Explain कमाल का करते हो भाई जी..... जो चीजें हम किताबों मे पढ़ के नही समझ सकते... वो आपके छोटे से Explanation के Video से समझ आ जाती है........ और सच मे, ऐसे Thoughts ज़ब कोई Scientist Apply करता है... तब हमें लगता है कि हाँ यार वो Scientist बहुत सटीक Theory देकर गया है...... पर आज कि Video देखकर लगा की...... वाकई Eienstein's की सोंच को किसी ने Challenge कर दिया..... और वो भी बहुत ही Solid Evidence के साथ.......... गजब का दिमाग़ लगाया है इस नए Scientist ने..... मान गए...... विज्ञान भी उसी को याद रखता है जो सबूत को सिद्ध करता है..... 🙏
Mass=Curvature in space-time Curvature in space-time=Gravity Mass of singularity=infinite=infinite curve so space-time break apart hence singularity not make any sense of existence or when or where This is summary of entire vdo
That's the thing about science that it's as big as universe meaning infinite That means infinite theories, infinite curiosities and mysteries Science is majestic which can't be explained by perspective of one
Science is not majestic cuz it proves explanation behind everything they find one having no explaination behind anything is majestic And whenever science reaches bharat it fails to explain the reasons behind the things so sanatan is what majestic the believe hope and trust we have on God The parabhram is majestic
Gaurav sir Quantum mechanics kehti hai jab Tak koi matter ke sath interact nahi karata tab Tak vo wave form me exist karata hai Par blackhole ke case me koi interaction hi nahi hai ( after all koi chij ko dekh nahi sakate to interact kahase karange) Toh their is high probability singularity yek wave function me exist karata ho
It sounds like you are saying that nothing exist until someone saws it ........... totally disagreed to2 your theory we cant even imagine what level of maths and physics is involved in this ....
@@krishyadav3995according to quantum physics , reality doesn't exist in a definitive state until it's observed, and observation inevitably changes reality. This means that particles exist in many states at once until they are measured. For example u observed the tree in the way I don't , now in this case that exists for u cause u observed it but not for me ...
bhai ye observer ke point of view se kha jata h , wave form is like possibilities and particle form is like one of outcome of that possibilities , take an example mai tujse puchu tere ghar ke bahar kon khada h , jb tk tu observe nhi kare tbtk koi bhi ho sakta h ladka , ladki , kutta , Aadmi , bacha kuch bhi , to ye h superposition, yha possibilities bhot h , isse hi wave nature keh sakte h , aur tu bahar Jake observe Karle to tujhe pta hi chal jayega kon h ye hogya particle nature , to black hole dekha nhi ja sakta kyuki wha se light espace nhi ho pati , par matter uske around kese behave karma h usi se hum black hole ke depiction ko samaj pate h , black hole ke case m interaction hoti h , ussi interaction ko to hum observe karte h ,
Gravity is a curvature in space time fabric. A black hole is a region of spacetime where gravity is so strong that nothing, including light and other electromagnetic waves, has enough energy to escape it. The change in gravity (from a star to black hole) is a direct impact of change of mass, due to change in acceleration?
ig you wanted to say "not has enough energy to excape it" so in that case if we create an object which has the energy to escape it then that means we can go in-out in black hole ?!??!/
@@DarkBoy-px1zlI don't think such force exists but there can be a way "until there is a vantablack object that we can mass produce so the light can be absorbed so that we can possibly make through like 50 meters inside a black hole 🤔
Bhai par ek doubt hei, like during the formation of blackhole, it is said that when a massive star comes to the end of its life, it uses all of its energy and expand to a point where the gravity of the star will dominate and the star collapse on itself. So if it is a star collapsing on itself, how can it explode, shouldnt it go implode?? and if it implodes, then at the centre of the blackhole, the remaining of the core of that star has to be present, and the core would have shrunk to a size where nuclear or repulsive forces balances the gravitational force. Right?? And one more thing, Like every where it is displayed as there is only one layer of space-time fabric, But that is not completely true . In a 3D space, there would be or there has to be multiple layers of space-time fabric. So if that is the case, when a blackhole of lets say any heavy body is in that, then shouldnt a sphere or a blanket of space time frabic wrap the planet or that heavenly body from all the sides?? I know its a little bit hard to imagine or understand what i meant, but through words, this is the max i could do to convey my thinking.
for the second one search up warping o spacetime thats the actual model of spacetime warping and commmon people find it hard to grasp it for the first one the surface of the star and the matter gets sucked in first which is hte implosion and then it rebounds creating the explosion and also the core shrinks to a size smaller than the point where the strong nuclear forces are overwhelemd by gravity. just like when stars do fusion the repulsive forces of electrostatic are overcame by the huge gravity and mass of star
About your first part, I think it first explodes and then implodes, but I have doubts like if a bomb explodes on this planet it creates vacuum in that space near it and air gets sucked into that space but when exploding in the space which is already vacuum how is it sucking things, is there something else which is burning up when supernova happens. Now the second part is space fabrics, it may be just one but depending on the mass of the objects, if you take a big sheet and put a heavy object in the center(sun) and then at a distance a bit less heavy one (earth)and then another small one(moon) close to the medium weight one(earth) , then i think the smallest will spin around the medium one and the medium one will spin around the most heavy one in sync. Hope you understood what I have typed. So I think its just one fabric.
The process you're describing is indeed related to the formation of a black hole through the collapse of a massive star, but there are some nuances to clarify. When a massive star exhausts its nuclear fuel, it can no longer support itself against gravitational collapse. The outer layers of the star are expelled in a powerful explosion known as a supernova. The core that remains after the explosion can either form a neutron star or collapse further to become a black hole. Here's a step-by-step breakdown: 1. Nuclear Fusion and Gravity Balance: Throughout its life, a star maintains a balance between the outward pressure from nuclear fusion in its core and the gravitational force trying to collapse it. Once it exhausts its nuclear fuel, this balance is disrupted. 2. Collapse: Without the outward pressure from nuclear fusion, gravity starts to dominate, causing the star to collapse. If the star is massive enough, this collapse can lead to a supernova. 3. Supernova Explosion: The core collapse can generate a shockwave that causes the outer layers of the star to be expelled in a supernova explosion. This explosion is what you may be referring to as the star "exploding." 4. Remnant: What remains after the explosion is the core of the star. Depending on the mass of the core, it can either become a neutron star or continue collapsing to form a black hole. 5. Black Hole Formation: If the core's mass is above a certain threshold (about 2.5 to 3 solar masses), the gravitational forces become so strong that nothing, not even light, can escape. This marks the formation of a black hole. Regarding the idea of the core shrinking to a size where nuclear or repulsive forces balance gravitational forces at the center of the black hole, it's important to note that within a black hole, traditional physical laws, as we understand them, break down. The classical notion of a "size" or "structure" at the center of a black hole becomes somewhat meaningless in the context of general relativity. The singularity at the center of a black hole is a point of infinite density, and our current understanding of physics can't precisely describe what happens at that point. It's an area where our understanding of gravity and quantum mechanics is incomplete, and it's a topic of ongoing theoretical research in physics.
AND THE SECOND HALF PART: The concept of a "layer" of space-time fabric can be a bit challenging because it's an attempt to represent the curvature of space-time in a simplified way. In reality, space-time is a four-dimensional continuum, and when we talk about the curvature caused by massive objects like planets or black holes, it affects the entire surrounding space. In general relativity, mass and energy curve space-time, and objects move along curved paths in response to this curvature. The presence of a massive object, such as a planet or a black hole, causes a curvature in space-time around it. This curvature is not like a physical layer but more like a deformation of the space-time fabric itself. The common visualizations involving rubber sheets or blankets are simplifications used to convey the idea of how mass warps space-time. However, it's important to remember that these are just analogies, and the actual mathematics of general relativity describe the curvature of space-time in a more complex and accurate manner. In the case of a black hole, the curvature of space-time is extremely intense near the singularity at the center. As you move away from the black hole, the curvature gradually decreases, and space-time returns to a more "normal" state. This curvature extends in all directions around the black hole. So, it's not so much about a physical layer wrapping around a massive object; rather, it's about understanding how the presence of mass warps the entire space-time continuum in its vicinity. The curvature is present in all directions around the massive object, creating a gravitational field that influences the motion of other objects in that region of space.
@@KhushiSingh-C13 idk if you wrote yourself or not but both are good explanations but for the secobd part Everything moves in a straight line however due to the warping of space time the space time bends which looks like the object is falling when in reality its just moving in a straight line
Sir honestly Me bachpan se ye sochta tha ki log space time fabric ko 1 cloth bata kar earth ki gravity use karke gravity ko proof karte the aaj apne mera doubt clear kar dia thanks🫡
00:06 Theory of black holes being proved wrong 01:35 Gravity is due to space-time curvature, not the other way around. 02:56 Gravity is caused by curved paths moving towards the center of mass due to curved space-time. 04:25 Objects getting closer to a black hole's event horizon move faster than the speed of light. 05:56 General Theory of Relativity and singularity inside black holes. 07:31 Black holes have ring-shaped singularities due to their rotation. 08:57 GPS satellites prove the General Theory of Relativity's time dilatation principle 10:28 Roy Kerr's theory may replace Einstein's GTR for understanding black holes.
Muja ik doubt haa galaxy ka centre ma black hole hota ha jo ass pass ki light absorb kar leta ha toh galaxy's centre bright kyo dikhti haa usa toh centre ma dark fikhna chahiye explain me plz ❤
Because the frictional and gravitational interactions at play in the extreme space surrounding a black hole cause this material to heat up and shine brightly across a range of wavelengths. For this reason the center of the galaxy looks bright. Hope you understood
*One day I thought that why we can't see a Black hole like other 3d Objects and after thinking a lot I came to the point that Black hole is Just a 2d disk which rotates. I remembered this When you Said that Singularity doesn't exists and Things just revolve in a Circular track in the darkness of Blackhole.* *By the Way , The Space Time can move faster than speed of light ( C ) because it is expanding more Faster and more faster than Speed of Light. We can Say that the Flow of Space Time near the Event Horizon is faster than Speed of Light.* *GTR is only applicable for things inside the universe and not for the Expansion of Space time Fabric*
Thermodynamics laws are same in the universe but our physics may not. We need to develop different kind of physics for better understanding of universe.
Correction: timing 8:10, मौत के कुएं में तेजी से घूमते हुए चीज नीचे नहीं गिरती जबकि जब वह धीरे होती है तो नीचे जाती हैं तेजी से घूमने की वजह से वह बाहर की तरफ आती है
😊सरल भाषा मे ये कहा जा सक्ता है की भवर की तरह ब्लैक होल है जैसे भवर के बिच मे हवा circular path मे घूमती है वैसे ही प्रकाश!डार्क मैटर भी घूमता है ये दोनो circular path मे होते है इस लिये बाहर नही आ पाते प्रकाश की गति का कौइ प्रभाव नही
The cores of very large stars are made of iron, and when the star dies, the core collapses in on itself and becomes very dense. A region of space-time, a singularity, a black hole is simply a solid object like planets, only much denser and harder, after all, it was created from an iron core. The enormous gravity levels everything with the surface, so there are probably no peaks or valleys. Even light cannot escape from it, so if we landed on its surface in a very durable vehicle that would not be crushed by gravity, we would see light on its surface. The larger the black hole, the slower the light moves, and maybe even the attraction would be so great that the light would move several km/h. , so we could see how light travels.
sir nice podcast ever we have from you but discussion chalte chalte awaz kam ho raha tha 100 persent sound me v kaan laga ke sun na pada and please keep it up and many of our Q and doubt solved.
Our universe is defined by 4 dimensions. And if we believe in the multiverse theory then there are different universes defined by different levels of dimensions. All these different universes are defined within a specific space. The space can extend and distract according to natural phenomena. Think of a balloon. When you insert gas in it from an external force it enlarges. When you release the air from it, it contracts and finally gets its original position. Universes act like a series of balloons under which there is always random natural phenomena exerts and retracts energies. A black hole is like a hole created between multiverses. We know that Matter and Energy flows from the higher end to the lower end. A Black Hole takes all the energies in it and throws out an Opposite force to the boundary of the next multiverse. It is like a tunnel.
DAMNNN THIS CHANNEL IS A GOLD MINE FOR SCIENCE ENTHUSIASTS. I STARTED PREPARING FOR JEE THINKING THAT I WILL LEARN NEW THINGS BUT IT'S MOSTLY RATTAFICATION BUT IT HELPS ME TO UNDERSTAND VIDEOS AND CONCEPTS LIKE THESE
Gaurav sir, I am science enthusiast and I have a doubt, you said that physics ka ek basic law ki ek rotating object tab Tak rotate karta hai jab Tak uspar koi outer effort padta hai ya phir koi cheej usse collide ni karti, chalo star burst hua black hole bana lekin stars jis speed par ghumte hai, ussse zyada speed hasil karne mai to time lagta hai to according to me USS time period ke liye uski singularity point honi chahiye. Sir mei ek choti si 10 saal ki bachhi hun and a bundle of curiosity and ur fan 😅 so pls try to find the answer to this question and make a video on it pls pls pls!😊😅
It's just my theory that Black Holes are just a hole which are formed by a distruction of a large mass object, when it exploads in result it breaks the space and time barrier which is formed between space and time and sucks every thing surrounding it just like a formation of tornado in sea beds where a hole is present and the water flows so fast in a circular way it forms a tornado as same as the black hole sucks in a circular way... It's only theory don't take seriously 😅😅
If you are comparing Archimedes principal with gravity then it should be true that gravity doesn't depend on mass of object it should be dependent on volume of the object
Your explanation is great. Keep it up. Astronomy and Astrophysics with Quantum Physics is so interesting and darkest part of Science no one understands. Laws violate each other. Theory can be rejected in a second. No one can be true or trusted. In fact, what is truth people are reasearching about it.
Gaurav sir you have both qualities of black hole and white hole . Just like black hole you collect as much knowledge as you can and just like white hole you gives us as much knowledge as you can. ☺☺☺
Few days ago i had a dream where i and my friend were in different world similar to Earth but the soil was whitish there....we ate biscuit their and had a good run then i suddenly came to my unkown vehicle similar to ufo and we were going to our real world and we were allowed to only see the screen which shows our location on the unknow spiral bright thing and that spiral thing was exactly similar to the thumbnail (smaller black hole) of this video.. That was best dream of my life,hope i see like it again😊
Sir, I have one question- as we all know that black holes also have a shape of sphere , and If the scientist said that the things going inside the black hole is going in a ring like form it will more there till eternity, then also there must be a part in that sphere where the gravitational influence is nullified from all directions, as if just take an example of Jupiter , it's a gas giant if anything goes inside it , it will be attracted towards its centre , as we all know that Jupiter is also not stationary so , according to the scientist the thing fall on the Jupiter will also revolve inside it till eternity?
@@rehan-vj8fj haan ye possibility to hai, but fir bhi usme koi ek point to hoga hi jaha saari force har direction se nullify hongi!!!, actually I am saying that because hum log just blackhole ki gravity ko measure nahi kar sakte(due to lack of info/tech) is hi liye uski gravitational influence ko hum log infinity lekar saare kaam karte hain, but probably uski gravitaty bhi uske mass pr depend karegi hi, isn't it?
Don't know what, sometimes I skip my fav channel's video and watch it later. But whenever I saw this guy's video I literally can't avoid it though I don't know much about this type of content 😅
I have a question that information can not be destroyed but I have heard that in black hole everything is stretched out at its max limit so could the smallest thing in the universe which make up every thing can be erased in black hole I have this question since 2 years pls solve my question
M great job done I think black holes are created due to thumb rule of electromagnetism it just tell us about how bigger is the universe beyond some where we don't know
We have the solutions of GTR in kerr co-ordinates in our MSc Syllabus...Rotating and charged black holes.... The problem is most of the student know only about the Schwarzchild solutions which says that black holes are not rotating and unchanged but there are 4 types of black holes based on rotation and charge.... Einstein's theory is correct...just the solutions get changes according to the scenario...
Mera logic: black hole eak rasta hai naye parallel universes ka, us universe mai white hole hoga, jahase black hole ki chije bahar nikalti hogi, qki chije kahi na kahi ja to rahi hogi
I already told my friend about the block hole being just like spinning water in a river or cyclone in a massive place with massive particles . He was laughing but today I feel proud of myself. I will show this information to him.
Maybe matter jo blackhole ke andar kate hai voh singularity ke tera ak infinite dense point na hokar ak infinite dense dise bante hai. Aur white hole seh ghumte huwe bahar aate hai. Kyuki agar hame big bang singularity ko leh, toh voh bhi ak explosion tha aur usme bhi motion tha...toh usse bhi rotate kerna chahiye. Aur fir Poplwaski ka theory laga doh.
Hello Sir. This comment might be late. But is it possible that the ring motion of the objects, due to the extreme gravity effect in the centre of the blackhole, releases in the similar manner and exits from behind. As you mentioned there is no singularity, therefore objects have to be released in a way.
That has a major flaw since gravity due to black hole does not follow inverse square law. So gravity just outside the horizon and at the horizon have massive difference in magnitude.
Yaar sacchime inka ek physics ka chanel hona chahiye jaise ye samjhate hai na tooo grate...mujhe samj aa gaya itna complicated topic to samajdaro ko to samj ayega hi....aur sirf ye topic hi nehi phele bhout sare topic mujhe samj AA Gaya kay chal Raha hai..
Doubt:Bro said that the space time fabric ball displaces is cause of gravity but radius is inversely propotional to gravity and also more space time fabric curve is when gravity is high these two are contradictory statements??🤔🤔🤔😅
Gauravji Actually hum jisko base bana diya hai waha hi mistake hai jiske kaaran alag alag results milte hai. 1. Light ki speed se jyaada kuch nahi Jaa sakta. 2. Existence of Big Bang 3. The universe is born and will end. 4.Parmanu is very very very small but it has three dimensions. and many more......
I think it's not the singularity nor the ring it's both at once or we can say new mystery of matter or space time collapsing theory to travel and experiments.
Sir to jab sun k pass v apna ek curvature ha to fir sun k as pas ke planet ek he ring me akshat ku nahi ghumta ? And yea kya planets k mass ki bajayse ho raha he. .?
Sun attracts earth to itself but earth gets so fast that it is enough to slide from the sun and because this process happens infinitly(or maybe not) it looks like it's revolving
Iska matlab light ke photons pe gravity ka pravab padta hai .😮 Aur agar aisa hai to phir jahir hai ki photons ka apna waight hota hai . Aur agar uske paas apna waight hai to phir bo to matter hai aur science ki mane to koi bhi bastu jiska apna waight ho bo kabhi bhi light ke speed se travel nahi kar sakta .to phir photons kaise travel kar pata hai .😮 Iska matlab hamlog bhi light ki speed se travel kar sakte hain . Aur agar han to kaise just imagine.😮😳😳😳😳 Gourav bhai pls reply me. Mom i am genius.
5:57 Yes Our Mind. That you visualize Us. Example: if i say we go on sun, You reach it just before read this whole comment but light take 8 minute from sun to earth 🌎.
There is no black holes. General Relativity predicts dilation, not singularities. In the 1939 journal "Annals of Mathematics" Einstein wrote - "The essential result of this investigation is a clear understanding as to why the Schwarzchild singularities (Schwarzchild was the first to raise the issue of General Relativity predicting singularities) do not exist in physical reality. Although the theory given here treats only clusters (star clusters) whose particles move along circular paths it does seem to be subject to reasonable doubt that more general cases will have analogous results. The Schwarzchild singularities do not appear for the reason that matter cannot be concentrated arbitrarily. And this is due to the fact that otherwise the constituting particles would reach the velocity of light." He was referring to the phenomenon of dilation (sometimes called gamma or y) mass that is dilated is smeared through spacetime relative to an outside observer. It's the phenomenon behind the phrase "mass becomes infinite at the speed of light". Time dilation is just one aspect of dilation, it's not just time that gets dilated. Dilation is the original and correct explanation for why we cannot see light from the galactic center. It can be shown mathematically that the mass at the center of our own galaxy must be dilated. In other words that mass is all around us. There is no valid XYZ coordinate we can attribute to it, you can't point your finger at something that is smeared through spacetime. More precisely, everywhere you point is equally valid. This is the explanation for the abnormally high rotation rates of stars in spiral galaxies, the "missing mass" is dilated mass. Dilation does not occur in galaxies with very, very low mass because they do not have enough mass in their centers to achieve relativistic velocities. It has recently been confirmed in 6 very, very low mass galaxies to show no signs of dark matter. For the same reason binary stars will always have predictable rotation rates. There was clarity in astronomy before television and movies popularized singularities starting in the 1960's. What we see in modern astronomy is evidence of dilation, a known fundamental phenomenon.
![ละลาย (LALALYE) - DAOU PITTAYA ต้าห์อู๋ พิทยา [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wo6r9TgausI/mqdefault.jpg)
The most loved topic for science lovers 😊
But there are many more things that are much more complex and interesting
Mee ☺️☺️I love science
My fav. Topic.. 😊
Yes ❤
I'm a science lover and it's already on my insta profile
Explain कमाल का करते हो भाई जी..... जो चीजें हम किताबों मे पढ़ के नही समझ सकते... वो आपके छोटे से Explanation के Video से समझ आ जाती है........ और सच मे, ऐसे Thoughts ज़ब कोई Scientist Apply करता है... तब हमें लगता है कि हाँ यार वो Scientist बहुत सटीक Theory देकर गया है...... पर आज कि Video देखकर लगा की...... वाकई Eienstein's की सोंच को किसी ने Challenge कर दिया..... और वो भी बहुत ही Solid Evidence के साथ.......... गजब का दिमाग़ लगाया है इस नए Scientist ने..... मान गए......
विज्ञान भी उसी को याद रखता है जो सबूत को सिद्ध करता है..... 🙏
Mass=Curvature in space-time
Curvature in space-time=Gravity
Mass of singularity=infinite=infinite curve so space-time break apart hence singularity not make any sense of existence or when or where
This is summary of entire vdo
Agreed 💯 Unless You Or Me ... Actually Go Down To The Depths Of The Unknown !!!!!
That's the thing about science that it's as big as universe meaning infinite
That means infinite theories, infinite curiosities and mysteries
Science is majestic which can't be explained by perspective of one
❤❤ and it's is unknown and dimensions are unknown with beings existing above them ❤❤
Thats what it is the science is 🤩
That ain't science, kid
Then why not an infinite speed?
Science is not majestic cuz it proves explanation behind everything they find one having no explaination behind anything is majestic And whenever science reaches bharat it fails to explain the reasons behind the things so sanatan is what majestic the believe hope and trust we have on God The parabhram is majestic
Gaurav sir
Quantum mechanics kehti hai jab Tak koi matter ke sath interact nahi karata tab Tak vo wave form me exist karata hai
Par blackhole ke case me koi interaction hi nahi hai ( after all koi chij ko dekh nahi sakate to interact kahase karange)
Toh their is high probability singularity yek wave function me exist karata ho
nice, you are very intelligent
Matter don't have eyes
It sounds like you are saying that nothing exist until someone saws it ...........
totally disagreed to2 your theory
we cant even imagine what level of maths and physics is involved in this ....
@@krishyadav3995according to quantum physics , reality doesn't exist in a definitive state until it's observed, and observation inevitably changes reality. This means that particles exist in many states at once until they are measured. For example u observed the tree in the way I don't , now in this case that exists for u cause u observed it but not for me ...
bhai ye observer ke point of view se kha jata h , wave form is like possibilities and particle form is like one of outcome of that possibilities , take an example mai tujse puchu tere ghar ke bahar kon khada h , jb tk tu observe nhi kare tbtk koi bhi ho sakta h ladka , ladki , kutta , Aadmi , bacha kuch bhi , to ye h superposition, yha possibilities bhot h , isse hi wave nature keh sakte h , aur tu bahar Jake observe Karle to tujhe pta hi chal jayega kon h ye hogya particle nature , to black hole dekha nhi ja sakta kyuki wha se light espace nhi ho pati , par matter uske around kese behave karma h usi se hum black hole ke depiction ko samaj pate h , black hole ke case m interaction hoti h , ussi interaction ko to hum observe karte h ,
No one can predict Gaurav Thakur's timing 😂❤
Einstein became famous for false assumption of singularity 😂
*Black Hole Be Like : Is Universe Mai Hamara Raj Chalta Hai* 😎🕳️🌌
acha
Like mil gaya ab bhag 😂😊
Hawking radiation: acha 😂
Dark matter: am I joke to you?
@@avinashkhandre0321 bro came for war 💀
Faster than light can't violate GTR because the property of tachyons (hypothetical particle travels faster than tlight) is predicted using GTR.
Nissan gtr?
@@Indiananimeeditx I can't understand it.
@@Indiananimeeditx Nope this gtr is different
@@Rey97_ 🥲
@@Indiananimeeditx🤣
I am student of physics honours or bhai ne kya explain kiya hai har ek concept ❤
GAMA Rays Left The Chat
What do you study and where?
At Rajasthan University maharaj College
Gravity is a curvature in space time fabric. A black hole is a region of spacetime where gravity is so strong that nothing, including light and other electromagnetic waves, has enough energy to escape it.
The change in gravity (from a star to black hole) is a direct impact of change of mass, due to change in acceleration?
?? explain your question
ig you wanted to say "not has enough energy to excape it" so in that case if we create an object which has the energy to escape it then that means we can go in-out in black hole ?!??!/
@@DarkBoy-px1zl it wont be a black hole then
@@DarkBoy-px1zlI don't think such force exists but there can be a way "until there is a vantablack object that we can mass produce so the light can be absorbed so that we can possibly make through like 50 meters inside a black hole 🤔
it will be a tunnel that we will go in and out daily :)@@nubtonoob152
You have always gave us the out of the box perspective you are the best teacher
Bhai par ek doubt hei, like during the formation of blackhole, it is said that when a massive star comes to the end of its life, it uses all of its energy and expand to a point where the gravity of the star will dominate and the star collapse on itself. So if it is a star collapsing on itself, how can it explode, shouldnt it go implode?? and if it implodes, then at the centre of the blackhole, the remaining of the core of that star has to be present, and the core would have shrunk to a size where nuclear or repulsive forces balances the gravitational force. Right??
And one more thing, Like every where it is displayed as there is only one layer of space-time fabric, But that is not completely true . In a 3D space, there would be or there has to be multiple layers of space-time fabric. So if that is the case, when a blackhole of lets say any heavy body is in that, then shouldnt a sphere or a blanket of space time frabic wrap the planet or that heavenly body from all the sides??
I know its a little bit hard to imagine or understand what i meant, but through words, this is the max i could do to convey my thinking.
for the second one search up warping o spacetime thats the actual model of spacetime warping and commmon people find it hard to grasp it
for the first one the surface of the star and the matter gets sucked in first which is hte implosion and then it rebounds creating the explosion and also the core shrinks to a size smaller than the point where the strong nuclear forces are overwhelemd by gravity. just like when stars do fusion the repulsive forces of electrostatic are overcame by the huge gravity and mass of star
About your first part, I think it first explodes and then implodes, but I have doubts like if a bomb explodes on this planet it creates vacuum in that space near it and air gets sucked into that space but when exploding in the space which is already vacuum how is it sucking things, is there something else which is burning up when supernova happens.
Now the second part is space fabrics, it may be just one but depending on the mass of the objects, if you take a big sheet and put a heavy object in the center(sun) and then at a distance a bit less heavy one (earth)and then another small one(moon) close to the medium weight one(earth) , then i think the smallest will spin around the medium one and the medium one will spin around the most heavy one in sync. Hope you understood what I have typed. So I think its just one fabric.
The process you're describing is indeed related to the formation of a black hole through the collapse of a massive star, but there are some nuances to clarify.
When a massive star exhausts its nuclear fuel, it can no longer support itself against gravitational collapse. The outer layers of the star are expelled in a powerful explosion known as a supernova. The core that remains after the explosion can either form a neutron star or collapse further to become a black hole.
Here's a step-by-step breakdown:
1. Nuclear Fusion and Gravity Balance: Throughout its life, a star maintains a balance between the outward pressure from nuclear fusion in its core and the gravitational force trying to collapse it. Once it exhausts its nuclear fuel, this balance is disrupted.
2. Collapse: Without the outward pressure from nuclear fusion, gravity starts to dominate, causing the star to collapse. If the star is massive enough, this collapse can lead to a supernova.
3. Supernova Explosion: The core collapse can generate a shockwave that causes the outer layers of the star to be expelled in a supernova explosion. This explosion is what you may be referring to as the star "exploding."
4. Remnant: What remains after the explosion is the core of the star. Depending on the mass of the core, it can either become a neutron star or continue collapsing to form a black hole.
5. Black Hole Formation: If the core's mass is above a certain threshold (about 2.5 to 3 solar masses), the gravitational forces become so strong that nothing, not even light, can escape. This marks the formation of a black hole.
Regarding the idea of the core shrinking to a size where nuclear or repulsive forces balance gravitational forces at the center of the black hole, it's important to note that within a black hole, traditional physical laws, as we understand them, break down. The classical notion of a "size" or "structure" at the center of a black hole becomes somewhat meaningless in the context of general relativity. The singularity at the center of a black hole is a point of infinite density, and our current understanding of physics can't precisely describe what happens at that point. It's an area where our understanding of gravity and quantum mechanics is incomplete, and it's a topic of ongoing theoretical research in physics.
AND THE SECOND HALF PART:
The concept of a "layer" of space-time fabric can be a bit challenging because it's an attempt to represent the curvature of space-time in a simplified way. In reality, space-time is a four-dimensional continuum, and when we talk about the curvature caused by massive objects like planets or black holes, it affects the entire surrounding space.
In general relativity, mass and energy curve space-time, and objects move along curved paths in response to this curvature. The presence of a massive object, such as a planet or a black hole, causes a curvature in space-time around it. This curvature is not like a physical layer but more like a deformation of the space-time fabric itself.
The common visualizations involving rubber sheets or blankets are simplifications used to convey the idea of how mass warps space-time. However, it's important to remember that these are just analogies, and the actual mathematics of general relativity describe the curvature of space-time in a more complex and accurate manner.
In the case of a black hole, the curvature of space-time is extremely intense near the singularity at the center. As you move away from the black hole, the curvature gradually decreases, and space-time returns to a more "normal" state. This curvature extends in all directions around the black hole.
So, it's not so much about a physical layer wrapping around a massive object; rather, it's about understanding how the presence of mass warps the entire space-time continuum in its vicinity. The curvature is present in all directions around the massive object, creating a gravitational field that influences the motion of other objects in that region of space.
@@KhushiSingh-C13 idk if you wrote yourself or not but both are good explanations but for the secobd part
Everything moves in a straight line however due to the warping of space time the space time bends which looks like the object is falling when in reality its just moving in a straight line
The way you explain is amazing ❤
@ntshanimeeditz6878 this is not my 1st vid
Sir honestly
Me bachpan se ye sochta tha ki log space time fabric ko 1 cloth bata kar earth ki gravity use karke gravity ko proof karte the aaj apne mera doubt clear kar dia thanks🫡
Yeh video to bahut hi informative tha. Maine bahut kuchh seekh liya."😊
Aab toh tm scientist ban gya h bhai Jaake dekhna toh black hole ke andar kya h
Greatly covered the topic in a very simplified way....
Great job Bhai...👍👍👍
TH-camrs pr kabhi yakeen mat krna !
Afsos kitni bholi awam hai india ki
Pretty impressive discussion on the latest development of the movements and singularity of the black holes...👍
00:06 Theory of black holes being proved wrong
01:35 Gravity is due to space-time curvature, not the other way around.
02:56 Gravity is caused by curved paths moving towards the center of mass due to curved space-time.
04:25 Objects getting closer to a black hole's event horizon move faster than the speed of light.
05:56 General Theory of Relativity and singularity inside black holes.
07:31 Black holes have ring-shaped singularities due to their rotation.
08:57 GPS satellites prove the General Theory of Relativity's time dilatation principle
10:28 Roy Kerr's theory may replace Einstein's GTR for understanding black holes.
Muja ik doubt haa galaxy ka centre ma black hole hota ha jo ass pass ki light absorb kar leta ha toh galaxy's centre bright kyo dikhti haa usa toh centre ma dark fikhna chahiye explain me plz ❤
Because the frictional and gravitational interactions at play in the extreme space surrounding a black hole cause this material to heat up and shine brightly across a range of wavelengths. For this reason the center of the galaxy looks bright. Hope you understood
*One day I thought that why we can't see a Black hole like other 3d Objects and after thinking a lot I came to the point that Black hole is Just a 2d disk which rotates. I remembered this When you Said that Singularity doesn't exists and Things just revolve in a Circular track in the darkness of Blackhole.*
*By the Way , The Space Time can move faster than speed of light ( C ) because it is expanding more Faster and more faster than Speed of Light. We can Say that the Flow of Space Time near the Event Horizon is faster than Speed of Light.*
*GTR is only applicable for things inside the universe and not for the Expansion of Space time Fabric*
Thermodynamics laws are same in the universe but our physics may not.
We need to develop different kind of physics for better understanding of universe.
Correction: timing 8:10, मौत के कुएं में तेजी से घूमते हुए चीज नीचे नहीं गिरती जबकि जब वह धीरे होती है तो नीचे जाती हैं तेजी से घूमने की वजह से वह बाहर की तरफ आती है
Kya baat hai bhai, its really amazing videos.. 👌👌 appreciate your efforts...
😊सरल भाषा मे ये कहा जा सक्ता है की भवर की तरह ब्लैक होल है जैसे भवर के बिच मे हवा circular path मे घूमती है वैसे ही प्रकाश!डार्क मैटर भी घूमता है ये दोनो circular path मे होते है इस लिये बाहर नही आ पाते प्रकाश की गति का कौइ प्रभाव नही
1:59 Mera bhi same yehi question arise hua tha kabse!!Lekin koi mila nhi ise suljhane mein..Akhir kar🔥🔥👍😀
bhai please go search warping of spacetime it will clear anymore doubts
The cores of very large stars are made of iron, and when the star dies, the core collapses in on itself and becomes very dense. A region of space-time, a singularity, a black hole is simply a solid object like planets, only much denser and harder, after all, it was created from an iron core. The enormous gravity levels everything with the surface, so there are probably no peaks or valleys. Even light cannot escape from it, so if we landed on its surface in a very durable vehicle that would not be crushed by gravity, we would see light on its surface. The larger the black hole, the slower the light moves, and maybe even the attraction would be so great that the light would move several km/h. , so we could see how light travels.
Gaurav sir I love you sir you always provide us some interesting things. God bless you sir ❤🙏
sir nice podcast ever we have from you but discussion chalte chalte awaz kam ho raha tha 100 persent sound me v kaan laga ke sun na pada and please keep it up and many of our Q and doubt solved.
Our universe is defined by 4 dimensions. And if we believe in the multiverse theory then there are different universes defined by different levels of dimensions. All these different universes are defined within a specific space. The space can extend and distract according to natural phenomena. Think of a balloon. When you insert gas in it from an external force it enlarges. When you release the air from it, it contracts and finally gets its original position. Universes act like a series of balloons under which there is always random natural phenomena exerts and retracts energies. A black hole is like a hole created between multiverses. We know that Matter and Energy flows from the higher end to the lower end. A Black Hole takes all the energies in it and throws out an Opposite force to the boundary of the next multiverse. It is like a tunnel.
DAMNNN THIS CHANNEL IS A GOLD MINE FOR SCIENCE ENTHUSIASTS. I STARTED PREPARING FOR JEE THINKING THAT I WILL LEARN NEW THINGS BUT IT'S MOSTLY RATTAFICATION BUT IT HELPS ME TO UNDERSTAND VIDEOS AND CONCEPTS LIKE THESE
Bhai tum 11th k hona😂😂😂😂😂😂
Pehle Jee Ka 1st attempt dede sab samjh aajayega rattafication 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Chomu😂😂😂
@@HeroGuy616 bhai 12th m hu aur jee ka 1st attempt kal tha aur maine papaer se do din pehle decide kiya ki i will not give it😐😐
@@ishangoyal8552 and aisa kyu Bro???
Ek to taiyari achi nahi thi aur upar se mock m kuch number bhi nhi aa rhe the
@@HeroGuy616
Excellent explanation. You made this complex subject seem so easy to understand. 👌🏻👏🏻
Gourav Bhai apka bohot bohot shukriya k apke wajah se hume itna accha knowledge milta hai..... thanks bhai
Gaurav sir,
I am science enthusiast and I have a doubt, you said that physics ka ek basic law ki ek rotating object tab Tak rotate karta hai jab Tak uspar koi outer effort padta hai ya phir koi cheej usse collide ni karti, chalo star burst hua black hole bana lekin stars jis speed par ghumte hai, ussse zyada speed hasil karne mai to time lagta hai to according to me USS time period ke liye uski singularity point honi chahiye. Sir mei ek choti si 10 saal ki bachhi hun and a bundle of curiosity and ur fan 😅 so pls try to find the answer to this question and make a video on it pls pls pls!😊😅
Please make a video on great filter theory. Gaurav sir
It's just my theory that Black Holes are just a hole which are formed by a distruction of a large mass object, when it exploads in result it breaks the space and time barrier which is formed between space and time and sucks every thing surrounding it just like a formation of tornado in sea beds where a hole is present and the water flows so fast in a circular way it forms a tornado as same as the black hole sucks in a circular way... It's only theory don't take seriously 😅😅
That's the beauty of science 😍
If you are comparing Archimedes principal with gravity then it should be true that gravity doesn't depend on mass of object it should be dependent on volume of the object
Your explanation is great. Keep it up. Astronomy and Astrophysics with Quantum Physics is so interesting and darkest part of Science no one understands. Laws violate each other. Theory can be rejected in a second. No one can be true or trusted. In fact, what is truth people are reasearching about it.
Gaurav sir you have both qualities of black hole and white hole . Just like black hole you collect as much knowledge as you can and just like white hole you gives us as much knowledge as you can. ☺☺☺
One of his best videos till date.
Few days ago i had a dream where i and my friend were in different world similar to Earth but the soil was whitish there....we ate biscuit their and had a good run then i suddenly came to my unkown vehicle similar to ufo and we were going to our real world and we were allowed to only see the screen which shows our location on the unknow spiral bright thing and that spiral thing was exactly similar to the thumbnail (smaller black hole) of this video..
That was best dream of my life,hope i see like it again😊
I think black holes might be creating a new star out of the supernova explosion ❤❤❤
The Possibilities Are ♾️ Infinite 💯
Gaurav ji you specify everything very easily
Sir, I have one question- as we all know that black holes also have a shape of sphere , and If the scientist said that the things going inside the black hole is going in a ring like form it will more there till eternity, then also there must be a part in that sphere where the gravitational influence is nullified from all directions, as if just take an example of Jupiter , it's a gas giant if anything goes inside it , it will be attracted towards its centre , as we all know that Jupiter is also not stationary so , according to the scientist the thing fall on the Jupiter will also revolve inside it till eternity?
Yaha sqeeze theorem laga sakte hai
bhai tu topper hi kya
@@younuskhan.007 nahi bro just question dimaag me aaya to poochhne ka prayaas kiya maine...😅😅
@@rehan-vj8fj haan ye possibility to hai, but fir bhi usme koi ek point to hoga hi jaha saari force har direction se nullify hongi!!!, actually I am saying that because hum log just blackhole ki gravity ko measure nahi kar sakte(due to lack of info/tech) is hi liye uski gravitational influence ko hum log infinity lekar saare kaam karte hain, but probably uski gravitaty bhi uske mass pr depend karegi hi, isn't it?
@@Alonehobbies nahi be sithe sithe bolna science aur geography me topper
Don't know what, sometimes I skip my fav channel's video and watch it later.
But whenever I saw this guy's video I literally can't avoid it though I don't know much about this type of content 😅
I have a question that information can not be destroyed but I have heard that in black hole everything is stretched out at its max limit so could the smallest thing in the universe which make up every thing can be erased in black hole I have this question since 2 years pls solve my question
The expansion of Universe is more than the speed of light....
Sir dhire dhire energy kam hoga aur vah object bhi singularity ki taraf girta jayega
What do you think?
Blackholes ke baare me meri tarah kon kon bahut jyada janna chahta h 👀
Tumha kuch nahi pata space kaa baara main 😂
We need more videos on Black hole❤❤
Gaurav sir is a legend 🎉🎉
M great job done
I think black holes are created due to thumb rule of electromagnetism it just tell us about how bigger is the universe beyond some where we don't know
We have the solutions of GTR in kerr co-ordinates in our MSc Syllabus...Rotating and charged black holes....
The problem is most of the student know only about the Schwarzchild solutions which says that black holes are not rotating and unchanged but there are 4 types of black holes based on rotation and charge....
Einstein's theory is correct...just the solutions get changes according to the scenario...
Agreed @underraredPie.....Could Also Take A Look At My Comment....from @jacquemartinue......And Tell Me If It Makes Sense ????? Thanks 🙏
Or a massive umbrella out of the ozone layer which will suck the rays of sun
2024 board exam dene wale like karo 😂😂
😂
10th ya 12th???
😂
12th
Are kunal tu 😂
Mera logic: black hole eak rasta hai naye parallel universes ka, us universe mai white hole hoga, jahase black hole ki chije bahar nikalti hogi, qki chije kahi na kahi ja to rahi hogi
This is better than studying for board exam😂
YOUR RESEARCH IS TOO GOOD.
Next level video ❤ aajkal video ache aa rhe h
Black hole ब्रह्माण्ड को आपस में जोड़ते हैं एक दूसरे से जोड़े हुए ब्रह्माण्ड ऊर्जा transfer होती हैं
Black holes k zariye sayad hum alternate universe me ja sakte hai❤from kolkata ❤️
Gaurav sir kya Mast Explain karte Hai Sare Concepts Clear!..❤❤
🔱ॐ नमःशिवाय🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷 हर हर महादेव🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷 जय महाकाल 🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷 जय सीताराम🌷🌷🌷🌷🇮🇳जय हिंद ❤️ 🔱ॐ नमःशिवाय 🙏🚩🪷🌼🥭🌿🌺🍎
I have a question sir
Why is pie considered as irrational even when it's decimal expansion repeats after a few digits
😂repeat kb hota h,kaha padha
@@KillerFizaye-pd1ql school k teacher ne Keh diya hoga 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@HeroGuy616 very true schools teach wrong information some times.
@@KillerFizaye-pd1ql Dividing 22/7
Leaves quotient :
3.142857142857.........
Clearly look
After 3.142857
It repeats
I already told my friend about the block hole being just like spinning water in a river or cyclone in a massive place with massive particles . He was laughing but today I feel proud of myself. I will show this information to him.
Huge. Respect to SIR ROY🙏🫡🫡
Maybe matter jo blackhole ke andar kate hai voh singularity ke tera ak infinite dense point na hokar ak infinite dense dise bante hai. Aur white hole seh ghumte huwe bahar aate hai. Kyuki agar hame big bang singularity ko leh, toh voh bhi ak explosion tha aur usme bhi motion tha...toh usse bhi rotate kerna chahiye. Aur fir Poplwaski ka theory laga doh.
EINSTEIN BE LIKE : DIMAAG KHARAB HOJAYEGA MERA 😂
Amma behen pey Ajaowngha inki amma behn pey 😅
😅😅
Hello Sir. This comment might be late. But is it possible that the ring motion of the objects, due to the extreme gravity effect in the centre of the blackhole, releases in the similar manner and exits from behind. As you mentioned there is no singularity, therefore objects have to be released in a way.
Gaurav Thakur respect button for fans✅✅✅
Really 😅😮
What if a black hole is a big (stable) atomic nucleus with huge positive charge and gravity is like attractive force like polarity 😃
That has a major flaw since gravity due to black hole does not follow inverse square law.
So gravity just outside the horizon and at the horizon have massive difference in magnitude.
My Mother health is not well please pray for her speedy recovery😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Fantastic video
You are my favourite explainer
Yaar sacchime inka ek physics ka chanel hona chahiye jaise ye samjhate hai na tooo grate...mujhe samj aa gaya itna complicated topic to samajdaro ko to samj ayega hi....aur sirf ye topic hi nehi phele bhout sare topic mujhe samj AA Gaya kay chal Raha hai..
Aap jo bataye🤯95%logo ko samajh nai aya hoga lekin mera pura dimag khul gaya. Hil Gaya Mai disturb ho gaya khatarna tarika reality ka 🤯❤️♥️♥️🥳
YOUR VOICE ATRACT ME❤
Doubt:Bro said that the space time fabric ball displaces is cause of gravity but radius is inversely propotional to gravity and also more space time fabric curve is when gravity is high these two are contradictory statements??🤔🤔🤔😅
A like for Space Enthusiasts
AMAZING ANIMATION AND BEST FOR LEARNING FACT & KNOWLEDGE YOUR GREAT BRO❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Yes
He should start a
Vlog ingredients channel😂😂❤❤❤
Respect for gaurav sir's editing❤
Thanks for 1 like ❤
So light speed se bhi jyada fast bhi koi chiz exist karti he zo ki black hole he right?
Correct 💯
He means the curvature fall at the event horizon of a black hole is faster then light. However, i still dont believe this.
Gauravji
Actually hum jisko base bana diya hai waha hi mistake hai jiske kaaran alag alag results milte hai.
1. Light ki speed se jyaada kuch nahi Jaa sakta.
2. Existence of Big Bang
3. The universe is born and will end.
4.Parmanu is very very very small but it has three dimensions.
and many more......
Amazing ❤❤
Very good gaurav you didn't make us sad ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Kashmiri shayari on the way was the administration of the company 😂😂😂
I think it's not the singularity nor the ring it's both at once or we can say new mystery of matter or space time collapsing theory to travel and experiments.
Kon kon chahta hai ki kaas ye vyakti hamara science teacher hota 😌😌😌
😌
❤❤❤❤❤आचार्य अग्निव्रत की unified theory of everything , "om Rashmi " ke bare me bhi video me explain kar sakenge kya❤❤
Sir to jab sun k pass v apna ek curvature ha to fir sun k as pas ke planet ek he ring me akshat ku nahi ghumta ? And yea kya planets k mass ki bajayse ho raha he. .?
Yes different masses of the planets impacts the position of the planet.
Sun attracts earth to itself but earth gets so fast that it is enough to slide from the sun and because this process happens infinitly(or maybe not) it looks like it's revolving
Iska matlab light ke photons pe gravity ka pravab padta hai .😮 Aur agar aisa hai to phir jahir hai ki photons ka apna waight hota hai . Aur agar uske paas apna waight hai to phir bo to matter hai aur science ki mane to koi bhi bastu jiska apna waight ho bo kabhi bhi light ke speed se travel nahi kar sakta .to phir photons kaise travel kar pata hai .😮
Iska matlab hamlog bhi light ki speed se travel kar sakte hain .
Aur agar han to kaise just imagine.😮😳😳😳😳
Gourav bhai pls reply me.
Mom i am genius.
If there is no singularity then what is neutron star
Jab koi planet space time me rakhne se kon si sij planet ko nishe khisti ya attract karti he
Nice information ❤
5:57 Yes Our Mind.
That you visualize Us.
Example: if i say we go on sun,
You reach it just before read this whole comment but light take 8 minute from sun to earth 🌎.
I think black holes are like a recycle bin or a dustbin. They eat dead stars or others and convert them into recycled atoms, protons, etc particles.
Wonderful explanation, we have got 1K+ Subscribers because of such topics.
किस किस को black ⚫ hole के baare में पता था
Like 👍करो अगर पता hai
There is no black holes. General Relativity predicts dilation, not singularities. In the 1939 journal "Annals of Mathematics" Einstein wrote -
"The essential result of this investigation is a clear understanding as to why the Schwarzchild singularities (Schwarzchild was the first to raise the issue of General Relativity predicting singularities) do not exist in physical reality. Although the theory given here treats only clusters (star clusters) whose particles move along circular paths it does seem to be subject to reasonable doubt that more general cases will have analogous results. The Schwarzchild singularities do not appear for the reason that matter cannot be concentrated arbitrarily. And this is due to the fact that otherwise the constituting particles would reach the velocity of light."
He was referring to the phenomenon of dilation (sometimes called gamma or y) mass that is dilated is smeared through spacetime relative to an outside observer. It's the phenomenon behind the phrase "mass becomes infinite at the speed of light". Time dilation is just one aspect of dilation, it's not just time that gets dilated. Dilation is the original and correct explanation for why we cannot see light from the galactic center.
It can be shown mathematically that the mass at the center of our own galaxy must be dilated. In other words that mass is all around us. There is no valid XYZ coordinate we can attribute to it, you can't point your finger at something that is smeared through spacetime. More precisely, everywhere you point is equally valid. This is the explanation for the abnormally high rotation rates of stars in spiral galaxies, the "missing mass" is dilated mass.
Dilation does not occur in galaxies with very, very low mass because they do not have enough mass in their centers to achieve relativistic velocities. It has recently been confirmed in 6 very, very low mass galaxies to show no signs of dark matter. For the same reason binary stars will always have predictable rotation rates.
There was clarity in astronomy before television and movies popularized singularities starting in the 1960's. What we see in modern astronomy is evidence of dilation, a known fundamental phenomenon.
ye sab 'shyad' word ka hi khel hai 😂