The NEW Big Agnes Backpack - Garbage OR Gold?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 พ.ค. 2022
- Big Agnes Prospector 50 bit.ly/3w8yOFF
Outdoor Vitals Shadowlight Backpack bit.ly/3sjesIb
OnX Backcountry..THE BEST navigation app 👉 bit.ly/3v99kq4
Gear I use and LOVE...
BACKPACK
TENT bit.ly/35auKqq
MY SATELLITE COMMUNICATOR
TREKKING POLES bit.ly/3hsHLR6
SLEEPING PAD bit.ly/2KNVZAf
OTHER SLEEPING PAD amzn.to/2XfSxRz
MULTITOOL (often out of stock & price can vary) amzn.to/3LJcZ4J
HOODIE bit.ly/3mXRXCn
BEST BACKPACKING DINNERS bit.ly/2YHBRXm
FAVORITE BACKPACKING LUNCHES bit.ly/3aKamNG
DOWN JACKET bit.ly/2EBbx6M
RAIN JACKET
CHAIR bit.ly/3eecrD1
INSECT REPELLENT (individual packets) amzn.to/2Yq6zjt
NECK GAITER bit.ly/2WVkZZK
SLEEPING BAG amzn.to/2QmWTTg
PILLOW bit.ly/3hGKPsp
COOK POT amzn.to/2EwYPpJ
DITTY BAG bit.ly/3f6VeLW
FOOD BAG bit.ly/3f6VeLW
STOVE amzn.to/2DGl75E
SPORK amzn.to/2CPV9em
LIP SAVER amzn.to/2sY1Ztr
FOOTPRINT amzn.to/2ItFtU2
BATTERY BANK amzn.to/2H4wJkz
TOOTHBRUSH bit.ly/2VpLC7c
FIRE STARTER amzn.to/2VgBP5O
HEADLAMP bit.ly/3Gr1AUo
GPS
WATER BOTTLE HOLDER bit.ly/3fdyzOF
WATCH amzn.to/2NFm9UX
SUNGLASSES amzn.to/2PZ3C7a
HAT amzn.to/2W3lvWz
🚨FOLLOW ME🚨
Instagram bit.ly/35gLzNu
Facebook bit.ly/2QG4BaP
📷MY CAMERA GEAR📷
MAIN CAMERA amzn.to/3gxi8zX
MAIN LENS amzn.to/3q83LVW
ND FILTER amzn.to/2DR26wM
GIMBAL amzn.to/2Lm38VK
CAMERA CLIP FOR BACKPACK amzn.to/2VjlihB
What should I bring camping? What do I need for backpacking? What tent to buy? What sleeping bag is best? How to camp. Dan Durston Xmid. Camping list. Complete camping and backpacking list.
Big Agnes backpack. Parkview backpack. Garnet backpack. Sun Dog backpack. Ditch Rider Backpack. Impassable backpack. Big Agnes trash can. What is a good backpack for backpacking. Hiking. camping. ul backpacking. ultralight gear for backpacking. Prospector 50 backpack. - บันเทิง
Would you bring the ‘Trash Can’ on trail?? Gimmick or no??
Gimmick. A 1 gallon ziplock has served me for many years, and when I get home, the whole thing goes in the garbage. No extra work in clean up.
Not a chance.
As a trash can its a gimmick for sure but as a extra pouch maybe not all depends on what one would actually use it for.. great video and love you views! keep on keeping on!
Definitely, just clean it back at home and save the plastic waste of 1 ziploc bag on every trip...in fact, i bought a reusable trash bag from a different vendor...and sure, you can reuse ziploc bags, but they are not as quite durable
It's a gimmick, but probably one I'd use. Ziplocks are a pain to wash out I find, that looks much more easy to clean; give it a rinse, whack it in the washing machine.
Unless you're packing out used toilet roll. Deffo ziplock that 😂
Emmett adds a great touch in the editing as well as in the story. He gives you someone to play off and that livens up your story. Here's to many more videos with Emmett's artistry.
Loved that intro! Sounds like Emmett has got your number!!! Haha
Dan, the purpose of the waterproof zipper, is to protect the zipper itself, from things like mud, dirt, etc. To stop things from getting into the zipper and prevent it from functioning correctly, or at all.
My hiking gear got stolen so I'm starting over, trying to replace a whole packing list all at once. It's difficult choosing decent gear in a market flooded with so much junk gear with huge price tags. I appreciate your videos and can't wait to get back on the trail
I feel your pain brother, my gear was once stolen and I had to start all over again and it was difficult to find gear that could equal what I had, particularly in a high loft down bag. Good luck re-outfitting and happy trails.
OMG! I'm loving the added flare you're getting with Emmett! ❤❤❤
This is by far the most passionate I've seen Dan, it's impressive and entertaining
I bought this backpack. It is water resistant. No it’s not waterproof but the majority of the shell material is water resistant. The roll top combined with the pocket zipper. After watching this review I bought a couple straps to put on the bottom. No biggie. I’ve hiked with it and it breathes better than I expected and found it comfortable. The large side pockets are great.
The trash bag actually was handy because I lost my stuff sack for my sleeping bag.
Did it make the squeaky noise he talked about?
After having the pack for a while now, are you happy with it? Cheers. :)
I bought the Shadowlight 60 a year ago and love it. Fixed the squeak in the frame by rubbing wax on the top 3 inches of the frame. Best backpack I have ever used.
I am glad to see that your gear review are honest and not influenced by the name on the product. I respect that and trust even more in your product review 👍
Hey thanks Dan. I was so excited for this review. The bag looks so cool. Thanks for your honest review. I have picked up other items you have recommended and you are right on. Blessings.
Why the water proof zipper: Assuming the pouch is waterproof/water resistant, it gives you a place to put items that are sensitive to water like electronics. Looking at that pouch it looks perfect for a phone, a battery bank and maybe some extra camera batteries for an action cam.
Thanks for the review! I was considering trying it out but I'll wait until they fix the issues you mentioned. I've been super happy with my Gossamer Gear Mariposa 60 for the last 2 years!
Thanks for this review Dan. I absolutely LOVE my OV Shadowlight backpack!! I second your recommendation there. 👌🏼
Nice review. Years ago I used to read Backpacker magazine, but they were hardly ever critical of the gear they reviewed. I appreciate reviewers who honestly point out the good and bad things about a piece of gear.
I find it interesting that you suggested the Outdoor Vitals pack instead of the BA one. One of the things you pointed out as a big negative of the Outdoor Vitals pack was the split front pocket. I would have a really hard time using that pack for that reason. I love the big stretchy mesh front pocket on my ULA Equipment pack.
The hip belt size issue on the BA pack seems odd. It almost looks like it may be removable, so I almost expected they would have different hip belt options online. Nope. It's one size. :-(
It was refreshing to see you not just love an item again. Thanks for such an honest review
Love your honesty. That's why I watch your great channel
Check where the back panel touces the top of the pack on the inside (maybe a panel in a pocket against your back) for the squeek or a tag at the top of the straps where they atatch to the pack. Had this squeek issue with the Arcteryx Aerios.
Thank you for your honesty.
An honest and fair review. You described what you liked and what you didn’t in good detail.
Finally! I was looking for a review on this bag and you delivered, saved me from a big $230 mistake. You the man as always!!!!
Awesome review, love your candid honest commentary
If you don’t like the backpack, pass it down to one of us!!! Any of us subscribers will love any of your “hand me downs!”
When I first saw the profile of the pack it looked like a Long Haul 50 by Superior Wilderness Designs. You should check them out. Made from ecopak fabrics - waterproof, the large side pockets, sewn in or removable hip belts - sized seperate from torso, material options for front pocket - mesh(two types) or pack fabric, multiple compression and lashing strap locations, built to carry heavy loads, and made by hand in Michigan. They're not cheap and their lead time is getting longer, but well wirth the cost in money and time. I absolutely love mine.
Dan this was genuinely an informative video and pretty funny, thank you!
I have a kinda similar trash bag that I made myself. I don't eat out of pouches, so I don't get trash that would start to smell or get gross. I also like to pick up trash I find on the trail, so it's important the trash bag is easily accessible and I hang it on the outside of my backpack.
I don't want to use disposable stuff (like ziplocks) if there's an alternative
Very good video, as always. Maybe they wanted to make the belt pockets removable because that way you can take the entire pouch with you without having to carry the entire backpack. I think that is an excellent idea for the locations when I want to go to the campfire with all my things pertinent to part crafting without having to empty the entire pouch of my backpack or maybe just to take one thing out of there and having the fear that I’m gonna forget to put it back and then losing it or maybe forgetting where I put it. I don’t know, I just think it’s a good idea. Thank you so much for sharing this video. Please forgive my spelling. I am blind and my iPad writes as I speak and sometimes it doesn’t pick up the correct words because of my Puerto Rican goofy accent. God bless you.
I have the Shadowlight and i love it. I can be squeaky too though.
Thank you for sharing and being honest! Innovation also needs to be functional.
I love that shadowlite backpack and a ton of Outdoor Vitals other gear and apparel.
The first 8 secs were all I needed to like this video 🤣🤣🤣 Thanks again!
I got this backpack today. I'm a waist 30in and the medium size works well, lots of room on the strap to further tighten it. Also, the hipbelt is removable. Also, maybe handy for air travel, there's a strap that you can secure the two shoulder straps together, and then place it in a raincover (not provided unfortunately) and check it in for your flight. It looks sturdy, it's comfy to wear (even with 11kg). Can't complain.
After having the pack for a while now, are you happy with it? Cheers. :)
I own a Shadowlight which I used last summer when I did the Colorado Trail. I liked the pack except for the compression strings on the sides and the hipbelt pockets which I was never able to open one handed.
David killing the Goliath. The way it goes. I just pulled out my 8 pound MSR Fusion 2 to replace my North Face Lunarlight that I've used for over three decades.. But I stay in one place for the season. I have different reasons than the thru hikers.
Great review! Thanks for sharing. I would like you to review a comparable backpack by Osprey, I am particularly interested in their antigravity line. I’ve been into backpack camping since the late 60’s- early 70’s and I still own and use an external frame pack made by Alpenlite. One of the very cool features of my backpack is that it will stand on it’s own on the frame without wetting or soiling the bottom of the bag. My greatest requirement for a good backpack is a robust and comfortable suspension system and that is where I think Osprey excels. I do try to go as lightweight as I can yet I still like to indulge in creature comforts. Let’s face it, if you’re not comfortable, you’re probably not having a lot of fun, and that’s the point, isn’t it?
I have the osprey thats comparable, cant remember what its called and the Big Agnes is far more comfortable and kight
Thank you for your honest review. That pack needs a lot of work.
I was wondering in your on trail video why you were cinching the hip belt down so much, now I know. Probably won't give up my deuter air contact lite any time soon but I really enjoy watching all your videos.
F-Stoppers invented that style for the back door access for backpacks, made for photographers and videographers. They even sell special padded inserts to use to put photographic gear in the pack for back access that would probably work with the Big Agnes pack too.
I don't think F-Stoppers invented that- I had an Osprey pack in the early- or mid-90's that had a zip-opening backpanel, called the Backside. And if I recall correctly, they had a few packs with that feature. Super handy, especially in snow. I always thought it was strange that the concept didn't stick around.
I think you just sold me on the Shadowlight. I'm a little older and have some nasty knee issues so I'm looking to outfit myself with some lightweight but still solid kit (The last time I put a backpack on it was 15 years ago with the Marines and they are anything but light!). Looks like I'll go with the Shadowlight and OV's quilt as well as a Durston XMid 1P. Thanks for the great info and a very entertaining channel!
Love my shadowlight pack!
Hi Dan, Thanks for all the great videos! I know this question isn't related to this particular video but I was wondering about your thoughts on the Haven XL Hammock Tent?
Respect for honest reviews
You should check out the Sierra Designs Flex Capacitor 40-60. Great weight carrying capacity and also a lightweight pack.
I find my flex capacitor uncomfortable over 30 lbs. The frame digs into the back of my hips.
Looks like a decent pack for someone who is starting out or for someone who carries more than 30lbs.
The weird thing with packs is this..... Not all packs work for everyone. What works for my body size/shape and my needs might not work for everyone.
It's taken me several packs and 2decades worth of trial and error to find "the perfect" pack for me.
I wanna see thank you for your work an helping me drop weight an get motivated I know you don't thru hike but you have inspired me to start. I spend way more time outside. My younger brother is joining me on hikes!!!
Thank you so much!!!!
Big Agnes big slam! I thought the chatter after the things you liked WAS the stuff you hated but then you ran down the real dislikes. Lol. Your honesty and insight is appreciated. Real and relevant!
Personally Id recommend the Osprey Exos 48 or 58L for similar goal, lightweight, decent load and brilliant build quality.
Yes! Ive got the 48L & dont regret buying it one bit! Love the design & fit!
Thru hiked the AT with the 58. Best bang for the buck.
Yeah, love my Osprey Eja!
Love my Exo 58! I think it’s one of the original versions. Been using it for over 6 years in the Sierra, Grand Canyon, and Colorado Rockies. I’ve hauled 50+ pounds and it handles the load no problem. Its sweet spot however is around 35lbs. It’s comfortable, functional, durable, and relatively light weight. It’s hard to switch out to a newer pack when this one still delivers every time I’ve needed it!
Good review Dan! The video of you on trail from behind shows that it rides low, would you have changed size of torso? It seems like based on your length that the pack doesn’t really reflect correct sizing. Cheers-southwest Michigan!
I love my OV Shadowlight. The only reason I don't use it on all of my trips is because I've gone to a llghter load and volume much of the time. I've still used it when I take my bear canister or I'm heading out on a trail work crew and want a few more luxury items at the end of the day. I will never part with this pack. One of my favorite features on the OV pack are the two upper side pockets, which I use for my cook kit, first aid kit and poop kit. It rivals the comfort of my ULA packs, but with even better access and organization. If I were to make any suggestions to improve the Shadowlight, I'd suggest adding stretchy shoulder pockets for those of us who carry a smart water bottle up front to help balance loads and for super easy access and a bottom stretchy pocket, like those found on Pa'lante, Atom Packs and Nashville. Big Agnes is a great outdoor company, but whoever designed that pack is not an experienced backpacker. They need to bring in longer distance backpackers and folks with more experience, like yourself, to workshop a well designed pack. After just a few trips, we all know features that are priceless for utility and comfort.
Great review. Thanks.
Mine squeaked too much and drove me crazy. I tried leukotape and chapstick, but it would come back.
I wished they put straps on the bottom just in case I needed them. I like it a lot though. Very durable material.
@@deborahhill3105 I remember doing something for a foam mat... like paracord in the belt area and plastic rings on both sides + a toggle. Would have used less cordage/easier if there were more grossgrain loops or rings.
If I were to change other things... If they're keeping the midline zipper, don't make it so tall (assuming that the sleeping bag is in polycro on the bottom. Then have some kind of buckle on the top to definitely keep the zipper from opening. Otherwise, a full mesh pocket would be more useful.
The side pockets could use drainage holes. The top side pockets could be positioned higher. The top closing V-strap could be longer or have an extension for bear canisters. The hose opening could go away or have a layer of robic over it. The pack foam could have options like GG packs. I forget if the frame integrates w/ the belt, but that's always better when it does. The hip belt pockets could go all the way to the pack.
VERY similar experience with their Impassable 20L day pack; aesthetics are awesome but pack did not vent at all (3 days in Zion), rear stuff sack is tiny and doesn't stretch and the side water bottle pockets invade the interior pack space a lot! love the look and the water bladder functionality but otherwise not so much
I really like the way it looks. I’m a backpack nerd lol.
Big Agnes has discontinued these and there are some great deals out there (I picked up mine for $130 CAN.) As an overweight guy I haven't found a bag yet that the hip belt actually helps put the weight on the hips (5'10", 275-280LBS WITH A 53" belly and 42" waist.) The stiff sides and wide belt is able to comfortably provide support so that it actually spreads the weight of the pack to my hips, back and chest along with my shoulders. Not a perfect bag (adding my own tiedowns is a bit of a pain) which has made changes to how and what I pack, but it has made the hiking part of camping far more enjoyable. Bigger people looking for a better fit should check them out before they sell out.
I was thinking the same thing when watching your Texas video. I kept asking myself why the pack looked like it was riding on your shoulders.
Reminds me of my old Gregory Paragon.
I want more hybrid backpacks. Crosses between ultralight and traditional packs.
drinking game on "backpack"! lol. Great video Dan!!
Is the seam sealed zipper pocket lined with a different material?? It may be WP if that’s the case
The Shadowlight 60 squeaking drove me nuts. A little leukotape or chapstick helped a little bit, but it always seemed to come back.
How do you like Sierra Design Flex Capacitor 40-60L at 2.9 lbs? It looks good or an i wrong? Live the compression system.
I own this pack. LOVE it.
Hey man, just curious after you've spent some time owning and using this pack - how have you found it over time? Cheers. :)
Nice color grading, Emmett
Dang Dan. You’re the grim reaper on this one. That said awesome review, it’s nice that you’re helping people avoid spending money to be disappointed. That thing did look sweet for sure though.
Waterproof pocket is for a rain cover. Not included. Pretty sweet pack really
I've had a problem with my osbrey exos that sounded all the time. so I understand your frustration. Would be fun to see you test the FORCLAZ MT900 UL, klättermusen Raido or Exped Core. ;)
The removable hip belt pockets are to stash herbs in Dan, you know that rocky mountain high. 😂 All jokes aside I still am thinking about getting this bag. Having a 36 waist may hopefully alleviate problems you were having with it. I may use the trash bag for trail trash. Maybe attach to the hip belt somehow for easy access. Great video though, I always appreciate the honesty in the reviews.
Ok, Dan, have you researched any of the Deuter Backpacks? Check out the Aircontact pro 65+15 to carry all of your gear. Yes, it's large and slightly heavy but carrying everything you need is something to check out.
I have the deuter air contact lite and absolutely love it.
Hello Dan Becker, can you review the Lanshan 1 pro? I have been looking for a good budget sub 2lb tent and this looks like a good option, but there are not that many videos about it for me to decide it's a good purchase.
I'd be more concerned with the hip-belt if it weren't for the fact that I've never bought a pack without first trying it on to be 100% certain I like the fit, but I'm glad you brought it up I know to try it on.
Are the removable hip pouches attached with MOLLE webbing? If so the purpose might be to replace with alternative accessories like bear spray holsters and Nalgene holders
I don't believe that it fits the specific geometry of MOLLE, but there are two straps that disconnect. This allows you to remove the pockets and attach accessories, exactly as you hypothesized. I don't own this pack, but I've seen other reviews where people have mounted larger knives, multitools, and even holsters. Whether or not it's a good idea can be debated, but that was the intent -- allow the user to easily mount whatever they wanted on the hip belt.
Dan, can you do a review on the new Rapide SL pad
45 pounds, Dude? Daaayyyuummm!
I am glad I watched this video...I almost bought this at Scheels this evening...oh well...the hunt continues. When you coming back to the Black Hills?
You should check out the AARN pack Dan. Very interesting design.
Hey Dan, would you review the Paria therodown 15 quilt & the thermodown 0 sleeping bag?
dooo it. doooooooo it.
I’ve used the Thermodown 15 quilt down to 30°F strapped to a Big Agnes Qcore Deluxe (4.2 R Value) pad and it kept me cozy.
I ordered two bagbacks from Atom Packs in UK. Have you reviewed them?
Didn’t you carry an extra liter of water too? LOL
That was a great prank, full of ultralight tears!
Thanks for the review.
If you won't use it again please send it to me😅😅
Dan, once again! too many bags. I can help you taking one from you......🤣
Great video.
Can you do backpack comparison videos. Side by side you're stuff. Like to see a review like this for the shadowlight if possible.
Plus, you can do other great comparison videos, side by side. Give you more content without having to go out as much since you already got experience with lots of gear.
Edit: should of waited for the last 2 minutes. Oops. But still, more reviews, lol.
What do you thing about the 45l vs 60l?
60l all the way. Nominal weight penalty for extra room when you need it
Ah Ah Ah it’s not big and nerdy.
My framed Kelty pack and I laugh at your load out🤣😂😜
Damnit!!!! I just bought a Mountainsmith Scream!
Could that one pocket be waterproof?
Hey Dan am getting into backpack camping am looking for a really good backpack to keep for years to come have any idea? price isn’t a issue.
I have been looking at this backpack, and found the hip sizing very weird as well. According to the Big Agnes site the large size only has a minimum hip measurement of 35". I realize it's going over clothing, but I'd be willing to bet a lot of taller people who need the large are in the 32", 33" waist range and won't get a snug fit from the belt.
great video! with good real world feedback for the company to produce a better product in the future! Im a casual backpacker who happens to be in Alaska for a few months for work, and im in the market for a new 50-60L pack. price isnt really a factor as I will always pay for quality, but im also not needing some crazy ultralight "throughiking pack" as im just a weekend explorer. any reccomendations? I like simplicity too I dont need a bunch of pockets, i was looking at the osprey rook 60L (i think) but that outdoor vitals you showed at the end looks nice too!
Mystery Ranch Terraframe 50. Will live through the apocalypse, will carry infinite weight, very comfortable, no gimmicks whatsoever. I love mine. A backpack is the one thing that cant fail you when outdoors, besides brain and heart of course! : D
my recommendation. Theres also a new line called Bridger by MR too. They look amazing as well. But cant go wrong on the terra 50, they also have an 80l version but that is truly overkill for a weekend exploration.
"Head scratcher" 😂😂😂
With that zipper on the back won’t water easily enter?
I’m 45 and just getting back into backpacking. I don’t want to go ultralight or with the old school heavy traditional pack. Dan can you recommend something that falls in between?
Do a review on the Nike ACG 44 liter backpack! Not sure how I feel about it and would love to hear your thoughts on it.
@danbecker since you are not a fan of the bag and I'm looking for a new one....maybe we can work something out!!! THX for the review and all the vids!!!
It's like the Big Ages pack designers went to the On Shoes website for their color palette.
After watching Eric Hanson's latest video where they floated their bags and had to swim in the canyon, It maybe now makes a bit of sense why they put that one waterproof zipper in.
I love BA but yeah, looks like they blew it with this. It looks like they took the REI Flash (my favorite pack to date) and made it heavier and worse.
@Gone Awry the flash. They will make sure they show both and the flash will easily come out on top.
I have the 55 REI Flash(and 9 packs total) and it's my go to pack, best yet.
Expedition lightning 60 is framed, larger and lighter than this pack. So is the flex capacitor 40-60 from SD
I found this video 2 days after I received this pack. Um, yeah, Dan is right on all of it. But might I suggest a pack: the Sierra Designs Flex Capacitor 40-60 liter pack. It's just a better pack and it's beginner friendly.
I think the real issue is just belt sizing. If it isn't going to fit you, then no matter how hard you try, it just isn't going to fit. I can't believe the belt isn't interchangeable since torso length is practically set, between only two different pack sizes. BA could get a lot more versatility by belt simple swapping for perfect fit for greater range of people. I can relate to too big of belt, I had a pack like that I'd had bought on sale once, it never did fit and it was a most miserable experience because of it.
Edit update: BA will not sell smaller belts. I think you're right, after using mine, the hard fact realization that torso length determines pack size, the belt size is determined generic human sizing, which not everybody fits into. My revelation moment came when I recognized I could very well be loosing a lot weight on longer trails than when I first started. My pack size too, was purchased in large to fit torso length and the belt fit but was tightened all the way. I have to "hack fit" a length of webbing to replace the buckle system, to tighten the belt correctly so to ride on the top iliac area, in case of weight loss. I'll have to deal with it, if I keep the pack.
I don't think you can have too big of a back pocket on the back of your backpack. That would be my biggest complaint - that thing is just small and tight as well.
The trash can thing - yeah its a gimmick but I would find some other use for it, I'm sure.
Hi I am Andy from the Philippines, Nice backpacks out there if you have any available packs for me even the worn out i would love to have it my pack got damage on my last trip hope you can see this message, God Bless you and take good care in the great outdoors hoping to see more videos from you.
Love from the Phil!
What exactly causes the squeaking mentioned at 11:46?
BA is a jack of all trades and master of none. Maybe branding experts... 😂
You should try one of their $1,000 carbon tent disasters. Just set it up inside a 4 season tent and it might survive the night.
my tiger wall has been pretty good. I'm thinking about buying this and selling when my custom bag comes in. why not?
@@dustyc324 solid strategy. You'll enjoy the custom backpack even more after using BA's 👍😂
The back, belt and the water bottle pockets seem like a copy of the rei flash 55.