After 41 years of listening to Rush, there are still so many of their songs that give me the chills every time I hear them. Xanadu is one of those songs. There will never be another band like Rush.
Yup, I bought A Farewell To Kings on iTunes just so I could have it on bluetooth for my car. I played it five days ago and was screaming out the lyrics in falsetto of course and even doing that I couldn't hit some of the notes Geddy was singing! Such a great album and such a great song.
At 59 years of age - I am still moved emotionally, physically and mentally by their music. As a young 13 year old drummer - I had practiced along to the artist/drummers of the 70's. But it wasn't until I heard Rush, more specifically Neil Peart, when the light came on - suddenly pulling me towards a style I wanted to emulate. I cannot count the hours I've spent over the past 45+ years trying to nail down his drum parts. Thank you for spending time on this episode showcasing Rush. We all miss the band. We all miss you Neil. Thank you for what you gave us during all of your years.
I'm 56 now... I get it. You can't duplicate it. Just be inspired by them. Listen to what they wrote and are writing and lay it down. Smart and with perspective.
I could have wrote that comment myself. Word for word it is exactly how I feel. Right down to the ages. I still get so choked up sometimes listening to Neil. What a great soul!
Likewise. Also 56 at the moment. I can’t reproduce Neil’s parts verbatim, but I do the best I can (see what I did there?) and play them as accurately as I can (and as I hear them, which occasionally gets revised when I listen more closely or see a transcription). It’s a mountain I will never summit, but I’m enjoying the journey. “From first to last The peak is never passed Something always fires the light That gets in your eyes One moment’s high And glory rolls on by Like a streak of lightening That flashes and fades In the summer sky” I won’t even approach that peak, particularly when it comes to the creativity that first imagined those parts and lyrics, but I enjoy the journey of following one of the true greats. He may have faded from this realm, but the brilliance he shone lingers on through his recordings, his lyrics, and his other writings. Thank you Neil, and Alex, and Geddy, for writing that soundtrack for me - and for setting such a shining example of what integrity looks like.
I swear Rush saved my life. Troubled teen with no Dad. My oldest Brothers were my best friends. They both went into the army and I was left with my Mom and her abusive boyfriend. Rush helped me escape reality and I Spent so many hours immersed in Everything Rush in the 80’s. Still…looking back to those days I would go back in a heartbeat and do it all over again just to relive the mind blowing alternate universe that Rush took me to every time I put on the headphones.
Proud of your honesty and open-ness, you were able to get to a good place by getting through a bad place and glad that RUSH was there to help like the friend it truly is. . .
Ahhhh. The epic Xanadu. Its where my RUSH journey began. My older brother made me listen to Xanadu, in the dark as a nine year old. I was part enthralled and scared. The song continues to blow my mind to this day as a 50 year old. The song means the world to me. Long live RUSH. Love your channel sir. Keep fighting the good fight.
This! The first time I heard the song was when I put the record on to listen to at bedtime. My big brother was ugh back then. I did it to myself not knowing what I was doing. I have a list of songs like that, heheh.
They wrote well. Taking the words and created magic. Neal wrote. They created together. The amazing thing is that people actually smarter than what they are believe. We think like this everyday. We have thoughts and opinions. We fantasize and dream. We watch and learn. I think we would be better people if we just listened.
@@lancejohnson8522 Yes and no. Neil wrote the lyrics. Geddy and Alex would come up with the music and then once they worked out the music Neil would start working out the drumming. This is according to what the band has said. So musically they all were part, but most the sound of the song is coming from Geddy and Alex.
Same here, I told myself I would eventually see them live 12 years back when I first started university and never did, I just always assumed theyd tour forever so id catch them eventually. Never thought that anything would happen to Neil. Definitely a huge regret of mine.
I had a few chances to see them back in the 80's and 90's, but I couldn't be arsed. You think that they are going to be around forever and then they are gone. BTW l, love your channel Jamel.
Test for Echo, 1996. Played all of 2112. I've seen enough of your channel, Jamal, to know that you do have a sense of what you missed (I mean, how many Rush posters do you have in the background?), and yeah, it was fucking great.
Same here Jamal; They never came down here to Australia - and so many of us never had the cash to fly across the world and see them. BTW, love your channel brother.
I first heard Rush in High School in 76. The album was 2112. It was the most amazing music I'd ever heard. Then, in October of 77 they came to play a concert in Beaumont with Max Webster as the opener. It was my 3rd ever rock show. It was their 'Farewell to Kings' tour. To my joy, they played the 1st side of 2112, as well as a lot of the new album, to include Xanadu, and songs from their earlier 3 albums. Amazing, awesome show. I would only realize how great they were then, many years and many shows from many bands later. I saw them a total of only 6 times through the years, but they are still one of the top bands ever. Their musicianship outdoes just about any band out there, even now. Sadly they retired after the death of Neil, and rightly so. There is always a place in my head for Rush.
An interview with Alex and Geddy would be amazing! I believe Geddy is working on a memoir right now, and Alex has his new Envy Of None band. So they will both have new projects to promote.
@@conanbarbarion1631 More superior? So they're both superior, but right-handed players are more so? Who are they both superior to? People with no hands? The fuck are you even saying?
I’d LOVE a full length interview sit down with Alex and Geddy. And Rick, bring your guitar and jam a little! It’d be a dream for you and we’d joy in seeing it!
I feel fortunate that Neil left some record of his thoughts on music in the form of instructional materials, and his thoughts on things other than drumming were just as fascinating. Would be nice if all three guys could be here to talk about the music, especially since I wish there had been a lot more of that around.
Rush fan for 46 years and this was so cool to watch you break it down and be as excited as I am about the band. Thank you Rick for all you do in the music community!
The most amazing bit, is that it was written to play live, with 12 & 6 string double neck, a 6 string guitar & 4 string bass double neck, keyboards, bass peddles and drums, by only 3 musicians. And Geddy still had some spare time for vocals 😂
Believe it or not, Geddy’s double neck Rickenbacker was a 4 string bass and 12 string guitar, at least originally. The live version of the Xanadu video from the Exit Stage Left tour (probably the most viewed live version), Geddy was using the 4/12 Rick. Many years later, Geddy replaced that Rick with a 4/6 version, but for most years it was the 4/12 string. Geddy played rhythm during the solo and for the outro. Geddy actually plays the melody on guitar during the outro, along with Neil matching him note for note on the glockenspiel, all while Alex just arpeggiates a single cord. It is a masterclass ending that only a group like Rush would orchestrate. That is why they have been called the world’s smallest orchestra. I don’t know of any other three piece band that literally orchestrated layers the way Rush did? Typically, in most three or four piece rock bands, the bass pretty much played the same key the melody of the guitar is playing, but Geddy would try to find harmonies to what Alex was playing, adding texture and a much fuller sound as opposed to when the two instruments are only playing different octaves of the same thing. The one takeaway everyone says after hearing Rush, even members of other famous bands, is “how can three guys make so much sound?”. I think that the orchestration of layers is a big part of that, and the fact that Geddy and Neil filled gaps like no other rhythm section. In fact, those two alone made enough sound to be considered a band, the meat and potatoes of the sound, so Alex just became the gravy… and what a tasty gravy he made.
Many people don't know he did the band's taxes in the down time time when he wasn't doing vocals, bass, 6-string rhythm, pedals, and synth through this performance.
I saw Rush live on the “Presto” tour. When they played “Xanadu” Geddy was playing bass with his left hand, keyboard with his right hand, Taurus pedals with his feet, and singing at the same time. Simply amazing!
That’s precisely what I found most amazing about the song when they recorded it LIVE for “Exit Stage Left,” particularly just before Geddy is about to start singing. So well layered it is almost ridiculous.
I saw them at Pine Knob for the Roll the Bones tour and couldn't believe there were only the 3 of them! I kept thinking there were dudes hiding in the back to accompany them live like so many groups do, but, NO! They just utilized every available limb like the comment above stated. Amazing!
I saw Rush just once (on the WORST NIGHT OF ALL), at the Philadelphia Spectrum, September 25, 1980; John Bonham died hours before that concert. It was bittersweet for Rush and we attendees, but Rush gave us a memory. They played their as-yet-unreleased “Tom Sawyer” for us! Philly bore witness first that “Tom Sawyer” would indeed affect the annals of RnR music. I never got to see ‘Zeppelin live, and Rush kind of appreciated that, huh? 👍🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Rick always makes you feel you are sharing your joy of music with an old friend, whether it’s an old favourite or something new to you you’ll learn something each time… Great job!
Check out the United States Army Band version in memory and honor of Neil Peart. after his passing. I tear up every time I hear it. ….and I still miss Neil.
Having seen them play Xanadu live at Maple Leaf Gardens on New Years Eve 1978 was an unbelievable thing to witness! The depth and complexity of their performance was mind-blowing for my 16-year-old self, especially as a fledgling bassist! Still just SO incredible to hear! Thank, Rick for featuring this!
You have to get Alex and Geddy to sit down....thank you so much for doing this. My countrymen, never sold out, always played what they liked and are among the few true musical geniuses. Only got to see them twice live...both magical experiences 20 years apart. RIP Neil.
3 of the greatest musicians, songwriters, lyricists and performers ever to play music. EVER. 👍🏻😎 P.S. Neil wasn’t a drummer. He was a master percussionist and one of the best lyricists ever.
@@Sherwoody - Answer: ALL OF THEM! LoL :o) Was just saying to a friend last night that you'll never see as many air drummers as when you go to a RUSH concert.
@fastguitar I grew up in Springfield, VA and lived by its second location in that town. In 1999 I worked at the parent location one in Rockville. Anyway, saw Rush in 1993 at Merriweather Post (near DC) and on its final tour at the NBA arena in Phoenix
What an absolute masterpiece this song is. How could this get old. Every time I listen to it, it must be played as loud as my ears can take. The 3 amigos of progressive rock. These guys make me proud to be Canadian.
Yeah it does. A lot of songs on exit stage left sounded better than their studio versions imo. Red barchetta, Spirit of radio, Jacob's ladder, the trees, xanadu, and definitely a passage Bangkok..imo
@@blue23song31 Side 3 of Exit...Stage Left is the pinnacle for me. Broon's Bane, The Trees, Xanadu. Unreal. I can't listen to the studio version of Xanadu to this day because I love the live version so much.
@@brentjones8099 I’m in total agreement with you. To this day I can listen to side 3 and not be able to wrap my head around the idea that it was just 3 guys doing that. Live
The thing about people giving recognition to rush is this.... People who don't recognize rush as a top band in music history that changed the direction of music. Those people are just ignorant about music. But people who really know good quality music and music composition know that rush is one of the best in history!
For sure. The old “your favorite bands favorite band” comment comes to mind. The non Rush music that has been made the last 30 years that would not exist without Rush is staggering.
Never where nerdy just a WELL SPOKEN Band WHO SHOWS WHAT BADDDD ASSS GROUP THEY ARE ,SO TALENTED, SO GREAT AND TOGETHER ,,,,,FORGET IT......RUSH IS WOWWWWE
I first heard Rush in 1985 when an army buddy played their music for me. I’ve been a fan ever since. Their sound is so big with only 3 musicians, and each one is a virtuoso. Amazing talent.
I played in a tribute band also and this closed the set. We did the first part of Hemispheres which ended on a big E chord, which we sustained and then did the atmospheric intro to xanadu. It was the most fun I’ve ever had playing in a band.
I saw Rush 30 times, and when people asked why I was "going to see them again" my answer was often, "it's like going to see the symphony orchestra, or the ballet." Timeless classics performed impeccably.
Well said... Only made it to see them about 6-7 times last time it was the hollywood bowl for R30...truly magical. It still fucking kills me that my life was a fucking mess when R40 rolled around and I missed it .
Unfortunately, only twice for me. Roll The Bones with a friend, and R40 in Seattle with my wife and kids. R40 was amazing. Originally had nose bleed seats, but ran into a woman from Ticketmaster in the consession line when my youngest (he was about 9) wanted a snack. She thought I was a cool dad for bringing his 9 and 15 year old kids to the show. We started talking and she ended up giving us Row 17 Floor seats on Gedde's side. Blew my kids' minds since they had heard me play Rush all their lives. I still get emotional thinking about that concert.
This breakdown is just an absolute gift to life long rush fans. THANK YOU RB! Having the chance to hear a song I have loved for ~40 years through your genius ears is simply priceless.
Growing up in southern Ontario and being just the right age, Rush was everything to me and my friends. My first concert was Rush and Max Webster. Indelibly etched in my mind. Listening to this reminds me of why we loved this band. I go through nostalgic phases of listening when Rush is concerned. Bouncing from one album to another. Xanadu is one of many that re-remind me of just why I love this band so much. Thnx for featuring it. My head bobbing back and forth was in perfect time with you. Made me giggle. Thnx again.
Xanadu is the song that made me a Rush fan. I could not comprehend how just 3 musicians could make such a huge sound! 27 Rush concerts spanning 13 tours under my belt and they NEVER disappointed!
@@thepatriotsrock2 "Did" what? Triumph never had the sound like Rush or the talent OR the record sales. Triumph was a good band, not in the same category as Rush.
I watched again because the first time was so much fun. He's loves this song as much as I do. And what a fun time the 2nd view was too. :) Nothing wrong with spending some time listening to a favorite and enjoying it with someone else. :)
Love the faces... And that he starts to make a point, but is so excited about it that he forgets to... And shouts THIS!! while pointing randomly... I get the sense that he loves it as much as I do!
Xanadu & La Villa Strangiato my top 2 favorites. I've seen RUSH at least 2 dozen times since the release of Moving Pictures. I've taken so many friends and family to experience the awe of what 3 people can do on stage, but most proud to bring my daughter to experience it on the R40 Farewell Tour and that she got to see the Greatest Drummer on the planet. Best Rock trio ever!! RIP Professor your music will live on forever
I was lucky to see them twice. The first time wasn't like any concert I'd ever been to, I was 15 and it forever changed the way I listened to and appreciate music. I was witnessing something special, it was almost a spiritual experience. I'll never forget it.
xanadu is a symphonic masterpiece played by three unassuming 25 years old rock players unnoticed by the music industry who insisted on showing the world that music could be done with integrity
It showed that 3 gifted atheists could exhibit the dis-integrity of most theists. But still, as much as I admire them, John 3 has more integrity by revealing the non-integrity of atheism. So they are caught in a double-bind.
@@PeacePromissor-kv1ei You completely lost me. I'm not familiar with all their albums, but even if I was, I donno if I'd get it. I'm sure it's too complex to explain here tho. So I'm not asking you to. Cheers! ✌🏼
As a life-long Rush fan, I LOVE seeing Rick geek out about Rush and apply his world famous (dare I say it?) analytical ear to them! I have to echo another comment, though, and say that Red Barchetta is one of the greatest Rush songs, and it has such an unusual structure. I'd love to see a "What Makes This Song Great" video on it.
Rick at perhaps the most contemplative I’ve ever seen him … before and during his discussion of his favourite Rush song (which came as a shock to me). And spending a half hour on it. For such an experienced musician and one who breaks down songs and teaches in this space better than almost anyone, that says a lot about this great Canadian band.
The end of an era. With Neil gone, we will never hear this again. We lost the most professional, talented, inventive group in the history of rock. Enjoy their work. Nobody can replace them.
Great post and I agree. I grew up with this band and I miss the anticipation of a new album and the tour that came with it. There was nothing like it. I’ll never forget getting Roll the Bones and Counterparts a month before they came out. I knew someone that worked at a WEA plant near me and he smuggled them out for me. The best is I still went out and bought the albums when they came out because you felt like you had to support them. That’s what that band created for a lot of people, loyalty to them. When Neil passed, I cried off and on for a week afterward. That’s never happened to me ever for someone that wasn’t a friend or a family member. It felt like a part of my life was gone and it was.
I watch “Time Stands Still” every week, including lots of their other video’s. My stomach aches, when the reality of reminded Neil is dead, one of a kind genius on drums, not to mention Lyricist 👍🏻
@@greengrass1072 Wow bro… your comment was awesome. I’ve been a fan since 1983 when I was 12 years old. When you bought the album when you didn’t have to says volumes about Rush fans and I always felt the same way about supporting them. I don’t know any other fan base with that kind of mentality. It’s giving back because you know they’re giving you their absolute best. That’s the feeling you had leaving a Rush show. They played every show like it was their last and gave you every penny’s worth. When I was in high school if I met someone that didn’t like Rush I tolerated it but if they started making fun or bad mouthing them in anyway I couldn’t be friends with that person lol. I took it very personal. That’s the weird indescribable connection Rush has with their fans that no other band has. If I met someone that loved Rush we were instant friends. I don’t understand why that is. Do you have any thoughts on that?
Couldn't agree more. I find myself playing songs multiple times because there's so much going on, and it's only three guys. They were unbelievable. I'm forever grateful I got to see them live, even if it was only once. I was born in the mid-80s, so I was kind of late to the party. I saw them on the Time Machine tour in Detroit. They played Moving Pictures in its entirety. A high moment in my life, for sure.
At least we have an enormous collection to listen to. I find new stuff I like when I go back and listen to the 80's albums I wasn't a huge fan of when they came out.
I love when Rick points out some thing that I never noticed before even after listening to this song 10,000 times over the course of the years! This was a great video
I was in the navy in the 80s and visiting my mate in Birmingham. We were into bikes and I had a Honda CB900 with a Harris 4 into 1 pipe on it. It was a street fighter before the term was invented. My mate played me moving pictures and then we went for a blast on our bikes. That blast has never ended and Rush have been with me every step of the way. I was 18 then and am 60 (where did that go) now and still get goose bumps when I listen to Rush. For me my fav is "The Camera Eye"
The segue on Exit Stage Left from Trees to Xanadu is magical. By the time it was released all of the tunes had been seasoned by a couple of years of touring. So, those complex arrangements just sounded a lot more natural to me than on the studio versions. The ambition to conceive and lay down those pieces and then the chops and technology to play them live. I'm literally as blown away today as the first time I heard them. Another great vid!
I love that long synth musical piece by Geddy between The Trees and Xanadu. The live version of Xanadu is on another level compared to the studio version. The video here on YT is excellent!
Xanadu is indeed a great song, and I agree it's a strong contender for being their best song, and I too love the Exit Stage Left version - but - Exit Stage Left wasn't exactly a live album. They spent a lot of time in the studio enhancing it; not just production engineering magic and edits but laying down tracks.
Alex Lifeson is one of the greatest guitar players ever. He was the complete package. A great song writer, soloist, rhythm player, and most important he played for the song not for himself.
"he played for the song".....only thing I'd adj.... change " he" to "they" .. It's fairly rare and kind of crazy how these guys could all fucking DESTROY on their instruments and they often did regularly through most of their songs,... But they NEVER outshined the song OR each other...... EVER.. One big reason why AL is continually under rated by most guitarists and fans of guitar playing ... BUT...The real 'players' and fans of rock and guitar who recognize greatness beyond the top 5-7 guys everyone can name... ....KNOW Lifeson is and will always be one of the best.
@@RaptorV1USA You make such excellent points on Rush as a "group". Too often people idolize one player out of a group of players. Rush is and was the consummate team of players. Each of them virtuoso in their craft. I'm certain I'm like many of their fans cannot think of one without thinking of all three.
As a budding guitar player, I worked my face off to be able to play this track, a serious lesson in staying “in the song” without blowing everybody else off the stage. For my money, Rush remains the most talented trio ever, utilizing the technology available in a hybrid of rock, jazz and classical themes. Hours and hours dedicated to learning what was really going on and doing my best to emulate what i heard. All of that work paid off when i was able to get very very close to the “Broon’s Bane/The Trees/Xanadu” trilogy from “exit stage left”. The things i gleaned from all that work still show up today, 40 years later. Rush remains my “go to” style of playing, even as i gig with many different genres. Thank you so much for this breakdown! I still love the joy that Rush produces in me and so many others ☮️❤️🎶
Agreed!! ....along with Jacob’s Ladder, The Camera Eye, Xanadu, & Working Man rounding out my Top 5. Really admire & believe the “Witch Hunt” sub-cult Rush fan a special breed!
It’s an absolute pleasure to watch Rick break this song down with that inimitable, almost childlike joy. Nobody else could do this music such justice. Rush is the Mount Everest of rock quality, easily one of the top five best groups in rock history. Xanadu is still a magical, perfect song, one that should be studied by anyone considering music as a craft. Rick - thank you so much for this episode!!!
That's why i love this guy so much.. He has a way of putting me right there with him in his excitement of what he is listening to. ANd takes me back in time to when i was young and so excited about new music. I just love Rick. Like you said, no one else could give the music the justice it deserves like Rick. Thank you Rick. You ROCK brother.
NEVER GETS old. A true masterpiece of Rush, and Classic Progressive Rock. Bravo on Rick calling this one. There is not too many great 3 piece out there like Rush. Killer performance.
Geddy's live variations during Xanadu theme are among my all time favorites. He played them every time I heard it live. ...even at R40 (I was at Irvine Meadows, CA).
YES, XANADU. I've been waiting for so long for someone to agree with me on that 😂 this is the best Rush's song ever. I love every single second of that record and I couldn't imagine my life without knowing it. it's pure poetry and as I said, I'm glad someone's acknowledged it as well ♥️
Definitely. It's their opus. I strongly prefer their performance if it on Exit.. Stage Left. But it was interesting hearing that their 2nd studio take was "the one." Of course, it was. Cuz they're awesome musicians.
Not a day goes by where at some point I listen to Rush. Tough to discern which is better Farewell to Kings, 2112, or Hemispheres. The Music is so sophisticated, that each Time I listen to it, I find something new.
@@patronus1776 Watching Alex Lifeson doing some of the fastest double-neck changes and switch throwing ever when going from the light twelve-string parts to the heavier six-string bits on the Exit... Stage Left video is so freaking awesome! While he's moving his left-hand onto the other neck his right hand is hitting the neck and pickup switches like a Jedi!
Me too dude. Watching Rick made me feel like a kid again. My first Rush song was 1980 flying to London. I was 15. Temples of Syrinx. Mind instantly BLOWN. Rush has been my band ever since. I’m 57 now.
14 the summer of 78. Heard Rush and this song for the first time in the bottom of a magical canyon on an indian reservation near the Grand Canyon. Some super Rush heads from Phoenix camping next to me and my scout troop with a casette player. About 2pm, they asked if i wanted a bong hit. I was like what's that? I agreed and the next question was do you like Rush? I didnt know them at the time..they played Xanadu for me. Things kinda changed for me after that.
@@superduper6532 Rush is the gift that keeps on giving. I turned my younger brother onto them and he and I were lucky enough to have seen them together the last three tours before Neil passed. And last month my brother just got the Sterns Rush LE Pinball machine. The BASTARD!!!🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🤣
Broon’s Bane/The Trees into Xanadu on Exit Stage Left was like a religious experience to me as a teenager. Pure brilliant creation straight from the source.
Xanadu is a great selection for 'best' song. Rush does a wonderful job of setting the stage and creating the vibe. Rush is one band that truly uses the drums and percussion as melody. Great musicians.
Neil's control of his volume and knowing where to gradually come in harder to increase it never fails to blow my mind. He had the technical prowess, but what REALLY set him apart was his trailblazing sense of composition. The construction of his parts is something that clearly took a fresh and original but still classically clever mind. Most of the great drummers today are only as great as they are because of him and his contributions to the craft. I can't imagine how long it will be before a mind like that comes along again. Great breakdown.
I’m not a musician but can truly appreciate the technical masterpiece that Xanadu, along with several other Rush tracks is. I just know when I listen to it, it’s transcendent.
"No room for error". Yup. Even Geddy pulling double & triple duty: bass, bass pedals, keys ....& effects pedals...... And Neil making MUSIC with his drums....
I think this is the issue with Alex missing out on plaudits....a super-bright light is missed in the light of a supernova! That band was a supernovae filled with three novas...one was bound to be missed in this world of self-publicity
I got goosebumps about 50 times watching this. This is the music that changed my life even though I didn’t hear it until about 1985 when I was 15 and had just got my first guitar.
A Farewell To Kings is one of my all time favourite albums. Great choice in tracks but I love Closer To The Heart just as much, in fact let's be honest with you I love the whole album. I've been a fan since I was 14 and I'm now 62, I guess once a Rush fan ALWAYS a Rush fan. Keep up the great work \m/.
When ancient civilizations look back and find this music and listen to how technical..melodic and perfectly timed each piece is..they'll be like.."NO way this is THREE people making all this sound"! Yea...they were..and still are..THE greatest rock trio of all time! Mozart in OUR day ladies and gentlemen!
My aunt lent me a copy of A Farewell to Kings 40 years ago after my parents bought me my first hifi system. I listened to the title track and when the intro ended and the wall of noise hit me, I was hooked. I love all kinds of music but Rush is the band I always come back to.
This video sums up all the reasons we love Rick. His genuine, unadulterated enthusiasm puts a smile on your face. Especially when he's Air Drumming. Plus, his appreciation, knowledge and incredible perspective on music makes this channel so enjoyable. Every school should have a music teacher like him.
Seriously underrated. Nobody denies Neil is one of the greatest rock drummers of all time - he generally comes up in the top 3 of any list that's worth anything - and that Geddy is *the* boss bassist, but Alex Lifeson gets ignored because he doesn't have the big personality of so many lead guitarists. He does what's needed for the songs. If it needs a Gilmour-esque melodic solo, that's what he does. If it needs shredding, he shreds. The band balanced beautifully, and it was due in no small part to Lifeson's technical excellence and musicianship.
I can't understand exactly how this term "underrated" is tossed about. It doesn't seem to have any connection to a musician's actual rating, in terms of accolades and rewards. Maybe the "underrated" epithet actually points to the author's opinion of him or herself as more sophisticated than anyone else.
Love how you have the ability to make me appreciate music that I already loved. I'm not a musician but the information you expound highlights things I enjoyed but perhaps never understood why, and that just makes my enjoyment that much more meaningful. Thank you.
I'm a massive RUSH fan and have listened to Xanadu numerous times over the years, but Rick, you gave me an insight to the song I never had before. Thank you!
So I have listened to Rush since 79. Seen them 5 times live. Had this album on vinyl, tape, cd and digital. And I STILL get goosebumps every time i hear it. Every time!
I first saw Rush play at a high school around 1973 or 74 in St Catharines, Ontario. The last time was at Molson Canadian Rocks for Toronto in 2003 (best concert I ever saw).
Farewell To Kings is my all time favourite. Xanadu is a masterwork. I feel blessed living in Toronto back in the day and watching Rush. Back then we were blown away. We thought nobody will get this outside of Canada.... hahaha....right,😂
I saw them in Toronto in 1985 at the Power Windows era. I saw them in a bunch of cities in the Northeast USA as well , Honestly I don’t think they gave a better show in Canada, their so great on tour that every time they play no matter what location they give a peak performance.
I’ve been listening to this band for 45 years. This video has made me appreciate little things throughout the song that I hadn’t noticed or at least hadn’t thought about - so thank you Sir!!
You are such a true fan, and for so many years. So many of your fans are as well. You just have to interview Geddy and Alex. Please make it happen. Mike, from “across the lake” in Ontario.
I echo that plea from across the "pond" in Exeter, UK. Get 'em on the channel Rick. They have always seemed to be such obliging gents that I sense that before long, you will.
I grew up in Ogdensburg NY by the border, 60 miles from Ottawa. Spent many days in Canada attending many concerts back in the 70s and 80s. We loved Rush and thought they were one of the best bands ever. They had a huge following in northern New York as did several other Canadian bands like April Wine, BTO, Guess Who, Gordon Lightfoot and many others. But Rush was always amazing.
i am from north ont. and would agree and focus on April Wine. they played a million concerts. had a good arena sound back in the 70's. 3 guitars.. and there drummer was animal
Its so good to hear a guy my age who grew up with the same music and still like myself still gets excited like we were back in jr high school again….. The magic of music is the keeper our soul for many of us and it’s one thing that we can always count on and will never disappoint….
Rick, you helped me appreciate a song I’ve loved for decades even more. Your insights into things like Geddy’s escalating vocals just take this song to the next level for me. Only by Rush. Only appreciated by Rick Beato. Fantastic!
Natural Science is my favorite Rush song, because of the sheer excitement, total originality, the imaginative and expansive lyrics and the amazing musicianship. Seeing it performed live has been one of life's great pleasures.
Natural Science is fucking unreal. Everything about it screams Rush. May be my alltime favorite as well. Though Hemesphers the song might be right with it.
Xanadu is still one of the most incredible songs Rush created. It’s amazing!!! Once again, you have hit one of the best rock performances ❤️ The lyrics are also incredible! Neil at the top of his game (RIP 😔)
I just cant seem to make it through a Rush song without crying: them being the sound track of my life, Neil's passing/the bands dissolution and seeing them play this song live from the 3rd row on the R40 is all too much to make it though this video without shedding tears. I do feel fortunate that we have the Rush community and to know that what is clearly evident in Rick's reaction and all of your heartfelt comments, I am not alone in my admiration.
I only had heard "Tom Sawyer" before hearing this for the first time. As it rolled on, I was gobsmacked totally by its' magnificence. I listened over and over and over, totally in awe of what was coming to my ears.
@@bassfan41 Agreed. The way he sings the lines : "The buildings are lost in their limitless rise, My feet catch the pulse and the purposeful stride... I feel a sense of possibilities, I feel the wrench of hard realities." Gives me shivers to this day!! 🔥
I love Necromancer more than Xanadu, BUT Necromancer suffers a bit from being splot into three parts that while great don't have the same coherence Xanadu does as a whole song @@johnmaldonado3909
I have not watched this video yet, but seeing your comment, just let me guess: he was talking about the Badd11 (008997) chord in Rush's "Xanadu" and John Denver's "The Eagle and the Hawk"
Eagle and the Hawk - John Denver's greatest too, IMO. Beato muses w/ the idea of doing a vid on that song - definitely should use one of the solo JD vids for his example - under rated guitarist just like Lifeson!
I can hardly believe it's nearing 50 years that I've been a Rush fan; in some ways it seems like yesterday. Personally I loath the thought of trying to choose a favorite, especially when so many of their compositions elicit such strong emotions. I also find it truly amazing that three brilliant, virtuosic musicians were able to maintain a personal and professional relationship that lasted roughly 46 years. RIP Neil.
I’m 59 and I still remember many of their lyrics! It’s truly amazing how only 3 men created such a complex and full sound...as if they were a much larger band...and their live shows were impeccable too. ❤ It was lovely to watch you analyzing and vibing to this song !! Great video, thank you. 😊❤
In Junior High English, we were reading the Coleridge poem when this came out. My teacher let me bring the record in and play it for the class. Imagine the horror of the long instrumental beginning for both the teacher and most in the class. But she caught on as it built, and by the time the lyrics arrived, she was ecstatic. It was a signpost of my early life. The teacher felt, appropriately, that she was reaching us. Or at least reaching me.
A Farewell To Kings was released right after the start of my 11th grade high school year. Being a budding Rush fan, I bought it the day it showed up in the stores. I played the sh!t out of that vinyl record for years, and with every listen grew to love it more. There is no way to describe the impact and influence on me as a musician and as a human being. The title track is a lesson and a foundation for a righteous society, and a condemnation of the usual human folly. It is relevant now, 45 years after it's creation, and will be relevant for thousands of years. LONG LIVE RUSH!!!
Oh yeah I was a freshman in high school but I remember skipping class to buy the 8 track tape. I've owned all the possible ways to own it. Vinyl, cd, cassette 8 track lol DVD
I grew up poor in Philadelphia, and I had one of those ubiquitous brown clocks where the numbered plates would flip, so I listened to the radio. I heard Tom Sawyer here and there but I was still unaware of ‘Rush’ proper. By around 1983 I finally had a stereo walkman radio and one day I heard Red Barchetta while lying in my bed - holy moly it put the hook in me & I was off like a rocket to the mall. I bought Fly By Night, but that wasn’t it. The following allowance I bought Moving Pictures, then as I went through High school I bought more Rush records, including of course A Farewell to Kings. Hearing Xanadu felt like hearing Red Barchetta the first time. Everything Rush did had a profound magic to it that opened me up to life through their sound. Of all of the life experiences that shape who I am as a person, Rush is by far the strongest and best influence on me. That looping guitar riff during Xanadu’s intro - I don’t even have words to describe what it does to my soul. I’m fortunate to have grown up with Rush, to have seen them live twice, and to have their music forever in me.
@@Bikewithlove I had that same radio!!! Grew up in San Diego...Surf/skate/Mx/Bmx/Sex/Drugs and every RUSH album and at least 4 live concerts...My best friend,after years of Megadeath, Metallica,Sabbath,Maiden etc. just recently started exploring RUSH with his guitar...Life is good with RUSH
Now that I'm done bawling like a baby.... I discovered RUSH shortly after my mom brought me and my sister up as very young kids from Jamaica to live in Canada. Could not believe my ears! Been hooked ever since!!! Think it was the year they released their debut album. I consider it a total honor live in the exact neighborhood that Geddy and Alex cut their teeth. I point out places to my twins as we walk/drive around the blocks here. So very sad to lose Neil! It's quite evident that Geddy cannot hit those notes anymore (and hasn't been able to for a while now). It's not surprising because what he did on vocals is just not human. HOW DID HE SING SOOOOOOOOO HIGH AND WONDERFUL WHILE PLAYING ALL THOSE PARTS??!?!?! I really wish they'd hire the best Geddy voice clone, and hit the road (they'll need a drummer too now). They'd be a 4 piece, but Alex and Geddy can do the music and let the clone sing, sparing Geddy's voice box. They are probably tired of touring after all of those years, so may be they could just do a few shows each year across Canada. We'd LOVE to see them still! I'm dying for the day that I run into them here in the city. Every time I see a vid of either of them they are some place really close to me. LOL
Let’s not forget that these guys (aliens probably) were 24 years old when they wrote and recorded this. 🤦🏻♂️ Rick, thank you for once again sharing your love for music and those that make it.
Well I'm from the United States so of course they are aliens. At least from my perspective. Unless, of course, I see them in Canada in which case I am then the alien and they are native. They are not, however, space aliens. Toronto is not outer space.
I would agree with you that rush is ancient aliens even though that whole theory is complete bullcrap. However, this is far from rush's greatest. Sing a melody from this song. you can't? okay then.
So I’m 22, and my dad is the one that introduced me to rush probably around when I was 10. I had just started playing the drums and was absolutely blown away by their precision timing, random off beat things that I couldn’t even describe and still have a hard time describing that Neil would do. I always loved them. It’s so cool hearing people talk about rush and their experience with them back when rush was first taking the music world by storm. At least the music world of actual musicians. The people that can understand how absolutely insane they are. I find it endearing we’re all kinda geeky in our own ways especially when it comes to music. Anyway, not even sure what I’m commenting at this point, but thought I would just say great video. Super cool too see deep analysis of all of their intricacies that have captivated listeners for decades. Wish I could have saw them live.
This was the first song I learned to play on guitar in the 80's. I grew up thinking this was how everyone played and when I tried to form my own bands later, I knew no one played like this. Drummers and bassists didn't like me because I would tell them to play more - like Rush. An amazing version of this song is from Exit Stage Left. Xanadu is a 20 min trifecta starting with Broon's Bane (a classical guitar composition vs. typical rock concert guitar solo), The Tree's, and then culminating with Xanadu. They were true master musicians at that point and there's a concert of the same tour where you can watch them play those songs. And none of this even dives into the depth of Neil's story telling and lyrical prose. Every album of theirs through Signals was a masterpiece to me - I was lucky to grow up with that kind of music.
Exit Stage Left was the very first album I bought when I was 11 years old. I was so naive at that time that I literally thought the woman on the cover that is holding the curtain was actually the singer. I bought it because the only song I knew from Rush, at that time, was Tom Sawyer from hearing it on Rock 103 in Memphis, TN. I had no idea even who was in the band, and if you look on the inside of the album, The picture of Geddy Lee is this shot of his sillhouette with his shoulder length hair and thin framed body with a spotlight behind his head. So at that age, it was plausible to me that it was the same girl on the cover, but with a bass guitar strapped on "her" shoulder. lol And he did certainly have a high voice. But the rest of that album opened not just a new world, but an entire new Universe of possibilities! And that YYZ drum solo, I was rendered absolutely speechless and dumbfounded. I had never heard anything like that anywhere.Everything on it just blew me away because all I ever heard in those days was normal industry rock like Foreigner or Styx with Mr Roboto or Bad Company or Journey or Billy Squire or Kasey Kasem's Top 40 on the radio. In my small 11 year old world, I thought THAT was what rock n roll was. Boy , did my mind open up like an acid trip...without the acid of course. It changed my life forever.
Right? For a short period I was in a band with all Rush-heads. We played a lot of covers from all sorts of bands and that Rush influence elevated it all.
I was just commenting on how I love the live version better on Exit Stage Left. My favorite part of the album is listening to the 3 songs Broons Bane, Trees and Xanadu. Also, Jacobs Ladder is killer. When I pick up my guitar I don’t usually put it down without playing those songs.
This song was the first time listening to Rush sent chills down my spine....It was wonderful! I had goose bumps all over. It was so haunting and amazing. I think I must have played it over 50 times that day. Definitely one of my fav's from them. Great choice!!!👍👍
I love how much you love this. That’s guys were perfectly in sync and made for each other. Geddy’s story about auditioning Neil and how excited he was prove that he knew right away. Alex thought his hair wasn’t long enough LOL
I had this cassette tape listening in my '76 Mercury Capri with Alpine head unit and Pioneer TS-6907's in the rear deck..... There were times when I would just sit in my car listening to these songs (because my car stereo sounded better than the one in my room.) You guys know... 🤘
Man there were nights me and my friends would buy beer and weed and sit in the car and listen for hours ....parked at some beach or even someone's house ! Nothing beat a good car party.
After 41 years of listening to Rush, there are still so many of their songs that give me the chills every time I hear them. Xanadu is one of those songs. There will never be another band like Rush.
Witch Hunt is my personal fave...great fusion of music and lyrics...
Yup, I bought A Farewell To Kings on iTunes just so I could have it on bluetooth for my car. I played it five days ago and was screaming out the lyrics in falsetto of course and even doing that I couldn't hit some of the notes Geddy was singing! Such a great album and such a great song.
Same here. I even got shivers listening to this breakdown! 😁
So well said on how so many of us feel about Rush. We were lucky to have them in our lifetime.
Geddy sure captures the mystery of Xanadu when he finally starts singing.
At 59 years of age - I am still moved emotionally, physically and mentally by their music. As a young 13 year old drummer - I had practiced along to the artist/drummers of the 70's. But it wasn't until I heard Rush, more specifically Neil Peart, when the light came on - suddenly pulling me towards a style I wanted to emulate. I cannot count the hours I've spent over the past 45+ years trying to nail down his drum parts. Thank you for spending time on this episode showcasing Rush. We all miss the band. We all miss you Neil. Thank you for what you gave us during all of your years.
I'm 56 now... I get it. You can't duplicate it. Just be inspired by them. Listen to what they wrote and are writing and lay it down. Smart and with perspective.
I could have wrote that comment myself. Word for word it is exactly how I feel. Right down to the ages. I still get so choked up sometimes listening to Neil. What a great soul!
This Isnt Rush?
Likewise. Also 56 at the moment. I can’t reproduce Neil’s parts verbatim, but I do the best I can (see what I did there?) and play them as accurately as I can (and as I hear them, which occasionally gets revised when I listen more closely or see a transcription). It’s a mountain I will never summit, but I’m enjoying the journey.
“From first to last
The peak is never passed
Something always fires the light
That gets in your eyes
One moment’s high
And glory rolls on by
Like a streak of lightening
That flashes and fades
In the summer sky”
I won’t even approach that peak, particularly when it comes to the creativity that first imagined those parts and lyrics, but I enjoy the journey of following one of the true greats. He may have faded from this realm, but the brilliance he shone lingers on through his recordings, his lyrics, and his other writings.
Thank you Neil, and Alex, and Geddy, for writing that soundtrack for me - and for setting such a shining example of what integrity looks like.
I'm exactly like you Mark same age and everything , what you said I couldn't of said it better myself... seen them 9 times and Neil was god
I swear Rush saved my life.
Troubled teen with no Dad.
My oldest Brothers were my best friends.
They both went into the army and I was left with my Mom and her abusive boyfriend.
Rush helped me escape reality and I
Spent so many hours immersed in Everything Rush in the 80’s.
Still…looking back to those days I would go back in a heartbeat and do it all over again just to relive the mind blowing alternate universe that Rush took me to every time I put on the headphones.
Great comment.
Amen to that
Peace Brother
Proud of your honesty and open-ness, you were able to get to a good place by getting through a bad place and glad that RUSH was there to help like the friend it truly is. . .
Were You a Musician?
Ahhhh. The epic Xanadu. Its where my RUSH journey began. My older brother made me listen to Xanadu, in the dark as a nine year old. I was part enthralled and scared. The song continues to blow my mind to this day as a 50 year old. The song means the world to me. Long live RUSH. Love your channel sir. Keep fighting the good fight.
Great choice, Xanadu hit hard
Well said. 🍻☮️
Oh my god, my older brother made me listen to Xanadu in the dark too!! My introduction to Rush when l was 13. Wild that we have the same story ❤
@@gailtrenholm837 That is too cool!
This! The first time I heard the song was when I put the record on to listen to at bedtime. My big brother was ugh back then. I did it to myself not knowing what I was doing. I have a list of songs like that, heheh.
Rush may not be your favorite band, but they are probably your favorite band's favorite band.
I've heard that same sentiment about King's X
True.
Yes, also Zappa
Steely Dan as well lol
Woah. Deep. :)
Neil Peart heard the world in a different way than the rest of us and knew exactly how a song should hit the brain. He was a musical genius.
And NO QUESTION that Alex is the most underrated guitarist. Masterful.
They wrote well. Taking the words and created magic. Neal wrote. They created together. The amazing thing is that people actually smarter than what they are believe. We think like this everyday. We have thoughts and opinions. We fantasize and dream. We watch and learn. I think we would be better people if we just listened.
Don't forget, it would not be great without the lyrics Neil wrote. Without Neil, Rush would never be greater than say Triumph.
@@lancejohnson8522 Yes and no. Neil wrote the lyrics. Geddy and Alex would come up with the music and then once they worked out the music Neil would start working out the drumming. This is according to what the band has said.
So musically they all were part, but most the sound of the song is coming from Geddy and Alex.
@MeWriter2112
Your comment* redefines “spot - on perfect!” I’m very sorry the same* is SO “under liked.”
So many Great ones, I’m just sad I didn’t get to see them live
1978 Hemispheres Tour for me. I was a junior in high school. Should have gone to more. Listening to them since 1976. They never get old.
Same here, I told myself I would eventually see them live 12 years back when I first started university and never did, I just always assumed theyd tour forever so id catch them eventually. Never thought that anything would happen to Neil. Definitely a huge regret of mine.
I had a few chances to see them back in the 80's and 90's, but I couldn't be arsed. You think that they are going to be around forever and then they are gone. BTW l, love your channel Jamel.
Test for Echo, 1996. Played all of 2112. I've seen enough of your channel, Jamal, to know that you do have a sense of what you missed (I mean, how many Rush posters do you have in the background?), and yeah, it was fucking great.
Same here Jamal; They never came down here to Australia - and so many of us never had the cash to fly across the world and see them. BTW, love your channel brother.
I first heard Rush in High School in 76. The album was 2112. It was the most amazing music I'd ever heard. Then, in October of 77 they came to play a concert in Beaumont with Max Webster as the opener. It was my 3rd ever rock show. It was their 'Farewell to Kings' tour. To my joy, they played the 1st side of 2112, as well as a lot of the new album, to include Xanadu, and songs from their earlier 3 albums. Amazing, awesome show. I would only realize how great they were then, many years and many shows from many bands later. I saw them a total of only 6 times through the years, but they are still one of the top bands ever. Their musicianship outdoes just about any band out there, even now. Sadly they retired after the death of Neil, and rightly so. There is always a place in my head for Rush.
An interview with Alex and Geddy would be amazing! I believe Geddy is working on a memoir right now, and Alex has his new Envy Of None band. So they will both have new projects to promote.
I absolutely agree! 👍
What project is Geddy doing now?
@@kennyplay5982 an autobiography/memoir
@@conanbarbarion1631 More superior? So they're both superior, but right-handed players are more so? Who are they both superior to? People with no hands? The fuck are you even saying?
Thisss. They also just did all the recordings for Rush pinball and the new YYZ video, so I’m sure they would find the time
I’d LOVE a full length interview sit down with Alex and Geddy. And Rick, bring your guitar and jam a little! It’d be a dream for you and we’d joy in seeing it!
YES!
I was thinking the same about 30 seconds into this.
👍🏻🥂
I feel fortunate that Neil left some record of his thoughts on music in the form of instructional materials, and his thoughts on things other than drumming were just as fascinating. Would be nice if all three guys could be here to talk about the music, especially since I wish there had been a lot more of that around.
I'd contribute $ for that to happen.
The thing about Rush is, whether you were a guitarist, a bassist or a drummer, they appealed to your senses. Truly a musicians band.
I mean, true, but I play trumpet and piano and they also appeal to my senses
I don't play anything other than vocal chords and they appeal to my senses.
I guess I should have said, no matter what you play or even if a vocalist, Rush appealed to you. 😊
The thoughtful lyrics also played their part. Truly a complete package.
I Remember as a young drummer, hearing this song, thinking this is the most amazing song I have heard..
Rush fan for 46 years and this was so cool to watch you break it down and be as excited as I am about the band. Thank you Rick for all you do in the music community!
As a musician I can never believe the talent of these guys! They are in a league of there own!!!
their*
Your knowledge of music is very limited then. Not even the most talented of rock trios, let alone jazz, jazz fusion, or top classical ensembles...
@@robertglisson6319 They are not?
@@robertglisson6319 Who would you place at their level? Just curious.
Dire Straits i would put above rush... i mean this is ALL personal tastes... One mans music is another mans noise...
Being a teenager in my bedroom looking at Tolkien illustrations, drawing Dungeons & Dragons maps and listening to Rush. Those were the happiest times.
Same. All 3
Lucky those who were teens in the 70s and 80s
You forgot feling misunderstood by your peers because you were so much smarter thatn them, otherewise that is exactly my teenage years.
Same here but I was drawing Tolkien images. I remember it well. Those were great times.
Wooooo !!!
The most amazing bit, is that it was written to play live, with 12 & 6 string double neck, a 6 string guitar & 4 string bass double neck, keyboards, bass peddles and drums, by only 3 musicians. And Geddy still had some spare time for vocals 😂
Believe it or not, Geddy’s double neck Rickenbacker was a 4 string bass and 12 string guitar, at least originally. The live version of the Xanadu video from the Exit Stage Left tour (probably the most viewed live version), Geddy was using the 4/12 Rick. Many years later, Geddy replaced that Rick with a 4/6 version, but for most years it was the 4/12 string. Geddy played rhythm during the solo and for the outro.
Geddy actually plays the melody on guitar during the outro, along with Neil matching him note for note on the glockenspiel, all while Alex just arpeggiates a single cord. It is a masterclass ending that only a group like Rush would orchestrate. That is why they have been called the world’s smallest orchestra. I don’t know of any other three piece band that literally orchestrated layers the way Rush did?
Typically, in most three or four piece rock bands, the bass pretty much played the same key the melody of the guitar is playing, but Geddy would try to find harmonies to what Alex was playing, adding texture and a much fuller sound as opposed to when the two instruments are only playing different octaves of the same thing.
The one takeaway everyone says after hearing Rush, even members of other famous bands, is “how can three guys make so much sound?”. I think that the orchestration of layers is a big part of that, and the fact that Geddy and Neil filled gaps like no other rhythm section. In fact, those two alone made enough sound to be considered a band, the meat and potatoes of the sound, so Alex just became the gravy… and what a tasty gravy he made.
Many people don't know he did the band's taxes in the down time time when he wasn't doing vocals, bass, 6-string rhythm, pedals, and synth through this performance.
😂
It was also recorded live, in one take.
@@johnbaker6847 Yes, and he also volunteered at H&R Block during tax season, helping underprivileged senior citizens do their taxes. Very impressive!
The vocals on that last "Oh is it paradise?" just give you goosebumps like...how?
I saw Rush live on the “Presto” tour. When they played “Xanadu” Geddy was playing bass with his left hand, keyboard with his right hand, Taurus pedals with his feet, and singing at the same time. Simply amazing!
He and Neil both had that ability to do four things simultaneously with their extremities. I think that is part of what bonded them.
That’s precisely what I found most amazing about the song when they recorded it LIVE for “Exit Stage Left,” particularly just before Geddy is about to start singing. So well layered it is almost ridiculous.
I saw them at Pine Knob for the Roll the Bones tour and couldn't believe there were only the 3 of them! I kept thinking there were dudes hiding in the back to accompany them live like so many groups do, but, NO! They just utilized every available limb like the comment above stated. Amazing!
I saw Rush just once (on the WORST NIGHT OF ALL),
at the Philadelphia Spectrum, September 25, 1980; John Bonham died hours before that concert.
It was bittersweet for Rush and we attendees, but Rush gave us a memory.
They played their as-yet-unreleased “Tom Sawyer” for us!
Philly bore witness first that “Tom Sawyer” would indeed affect the annals of RnR music.
I never got to see ‘Zeppelin live, and Rush kind of appreciated that, huh? 👍🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
And was thinking about baseball....all at the same time
Rick always makes you feel you are sharing your joy of music with an old friend, whether it’s an old favourite or something new to you you’ll learn something each time… Great job!
I always get chills with "Time Stand Still.".... but all their works have such a unique, one-of-a-kind sound... phenomenal!
Check out the United States Army Band version in memory and honor of Neil Peart. after his passing. I tear up every time I hear it. ….and I still miss Neil.
@@bakkusmgr Thank you... I certainly will! 😍
@@bakkusmgr Just listened... very moving...
The lyrics are fantastic
@@bakkusmgr GREAT comment. I watched that vid more than a few times.
Having seen them play Xanadu live at Maple Leaf Gardens on New Years Eve 1978 was an unbelievable thing to witness! The depth and complexity of their performance was mind-blowing for my 16-year-old self, especially as a fledgling bassist! Still just SO incredible to hear! Thank, Rick for featuring this!
Omg I was there too . I’m sure we high fived that night.
You have to get Alex and Geddy to sit down....thank you so much for doing this. My countrymen, never sold out, always played what they liked and are among the few true musical geniuses. Only got to see them twice live...both magical experiences 20 years apart. RIP Neil.
Great idea! Maybe Alex will bring some of his beer, and Geddy some of his wine!🍷🍺
3 of the greatest musicians, songwriters, lyricists and performers ever to play music. EVER. 👍🏻😎
P.S. Neil wasn’t a drummer. He was a master percussionist and one of the best lyricists ever.
Just curious, how many people out there have played air drums to Tom Sawyer?
@@Sherwoody LOL! ALL OF THEM! 🥁🥁🥁🥁😅
@@Sherwoody - Answer: ALL OF THEM! LoL :o)
Was just saying to a friend last night that you'll never see as many air drummers as when you go to a RUSH concert.
You go squirrel
@@MarkKramKarmVI
😂🤣😂🐿
What a joy seeing Rick smile, head-bang and groove to this epic composition! Xanadu really is one of Rush’s Crown Jewels - Strangiato is the other.
Natural Science is the other.
@@davidwoolbright3675 Hemispheres is the other.
I was hoping the selection was Strangiato
I love that you love Rush.
@fastguitar I grew up in Springfield, VA and lived by its second location in that town. In 1999 I worked at the parent location one in Rockville. Anyway, saw Rush in 1993 at Merriweather Post (near DC) and on its final tour at the NBA arena in Phoenix
The beginning with the drum rolls and the big crescendo is just magical.
What an absolute masterpiece this song is. How could this get old. Every time I listen to it, it must be played as loud as my ears can take. The 3 amigos of progressive rock. These guys make me proud to be Canadian.
The live version of Xanadu from their "Exit Stage Left" tour is magical. (And on utube.) Even outdoes the album cut IMO.
Yeah it does. A lot of songs on exit stage left sounded better than their studio versions imo. Red barchetta, Spirit of radio, Jacob's ladder, the trees, xanadu, and definitely a passage Bangkok..imo
@@blue23song31 Side 3 of Exit...Stage Left is the pinnacle for me. Broon's Bane, The Trees, Xanadu. Unreal. I can't listen to the studio version of Xanadu to this day because I love the live version so much.
Blessed to see Moving Pictures tour in Phoenix with Max Webster opening. Are you a Lost Horizon fan?
@@brentjones8099 I’m in total agreement with you. To this day I can listen to side 3 and not be able to wrap my head around the idea that it was just 3 guys doing that.
Live
I agree... for me, Rush going from Trees to Xanadu in my opinion, is tge GREATEST live piece of audio art in history...
Glad Rush is getting more recognition. More than just a “nerd” band, they’re incredible
The thing about people giving recognition to rush is this.... People who don't recognize rush as a top band in music history that changed the direction of music. Those people are just ignorant about music. But people who really know good quality music and music composition know that rush is one of the best in history!
For sure. The old “your favorite bands favorite band” comment comes to mind.
The non Rush music that has been made the last 30 years that would not exist without Rush is staggering.
what? thi is not Rush?
Never where nerdy just a WELL SPOKEN Band WHO SHOWS WHAT BADDDD ASSS GROUP THEY ARE ,SO TALENTED, SO GREAT AND TOGETHER ,,,,,FORGET IT......RUSH IS WOWWWWE
@@alsavantjes YES IT IS.....
I first heard Rush in 1985 when an army buddy played their music for me. I’ve been a fan ever since. Their sound is so big with only 3 musicians, and each one is a virtuoso. Amazing talent.
Having played in a Rush tribute band, Xanadu was our evening closer which was given a standing ovation every time! My favorite still. ❤️🥰🥰
I played in a tribute band also and this closed the set. We did the first part of Hemispheres which ended on a big E chord, which we sustained and then did the atmospheric intro to xanadu. It was the most fun I’ve ever had playing in a band.
I saw Rush 30 times, and when people asked why I was "going to see them again" my answer was often, "it's like going to see the symphony orchestra, or the ballet." Timeless classics performed impeccably.
I saw them twice. On the Snakes and Arrows tour and performing Moving Pictures in its entirety. The latter was one of best concerts I’ve ever been to
Seen em 17 times,wish I could see em more but ....
Except better!
Well said... Only made it to see them about 6-7 times last time it was the hollywood bowl for R30...truly magical.
It still fucking kills me that my life was a fucking mess when R40 rolled around and I missed it .
Unfortunately, only twice for me. Roll The Bones with a friend, and R40 in Seattle with my wife and kids. R40 was amazing. Originally had nose bleed seats, but ran into a woman from Ticketmaster in the consession line when my youngest (he was about 9) wanted a snack. She thought I was a cool dad for bringing his 9 and 15 year old kids to the show. We started talking and she ended up giving us Row 17 Floor seats on Gedde's side. Blew my kids' minds since they had heard me play Rush all their lives. I still get emotional thinking about that concert.
This breakdown is just an absolute gift to life long rush fans. THANK YOU RB! Having the chance to hear a song I have loved for ~40 years through your genius ears is simply priceless.
His analysis at 26:32 brings the subtlety alive
Growing up in southern Ontario and being just the right age, Rush was everything to me and my friends. My first concert was Rush and Max Webster. Indelibly etched in my mind. Listening to this reminds me of why we loved this band. I go through nostalgic phases of listening when Rush is concerned. Bouncing from one album to another. Xanadu is one of many that re-remind me of just why I love this band so much. Thnx for featuring it. My head bobbing back and forth was in perfect time with you. Made me giggle. Thnx again.
Rick, you do this every time. You bring me back to music I love, and you show new ways to listen to it, new ways to appreciate it.
Thank you.
Xanadu is the song that made me a Rush fan. I could not comprehend how just 3 musicians could make such a huge sound! 27 Rush concerts spanning 13 tours under my belt and they NEVER disappointed!
I know eh?! They sound like at least 5 guys. Same thing live. The best 3 peice band ever, by far!
Xanadu was the most musically complex song rush ever did and I have heard flawless live performances. They were the gods of rock.
Triumph did it with 3
@@thepatriotsrock2 "Did" what? Triumph never had the sound like Rush or the talent OR the record sales. Triumph was a good band, not in the same category as Rush.
@@thepatriotsrock2 not quite
This is exactly why I watch. He gets as excited as I do when telling people about Rush. There is a love there that would be impossible to hide.
He’s absolutely giddy like a schoolgirl here LOL
YES!
I watched again because the first time was so much fun. He's loves this song as much as I do. And what a fun time the 2nd view was too. :) Nothing wrong with spending some time listening to a favorite and enjoying it with someone else. :)
@@obiwanbenobi4943 agreed. Speaking of sharing something you love, I too love Linux.
Love the faces... And that he starts to make a point, but is so excited about it that he forgets to... And shouts THIS!! while pointing randomly... I get the sense that he loves it as much as I do!
I love how excited you are! I love how excited I am…still…every time I listen to them! Simply one of the greatest…
Xanadu & La Villa Strangiato my top 2 favorites. I've seen RUSH at least 2 dozen times since the release of Moving Pictures. I've taken so many friends and family to experience the awe of what 3 people can do on stage, but most proud to bring my daughter to experience it on the R40 Farewell Tour and that she got to see the Greatest Drummer on the planet. Best Rock trio ever!! RIP Professor your music will live on forever
Nailed it.. my favorites as well but they all are badass.
I was lucky to see them twice. The first time wasn't like any concert I'd ever been to, I was 15 and it forever changed the way I listened to and appreciate music. I was witnessing something special, it was almost a spiritual experience. I'll never forget it.
xanadu is a symphonic masterpiece played by three unassuming 25 years old rock players unnoticed by the music industry who insisted on showing the world that music could be done with integrity
Do one on Tom Sawyer that’s my favorite
I was so surprised when they decided to cover an Olivia Newton John song but it really worked.
@@Win7ermu7e 🤣🤣
It showed that 3 gifted atheists could exhibit the dis-integrity of most theists. But still, as much as I admire them, John 3 has more integrity by revealing the non-integrity of atheism. So they are caught in a double-bind.
@@PeacePromissor-kv1ei You completely lost me. I'm not familiar with all their albums, but even if I was, I donno if I'd get it. I'm sure it's too complex to explain here tho. So I'm not asking you to. Cheers! ✌🏼
As a life-long Rush fan, I LOVE seeing Rick geek out about Rush and apply his world famous (dare I say it?) analytical ear to them! I have to echo another comment, though, and say that Red Barchetta is one of the greatest Rush songs, and it has such an unusual structure. I'd love to see a "What Makes This Song Great" video on it.
I am ₩ -1119
Rick at perhaps the most contemplative I’ve ever seen him … before and during his discussion of his favourite Rush song (which came as a shock to me). And spending a half hour on it. For such an experienced musician and one who breaks down songs and teaches in this space better than almost anyone, that says a lot about this great Canadian band.
Honestly, I can see Geddy and Alex being interviewed by Rick. It's nothing short of amazing how humble those two men are.
oh my God this needs to happen
My thoughts exactly!
The question is, how many times will Alex make Rick laugh so hard he has to pause the interview.
I think having to open for "kiss" helped to keep them humble.
@@midwesternmonkey3702 I also seem to remember a story about some band from Boston that taught them how not to treat an opening act.
The end of an era. With Neil gone, we will never hear this again. We lost the most professional, talented, inventive group in the history of rock. Enjoy their work. Nobody can replace them.
Great post and I agree. I grew up with this band and I miss the anticipation of a new album and the tour that came with it. There was nothing like it. I’ll never forget getting Roll the Bones and Counterparts a month before they came out. I knew someone that worked at a WEA plant near me and he smuggled them out for me. The best is I still went out and bought the albums when they came out because you felt like you had to support them. That’s what that band created for a lot of people, loyalty to them. When Neil passed, I cried off and on for a week afterward. That’s never happened to me ever for someone that wasn’t a friend or a family member. It felt like a part of my life was gone and it was.
I watch “Time Stands Still” every week, including lots of their other video’s. My stomach aches, when the reality of reminded Neil is dead, one of a kind genius on drums, not to mention Lyricist 👍🏻
@@greengrass1072 Wow bro… your comment was awesome. I’ve been a fan since 1983 when I was 12 years old. When you bought the album when you didn’t have to says volumes about Rush fans and I always felt the same way about supporting them. I don’t know any other fan base with that kind of mentality. It’s giving back because you know they’re giving you their absolute best. That’s the feeling you had leaving a Rush show. They played every show like it was their last and gave you every penny’s worth. When I was in high school if I met someone that didn’t like Rush I tolerated it but if they started making fun or bad mouthing them in anyway I couldn’t be friends with that person lol. I took it very personal. That’s the weird indescribable connection Rush has with their fans that no other band has. If I met someone that loved Rush we were instant friends. I don’t understand why that is. Do you have any thoughts on that?
Couldn't agree more. I find myself playing songs multiple times because there's so much going on, and it's only three guys. They were unbelievable. I'm forever grateful I got to see them live, even if it was only once. I was born in the mid-80s, so I was kind of late to the party. I saw them on the Time Machine tour in Detroit. They played Moving Pictures in its entirety. A high moment in my life, for sure.
At least we have an enormous collection to listen to. I find new stuff I like when I go back and listen to the 80's albums I wasn't a huge fan of when they came out.
I love when Rick points out some thing that I never noticed before even after listening to this song 10,000 times over the course of the years! This was a great video
I was in the navy in the 80s and visiting my mate in Birmingham. We were into bikes and I had a Honda CB900 with a Harris 4 into 1 pipe on it. It was a street fighter before the term was invented. My mate played me moving pictures and then we went for a blast on our bikes.
That blast has never ended and Rush have been with me every step of the way. I was 18 then and am 60 (where did that go) now and still get goose bumps when I listen to Rush.
For me my fav is "The Camera Eye"
The segue on Exit Stage Left from Trees to Xanadu is magical. By the time it was released all of the tunes had been seasoned by a couple of years of touring. So, those complex arrangements just sounded a lot more natural to me than on the studio versions. The ambition to conceive and lay down those pieces and then the chops and technology to play them live. I'm literally as blown away today as the first time I heard them. Another great vid!
Don't forget Broon's Bane... into the trees..... into Xanadu
I love that long synth musical piece by Geddy between The Trees and Xanadu. The live version of Xanadu is on another level compared to the studio version. The video here on YT is excellent!
Xanadu is indeed a great song, and I agree it's a strong contender for being their best song, and I too love the Exit Stage Left version - but - Exit Stage Left wasn't exactly a live album. They spent a lot of time in the studio enhancing it; not just production engineering magic and edits but laying down tracks.
Truly a magical moment in rock history.
ABSOLUTELY... ESL version is even MORE majestic/ethereal!!
No coincidence he picked my favorite song as well!
🤘🤩🤘
Alex Lifeson is one of the greatest guitar players ever. He was the complete package. A great song writer, soloist, rhythm player, and most important he played for the song not for himself.
"he played for the song".....only thing I'd adj.... change " he" to "they" ..
It's fairly rare and kind of crazy how these guys could all fucking DESTROY on their instruments and they often did regularly through most of their songs,...
But they NEVER outshined the song OR each other...... EVER..
One big reason why AL is continually under rated by most guitarists and fans of guitar playing ...
BUT...The real 'players' and fans of rock and guitar who recognize greatness beyond the top 5-7 guys everyone can name...
....KNOW Lifeson is and will always be one of the best.
@@RaptorV1USA You make such excellent points on Rush as a "group". Too often people idolize one player out of a group of players. Rush is and was the consummate team of players. Each of them virtuoso in their craft. I'm certain I'm like many of their fans cannot think of one without thinking of all three.
If you are a fan of Alex, check out his guest appearance on "The Trailer Park Boys"
@@jimmiller3139 ,"Play I LIKE TO ROCK "!
"He's a drunk male prostitute "...
I heard that the way they wrote his solos is they would jam on a song at length and GL and NP would pick their favorite parts and piece them together.
As a budding guitar player, I worked my face off to be able to play this track, a serious lesson in staying “in the song” without blowing everybody else off the stage. For my money, Rush remains the most talented trio ever, utilizing the technology available in a hybrid of rock, jazz and classical themes. Hours and hours dedicated to learning what was really going on and doing my best to emulate what i heard. All of that work paid off when i was able to get very very close to the “Broon’s Bane/The Trees/Xanadu” trilogy from “exit stage left”. The things i gleaned from all that work still show up today, 40 years later. Rush remains my “go to” style of playing, even as i gig with many different genres. Thank you so much for this breakdown! I still love the joy that Rush produces in me and so many others ☮️❤️🎶
I loved watching your take on details in Xanadu! It's my all time favorite Rush sing, a true masterpiece ❤🎸🎸💯
My favorite Rush song is Witch Hunt. Very underrated, great playing and awesome lyrics, very atmospheric played live
"Bravado" is pretty amazing as well.. dang it's hard to hear a song from them that's not amazing..
Faces are twisted and grotesque.
Agreed!! ....along with Jacob’s Ladder, The Camera Eye, Xanadu, & Working Man rounding out my Top 5. Really admire & believe the “Witch Hunt” sub-cult Rush fan a special breed!
@@vandrive5687 I believe it is considered a trilogy, with Earthshine being #3.
I'm not sure of #2.
Maybe look into that.
It’s an absolute pleasure to watch Rick break this song down with that inimitable, almost childlike joy. Nobody else could do this music such justice. Rush is the Mount Everest of rock quality, easily one of the top five best groups in rock history. Xanadu is still a magical, perfect song, one that should be studied by anyone considering music as a craft. Rick - thank you so much for this episode!!!
That's why i love this guy so much.. He has a way of putting me right there with him in his excitement of what he is listening to. ANd takes me back in time to when i was young and so excited about new music. I just love Rick. Like you said, no one else could give the music the justice it deserves like Rick. Thank you Rick. You ROCK brother.
Just like a school age buddy that said " hey I got this album - wowzer - you gotta hear this!"
well said
NEVER GETS old. A true masterpiece of Rush, and Classic Progressive Rock. Bravo on Rick calling this one. There is not too many great 3 piece out there like Rush. Killer performance.
So glad to know others appreciate Alex's contribution to what made Rush!! Each member was special!
What is amazing is that they could reproduce this live!!! The live version of this on Exit Stage Left is absolutely astounding!
They played it on the last tour and it was still perfect. Saw it twice.
@@ryanrussell9556 Luck you, epic!
Reproduce it live? It was originally recorded in ONE TAKE
Exit Stage Left defined the summer of 1983 for me.... it was a golden age of music when i was a teen
Geddy's live variations during Xanadu theme are among my all time favorites. He played them every time I heard it live. ...even at R40 (I was at Irvine Meadows, CA).
YES, XANADU. I've been waiting for so long for someone to agree with me on that 😂 this is the best Rush's song ever. I love every single second of that record and I couldn't imagine my life without knowing it. it's pure poetry and as I said, I'm glad someone's acknowledged it as well ♥️
Definitely. It's their opus. I strongly prefer their performance if it on Exit.. Stage Left. But it was interesting hearing that their 2nd studio take was "the one." Of course, it was. Cuz they're awesome musicians.
Not a day goes by where at some point I listen to Rush. Tough to discern which is better Farewell to Kings, 2112, or Hemispheres. The Music is so sophisticated, that each Time I listen to it, I find something new.
@@patronus1776 Watching Alex Lifeson doing some of the fastest double-neck changes and switch throwing ever when going from the light twelve-string parts to the heavier six-string bits on the Exit... Stage Left video is so freaking awesome! While he's moving his left-hand onto the other neck his right hand is hitting the neck and pickup switches like a Jedi!
The trees / Xanadu on exit stage left is Rush’s greatest- there is something magic about it.
“I think I’m going Bald” is still the best Rush song ever:)
Seeing Rick's reaction to every sound and every moment made me tear up because it's exactly how I felt hearing this song for the first time.
Me too dude. Watching Rick made me feel like a kid again. My first Rush song was 1980 flying to London. I was 15. Temples of Syrinx. Mind instantly BLOWN. Rush has been my band ever since. I’m 57 now.
I kept waiting for Rick to cry. Heck, I did. Great memories. So glad to have experienced and loved Rush.
14 the summer of 78. Heard Rush and this song for the first time in the bottom of a magical canyon on an indian reservation near the Grand Canyon. Some super Rush heads from Phoenix camping next to me and my scout troop with a casette player. About 2pm, they asked if i wanted a bong hit. I was like what's that? I agreed and the next question was do you like Rush? I didnt know them at the time..they played Xanadu for me. Things kinda changed for me after that.
Super Duper ... Supai Indian Res, correct? Love Grand Canyon! Great story. What a place to be initiated. 🎶🎸👍
@@superduper6532 Rush is the gift that keeps on giving. I turned my younger brother onto them and he and I were lucky enough to have seen them together the last three tours before Neil passed. And last month my brother just got the Sterns Rush LE Pinball machine. The BASTARD!!!🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼🤣
Broon’s Bane/The Trees into Xanadu on Exit Stage Left was like a religious experience to me as a teenager. Pure brilliant creation straight from the source.
It still is!!!
Side Three of ESL transformed me from a casual Rush fan to a complete Rush fanboy when I first heard it in the summer of 1982.
Xanadu is a great selection for 'best' song. Rush does a wonderful job of setting the stage and creating the vibe. Rush is one band that truly uses the drums and percussion as melody.
Great musicians.
Neil's control of his volume and knowing where to gradually come in harder to increase it never fails to blow my mind. He had the technical prowess, but what REALLY set him apart was his trailblazing sense of composition. The construction of his parts is something that clearly took a fresh and original but still classically clever mind. Most of the great drummers today are only as great as they are because of him and his contributions to the craft. I can't imagine how long it will be before a mind like that comes along again. Great breakdown.
Massive 55 year old Rush fan from Toronto! This is so fascinating to see a genius and a rush fan, break this epic tune down. Thank you Rick!
Lose some weight, Bruno. You're not getting any younger. 😂
I’m not a musician but can truly appreciate the technical masterpiece that Xanadu, along with several other Rush tracks is. I just know when I listen to it, it’s transcendent.
I can’t help but smile watching beato listen with all the excitement of a child on Christmas morning. Truly an epic song played by epic musicians!!
hear hear
💯 x 💯
I took love Beato's reaction listening to Xanado.
Just 2 for me that never get props are
Don Brewer....
Grand Funk
And
Bill Ward.....
Black Sabbath
There's never been so much talent in such a small group. No room for error.
Primus is similar, and admittedly different too.
Pure genius.
"No room for error". Yup. Even Geddy pulling double & triple duty: bass, bass pedals, keys ....& effects pedals...... And Neil making MUSIC with his drums....
ELP
I think this is the issue with Alex missing out on plaudits....a super-bright light is missed in the light of a supernova! That band was a supernovae filled with three novas...one was bound to be missed in this world of self-publicity
I got goosebumps about 50 times watching this. This is the music that changed my life even though I didn’t hear it until about 1985 when I was 15 and had just got my first guitar.
A Farewell To Kings is one of my all time favourite albums. Great choice in tracks but I love Closer To The Heart just as much, in fact let's be honest with you I love the whole album. I've been a fan since I was 14 and I'm now 62, I guess once a Rush fan ALWAYS a Rush fan. Keep up the great work \m/.
When ancient civilizations look back and find this music and listen to how technical..melodic and perfectly timed each piece is..they'll be like.."NO way this is THREE people making all this sound"! Yea...they were..and still are..THE greatest rock trio of all time! Mozart in OUR day ladies and gentlemen!
mozart might give up piano and pick up drums
Sounds like the plot to 2112
Bill & Ted's excellent adventure.
They will say it was aliens lol.
It's easier to be musically tight with three members than with 4, 5 or 6 members
Rush. The greatest rock band ever. From another planet.
A planet call Canada ;)
From a planet in the solar federation
Absolutely agree
@@CruceEntertainment They have assumed control
Nope, just from Canada
Xanadu is an absolute masterpiece! You get the whole package in one song. Definitely my favorite RUSH song.
Yep. Always loved The Camera Eye -- but you just have to hand it to them on that one.
Agree.
Cygnus X1 has entered the chat.
..ļ
I can't imagine Rush's sound and artistry will ever be equaled.
My aunt lent me a copy of A Farewell to Kings 40 years ago after my parents bought me my first hifi system. I listened to the title track and when the intro ended and the wall of noise hit me, I was hooked. I love all kinds of music but Rush is the band I always come back to.
This video sums up all the reasons we love Rick. His genuine, unadulterated enthusiasm puts a smile on your face. Especially when he's Air Drumming. Plus, his appreciation, knowledge and incredible perspective on music makes this channel so enjoyable. Every school should have a music teacher like him.
Well said!!
I don’t believe it’s possible to have that many superheroes with his inhuman musical ability.
I wish I did! In the 80's in London, unless you were middle class or a 'Swot' it was unlikely you would get music lessons
Absolutely, every morning while I have breakfast I listen to one of his episodes.
Beautifully said.
Can we talk about how criminally underrated Alex is?
Seriously underrated. Nobody denies Neil is one of the greatest rock drummers of all time - he generally comes up in the top 3 of any list that's worth anything - and that Geddy is *the* boss bassist, but Alex Lifeson gets ignored because he doesn't have the big personality of so many lead guitarists. He does what's needed for the songs. If it needs a Gilmour-esque melodic solo, that's what he does. If it needs shredding, he shreds. The band balanced beautifully, and it was due in no small part to Lifeson's technical excellence and musicianship.
Absolutely brilliant.
@@katherineheasley6196 In a nutshell, Alex was incredible at serving each song with his musicianship
Millions of album sales and multiple guitar deals with Gibson and Fender. That's underrated?
I can't understand exactly how this term "underrated" is tossed about. It doesn't seem to have any connection to a musician's actual rating, in terms of accolades and rewards. Maybe the "underrated" epithet actually points to the author's opinion of him or herself as more sophisticated than anyone else.
Love how you have the ability to make me appreciate music that I already loved. I'm not a musician but the information you expound highlights things I enjoyed but perhaps never understood why, and that just makes my enjoyment that much more meaningful. Thank you.
I'm a massive RUSH fan and have listened to Xanadu numerous times over the years, but Rick, you gave me an insight to the song I never had before. Thank you!
So I have listened to Rush since 79. Seen them 5 times live. Had this album on vinyl, tape, cd and digital. And I STILL get goosebumps every time i hear it. Every time!
I first saw Rush play at a high school around 1973 or 74 in St Catharines, Ontario. The last time was at Molson Canadian Rocks for Toronto in 2003 (best concert I ever saw).
@@SherwoodyVery cool🤘
Farewell To Kings is my all time favourite. Xanadu is a masterwork.
I feel blessed living in Toronto back in the day and watching Rush. Back then we were blown away. We thought nobody will get this outside of Canada.... hahaha....right,😂
I saw them in Toronto in 1985 at the Power Windows era. I saw them in a bunch of cities in the Northeast USA as well , Honestly I don’t think they gave a better show in Canada, their so great on tour that every time they play no matter what location they give a peak performance.
I’ve been listening to this band for 45 years. This video has made me appreciate little things throughout the song that I hadn’t noticed or at least hadn’t thought about - so thank you Sir!!
You are such a true fan, and for so many years. So many of your fans are as well. You just have to interview Geddy and Alex. Please make it happen.
Mike, from “across the lake” in Ontario.
I echo that plea from across the "pond" in Exeter, UK. Get 'em on the channel Rick. They have always seemed to be such obliging gents that I sense that before long, you will.
Either one or both. Absolutely. Please.
That would be amazing!
I grew up in Ogdensburg NY by the border, 60 miles from Ottawa. Spent many days in Canada attending many concerts back in the 70s and 80s. We loved Rush and thought they were one of the best bands ever. They had a huge following in northern New York as did several other Canadian bands like April Wine, BTO, Guess Who, Gordon Lightfoot and many others. But Rush was always amazing.
I grew up in Potsdam, NY. Did you listen to Chez 106?
saga, red rider, aldo nova, honeymoon suite
@@driver4011 Triumph
i am from north ont. and would agree and focus on April Wine. they played a million concerts. had a good arena sound back in the 70's.
3 guitars.. and there drummer was animal
@@TeeDOG6 yes chez 106 was the go to station, I listened to chez all the time. They were the first FM station in our area.
It's a testament to Rush's greatness that after one Rick's longest sabbaticals, he comes back with a breakdown of a Rush song.
Its so good to hear a guy my age who grew up with the same music and still like myself still gets excited like we were back in jr high school again….. The magic of music is the keeper our soul for many of us and it’s one thing that we can always count on and will never disappoint….
Rick, you helped me appreciate a song I’ve loved for decades even more. Your insights into things like Geddy’s escalating vocals just take this song to the next level for me. Only by Rush. Only appreciated by Rick Beato. Fantastic!
Natural Science is my favorite Rush song, because of the sheer excitement, total originality, the imaginative and expansive lyrics and the amazing musicianship. Seeing it performed live has been one of life's great pleasures.
Natural Science is fucking unreal. Everything about it screams Rush. May be my alltime favorite as well. Though Hemesphers the song might be right with it.
A greater song than Natural Science does not exist. It's the pinnacle of human achievement.
Was my favorite song in high school. It's in the yearbook
Seeing that song live for the first time was just amazing! I saw it a few times again, but that first time was just 🤯
I love Losing It! Great song and they actually did it live on stage finally and it's on you tube! Great watch!
Xanadu is still one of the most incredible songs Rush created. It’s amazing!!! Once again, you have hit one of the best rock performances ❤️ The lyrics are also incredible! Neil at the top of his game (RIP 😔)
I just cant seem to make it through a Rush song without crying: them being the sound track of my life, Neil's passing/the bands dissolution and seeing them play this song live from the 3rd row on the R40 is all too much to make it though this video without shedding tears. I do feel fortunate that we have the Rush community and to know that what is clearly evident in Rick's reaction and all of your heartfelt comments, I am not alone in my admiration.
And now Taylor is gone. Heaven is gonna be fucking noisy now boi.
Are you a woman? i have met very few female Rush in my life.
Grew up with rush . Was depressed for days when Neil passed .
Drama queen
@@jameswelch1463 I guess there always has to be a grumpy guy in the YT section, but hey if the shoe fits ;)
Xanadu is THE masterpiece of masterpieces in the entire RUSH universe.
Natural Science is #2.
The Camera Eye #3.
RIP Professor Neil Peart 🔥
I only had heard "Tom Sawyer" before hearing this for the first time.
As it rolled on, I was gobsmacked totally by its' magnificence.
I listened over and over and over, totally in awe of what was coming to my ears.
What about the Necromancer?
Camera Eye is up there for me too and I think it's Getty's best song lyrically. I love the way he sings the lyrics
@@bassfan41 Agreed. The way he sings the lines :
"The buildings are lost in their limitless rise,
My feet catch the pulse and the purposeful stride...
I feel a sense of possibilities,
I feel the wrench of hard realities."
Gives me shivers to this day!! 🔥
I love Necromancer more than Xanadu, BUT Necromancer suffers a bit from being splot into three parts that while great don't have the same coherence Xanadu does as a whole song @@johnmaldonado3909
Beato hears one chord and it harkens him back to a random John Denver track. I love the catalogue in his brain. Like a giant musical database.
I always thought I was the lone weirdo who loved Rush and John Denver.
I have not watched this video yet, but seeing your comment, just let me guess: he was talking about the Badd11 (008997) chord in Rush's "Xanadu" and John Denver's "The Eagle and the Hawk"
Just watched the video and it looks like I was right lol
And we all went and listened to it
Eagle and the Hawk - John Denver's greatest too, IMO. Beato muses w/ the idea of doing a vid on that song - definitely should use one of the solo JD vids for his example - under rated guitarist just like Lifeson!
a 37 minute stream on a 10 plus minute song... now that is passion! I am on a road trip tomorrow I am pulling out this CD for it!
I can hardly believe it's nearing 50 years that I've been a Rush fan; in some ways it seems like yesterday. Personally I loath the thought of trying to choose a favorite, especially when so many of their compositions elicit such strong emotions. I also find it truly amazing that three brilliant, virtuosic musicians were able to maintain a personal and professional relationship that lasted roughly 46 years. RIP Neil.
I’m 59 and I still remember many of their lyrics! It’s truly amazing how only 3 men created such a complex and full sound...as if they were a much larger band...and their live shows were impeccable too. ❤ It was lovely to watch you analyzing and vibing to this song !! Great video, thank you. 😊❤
I cannot believe that I missed this all my life. This quality of music don't exist today regularly. Thank you😍
In Junior High English, we were reading the Coleridge poem when this came out. My teacher let me bring the record in and play it for the class. Imagine the horror of the long instrumental beginning for both the teacher and most in the class. But she caught on as it built, and by the time the lyrics arrived, she was ecstatic. It was a signpost of my early life. The teacher felt, appropriately, that she was reaching us. Or at least reaching me.
Yeah, most people can't handle the beginning. Their loss.
On the LP there are no scratches on certain RUSH songs due to the impatience of ...well, me at 17. At 60, I savor every turn of the record albums!
I did the exact same thing in high school...
I always loved songs beginnings before the lyrics start
A Farewell To Kings was released right after the start of my 11th grade high school year. Being a budding Rush fan, I bought it the day it showed up in the stores. I played the sh!t out of that vinyl record for years, and with every listen grew to love it more. There is no way to describe the impact and influence on me as a musician and as a human being. The title track is a lesson and a foundation for a righteous society, and a condemnation of the usual human folly. It is relevant now, 45 years after it's creation, and will be relevant for thousands of years. LONG LIVE RUSH!!!
Oh yeah I was a freshman in high school but I remember skipping class to buy the 8 track tape. I've owned all the possible ways to own it. Vinyl, cd, cassette 8 track lol DVD
I grew up poor in Philadelphia, and I had one of those ubiquitous brown clocks where the numbered plates would flip, so I listened to the radio. I heard Tom Sawyer here and there but I was still unaware of ‘Rush’ proper. By around 1983 I finally had a stereo walkman radio and one day I heard Red Barchetta while lying in my bed - holy moly it put the hook in me & I was off like a rocket to the mall. I bought Fly By Night, but that wasn’t it. The following allowance I bought Moving Pictures, then as I went through High school I bought more Rush records, including of course A Farewell to Kings. Hearing Xanadu felt like hearing Red Barchetta the first time. Everything Rush did had a profound magic to it that opened me up to life through their sound. Of all of the life experiences that shape who I am as a person, Rush is by far the strongest and best influence on me. That looping guitar riff during Xanadu’s intro - I don’t even have words to describe what it does to my soul. I’m fortunate to have grown up with Rush, to have seen them live twice, and to have their music forever in me.
@@Bikewithlove I had that same radio!!! Grew up in San Diego...Surf/skate/Mx/Bmx/Sex/Drugs and every RUSH album and at least 4 live concerts...My best friend,after years of Megadeath, Metallica,Sabbath,Maiden etc. just recently started exploring RUSH with his guitar...Life is good with RUSH
So very well said.
Great comment and agree.
Now that I'm done bawling like a baby....
I discovered RUSH shortly after my mom brought me and my sister up as very young kids from Jamaica to live in Canada. Could not believe my ears! Been hooked ever since!!! Think it was the year they released their debut album. I consider it a total honor live in the exact neighborhood that Geddy and Alex cut their teeth. I point out places to my twins as we walk/drive around the blocks here.
So very sad to lose Neil!
It's quite evident that Geddy cannot hit those notes anymore (and hasn't been able to for a while now). It's not surprising because what he did on vocals is just not human. HOW DID HE SING SOOOOOOOOO HIGH AND WONDERFUL WHILE PLAYING ALL THOSE PARTS??!?!?!
I really wish they'd hire the best Geddy voice clone, and hit the road (they'll need a drummer too now). They'd be a 4 piece, but Alex and Geddy can do the music and let the clone sing, sparing Geddy's voice box. They are probably tired of touring after all of those years, so may be they could just do a few shows each year across Canada. We'd LOVE to see them still!
I'm dying for the day that I run into them here in the city. Every time I see a vid of either of them they are some place really close to me. LOL
Let’s not forget that these guys (aliens probably) were 24 years old when they wrote and recorded this. 🤦🏻♂️ Rick, thank you for once again sharing your love for music and those that make it.
How old was Mozart when he wrote many of his symphonies? Not very.
@@alwaysopen7970 must've been early alien?
@@EASTON1970 - A Classical Alien.
Well I'm from the United States so of course they are aliens. At least from my perspective.
Unless, of course, I see them in Canada in which case I am then the alien and they are native.
They are not, however, space aliens. Toronto is not outer space.
I would agree with you that rush is ancient aliens even though that whole theory is complete bullcrap. However, this is far from rush's greatest. Sing a melody from this song. you can't? okay then.
So I’m 22, and my dad is the one that introduced me to rush probably around when I was 10. I had just started playing the drums and was absolutely blown away by their precision timing, random off beat things that I couldn’t even describe and still have a hard time describing that Neil would do. I always loved them. It’s so cool hearing people talk about rush and their experience with them back when rush was first taking the music world by storm. At least the music world of actual musicians. The people that can understand how absolutely insane they are. I find it endearing we’re all kinda geeky in our own ways especially when it comes to music. Anyway, not even sure what I’m commenting at this point, but thought I would just say great video. Super cool too see deep analysis of all of their intricacies that have captivated listeners for decades. Wish I could have saw them live.
Let's not forget "The Trees" fellas.
Excellent song breakdown. Listening to Neil Peart's drum fills and rolls gives me goosebumps.
This was the first song I learned to play on guitar in the 80's. I grew up thinking this was how everyone played and when I tried to form my own bands later, I knew no one played like this. Drummers and bassists didn't like me because I would tell them to play more - like Rush. An amazing version of this song is from Exit Stage Left. Xanadu is a 20 min trifecta starting with Broon's Bane (a classical guitar composition vs. typical rock concert guitar solo), The Tree's, and then culminating with Xanadu. They were true master musicians at that point and there's a concert of the same tour where you can watch them play those songs. And none of this even dives into the depth of Neil's story telling and lyrical prose. Every album of theirs through Signals was a masterpiece to me - I was lucky to grow up with that kind of music.
Exit Stage Left was the very first album I bought when I was 11 years old. I was so naive at that time that I literally thought the woman on the cover that is holding the curtain was actually the singer. I bought it because the only song I knew from Rush, at that time, was Tom Sawyer from hearing it on Rock 103 in Memphis, TN. I had no idea even who was in the band, and if you look on the inside of the album, The picture of Geddy Lee is this shot of his sillhouette with his shoulder length hair and thin framed body with a spotlight behind his head. So at that age, it was plausible to me that it was the same girl on the cover, but with a bass guitar strapped on "her" shoulder. lol And he did certainly have a high voice. But the rest of that album opened not just a new world, but an entire new Universe of possibilities! And that YYZ drum solo, I was rendered absolutely speechless and dumbfounded. I had never heard anything like that anywhere.Everything on it just blew me away because all I ever heard in those days was normal industry rock like Foreigner or Styx with Mr Roboto or Bad Company or Journey or Billy Squire or Kasey Kasem's Top 40 on the radio. In my small 11 year old world, I thought THAT was what rock n roll was. Boy , did my mind open up like an acid trip...without the acid of course. It changed my life forever.
Right? For a short period I was in a band with all Rush-heads. We played a lot of covers from all sorts of bands and that Rush influence elevated it all.
I was just commenting on how I love the live version better on Exit Stage Left. My favorite part of the album is listening to the 3 songs Broons Bane, Trees and Xanadu. Also, Jacobs Ladder is killer. When I pick up my guitar I don’t usually put it down without playing those songs.
@@Black2th isnt the innoocence beautiful? Espcially to this great music.✌
@@davidvasquez8658 You bet your sweet Aspercreme. lol ;)
This song was the first time listening to Rush sent chills down my spine....It was wonderful! I had goose bumps all over. It was so haunting and amazing. I think I must have played it over 50 times that day. Definitely one of my fav's from them. Great choice!!!👍👍
These guys would rehearse their songs to perfection and record live takes in the studio. It's an insane level of musicianship!!
I love how much you love this.
That’s guys were perfectly in sync and made for each other. Geddy’s story about auditioning Neil and how excited he was prove that he knew right away. Alex thought his hair wasn’t long enough LOL
I had this cassette tape listening in my '76 Mercury Capri with Alpine head unit and Pioneer TS-6907's in the rear deck..... There were times when I would just sit in my car listening to these songs (because my car stereo sounded better than the one in my room.) You guys know... 🤘
Mine was a '74, but I pined for a stereo like yours.
Man there were nights me and my friends would buy beer and weed and sit in the car and listen for hours ....parked at some beach or even someone's house !
Nothing beat a good car party.
Alpine? Aristocrat. I had Alphine speakers that were $30 at Kmart.
@@residentmanager3088 not in the early 80s you didn't. Alpine was top stuff.
@@HorsepowerHouse I agree that Alpine was top notch. I just couldn’t afford it. Alphine was the Alpine knock off and it was cheap and crap. 😂