and here I thought live Marillion was forever lost as no one, including the genius Mr. Fish himself can do Marillion. Amazing vocals, drumming, guitar.... all of you are nailing old Marillion and that is not an easy feat..... I have my Marillion gooseflesh back.
Jesus H Christ! What a cover. Absolutely outstanding. I've never seen anyone able to perform Grendel properly, never mind give it all the soul it deserves. Absolutely amazing.
Very impressive! The singer nailed that very difficult dramatic last part so well and was living the role! As for the musicians... all excellent... and a special bravo to Marcella for her out of this world guitar playing!
I hear it and I am 40 Years younger^^Very good Cover.I see it 2 Times live 1 with Mick Pointer Band and 1 with Steve Rothery Band very very cool thank you good work
J adore cette chanson depuis que l'ai entendu il ya un certain temps voyage du début de marillion magnifique chanteur et le groupe sont tous excellent merci continuez à me faire revivre toutes les superbes chansons du grand fish belle époque 💚💚
Can we please make an crowdfunding so we can still enjoy this amazing music and performance… will start to pay €100 for see them in live Paradiso, Amsterdam.
I last saw the group in April... It was the third appearance. After the first performance I was euphoric. The second one was rather weak and wasn't as good. But what the group did in April... Definitely better than Marillion. At least those who didn't experience the Fish era will be very well rewarded with a "good" performance...
Riascoltati ieri sera, con il nuovo cantante. 2 ore 1/2 di musica FANTASTICA!!!!! Sono uscito sudato come un cavallo e senza voce!!! Da rivedere sempre
Grandi tutti! Bravo anche il nuovo cantante... che non conosco, ma spero di aver modo di conoscerlo! Marcy come sempre si gasa tantissimo, quanto me piasce quando si scatena! Voto DIESCI! :D Roby è una macchina precisa dietro le bacchette e Guglielmo impeccabile, si vede che si porta dietro l'esperienza genesiana ;)
Kleiner Tipp, auch wenn Sie nicht nach Luxembourg kommen. Die Gruppe spielt mindestens einmal im Jahr in Nierstein/Rhein das liegt bei Mainz. Der Weg dürfte nicht so weit sein... Ich würde wenn ich Zeit hätten denen sogar in die Niederlande folgen...
I have watched some old Mr. Punch videos before, but didn't quite catch when did the vocalist change. Somebody please enlighten me? :) Nevertheless: covering Grendel here is an act of greatness and preserving a true masterpiece. Keep up the good work! In my opinion this song was the most "epic" song (of Fish years) Marillion made in the true meaning of the word. It's a classic triptych with a beginning, a middle and the end. A viking saga ending to the one of the greatest guitar solos of progressive rock have ever witnessed.
Hi. In 2019 Marco Vincini became the new singer. If i remember well this gig in Weert was his first one with the band. Marco was before he joined Mr Punch the singer in a Genesis tribute band (the cage)
@@overruled2012 thank you so much! And good luck for Marco - he is doing great and I'll be forward to seeing and hearing more of his great singing. Mr. Punch just does rule! :D
Se Fish avesse preso loro come musicisti avrebbe fatto faville , invece , a parte i primi due album, si è sempre circondato da musicisti mediocri come il chitarrista
and here I thought live Marillion was forever lost as no one, including the genius Mr. Fish himself can do Marillion. Amazing vocals, drumming, guitar.... all of you are nailing old Marillion and that is not an easy feat..... I have my Marillion gooseflesh back.
Please, come and play in Paradiso, Amsterdam 😀
Jesus H Christ! What a cover. Absolutely outstanding. I've never seen anyone able to perform Grendel properly, never mind give it all the soul it deserves. Absolutely amazing.
this !!
Amazing version!
Very impressive! The singer nailed that very difficult dramatic last part so well and was living the role! As for the musicians... all excellent... and a special bravo to Marcella for her out of this world guitar playing!
I hear it and I am 40 Years younger^^Very good Cover.I see it 2 Times live 1 with Mick Pointer Band and 1 with Steve Rothery Band very very cool thank you good work
Very good copy of one of Marillion's best song ever!!! Thanks.
Non ho parole. Meglio degli originali. Fantastici !!!
Bravissima Marcella !!!!!!!
that bass sounds so perfect for this tune
Everything about this is brilliant…….
Keyboard player is spot on. Very impressed. Guitarist better looking than Steve Rothery as well. 👍
Pourquoi 8 dislike ? C’est excellent. Si on aime Marillion on ne peut que apprécier ce tribute 👏 🙌 bravo
Amazing singer and cover
J adore cette chanson depuis que l'ai entendu il ya un certain temps voyage du début de marillion magnifique chanteur et le groupe sont tous excellent merci continuez à me faire revivre toutes les superbes chansons du grand fish belle époque 💚💚
Superb. Bring your magic to America!
these guys are good! hope they are still around....
they are !!!
Oh my. Takes me back to my teens. Marillion during the Fish era is the only Marillion and you guys give it a good go👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Great Performance. Greetings from Germany
amazing thanks for taking me back over 30 years
Einfach perfekt 👍👍👍
Beautiful Cover!!!! Bravo!!!!👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
goosebumpsssssssssss
Super.... Merci pour le partage.
Excelente versión. Épica! Un abrazo desde Caracas.
Mais ces types sont formidables!
Ils sont géants, il faut aller au concert en Angleterre ...c'est bientôt, j'ai trop envie d'y aller
Goodness me that is such a difficult song with lots of difficult timings and changes - wow nailed it!
the guitarrist killed
Amazing cover .Amazing Band. you got the soul dude
Bass, voice, drum, keyboard and guitar are all very good, congratulations
Great rendition. Thanks for sharing!!!
Amazing!!!!!!!
Can we please make an crowdfunding so we can still enjoy this amazing music and performance… will start to pay €100 for see them in live Paradiso, Amsterdam.
Oups j'ai des frissons, bravo
You are just amazing, well done for this great interpretation and this trip back thirty years.
Last guitar solo would have had Rothery salivating. Brilliant!
One of the most beautiful songs on the planet. Great cover.
Saw them play this last Friday, Saturday and Sunday in Leicester. Utterly superb.
Best cover ever….almost Better than original 🤣
I last saw the group in April... It was the third appearance. After the first performance I was euphoric. The second one was rather weak and wasn't as good.
But what the group did in April... Definitely better than Marillion. At least those who didn't experience the Fish era will be very well rewarded with a "good" performance...
Riascoltati ieri sera, con il nuovo cantante. 2 ore 1/2 di musica FANTASTICA!!!!! Sono uscito sudato come un cavallo e senza voce!!! Da rivedere sempre
Phenomenal!
new singer, new talent, old songs, best memories... come to Germany, Netherlands,... soon, please! ;-)
Thank God for coverbands like these...
Great incorporating of metal sound
Woww very amazing !!
Grandi tutti! Bravo anche il nuovo cantante... che non conosco, ma spero di aver modo di conoscerlo!
Marcy come sempre si gasa tantissimo, quanto me piasce quando si scatena! Voto DIESCI! :D
Roby è una macchina precisa dietro le bacchette e Guglielmo impeccabile, si vede che si porta dietro l'esperienza genesiana ;)
This band ist GREAT!
I WOULD DIE FOR THIS BAND XXXXXXXXXXXX
Sehr sehr gut gemacht ,kommt bitte nach luxembourg
Kleiner Tipp, auch wenn Sie nicht nach Luxembourg kommen. Die Gruppe spielt mindestens einmal im Jahr in Nierstein/Rhein das liegt bei Mainz. Der Weg dürfte nicht so weit sein... Ich würde wenn ich Zeit hätten denen sogar in die Niederlande folgen...
Ich werde 100%2025 da sein ,DANKE
@@Highlanderone88 "mindestens einmal im Jahr in Nierstein/Rhein"... 🤣Mr. Punch kommt dieses Jahr noch einmal. Am 16.11.2024 ins "E-Werk" Nierstein...😁
Complimenti, quasi meglio dell'originale.
What a remarkable performance!!!
I watched Steve Rothery play this early in 2019 with his band. It took him three attempts to get the intro right! 😁
Brilliant,loved the ending too!
OMG!!! Totally Amazing, outstanding band!!! Had an amazing afternoon during Marillion weekend in Leicester 2019!! Thank you all soooo much!!
Excellent thanks💛🎶👏👏👏👏👏
Wow, hopw close to the original live version that sounds. Vocals are very close to Fish and performance is top notch
Superb cover.Look forward to seeing you at Camden.
Nail it 😎😎 never thought I'd say that
Weldone! excellent performance!
Belíssimos!
Mantab gan...
Cara, vcs são phoda!
Bravo 👏👏👏👏👏👏
Scotched !
The rhythm section is of The Watch
Grandissimi ma sto cantante e' proprio FORTE!!!!
I saw them in Italy, great show.. very close to Marillion
I have watched some old Mr. Punch videos before, but didn't quite catch when did the vocalist change. Somebody please enlighten me? :) Nevertheless: covering Grendel here is an act of greatness and preserving a true masterpiece. Keep up the good work! In my opinion this song was the most "epic" song (of Fish years) Marillion made in the true meaning of the word. It's a classic triptych with a beginning, a middle and the end. A viking saga ending to the one of the greatest guitar solos of progressive rock have ever witnessed.
Hi. In 2019 Marco Vincini became the new singer. If i remember well this gig in Weert was his first one with the band. Marco was before he joined Mr Punch the singer in a Genesis tribute band (the cage)
@@overruled2012 thank you so much! And good luck for Marco - he is doing great and I'll be forward to seeing and hearing more of his great singing. Mr. Punch just does rule! :D
On my humble opinión with the new singer they have become a perfect Marillion's tribute band, the way he imitates Fish voice can't be any better.
They found a better singer. As to the imbecilic remark (of Fish years), it is beneath contempt, there is only one Marillion, FISH.
vocalist has the raw aggression of a Marillion era Fish, the one thing Martin Jakubski lacks 😯
awesome rendition. the vocals are as close to fish as you can possibly get. if there was only audio, i'd definately think it's fish singing.
Maddona troppo uguale a Fish me hai portato al quello tempo ☀️
Marillion needs to replace H with this guy he as heart and passion
Come on man.. Have you seen Hogarth perform Neverland live? Easter? Out of this World? The New Kings?
Marillion kadar iyi olmuş, hatta muhteşem Turkey
La chitarrista ondeggia troppo, cmq può andare 😛
Se Fish avesse preso loro come musicisti avrebbe fatto faville , invece , a parte i primi due album, si è sempre circondato da musicisti mediocri come il chitarrista
Bellisimo