QUICK CORRECTION! In the video, I say that *Bricklink* categorizes "Ninja" as a Castle subtheme, but I got it mixed up with *Brickset* - the point still stands though, as long as you swap the names around. Sorry about that folks!
I definitely noticed that since I have spent significant hours on BrickLink and categorizing my own collection records. BrickLink does not categorize Ninja as a Castle subtheme, though I think it makes sense to categorize "historical" themes according to technology available, which counts Ninja as a late-era Castle subtheme (swords, castles, and horses albeit with the introduction of muskets/arquebus) even though the literal historical references were from different eras across the world. This also applies to Vikings and Fantasy Era, as the technology level is roughly the same, although incorporating fantasy/mythology rather than strictly historical reference. This method would also count Rock Raiders as a Space subtheme with advanced scanning, teleportation, hover/propulsion, and lasers likely well advanced from our current level of technology.
@@jays8710 Something like that was found in a Danish catalogue, but it was more so referring to Rock Raiders itself as "Underground", not a subtheme of the same name.
I kept getting Ninjago stuff recommended to me until I put the castle in the search bar, I think that was for eBay. That theme has like 4-5 castles in it and factions so I can see it. Why do all my favorite themes have unobtainable minifigure “heroes”?! Ughhhhh!!!!
I think it must have the word "space" in it, such as "Classic Space" and "Space Police 3" So Blacktron, Ice Planet, and Power Miners are all not space themes
Technically, Bionicle is a Lego Space theme, cause everything happened inside a giant robot shaped spaceship, and the time it wasn't on the Great Spirit Robot is when we dealt with alien worlds. Heck, Hero Factory is a theme with a Galaxy spanning police force, not that different from Space Police line.
Honestly, I subscribe to that idea. I mean, even if both don't take place in the SAME underground, the aesthetics are the exact same. Which also goes for "Space" sets.
Well just looking though the lastest Lego catalogue proves that. With exception to City and Friends, it's all licenced themes. A real shame if you ask me.
Why make more Space or other Sci-Fi themes when you have access to Star Wars; the most successful sci-fi brand of all time? Why continue to make Castle when you have access to Lord of the Rings? Why continue to make Adventurers when you have access to Indiana Jones? Why continue to make Pirates when even Pirates of the Caribbean couldn’t draw interest? The only in-house IP they really can’t replace are City (any replacement I could think of is aimed more towards a Duplo age range), Ninjago (there’s nothing to replace it with), and Monkey Kid if that’s still around (because the Chinese would be mad). The more I learn, the more I realize that I was there for Lego’s last great in-house brand (Bionicle). And that makes me sad, honestly. If they didn’t relegate original IP to overpriced collector’s items and insidiously marketed “Gift With Purchase” items, I’d gladly support it.
@DragonxFlutter Yeah I was only around for the end of the original themes Rock Raiders, Adventure, knights kingdom, Castle, bionicles etc. But the thing is variety is the space of life which you get with new space sub themes every few years. There isn't much variety with star wars except for when they used to do EU stuff I guess. Isn't everyone sick of Star Wars anyway. I just long for the days of fun Lego themes that embraced the fun and charm of Lego...
@@SuperSecretBricks Power Miners, unlike Rock Raiders, does take place on earth, lore wise, so it would be classified as either Underground or if you really want to stretch it, an offshoot of City. Definitely not Space tho
My thought exacly. And from what I had seen, not the first time LEGO did something like this. All tho the examples I'm using are of "finished sets" rather than "ideas for later". Ex The bike in the set "Swamp raid" from LEGO Agents was originally desighned for Mars Mission. Or an transforming mech "Undersea Explorer" from LEGO Atlantis was originally intented for Power Miners.
the same thought occurred to me initially, but on further thought, I could also see magma just being a sort of natural escalation of any sort of underground setting- after all, you're bound to run into the stuff if you dig deep enough
YESSSS just came here to suggest that! I would be all over that. I just recently already made up my own mining faction of Aquazone, basically underwater Rock Raiders. I'd absolutely submit that moc as part of it.
@@Thinginatornot to be rude but doesn't something like this allready exist ? That been the original Aqua Raiders theme ? (Or Aquanots for that matter, since their mission was to mine chrome crystals) Could you elaborate what did you mean with "Underwater Rock Raiders".
Rock Raiders travels through space and mines foreign planets. They experience foreign aliens (rock monsters) if Mars Mission is space, then so is Rock Raiders
I think the most divisive thing for Rock Raiders is really just the marketing. Roboforce promo and magazine art features the robots clearly operating on a Traditional LEGO Space Environment: a bizarre, rocky alien world likely lacking an atmosphere with Tron Lines TM in the sky and the like. That, to me, is the DEFINITIVE LEGO Space Aesthetic: even more than the builds, its how LEGO presented them. (Also, for Roboforce, it was heavily marketed in tandem with UFO, with some promo material using the same Green Planet background that UFO featured, suggesting they were on the same planet. I believe Insectoids used this backdrop too, which tracks given Insectoids and UFO are both supposed to represent two species from the same planet). This is why Aquazone doesn't often get called a space theme, and its why more "low key" themes that clearly involve outer space aren't considered space themes either sometimes, such as Life on Mars, as its more an extension of Town-Spaceport (something you brought up in your overview of the 2024 Space video). Similarly, all Rock Raiders marketing material features only caves! Even the Hover Scout, while surely in the same design language as small space-faring craft in previous themes, is shown to be used to float around through caves, so I think that's why people may not see Rock Raiders as a Space theme. Hell for the longest time I didn't even know Rock Raiders had a mother ship, because surely if such a thing was important it would've made into a set, right? Instead the "mothership" set for Rock Raiders is their big VTOL propeller driven vehicle. And maybe that's the OTHER thing, aesthetics of the builds. Roll cages and Propellers don't suggest Space-faring utility. In other Space Themes that feature some sort of terrain excavation, you find that flying craft are very versatile, being presented as both atmospheric craft, ground effect vehicles, and spacecraft all at once. With Rock Raiders, you don't have that, much like how all the vehicles in Aquazone are clearly submarines and couldn't be used for anything else but that. It's weird, subconscious ideas like this that i think affect people the most I believe. HOWEVER, PERSONALLY, Rock Raiders is at least Space-Adjacent. If Roboforce can count, Rock Raiders can count, and Aquazone is part of that club too I think. On a similar note, Ninja is absolutely a castle theme. It features Castles! I think the qualifier there is a lot less ambiguous haha. Still undecided on Life on Mars, though. I kind of like it as more of a 20 Minutes into the Future Lego Town sort of theme, but I can't really argue against why people would consider it a part of space lol. I also think UFO is in an interesting position when compared against its spiritual successor Alien Conquest. Alien Conquest is clearly depicting a B-movie style invasion of a Ambiguously Contemporary Earth, where as UFO is clearly not - but a lot of UFO's tv commercials (and the name UFO) and design language of them having flying saucers certainly suggests they were meant to be this.... but instead they just fight the Roboforce lol.
@@RRSlugger I think ultimately it’s easier to look at this stuff as a spectrum rather than a hard yes or no. Stuff like Nexo Knights blurred lines between Castle and Space after all, and themes like Mars Mission blur between Town Space and Classic Space.
@@Dreadwolf3155 hecc yeah dood, they were technically only around from Futuron until I think Exploriens (or whatever came before them) but I consider the Tron Lines across the skyline a key aesthetic element of LEGO Space lol
As far as I'm concerned, I feel like any conversations about "does (BLANK) count as (BLANK)" eventually fall apart for the same reasons that "is a hot dog a sandwich" conversations eventually fall apart: categorizations are tools for helping to convey information, and as such aren't meant to consider every single literal ramification of their divisions. Calling any one theme or another "LEGO space" or "LEGO castle" is mostly shorthand as a way for all of us to quickly understand what the other peraon is talking about due to our generalized expectations of what each entails, and arguing over edge cases or oddities misses the point of why we try to have categories at all. And this is especially true of terminology that exists mostly among fans and the creators had little to no involvement in popularising. Maybe this isn't the answer that anyone else is looking for, but I've been thinking a lot about these kinds of arguments in general this year and so I felt like the perspective I've come to would be more interesting to ahare than getting into heated debates over semantics with other people would.
Exactly, this entire video reminded me of Wittgenstein for this reason. He argued that we cannot pinpoint the meaning of any word to a set of properties or anything like that. What, for example, belongs to our concept of a "game"? Whatever you think is the essence of games, there is always a counter example. I really like his notion of "family resemblance" in this context. We sometimes immediately see that people are siblings by their facial characteristics (e.g., a certain shape of the nose, eyes or ears) and yet these characteristics cannot be exhaustively formalized. Well then, the same must hold for our Lego space and Lego castle themes. Simply put, Rock Raiders is at least space-esque, and it depends on our purposes whether it is part of space or not! It's strange how one can suddenly start philosophizing about Lego haha, perhaps it's time for a new discipline
I've got it! Sci-fi - Lego Space Fantasy - Lego Castle Slightly more than Modern - Lego City All Lego themes can be boiled down these three categories. Dino Attack is Lego City, Chima is Lego Castle, and Nexo Knights is, of course, Lego Space. (This is a joke.) Actually, this almost makes it sound like the decision to step away from Lego Space because of Star Wars was a part of the licensing agreement. I wonder if that's still relevant today?
In terms of the licensing agreement, I don’t think so. At least not directly. Every time Lego tried to do a sci-fi theme after acquiring the Star Wars license, it just didn’t have the pull to attract buyers. Why would a random kid want something as generic sounding as “space police” when he could beg his parents for a much more recognizable Star Wars set instead? At the end of the day, it’s all brand recognition. Why waste marketing money trying to compete with yourself when you could put that money into an IP that practically does the advertising for you?
not sure whether it's more cursed that this puts Adventurers in Castle or that it places Life on Mars into City. Both are second place to Bionicle is Lego Space as a conclusion of this categorization. I love it.
Watching these videos over the last few months has reinvigorated my love of Lego, and now I have a complete set of the Rock Raiders theme. Slugger's content has cost me more than any other TH-cam channel.
No matter which way you drill into the brickonium ore, Rock Raiders is still awesome, and deserves all the praise it gets. Darn I need to rebuild my Loader Dozer, but Rocky the Rock Monster is kinda enjoying chilling on top of Grand Emporium with a pair of chrome drills, so perhaps not.
In an alternate timeline, Lego had an ongoing licensed comic book with a writing team that was left adrift and had to come up with their own ongoing stories and lore and kept adding the new sets into the stories, they had a flourishing internal lore and storylines, where Rock Raiders and AquaZone traveled across planets with Mtron and Exploriens to defend from evil aliens and robots and so on. TH-camrs make three hour video essays explaining the insane continuity and time travel retcons of this comic. Fans often make MOCs of their personal Legosonas. In this alternate timeline, there's no Sonic comic book.
@@RRSlugger It really isn't debatable. I looked up those Lego colors and the bricks were definitively transparent. It doesn't matter if the brick shape causes distortions or if the color is dark. "transparent" and "translucent" are well-defined material properties -- if the light is not being diffused (which would specifically make the image look blurred), it's definitively not translucent.
@@klikkolee Hmm, I certainly could be wrong about that! Perhaps a better example of the translucent effect would be one of those trans neon orange boulders from Life On Mars. Maybe I should have put a picture of that up instead? It’s very interesting - I’ve received all sorts of comments on this topic, from folks like yourself telling me it *is* transparent, to folks telling me that “trans neon orange” is *supposed* to stand for translucent neon orange, not transparent neon orange. 😅
@@RRSlugger It looks like there's a fine texture on the boulders.This kind of texture will from a practical standpoint diffuse light, so it's reasonable to refer to the part as a whole as translucent, but the material itself appears to still be transparent. I see a similar thing with images of trans neon orange slopes -- when viewing through the textured face, the part appears translucent, but looking only through non-textured faces shows that the material is transparent.
Much like the unique alien mini figure and slimy slug prototypes, it's hard not to mourn the possibility of an entire series based around various underground factions. Imagine if the rock monsters got their own theme, or a blacktron style rival mining crew theme
Fun fact: the word "factoid" originally meant "an inaccurate statement or statistic believed to be true because of broad repetition, especially if cited in the media". But, because of broad repetition, has come to mean a small fact.
1:15 that is clearly transparent -- somewhat literally; if you can clearly see an image through it, it's transparent, regardless of color. A translucent material blurs the image due to diffusing the light as it passes through. This was taught in school for me, and it's also consistent with the first definition of "translucent" I got when looking up the word: "Transmitting light but causing sufficient diffusion to prevent perception of distinct images"
Very cool. I love the shot of Jet in an explorean space suit. My head canon was always that the LMS Explorer was a later generation of explorean ship. Personally I consider Rock Raiders to be a space theme, and can see the case for Aquazone. Ninja and vikings are also castle themes and Pharaoh's Quest is an adventurers theme.
Considering the opening cinematic of both versions of the video game , i always considered Raiders a space theme and always thought it a shame we never got an LMS Explorer.
Oh my god! I did a physical double-take when I saw pictures from James Gurney’s Dinotopia series at 6:02 !!! That book: ‘The World Beneath’ was released in 1995, and I grew up reading that book over and over as a 7yr old kid. I had no idea it influenced the Lego RR series but knowing that it does makes so much sense to me!!! I used to spend hours pouring over those paintings of underground caverns, only for TLG to release an ‘underground’ theme only a few years later that I absolutely loved that was influenced by it 🤯!Truly blew my mind. Thank you RR Slugger for showing me this. I only wish I knew what book it was you had on screen there?
Right?? I was equally mind blown to learn that the science fiction works Rock Raiders was based on were from this book called Dinotopia, haha! I had the same revelation, but in reverse. 😆 The book I was showing off is called "The Ultimate LEGO Book", by DK publishing, 2000. It's wonderful and gives a great look into LEGO at the time!
@@RRSlugger- thanks for letting me know the name of the book. Very kind of you. The connection between RR and Dinotopia seems odd until you realise that that particular Dinotopia book shown in those two pictures is VERY heavily influenced by 'Journey to The Centre of The Earth' by Jules Verne. It's interesting to think that maybe at some point 'Underground' might have been a Jules Verne inspired adventure series. "High Adventure, Underground" indeed!! 😁
I never thought of Rock Raiders as a “Space” theme, but I didn’t know any of the lore at the time. It was obviously in the future like Space, but for all I knew, this was all going on under Earth’s crust. Same could be said for Aquazone. I assumed at the time it was Earth in the distant future after humans set up colonies under the ocean.
Oooh! I love it when new details come to light about internal development, fascinating. Side note, as Lego colours have internal numbers who wants to start naming their colours that way, goodbye bright blueish green, hello colour 107! (Source the 2020 modular bookshop)
As someone who doesn’t know much about Rock Raiders, i’d say it makes more sense for Rock Raiders to be a space theme instead of not being a space theme. The alien like rock monster looking guys, the futuristic equipment and aesthetics and not to mention the lore itself setting it in a distant galaxy!
Rock Raiders was one of three LEGO themes with the "Raiders" suffix, the others include the LEGO Aquazone subtheme Aquaraiders (1997) and the standalone LEGO Aqua Raiders theme (2007).
Okay, even if it would be considered Underground instead of Space... Because due to Star Wars, Underground were meant to replace Space, it wouldn't be a different theme as much as evolution of it. If Space themes were to be replaced with Sci-Fi esque Underground themes focusing on singular zones and exp-loration of them, I can guarantee that most fans would most likely consider them Space anyways. After all, by that point we would already have Ice Planet and Aquazone as space themes, without Space proper Underground would become a new Space. So in a sense, it doesn't matter if Lego doesn't view RR as space theme if RR was meant to create a substitute to fill the same niche that Space filled.
I find the need within our community to taxa LEGO themes fascinating. It speaks volumes about our collective interest in LEGO's history and the plenty of ways past design languages have informed subsequent LEGO themes and specific sets. I am glad LEGO is starting to take this part of our community more seriously and hope they bring along more interesting projects with direct connections to their own history. I yearn for more themes and sets that exemplify the design philosophy they had in the 90s: Rock Raiders, Time Twisters, Paradisa, Adventurers, you call it!
I'd be here for a series of MOCs exploring the Underground World filled with factions with alliterative names. Rock Raiders, Magma Mites, Tunnel Terrors, Borehole Brigade, Crystal Company, things like that.
Looking at other sets, it would be very easy to picture Lego Pirates as a follow-up to Lego Castle, as that is more-or-less how it worked in real life, and one could even juryrig castles with cannons and pirates for a fun crossover. In much the same way, Rock Raiders can easily tie into Lego Space, it gives a lot more purpose to *why* they're in space, rather than being there for the sake of space. With Rock Raiders' brutalist/industrial aesthetic (most sets lean more industrial, but on the larger builds and especially the LMS Explorer I think the brutalist stylings make the builds pop) it could even exist as a former era of design, left behind as being too blocky or instead a more modern refutation of the classic ornamentation as they go more utilitarian and solidly built with their designs. Anywhere can fit and in space there's room for anything, even the Time Cruisers.
I’m literally building an Imperial Guard Brigantine MOC right now that has Lion Knight motifs in its décor to imply that the redcoats are descended from the Lion Knights. Though due to economic restrictions, as bluecoat torsos are cheaper literally half of the crew is made up of them. It would be nice to have an obvious Castle faction to tie the bluecoats to as so far all I can come up with is the Black Falcons, who make me think of the Holy Roman Empire more than France and doesn’t seem a great match…
Oddly enough I never actually considered Rock Raiders as a space theme until this video brought up the thought bubble. For me, it's a given theme, if not an official theme. It does make sense to me that it can be considered a space theme because it takes place in space to an extent. =w= Regardless though, I love Rock Raiders. >w
Urge to sing the "Sonic Underground" theme but switch the lyrics to fit Rock Raiders, now that we know LEGO had a project named "LEGO Underground", is... rising!!! D: I must resist!!!!! GAH!!! *_"Rock Raiders formed, New theme awaits!~"_* *_"Retailers warn of a deadly fate!~"_* *_"Give up your new theme, separate!~"_* *_"Bide your time, lie in wait!~"_* *_"LEGO UNDERGROUND!~ LEGO UNDERGROOOUUNND!!!-"_*
I never really thought of "Power Miners" (which "Magma Mites" may have been an early concept of) as a "Space theme", but the earlier Rock Raiders theme has often been kind of a stumper for me. Even then, there are far fewer transparent/translucent elements in Rock Raiders, in comparison to many other Space-oriented themes (like Spyrius, Unitron or Exploriens as examples), as well as the early waves of Star Wars to an extent. In some cases there, the only transparent/translucent elements were the lightsaber blades.
Like you said, to each their own preference on how to class them, but, if you’re on a journey through space in search of rare minerals to mine, these guys have better resume than the average miner, chuckles. These guys are very diverse in what they do and, once they’re back on course where they need to be, they’ll be right back to exploring other planets and harvesting as much data as possible! They are space miners! 😁
This type of discussion is quite interesting to me, though I have way too many thoughts to type in a simple comment... I have a strong personal reference point, albeit anecdotal, from having lived through the introduction of most of the defining themes and seeing how they interacted with existing collection through the 90's and early 2000's. Themes from the 70's and 80's were quite precisely defined, especially for Town/City and the Trifecta of Space, Castle, and Pirates. It was during the 90's that many of these definitions became harder to apply with specific new themes that could interact with the old themes but in new ways. Instead of having precise definition, themes seemed to have their own identity apart from a whole-world inclusion while still having references and tie-ins to adjacent themes (whether or not for lore or just marketing), so they could play well on their own if it was all the child had but could also mesh well with existing collections from previous themes. In general, the trouble is that there are different reasons that themes could be related, and a chosen taxonomy depends on personal preference or focal points. I tended (and still tend) to categorize themes primarily on geographical/cultural and technological basis the most strongly, so Ninja and Vikings are Castle subthemes while Ninjago or Chima are not. Nexo Nights is clearly a fantasy version of a Space theme due to these bases. This also sets Rock Raiders as a Space subtheme (due to futuristic technology and intergalactic locations) and Power Miners as a City subtheme (due to roughly similar technology to real-world modern technology and taking place on Earth, though in a fantasy setting). LEGO in Space fits these distinctions as well, since technology is either current or only slightly futuristic and they have direct reference to being missions from Earth rather than fully established worlds on foreign planets or in other galaxies. Life on Mars is still a line-blur since the human element is a subtheme of "LEGO in Space" while the Martians are a clear fit as a futuristic/sci-fi "Space" subtheme. If the current City "Space" (LEGO in Space) subtheme sets included advanced alien technology and vehicles, it would have the same line blur in my mind. Since it only has a slight exploration of the idea "what if we find life in space" rather than a full dive into the concept, it is still a "LEGO in Space" subtheme in my opinion. Now, a whole new theme category for underground would be quite an expansion on the unique place Rock Raiders holds between other typical themes!
I think it has to do with a mix of things, like looking at the sets at face, looks like a older version of power miners and that to a lot of people, especially for people born after rock raiders end but grew up with power miners might think, “oh it must take place on earth like power miners” but also not a lot of people aware of the context to Rock raiders in the video game and that it takes place in space. One reason I can think of is, I think the majority of Lego fan aren’t aware of the string of games that released around the late 90s or think of the string of newer Lego games in the mid 2000s like Lego Batman and Star Wars than the ones that came before and especially for rock Raiders where it’s one of the niche ones out of the ones that came out in the late 90s I mean, some people heard of rock Raiders the game, but have they played it or seen Contant from it probably not, so a lot of Lego fans think it’s not a space theme just cause of face value and there not a lot of giveaways either to say confidently to someone looking at the theme at face value that it’s a space theme like the small hover vehicle you mentioned I’m sure for some people seen it face value not thinking it’s a space theme will just think of that as they’re just trying something different
This is a good point! Many LEGO fans these days were born into a post-Power Miners world, and that retroactively casts Rock Raiders in a different light, indeed. 👍
wow! magma mites is a fascinating new reveal. if I still had any of my old power miners lava monster figures I'd definitely be tempted to make my own knockoff magma mite. also, I want to say an old lego book I used to get from the library in the 2000s also called ninja a castle theme. can't confirm that tho
I don’t know what the timeline for Bricklink as a website is, but Ninja has been counted as a Castle sub-theme in official material at least as far back as The LEGO Book from 2009. That same book groups Rock Raiders, Adventures, Power Miners, Western, Time Cruisers, Aqua Raiders/Aquazone, Alpha Team/Agents, Exo-Force and even Racers, Ferrari & Sports for some reason under “Adventures”, treating them as sub-themes to that. This was probably done to make the book more accessible to children (looking through it again it’s dominated with two-page images of sets that would have been concurrently available when the book was still in print, methinks there’s a motive behind that), so that book probably doesn’t hold up as a classification standard. Though Pirates has its own chapter, as it should. Standing Small, the minifig-focused book sold alongside 2009’s The LEGO Book, places Rock Raiders and Power Miners together as “Underground”, though it does make mention of the Rock Raiders being stranded on Planet U while the Power Miners are inside of Earth.
Like I said before, I've always thought of it as one of those themes that exists within the umbrella of Space but focuses on surface vehicles and atmospheric craft rather than ships. Insectoids could be considered very similar in this regard, as that theme was mostly surface vehicles and atmospheric craft as well with the theme only really having one actual ship, that being the Celestial Stinger. I'm pretty sure M-Tron had a bunch of surface vehicles as well, Robo-Force was all mechs yet was directly marketed as a space theme, and Unitron was most well-known for its monorail set. As for classifying Ninja as a Castle subtheme, I personally do so because the theme 100% fits the general format of a castle theme. After all, Flying Ninja's Fortress, despite the name, _is_ a castle, just one of Japanese design rather than Medieval European. It has the secondary fortress and outpost sets, Samurai take up the role the knights of previous castle themes, and there's two battling factions like any other castle theme. So, if the shoe fits...
I put it this way rock Raiders is a space theme because they have a giant space barge that they showed up to on a planet to do mining operations so even though we only see the side where they're actually mining and not the massive ship they still have a spaceship and they still use it to get around to different planets
Wait what? Ninja and vikings are not considered castle themes by bricklink. That's more of being lumped in as a historical theme on places like eurobricks. Also if alien conquest counts as space rock raiders does too.
Thanks for the fact check!! I got it mixed up with *Brickset* which DOES categorize Ninja as a Castle subtheme. The point still stands if you swap the names around. 👍
@@RRSlugger Ahh, that would do it. Also going to the topic of the video. I think this makes Rock Raiders "Retroactive Space", In a sense where when it originally released its easy to say its not space, but as time goes on its harder to justify it. From what was said about the magma mites, I think the best option for their vehicles would be something similar to the armorizers seen in transformers legacy united. Would have loved to see a lego space dwarf faction if this theme persisted.
I have to disagree on Mars Mission for one specific reason: the space shuttle included in the Astro base. There is obvious space travel going on even without considering the lore. You could less significantly make the same point for the alien flying saucers, too. (Ironic, given they’re Martian natives) The only way out of categorizing mars mission as space is by categorizing it as launch command, but Mars Mission is a serious departure from Lego Town, the home theme of Launch Command.
no that is transparent, not translucent. translucent just means light passes through, transparent is when you can clearly see whats on the other side, transparent neon orange, is correct.
Well I might as well through my hat into the ring and say that Fright Knights is technically a space theme because it was shown to take place on a volcanic planet in one of the Lego UFO commercials. They’re also shown interacting with the aliens from UFO in a lot of marketing material. Fright Knights also has a few little flying machine sets that look very similar to the little flyers you pointed out in this video. So it’s technically a space theme.
I can see the Magma Mites commercials in my head. The theme song would be like MAG-MA MITES! ( D - F - G all evenly spaced). I can smell how extreme that theme would’ve been.
For me, this raises the question of whether Blacktron and Rock Raiders could bump into each other. For me, that wouldn’t quite click. So I consider it mostly it’s own thing
Honestly, I can buy that idea of Space, “Underground” and “Underwater” being sibling themes under a general “sci-fi” banner. It’s like Castle, Pirates, and Western being under a “historical fiction” banner, or the various rebrandings and addons of Town being under a “semi-realistic modern life” banner.
*If A implies B, B does not necessarily imply A.* "My cat is grey," does not imply that all cats are grey, nor that all grey things are cats. Sure, a Space set doesn't necessarily have to go to space, but if it does go to space, that's Space. Sure, it wasn't originally intended to be a Space theme, but it became one in the show. Sure, some people might not consider the show lore to be relevant, but those people are wrong. It's in space now. It's Space. (imho)
Back in 2010 my dad bought so many lego sets for 100 dollars. He bought rock raiders hq, pharaoh's Forbidden Ruins, Wolfpack castle, ninja theme in the 90s, Fort Legoredo, Dragons den and some more castle themes and a Dino island set. This is not all the sets but these are just some of them.
Power Miners fit the Underground supertheme, right? Even if it’s officially just Rock Raiders in there, I feel like the spiritual sequel/successor should be too! And I’d love to learn more about Magma Mites, that sounds fun!
Transparent means you can see through it. Translucent just means light passes through it. Translucent pieces can be opaque. Since you can clearly see through transparent neon orange, it is indeed transparent
Honestly I think the broader overarching category of themes I put Rock Raiders in is "lego themes with distinctive unique characters", because that's really what pops out to me about the theme, and there's not many themes that go that far. Adventurers, Life on Mars, Alpha Team, Exo-Force, and Lego's Atlantis are some of the big ones that really go all the way, but it can get blurrier with like Knight's Kingdom or the Extreme Team, and obviously Bionicle and Ninjago go even further. Classic Lego is defined by genericism, everybody has the same kind of blank smile, and it was up to the audience to interpret and project who they were. As things developed, Lego developed a lot of in-house fiction to help support their newer characters in the 90s and 00s, but then the rise of licensed themes largely supplanted that. So now even though modern Lego faces are much more complex, the company doesn't use them to imply specific characters when they're in an in-house theme like City.
I think both Ninja and Vikings belong under the castle umbrella. But sure, Ninja being set sometime after 1543 is kind of inbetween Pirates and Castle themes time-wise.
I havea great idea for the next summer of slug, the next community theme will be Magma Mites! or a wide LEGO Underground community theme. although you seemed like you also had the idea at the end of the video.
I have no clue why alien conquest is apparently space but rock raiders isn’t. Alien conquest takes place on earth, rock raiders takes place in space. Seems pretty clear cut to me haha
I think Ultra Agents also falls into the same debate as Rock Raiders since both could be considered either LEGO Space Themes or LEGO Sci-fi Themes. Both themes referenced space travel existing in their lore and have a sci-fi aesthetic... ...but at the same time nither really has a specific "Spaceship/Starship" set made specifically for going into space, there are a few sets that look like they could operate in space and one could even say some of the helicopter type vehicles count because M-Tron had one... ...at the same time not every space theme is actually about space travel, Alien Conquest seems to mostly take place on earth with the only space aspect being the presense of aliens... ...which begs two questions: 1. Does LEGO Space even have to be in space at all to be considered "Space" 2. Should there be a LEGO Sci-fi Theme Category for themes that have futuristic aspects but have little or nothing to do with space specifically?
@@RRSlugger If I was going to create a LEGO Sci-fi theme category I'd probably consider the connection universe in the LEGO Club Comics from the first half of the 2010s a good starting point... The comics released at the end of 2011 and 2012 connected various themes into an overarching storyline narrative, as a result themes as different as Monster Fighters, Dino, Atlantis and a few other themes existed in the same universe as Galaxy Squad and Alien Conquest... Lore wise they can all be considered part of a LEGO Sci-fi theme because they have futuristic tech and are inhabited by fantastical beings but not all of them have anything to do with space so they wouldn't be LEGO Space even though they would be connected to Space by lore.
I understand the confusion of the themes of the 90s. 1998 is the end of the 3/4 classic themes. Castle ended with the Fright Knights in 1998. The Ninja Theme has similar set numbers as the Castle sets, but had not the same banner als Castle. Knights Kingdom is not a part of Castle. That was it's own series. Pirates theme is obvious and ended with Imperial Armada. In North America were more sets made for this line. Space ended with Insectoids. Rock Raiders is indeed a theme that is in Space. But it is not a part of Space theme that ended in 1998. The same can be said of Town. De Town banner was dropped and it was labeled as City. While Brickset and Bricklink do not recognize that and is labeled as Town (or Classic Town). To me, Brickset and Bricklink made some errors when they made the databases. My own collection of catalogs is more accurate (sometimes).
QUICK CORRECTION! In the video, I say that *Bricklink* categorizes "Ninja" as a Castle subtheme, but I got it mixed up with *Brickset* - the point still stands though, as long as you swap the names around. Sorry about that folks!
Have you searched for the catalogues she mentioned about the upcoming Underground-sets?
I definitely noticed that since I have spent significant hours on BrickLink and categorizing my own collection records.
BrickLink does not categorize Ninja as a Castle subtheme, though I think it makes sense to categorize "historical" themes according to technology available, which counts Ninja as a late-era Castle subtheme (swords, castles, and horses albeit with the introduction of muskets/arquebus) even though the literal historical references were from different eras across the world. This also applies to Vikings and Fantasy Era, as the technology level is roughly the same, although incorporating fantasy/mythology rather than strictly historical reference.
This method would also count Rock Raiders as a Space subtheme with advanced scanning, teleportation, hover/propulsion, and lasers likely well advanced from our current level of technology.
@@jays8710 Something like that was found in a Danish catalogue, but it was more so referring to Rock Raiders itself as "Underground", not a subtheme of the same name.
I kept getting Ninjago stuff recommended to me until I put the castle in the search bar, I think that was for eBay. That theme has like 4-5 castles in it and factions so I can see it. Why do all my favorite themes have unobtainable minifigure “heroes”?! Ughhhhh!!!!
"Transparent neon ORANGE"; well, I've been calling it 'RED' for like 35 years or so. 🙂
Objection! Rock Raiders has a space between rock and raiders. 🤔 So where do we draw the line now
I think it must have the word "space" in it, such as "Classic Space" and "Space Police 3"
So Blacktron, Ice Planet, and Power Miners are all not space themes
@@headcrabking9054objection! Ice Planet & Rock Raiders have A Space in their names. 🤔 so where can we truly draw the line?
@@ZannyAisling they have space the *type character* not space the *word*
Hold It! With that logic, isn’t every lego theme a space theme?
@@piingoo nah, Znap! is still not a space theme, neither is Mtron
Technically, Bionicle is a Lego Space theme, cause everything happened inside a giant robot shaped spaceship, and the time it wasn't on the Great Spirit Robot is when we dealt with alien worlds. Heck, Hero Factory is a theme with a Galaxy spanning police force, not that different from Space Police line.
I ALWAYS HEAVLY headcanon that HF also takes place in Lego space universe if you count some of the original 2010 ads which featured humans
Ninjago is also a space theme then since one episode from season 3 takes place in space!
Join me soon for my Brick Nerd article, "Power Miners is a LEGO Underground theme"
Or is it a Rock Raiders theme? 😅
Wait hold on you're actually on to something here
Honestly, I subscribe to that idea. I mean, even if both don't take place in the SAME underground, the aesthetics are the exact same. Which also goes for "Space" sets.
Power miners is part of City theme. It's even said in comics xD
The response of Suz shows that licenses have indeed pushed out in house themes and in particular space and castle.
And eventually pushed out alternate build ideas in all but the creator series.
Well just looking though the lastest Lego catalogue proves that. With exception to City and Friends, it's all licenced themes. A real shame if you ask me.
Why make more Space or other Sci-Fi themes when you have access to Star Wars; the most successful sci-fi brand of all time? Why continue to make Castle when you have access to Lord of the Rings? Why continue to make Adventurers when you have access to Indiana Jones? Why continue to make Pirates when even Pirates of the Caribbean couldn’t draw interest?
The only in-house IP they really can’t replace are City (any replacement I could think of is aimed more towards a Duplo age range), Ninjago (there’s nothing to replace it with), and Monkey Kid if that’s still around (because the Chinese would be mad).
The more I learn, the more I realize that I was there for Lego’s last great in-house brand (Bionicle). And that makes me sad, honestly. If they didn’t relegate original IP to overpriced collector’s items and insidiously marketed “Gift With Purchase” items, I’d gladly support it.
@DragonxFlutter Yeah I was only around for the end of the original themes Rock Raiders, Adventure, knights kingdom, Castle, bionicles etc.
But the thing is variety is the space of life which you get with new space sub themes every few years. There isn't much variety with star wars except for when they used to do EU stuff I guess.
Isn't everyone sick of Star Wars anyway.
I just long for the days of fun Lego themes that embraced the fun and charm of Lego...
i want my coloured ships back... :(
I feel like the "Magma Mites" idea might have inspired Power Miners's Lava Monster focused wave. Neat to know the idea for that goes that far back
I'd like to believe that too! They certainly sound similar!
Bur now, does Power Miner categorises as being part of the Rock Raiders theme? Underground theme? Or Space theme?
@@SuperSecretBricks Power Miners, unlike Rock Raiders, does take place on earth, lore wise, so it would be classified as either Underground or if you really want to stretch it, an offshoot of City.
Definitely not Space tho
My thought exacly. And from what I had seen, not the first time LEGO did something like this.
All tho the examples I'm using are of "finished sets" rather than "ideas for later".
Ex The bike in the set "Swamp raid" from LEGO Agents was originally desighned for Mars Mission.
Or an transforming mech "Undersea Explorer" from LEGO Atlantis was originally intented for Power Miners.
the same thought occurred to me initially, but on further thought, I could also see magma just being a sort of natural escalation of any sort of underground setting- after all, you're bound to run into the stuff if you dig deep enough
theorycrafting more "Underground" set concepts could be a wonderful idea for the Summer Of Slug 2025 community theme
YESSSS just came here to suggest that! I would be all over that. I just recently already made up my own mining faction of Aquazone, basically underwater Rock Raiders. I'd absolutely submit that moc as part of it.
@@Thinginatornot to be rude but doesn't something like this allready exist ? That been the original Aqua Raiders theme ? (Or Aquanots for that matter, since their mission was to mine chrome crystals)
Could you elaborate what did you mean with "Underwater Rock Raiders".
Rock Raiders travels through space and mines foreign planets. They experience foreign aliens (rock monsters) if Mars Mission is space, then so is Rock Raiders
I think the most divisive thing for Rock Raiders is really just the marketing. Roboforce promo and magazine art features the robots clearly operating on a Traditional LEGO Space Environment: a bizarre, rocky alien world likely lacking an atmosphere with Tron Lines TM in the sky and the like. That, to me, is the DEFINITIVE LEGO Space Aesthetic: even more than the builds, its how LEGO presented them. (Also, for Roboforce, it was heavily marketed in tandem with UFO, with some promo material using the same Green Planet background that UFO featured, suggesting they were on the same planet. I believe Insectoids used this backdrop too, which tracks given Insectoids and UFO are both supposed to represent two species from the same planet).
This is why Aquazone doesn't often get called a space theme, and its why more "low key" themes that clearly involve outer space aren't considered space themes either sometimes, such as Life on Mars, as its more an extension of Town-Spaceport (something you brought up in your overview of the 2024 Space video). Similarly, all Rock Raiders marketing material features only caves! Even the Hover Scout, while surely in the same design language as small space-faring craft in previous themes, is shown to be used to float around through caves, so I think that's why people may not see Rock Raiders as a Space theme.
Hell for the longest time I didn't even know Rock Raiders had a mother ship, because surely if such a thing was important it would've made into a set, right? Instead the "mothership" set for Rock Raiders is their big VTOL propeller driven vehicle. And maybe that's the OTHER thing, aesthetics of the builds. Roll cages and Propellers don't suggest Space-faring utility. In other Space Themes that feature some sort of terrain excavation, you find that flying craft are very versatile, being presented as both atmospheric craft, ground effect vehicles, and spacecraft all at once. With Rock Raiders, you don't have that, much like how all the vehicles in Aquazone are clearly submarines and couldn't be used for anything else but that. It's weird, subconscious ideas like this that i think affect people the most I believe.
HOWEVER, PERSONALLY, Rock Raiders is at least Space-Adjacent. If Roboforce can count, Rock Raiders can count, and Aquazone is part of that club too I think. On a similar note, Ninja is absolutely a castle theme. It features Castles! I think the qualifier there is a lot less ambiguous haha.
Still undecided on Life on Mars, though. I kind of like it as more of a 20 Minutes into the Future Lego Town sort of theme, but I can't really argue against why people would consider it a part of space lol. I also think UFO is in an interesting position when compared against its spiritual successor Alien Conquest. Alien Conquest is clearly depicting a B-movie style invasion of a Ambiguously Contemporary Earth, where as UFO is clearly not - but a lot of UFO's tv commercials (and the name UFO) and design language of them having flying saucers certainly suggests they were meant to be this.... but instead they just fight the Roboforce lol.
Well put! I can't say you're wrong about any of this. 😊
@@RRSlugger I think ultimately it’s easier to look at this stuff as a spectrum rather than a hard yes or no. Stuff like Nexo Knights blurred lines between Castle and Space after all, and themes like Mars Mission blur between Town Space and Classic Space.
tron lines!!!!
@@Dreadwolf3155 hecc yeah dood, they were technically only around from Futuron until I think Exploriens (or whatever came before them) but I consider the Tron Lines across the skyline a key aesthetic element of LEGO Space lol
Lego taxonomy is becoming a legitimate field of study and I’m all here for it
As far as I'm concerned, I feel like any conversations about "does (BLANK) count as (BLANK)" eventually fall apart for the same reasons that "is a hot dog a sandwich" conversations eventually fall apart: categorizations are tools for helping to convey information, and as such aren't meant to consider every single literal ramification of their divisions.
Calling any one theme or another "LEGO space" or "LEGO castle" is mostly shorthand as a way for all of us to quickly understand what the other peraon is talking about due to our generalized expectations of what each entails, and arguing over edge cases or oddities misses the point of why we try to have categories at all. And this is especially true of terminology that exists mostly among fans and the creators had little to no involvement in popularising.
Maybe this isn't the answer that anyone else is looking for, but I've been thinking a lot about these kinds of arguments in general this year and so I felt like the perspective I've come to would be more interesting to ahare than getting into heated debates over semantics with other people would.
Hot Dog is indeed a sandwich. An oddly filled sandwich, but a sandwich non-the-less.
Well said! While this is definitely something I find interesting to ponder, it's not a hill worth dying on. 👍
Exactly, this entire video reminded me of Wittgenstein for this reason. He argued that we cannot pinpoint the meaning of any word to a set of properties or anything like that. What, for example, belongs to our concept of a "game"? Whatever you think is the essence of games, there is always a counter example. I really like his notion of "family resemblance" in this context. We sometimes immediately see that people are siblings by their facial characteristics (e.g., a certain shape of the nose, eyes or ears) and yet these characteristics cannot be exhaustively formalized. Well then, the same must hold for our Lego space and Lego castle themes. Simply put, Rock Raiders is at least space-esque, and it depends on our purposes whether it is part of space or not!
It's strange how one can suddenly start philosophizing about Lego haha, perhaps it's time for a new discipline
I've got it!
Sci-fi - Lego Space
Fantasy - Lego Castle
Slightly more than Modern - Lego City
All Lego themes can be boiled down these three categories. Dino Attack is Lego City, Chima is Lego Castle, and Nexo Knights is, of course, Lego Space.
(This is a joke.)
Actually, this almost makes it sound like the decision to step away from Lego Space because of Star Wars was a part of the licensing agreement. I wonder if that's still relevant today?
Joke it may be, but your reasoning is solid enough to actually serve as a basis for categorization.
In terms of the licensing agreement, I don’t think so. At least not directly. Every time Lego tried to do a sci-fi theme after acquiring the Star Wars license, it just didn’t have the pull to attract buyers. Why would a random kid want something as generic sounding as “space police” when he could beg his parents for a much more recognizable Star Wars set instead? At the end of the day, it’s all brand recognition. Why waste marketing money trying to compete with yourself when you could put that money into an IP that practically does the advertising for you?
not sure whether it's more cursed that this puts Adventurers in Castle or that it places Life on Mars into City. Both are second place to Bionicle is Lego Space as a conclusion of this categorization. I love it.
I love how you find any excuse to talk about Rock Raiders (and I'm absolutely here for it)
Watching these videos over the last few months has reinvigorated my love of Lego, and now I have a complete set of the Rock Raiders theme. Slugger's content has cost me more than any other TH-cam channel.
No matter which way you drill into the brickonium ore, Rock Raiders is still awesome, and deserves all the praise it gets.
Darn I need to rebuild my Loader Dozer, but Rocky the Rock Monster is kinda enjoying chilling on top of Grand Emporium with a pair of chrome drills, so perhaps not.
Man, I love RR Slugger videos.
In an alternate timeline, Lego had an ongoing licensed comic book with a writing team that was left adrift and had to come up with their own ongoing stories and lore and kept adding the new sets into the stories, they had a flourishing internal lore and storylines, where Rock Raiders and AquaZone traveled across planets with Mtron and Exploriens to defend from evil aliens and robots and so on. TH-camrs make three hour video essays explaining the insane continuity and time travel retcons of this comic. Fans often make MOCs of their personal Legosonas. In this alternate timeline, there's no Sonic comic book.
1:15 That is transparent though as you can see things through it. If it were translucent it would let let light but not distinct shapes through
I think it's debatable, especially with colours like trans dark blue and trans green. Often times you can't clearly see what's on the other side.
@@RRSlugger It really isn't debatable. I looked up those Lego colors and the bricks were definitively transparent. It doesn't matter if the brick shape causes distortions or if the color is dark. "transparent" and "translucent" are well-defined material properties -- if the light is not being diffused (which would specifically make the image look blurred), it's definitively not translucent.
@@klikkolee Hmm, I certainly could be wrong about that! Perhaps a better example of the translucent effect would be one of those trans neon orange boulders from Life On Mars. Maybe I should have put a picture of that up instead?
It’s very interesting - I’ve received all sorts of comments on this topic, from folks like yourself telling me it *is* transparent, to folks telling me that “trans neon orange” is *supposed* to stand for translucent neon orange, not transparent neon orange. 😅
@@RRSlugger It looks like there's a fine texture on the boulders.This kind of texture will from a practical standpoint diffuse light, so it's reasonable to refer to the part as a whole as translucent, but the material itself appears to still be transparent. I see a similar thing with images of trans neon orange slopes -- when viewing through the textured face, the part appears translucent, but looking only through non-textured faces shows that the material is transparent.
Much like the unique alien mini figure and slimy slug prototypes, it's hard not to mourn the possibility of an entire series based around various underground factions. Imagine if the rock monsters got their own theme, or a blacktron style rival mining crew theme
Lego fans: "Where are the Lego Space themes?"
The LEGO Group: "My siblings in Mata Nui, the Lego Space themes never left. It's called Lego Star Wars."
Seems like it is a LEGO Space theme, but they branded it as underground to get around restrictions imposed from picking up the Ster Wars license 😅
Another possibility!
Fun fact: the word "factoid" originally meant "an inaccurate statement or statistic believed to be true because of broad repetition, especially if cited in the media". But, because of broad repetition, has come to mean a small fact.
Dang... Well that's ironic! 😅
You're my favourite Lego youtuber, Slugger. Thanks for your hard work and detail orientation!
Thank you! ❤️
1:15 that is clearly transparent -- somewhat literally; if you can clearly see an image through it, it's transparent, regardless of color. A translucent material blurs the image due to diffusing the light as it passes through. This was taught in school for me, and it's also consistent with the first definition of "translucent" I got when looking up the word: "Transmitting light but causing sufficient diffusion to prevent perception of distinct images"
Foolish Slugger. EVERY Lego theme is a space theme, for everything happens within space!
Rock raiders, my favorite space theme
Very cool. I love the shot of Jet in an explorean space suit. My head canon was always that the LMS Explorer was a later generation of explorean ship. Personally I consider Rock Raiders to be a space theme, and can see the case for Aquazone. Ninja and vikings are also castle themes and Pharaoh's Quest is an adventurers theme.
3:40 You got me there!
Considering the opening cinematic of both versions of the video game , i always considered Raiders a space theme and always thought it a shame we never got an LMS Explorer.
Oh my god! I did a physical double-take when I saw pictures from James Gurney’s Dinotopia series at 6:02 !!! That book: ‘The World Beneath’ was released in 1995, and I grew up reading that book over and over as a 7yr old kid. I had no idea it influenced the Lego RR series but knowing that it does makes so much sense to me!!! I used to spend hours pouring over those paintings of underground caverns, only for TLG to release an ‘underground’ theme only a few years later that I absolutely loved that was influenced by it 🤯!Truly blew my mind. Thank you RR Slugger for showing me this. I only wish I knew what book it was you had on screen there?
Right?? I was equally mind blown to learn that the science fiction works Rock Raiders was based on were from this book called Dinotopia, haha! I had the same revelation, but in reverse. 😆
The book I was showing off is called "The Ultimate LEGO Book", by DK publishing, 2000. It's wonderful and gives a great look into LEGO at the time!
@@RRSlugger- thanks for letting me know the name of the book. Very kind of you.
The connection between RR and Dinotopia seems odd until you realise that that particular Dinotopia book shown in those two pictures is VERY heavily influenced by 'Journey to The Centre of The Earth' by Jules Verne. It's interesting to think that maybe at some point 'Underground' might have been a Jules Verne inspired adventure series. "High Adventure, Underground" indeed!! 😁
I want to believe you, but this coming from the Slugger of Rock Raiders, this feels like Rock-Raided propaganda
I’ve actually watched it now and the Slug is right. Listen to the Slug, everybody
@@elithornton5641 Hahahaha ❤
Rock Raiders is the hagfish of Lego space themes
clints reptiles enjoyer i see xD
7:50 next summer of slug prompt? Just an idea :3
Thanks to you I bought recently two Rock Raiders sets and constructed one by my own. Thank you, what a fun series!
I never thought of Rock Raiders as a “Space” theme, but I didn’t know any of the lore at the time. It was obviously in the future like Space, but for all I knew, this was all going on under Earth’s crust.
Same could be said for Aquazone. I assumed at the time it was Earth in the distant future after humans set up colonies under the ocean.
You should do a whole series on the underground concept art and maybe attempt to build some of the models. Seems right up your alley
Is it April 2025 already!? Wow I didn't think I slept for that long last night.
Oooh! I love it when new details come to light about internal development, fascinating.
Side note, as Lego colours have internal numbers who wants to start naming their colours that way, goodbye bright blueish green, hello colour 107! (Source the 2020 modular bookshop)
7:33 is that where the slug came from?
Thanks to you, I decided to buy the Chrome Crusher! Possibly my favourite RR vehicle. I have it now on my workbench.
As someone who doesn’t know much about Rock Raiders, i’d say it makes more sense for Rock Raiders to be a space theme instead of not being a space theme.
The alien like rock monster looking guys, the futuristic equipment and aesthetics and not to mention the lore itself setting it in a distant galaxy!
I'm all for more Underground, in Lego, on this channel, in general... Also, that squid alien looks very dapper with his little bowler hat.
Rock Raiders was one of three LEGO themes with the "Raiders" suffix, the others include the LEGO Aquazone subtheme Aquaraiders (1997) and the standalone LEGO Aqua Raiders theme (2007).
Okay, even if it would be considered Underground instead of Space...
Because due to Star Wars, Underground were meant to replace Space, it wouldn't be a different theme as much as evolution of it. If Space themes were to be replaced with Sci-Fi esque Underground themes focusing on singular zones and exp-loration of them, I can guarantee that most fans would most likely consider them Space anyways. After all, by that point we would already have Ice Planet and Aquazone as space themes, without Space proper Underground would become a new Space.
So in a sense, it doesn't matter if Lego doesn't view RR as space theme if RR was meant to create a substitute to fill the same niche that Space filled.
My thoughts exactly! ❤
Roboforce does have a couple space ships! the heads of the robots detach to be stand-alone flyers. great content, as always!
I find the need within our community to taxa LEGO themes fascinating. It speaks volumes about our collective interest in LEGO's history and the plenty of ways past design languages have informed subsequent LEGO themes and specific sets. I am glad LEGO is starting to take this part of our community more seriously and hope they bring along more interesting projects with direct connections to their own history. I yearn for more themes and sets that exemplify the design philosophy they had in the 90s: Rock Raiders, Time Twisters, Paradisa, Adventurers, you call it!
I'd be here for a series of MOCs exploring the Underground World filled with factions with alliterative names. Rock Raiders, Magma Mites, Tunnel Terrors, Borehole Brigade, Crystal Company, things like that.
If it’s got either aliens, space travel or are just straight up on a different planet, it’s a space theme
Plenty of lego city space sets from 2022 and 2024 feature space travel and outer-planet bases
If we started calling it "Lego Science Fiction" or Lego scifi, everything would be so much easier.
We need a 90's Lego game collection released for modern systems and consoles. Racers 1 and 2, Rock Raiders, Loco, Chess, etc.
Looking at other sets, it would be very easy to picture Lego Pirates as a follow-up to Lego Castle, as that is more-or-less how it worked in real life, and one could even juryrig castles with cannons and pirates for a fun crossover.
In much the same way, Rock Raiders can easily tie into Lego Space, it gives a lot more purpose to *why* they're in space, rather than being there for the sake of space. With Rock Raiders' brutalist/industrial aesthetic (most sets lean more industrial, but on the larger builds and especially the LMS Explorer I think the brutalist stylings make the builds pop) it could even exist as a former era of design, left behind as being too blocky or instead a more modern refutation of the classic ornamentation as they go more utilitarian and solidly built with their designs. Anywhere can fit and in space there's room for anything, even the Time Cruisers.
I’m literally building an Imperial Guard Brigantine MOC right now that has Lion Knight motifs in its décor to imply that the redcoats are descended from the Lion Knights.
Though due to economic restrictions, as bluecoat torsos are cheaper literally half of the crew is made up of them. It would be nice to have an obvious Castle faction to tie the bluecoats to as so far all I can come up with is the Black Falcons, who make me think of the Holy Roman Empire more than France and doesn’t seem a great match…
Oddly enough I never actually considered Rock Raiders as a space theme until this video brought up the thought bubble. For me, it's a given theme, if not an official theme. It does make sense to me that it can be considered a space theme because it takes place in space to an extent. =w=
Regardless though, I love Rock Raiders. >w
New rr slugger upload we're so back chat
7:42 Oh yes! Please do theory craft what Magma Mites, and other subthemes, could have been. I'm intrigued by the idea.
Totally remember this game! Great to be a 90s kid...
The slug is known for many things: but consistency is rarely one of them.
Urge to sing the "Sonic Underground" theme but switch the lyrics to fit Rock Raiders, now that we know LEGO had a project named "LEGO Underground", is... rising!!! D:
I must resist!!!!!
GAH!!!
*_"Rock Raiders formed, New theme awaits!~"_*
*_"Retailers warn of a deadly fate!~"_*
*_"Give up your new theme, separate!~"_*
*_"Bide your time, lie in wait!~"_*
*_"LEGO UNDERGROUND!~ LEGO UNDERGROOOUUNND!!!-"_*
Ever since I saw that one video of Solar Sands calling you the Patrick Bateman of lego, I've not stopped watching.
Haha thank you! ❤️
I never really thought of "Power Miners" (which "Magma Mites" may have been an early concept of) as a "Space theme", but the earlier Rock Raiders theme has often been kind of a stumper for me. Even then, there are far fewer transparent/translucent elements in Rock Raiders, in comparison to many other Space-oriented themes (like Spyrius, Unitron or Exploriens as examples), as well as the early waves of Star Wars to an extent. In some cases there, the only transparent/translucent elements were the lightsaber blades.
Like you said, to each their own preference on how to class them, but, if you’re on a journey through space in search of rare minerals to mine, these guys have better resume than the average miner, chuckles. These guys are very diverse in what they do and, once they’re back on course where they need to be, they’ll be right back to exploring other planets and harvesting as much data as possible! They are space miners! 😁
Slugger: "Many folks out there consider Aquazone to be a part of LEGO Space"
Me: "WELL THEY MUST GO TO SCHOOL!"
I feel like even if it's not technically a space line. it does function as if it is a space line.
I for one do consider AquaZone part of LEGO Space, so as to separate it from more conventional underwater themes like Atlantis and Alpha Team.
This type of discussion is quite interesting to me, though I have way too many thoughts to type in a simple comment...
I have a strong personal reference point, albeit anecdotal, from having lived through the introduction of most of the defining themes and seeing how they interacted with existing collection through the 90's and early 2000's.
Themes from the 70's and 80's were quite precisely defined, especially for Town/City and the Trifecta of Space, Castle, and Pirates. It was during the 90's that many of these definitions became harder to apply with specific new themes that could interact with the old themes but in new ways. Instead of having precise definition, themes seemed to have their own identity apart from a whole-world inclusion while still having references and tie-ins to adjacent themes (whether or not for lore or just marketing), so they could play well on their own if it was all the child had but could also mesh well with existing collections from previous themes.
In general, the trouble is that there are different reasons that themes could be related, and a chosen taxonomy depends on personal preference or focal points.
I tended (and still tend) to categorize themes primarily on geographical/cultural and technological basis the most strongly, so Ninja and Vikings are Castle subthemes while Ninjago or Chima are not. Nexo Nights is clearly a fantasy version of a Space theme due to these bases.
This also sets Rock Raiders as a Space subtheme (due to futuristic technology and intergalactic locations) and Power Miners as a City subtheme (due to roughly similar technology to real-world modern technology and taking place on Earth, though in a fantasy setting). LEGO in Space fits these distinctions as well, since technology is either current or only slightly futuristic and they have direct reference to being missions from Earth rather than fully established worlds on foreign planets or in other galaxies. Life on Mars is still a line-blur since the human element is a subtheme of "LEGO in Space" while the Martians are a clear fit as a futuristic/sci-fi "Space" subtheme. If the current City "Space" (LEGO in Space) subtheme sets included advanced alien technology and vehicles, it would have the same line blur in my mind. Since it only has a slight exploration of the idea "what if we find life in space" rather than a full dive into the concept, it is still a "LEGO in Space" subtheme in my opinion.
Now, a whole new theme category for underground would be quite an expansion on the unique place Rock Raiders holds between other typical themes!
I think it has to do with a mix of things, like looking at the sets at face, looks like a older version of power miners and that to a lot of people, especially for people born after rock raiders end but grew up with power miners might think, “oh it must take place on earth like power miners” but also not a lot of people aware of the context to Rock raiders in the video game and that it takes place in space. One reason I can think of is, I think the majority of Lego fan aren’t aware of the string of games that released around the late 90s or think of the string of newer Lego games in the mid 2000s like Lego Batman and Star Wars than the ones that came before and especially for rock Raiders where it’s one of the niche ones out of the ones that came out in the late 90s I mean, some people heard of rock Raiders the game, but have they played it or seen Contant from it probably not, so a lot of Lego fans think it’s not a space theme just cause of face value and there not a lot of giveaways either to say confidently to someone looking at the theme at face value that it’s a space theme like the small hover vehicle you mentioned I’m sure for some people seen it face value not thinking it’s a space theme will just think of that as they’re just trying something different
This is a good point! Many LEGO fans these days were born into a post-Power Miners world, and that retroactively casts Rock Raiders in a different light, indeed. 👍
Would love to see future videos speculating what each underground sub theme or faction might have looked like. Endless possibilities
Technically everything is in space, so Lego city, castle, pirates, etc. all space themes :^)
Lego pirates also takes place in the space inbetween land and involves vehicles designed for far travels.
Rock Raiders isn't a space theme... it's a lifestyle
Who do you think you are? What gives you the right?
Can't wait to watch this.
Can't wait to reply to this
wow! magma mites is a fascinating new reveal. if I still had any of my old power miners lava monster figures I'd definitely be tempted to make my own knockoff magma mite. also, I want to say an old lego book I used to get from the library in the 2000s also called ninja a castle theme. can't confirm that tho
In the vastness of space exists all lego.
We need to find her and get more information about the second wave!
I don’t know what the timeline for Bricklink as a website is, but Ninja has been counted as a Castle sub-theme in official material at least as far back as The LEGO Book from 2009.
That same book groups Rock Raiders, Adventures, Power Miners, Western, Time Cruisers, Aqua Raiders/Aquazone, Alpha Team/Agents, Exo-Force and even Racers, Ferrari & Sports for some reason under “Adventures”, treating them as sub-themes to that. This was probably done to make the book more accessible to children (looking through it again it’s dominated with two-page images of sets that would have been concurrently available when the book was still in print, methinks there’s a motive behind that), so that book probably doesn’t hold up as a classification standard. Though Pirates has its own chapter, as it should.
Standing Small, the minifig-focused book sold alongside 2009’s The LEGO Book, places Rock Raiders and Power Miners together as “Underground”, though it does make mention of the Rock Raiders being stranded on Planet U while the Power Miners are inside of Earth.
Like I said before, I've always thought of it as one of those themes that exists within the umbrella of Space but focuses on surface vehicles and atmospheric craft rather than ships. Insectoids could be considered very similar in this regard, as that theme was mostly surface vehicles and atmospheric craft as well with the theme only really having one actual ship, that being the Celestial Stinger. I'm pretty sure M-Tron had a bunch of surface vehicles as well, Robo-Force was all mechs yet was directly marketed as a space theme, and Unitron was most well-known for its monorail set.
As for classifying Ninja as a Castle subtheme, I personally do so because the theme 100% fits the general format of a castle theme. After all, Flying Ninja's Fortress, despite the name, _is_ a castle, just one of Japanese design rather than Medieval European. It has the secondary fortress and outpost sets, Samurai take up the role the knights of previous castle themes, and there's two battling factions like any other castle theme. So, if the shoe fits...
I put it this way rock Raiders is a space theme because they have a giant space barge that they showed up to on a planet to do mining operations so even though we only see the side where they're actually mining and not the massive ship they still have a spaceship and they still use it to get around to different planets
Rock Raiders is the first Raiders-style theme.
Wait what? Ninja and vikings are not considered castle themes by bricklink. That's more of being lumped in as a historical theme on places like eurobricks.
Also if alien conquest counts as space rock raiders does too.
Thanks for the fact check!! I got it mixed up with *Brickset* which DOES categorize Ninja as a Castle subtheme. The point still stands if you swap the names around. 👍
@@RRSlugger Ahh, that would do it. Also going to the topic of the video. I think this makes Rock Raiders "Retroactive Space", In a sense where when it originally released its easy to say its not space, but as time goes on its harder to justify it.
From what was said about the magma mites, I think the best option for their vehicles would be something similar to the armorizers seen in transformers legacy united.
Would have loved to see a lego space dwarf faction if this theme persisted.
I have to disagree on Mars Mission for one specific reason: the space shuttle included in the Astro base. There is obvious space travel going on even without considering the lore. You could less significantly make the same point for the alien flying saucers, too. (Ironic, given they’re Martian natives)
The only way out of categorizing mars mission as space is by categorizing it as launch command, but Mars Mission is a serious departure from Lego Town, the home theme of Launch Command.
RR may not be a "Lego Space" theme but it definitely happens in space. The intro to the RR PC game is on a starship lol.
LUGNET, that's a name I haven't heard in a long time. A long time...
no that is transparent, not translucent. translucent just means light passes through, transparent is when you can clearly see whats on the other side, transparent neon orange, is correct.
I think it's debatable, especially with colours like trans dark blue and trans green. Often times you *can't* clearly see what's on the other side.
Well I might as well through my hat into the ring and say that Fright Knights is technically a space theme because it was shown to take place on a volcanic planet in one of the Lego UFO commercials. They’re also shown interacting with the aliens from UFO in a lot of marketing material. Fright Knights also has a few little flying machine sets that look very similar to the little flyers you pointed out in this video.
So it’s technically a space theme.
The way they talk about the planned underground subtheme makes me think about Power Miners
I've always thought of RR as a sort of space spinoff.
I can see the Magma Mites commercials in my head. The theme song would be like MAG-MA MITES! ( D - F - G all evenly spaced). I can smell how extreme that theme would’ve been.
For me, this raises the question of whether Blacktron and Rock Raiders could bump into each other. For me, that wouldn’t quite click. So I consider it mostly it’s own thing
Honestly, I can buy that idea of Space, “Underground” and “Underwater” being sibling themes under a general “sci-fi” banner. It’s like Castle, Pirates, and Western being under a “historical fiction” banner, or the various rebrandings and addons of Town being under a “semi-realistic modern life” banner.
*If A implies B, B does not necessarily imply A.* "My cat is grey," does not imply that all cats are grey, nor that all grey things are cats.
Sure, a Space set doesn't necessarily have to go to space, but if it does go to space, that's Space.
Sure, it wasn't originally intended to be a Space theme, but it became one in the show.
Sure, some people might not consider the show lore to be relevant, but those people are wrong. It's in space now. It's Space. (imho)
I like it! Makes sense to me. 😊
Back in 2010 my dad bought so many lego sets for 100 dollars. He bought rock raiders hq, pharaoh's Forbidden Ruins, Wolfpack castle, ninja theme in the 90s, Fort Legoredo, Dragons den and some more castle themes and a Dino island set. This is not all the sets but these are just some of them.
Power Miners fit the Underground supertheme, right? Even if it’s officially just Rock Raiders in there, I feel like the spiritual sequel/successor should be too! And I’d love to learn more about Magma Mites, that sounds fun!
Magma mites sounds like power miners wave 3
A custom “underground” subtheme MOC series would be awesome! I would watch
I miss the summer of slugg
Transparent means you can see through it. Translucent just means light passes through it. Translucent pieces can be opaque. Since you can clearly see through transparent neon orange, it is indeed transparent
I think it's definitely debatable with some "transparent" LEGO colours though - trans dark blue and trans green come to mind...
Honestly I think the broader overarching category of themes I put Rock Raiders in is "lego themes with distinctive unique characters", because that's really what pops out to me about the theme, and there's not many themes that go that far. Adventurers, Life on Mars, Alpha Team, Exo-Force, and Lego's Atlantis are some of the big ones that really go all the way, but it can get blurrier with like Knight's Kingdom or the Extreme Team, and obviously Bionicle and Ninjago go even further.
Classic Lego is defined by genericism, everybody has the same kind of blank smile, and it was up to the audience to interpret and project who they were. As things developed, Lego developed a lot of in-house fiction to help support their newer characters in the 90s and 00s, but then the rise of licensed themes largely supplanted that. So now even though modern Lego faces are much more complex, the company doesn't use them to imply specific characters when they're in an in-house theme like City.
It would have been super interesting to see what lego did with an underground banner with different factions
This, 100%!
I think both Ninja and Vikings belong under the castle umbrella. But sure, Ninja being set sometime after 1543 is kind of inbetween Pirates and Castle themes time-wise.
I havea great idea for the next summer of slug, the next community theme will be Magma Mites!
or a wide LEGO Underground community theme.
although you seemed like you also had the idea at the end of the video.
I have no clue why alien conquest is apparently space but rock raiders isn’t. Alien conquest takes place on earth, rock raiders takes place in space. Seems pretty clear cut to me haha
I think Ultra Agents also falls into the same debate as Rock Raiders since both could be considered either LEGO Space Themes or LEGO Sci-fi Themes.
Both themes referenced space travel existing in their lore and have a sci-fi aesthetic...
...but at the same time nither really has a specific "Spaceship/Starship" set made specifically for going into space, there are a few sets that look like they could operate in space and one could even say some of the helicopter type vehicles count because M-Tron had one...
...at the same time not every space theme is actually about space travel, Alien Conquest seems to mostly take place on earth with the only space aspect being the presense of aliens...
...which begs two questions:
1. Does LEGO Space even have to be in space at all to be considered "Space"
2. Should there be a LEGO Sci-fi Theme Category for themes that have futuristic aspects but have little or nothing to do with space specifically?
That second question in particular is worth pondering, for sure! Does sci fi = space? 🤔
@@RRSlugger If I was going to create a LEGO Sci-fi theme category I'd probably consider the connection universe in the LEGO Club Comics from the first half of the 2010s a good starting point...
The comics released at the end of 2011 and 2012 connected various themes into an overarching storyline narrative, as a result themes as different as Monster Fighters, Dino, Atlantis and a few other themes existed in the same universe as Galaxy Squad and Alien Conquest...
Lore wise they can all be considered part of a LEGO Sci-fi theme because they have futuristic tech and are inhabited by fantastical beings but not all of them have anything to do with space so they wouldn't be LEGO Space even though they would be connected to Space by lore.
I understand the confusion of the themes of the 90s.
1998 is the end of the 3/4 classic themes.
Castle ended with the Fright Knights in 1998.
The Ninja Theme has similar set numbers as the Castle sets, but had not the same banner als Castle.
Knights Kingdom is not a part of Castle. That was it's own series.
Pirates theme is obvious and ended with Imperial Armada. In North America were more sets made for this line.
Space ended with Insectoids. Rock Raiders is indeed a theme that is in Space. But it is not a part of Space theme that ended in 1998.
The same can be said of Town. De Town banner was dropped and it was labeled as City.
While Brickset and Bricklink do not recognize that and is labeled as Town (or Classic Town).
To me, Brickset and Bricklink made some errors when they made the databases.
My own collection of catalogs is more accurate (sometimes).