Gravity Falls (IN 100,000 DOMINOES!)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.พ. 2025
- After over a month of hard work I finally have a new video out “Gravity Falls - In 100,000 Dominoes!” This video is packed with a total of 9 messages/ciphers for dedicated fans, Can you find and or solve them all? Overall I used a total of 101,020 dominoes, the most I’ve ever used for a screen link. I hope you all enjoyed this video dedicated to such an amazing show.
And for those that don’t know this is a screen link, that means that each clip is created on it’s own, then edited together to make it look like one long setup. As always I hope you enjoy this video and if you did please like, comment, and share this video anyway that you can, I greatly appreciate it.
Music By: NateWantsToBattle / natewantstobattle
Music used in this video: • Gravity Falls Theme So...
Follow me on Twitter If you want to easily be informed when I’m working on upcoming videos: / dominoking0197
#GravityFalls #DipperPines #Disney
Person: So what did you do today?
DominoKing: Oh, you know the usual, just placing over 100,000 dominoes in place to create Gravity Falls Characters!
me:i rewatched all the episodes of gravity wfalls and steven universe
iluminati confirmed
4-16-15-6-4-25 25-19-23-6-5 23-10-20 10-9-1 16-19'5 22-23-21-13 = Thirty years and now he's back
(2:06)
Ooooh, thanks!! I am terrible at decoding things like these xD
oh wow thats awesome
A1Z26 cipher! Yaaay, another guy who knows how to decode! (I hope you didnt use a translator lol(
@@questionmark827 Nope, its correct.
How?
3:26
Code is :
Congratulations you solved a simple cipher that even "Time Baby" could figure out. However i musw go back to my own dimension, but don't worry i'll be back! Remember; reality is an illusion, the usniverse is a hologravm, buy gold, bye! -Bill Cipher
PS: The spelling mistakes are part of the Message.
Oh yeah and the Symbols surrounding Bill Cipher Are Hidden Symbols found in different Characters of Gravity Falls.
Mam prawie tom samom tapete
Pleaaase tell me you didnt use a translator. Thats the Atbash cipher
Thanks XD
How do u know?
@@testepoi4843 Its called decoding. It was the atbash cipher.
*[“A-X-O-L-O-T-L! MY TIME HAS COME TO BURN! I ENVOKE THE ANCIENT POWER THAT I MAY RETURN!*
*-Bill Cipher]*
SHOO SHOO ** Litterly 5 minutes later** SAPPHIRE HELP IM SLOWLY TURNING INTO SPINEL
Bill cipher *[UH WHAT YOU YOU WANT ME TO DO?!]*
Sapphire ! I DONT KNOW LOOK IN THE FUTURE AND SEE A CURE MY BODYS TURNING INTO A NOODLE EVERY SECOND
Bill cipher *[CANT YOU UH- REGENERATE?!]*
Sapphire ! NO
Hey everybody, sorry about not uploading for a while, I’ve been busy and haven’t had time to build as much as I want to. However I've put a ton of work into this video and hope you enjoyed all the time and effort put into this video. If you want to help and support this channel like,comment, and share this video anyway that you can, I greatly appreciate it.
I'm glad
no problem, this is awesome!
+TheDominoKing hey King, you are awesome and your video's are awesome too. no need to apologise about anything. you can upload whenever you want and i'll always appreciate your work. you're talented but sadly you don't get the amount of attention you deserve. have a great day!
"a ton of work"? skeleTON is better.
When people are commenting first on your videos, you know you are becoming a successful TH-camr
the end code translates to : Congratulations on solving a cipher even "time baby" could figure out. However I must go back to my own dimension, but don't worry I'll be back! Remember; Reality is an illusion, the universe is a hologram, buy gold, bye! -Bill Cipher
Bruh
what? other people already posted it.
+Josiah Araki its in caesar cipher? if is what is the key?
no it is the a=z
i always Translate the end messages on gravity falls
I love how they put waddles before mabel
itz gacha lucy : v lol and ur gâcha so like
Lol
He is more important I guess
I know lol
he did make robbies pants shrink so you gotta give him that
My fav character: bill cipher
Yes I worship a dream demon that looks like a cute Dorito.
Lol
Same
SAMEEEEE
Yeah, I heard that.
•Aesthetic Birb• ʕ•ᴥ•ʔ me also
OH MY FREAKING GOODNESS YOU ARE AMAZING. Seriously I have basically grown up with this show and it's so cool to see dominos with perfectly accurate characters in my all time favorite show! You deserve more subscribers than what you have! This is true dedication!
Thank you! And as a huge Gravity Falls fan myself I'm glad you enjoyed the video.
+TheDominoKing Your welcome! I'm so happy that even though it's over, people still love it. And even the other things you do like the Undertale one is just amazing.
Grow up with it? It's only a few years old
+Robatron19 that's what I was thinking lol
+Robatron19 He's probably a teen, around 15.
that show ended way too soon. One of the best shows I've ever watched.
SuperSugarPaws Kawaii me too I loved that series I wish they had made gravity falls 2
It's one of the few good disney channel cartoon's , i'm sure if they had of partnered with cartoon network it would have had at least 2 more seasons.
SuperSugarPaws Kawaii IKR I loved it
SuperSugarPaws Kawaii so true. Heck, I even liked bill (despite him being evil and all)
SuperSugarPaws Kawaii it should do S3 where it's 10 years later and dipper makes journal number 4
3:27 atbash code
Congratulations you solved a simple cipher that even “Time Baby” could figure out. However I must go back to my own dimension, but don’t worry I’ll be back! Remember; reality is an illusion, the universe is a hologram, buy gold, bye! - Bill Cipher
10popotitos
Ooooooooooooo
Holy christ dude you figured it out
Undertale
Yep! I decoded it myself too! I think the atbash code is the easiest one to decode tbh.
Bless you
*Imagine doing all this, then realizing one of the cameras wasn’t on*
I would just say screw it
That's when you load the shotgun
weren’t
Redo it
Yes I am crazy
It was probably Pacifica
Whenever I see Bill on any thumbnails, I click. And this was amazing
What Did you See?
Ngl same
Gosh I forgot about this comment
Same
@@elwiwi-v1h úūğ021q13r5r56üy88990quasgh
Why.fnn
Me: There will be no more gravity falls
Someone: But there is
Me: Not there isn't
Friend: *Shows This Video* It's a remake called Domino Falls.
Ha
XD nice
@Khalish Irshad Idham I HOPE
Literally
Domino do be fallin tho ngl
2:40
The codes are:
(First code): Game over.
(Second code): Gravity Falls.
Yes, I can read those Ciphers. I learned them and now i write them on every notebook.
My teachers will freak out if they see those. Haha!
What cipher is this? I solved every other code except for this one lool
I was wondering that too
I know the code and how to decipher it but I dont know what its called
Whats it called
me to all the other replies: the english\englishian cipher
I love how nobodies asking
“HOW MUCH DID YOU EVEN PAY FOR THAT?”
I love how nobody's asking
HOW LONG DID IT TAKE YOU TO CLEAN THAT UP?
I love how nobody's asking HOW MUCH SPACE DID THIS TAKE UP???
More like:
How much did it take for you to make that
Yes my dimiond
Pink Diamond HOW MUCH DID YOU PAY FOR THAT?
whoever did this, you are amazing.
+Neku Sakuraba Thank You!
+leon weiss ba dum tsss
thats right :o
+TheDominoKing I congratulate you I would have died by the tenth domino
You can watch Gravity (2013) full movie here *fullmoviesweb(dot)pw/gravity-2013-full-movie/.* Thanks, Logan.
I miss Gravity Falls.......
But my aim is gettin' better!
I'll show my self out
You are aloud to show yourself out, ** Stanley chackling in the corner **
Bronze Squid1023 who elese got that refrence.....
eM
Bronze Squid1023 your can see it in Netflix 😊😎😎😎😎
BronzeSquid 1023 please do
God bless anyone who has the patience to do this
Word
Preach
i did XD
Yes that must be rage inducing ultimately
MTT
TheDominoKing: yes after 2 months i finally finished
Wind: i'ma end this mans whole career
*_Scrolls Down If Alex Commented_*
*this needs to be noticed immediately*
edit: 481 weirdos watchin Gravity Falls i see, this comment is from 2 years ago YA STALKERRRZZ
That made me laugh so much! ......l’m still giggling a little because I did the same thing.😂
Sonic really?
Hi. I'm probably not the one you are looking for. Bye.
@@alexbowlin7044 oh why hello there another Alex, very common to see a-you here.
I was gonna like this, but that edit made me decide against it
Childhood in 100,000 dominos
@Riley Gooch .
Alex Hirch NEEDS to see this!!!
Diana Kallos spam to Alex! I miss him
We neeeeed more gravity falls
Diana Kallos yep
Diana Kallos yep!!! And he will LOVE it!!
Same
"Razzle dazzle friends!! It's me, the razz dazzler!!!
this is what my life has become"
- Bodacious T
It's called death Ball
"no one will EVER call you that"
-wendy
+eric jiga the final code is congratulations you solved a simple cipher that "time baby" could figure out. however i must go back to my own dimension, but don't worry i'll be back! rember; reality is an illusion, the universe is a hologram, buy gold, bye! - bill cipher
which decipher did you use? atbash? just tell me ples
+Diamond Revealer atbash
+inge widiyanti kk thanks!!
+inge widiyanti THANK YOU
Bill cipher, the sans of gravity falls ; the overpowered character who 90% of the community have a crush on.
Such a common yet fascinating stereotype
This is the most spot in comment I've read about Bill and sans
Omg so true 😂
i think Bendy (from Bendy and the ink machine) falls under that category
@@johnsforehead273 yup... I mean have you seen the fanfictions about those three?
It’s unavoidable in any fandom.
OMG this video is amazing! I really like your style! I hope that it will go viral :D
Well that it did.
Omg OMG
@@lolbitwolf2534 what?
When Bill sees a Dorito ''My children why are you in bags
I agree
Lol
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
🔼👁
Im afended
2:05 Thirty years and now he's back.
2:52 Gravity Falls Game Over
3:01 Goodbye
Yeah, I'm not doing the last message and I didn't look carefully enough to track down the others. Nice work! Really impressive and fun to watch!
More like Domino Falls
StarTemsPines Plays BADUM PSHHH
that's a pun
meikanokimi Yeah cause GRAVITY makes you FALL
StarTemsPines Plays pure gold.
There is a reason why your profile picture is Sans.
Therory: he made a deal with Bill to help build with the domnos
He did
In return he gave me a new hat
Mine got disintegrated a bit when I was in stans mind
Ok
@@thebreadking2667 your hat is honestly amazing
@@Queen_Bread Why thank you
At 2:28 I literally said " There's my Dorito."
228 whaaaaaaaat ټ
I'm balling.
Gangster Lugia what
@@dipperpines28 Oh yeah?
@@ghaztlheee
Yeah!
These set ups were insane!! Too bad the shows over now :3
+Kinetic prince Thank you! At least the show ended on a night note.
yeah!
FOR now hopefully. they will return someday.. maybe next summer?!
+Erik Li same
+Kinetic prince I need season 3...
*Intro to fixing it with soos* Ok people today me and Dipper are gonna fixety fix this mess of dominoes. *After 10 hours of work* Ah final- *knocks over whole thing* BEEEEEEEEP Ok that was it for fixing it with Soos bye.
We can all agree this is amazing!!
yes
Our adventure shall be ever preserved in this video... and the fallen dominoes.
3:07
"X-O-L-O-T-L MY TIME HAS COME TO BURN
I INVOKE THE ANCIENT POWER THAT I MAY RETURN"
XavierOG mah bae has spoken once again
A-X-O-L-O-T-L. There are loads of theories on the axolotl being connected. Look up gravity falls axolotl and you will see.
A-X-L-O-T-L. Not axolotl, though that's how it's spelled. Bill spells it A-X-L-O-T-L.
The Chaostale Group axolotl
LOL 😂
Oh my Cipher I love it!! I love it even more that you included his death message when Bill was on the screen.
I have 4 questions:
1. HOW MUCH MONEY DID THIS COST YOU?!
2. HOW MANY HOURS DID THIS TAKE YOU?!
3. What was that code thing at 1:55-2:05,2:42-2:50,3:01 & 3:26?
And 4. Why are you so awesome?
Chyro Mancer Gamer three letters back with the last one
Cheeta0Tuber 2 uhh what do you mean?
SUSHAMA AGRAWAL Ohh I see.. thanks
T H I R T Y // Y E A R S// A N D// N O W // H E ' S B A C K ... went to themysteryofgravityfalls.com/ and typed the numbers, hit the [ A1Z26 ] option, then hit 'flip it around', followed by 'uncover a secret'. Curiosity killed the cat... but satisfaction brought it back. Zombie cat says peace out
For the number one
"When live gives you lemons call them yellow oranges and sell them for double the price!" -Stanly Pines
All ya domino videos are so well done it's blowing my mind how do you have that much time to do everything :D
What blows MY mind is how it don't mess up
Nubz RBLX Provably lots of trial qnd error.
Nubz RBLX Same
Cookies&Cream just talent
Cookies&Cream same
Oh my god...maaan..how..how you doing this..it must be very hard...i love gravity falls..you are awesome
+Nadia Rusňaková Thank You!
You're welcome :D
same
You are AWSOME to me
Gravity falls I love it sadly it ended in season 2 why world why #save gravity falls
That song....*strangely, she cannot cope with the nostalgia and bursts out in tears* I MISS THAT SHOW SO MUCH!!
.
S
Shaina Gies awkward fan hug?
3:26 - Congratulations you solved a simple cipher that even Time Baby could figure out. However I must go back to my
own dimension, but
don't worry I'll be back! Remember; reality is an illusion, the universe is a holgram, buy gold, bye! - Bill Cipher
I miss gravity falls
Lord Beerus me too
Lord Beerus me three
I winder if there just that one guy who comes in when all of this is done and just like sweep up all the dominoes with a broom. I could imagine that happening.
Wonder*
True
Sнα∂σω_Ƙιтту ☺😊😀😁
Sнα∂σω_Ƙιтту lol me to
Sнα∂σω_Ƙιтту I would be that guy
that must be the one room no one can come in. you can't even breathe to loud in the house
Petition for Gravity Falls to come back starts here
Yes sir
YES SIR
2:47 smile face :)
lol
LMAO hahahahha LOL
You ruined it. And somehow I'm still laughing.
I can't even get a domino to stand up.
Ur not alone
THIS IS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!! I don't know how you had so much patience and dedication, but it turned out FANTASTIC! If i could, I'd give you thousands of likes 👌🏻😉
The sound of the dominoes falling sounded like the theme...
And I dont mean the music they played over top....
Suzanne Halliday crap i heard it tio
no it doesn't
wot the heck
This is truly amazing! 60,000 subscribers! YOU DESERVE 10 TIMES AS MUCH! Just subscribed and liked!
P.S. GRAVITY FALLS IS THE BOMB LOVE THAT SHOW!!!
Hey....
You're right 😀
+Gamer Panda same here!
+Gamer Panda too bad it ended :(
Oops Forgot to Press record :P
☆Starlight Angel☆ That would be horrible XD
☆Starlight Angel☆ that would be the WORST experience EVER When Things Go Wrong
☆Starlight Angel☆ this is why we bring multiple cameras, people!
AHAHAHAHAHAHHA WASTE OF TIME.
That would *suck* so frickin' *hard.*
3:26
Congratulations
you solved a simple cipher that even “Time Baby” could figure out. However I
must go back to my own dimension, but don’t worry I’ll be back! Remember;
reality is an illusion, the universe is a hologram, buy gold bye! - Bill Cipher
Dr. Disasderp how did this happen
Love how you started with gzemznohep/backwards message
I cry in the final episode 😭😭😭
We all cry at the finale
"backwards message" nice m8 XD
Amo a gravity fall
2:47 that says' game over gravity falls
Goodbye gravity falls*
What is the name of the code
I mean, what kind is this code?
It's the Authors code.
the amunt of time put into this is crazy
No doubt this goes viral. 😱😱😱
+WebGuy1000 - Domino Entertainment That'd be cool.
I had a Dominoes Pizza Ad before watching this
Johto Trainer Mahad ironic
clearly not a coincidence
Johto Trainer Mahad I DiD TOO!!!!!
i had little lungs in a great big world
Jude Sullano lol
*Almost finished knocks a domino over* NO!!!! ALL THAT WORK!!!
*Looks at it* Actually nevermind.
LOL
That’d suck.
Throc Morton hahahahaha🤣🤣
Throc Morton lol 😂
OH MY CIPHER THAT'S FREAKING IMPRESSIVE I IMAGINE HOW MUCH TIME IT TOOK GREAT WORK!!!!!!!
Spinel For Diamond I subbed cause u spinel
@@we_are_gamers787 Isn't that just... *Sweel* ?
I'm kidding, thanks
Spinel! You watch Gravity Falls? 😂
@@randomperson5233 yes! I think Bill is hilarious!
I love the electric guitar in gravity falls intro theme song
" A-X-O-L-O-T-L MY TIME HAS COME TO BURN! I INVOKE THE ANCIENT POWER I MAY RETURN! " By - Bill Cipher
at 2:50 it says "game over" "gravity falls"
how u know
journal 3
Wow Domino-King...More Like Domino-God!
was a sexy show
1. this guy must have lots of patients
2. this guy is underrated
3. You have to agree he is one of the best channels on the platform
THAT DIPPER WAS BIG, i guess you can say he's a big dipper
IIt seems like you put a ton of work into that pun. A SKELE-TON.
Nyeh heh heh
JewelOfThePhoenix DAMNIT SANS !!!
I Know Lots Of Things ;)
At the end, I guess you could say that is one big Doritos.
Dude, You. Are. Awesome!!! I Love Gravity Falls so Much! and what you did is sosososos awesome!
0:32 amazing, Love amazing
Me: hey look wing di- nevermind.
2:06 leads to A1Z26 cipher it means dpofdy yswfe wjt jia ps'e vwum, and when thats decrypted, its means "Thirty years and now he's back", which is a reference to Not What He Seems/A Tale of Two Stans
LTZ Xenim how do u decrypt it please I really wanna know and also what about all the letters (not numbers) that's written on the actual show , how do u turn that to English please I wanted to know for a really long time
Moneira Al yahya i think there are tutorials on the gravity falls wikia for every type of encryption used in the show
exnerhimself can u please reply back with a link
It's on the gravity falls wikia. Just search for the gravity falls wikia...
Moneira Al yahya you have to pass it from A1Z26 cipher, then use tjr atbash cipher and finally the cesar cipher
gravity fall is one of the best shows I whatched
Best in the universe T_T
Yep. Agreed.
How does somebody have THIS many dominoes
lee armani every clip is different this is not build all in one .. read the description and you will understand ;)
lee armani it's best not to think about it
The criss cross effect at 3:09 was SUPER AWESOME!!! I love it whenever you do that!
This dude has more patience then dude perfect
Imagine he ran out of storage while it was recording
gravity falls book 3 dipper waddles mabel soos wendy stanley book 1 Stanford book 2 gideon wallford bill cipher
Show this guy some support he took a long while to place these down
You did a really good job with this one Domino King, although I'm terrible at deciphering codes, so those parts will always be a mystery to me, don't worry about taking too long to upload, I'm sure most the people who watch these videos understand how much work it is to make them. Also, I understand if you don't want to, but will there ever be an undertale part 2 video? I really enjoyed that one, all the characters were perfect, like they were taken right out of the game, plus I absolutely love that game, so that helps too.
Thank you! And I will eventually make an Undertale part 2 but, I'm kinda burned out from building Undertale at the moment.
+TheDominoKing I can definitely understand how that'd happen...
+eric jiga the final code is congratulations you solved a simple cipher that "time
baby" could figure out. however i must go back to my own dimension, but
don't worry i'll be back! rember; reality is an illusion, the universe
is a hologram, buy gold, bye! - bill cipher
Woww Great Show!! All Codes here: 2:05= Thirty years and now he's back.
2:51= Game Over. Gravity Falls. 3:18= Good Bye. 3:26= congratulations you solved a simple cipher that "time baby" could figure out. however i must go back to my own dimension, but don't worry i'll be back! remember; reality is an illusion, the universe is a hologram, buy gold, bye! - bill cipher
Fun fact: The whisper when it's backwards it says "Three words back" !
And other whispers say "27 Letters" "Switch A and Z"
A tale of two stans episode whispers "He is not what he seems"
Weirdmageddon whispers say (In order of the episodes)
"I'm watching you nerds" "I'm watching you" "Goodbye gravity falls"
This is amazing!
You just earned yourself a new subscriber
You must have a really big house to fit all these dominos on the florr
*Floor
It's a screen clip thing. Which means that this video is made to look like they are all connected, but are just separate clips. But still, that IS a huge area.
Actually he did it all around his house and stationed cameras to capture it and edited it since all of it won't fit a single frame
ya
i wish there was the BEWARB mosquito bite mark
lol
+AnnaTheMarkiplier xD
Yeah, that would be epic.
yes! xD
I know right
now you HAVE to do Steven Universe in dominoes!
+Hunter Allen Possibly in the near future...
+TheDominoKing 😀
TheDominoKing that is if its not too much work for you, myself and a lot of other people would love it.
This guys worst nightmares:
“Oops I forgot to press record”
“Camera low battery”
2:05 Thirty years and now he's back
3:08 is a backward message when bill is being defeated
Ik I'm not dumb
who ever makes these dominos ur really talented
miss flawless 100 marie factories make these dominoes
Why are people sending hate he took soooooo long making this
I wonder how long this took to clean up
Trinity Wilmes I WONDER HOW LONG IT TOOK TO MAKE!!! Lol
Zazzy Z-man I WONDER HOW LONG TO POO! lol
randome dogs they asked how long was it to _clean_ not put together
AngelSpirit04 AJ And make the ciphers! Me like the ciphers.
lol me too
The backwards message at the beginning: (BACKWARDS MESSAGE BACKWARDS MESSAGE BACKWARDS MESSAGE)
The numeral code (THIRTY YEARS AND NOW HE'S BACK) {A1Z26 + ATBASH + THREELETTERSUP}
The Cipher Cipher 1 (GAME OVER GRAVITY FALLS)
The Cipher Cipher Cipher Flskhu Uohpsf 2 (GOOD BYE)
The decoded message at the end (Congratulations you solved a simple cipher that even "Time Baby" could figure out. However I must go back to my own dimension, but don't worry I'll be back! Remember; reality is an illusion, the universe is a hologram, buy gold bye! - Bill Cipher)
The backwards message at the end (Goodbye Gravity Falls)
Not sure if there's a code around Fiddleford, or he's talking normally and I can't hear it.
Bombtario
Fiddleford is talking. he says
In Gravity Falls, The world becomes sky. Fear the beast with just One Eye!
(Season 2 Episode 12 A Tale of Two Stans Reference)
i am so sad gravity falls is over (well only weirdmageddon is left in my country, but i kinde watched all of the episodes cause i was to excited and i was in school then), also great video
kinda**
I wish I had more gravity falls. I'm gonna miss it.
Dude, same here! This Saturday is the last episode. . .Hope for 3rd season even if a lot of people think there will be nothing like this (btw sorry if i am incorrect with the grammar, i kinda suck)
+TheBgHero - The Bossiest Boss Ever the creator Alex Hirsch said the series is over
+Narwalrus Society on some other video of gravity falls somebody said that alex hirsch (is that how you spell it?) gravity falls season 2 is finished because it's end of the summer, but it doesn't mean that series are over, however, i don't know if that's true
You did this on my b-day :D if I watched this on my b-day it would be a great b-day present.
I have three questions
1. Where do you get all the space for this
2. How long does it take to set up
3. How long does it take to clean up
P.S. This was amazing
+Lucas Gillette 1. I build in the basement where no one else uses.
2. Videos like "Gravity Falls" and "Undertale" usually takes 3-4 weeks of building. However my shorter domino creations like "Deadpool" usually take a day or two.
3. The longest it's ever taken me to clean up was probably 4 hours, but usually it only takes an hour or two.
And thank you!
+TheDominoKing wow! i subscribed
@@TheDominoKing glad i heard undertale from ya
2:50 - "GAME OVER, GRAVITY FALLS"
3:08 - "GOODBYE"
3:26 - "CONGRATULATIONS YOU SOLVED A SIMPLE CIPHER THAT EVEN "TIME BABY" COULD FIGURE RUT. HOWEVER I MUST GO BACK TO MY OWN DIMENSION, BUT DON'T WORRY I'LL BE BACK! REMEMBER: REALITY IS AN ILLUSION, THE UNIVERSE IS A HOLOGRAM, BUY GOLD, BYE! -BILL CIPHER"
can you make 100000 SVTFOE dominoes? awesome video btw😀😃
DR. Vince omg yas
I respect you for this. This is by far the best tribute to gravity falls I've seen so far