I'd love it if an animator on some show, knowing these videos exist, perfectly animated someone in the show playing piano, but animate them playing an entirely different song than what they are supposed to be playing.
If I had to guess, I’d say the animators took piano lessons for, like, 2 weeks, and just assumed the black keys are never used because they never made it that far.
I think the coralline piano being played completely wrong fits perfectly into the story. The piano is playing itself in the sole reason of impressing coralline to stay so the piano makes the noise itself while making the dad play it's keys in a random but albeit very impressive manor
You mean like the song that you hear is one thing, but the keys he presses if you did in real life play Never Gonna Give You Up by Rock Astley? I'm down.
The Corpse Bride clip you took as reference is in PAL speed (25 fps, taken from an old European DVD, perhaps). Movies were sped up for that format and that caused that the audio track was always half a tone over where it should be. I checked against the original speed (24 fps) and it sounds exactly how you play it in the "what they actually played" part.
7:05 i love how in this scene they put effort both into making the keys kinda accurate and making the synth look as similar as possible to the original DX7
I mean, the movie is about music. Besides, I'm pretty sure they knew that alot of musicians would watch and besides, animating it inaccurately would look pretty awkward and earn them alot of criticism..
@@alfredoosorio1381 the name of the character using his capacity to play the piano via dropping pens is "weather report" (his ability is also called weather report)
Piano animations are actually more accurate than I thought (except the Coraline one lol) Even when they don't match the exact notes, the codes do make sense in a lot of these
I definitely don't know what the actual creators of Coraline were thinking, but with how much detail and though that went into that movie, I'd imagine it being so off is playing into the facade like nature of the other world. E.g., everything's sounds amazing but when you really look at it, it's actually completely off.
@@IAmzColbz Yeah come to think of it, maybe the Coraline animation was actually intended to be wrong since everything in the Otherworld is supposed to be a fake.
@@mickeybat5816 which is part of the point. The other mother's world is so fake that as long as it sounds great to Coraline, it doesn't have to be realistic. If the other father stepped away from the piano entirely, it's likely that the music would still be playing since it's just a construct of the other mother's vision
6:35 this thing is actually very good. it shows us that anything that happens in this world is wrong, but illusiont helps us see it like it is how it supposed to be
I remember hearing somewhere that they paid *very* special attention to all the instruments in soul, and I think recorded one of the pianists performances and mapped everything to his keystrokes.
Your Lie in April not only got the piano perfectly right, but also the violin. Which is by far the biggest achievement I’ve ever seen in Animation/Anime
4:19 Some of the keys are played 4% faster than their original speed. So technically some clips are animated correctly, but due to their slightly faster speed their pitch also got affected This is more commonly known as the PAL pitch, as most movies play at 25fps here instead of 24
The frame rate has nothing to do with the position of the characters hands not playing the correct keys so this explanation means nothing to what the issue is.
Let’s take the time to appreciate that this man went through every single one of these clips, checked which part of the piano it was played in (not to mention that some clips have parts where the place of the hand is not seen properly), then replayed it off by ear. ++Respect
i really wanna see a show where a character is shown to be playing this like grand classical piece but really the notes that are actually being played is some sort of meme song
Im assuming it shouldn’t be that hard to animate the right keys on a piano, but having a show with lower budget than these movies with a usual hundred million dollar budget not being able to pull it off is kind of astonishing.
@@Realfm0lk I mean it’s so simple why would any animator have any musical experience to get right or should they even care so what if it is no cares that make the movie or low quality since nobody cares to hard to do it unless it’s a story about music
The corpse bride one got me… the lower key transposed version actually sounds better to me than the way it’s actually meant to be played. One sounds a bit more dark and the other has a more uplifted sound, then again I think the song is played in two different keys depending on the point in the movie unless I’m remembering it wrong.
It's kinda crazy how for the Ghost Bride, they animated a piano correctly... IN STOP MOTION. That's just so much extra effort for an animation style that is already one of if not the most difficult to do.
It’s arguably easier to animate piano in stop motion and 3D than 2D..as you have the scale there, just move the parts to the right keys 😅 in 2D you have to draw every frame and scale can get wonky
I guess the Corpse Bride’s piano is half key because the piano is in land of the dead. So they wouldn’t bother to tune them correctly and it was broken down. Also, in same movie, I wonder if the skeleton played correct piano in “Die, die we all pass away” song. “Your lie in April” did both Piano and Violin’s animation right. I watched 2set Violins commented on the Violin part before. That anime really something.
It's less interesting than that. It's half a step up because the clip was taken from a PAL copy that accelerated the video track from 24 fps to 25 and the audio along with it.
Would not be out of place ... it's pretty common for old, pretty used pianos even in the real world. If the tuning blocks are too worn out and the strings too stretched to hold a 440Hz tune, you can just tune them a semitone or 2 lower as long they are to be played solo only. (And not by someone having perfect pitch).
For the Tinkerbell Chopsticks: Tinkerbell steps back on to E and Terrence on to A before they move from D and B to C and C. As well, they move further down/up the scale at the end and you don't. Was I right?
I’m surprised Part 6 got it so accurate tbh, I always thought they’d just fudge it to make the scene look cool, nice to know David Production put in the effort
Pasaron muchos meses pero igual lo digo, en esa escena no se ven las notas ya que el dejó de verlas por un trauma que tiene a causa de su madre muerta. Cuando inicia a tocar si se ven pero cuando recuerda a su madre desaparecen.
Makes sense in the anime though. In story, he couldn't really hear what he was playing, like he was underwater and the notes were blurred. So, by blurring the music, it shows he can't really focus on what he's actually playing.
The chopsticks song 3:05 was wrong because in the movies they animated and played the “fancier” ending but the audio they put over it played the simpler ending so it didn’t match up.
1:07 you are off on what she actually played. You can see she was using her left hand and right bc of the hammers. When you only played one note it was wrong
I really do like what you’re doing here telling me what animation is doing is wrong, but also telling me how it is supposed to be done correctly is both funny and amazing.
Big props to you for showing why the MC of Soul was playing but NOT just saying “he shoulda played this” since he was playing jazz and it was extemporaneous.
I like that they are all either horribly incorrect or almost perfect
And then theres Soul which has no mistakes
@@zenith8417 and Your Lie in April too
@@zenith8417 And JoJo
Tom and Jerry was flawless, too.
sorry gotta ruin the 321 likes
I'd love it if an animator on some show, knowing these videos exist, perfectly animated someone in the show playing piano, but animate them playing an entirely different song than what they are supposed to be playing.
that would be amazing foreshadowing
Hope we dont get rickrolled by a piano then
@@QwerginMemes yes like someone should play the world is dead when their supposed to be playing ode to joy for foreshadowing
just including a rickroll in the episode
I can see this turning into a rickroll
The thing that I learn from this is if the character presses a few black keys it's probably animated correctly
only when the song is not in c major or a minor lol
If I had to guess, I’d say the animators took piano lessons for, like, 2 weeks, and just assumed the black keys are never used because they never made it that far.
@@Naltrex Or D Dorian. Or F Lydian. Or G Mixolydian.
But eh - no-one really cares about those.
@@ARCtheCartoonMaster this destroyed my motivation to learn piano thanks a lot
@@plunger5030it’s not that bad, it’s just some scales lmao. Haven’t learnt them yet, but I’ll to it.
5:38 i love how even though this part was muted, i could still tell exactly what song they were playing 😭
that’s the most obvious one kid
@@estonianwithknifedamn you must be a fun person to talk to at parties
Bro he doesn't get invited to parties@@matt9999
@@matt9999He kinda has a point but eh
Rush e
I think the coralline piano being played completely wrong fits perfectly into the story. The piano is playing itself in the sole reason of impressing coralline to stay so the piano makes the noise itself while making the dad play it's keys in a random but albeit very impressive manor
The coraline one is fitting. The character itself is meant to be a facade to make her feel in awe
That’s what I was thinking!
I was gonna say that! We had the same thought!
6:26
One of the rare times where the piano not being animated properly not only suits the film, but also makes somewhat sense in the context of the movie
Plus, it literally has gloves that control the player's fingers, so the fact that even the Piano itself plays wrong, is a red flag
I think the reason why soul took so long to make was because they played the piano right.
And every other instrument
I wonder how long?
Ma men🤜🤛
@@gabrielyulaw1204yeah what men
Well yeah it is a movie about music after all
imagine a animator decides to animate the piano to play never gonna give you up but the actual songs different
Animator: oh yea it’s big brain time
That would be genius
You mean like the song that you hear is one thing, but the keys he presses if you did in real life play Never Gonna Give You Up by Rock Astley?
I'm down.
@@xxxhockeyxavier5172
Think about it when the animator plays too much "Big Brain Academy". That would leave someone else's mark.
I remember that actually happening but I don’t remember on what…
0:45 Moonlight sonata (Beethoven)
1:14 Etude N° ? (Chopin)
1:38 Für Elise (Beethoven)
2:59 Chopsticks
6:05 Rush E
7:45 Axel F
1:14 is the 11th of the Etudes
4:27 wow I loved that tone!
I gotchu! th-cam.com/video/EBS9o9RCyt4/w-d-xo.html
219 no comments ill fix that😊
The Corpse Bride clip you took as reference is in PAL speed (25 fps, taken from an old European DVD, perhaps). Movies were sped up for that format and that caused that the audio track was always half a tone over where it should be. I checked against the original speed (24 fps) and it sounds exactly how you play it in the "what they actually played" part.
Wow crazy attention to detail
Yeah I also thought it sounded a little more pitched up that normal and I don't even play piano
So that's why movies I watched on DVD as a kid sounded different compared to when they played them on TV channels...!
Awesome. But now I’m darn curious about the classic bugs/tom hungarian rhapsody cartoons.
It made me confused because I know how to play it and recognised that it was correct in the original clip
7:05 i love how in this scene they put effort both into making the keys kinda accurate and making the synth look as similar as possible to the original DX7
Lol, and they also switched the sound to synthric bass i think
7:05 is so satisfying 😊
Yup
what is that music name
???
@@mastmajagaming1457 the song is "axel F"
the fact that soul animated all the music parts right just makes it that much better in my opinion.
I mean, the movie is about music.
Besides, I'm pretty sure they knew that alot of musicians would watch and besides, animating it inaccurately would look pretty awkward and earn them alot of criticism..
Almost any animation that tries to be about music does it's best to it right. You can see the same with Nodame Cantabile and Your Lie in April
Same.
It's almost as if in order to properly show him pouring his soul into the music, the animators have to pour their souls into the animation.
@@Lucki_MORELIKEUNLUCKI
2:34 holy shit soul MUSIC GOT IT RIGHT
Lol i mean it’s a music movie anyways!
Pixar does everything right
Soul is a goddamn masterpiece, I was on the verge of tears every time the great beyond was on screen
Well I mean yeah the main character plays the piano and it’s a music movie ofc they would want to get everything right
Whats name this moooooovie
2:31 It was pretty much perfect
5:10 i love how he can play not just 2 notes in one note, but a whole chord!
yes i saw that too 💀
Every fake tiktok music tutorial be like
th-cam.com/users/shortsSZDCj1YHO2w?si=vf8LnIaGsrzVIimP He just made fun of them all.
I just love the jojo one. That scene is a great opportunity for Weather to show off the precision and versitility of his stand.
I don’t understand a fuck of this but I’m agree
@@alfredoosorio1381 the name of the character using his capacity to play the piano via dropping pens is "weather report" (his ability is also called weather report)
@@piksqu9544 Via dropping what? 🤨
@@piksqu9544Via dropping what? 😳
@@light_witcherPENS
Piano animations are actually more accurate than I thought (except the Coraline one lol)
Even when they don't match the exact notes, the codes do make sense in a lot of these
I definitely don't know what the actual creators of Coraline were thinking, but with how much detail and though that went into that movie, I'd imagine it being so off is playing into the facade like nature of the other world. E.g., everything's sounds amazing but when you really look at it, it's actually completely off.
@@IAmzColbz Yeah come to think of it, maybe the Coraline animation was actually intended to be wrong since everything in the Otherworld is supposed to be a fake.
Well with how crazy the dad was moving I don't think they could've actually done it correctly if the wanted to.
@@mickeybat5816 which is part of the point. The other mother's world is so fake that as long as it sounds great to Coraline, it doesn't have to be realistic. If the other father stepped away from the piano entirely, it's likely that the music would still be playing since it's just a construct of the other mother's vision
@@IAmzColbz tru. I was jus talkin about the fact it was a cartoon lol, not from a lore standpoint.
5:15 blud really played a chord on a singular note 💀💀💀💀
Tik Tok piano tutorials be like:
Let's just assume they tuned the piano incorrectly on purpose
😂😂😂
That intro scene for Weather Report is still one of the coolest ways to show off a Stand ever. And it was accurately animated too
6:35 this thing is actually very good. it shows us that anything that happens in this world is wrong, but illusiont helps us see it like it is how it supposed to be
Wasn't that also the entire message of the movie, aside from the predator message
@@localheaddealer1382the predator message is creepy af
What movie was it again?
The movie is Coraline
@@localheaddealer1382exactly
Of course Disney and Pixar are gonna try and get it as accurate as possible.
I remember hearing somewhere that they paid *very* special attention to all the instruments in soul, and I think recorded one of the pianists performances and mapped everything to his keystrokes.
@@charlieinthe_box he did, it was John Batiste who used to lead the band on Stephen Colbert’s show and wrote most of the Jazz music in the movie
youre saying that as if its a bad thing
Well especially in soul, would be pretty funny if they fucked up the animation of the piano.
I mean, just look at the movie soul
Your Lie in April not only got the piano perfectly right, but also the violin. Which is by far the biggest achievement I’ve ever seen in Animation/Anime
The idea of accurately animating a violin sounds like hell
it is@@TheNinja94a
I know I'm a major db fan but i think Your Lie In April Might just be the best anime i've ever watched
Which piece did she play in this clip?
hibike no euphonium and bocchi the rock, getting the whole band animated accurately
4:02 dang my fav sound is there
I like how some of the melodies are 💯 percent correct only with problems. 4:03
4:19 Some of the keys are played 4% faster than their original speed. So technically some clips are animated correctly, but due to their slightly faster speed their pitch also got affected
This is more commonly known as the PAL pitch, as most movies play at 25fps here instead of 24
No
@@iTacolot no u
@@iTacolot DGG: makes a point on how the pianos are animated correctly
Taco: says no and refuses to elaborate
The frame rate has nothing to do with the position of the characters hands not playing the correct keys so this explanation means nothing to what the issue is.
I agree Because of AUS 🇦🇺/ UK 🇬🇧/ PAL Tone
Let’s take the time to appreciate that this man went through every single one of these clips, checked which part of the piano it was played in (not to mention that some clips have parts where the place of the hand is not seen properly), then replayed it off by ear. ++Respect
I guess that's why half of them are replayed wrong on purpose!
4:36 Makes sense that an old skeleton piano would be ridiculously flat, if anything that’s tremendous attention to detail
But it is actually the speed, it's 25 FPS, meaning it's 4% faster. The PAL speed pitches it up. Meaning this was on a DVD.
I like your thinking aswell though
The fact you said a skeleton piano means that sans could do this all day because hes lazy
What is the name of the movie of the skeleton piano?
@@Intothepitbro987I forgot what it was but remember seeing the movie before…
The princess and the frog one is right since they were highlighting only one instrument with several others playing in the backround
6:05 Rush E
i really wanna see a show where a character is shown to be playing this like grand classical piece but really the notes that are actually being played is some sort of meme song
Isn't this comment copied from someone else?
Can always rely on JoJo to put in tons of effort into making things as good as possible
Ikr man dope as heck
yet another jojo dub
Im assuming it shouldn’t be that hard to animate the right keys on a piano, but having a show with lower budget than these movies with a usual hundred million dollar budget not being able to pull it off is kind of astonishing.
@@Realfm0lk considering how so many movies don’t animate it correctly, there’s probably a reason.
@@Realfm0lk I mean it’s so simple why would any animator have any musical experience to get right or should they even care so what if it is no cares that make the movie or low quality since nobody cares to hard to do it unless it’s a story about music
6:25 kills me cause it's so damn funny how it looks like he's just slamming the keys which would not make anything😂
Lol💀
@@Antiuttpdestroyerhow about, Lol😂?
1:34 i hope he like Fur Jaws
00:01:34-My True Reaction: 😂😂😂😂
For the coraline one, it makes sense that its incorrect, because most likely the beldam just used magic to make it sound like its supposed to
The cat (Is it a cat?) at 5:10 is so good he can make 1 key sound like 8 notes
Yea he's a cat quami from miraculous ladybug
@@samibeachboysandfullhousef8765kwami
It’s plagg the Kwami he’s my favorite person ever in show history
Miraculoussss simply the besttt
Let's go with cat
The corpse bride one got me… the lower key transposed version actually sounds better to me than the way it’s actually meant to be played. One sounds a bit more dark and the other has a more uplifted sound, then again I think the song is played in two different keys depending on the point in the movie unless I’m remembering it wrong.
It's because of the format, on DVD it was at 25fps while meant on 25fps
I love how the video is titled "Pianos are Never Animated Correctly" and then proceeds to show several pianos being animated correctly
I know I’m a year late to this comment but it’s a compilation of the most popular vids so maybe that’s why?
5:02 they did a really good job on the anime
It's kinda crazy how for the Ghost Bride, they animated a piano correctly... IN STOP MOTION. That's just so much extra effort for an animation style that is already one of if not the most difficult to do.
It’s arguably easier to animate piano in stop motion and 3D than 2D..as you have the scale there, just move the parts to the right keys 😅 in 2D you have to draw every frame and scale can get wonky
It's actually Corpse Bride but ok
I love that the piano in SOUL is actually animated correctly
Because they had too? It was basically a movie about a guy and a paino💀
@@Daily_Dose_of_Grass *piano
Can we all appreciate how fluent and beautiful the animation was on the piano scene
W...wwhic..hchch which one......?..
yea
I guess the Corpse Bride’s piano is half key because the piano is in land of the dead. So they wouldn’t bother to tune them correctly and it was broken down.
Also, in same movie, I wonder if the skeleton played correct piano in “Die, die we all pass away” song.
“Your lie in April” did both Piano and Violin’s animation right. I watched 2set Violins commented on the Violin part before. That anime really something.
It's less interesting than that. It's half a step up because the clip was taken from a PAL copy that accelerated the video track from 24 fps to 25 and the audio along with it.
Would not be out of place ... it's pretty common for old, pretty used pianos even in the real world. If the tuning blocks are too worn out and the strings too stretched to hold a 440Hz tune, you can just tune them a semitone or 2 lower as long they are to be played solo only. (And not by someone having perfect pitch).
4:56 now look at them yoyos thats the way you do it, you play that gutiar on the MTV
3:58 JoJo is actually very accurate!
For the Tinkerbell Chopsticks: Tinkerbell steps back on to E and Terrence on to A before they move from D and B to C and C. As well, they move further down/up the scale at the end and you don't. Was I right?
Yes
I’m surprised Part 6 got it so accurate tbh, I always thought they’d just fudge it to make the scene look cool, nice to know David Production put in the effort
I can't wait for my grandchildren to be able to watch part 7 when it finally comes out
5:51 it’s RUSH E but dull version, (AKA, RUSH DULL)
Rush D
Crush Rush A 2.0.EXE
1:43
can someone tell me what song this is?
Für Elise
7:08 Looks like rickroll
1:58 can you blame him, it's a TINY piano, it's pretty much impossible to play it perfect on a TINY piano
Plankton: will you stop that tiny piano!?
@@sophieheart2707 *Nuh-uh*
6:40 I won’t believe it!! He has those funny gloves from that piano D:
4:47 : Fun Fact, the book has no notes at all, but he still managed to play it! (Edit : thx for 104 likes, lets reach 200. )
😂😂😂
Pasaron muchos meses pero igual lo digo, en esa escena no se ven las notas ya que el dejó de verlas por un trauma que tiene a causa de su madre muerta. Cuando inicia a tocar si se ven pero cuando recuerda a su madre desaparecen.
Makes sense in the anime though. In story, he couldn't really hear what he was playing, like he was underwater and the notes were blurred. So, by blurring the music, it shows he can't really focus on what he's actually playing.
You will never dissapointme jojos 3:58
I'm impressed by how accurate most of them are.
7:58 High notes sound but Peter is already reaching the lowest octaves, WTF? O.o?
3:40 Woah this anime sure is bizzare..
And sure is an adventure
And about jojo
And about the bloodline
Hehe
I enjoy how much work Disney put into soul all the instruments were animated incredibly
At 2:55 the difference is that you went in on it, and on the audio you didn't.
4:27 Make This The Original Corpse Bride Audio It FITS TOO WELL!
love how plagg played a whole chord by pressing one note 😂
2:28 our favorite part of the video
The chopsticks song 3:05 was wrong because in the movies they animated and played the “fancier” ending but the audio they put over it played the simpler ending so it didn’t match up.
Correct!
It's amazing that he can even see the keys that they play on some of the angles
I love how a movie almost completely based on music, Soul, perfectly depicts every instrument
0:44 the better question is if he played this accurately, would they be dead?
Yes
Yes
Sure
Well which keys are Rick and Morty under??
5:27 is my favorite
These clips are the pure definition of “He a bit confused, but he’s got the spirit”
1:24 BRO WHO ANIMATED THOSE FINGERS 💀💀💀💀💀
Lol
The fingers are real slow
macaroni ahh fingers bro 😭😭🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Those goofy ah fingers can't bend bro💀
bro got cheese strings for fingers
8:03 why is the family guy one so funny 😂😂😭
It’s the same thing with violin/viola/bass/cello. I played viola for a long time and it always gets me whenever I see one of these played on tv
Not sure what I was expecting at 6:33
The best part out of the whole thing. It's hilarious.
I like to think that it’s on purpose as that world is perfect and something that should sound horrible will be made to sound perfect.
@@DoneRegularly On one hand, it's fitting with the shows theme, on the other hand... *_banging piano noises_*
What the name this song 6:26
@@lrf7teen747 other father song from coraline
1:07 you are off on what she actually played. You can see she was using her left hand and right bc of the hammers. When you only played one note it was wrong
It didn’t show what she actually played after a few seconds that’s why he resorted to the one note probably as a bit
@@william3371nah you can see the hammers go down
You can see she's still playing throuvh the back of the piano @@william3371
You have to appreciate that in the movie about music and finding purpose in life, they get the music right.
5:33 this chord is Db7 (add9) or 9
2:10 gotta give peobody points. Must be hard reachin with paws
Fr the piano looks so long
I love how accurate Soul is
I really do like what you’re doing here telling me what animation is doing is wrong, but also telling me how it is supposed to be done correctly is both funny and amazing.
7:52 this is my favorite family guy part in the whole episode
THE MUSIC JUST SOUND SOO GOOD (even though its not animated correctly)
4:19 It’s the UK version. The music is always an tone higher there.
As a person who just played a violin I’m proud of this guy
2:07 that hand movement though
2:50
still snoop dogg and dre
6:26 Coraline 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Same😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
My bro is spamming keys with his whole hands
What the movie?
@@khm3rboran…I want you to look at what the comment with the timestamp says and then look at yourself.
3:41 😮😮😮 my favorite
4:50 Tanjiro’s VA got enough of killing demons… So he’s playing piano now
Fr lol
What anime is it
Your Lie in April
@@TheCyanDuckYT Thanks
Big props to you for showing why the MC of Soul was playing but NOT just saying “he shoulda played this” since he was playing jazz and it was extemporaneous.
6:14 Nick Jr!
7:52 is the last one, and didn't show us how u actually play it
5:15 I like that he played a chord with just one key
8:11 Come on, Peter! You can do better than that!
Ok, on the second one, they were exactly the same. 0:20 maybe I’m missing something but I think it was animated correctly…
its interesting that while off key, a lot of them almost get it right
Go to 2:04 and wait a few seconds and the correction sounds like a Nintendo Wii sound
0:20 All of the notes are 100% correct!
5:36 Happy to see the one I requested there too!
Sad it got copyright claimed
2:42 they played it 140% correctly
The sound isn’t correct
3:17 i was so happy when i saw aristocats and jojos bizarre adventure
Major: 0:10
Minor: 0:14
7:08 what movie did this come from?
Monsters vs aliens
Monsters V.S. Aliens by Dreamworks
What is the name of the song
@@EliGalvez-j4o It's Axel F, NOT Crazy Frog
@@JAMESLORDTHE7TH thanks, but…………..💀💀💀