I think a war is a war a genocide is when the population is being eradicated. But when Gaza population growth is significantly high every year, it shows to any normal unbiased person. That this is not genocide, its just dumb people using a word they don't understand 🙄 😅
That is not an argument, and I use the same sentence in reverse on you. The Jews have not tried to kill all the Palestinians,so not genocide. If Hamas hide under the noses of there own people, then civilians will be killed.
So you do not want do define the term 'genocide' but insist, there is no 'genocide' in gaza. We have a definition of the term 'Human' and the US politicians do not match to that.
@WynonaRoder I was going to call.him potatoe or spud but was worried I'd be accused of racism. So at least dumpling has the same shape but a different color
@@mubzis1491 it has nothing to do with political correctness and everything to do with colonialism. Political correctness is what the colonisers have to adhere to in order not to offend their own people back home. Political correctness allows them to say, "we're doing democracy against the undemocratic" which in plain speech is "we're committing atrocities against Natives, so that you can buy their spices, oil and silk from us at an inflated price". There's nothing wrong with polical correctness, it's a language like any other. It's the language of politicians. We just need to keep on translating. It's all in the communication.
No, he is in that position because he is a useful idiot. It's not about us the little people (mind you I'm not from the USA), but who controls them the people of government. He's not there for the little people, but follows the orders from the people ruling the little people (chattel).
Patel won't call it genocide because then he knows they're in violation of International Law and American Law so he's not going to admit that genocide is ongoing via American bombs & billions. Shame Shame Shame. Respect for Said Arikat for yet again putting pressure on Patel.
I’m not a lawyer and can’t tell you what a genocide is but I can tell you that this isn’t one. This dude is a joke just like the rest of the monsters he serves
I am deeply surprised as he is an Indian like me. How can he utter such nonsense in front of so many people. "We dont know what is genocide but we know what Israel is doing is not genocide "
Why is it so difficult to understand? He himself doesn't know the definition but his team knows and they have verified the situation against that definition and have told him that it is not a genocide.
@@contactpjoshi123 They have verified WHAT? Are you mental? EVEN in LEGAL terms this is nothing but a frikkin GENOCIDE! So, the DENIAL from them is whats so frikkin difficult to understand! Do YOU understand now?
A Genocide is unfounded 🤔 first explain what a Genocide ia. Do they think the world is that stupid or It's because as soon as he explains what a Genocide is he won't be able to waffle away with that crap what a clown 🤡
He doesn't know what a genocide is because he's not a lawyer. But he decided that it's not a genocide, not matter what the International Court says. The next question should be: do you even listen to yourself?
I'm sorry, but anyone with access to the internet in this day and age and even those with no access, can easily tell what the definition of genocide is. Saying "I'm not a lawyer" is absolutely shameful
Listen to him!! he's turned a question about "what do you consider genocide?" into an accusation of Hamas.. This man is beyond disgusting I don't know where his soul is but he has sold it a long time ago.
The same question was asked of UK prime minister Keir Starmer. Starmer denied there was a genocide happening and refused to provide a definition. Starmer is supposedly a human rights lawyer. The work of the Israel lobby in the UK.
The guy really does show his language skills in avoiding an answer. It seems what he is really saying is ‘we think the widespread slaughter of civilians, most of them women and children, greatly reducing the population way beyond the numbers normally expected in a war, is not something we care about’. Disgraceful.
You know what’s infuriating? Let’s look at the exchange; “do you have a definition for genocide” “I’m not a lawyer” The next fucking words out of that reporters mouth should have then been “if you’re coming out here TELLING us the UN definition of genocide they’re using to call Gaza a genocide is unfounded, you should damn we’ll be coming with your definition, the fact you don’t speaks volumes”
How can you say that genocide is unfounded and at the same time not give a proper definition of the word? If you don't have the definition of the word, then how would why would you know genocide is not present?
I am a lawyer and I can tell you that the definition of the word genocide is not a legal matter that only a lawyer can explain or define. It’s a matter of English vocabulary and language. He was simply afraid that if he gave a definition of the word genocide it would accurately describe Israel’s actions.
When Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart was asked to describe his test for obscenity in 1964, he responded: "I know it when I see it." People saw the statistics and heard or watched the published intentions in footage, statements by leaders in power, and released the press, UN observers and by the surviving people, etc, then if you have been asked the definition for genocide, my mind directly goes to this: I KNOW IT WHEN I SEE IT.
Who is providing the 2000 pound bombs to Israel- what is indictment killing of civilians if a 2000 bombs aren’t- how that’s right these are targeted weapons are they not
He is not a lawyer he is a talker. He is doing what exactly? Telling the news that should be believed -to the media. A few learned sentences that cover almost everything. A little of variation but mostly “we are working” on something
As defined is US Law, the crime of genocide is definded in part thusly “Whoever, whether in time of peace or in time of war and with the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in substantial part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group as such”
![เจ็บที่ยังฮัก - ม่อน วรวิทย์ [ Official Mv ] จอนนี่มิวสิค](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KALIGSRSjFs/mqdefault.jpg)
It's simple.
It's called genocide when we are enemies, it's not called genocide when we are allies
exactly
"It's not a genocide but I don't know what a genocide is" is effectively the nonsense coming from his mouth.
My thoughts exactly
@@NAM-zo5nj perfectly put. Thank you.
All the Palestinians have not been killed, so not genocide.
Exactly!! "I can't define it, but this is not it"🙄🙄🙄
I think a war is a war a genocide is when the population is being eradicated. But when Gaza population growth is significantly high every year, it shows to any normal unbiased person. That this is not genocide, its just dumb people using a word they don't understand 🙄 😅
EVIL,EVIL,EVIL🥵🥵🥵
How can the genocide supporters condemn genocide..
That is not an argument, and I use the same sentence in reverse on you. The Jews have not tried to kill all the Palestinians,so not genocide. If Hamas hide under the noses of there own people, then civilians will be killed.
Not supporters, but active participants
So you do not want do define the term 'genocide' but insist, there is no 'genocide' in gaza. We have a definition of the term 'Human' and the US politicians do not match to that.
Paid to lie
I dont know what genocide is but this surely is not one. What a moron
Forget legal. What about a humanistic definition! You dumpling!
😂 this is the perfect name for him. Dumpling.
I've gone off dumplings now.
@WynonaRoder I was going to call.him potatoe or spud but was worried I'd be accused of racism. So at least dumpling has the same shape but a different color
@@Nooooooooooooooo1x these days everyone is scared of being labelled.
Too much of political correctness
@mubzis1491 except against Muslims feel free to say and do what you like yo Muslims. But west ! No no no not allowed. Israel? No no no not allowed.
@@mubzis1491 it has nothing to do with political correctness and everything to do with colonialism. Political correctness is what the colonisers have to adhere to in order not to offend their own people back home. Political correctness allows them to say, "we're doing democracy against the undemocratic" which in plain speech is "we're committing atrocities against Natives, so that you can buy their spices, oil and silk from us at an inflated price". There's nothing wrong with polical correctness, it's a language like any other. It's the language of politicians.
We just need to keep on translating. It's all in the communication.
Stop shameless Genocide
“I’m not a lawyer but the allegations are wrong”?!?
But didn’t you just say that you’re not a lawyer??
What you’re NOT is very intelligent!
Doesnt know what is the definition of genocide but he still knows by some divine power what a genocide isn't. Twisted hypocrisy.
They are all blind in sight and conscience
On the contrary I assume that the US administration shares the genocidal ambition of "Herzl'stan and enables it .
I noticed that since the ultimatum in the letter expired, Matthew Miller is no longer in sight. They let this loser perpetuate the lies.
In order to state that a genocide is not taking place they would have to know what constitutes a genocide....why are we putting up with this crap.
This guy is the real face of USA. Emotionless, liar and cruel...
How stupid this guy is ' I am not a lawyer '. Really? He probably has an IQ of less than 50!
His hired to be useless it's what's his good at
He gets 10 of 10 for being useless from me.
No, he is in that position because he is a useful idiot. It's not about us the little people (mind you I'm not from the USA), but who controls them the people of government. He's not there for the little people, but follows the orders from the people ruling the little people (chattel).
Patel has bo clue, he's repeating, what's being told to him
Patel won't call it genocide because then he knows they're in violation of International Law and American Law so he's not going to admit that genocide is ongoing via American bombs & billions. Shame Shame Shame. Respect for Said Arikat for yet again putting pressure on Patel.
If you ever feel stupid, just remember that Vedant Patel exists.
I have been waiting for someone to ask this question for so long 🙏🏾 it is not Genocide but I won't define what Genocide is.....
I’m not a lawyer and can’t tell you what a genocide is but I can tell you that this isn’t one.
This dude is a joke just like the rest of the monsters he serves
I am deeply surprised as he is an Indian like me. How can he utter such nonsense in front of so many people.
"We dont know what is genocide but we know what Israel is doing is not genocide "
Why is it so difficult to understand? He himself doesn't know the definition but his team knows and they have verified the situation against that definition and have told him that it is not a genocide.
@@contactpjoshi123 They have verified WHAT? Are you mental?
EVEN in LEGAL terms this is nothing but a frikkin GENOCIDE!
So, the DENIAL from them is whats so frikkin difficult to understand! Do YOU understand now?
A Genocide is unfounded 🤔 first explain what a Genocide ia. Do they think the world is that stupid or It's because as soon as he explains what a Genocide is he won't be able to waffle away with that crap what a clown 🤡
He doesn't know what a genocide is because he's not a lawyer. But he decided that it's not a genocide, not matter what the International Court says. The next question should be: do you even listen to yourself?
"I can't say what genocide is because I'm not a lawyer but it's not a genocide." Truly vile.
GENOCIDE UNFOUNDED ????????????????????????????????????? WTF
These guys will leave office soon and face public on their daily lives
I'm sorry, but anyone with access to the internet in this day and age and even those with no access, can easily tell what the definition of genocide is. Saying "I'm not a lawyer" is absolutely shameful
imagine having to tie yourself in knots like that in front of the whole world, the man has no shame. he is a discrace.
He's not a lawyer and yet he would dispute the findings of lawyers and Judges that say it is Genocide.
Not your partners, your bosses.
If they define terrorism or genocide, their duplicitous policy will be in danger
You don’t need to be lawyer to define genocide
Neither they have definition for Genocide nor for Terrorism.
Guy cant read Britannica or Wikipedia. Why is he paid anything?
How do you believe that it is unfounded to call it Genocide?When you can’t even define the word
The UK government is evading this question as well. We all know why.
Pol Pot= genocide. Idi Amin = genocide. Rwanda hutu= genocide. Benjamin Netanyahu= genocide.
Has anyone asked this reporter what _his_ definition of genocide might be? And remember: if you start a war, you cannot complain when your losing.
"I'm not a lawyer but Kier Starmer is a lawyer and he doesn't know either."
What rubble😢😢😢😢 theres body parts
I'm quite sure that the definition of what constitutes genocide has been expressed in the legislation that makes the support of genocide a crime.
Listen to him!! he's turned a question about "what do you consider genocide?" into an accusation of Hamas..
This man is beyond disgusting I don't know where his soul is but he has sold it a long time ago.
Ask him if he know what diaper is?
Thank you for asking the obvious question, Please keep asking for their definition until they produce it in writing.
I dont know what the definition is but I've been told it is unfounded
Patel can't define genocide because he is aiding and abetting the genocide.
To them, the term genocide does not apply to them...
For a SPOKEsperson, he sure doesn't SPEAK much. clown world, clown nation, clown situation.
If he doesn't know the law he shouldn't be working there.
This type of Patel Fatel is ruining everything and they don’t even realize it.
US bla bla bla
The same question was asked of UK prime minister Keir Starmer. Starmer denied there was a genocide happening and refused to provide a definition. Starmer is supposedly a human rights lawyer. The work of the Israel lobby in the UK.
If you have morality, you can't be a spokesman like him also if you are a spokesman like him, u can't be a moral person. Both r quite opposite.
The guy really does show his language skills in avoiding an answer. It seems what he is really saying is ‘we think the widespread slaughter of civilians, most of them women and children, greatly reducing the population way beyond the numbers normally expected in a war, is not something we care about’. Disgraceful.
His like Rumsfeld spinning words into a web of rubbish
Can’t even define what genocide is.
That is WHY YOU ARE NOT GOING FOR A SECOND TERM…….
yeah pretty much
I fail to understand why and how there are still people in the room after getting such weak responses
they just can not remember it ***********
Wow only lawyers know the definition of genocide 🤯🤯🤯🤯
Freaking Patel. How about you go to one of your lawyers and get the definition so you can talk to the grown-ups at the big table!
You know what’s infuriating? Let’s look at the exchange; “do you have a definition for genocide”
“I’m not a lawyer”
The next fucking words out of that reporters mouth should have then been “if you’re coming out here TELLING us the UN definition of genocide they’re using to call Gaza a genocide is unfounded, you should damn we’ll be coming with your definition, the fact you don’t speaks volumes”
Liars all of them
I do not know the definition of genocide, but we found it unfounded! 😂 That is brilliant!
I KNOW KOSHER AND BACON IS KOSHER
Excellent question. Can’t wait for the response!
Im horrified to live in this timeline. How shameful are our leaders.
Resistance
I don't know what a genocide is but I know definitively that this is not a genocide. 🤔
he is a participant in the genocide. This is like allowing a criminal to define the crime that they are on trial for.
How can you say that genocide is unfounded and at the same time not give a proper definition of the word? If you don't have the definition of the word, then how would why would you know genocide is not present?
hey 3 year old, do you have a definition for what a crayon is?
*3 year old*: I am not a lawyer I cannot give you a legal definition of a crayon
3 years olds, unlike Patel, can answer relevant age appropriate questions 😅
He can't define Genocide as he is not a lawyer, but he's certain it's not Genocide even though he states he doesn't know the definition of it. Right.
Dicusting!!!!!!!
If he's not a lawyer and can't give a definition of what is Genocide then how is he sure what is going on does not qualify?
Ask him definition of humanity
I am a lawyer and I can tell you that the definition of the word genocide is not a legal matter that only a lawyer can explain or define. It’s a matter of English vocabulary and language. He was simply afraid that if he gave a definition of the word genocide it would accurately describe Israel’s actions.
Can assailants define genocide? Only victims know what genocide is?
These are real enemies of humanity
They are true HOMELANDER.
What is he doing there, if he doesn’t know what genocide is?
He is not a lawyer but he doesn’t accept UN lawyers opinion when they say that is genocide.😂
He is not a lawyer who cannot describe what genocide is but can definitely claim what Israeli is doing is not a genocide
hes a not lawyer so he cant define genocide. but he can tell you allegations of genocide are unfounded.
how does that work 🤔
When Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart was asked to describe his test for obscenity in 1964, he responded: "I know it when I see it."
People saw the statistics and heard or watched the published intentions in footage, statements by leaders in power, and released the press, UN observers and by the surviving people, etc, then if you have been asked the definition for genocide, my mind directly goes to this:
I KNOW IT WHEN I SEE IT.
The face of a hypocrite!
American.authorities hands are in blood of the palatines todays Israel is not the Israel of yesterday that the lords hand was with
Pissreal never was anything but a colonial project
Who is providing the 2000 pound bombs to Israel- what is indictment killing of civilians if a 2000 bombs aren’t- how that’s right these are targeted weapons are they not
Next time he step on to the podium, just tell him to update about what's the US definition and characteristics of genocide
He will probably lie again
He js a gujarati. He knows what genocide is
He is not a lawyer he is a talker.
He is doing what exactly? Telling the news that should be believed -to the media. A few learned sentences that cover almost everything. A little of variation but mostly “we are working” on something
They can't say it because then they are admitting to being complicit in a genocide.
By default.
The lawyers say it is not genocide, I doubt that will work if you ever face trial for your aiding and abetting.
He needs to be in prison for the remainder of his life
how did he go from what we do in the shadows to this
Why these journalists don't stop going to these briefings or it's a must ?? Because they're being treated like babies and it's humiliating.
As defined is US Law, the crime of genocide is definded in part thusly
“Whoever, whether in time of peace or in time of war and with the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in substantial part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group as such”
U.S. is also complicit in Gaza genocide.
I thought the US was capable of gathering information.
It seems I was mistaken.