Vocal Coach Reacts to G.E.M 鄧紫棋 - Amazing Grace + Gloria｜LIVE on Tatler! XFEST HK vs Inter Miami CF
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 เม.ย. 2024
- Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili.com/7295246
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on TH-cam: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia.com/rozette
#reaction #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #邓紫棋 #messi - บันเทิง
我懂了，Gem因為她獨特的鼻音和偶爾出現的哭腔，顯得整首歌很有感情
尤其在這場災難性的足球賽之後，她的聲音很有撫慰性
每個歌手有自己唱歌preference, 我相信GEM已經用最好最真摯方式去表演，作為觀眾我好enjoy.
Amazing live performance!🎉
第二首歌是紫棋原創中文專集其中一首，後來整張專集又翻成西班牙語。
推薦我是歌手的歌 如果沒有你，存在，你把我灌醉，存在，你不是真正的快樂
All the hk people inside the Hong Kong Stadium enjoy the performance of G.E.M.
This is absolutely HER choice for sure!
Can't wait 🔥🔥 I am hoping and waiting for this before you announce and now you really did!!!
Nice performance 👏 GEM ❤
Amazing analysis!!!
I'm so glad that you'll be reviewing this performance!! It probably wasn't due to my recommendation in the comments, but I am going to pretend that it is! Haha! Thank you!
希望老師可以看到這則留言，紫棋是因為信仰特地學西班牙語的唷❤她發音真的很標準！！
十1
她不是基督徒，她是 ……
请问阁下是否讲西班牙语（西班牙）？ 我只能够听出她的西班牙语发音是西班牙发音，但是因为我不讲西班牙语所以无法判断是否标准…..个人猜测应该不会很标准，但是已经很好了（在不讲西班牙语的前提下）。我没有任何恶意，只是想确认一下阁下是否是一个European Spainsh speaker？ 我非常欣赏GEM的表演，是当下我最喜欢的华语歌手。
@@Christine-si4py据我所知她似乎是新教徒（Protestant)，如果有误请纠正，并且有兴趣了解一下她的信仰是什么。
@@christianj0726 基督教
感谢老师💜！！感谢杰凯💜！！感谢你们的团队😊
Gem created a Spanish version of her album ‘Revelation’ which has a slight difference compare to the Chinese version but not much.
Thanks❤
G.E.M.'s songs from Chapter 1 - Gloria to Chapter 12 - The Sky she did them first in chinese and then in spanish all 12 Chapters
She learned Spanish and released a Spanish album last year
.. guess she said a prayer and thanked god at the end coz the football fans didn't boo her 😝...
She came on right after the game ended, and everyone was still pissed, shouting 'refund' before she started singing
She did the great job for sure. 👍👍👍
老師超棒欸
非常精彩的解析
預告片的歌很好聽❤
期待中
我很喜歡老師的點評
每一首都是用讚美角度去欣賞歌曲
給的評論都很有風度
期待期待！！希望日期能挪前~
可以給老師看看啓示錄 音樂連續劇
我在嗶哩嗶哩也有推介這場LIVE表演，再次期待老師的真實評價👍🏻
Very professional comment . Two thumbs up
Gem is the best singer actually!
💜
不妨讓老師聽聽gem的rap風格的歌
讓老師欣賞她的創作能力
推薦幾首：句號、透明、依然睡公主、孤獨🙏
這比較難吧，他們主要看的是唱功，不太看詞
而這幾首蠻重詞的(像上次的摩天我覺得老師不了解詞的含義就很可惜)
给老师听听受难曲
Pink is LA Galaxy team jersey colours, and David Beckham is the owner of
gem❤❤❤❤
真誠地向團隊及老師表達謝意。 常看老師的reaction video可以受益良多。
真心向團隊及老師推薦So Hyang 的Bridge over troubled water/You raise me up/Oh Holy night. She’s one of the best female vocalists of our time in my humble opinion.
David Beckham’s wife is the member of Spice Girls (Victoria)
TKS❤
gem唱得很好👍🏻是現代唯一唱得嘅香港人
北姑好吧
國語或者很動聽？鼻音太重，有點怪。
唯一？她除了巨肺懂唱歌嗎？一直嗌歌飆高音，如果是有比較好聽的話都可以叫特色，但明顯是一堆發音壞習慣沒有努力改過，真的懂唱是林憶蓮那種歌手！
鼻腔跟哭腔泛濫，明明可以處理得更細緻，卻不好好去改善，根本一點都不好聽
彭羚跟林憶蓮才是懂唱的歌手
Please, react to her album Revelation and also Revelacíon (Spanish Version)!
GEM is the best ❤❤❤
簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍
遇廣告看完看🈵
希望可以给老师react邓紫棋的“受难曲”
想看老師點評一下鄧紫棋在時光音樂會這個節目唱的唯一，或者11，強推！！！希望老師能看到這條評論🥺
老師的分析很強，Gem剛出道就有說她偶像是Christina
[Gloria]MV可看性極高❤
th-cam.com/video/stGUpMav1sc/w-d-xo.html si=fHB1Y8-ZuP_eAMg_
Can't wait for you to talk about Zhou Shen's newest song Mirage!!
老师 太强了 不像国内的只是会批评就不会指出什么发音的地方~~~
👍👍👍
her nasal sound and the crying sound bother a lot of Chinese listeners, believe me!
推薦可以聽A-lin上the first take的有一種悲傷~~
想讓老師聽一下 李宗盛 山丘
GEM's album "Revelation" was re-recorded entirely in Spanish.
存在please!
很专业的分析
點解唔俾Mirror表演果段俾老師睇🤣
因為怕醜出香港
老師超厲害~~給讚
Gem的發音特色應該源自於天生生理缺陷發展而來的
什麼缺陷，GEM唱歌音準完全冇問題，很好聽，有辨識度，每個歌手都有其特點，否則就唔會紅，就好似老師教人唱歌，都應該要知道！
好久😢😢😢
真的
You will keep trying until she approves 😂
Hah😂 so funny
please do react Queen Sohyang's version
希望不要等那么久 日期能够提前
想看阿刁~~
如果不是在完場之後有GEM神級演出，那一天香港可能發生大暴動，多謝GEM😅
真的假的😂😂😂
GEM在香港根本不受歡迎，而且是她自己的出位言行導致的，層有一段時間她挺受歡迎，現在沒剩多少香港人會想看到她
@@fragrantsnow1495
你可以代表香港人？
@@fragrantsnow1495 我係香港人, 好鍾意聽佢嘅歌喎, 唔好鳩up
@@fragrantsnow1495你確定可以代表香港人 你知唔知香港好多靚仔靚妹都好鍾意佢呀
希望快點看到老師點評女神張惠妹，謝謝
Haha, who is that? Beckham 😂 Rosetta’s cute/unconfident smile
希望老師看看子棋2011紅館演唱會 跟現在的唱法真的很不一樣!
Pink is Miami team😂
GEM 是临时救场的哦
不是，是本來就要表演⋯ 不是「臨時」
Where was the game? If they sung that song in China then they are incredibly nice.
點評這場前 應該先了解Gem 承受多少壓力來唱這首歌
因為美斯沒有在這場表演賽出場 所有觀眾都大喊退錢退票 就是gem 的歌聲來安撫他們的情緒
re的过程中有解释，更何况她唱歌选择用何种技术跟这个并没有什么关系
不用特別去了解吧
點評唱歌技巧我覺得直接聽最真實
有時前置太多反而會先入為主
这是粉丝自己的事情。
對不起 因為我在這re 開播前留言的🙏 只是覺得壓力會影響發揮而已 謝謝各位
利申：不是粉絲
想介紹給老師一位也算是比較新晉的香港女歌手黃洛妍Janees，她是炎明熹Gigi那個參賽節目之後第二季的參賽者之一，她在參賽中翻唱了一首叫《溝渠暢泳》，想讓老師認識一下這位歌手。
我覺得可以給老師聽聽看近期在中國有小紅的魏如萱在台灣金曲獎上面演唱的影片欸！
很好奇老師會有什麼反應～～
有小紅嗎？😂
Who the hell of singer is it? What heck is 台灣金曲獎? Don't put my leg!
這些preferences跟文化有關係嗎？了解老師的取向，但她選擇在轉共鳴時不做混聲我感覺聽著更有情緒，好像普遍western的取向跟老師一樣。這跟歌手母語的不同會不會有關呢？中英文發音本來就有差，在唱歌選擇上會不會也因此有影響，感覺偏西方文化的歌手在這些選擇上會偏老師多點。
應該不是東西方的問題。我認為比較是傳統發聲部位技巧，和非傳統發聲部位技巧的分別。現代流行歌曲，歌手都會尋找新的發音部位和技巧，去創造自己的特色。
相信畢加索當時的畫風，也會令很多傳統繪畫老師不願意接受…. 😄
不要一次預告這麽多……我都有點找不到哪個才是我沒看過的比較新的影片了😅😅
老師示範的是希望學唱的人學習的方式 鄧紫棋那樣唱不是不好 而是很難控制好 要像鄧紫棋那樣唱要有非常深厚的功力 所以老師一直都是在稱讚他的 只是同時也要讓學唱歌的人有正確觀念
只是每个人技术选择不一样吧，老师说出自己的教学理念也挺好，这样想唱成邓那样的人就知道理念不同，不会去跟她学了，省了一个互相折磨
This team is Inter Miami😅
SPANISH AH
Hello.. please
Check out new gg de Lana cover song.. I love the way you are by Eminem and Riana 😊❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
By the way she is there right now in USA. She have a concert starting now
11 States in USA if I'm not mistaken...
Thanks in advance ❤️❤️❤️❤️😊
香港大球場：@
美斯、蘇亞瑞及碧咸等邁阿密球員們跟姜濤及盧瀚霆合照一張專輯！
鄧紫棋同碧咸及教主拍照！
I am surprised 老師不知道貝克漢 🤣🤣
David Beckham Take Photos With AnSon Road 🛣️🛣️🛣️ On and David Keung To...
我也不知道，不跟这个圈子而已，很奇怪吗
@@dwmobusa 不奇怪~我跟老師的學生一樣surprised 一下而已
G.E.M. 的唱法
那些鼻腔哭腔 喜歡的會超喜歡是她的特色呀
不喜歡的就會覺得 太難頂 不好聽 口齒不清
超難聽
Such As David Keung To...
不不知道有沒有機會請老師聽看看伍佰的歌😆
看完後最驚訝的是，怎會不知道貝克漢
The coach is trying very hard to defend the singer. So nice of her.
同样声音每个人发出来听感不同，可能GEM才是合理的，没必要重复“示范”
同意到極
I think that is their selling point, they are doing business reaction. Also, some of haters and the people don't know music like her reaction. I get it.
Funeral of Messi (and maybe Beckham)
😂😂
Blame Tatler... 唔使夠錢想硬食。
@@lorenzoxiong2611Messi didn't say that by himself. If it is not his fault, why not say something?
@@hollandbankchq Cuz that means he would take all the blames. Tatler 因此可以獨吞所有錢，甚至不用退50%. 我認為Messi只是不想同流合污的同時還要承受所有質疑。從Messi上下半場的表情差異就能看出端倪。
@@lorenzoxiong2611 If I were Messi, I will tell public he really wanted to play but Tatler didn't pay enough money to him or Miami. Now Messi lose a lot of incomes from China. It is huge amount and shouldn't be his responsibility as you said.
別再冤枉美斯了，他不握手那個畫面是因為他不是正選也不是後備所以才不去握但在賽前美斯出席了不少慈善活動😅
老師可以做Dimash唱歌的解說嗎?
做很幾次嘍
被D粉骂得半死了已经
1:11 / 7:30
Please check 薛之谦 thanks
美國足球隊衫
周杰倫官方2013最強live 什麼時候要測 建議rap的跳過，有兩集！
th-cam.com/video/XVf8_DaO19Y/w-d-xo.htmlsi=oseWnrHREYTGpG09
音樂本就可以是很主觀的東西，我就更喜歡GEM這種，倒是對JJ無感--無論他出道還是現如今。就像我也不喜歡這位老師的一貫唱法，但不代表老師不好或不對。😛
其實我也想的一樣。我覺得R這位老師雖然很會唱，但很難感動我，感覺就是匠氣很重。
就是听个技术分析而已呀，喜欢是很个人的东西，只要不因为喜欢的点不一样而互相攻击就行了
GEM唱歌技巧很差，哭腔跟鼻腔泛濫，除了巨肺和可以飆高音，她真的還好，感情投入的話一堆歌手完爆她
@@fragrantsnow1495 好不好市場決定，正因為她這種技巧單一反而顯得不太矯揉造作，符合現代modern審美。現代人沒有那麼多耐心去靜下來聆聽一個歌者的內心世界，他們更傾向於聆聽節奏與動律，以適配和緩解城市給人的高度緊張感。GEM的這些單一的唱法唱腔其實聯動起來就像固定的節拍器在洗腦。這也是為何像這位老師說的，遠在大城市紐約的老師就會教她的學生像GEM那樣唱歌，而她是不認同的。
老師的唱功實力比鄧更好！
我喜歡這位老師的唱腔！
Pls react to one ok rock😢
可以評周杰倫跟王力宏嗎
omg so many chinese pop singers, have the issue with no control at the end of the phrase with air sound, if i hear it more than once in a song, my ears gets annoyed ,,
I don't know why, U2 always sing Amazing Grace in professional sports events, marching bands perform in games too. Maybe the performer and the attended team from where they come from are religious.
给老师听前 其实简单的功课还是要做的 *粉红是客队的球衣*西班牙语的revelation都没听过*而且肯定是闭幕*
為什麼？
如果只是表達自己的意見可以不要說「其實xxxxx還是要做的」
好像在道出什麼真理似的
連阿根廷講西文都不知道😂
她甚麽都不知道。😣
西班牙話
I thought you guys decided not to review GEM again. Your early decision was probably wise if your objective is to avoid controversy…. 😄😄😄
I don't think so. Avoid controversy…is their selling point. Ha! Ha!
@@Norwayoil
I am just teasing. I think they are trying well. You just cannot avoid controversy when criticizing artists.
@@jyyau Yes, I agree on some of your point. I am talking about their title on all of their videos. What they stand from? They put too much personal opinions and habit on top of her reaction. That's the problem. They did not put some respect on their G.E.M. music video. I can see that from the teacher face and her body language, on her early reaction. I feel that they are a great actors. There is a big gap on musician and vocal singer. One is stand for unlimit way on their own creative product and the other one is stand for die hard formaul way of vocal technique which is like a AI robot. My personal opinion will stand for the first one. Our music need some more emotion, real stories, so we need some more first party singers to express their own real stories. There is no such perfect singer in the world, we aren't robort. that is a true fact. We need something get improve all the time, that's a human being.
@@Norwayoil
I do not necessarily agree to their criticism. But I still respect subjectivity in the positive way. 😄
完全听不出区别😂
老師嘅作品老師唱歌好勁老師教唱歌好專業 有幾個人聽？😨
@szewingng914 : I don't think so. You are completely wrong! There are tons of the singers like her in the world, that's why she only work on here. Do you know the reason? She put vocal into the formula way which is like a robot production, so there is no improvement and new things in her music. Music need some creative things, the singers will get improvement on theirs products. Don't you know!
@@Norwayoil she is not trying to be world superstar anyways. You are saying like all elementary school teachers are completely useless because they don't teach anything creative. There are university professors who study the most innovative technology in the world. There are also elementary school teachers, middle school teachers who can give their students a solid foundation so they are well prepared to learn from university professors in the future. Everyone has their own position and contribution in the learning process. It is those teachers who are tons in population that give people a good foundation so they can go pursue their own unique way of artistry in the future.
@dwmobusa you have the best answer my friend
@@fragrantsnow1495 thx bro
@@dwmobusaI didn't get that what the hell you are talking about. Your dropping look like you are coming from elementary school. Who the hell of the teacher taught you the standard of super star. What about yourself? Who the heck of professors told you about how to become a super star. Who the hell you are learn it from? You know nothing about music. Don't you know the different on musician and vocal singer? They look like a robot. Don't you know this is only a business reaction? They have to get the way to attract their audiences. They get into the wrong way, they did not respect the way from the other singer. Ha! Ha! Don;t you know? Kid!
th-cam.com/video/CdqbMdYZlsU/w-d-xo.htmlsi=xu68URVcKlSvX5TT try to do reaction on 李宗盛-新写的旧歌
邓紫棋的节目太多了
Get the facts straight lol. Dont fall into Chinese propaganda. They DID NOT pay to get him to play. The organizer lied. They paid to get the team to play. He was not contractually obligated to play.