-Islamic groups and Sectarians.
True
I love this video this mufti menk educated speaks well if only allah remove the veil he will see quraan is all we need .
He is very charismatic
THEY FOLLOW NOT EXCEPT ASSUMPTIONS 👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻
The Hadiths followers turn to mock Quran only Muslims,Allah is the Best Judge, may Allah guide all of us
A person caught in the cusp of a cult will never be allowed to see the light of truth. Whereas the truth will open itself to any challenge because it has no threats 😊
They are Blind Believers who just heard a certain thing many times from many people
- the result of hearsay is a Firqa/Sect - a group sticking together and confirming their beliefs with each other.
If anyone Study Islam ...just Study the Quran you don't need to follow books other thank Quran ✨
Ironically I was just watching this video a few days back, I actually use to like Mufti Menk and I kinda still do for some reason but I was flabbergasted when he said that the 59:7 is talking about the hadith because of my many debates with traditionalists I am very familiar with this ayah as it is one of the most quoted ayah by them trying to prove we have to follow the hadith. I guess I wasn't expected someone like Menk to be so out right dishonest. Also makes me chuckle every time one of these scholars say authentic hadith and then try justify the whole thing about weak and fabricated narrations. First of all every scholar has his own view about which hadith is weak, fabricated and which is not, there is no consensus even among themselves about this and then everyday one previous sahih is declared dhaif or moudu or vice versa. Also why are all of these so called know dhaif and moudu narrations still left in the books and being printed till today as they are. And just for arguments sake lets say I agree with you, but how can I base the majority of my deen and subsequently my akhira on something that has so much blasphemy, contradiction and by your own admission peppered with fake and dubious narrations! Unlike the one book which has no contradictions.
I cried a lots asking Allahh to show/ guide me to the right way to worship “HIM “alone.
May Allahh guide us all to the right path.
One of my friend sent me this video link to prove his argument. Poor guy didn't know I will do a video. 🤣😂I used to be a great fan of Mufti Menk. But I have stopped watching him long time ago. But I didn't know he was going against the Muslims (Quran alone). He called for war, all the scholars did by their lie. What is see is that they are working for saitan. Why else they would mistranslate ayahs?
As if he does't know the differences between Obey And Follow. He is repeating it again and again.
He is a charming person. But a lier! and a slave of saitan. Sorry to say that. Maybe without knowledge, or with! only Allah will know.
If we can follow a book with contradiction then we can follow the Bible and Hindu vedas as well. If a book got contradictions and lie in it (da'if) then we gotta reject the whole book. It is the fundamental principle the scholars use, but not with Hadiths.
@@kshnell8 You are already a worshipper when you love all with all your heart and seeking for knowledge. You are connected with him 24/7. When you think about him, study about him, reading about him, talking about him, you are worshipping him.
It's like talking to a brick wall. I had a conversation in the comment section of The Impactful Scholars video about hadith authenticity with another person, where i merely asked to be shown in the quran where we must follow the companions and their narrations. Thats what i asked. What i got was everything from being called a kafir to been given a day to day life story of Abu Hurayra🤣🤣. They just spew out the same nonsense they hear from their ulema and scholars, yet when you ask the direct question, there is no direct answers. Its pathetic.
@@YasirAddaee
Alhamdulillahh, I thank Allahh finding your channel and thank you daring to tell the truth about Allahh’s book. Here in Indonesia so many blind followers included my own family, it is sad 😢.
So many muslims playing God , they judged other to them i am going to hell because I don’t wear hijab just dress decent 😊
But now, since I know little more about my religion doesn’t bother me anymore. I only care about my creator judgment 😊
This Menk is the Internet Super star, nothing deep he understood than the surface layer.
Misleading millions of people
A couple of interesting verses
//Quran 8.22
Indeed, the worst of living creatures in the sight of Allāh are the deaf and dumb who do not use reason//
//Quran 17.36
Do not follow what you have no knowledge of. Indeed, all will be called to account for hearing, sight, and intellect.//
Salaamun 3alaykum,
Why is it so hard to note that Rasool and Nabi mean two different things?
All scholars are refused to differentiate it. These scholars are repeaters, incapable of forming critical thinking.
Salamun Alaikum
@@halalmoney4685 WalikkumSalaam
@@YasirAddaee so unfortunate that critical thinking and simple question asking is so foreign to the scholars. So many people being misguided on their shoulders 🫤
@@salihtaysi yeah. People ask me questions when i tell them to watch a video on a related subject they dont want that either. Amazing. People act as though they are enchanted by these scholars. When sunnis are attacking others it's okay, when we reply with little bit of force they say "why do you insult him, why don't you contact him and explain" as if these scholars will listen to anyone. Mufti Menk is one of the most arrogant one.
I have him on my Twitter even when he wasn't that famous. They won't let you form critical thinking.
It will take time .
We will nail one by one
" Blessed is the man who walketh not in the counsel of the ungodly , nor standeth in the way of sinners , nor sitteth in the seat of the scornful . ( 1)
But his delight is in the law ( salat) doth meditate day and night . ( 2)
And he shall be like a tree planted by the rivers of water , that bringeth forth his fruits in his season ; His leaf also shall not wither , and whatsoever he doeth shall prosper . ( 3 )
The ungodly are not so but are like the chaff which the wind drives away . ( 4 )
Therefore the ungodly shall not stand in the judgment, nor sinners in the congregation of the righteous. ( 5)
For the Lord knoweth the way of the righteous, but the way of the ungodly shall perish ." (6 )
The Book of Psalms
very nice. I do like those.
@@YasirAddaee Me too , as a good ex Christian that I am. 😁
@@adrianabonitaaziz I have about 16 different bibles. I do like some of the verses in the bible.
"Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind."
and there are many verses that are great. those who are truly seeking the truth will find it.
@Yāsir Ad-Da'ee Because of the Quran , I can read it with a certain heart . Yes , there are many wonderful stuff in the Bible. I let the Quran judge it for me . The Quran is the criterion.
@@adrianabonitaaziz well said
Brother Yasir I thank you from the bottom of my heart for speaking the truth and uphold the glorious book of Allah. Unfortunately muslims( most of us rely on mullah and moulvi) have no knowledge of qur'an and rely on them. We believe whatever coming from their mouth is true. Interestingly when the quote in Arabic, 99% percent audience consciously or un consciously thinks that these are the aya they are uttering, infact there are the hadith in Arabic. I am trying with little effort to convince my fellow muslim friends and neighbors to read the quraan over and over. Allah swt will open our heart to understand it's verses. Aameen.
Please keep up the good work. Allahbwoll make it easy for you inshaAllah.
Thank you. Study the Quran as much as you can, and follow the Quran as much as you can. Everything else will come from Allah. Guidance comes from Allah.
What's not in the Quran, that's not in Islam. If you follow the Quran as much as you understand even if you follow based on your understanding if they are wrong Allah will accept your deeds.
For true Muslims, salvation can be achieved by rejecting all forms of shirk, including hadith books and other written works.
Exactly,if Allah says obey the messenger and obey Allah meaning if we don't obey the Messenger, we are denying His message which is the Quran ,may Allah bless you
Yes I have detailed videos on this subject as well. They usually threw this ayah around without really understanding it.
@@YasirAddaee
It's not that Rasuulu-LLaahi and Nabii’u-LLaahi Muḥammad ﷺ and his companions are dead but the so-called Aḥaadiiṯ are collections of hearsays that have absolutely whatsoever no connections to Muḥammad ﷺ and his companions!
And the same goes The Tawraat and The Injiil of The Qurʼaan that are like The Qurʼaan are Allaah's words and certainly not human hearsays written down called The Bibles that are in-line with the Aḥaadiiṯ, altogether humanity is humanity's Dilemma!
@@samantarmaxammadsaciid5156 I am having bit hard to understand what you are trying to say.
If you watch my videos you will understand I reject Hadiths and likes of it as a whole. I don't accept them, and I don't waste my time on them anymore. I have wasted over 25 years on them.
As for Torah and Injeel we don't need to focus on them at all. I have studied Torah, Misnah, Gemorah and Talmud, bible (new testaments) cover to cover. they are pointless wasting our time on them.
Our goal should be to study the Quran much deeper and try our best to understand it as Allah wanted us to understand.
Allah sent the Quran for the whole of mankind, So we don't need scholars to explain the Quran from their assumptions.
If you study the Quran with context you will understand without any issues.
@@YasirAddaee
Thanks for replying!
It's that since you mentioned we cannot follow because he's dead (I don't remember the exact words), I just thought it's not he's dead that is problem to us but the transmission of the information related to him and his companions that were composed much later dates without ever verifiably meeting the claimed chain of peoples that they were quoting, that's all!
In order to understand the Qurʼaan, in my opinion, it is best to understand the Qurʼaanic creation of Aadam and his Zawj (= his Pair / Couple) = a singular masculine noun for both the masculinity and the femininity; in other words, Aadam and his Zawj is altogether one body of the contrastive duality of Aadam until Aadam obeyes Aš-Šayṭaan (the Distant one) and then becomes two separate and parallel individuals of Male and Female (the actual and first time that the femininity became a separate bodily female) in the Earth Jannat, of the first creation as opposed to this earth of Ad-Dunyaa = the Nearer / Lower (Life) (Nearer = by directing our hearts towards our Creator Allaah; Lower = by directing towards our inner unmanaged desires of our inner Aš-Šayṭaan) by way of the natural selection of the natural evolution!
In other words, the study of the Qur’aan is the study of Allaah's creation alongside of understanding our actual ourselves and our physical universe!
Yes, I only agree with Mufti menk when he says: "following the Qur'an is following the prophet Muhammad (a.s)". The biggest sickness the Muslims have today is that they SEPERATE what Allah has revealed from the Messenger! This is the greatest misguidance!
They talk about the Miracles of the Quran. But they don't believe it can guide people.
Great of you Yasir!
Stunning Reply!
Thank you. My friend sent me the link to this video to prove his point. He didn't know I would make a video out it. I am planning to do all the scholars one by one. *إنْ شاء الله*
All who are misguiding people.
Salamun alaikkum, halal money
@@YasirAddaee how can I send like same to you . I mean your contact numbers
@@fairooslebbe3000
you can email me.
yasiraddaee@gmail.com
@@fairooslebbe3000 who is this?
Well said hope Mufti Menk could understand it.
He wont, these people are arrogant. I have messaged him on twitter never replied. I did that for two years. when i was a sunni i have tried to contact him for many years asking questions. never got replies.
@@YasirAddaee because he know that he don’t have anything to say
@@ghazalafarrukh1345 See this is their job, their income is based on peoples following and donations. So if they go against the Sunni teachings everything will go away. I have never seen a single scholar who left Sunni faith and started the Quran alone's teaching. Even those who left still hold some of the parts of Sunni teachings.
@@YasirAddaee i agreed what you said 💯true
@@ghazalafarrukh1345 May Allah guide him to the right path
I can point the partners they associate with Allah , but where are the partners that we associate with Allah ??!!🤷🏿
If you follow hadiths then you would be ascribing partners to Allah. Only Hadith authorized by Allah is Quran.
Yes absolutely perfect! Thank you!
You are welcome
In surah 39 verse 23 Allāh SWT says AlQuran is Ahsanal Hadith, Allāh SWT best hadith. In surah 31 verse 6 Allāh SWT that any other hadees is nonsense that will mislead us. Check the Arabic text in both verses.
The books prophet muhammad himself was unaware of being labeled as his AUTHENTIC, what a HUGE LIE toward him.
Yes, these scholars are repeaters. They were programmed to think and speak one way, that's the only way they can think. He used to be my favourite scholar a long time ago. His Quran recital is amazing. May Allah guide him to the right path.
And 59:6-7 points to distribution of spoils of war; not to those forged books of Sunnah and hadiths which were forged after the death of Rasool
So glad to see more and more people are waking up and engaging in critical thinking.
To start with they never distinguish between Rasool (messenger) and Nabi (prophet). Once it is differentiated, a lot could be unravelled.
But, nay, they just love the "people of the grave".
And follow he said, she said, who said....ofcourse there may be some truth in gossip....😂
MM is so earnest in convincing...but, alas the argument doesn't hold.
People don't like to question their faith, they love the easy way out. Thinking is hard. So they leave it to their scholars. Their scholars hate thinking as well, they love to follow their imams of the past and their teachers. Once they come out with their degrees their ego gets in their way to understanding things clearly.
//Quran 31.6
And of the people is he who buys the *lahw’al Hadith* to mislead from the way of Allāh without knowledge and who takes it in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment.
31.7
And when Our verses are recited to him, he turns away arrogantly as if he had not heard them, as if there was in his ears deafness. So give him tidings of a painful punishment.//
Tanks bro, Yasir brother ...
You are welcome.
In surah 43 verse 43 Allāh SWT ordered Muhammad to follow the Revelation. In verse 44 Again Allāh SWT ordered Muhammad to follow only Al-Qur’ān and also his followers to follow Al-Qur’ān. What is the matter with him and his ilk that they can't understand. Chapter 18 v 57 applies to these types.
none of them can understand the Quran. Their hearts and ears are sealed.
Excellent program
I have a new one as well. about HADITH of the prophet.
Thanks brother
How many sahih hadiths do they believe in? They dont know 😮 quran has limited ayets.
They Believe 100% of Bukhari and Muslim. They will not even grade them.
Some scholar (I think sheikh Ibn Baz) said there is a mistake is “Sahih” Muslim
I sometimes believe they are deliberately doing this and know exactly what they are doing
Yeah, He cannot mistranslate Obey and Follow. These are deliberate.
Allah is telling us He(Allah) is alive and worship Allah alone. It is clear in Quran.
The question is that why these so called ulemas are hell bent upon proving that we must follow the hadith?
They just follow assumptions, they are far away from the truth. They are too lazy to ponder upon the Quran. And this is how they can make money. If they just preach the Quran many won't follow them. Their income is based on their made up stories, hadiths and fiqh
This person saying with the way brother addressed Mufti Menk is disrespectfully, what? How can you respect these so called scholars that mislead the whole umah, take the verses of the Quran out of context, I use to like to listen to them,but since I started reasoning, I do not bother to listen to any of them anymore. They will have to answer allah ( SWT ) on the day of judgement. None of them deserve any respect. What is veeery painfully, is that the majority of the umah put them on a pedestal sad.
Yasir Ad-Daee is so clear and contextually concise, but Menk and his ilk chooses to be "deaf dumb and blind". I hope and pray they have a change of mind and heart.
Jazakallah Brother… I was expecting a video from you for a long long time. This is just another mind clearing video…. an eye opener…
BTW, have you seen Sam Gerrans, Benjamin Bilal, Omar Zaid videos???
Thank you. Yeah Sure I do. They are good.
Expecting more stuffs from you. I have a question for you… what is your opinion about the Flat Earth????
@@shuaibSamadAli68 I am a world traveller, in this day and age people believe in flat earth is stupidity. Also its unscientific. but i don't have a problem if people like to believe that.
These people are bereft of consistency, logic and honesty. 59:7 taken out of context. Is that the best he can do? His facial expressions are very telling too. Meanwhile, whilst your beard is shorter and less impressive than mufti 😜 your grammar knowledge and emphasis of the singular/plural words is much appreciated as a student of the Quran. Thank you Sir!
Thank you
Menk want to elevate Mohamad to d level wd Allah. He wanted to let people knew that Allah has given Mohamad d authority to make his own judgment aside from d Qur-an. He wanted to follow hadith as other source aside from d Qur-an, w/c s strictly fobidden by Allah. Ds s d main reason why Mohamad did not allow his sahaba to write anything of him, while he was still alive, he did not want any writings to circulate other than d Qur-an
"We" are following in the footsteps of Christians who elevated Prophet Isa to such a level they literally tuned him into god and this is what we are doing and some have already done it. It is no wonder when the west first encountered Muslims they called us Mohammedans because they saw us worship Mohammad instead of Allah.
My mufti menk is lost in his explanation. May Allah guide him to see the games previous scolars had played
Yeah he won't change, it's coz his world will become harder for him.
Fabrications weaker narrations different versions are all confusing to me. Where there is confusion keep away.
no keep away from Hadiths and other religious books. this is the command of Allah.
"Fadarhum WaMa Yaftharun"
@@YasirAddaee when you say religious books . Are you talking of books revealed to other prophets . Or are u talking of man written books.
@@reynoldfranks4332 Do you have other books with you without any corruptions? Can you prove? I am talking about Just the Quran. No other craps.
U cant change the message of the other messengers . Quraan clarifies that. Corrupting books does not change the message . As allah message through his prophets is devine. A muslim is one who obeys the commands of allah . Allahs commands are sent to mankind through his prophets . And not the molvis
@@reynoldfranks4332 See you are confused with the message and the book. I am talking about books. not The message of Allah. I have read the Bible cover to cover and I have over 16 different bibles.
I have read Talmud, Tanakh.
I am not denying the message of Allah. I am saying their books are corrupted, and Quran is clear about it. Also they have written books with their own hands and attributed to Allah just like the Sunnis and Shias.
my dear brother my statement is very clear.
Do explain it more. As we need repetition just as they gove repirition. Please explain in more lectures what flow the messenger could mean
I am not talking about the Messenger here, I am talking about Mufti Menk and his ignorance.
Brillant, keep up the excellent work, and please do more videos to expose more. I have left a link to the ultimate truth books.
Thank you. I will try my best.
Shame make Duah for this guy he is confused may Allah SWT have mercy on us.
Lol prove me wrong! What am i confused according to this video? Are you trying to tell me Quran doesn't have the Ayah i actually pointed out?
The problem with you is that you hate criticizing your god Mufti menk. Fear Allah.
Watch the video again and prove me wrong instead of commenting generally without proper knowledge and just with blind faith.
ToadY is the first time in all these years where i have heard someone say all we need us quran. I am interested to learn more. Since im dyslexic i learn and grasp things slowly. They need to be explained over and over again to me un different ways. But it seems good. Also i would like other youtubers chanella who also teach this. As this is all new to me. And i want me and my household to understand
I have many videos explaining things differently. Some are short and some are long. not too long. I don't make too long videos.
❤👍👍👍
Beware of scholars who are attached to nation states,. There are plenty of sincere scholars from all schools, Shia and Sunni,. But most tote 👜 a geopolitical aim and have guidelines they have to follow,.
I keep getting recommendations for your videos,. I am a Shia, but I like free thinkers so i will just blind faith sub,. And peep your stuff out when time allows
Wa Salam 😊😎😇
Thank you. Think about your position. You believe in the Quran 100%, Sunnis Believer in the Quran 100%, we Quran alone followers Believe in the Quran 100%. So where is our dividing point?
Your Hadiths, and Their Hadiths. If both of you give up hadiths we all will be united. Allah will ask us about what he revealed not what your scholars say. By following whatever your scholars are saying, you are obeying them. Surah 33:66-68.
Thank you again for watching my videos.
WaSalaamu Alikkum
YASIR Ad dee MASHHA ALLAH WHAT A AN INSPIRING LECTURE TO EXPOSE MUFTI AND DR ZAKIR ON MY WISH IF YOU GIVE A LECTURE FROM QURAN C4 V150 ( يريدون ان يفرقوا بين الله ورسوله ) THIS ONE VERSE IS SUFFICIENT TO KNOW ABOUT ( اطيو الله واطيو الرسول
ALLAHUL KABEER
Please reupload your videos on women and how salafi islam keeps women down, do you still speak for women? I cannot find your comments or videos.
The subject of women is a very sensitive issue, i cannot be wrong even a bit. So i have to do lots of research before I post anything like that. I have never had any videos on women. I will work on it *إنْ شاء الله*.
I will get to it eventually. Salafies are mushriks! ignorant beyond remedy whether they are women or men. The Salafi groups think they are following their companions. But they are not. Islamic history is a bogus history! just story.
@@YasirAddaee Brother two things. One I wish you would keep the insults to a minimum in the videos and comments, I'm not the sensitive type and curse like a sailor in real life and have no issues with cursing at all. But when we insult or mock, this just drives people away or shut downs whatever reasoning they have left in them in trying to receive the message.
Second I would love to listen to your journey as to how you got here. It seems like you have devoted a lot of time to traditonalist religion before you had a change of heart. I know my journey was also hard and sometimes scary too. And even today I am called kafir, jahanami, murtad and what not believing and following only the Quran.
And and one extra thing. Keep on doing what you are doing, today not too many people might listen to what you have to say but slowly and surely this will change and I see more and more people waking up from the "matrix of traditional Islam" and taking red pill instead of the blue.
Mufti menk kills me im not an arab but i understand that verse Alhamdulillah. Rasul only follow ALLAH
These are the ulama of Shaytan. If we are true Muslims then we should follow the Qur'an alone.
@Yaser Ad-Daee. Subject matter and Quranic scholarship aside, my objection is about the bad language and abuse with which you addressed Mufti Menk. If you have read the Quran and if you obey it, you are required to address your opponents with respect and civility. The Quran commands that when you speak with others about religion you need to be respectful. I think you owe an apology to the Mufti. I am not a follower or a fan of the Mufti. I am speaking as an objective Muslim and not as a sectarian. Much of what you say makes sense but how you say it is not good. I hope you would not take this in a wrong way.
No i will never say sorry to a saitan like him, he is insulting us and calling us a kafir in so many words, and he is twisting the words of Allah. He is an enemy of Allah and us. So No! I don't care. This man is not a human, he is a saitan! You love him, you worship him, I don't care. Don't tell me how I should treat saitan.
LSD schollars 😂🤣
So when the Quran tells you to seek the people of knowledge. Which could it possibly be 🤔 Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and his companions?🤔 I mean who could those people be?
brother don't go in this direction.
Imagine living your life and passed away at the age of 70, 80 or 90. As Allah commanded you to seek knowledge. In what circumstances would you be displeased by the hadith even if it has its own contradiction?
The quran only has 114 chapters. And it's very easy to finish it. At a very young age.
What other relevant knowledge what Allah want you to gain afterwards?
Sure, those can be passionate. Making horrible claims that It's multiple revelations When the Quran says one revelation, one book. Which I agree.
But we both know it is the closest thing we can do in getting knowledge, as you agreed that being attached to the Quran. it will lead you in following prophet Muhammad peace be upon him.
So to summarize this comment because I know you don't like long paragraphs.
When the Quran tells you to seek the people of knowledge, who could it possibly be?
And no, it's not a good excuse to say that they passed away so therefore there's no reason to follow them💀
For example, My math teacher can pass away but I would still need his files to get educated.
In what sense What I not gain knowledge if he passed away? If I'm going to be tested by the math class? It doesn't make any sense.
Besides Allah will ask you on the day of judgment. What did you do with your knowledge and your spare time?
If so far you lived all your life being skeptical.
That's not good at all whatsoever. And you know it.
I'd rather gain multiple knowledge even if it isn't beneficial to me, as it is sinful to waste time On irrelevant things.
Hadith is not irrelevant because it is the only closest way to reach our beloved prophet peace be be upon.
And so what if Those scholars made a huge mistake. That has its own conflict with the Quran? Who says you'll get caught in the crossfire?
That is a mistake on the scholars. Not you, and they will be held accounted for it, so Don't worry about their judgment. You need to worry about yours.
Just because you are ignorant doesn't mean everyone else is just ignorant and foolish as you are. If you like to be a mushrik even after Allah revealed the Book to us, then in Qiyamah you will be informed on what you differ.
You are a Quran rejector without even trying to understand!. Study the Quran first, then we can have a conversation.
@@YasirAddaee What am I ignorant of? I'm taking this insight from the Quran
The Quran commands you To seek knowledge, and also seek the people of knowledge.
So far you've touched on the obey fallacy direction.
But what about the seeking direction?
But either way those are two commands. So far, and it's not valid if you're always skeptical. Which you have every right to be.
@@DestinyKay-gw8ge Just because you misunderstood something because you are a Musrhik who worships your scholars like a Hindu. That doesn't mean I have to be a Mushrik like you.
Let me try this. This is your statement right? "The Quran commands you To seek knowledge, and also seek the people of knowledge."
Now where in the Quran it says this? Let's break down 1 thing at a time.
I am trying to be very nice here! If you show your Mushrik Arrogance You can take it with someone else. I have no respect for most Mushriks. Let me give you a chance to have civilized arguments.
What I hate about Arrogant mushriks is that they throw around statements but they won't give you reference. When we give reference they will try to move on to other subjects.
So anytime you argue something you should learn to give reference!
@@DestinyKay-gw8ge Another thing is that you don't have any proper argument for this video, everything you said got nothing to do with this video and you couldn't even make a valid argument to this video. And you got the audacity to argue with me. Not only you. Your god mufti menk won't be able to argue.
@@YasirAddaee I see you have been debating with a lot of these "mush" days. But There's no need to take it out on me as I acknowledge the contradiction of multiple revelations claimed by scholars when the Quran says one Revelation.
I thought this was simple. But I'll grant you for your experiences and encounters.
But anyway
In the Quran, Allah encourages Muslims to seek knowledge and guidance from the people of knowledge. One verse that highlights this is Surah Al-Anbiya, verse 7: "And We sent not before you, [O Muhammad], except men to whom We revealed [the message], so ask the people of the message if you do not know." This verse emphasizes the importance of seeking knowledge and guidance from those who have been entrusted with the message of Islam.
Menk is supposed to understand Arabic but in this talk of his he deliberately misconstrued the verse where Allāh SWT refers to booty to be distributed. In the verse below when Muhammad was asked to bring another Qur'an or to change somethings in Al-Qur’ān Allāh SWT orders Muhammad to say he cannot change anything abd he follows only Al-Qur’ān. Check hhe Arabic text. People who go to ulooms don't want to let go of the idle tales they were taught because they will realize that they wasted years of their lives learning nonsense. Shame.
AlQuran chapter 10 verse 15.
But when Our Clear ayât are rehearsed unto them, those who rest not their hope on their meeting with Us, Say: "Bring us a Qur'an other than this, or change this," Say: "It is not for me, of my own accord, to change it: I follow naught but what is revealed unto me: if I were to disobey my Rabb, I should myself fear the penalty of a Great Day (to come)."
Clear as daylight. He follows only Al-Qur’ān.
he is jahudi we follow Allahs deen
I wonder how these quraniya people pray?or pay their zakat or how they do fasting in d month of Ramadan .
Seems like you didn't watch the video. You are too quick to comment. Bloody troll. Watch the whole damn video.
Quraniya people? if you learn to give respect you will get respect. I hate Arrogant, Ignorant Hadith thumping, scholars worshipping, camel urine-drinking Mushriks.
We are not Quraniya. We are Muslims (Submitted ones)
If you don't know something you should ask humbly. If you have asked humbly i would have explained to you about Zakat.
I have videos on Fasting and your Mushrik Prayers. Go watch them before you spew your ignorance just like your god mufti menk. Mufti menk is an idiot mushrik. You people are blindly worshipping him.
@@YasirAddaee brother ignore the mushriks they like to worship creations if he really was interested he would have found out
Monki scholar ...... misleading.
Yeah! they don't like when we form our own thoughts and reasonings. They don't like it when we try to understand the Qur'an ourselves. How else can they make money? Followers are their life source.
@Yāsir Ad-Da'ee In fact mushriks don't like a person who understands the Quran . They mock the person , like , you are not a scholar and you don't speak Arabic !
@@adrianabonitaaziz They always say that, i have been insulted so much. I don't care. They say I don't even know to pronounce Arabic properly. You are not an Arab. you are Indian or Pakistani things like that. They can say whatever they want. They are racist and ignorant.
I tell them If Arabs can understand why many Arabs are converting to Christianity and other religions? If they can understand the Quran as is, they shouldn't be converting.
There is a Saudi Arabian Murthad youtube channel is there. He attacks islam. If knowing Arabic is the only thing you need to understand Quran then they will never leave islam.
@@YasirAddaee If we would depend on language to understand the Holy Quran , mushriks would simply not exist. Peace be up on you !
@@adrianabonitaaziz yeah.
Just here yourself out. Absolute nonsense, abject and stubborn ignorance coming from your mouth. How do you follow the Quran without following the explanation and authentic teachings of the prophet
So you didn't watch the video. you worship mufti menk without even trying to understand what i am saying. Troll Mushrik
lol....question why do you grow your bread out, as its from the hadith not the quran 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Fool! I don't grow them, it grows. No wonder Mushriks are like cattle. You are a great example. Learn to think.
So anyone who got a beard following the hadiths? So Hindus with beards are following your saitan books (Hadith books)? Amazing.
But you don't have much to say about the video but only what I look like. It shows how arrogant and ignorant you are.
@YasirAddaee I agree with most of the things which you say but I have some questions. Please let me know how can we connect so I can talk to you .
you can message me on Telegram @MicroKhan
since i am in dubai right now, voice calls might not work. just message me. In few weeks I will be heading to Canada where voice calls will work.
@@YasirAddaee thanks