If you liked this exam and want more refereeing content, check out this detailed breakdown on Attack on Preparation by Chris Lennon! (FIE Foil Referee): th-cam.com/video/5x8UpFVdS5Q/w-d-xo.html
I agreed with my betters 15/31; I changed my call 7 times after slo-mo it helped 3 times; it took a while before I called simultaneous and continued to have trouble with it; on 4 occasions (3, 4, 24, and 26) I could not bring myself to see it the way it was called. I have a long way to go; thanks for the exercise.
That's quite a good score considering the option of simultaneus, well done the simul hits were generally ones that were most contentious among fie refs as well
I just listed the call the ref made in the bout in the description as the answer. But you are right - when asking FIE refs to take this exam there was disagreement on 2 or 3 calls in it, so sometimes it does depend on the ref.
If you liked this exam and want more refereeing content, check out this detailed breakdown on Attack on Preparation by Chris Lennon! (FIE Foil Referee):
th-cam.com/video/5x8UpFVdS5Q/w-d-xo.html
It would be useful to know if any calls were switched after video.
@@bikingfencer It was a lot, maybe half
@@bikingfencer oh no sorry I misread your comment. A lot were video reviewed but not that many were actually changed after review
I agreed with my betters 15/31; I changed my call 7 times after slo-mo it helped 3 times; it took a while before I called simultaneous and continued to have trouble with it; on 4 occasions (3, 4, 24, and 26) I could not bring myself to see it the way it was called. I have a long way to go; thanks for the exercise.
That's quite a good score considering the option of simultaneus, well done
the simul hits were generally ones that were most contentious among fie refs as well
Thanks for posting these videos. It is soooooo difficult and I only scored 17/31.
Yeah i think i made it too hard haha, but congrats it's not a bad score - since simultaneous is also an option it's a good result
Small mistake in the cards, 22 says "Itkin - Garozzo" but in fact it is Meinhardt and Garozzo.
Do these calls have a right answer..? Or does it just depends on the ref?
I just listed the call the ref made in the bout in the description as the answer.
But you are right - when asking FIE refs to take this exam there was disagreement on 2 or 3 calls in it, so sometimes it does depend on the ref.
@@OlympicFoil It would be useful to know which calls the FIE refs disagreed on.
@@bikingfencer I'll look through and try to recall, let me get back to you in a while
@@bikingfencer
ok:
kruse - trani
imboden - bianchi
Meinhardt - Garozzo
Cheung - Meinhardt
Nista - Rosatelli
had some disagreements
Seeing the thumbnail I know this is a hard one
haha yeah