Oh my god! I had the pleasure of being able to witness humanity and cinematic art merged together in a beautifully heartbreaking story. I wish I could have told the director during their Q&A how powerful this film was. It hits on so many different levels and so many degrees of me growing up from being a child to a son, to fatherhood and parenting. I came home and held my son in my arms and wept in his arms. Thank you to the production for creating such deep and touching story. This is an award winning film that must be seen.
This movie had me ugly crying …. And it‘s kinda crazy how everyone of us went through the same pain to a certain extent…money and pride can‘t buy you moral and happiness… be kind to each other
I have seen this movie last week on the Far East Film Festival in Italy. Such a powerful and beautiful movie. Nick Cheuk is an amazing person and a really good director. I'm really glad that I had the opportunity to watch this movie and to know Mr. Cheuk. Just one more thing: No one is worthless. Please, if you are struggle with something, don't close yourself. Someone out there will listen. Maybe I'm not the person you want to talk but if someone need I'm here
just watched this - cried many times during. very touching film that hit close to home. thank you to the director, actors and team for this amazing work and shedding light on youth mental health. 👏🏻
I watched this movie in a flight and was I the only one who thought the end was a huge plot twist? Anyway I cried three times watching this movie and it’s sad how some kids actually have experienced this. The actors did an amazing job and the directors and producers deserve an applause for this amazing of a film. Truly does touch your heart.
did you mean the plot twist is the writer of the suicidal message? or something else but for me its the teacher is not the boy who struggled all the time.
just finish this movie in HKfilmfest in thailand & wanna say thank you to the director & all the staffs & everyone who work for this meaningful movie. thank you so much 🥹😭🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
昨天在金馬影展看了這部片，從第一幕流淚到最後工作人員名單跑完，坐在位置上閉上眼，淚水仍靜靜湧出。既心痛又溫暖，我在限時動態如此形容。推薦大家去看這部電影，不論你此刻扮演的角色是學生、家長、老師、兄弟姐妹，一個半小時的影像或許會讓你潰堤，但也會像天臺上的微風，溫柔撫過曾經的傷口，給人希望與慰藉。
真的 … 演到心坎裡..
非常同意
不是電影令你哭，是童年未治好的創傷令你哭
真的看完會心痛
非常同意 這部真的很好看
在生兒育女前想清楚「如果孩子的出生，是為了繼續自己的勞碌，恐慌，貧窮，那麼不生也是一種善良」張爱玲金句
所以我自己唔會考慮生育
真係好啱，其實好多人生都只係因為希望自己會有個幸福嘅家庭，冇諗其實細路係咪真係可以開心咁生活，講到底人都係自私嘅。
唔係話自己嘅家庭唔好，只係生仔真係要以細路嘅角度諗多啲。
聞天祥老師在金馬60入圍記者會上介紹本片說：
「中間有一段大轉折，當下情緒措手不及，既感動又心痛！」
我今天有幸成為金馬觀眾票選最佳電影的評審之一，
搶先看了，完全命中！真是心碎般的痛！
2023年，到11月，才是港產片收成期。月頭的《白日之下》，月中的《年少日記》，不同的電影，同樣的心痛。
祝願《年少日記》叫好又叫座，讓全世界觀眾看到香港電影的佳作。
睇咗幾十年港產片，呢套絕對係最震撼心靈的…由後喊到落尾，帶給我很多的反思
太晚才看到這片。這樣好的一部片。這樣的悲劇劇情，導演以相當節制的手法處理情感，讓人不會陷入情緒的沮喪，而是與男主一同尋求生命的救贖和和解。
鄭中基毒打兒子那一幕,嗰啲藤條聲 令我回想起細個俾阿爸阿媽瘋狂抽打嗰陣時嘅感覺 一直閃一直退盡量想搵啲可以打得少嘅地方攝入去 希望可以打少啲,但其實係唔會囉,因為已經打上癮 打唔到他們預期嘅效果是不會停的,例如喊得越大聲打得越瘋狂.你諗住忍痛唔喊 他們條氣又覺得唔順,點解今日打極都唔喊,又在瘋狂式抽打,打到頂唔順終於喊先開始慢慢停手 因為他們已經攞到滿足感,呢個係我人大了之後諗返喺細個嘅感覺,當然不是每個人都一樣
我老母都係咁，所以生仔根本就係私心，因很多家長都當小朋友係工具，d父母自己做吳到既野會要求仔女做到，仔女做吳到佢地就會同人比較同折磨，有精神問題其實係d家長，但有問題既人係永遠吳會覺得自己有問題，我老母好鐘意揾我嚟出氣，細個剩係打我，我點努力討好佢佢都係針對我，我大個左之後我開頭都有揾佢諗住關係會變好，這只是一廂情願，因連我亞爸出街見我都要同我老母報到，我老母從來無打過電話關心我，我有打過電話揾佢佢只會問我買左樓未同埋講人地仔女買左邊度，人哋點點點好既八婆野。
Same here
同感，我是那種忍耐不哭的，結果兄弟姊妹中我被打得最慘。而我爸也承認因為我不哭。現在想起來，教育只是幌子，出氣才是理由。
😢
關咩事，細個打得最甘係我，我既家姐，細佬妹都冇乜打過，而家佢地一個個都唔孝順，
呢幾年成日話國内電影點追過香港：但我認為剛相反：近呢批香港新導演吾需什麽合拍片都可以好多高質作品出咗嚟：
打飛機就追過香港
近幾年嘅港產片的確係有好多好有水準
濁水飄流 窄路微塵.....等等
新導演新演員（叫做新）填補咗個幾十年嘅斷層，而且拍D嘢好本土，或者大制作幾乎係零，但每部小制作都係精品，特別係配樂方面（緣路山旯旮）都好正，其實有咁多好嘅電影真係要多謝一個人，需然佢套超大制作真係麻麻，但佢真係養住好多香港電影人，我相信新一代嘅電影人再浸多幾年，就可以再次揚威海外
睇咗兩次！仍然係咁震撼⚡️！香港電影加油💪🏻🔥！
中場喊到尾，尤其是阿哥自殺前㩜住細佬一段。
Oh my god! I had the pleasure of being able to witness humanity and cinematic art merged together in a beautifully heartbreaking story. I wish I could have told the director during their Q&A how powerful this film was. It hits on so many different levels and so many degrees of me growing up from being a child to a son, to fatherhood and parenting. I came home and held my son in my arms and wept in his arms. Thank you to the production for creating such deep and touching story. This is an award winning film that must be seen.
呢度電影好寫實
其實好多香港家庭都係咁 我細個都類似
朋輩壓力同互相比較嘅影響對於一個小朋友嚟講真係好大
好影響到個人嘅自信同對將來成就嘅懷疑
希望香港嘅教育同家庭教育好好正視
唔好比咁多學習壓力學生
佢地值得一個快樂嘅童年
因為太真實，所以先令人感動
今天看完無劇透下, 想提提大家過電影的背樂好觸動到我.
到電影中後段, 只有輕輕的幾粒前奏音符, 劇情未到情緒位下, 我已經雙眼水汪汪了~ 很神奇~
Claude Debussy - Rêverie
社會真係好要改變吓。特別係叫啲大人唔好再話「年輕人唔捱得苦」我個個心真係好痛！
是！他們捱得多辛苦都事實！但每個年代不同，唔通要像他們咁先安樂！時代變！人亦會變！(同進步！)
睇完，好好睇好感人，喊死我😭😭
This movie had me ugly crying …. And it‘s kinda crazy how everyone of us went through the same pain to a certain extent…money and pride can‘t buy you moral and happiness… be kind to each other
非常好睇 👍一定要入場支持🙏🎈🎈
第一幕直接被嚇到
搭飛機嘅時候睇呢套戲，喊左我幾次。呢套戲好真。好在隔離位果個全程帶住 airpod 訓覺
我去咗睇套戲
我嗰行最少有三個人喺度喊
後面嗰兩個又喺度喊
真係好感人 去睇嘅人記住帶紙巾
唔只係感人更加重要既係要教訓香港啲仆街虎爸虎媽咁撚鍾意對自己小朋友濫用體罰
一定要睇！
I have seen this movie last week on the Far East Film Festival in Italy. Such a powerful and beautiful movie. Nick Cheuk is an amazing person and a really good director. I'm really glad that I had the opportunity to watch this movie and to know Mr. Cheuk.
Just one more thing: No one is worthless. Please, if you are struggle with something, don't close yourself. Someone out there will listen. Maybe I'm not the person you want to talk but if someone need I'm here
真係好好睇
just watched this - cried many times during. very touching film that hit close to home. thank you to the director, actors and team for this amazing work and shedding light on youth mental health. 👏🏻
我都喊 令我回憶細個時 😢
到我而家幾十歲仲記得，小學3年班有個叫鍾老師Miss，唔知點解針對得我好緊要，我性格熟於比較靜，可能蠢D成績唔算好，勉強都算合格，每次默書成績50分合格攞到6，70分左右，佢直頭對我‘’妙‘’咀。我呢世都記得呢D咁嘅人，對日後性格都有影響。
我都好有印象記得呢啲老師
我細個啲老師會當住同學面攞我同家姐比
家姐成績比我好好多
真係一世都抹唔甩呢啲記憶
@@ebhihaha 唔洗做到春風化雨，但係對小朋友影響好大，以為自己唔夠好？唔夠乖？ 後來中，小學性格怕事同人相處極慢熱，到好大個先改變到。佢地唔會諗，呢D惡果會落係佢地仔女或者再下一代身上會點。
澳洲小學完全冇功課，冇課本，書包只有餐盒和水，連筆都放在學校。
呢度就業率高，籃領人工高，只要唔介意遠少少，住平，食唔貴，同香港差唔多，有時間可以自己種，減輕生活成本。
這種故事裡的年輕人的經歷，不可能出現在澳洲。所以生活的複雜，其實是被環境迫出來，也是心境被環境同化的結果，如陷入無助難以自救的困境，唯有想想外面。
就算歐美，美國咪一樣有華人虎媽，家長心態最重要
唔只係澳紐，西方既歐洲絕大部分國家父母管教都一樣寛鬆過香港，包括埋東歐巴爾幹半島前共產國家
@@Winter_Treedontdont 唔同既係歐美國家虎爸虎媽同香港相比少得多
今天看了，真的很悲哀，看到有傑自殺一幕，淚水忍不住湧出來。
呀爸打佢，細佬同呀媽繼續做功課嗰幕好恐怖，導演好識帶觀眾投入個情緒。不過全戲hand held係咪真係有必要呢？Hand held唔代表有質感喎😂。壓死駱駝最後一根稻草係佢問呀媽，咁如果我下次都考唔好呢，呀媽答咁你唔好再叫我媽咪，然後成家去LA唔帶佢地，喺一個小朋友角度係勁hurt，希望社會進步唔係要兩極化變到一味放任小朋友，人係要有適當挫折同壓力，希望社會進步係家庭重視咩係有愛嘅家庭，無論父母自己要相愛定係建立愛喺家庭入面都好重要！社會嘅人就唔好再怪輕生嘅年輕人。
你仲未知套電影講咩。 個老豆癲左一樣打個大仔，點解亞媽仍然要同個細仔一齊做功課，因佢作母親都無力阻止，如果唔陪個細仔做功課既話，你認為個老豆見到佢地一邊睇住...會有咩反應呢? 你認為HAND HELD 因你未見過家暴虐待兒童..身上有傷有幾恐怖。 咩叫壓死駱駝最後一根稻草，唔同我講文化，有一句話就系..雪崩時沒有一片一雪花是無辜。 唔好話20樓，你企系天台再望地下，就知恐怖感， 10歲知道跌落去有幾痛架，知咩叫死亡，點解佢仍然選擇依條路，你有想過嗎? 仲有咩社會進步，咩兩極化..你講政治呀!!? 你依D咪叫大人唔知小朋友聽咩，老野思想。
@@jng4348 電影人表示唔使全戲hand held都可以拍到個壓逼感、恐怖感
@@jng4348 兩極化係講對小朋友嘅要求，我打得好清楚，得政治睇法可以兩極？你中學畢業未？
@@vaguelyright-et1vh 因為要求真實感，你不知道道，因此事並不只有香港才會發生
@@vaguelyright-et1vh 小朋友，你就中學未畢業! 你連咩叫兩極化都未知，就唔好學班政棍口吻講野啦。 父母和子女關係非常複雜， 因子女0-14歲成長中建立三觀、自我意識及人際關係，是直接受父母影響。 你聽過家暴是有遺傳嗎? 就如電影中，父親的童年直接形成他對兒子的要求及態度。 簡單就是，父母行為就是子女成長課本，尤其人在10歲前思想邏輯是非常跳躍飄忽，完全不合乎社會意思，你知道嗎。
任何食過藤條燜豬肉既人都要睇這套片
我強烈讉責香港啲仆街父母濫用體罰
剛看完 心痛😢
好好睇 好值得入場！❤❤🎉
簡單結論，不生育沒傷害
生命從來都係冇意義同痛苦的輪迴，反生育係唯一出路
好想睇～～～～～～
好好睇，睇到喊
今日睇完呢套電影😭到🐷頭咁,呢套係近年我比較真的感覺好好睇好感人👍👏
好好睇！推推
very touching and inspiring!
I watched this movie in a flight and was I the only one who thought the end was a huge plot twist? Anyway I cried three times watching this movie and it’s sad how some kids actually have experienced this. The actors did an amazing job and the directors and producers deserve an applause for this amazing of a film. Truly does touch your heart.
did you mean the plot twist is the writer of the suicidal message? or something else
but for me its the teacher is not the boy who struggled all the time.
@@MuhammadSutomo yea the plot twist where the teacher was the brother
Why Netflix or disney+ or NOW 冇得播？anyone knows?
好好睇，十分傷感😭！
Where can i watch this?
個心乸住乸住,一開場乸到完場😢
睇完破地獄韋羅莎喪子諗起呢套揮手區
童年過得不好，長大後踩上成魔之路，最後社會來結帳
好睇🥲
we are all products of our past experience，過去的創傷不會因為時間而淡化，只是埋藏起來了，等相似事件再出現它便會被觸發，尋求專業幫助一步步清創過往的傷口，才能真正撫平創傷
好難過！就失去了一個生命！😢
重睇過呢套二次~真係好好睇~
但都發現一個問題~
啦~我講劇情炸~~同現實同演員無關嫁~~
記得有一場大仔問~佢會努力去考前十...老豆話要求太高~就話考15都可以~考到就一家人去美國迪迪尼.....
最後當然係個仔考唔到啦...
咁其實父母都無正視過佢既問題~~個大仔成日失眠...個腦無可能集中溫到書嫁啦...又唔肯請一個好既補習比佢..唔洗佢高分姐~合格姐..都唔會搞到佢咁慘~~
最慘係咁細既年紀唔識搵人去傾...個啊媽又唔信佢有病,,,,唉
人為悲劇！自己脾氣不好真是唔好生！害左自己同下1代，何必？根本D父母不值得可憐！始終有因就有果！不論父母，子女，夫妻，朋友，仇人什麼也好，冤親債主也好，有報應架！初初都唔信，之後發生太多事經歷得多時候，你就相信明白！
想問下背景音樂係咩？
Debussy: Rêverie
شاهدت الفلم الليله و دموعي لم تتوقف عن الانهمار للحظه حقا تحفه سينمائيه واجمل ما شاهدت 😢❤
我睇到後面心痛哥哥
我真係由頭咸到落尾😢好鬼貼題
_time still turn the pages of the book its burned_
適唔適合同仔（青少年）一齊去睇呢？
請問看過的人，會不會看得心情很悶很沈重？有點想看，但又怕看了心情不好…
請問預告片呢隻音樂係咪就係片中練琴嗰隻？叫做乜嘢名？
Reverie by claude debussy
哩套睇到人好心痛
有冇人知首鋼琴曲係咩歌？
Debussy, Reverie
以前嘅年代都仲有離家出走呢樣選擇，宜家好似得死一樣，冇其他選項
一開始睇套戲我諗起陽光普照，我以為係細佬讀書壓力太大自殺😢
我都係 以係同陽光普照一樣走向
wow
鄭中基真係好適合做狂燥人士，做返佢自己，如果加一場戲喺飛機上面拍仲夾～
對
😢😮
喊燃死
😢
筆者評80分。破綻蠻多，沒有情韻。只是機械的演出一個悲劇。
其實看電影除了情感外，還有尋找電影所要傳達給人們的意義。
希望鄭中基以後唔好再拍呢啲戲
你地睇埋我個份👋🥱
very touching movie
if you like this, highly recommend "Close"
just finish this movie in HKfilmfest in thailand & wanna say thank you to the director & all the staffs & everyone who work for this meaningful movie. thank you so much 🥹😭🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻