Genuinely so impressed by Vanessa Hudgens. She's obviously put in the time and work to hone her craft and it really shows. She's so beyond talented and did such a great job with this song that is unbelievably difficult to sing
honestly, I really thought Vanessa wasn't gonna be good as Maureen at all. and then she fucking KILLED IT. like, we know she's not idina, but she brought a sense of whimsy to Maureen and made the character her own. totally love this, Vanessa's a queen.
Shes literally nose singing. Hard to tell what shes saying. she was def used for marketing because without disney autotuning her high school musical sound she really isn't even comparable to broadway proffessional talent.
@@extatis I think you mean this is how she really sounds without all the bullshit like: auto tune or a studio or a cd with editing this is something you and I will never sing like . it's not spot on but nobody is perfect and every human makes mistakes that why she is not always on tune ,and some of the biggest artists are also out of tune look at some live performance's of them
@@stevieberkel9602 ummm most Broadway stars sing nearly perfectly in tune, 8 shows a week. I’ll give her the benefit of the doubt that this was a bad day, particularly since this was a dress rehearsal and they were told to mark. However, singing that out of tune as much as they both did in this would make most professional performers cringe.
This actually very impressive since this was actually the DRESS rehearsal. The guy who played I think Roger hurt his foot before the actual filming so they showed the dress rehearsal.
Kiersey Clemons is absolutely gorgeous! It's nice to hear a deeper more gravelly Joanne for a change not that I don't love Tracie Thoms version of Joanne I mean she killed it but it's nice to get some lower alto representation xxx
This is a popular for me cause agree so much. In my opinion, she does better then Vanessa. I would love to see Idina take vanessa's place in this scene and then just leave everything else.
I think that this is good. A lot of people said that Vanessa is not for this, but I like that both girls have a different type of voices, and I think that the combination really works! 👏 The interpretation is exellent!
i love her more as maureen instead of mimi, though i do love both. she absolutely KILLED this performance and i wish she stopped getting hate for both of them.
I think Vanessa did a good job with the pysciallity but some of her line delivery in this was too cutesy and sweet. I feel like that where her performance went week. But she did impress me with her physicality it had alot of potential.
Vanessa's voice doesn't suit the song, but her look and acting does and I think it's still good. Not great, but it could be much worse. They could have picked someone that failed across the board.
@@artisht4057 I have to agree with the person above. Her voice was too soft, high and nasally for the character she portrayed. The acting though is solid. If I were to choose Idina and Eva Noblezada makes a solid Maureen.
I watched so many versions and she was the only one I liked equally as the recording.... We are very differant people. I think these 2 are my fav ones so far.
This was a bad pairing in my opinion. They both have great voices, but when they sing together it almost sounds like they’re in pain. Plus there really wasn’t any chemistry between the two. Again just an opinion. But I did like Vanessa’s performance of Over The Moon.
It's a chop for me. This feels like Vanessa, the singer, performing instead of Maureen conversing in a sing-song way. For her to be an actor I'm surprised she didn't give her scene partner much to reACT to during the 1st part.
What even is thisss. Yesterday I was watching the original version with Idina off broadway, today I'm watching this and I'm like... what were they thinking? It's not even that Vanessa's voice isn't fit for the role (and it isn't, it's too sweet) but the stage, the coreography??? WHO DID THIS? lol
Oh my god the best Maureen Johnson and Joanne Jefferson ever. (Vanessa Hudgens and Kiersey Clemons) Rent: Live in second place are Idina Menzel and Tracie Thoms from the movie and in third place Tracie Thoms (Joanne) and Eden Espinosa (Maureen) RENT: Filmed Live on Broadway and fourth place Nicole Scherzinger and Tracie Thoms Rent at RENT at the Hollywood Bowl
Vanessa is really good but not compared to those broadway singers who've been training since they were children. I agree with other people that this song was a bit too difficult for her
Vanessa and Kierey voice way to small for this sorry not sorry, should’ve gotten someone with bigger vocals like Elizabeth Gilles and Amber Riley. This some high school level acting and singing
I agreed the part that aired was a disappointment. It was a dress rehearsal they did not know was going to be used. You can tell there were some scenes they were holding back, or a little pitchy. They actually performed the show while the dress rehearsal was being aired, and from clips I've seen, they were 10x better.
Yikes. This was just plain bad all around. Not hating on Vanessa at all, but neither of these actresses were right for the role they were cast in, the staging was lame, there was no chemistry at all between them, and while Vanessa overacted, the Joann actress underacted. Bleh.
Kiersey was so good in this but Vanessa is below the level. The song does not suit her voice. She sounds so cute when the song is meant to sound fierce, angry and sexy... while she totally manages to get the acting on point her voice was hard to make me think of her a Maureen.
This made me cringe. Girl with the white hair can’t even sing. Not I’m pressed from her. I still love vanessa, but her voice just didn’t fit this song lmao this ain’t it. Vanessa really did improve tho I gotta say
Nah who they should’ve put is Lea Michelle and Amber Riley and I’m sorry to these singers but something is missing and it’s flavor and they are singing it I will say it’s just bland. No offense to anyone
The Joanna voice is not good in my personal opinion her voice is flat, and her voice cracks a ton.. Voice crack #1: 2:28 Voice crack #2: 2:50 Voice crack #3: 3:10
I think the problem is... Kiersey is incredibly talented and she can sing but her voice isn’t this deep/low, she’s actively trying to make her voice deeper/lower so she keeps losing control, resulting in the voice cracks. Her natural singing voice is a little lighter, raspy, not deep/low with growls.
@@malin434 and the role of Joanne isn’t even that deep either, she sings some of the highest notes so idk why she decided to sing so low when her normal singing voice was probably fine
Genuinely so impressed by Vanessa Hudgens. She's obviously put in the time and work to hone her craft and it really shows. She's so beyond talented and did such a great job with this song that is unbelievably difficult to sing
I genuinely think Vanessa KILLED this!! she really captured everything Maureen especially her mannerisms
Agree
Shes nose singing.
i realize I am kinda off topic but does anyone know a good website to watch new series online?
@Stephen Gideon I use flixzone. You can find it on google =)
@London Gannon yup, I've been using flixzone for since march myself =)
My fiance: stop singing showtunes
Me: TAKE ME BABYYYY, or leave mee
WHEN’S THE WEDDING AHHHHH
honestly, I really thought Vanessa wasn't gonna be good as Maureen at all. and then she fucking KILLED IT. like, we know she's not idina, but she brought a sense of whimsy to Maureen and made the character her own. totally love this, Vanessa's a queen.
y'all we get it she's not Idina. Doesn't mean she's not singing the song well. I think it just makes the character a little cuter.
Shes literally nose singing.
Hard to tell what shes saying. she was def used for marketing because without disney autotuning her high school musical sound she really isn't even comparable to broadway proffessional talent.
She’s also out of tune a lot :s
@@meltedmarshdaddy Did you see her as Rizzo in the live tv performance of Grease? She gave an incredible performance, and her singing was high class.
@@extatis I think you mean this is how she really sounds without all the bullshit like: auto tune or a studio or a cd with editing this is something you and I will never sing like . it's not spot on but nobody is perfect and every human makes mistakes that why she is not always on tune ,and some of the biggest artists are also out of tune look at some live performance's of them
@@stevieberkel9602 ummm most Broadway stars sing nearly perfectly in tune, 8 shows a week. I’ll give her the benefit of the doubt that this was a bad day, particularly since this was a dress rehearsal and they were told to mark. However, singing that out of tune as much as they both did in this would make most professional performers cringe.
This actually very impressive since this was actually the DRESS rehearsal. The guy who played I think Roger hurt his foot before the actual filming so they showed the dress rehearsal.
You can tell Vanessa had fun playing Maureen
Better love story that Troy and Gabriella
@Kitty Kat you know nothing kitty kat
The best one is still Angel and Collins' one though TT. TT
You did not just compare troyella-
@@aja3684 oh we did.
Leia Organa omg..
I don’t remember this part of High School Musical.
It must be because it is not part of High School Musical! Don't be rude, get to know Vanessa's other projects, before summarizing her at HSM!
@@vhbrnews How is that rude...
@@vhbrnews i think it was a joke lol
@@vhbrnews it was a joke smh
😁😅😂
I like that she made this her own.
the chemistry between these two is brilliant
Kiersey Clemons is absolutely gorgeous! It's nice to hear a deeper more gravelly Joanne for a change not that I don't love Tracie Thoms version of Joanne I mean she killed it but it's nice to get some lower alto representation xxx
HELL yeah, she's out there reppin' us altos and she KILLED IT!!! 🔥🔥🔥
She can really sing. She never really got to show off her pipes on Austin and Ally, but she really kills it here
unpopular opinion: I luv Kiersey in this
This is a popular for me cause agree so much. In my opinion, she does better then Vanessa. I would love to see Idina take vanessa's place in this scene and then just leave everything else.
I think that this is good. A lot of people said that Vanessa is not for this, but I like that both girls have a different type of voices, and I think that the combination really works! 👏 The interpretation is exellent!
I love kiersey Clemons tone!!!!!
Vanessa was amazing and I love the crowd interaction
Vanessa can fit any character
this is actually pretty incredible
My heart left my body! OMG Vanessa killed it!
Absolutely!
The acting though, they did a great job!
i love her more as maureen instead of mimi, though i do love both. she absolutely KILLED this performance and i wish she stopped getting hate for both of them.
wow this just confirmed that I am indeed bisexual 🌈🤩
Good for u I am bi too
What a great audience
That surprise look on Vanessa’s face wasn’t scripted ladies and gentlemen she was indeed taken by surprise when homegirl grabbed her
Best Maureen and Joanne I've ever seen
yikes
@@darellgrant8753?
i prefer the original broadway cast maureen and joanne but these two are a very close second.
Vanessa looks like Cecily Strong in this
i was thinking the same thing!!! it’s actually uncanny in this wow
I think Vanessa did a good job with the pysciallity but some of her line delivery in this was too cutesy and sweet. I feel like that where her performance went week. But she did impress me with her physicality it had alot of potential.
Totally agree! She did a good job acting and embodying Maureen but fell a little short with the singing. Her voice needs more power.
When you put the two best musical franchises on Disney Channel together, those being HSM and A&A, this is what you get. Not bad 😎
Performance incrível.🇧🇷🇧🇷
She talented
Vanessa is a goddess
go home Gabriella you’re drunk
I CANT-
Hdudrxy gdvvdg BYE
LMAO
I don't care what they say. Vanessa Hudgens was a great Maureen
This was very impressive, actually.
I love Vanessa but I didn’t think her voice suited this song at all
I do love the staging though
strawie yeah.. like they are both great and all but neither of the voices fit the characters
This is actually really good
Kiersey 🥰
This role does fit Vanessa better lol
Yea right, she’s a sweet girl next door type, this performance doesn’t fit her at all
This was so good tbh
0:54 ATE
Vanessa's voice doesn't suit the song, but her look and acting does and I think it's still good. Not great, but it could be much worse. They could have picked someone that failed across the board.
YOU ATE JUST A HATER IF VANESSA
@@artisht4057 I have to agree with the person above. Her voice was too soft, high and nasally for the character she portrayed. The acting though is solid. If I were to choose Idina and Eva Noblezada makes a solid Maureen.
I have to agree it was kinda boring sounds. Or not belted
I watched so many versions and she was the only one I liked equally as the recording.... We are very differant people. I think these 2 are my fav ones so far.
@@padmeamidala3331 Here after the Shoshana-Eva duet I seeee ✊
Vanessa was surprisingly good. I would say even better than the other girl
So awesome just saw this today you’re amazing
This was a bad pairing in my opinion. They both have great voices, but when they sing together it almost sounds like they’re in pain. Plus there really wasn’t any chemistry between the two. Again just an opinion. But I did like Vanessa’s performance of Over The Moon.
Awesome!! Love this!!
talented!!
Hapa Pinoys can sing! Nailed it!
Cuando sos perfecta en todo❤
I see Gabriella have been taking pointers from Sharpay
Omg 4 yrs already ? ❤
Idk WHAT people are on??? VANESSA NAILED IT!
Guys Vanessa killed it hush up
Vanessa 😍😍😍🤩🤩🤩
Quit comparing it and enjoy it for what it is
It's a chop for me. This feels like Vanessa, the singer, performing instead of Maureen conversing in a sing-song way. For her to be an actor I'm surprised she didn't give her scene partner much to reACT to during the 1st part.
What even is thisss. Yesterday I was watching the original version with Idina off broadway, today I'm watching this and I'm like... what were they thinking? It's not even that Vanessa's voice isn't fit for the role (and it isn't, it's too sweet) but the stage, the coreography??? WHO DID THIS? lol
this is exactly what I was thinking like whose idea was this??? 💀💀
Very poorly casted all together
Imagine if the people at “Wicked” casted Vanessa as Elphaba
Oh god😳. I absolutely love Vanessa and everything but that just doesn’t fit her lol. Leave the moment for idina lmao
no. vanessa has a sweet voice and would be a great nessa rose. dont think she would be a very great elphie though
oh god that would not go well at all
I like vannesa but I dont think her voice was suit for this song but she handle it very well🙌
하이스쿨뮤지컬 보고 자란 팬으로써 잘하는줄알았지만 역시 바네사허진스 언냐 잘하구나 👍👍
Sharpay is doing her own version of this in a different studio for sure lol
and as of 2021 you can imagine a Pony singing this song now.
Haha love this
Funny she has played Mimi as well. Man, she's so hot in this clip. Nails Maureen perfectly.
Sorry I was laughing the entire time… and not for the right reasons
This was soo cringe worthy🤣🤣. I still love vanessa tho
Oh my god the best Maureen Johnson and Joanne Jefferson ever. (Vanessa Hudgens and Kiersey Clemons) Rent: Live
in second place are Idina Menzel and Tracie Thoms from the movie
and in third place Tracie Thoms (Joanne) and Eden Espinosa (Maureen) RENT: Filmed Live on Broadway and
fourth place Nicole Scherzinger and Tracie Thoms Rent at RENT at the Hollywood Bowl
Vanessa redeemed herself by playing Maureen from her horrible performance as Mimi in 2010..
❤
Vanessa is really good but not compared to those broadway singers who've been training since they were children. I agree with other people that this song was a bit too difficult for her
She’s been singing broadway since a child lmaooo
Oh my lord 😻
Vanessa and Kierey voice way to small for this sorry not sorry, should’ve gotten someone with bigger vocals like Elizabeth Gilles and Amber Riley. This some high school level acting and singing
Wow 👏🏽
vanessa is fine but she really needs more training.
I don't think their voices much well when they sing simultaneously
They could’ve worked a bit more on their blend tbh
Vanessa played Maureen? I thought she did Mimi 🤔
So Hot!!!!! I love that Joanne and Maureen so much!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Adult Gabriella Montez
Vanessa was pretty pitchy here, and it was stuck in her nose most of the song. She isnt Idina, but like...she was flat more than she was on pitch
I like this version almost as much as Idena Menzel's version.
They needed better singers.
3 some? Please?
She did rent...🙄
that harmonizing just wasn’t it
Is it just me or do i not like how Vanessa Hudgens sounds in this?
that girl with the short hair cannot sing like wtf
@G. B. doesn't mean Vanessa can't sing tho, idk why y'all think she can't.
Chloe Cottom they both have short hair
BAHAHAHAHAHA I CANT-
John Wick 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
John Wick yeah that is true. She kinda made me cringe a bit-
Is this channel legit Vanessa Hudgens?
This production was an embarrassment.
BrooklynRider they did really good, fuck off.
Matthew Henneberry ehh there were good parts but overall it was disappointing in my opinion
You try out then! Being in that audience would have been entertaining af
Oof
I agreed the part that aired was a disappointment. It was a dress rehearsal they did not know was going to be used. You can tell there were some scenes they were holding back, or a little pitchy. They actually performed the show while the dress rehearsal was being aired, and from clips I've seen, they were 10x better.
Yikes. This was just plain bad all around. Not hating on Vanessa at all, but neither of these actresses were right for the role they were cast in, the staging was lame, there was no chemistry at all between them, and while Vanessa overacted, the Joann actress underacted. Bleh.
No😅
Kiersey was so good in this but Vanessa is below the level. The song does not suit her voice. She sounds so cute when the song is meant to sound fierce, angry and sexy... while she totally manages to get the acting on point her voice was hard to make me think of her a Maureen.
This is a hot ass mess
Oop
This made me cringe. Girl with the white hair can’t even sing. Not I’m pressed from her. I still love vanessa, but her voice just didn’t fit this song lmao this ain’t it. Vanessa really did improve tho I gotta say
Nah who they should’ve put is Lea Michelle and Amber Riley and I’m sorry to these singers but something is missing and it’s flavor and they are singing it I will say it’s just bland. No offense to anyone
A mess
Vanessa still in a bed
The Joanna voice is not good in my personal opinion her voice is flat, and her voice cracks a ton..
Voice crack #1: 2:28
Voice crack #2: 2:50
Voice crack #3: 3:10
I think the problem is... Kiersey is incredibly talented and she can sing but her voice isn’t this deep/low, she’s actively trying to make her voice deeper/lower so she keeps losing control, resulting in the voice cracks. Her natural singing voice is a little lighter, raspy, not deep/low with growls.
@@malin434 Ooooh
@@malin434 and the role of Joanne isn’t even that deep either, she sings some of the highest notes so idk why she decided to sing so low when her normal singing voice was probably fine
🙄
Wow. I had read this was a disaster. I get why.
Sorry Vanessa but Idina's version is better than yours. 😅💕
vanessa's trying too hard... her voice has gotten better but it's still not great
Meh
a hot mess