🚀Go to galaxylamps.co/goodtimesbadtimes, use the code GoodTimesBadTimes and get your Galaxy Projector 2.0 with 15% off! 📌 Support GTBT on Patreon! www.patreon.com/GTBT ➡ Paypal: www.paypal.com/paypalme/GoodTimesBadTimes
Wow, I actually want that Galaxy Projector thing, not sure if I can afford it, but I already have lots of light-bulbs changing colors inside here, and that system look amazing. **"Writing wish list to Santa"**
If you are going to make a Russian perspective video, you are not supposed to state your opinion like you did by called the Russian cities some of the most poluted cities in the world. That is not the Russian perspective.
Russia is the country which expands itself as the largest country of Europe and the world but Europeans don't favor any good view on Russia's then usa,even Russia saved Christianity in europe by expelling ottomans islamic regime,but the europe won't understand Russia because of atheism vast spreading across europe rather then Christianity
@@himatakukawokan3942 you got that right, the Ottoman had all of Northern Africa, all of the Middle East and a quarter of Europe. And thanks to Russia, the Ottoman Empire shrank into what is now Turkey.
The funny thing is that Hubert was probably the self conscious one and thought people didn’t like his accent. And then everyone freaks out when he leaves😂.
36:06 - Speaking of societal pressure and feedback loop mechanism that democracy relies on, I've decided to bow to your many requests and return to the role of the channel narrator. Stammering Pole is back ;) and until I can manage it I will also provide the audio coverage I would like to thank Alex for the two episodes, though especially since some comments were a bit harsh if for some reason I'm not able to record, he'll be the one to fill in in return, please leave a comment or a like button as our performance has been way below average lately. Dziękuję.
I always wondered what accent this was. I’m American so I dont have a huge knowledge of the different european accents but for whatever reason I thought he was czech.
@@lucasglowacki4683the worst cigarettes I had in Poland had Cyrillic inscribings on the pack. The ones with everything written in Polish were top notch
@KarlFranz5017True, but that’s the internet…you will always have negative comments. I know it’s “not nice” and “not fair” but that’s how the world is…not always as it should be. There are always lessons to learn and a skin to thicken…life is full of little sufferings🤷🏻♂️
@KarlFranz5017 Now who's coming across as rude and insulting? :D Seriously though, I personally didn't see any rude comments from other viewers. At worst I saw people commenting on the mispronunciation of certain words and remarking that it sounded like an AI voice which, of course, it did.
No wonder performance went down with Alex. It's not that there was anything obviously wrong with his narration. It's just that Stammering Pole is the voice, the "face" of the channel, and so... with him missing, it wasn't the same. The content didn't hit the same. I legit hesitated to click this video because of that. There's just simply something really authentic about Stammering Pole, and the way he narrates, that we all seem to like and connect to. So I'm quite happy he's back.
Performance was down before that, go look at his channel's view numbers on videos going back a few weeks and you'll see the dip from a couple months ago
@@TheOriginalFaxon Well, yeah. Videos immediately prior to Alex had been presenting some oddities in the script. Also, perhaps the topics weren't quite as appealing. I reckon GTBT has been experimenting a bit with their video formula, trying to increase their internal production efficiency, but it has had a negative impact in performance thus far, so they are readjusting.
I think most people can’t grasp how dramatically world has changed with 2022 invasion. I’m Ukrainian in Ukraine, its been crazy 2 years, but it’s often shocking to me to comprehend that life will never be as it has been.
Not everybody is Ukrainian that lives in Ukraine. The only way our lives are affected here in Europe is by increased prices(inflation) and next to nonexistent Russian tourist/students visits
@okoice You think like a Russian who don't want to know or refuse to see what's going on outside your small daily circle. Everything has changed and you don't have to live in Ukraine to find out. You're as inside the global hybrid-war as anyone else, the only question is - will you wake up in time to choose the right side. Will the war come by deadly military means or not where you are is irrelevant. As long as you as much as make public comments about it or pay taxes, you're no longer neutral or impartial.
may be, but he is 100% right that West created instability in recent years, for squeezing money from young economies like Russia, India, China which have better workforce
@@LaplacianDalembertian Total nonsense on the economies of those countries, those countries are having problems due to the fact that they're over-regulated, corrupt, and hostile towards entrepreneurialship and innovation unless you're wealthy and well-connected towards those in power. When it comes to what this crank is proposing for the world problems, The cure is far worse than the disease, he accuses the west of creating for some of the world's problems, and that's true to an extent. But what he proposes is pretty much the stuff he accuses the West of doing, but on a fat greater scale and even more destructive. What's even more terrifying is that this person isn't just some crank posting anonymously on Reddit, he is a high ranking official in the Russian government. Putin and others may believe this nonsense, but what this guy is proposing is very much adjacent to what Putin's rhetoric has been saying, it is very indicative of the type of thinking that's going on within the Russian elite.
@@LaplacianDalembertianRussia beats world records in capital outflows. Russian oligarchy wastes money on yachts and possesions in London instead of investing in Russia and creating the wealth there. 140mln slaves willing to die for the benefit of their tsar. Stupidity of the people is so depressing.
24:26 "my plan works because i personally believe that my opponent will behave opposite to all publicly avalable information about their intended behavior" Oh yeah and btw if im wrong and they behave as they themselves have said, all of humanity dies in nuclear hellfire. Truly one of the geopolitical takes of time
The fact that you had to read the toilet paper that Karaganov published and then made a video about it deserves our sincere empathy. I am sorry you had to go through this, but we thank you for making us aware of what kind of nonsensical and conflicting garbage is filing all of the Russian elite's brains.
Russia's elite, and the rest of the population in general, have a sort of "bunker mentality" combined with the idea that their hardships have made them tougher and stronger. Combined with their disregard for life (which everyone else knows too) gives them the assumption that they can bluff their way out of problems. They do this under the assumption that the West, who value peace and the lives and wellbeing of their citizens, would rather just let Russia have what it wants instead of risking a war.
Thats wy Russia is putting more resources to demobilise its opponents than to attack them through combination of intimidation and toxic propaganda. Propaganda has always been as important to Russia as its military.
did your ancestors got rick-rolled by the russians? or the evil nazi germans? if yes, do you hold resentment on the treatment of your ancestors by them?
@@attilamarics3374 What does this even mean? Will the legality of any "preemptive retialiatory nuclear strike" be litigated afterwards, and is the president is found guilty, he goes to jail? Using nuclear weapons in defense only is russian doctrin, but this can change if they feel like it. Of course, there are strong deterrants to doing so (like skyrocketing western pressure which is likely to be flanked by pressure from China as well, because who likes a country that declares offensive use of nuclear weapons as justified?), but it is not cast in stone. Especially if lunatics like this Karaganov guy have any say in foreigns affairs.
"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men in a society, over the course of time they create for themselves a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that glorifies it." -- Frederic Bastiat, Economic Sophisms (1848)
@@crhu319 You are using TH-cam an American website/company and have the gall to complain about the very country that has allowed you the freedom to bitch about it 😂
@@dytiscusmarginalis8443 Well who is pushing Russia ? West ofc? WHy nato needs to be on borders with Russia? Did Russia expand to western world or what? You can just write cope like 99% western bots you dont give real reasons why is nato keep pushing for war with Russia.
@@mathew9508 it basically calls for everyone west of Berlin to be turned into Dust lol. It's not just mein Kampf, like Himmler wrote doctrinal essays to explain the ideology for the SS and like this is basically the same thing
this is my country's elite and it's mindset. I wonder how US thinkers thinks such a Russia is their future ally against China, they (american strategists) seems absolutely insane to me
The problem is these guys have way to many mass destruction weapons by the push of one button.. he basicly says lets play nuclear roulette.. there is nothing i can imagin that is more psychopath mode than this..
He's a damn nutjob... "we did the world a disservice by not threatening to nuke the West at the outset of the war", and implying that nuclear strikes on the West would not be returned in-kind...
Karaganov very conveniently points out the cancer of consumerism from the West but very conveniently leaves out the oligarchy who are themselves heavy consumers and part of the system. Interesting.
Ya it's actually great as if you take away those 2 cities the native people of the Asian north would outnumber these white Russians and you can only imagine the prison compounds they could put those who remain inti
In metropolitan area of this cities lives around 30mil so more like 25%, but counting that there are lots of minorities in Russia and a lot of people live in remote areas making them insignificant in globalised world, then you have around 50 million of Russians left. So not that far...
@@sirex9244 Did you watch the episode? I mean dude, he wanted to use Nuclear weapons, as to deliver a message from God.. if that is not language in the assylum i have never heard about it before.
@@sirex9244 What does that have to do with "Grand illussion in Russian thinkers"? And yes was a setback, but only because Russias leaders have no value for human life, and did throw what -10-15000 thousand russian soldiers life away there. So, yea there is that also. Stay on topic or dont talk plz, otherwise it just get pathetic.
@@matejlesjak3072 you are wrong. It's western oligarchs vs Rus oligarchs. I'd much rather keep living under the devil I know that under Putins boot. Russian living standards are medival
I started following your channel during the first weeks of the Ukrainian conflict because of your great focus on verifiable facts, and your ability to contextualize the chaos. Your voice reminded me of Caspian Report, which was very well enunciated and easy to understand. I'm sorry that everyone got so heated in the comments when you tried switching it up, but I think we were all afraid that you wouldn't be our narrator anymore, and that was a sad thought. I'm glad that you are willing to continue being the voice of the channel, as we all appreciate you and your team's hard work, as well as your presentation of that work. Thank you so much for making this great geopolitics channel.
Thank you for the two videos Alex, you have a great voice, it just isn’t what we expect from this channel. Gaining a new friend does not repair the damage of losing an old one. And gaining a new narrator, even an excellent one, is not the same as keeping the old one who we know and love.
So the Russian point of view is in a nutshell, violence is justified, even expected if it advances Russian objects, but no one else should take this perspective. Glad by accident of birth I don't live in Russia or its periphery.
Even their "rational" point of view is mad. They have a severe lack of irony as well as they fail to understand that Russia is in a state of severe decline. They presume that the CCP is their ally, but the reality is that they're nothing more than a client state of the party. It seems like a trend for every person living in a dictatorship to project their own situation onto Western countries, then act as if they're somehow better off because of it.
@lif6737 Because there are emerging countries that have prospects for dynamic development. The share of GDP of Western countries will fall, as well as their ability to influence the rest of the world. A couple of centuries ago, the West had colonies all over the world, which it could plunder. The accumulated potential and the industrial revolution, even the opportunity for the West to dominate the world. Now that dominance is beginning to decline. The world financial system revolves around Western countries, large Western corporations have the ability to extract resources cheaply from poor countries. Together with the historical memory of colonies, this gives these countries a reason for resentment. Based on your question I conclude that you don't even realize it.
@@NameRiioz resenting in a hut doesn't change the world. the reality is that western technology is required for any sort of advancement to a state that could challenge the west, china in all its power cannot technologically challenge the west and they know it, its why they go back and forth. russia cannot operate its gas and oil fields without western technology either. the reality is if you want to be bitter and resentful for things that happened hundreds of years ago you are welcome to, it will be in a corrupt shithole though, or you can actually work with the west and develop your economy, create a deliberative democracy and advance your society. the west is happy to do it too, look at how much of the world has become developed and become important partners and equals. the reality is this resentment is stoked by despots who wish to distract from the plundering they are doing. you can get big mad about that reality or you can accept it.
@@NameRiioz Given your one-dimensional text wall, you don't even realise ru. still is essentially a colon. empire. To this very day. Griefing hard over it's formerly lost "dominions". So good job.
I understand the historic desire for the Russian State to establish land buffers between itself and its historic enemies, but why is this argument still used in a modern context where Russia is in possession of the World's largest stockpile of nuclear weapons?
Because that's just excuse for imperialistic, terrorist aspirations of russian state. Allofvthe russia's "enemies” are just former victims which they all have to be constantly on guard 😞
Because there might once come a day again when nuclear weapons can be almost perfectly countered. At that time, they'd not want a bunch of powerful enemies right on their borders.
@@Tomislavr7 what powerful enemies? Georgia? Lithuania? Finland? The only powerful neighbor that can crush Russia is China and Putin behaves like Xi's puppet
Alex is not a bad narrator by any means, quite the opposite. Alex' presentation and narration is just great. The problem, I think, is that he just isn't Hubert. I don't really know how to describe it, but it kinda feels like Hubert's voiceover gives the channel it's character, in a way. It's just something nice about hearing Hubert introduce the episode with "Welcome to The 20's Report." - It's the same as the introduction to ColdFusion, where the AI says "You are watching ColdFusion TV" And again, I cannot stress this enough, Alex is a great narrator. We don't hate/dislike him at all, we've just "grown up" for lack of a better term, with Hubert.
GTBT I think what happened is that you filled in the wrong part of your work flow. You're the super star now. You should try and fill in for researchers and writers and remain our beloved host. The other orator was great, but your voice is the identity of the channel. Please stay healthy!
yes, I said that. If he needs help, he should seek it in other parts of his video creation process. The narration and voice over must be the easiest part of the process by far.
Yes, I agree, the other narrator was very good, but so much the same as in many other channels. I stopped subscribing, but with return of "stammering Pole" (I never noticed any stammering though...) I'm back too. Have a great weekend everyone! 🙂
I love you Polish Guy! My absolute favorite channel, all categories included. I can't help to feel bad for Alex, however. He's a great narrator. But imagine having Sir David Attenborough replaced with Samuel L Jackson for a BBC Nature Documentary. Samuel L Jackson have done other documentaries, and he's done a great job. But there's a special feel with SDA in BBC's doc's, that can't be replaced.
I've been following you since the beginning of the 2022 Ukrian invasion, just wanted to leave this comment to push up your engagement because I relly think it's important what you do. Also Alex did a great job as well, people hate change :)
I only began to understand the Russian psique after learning about their history: their paranoia, centralization of power and corrupt bureaucracy predates the USSR by centuries. Their nearly annihilation and occupation under the Mongols shaped how Russian see the rest of the world and what is needed to survive. Napoleon and Hitler only reaffirmed their convictions. I still condemn all their military incursions since the fall of the USSR, but now I understand why they believe they are justified, as reprehensible as we in the West mind find them (as we should).
It's a bad neighborhood for sure. Geocide seems to be their go to method for dealing with perceived threats. I find it odd they perceived Ukraine more of a threat than the Islamic countries to the South. Europeans in general no longer have conquest in mind from what I see. They (Russia) were profiting nicely from selling NG and oil to the West. The Islamic ideology certainly still has conquest in mind. And has no issue with terrorism to achieve it. As recently has been shown in Russia itself.
That's the main problem of the western countries. They understand only themselves-western mentality. It's the same with their values which they consider as universal values. That's why this is the end of the unipolar world where the US, EU and Australia are done.
Nop! ruZia today is last colonial empire!!! Just it's colonies are it's nabers and not over sees like in case of European colonial empires of the past! There for ruZians today are reciving pleasure when they think that they are the top dog. NOBODY in ruZia remembers their history cause its all fake!!! they lie and lie and lie some more. Revriting hisoty is a ruZian national sports practiced by it's ppl hating elites! The devil is walking the Earth and after he was finished with Germany - he went to ruZia!!!
No, you do not fully understand it. There is a really no way to understand russians unless you have been brought up by them. They are evil beyond your comprehension
Thank you for commenting rationally on the alarming content of the video, rather than the narrator. (NB I'm glad to hear Hubert) The truth really ought to win, but it's an ongoing battle.
It was funny for me to see most comments on one video talking about the voiceover and not the actual video. But I still enjoyed it. Trzymajcie tak dalej
I didn't have any issues with the other narrator but I was used to the original one. Very good episode. I've been planning on reading this guys articles but i think this sufficiently covers it. Thanks!
The statement at the end is not true. Most of the Russian population lives in cities, where basic needs are good. Many villages are also in good condition, but there it is more difficult. The problem is that there is a tendency for people to leave villages for cities, so many villages are abandoned and the infrastructure is not developing. Of course, you can find troubled places in Russia and take photographs, but making loud statements is very reckless.
Performance below average has been a widespread issue, many are suffering burnout at the hands of the information wars and the garbage being thrown at us by the Chinese & Russian bots. As for the harsh comments on the other narrator, just another example of how toxic the social media environment is. Thanks for the great report. Looking forward to the next one.
It is a testament to Hubert's use of language as a tool that his voice was missed when absent. But it's the content of this youtube channel that makes it an exemplary analysis. Perhaps it's also a testament to the the fact that 1st-language English speakers don't often hear quality discussion in a American or British accent anymore, and have come to regard a such an accent as suspect, or frivolous. Bring back Alex, at least sometimes.
I just discovered this Chanel. Great content, I disagree with the general assessment of the geopolitical situation in the world and the current developments, but the intellectual quality of the content of this channel is to be taken into account, therefore I subscribe, it's always good to listen at what those who think different than me, and when they do in this inteligent manner is even necessary to do so.
Not to get on the “Polish train” or anything but seriously…Poland NEEDS to take a lead in Europe. They’re one of the few who haven’t completely lost their minds and are still big enough to make a difference!🇵🇱👌🏼
I still "watched" the previous videos but i really "listen" to Hubert. You're an amazing narrator. Like David Attenborough has his distinctive voice, so do you. Every time you release a video i can't wait to listen to it. So glad to hear you back again.
🚀Go to galaxylamps.co/goodtimesbadtimes, use the code GoodTimesBadTimes and get your Galaxy Projector 2.0 with 15% off!
📌 Support GTBT on Patreon! www.patreon.com/GTBT
➡ Paypal: www.paypal.com/paypalme/GoodTimesBadTimes
Wow, I actually want that Galaxy Projector thing, not sure if I can afford it, but I already have lots of light-bulbs changing colors inside here, and that system look amazing.
**"Writing wish list to Santa"**
@0:26 "the author of these feces" 😂
If you are going to make a Russian perspective video, you are not supposed to state your opinion like you did by called the Russian cities some of the most poluted cities in the world. That is not the Russian perspective.
Russia is the country which expands itself as the largest country of Europe and the world but Europeans don't favor any good view on Russia's then usa,even Russia saved Christianity in europe by expelling ottomans islamic regime,but the europe won't understand Russia because of atheism vast spreading across europe rather then Christianity
@@himatakukawokan3942 you got that right, the Ottoman had all of Northern Africa, all of the Middle East and a quarter of Europe. And thanks to Russia, the Ottoman Empire shrank into what is now Turkey.
The old narrator received too much hate; but I’m happy to see the old narrator back!
*new
The funny thing is that Hubert was probably the self conscious one and thought people didn’t like his accent. And then everyone freaks out when he leaves😂.
Yea ngl I didn’t like the first narrator but damn those comments were rough. Hope he didn’t look through for long.
I find his voice calming. I listen to the horrible state of the world to help me fall asleep.
@@lucasglowacki4683are you sure it’s him? Sounds like a different guy to me
36:06 - Speaking of societal pressure and feedback loop mechanism that democracy relies on, I've decided to bow to your many requests and return to the role of the channel narrator.
Stammering Pole is back ;)
and until I can manage it I will also provide the audio coverage I would like to thank Alex for the two episodes, though especially since some comments were a bit harsh if for some reason I'm not able to record, he'll be the one to fill in in return, please leave a comment or a like button as our performance has been way below average lately.
Dziękuję.
Alex did a great job! Just not quite the voice we've come to trust.
Yea I dont get some the hate he got. He wasn't bad. He just wasn't what we grew to know and love.
Same thing happened to the Filmento youtube channel. Human brains don't like change.
thank you
Alex was so.smooth, naah we like the Polski accent 😊
Babe, wake up, we got the Polish guy back on GTBT!
I always wondered what accent this was. I’m American so I dont have a huge knowledge of the different european accents but for whatever reason I thought he was czech.
@@user-mm1nt1it5v It's neither, he's from Baku, Azerbaijan, he mentioned it in another episode
@@swagmastero9278 That's Caspian Report
@@ShunShufen How foolish of my, my mistake
@@user-mm1nt1it5vCzech and Polish are both West Slavic languages so their accents may be similar.
HE’S BACK FROM GETTING CIGARETTES GUYS
😂
Polskie Papierosy! Extra Mocne?😂
Finally!!!!!
He's Australian....
@@lucasglowacki4683the worst cigarettes I had in Poland had Cyrillic inscribings on the pack. The ones with everything written in Polish were top notch
Old narrator😍
@KarlFranz5017True, but that’s the internet…you will always have negative comments. I know it’s “not nice” and “not fair” but that’s how the world is…not always as it should be. There are always lessons to learn and a skin to thicken…life is full of little sufferings🤷🏻♂️
@KarlFranz5017 Would it have been better to sugar coat the feedback and effectively lie?
@KarlFranz5017 Now who's coming across as rude and insulting? :D
Seriously though, I personally didn't see any rude comments from other viewers. At worst I saw people commenting on the mispronunciation of certain words and remarking that it sounded like an AI voice which, of course, it did.
@KarlFranz5017 honestly i prefer the new one
@@ShunShufenabsolutely right on your point! We got back the Indian guy because of the direct outcry and outrage.
While im glad we have our old narrator back, i hope you dont get burned out!
Glad to hear Hubert back with the voiceover
No wonder performance went down with Alex.
It's not that there was anything obviously wrong with his narration. It's just that Stammering Pole is the voice, the "face" of the channel, and so... with him missing, it wasn't the same. The content didn't hit the same.
I legit hesitated to click this video because of that.
There's just simply something really authentic about Stammering Pole, and the way he narrates, that we all seem to like and connect to.
So I'm quite happy he's back.
Performance was down before that, go look at his channel's view numbers on videos going back a few weeks and you'll see the dip from a couple months ago
@@TheOriginalFaxon Well, yeah. Videos immediately prior to Alex had been presenting some oddities in the script.
Also, perhaps the topics weren't quite as appealing.
I reckon GTBT has been experimenting a bit with their video formula, trying to increase their internal production efficiency, but it has had a negative impact in performance thus far, so they are readjusting.
I think most people can’t grasp how dramatically world has changed with 2022 invasion. I’m Ukrainian in Ukraine, its been crazy 2 years, but it’s often shocking to me to comprehend that life will never be as it has been.
Not everybody is Ukrainian that lives in Ukraine. The only way our lives are affected here in Europe is by increased prices(inflation) and next to nonexistent Russian tourist/students visits
@okoice
You think like a Russian who don't want to know or refuse to see what's going on outside your small daily circle. Everything has changed and you don't have to live in Ukraine to find out. You're as inside the global hybrid-war as anyone else, the only question is - will you wake up in time to choose the right side. Will the war come by deadly military means or not where you are is irrelevant. As long as you as much as make public comments about it or pay taxes, you're no longer neutral or impartial.
@@okoice have you seen the video?
@@okoice you have written 2 unrelated sentences, both of which is unrelated to the original comment or video
@@okoice you must be not paying attention. Ukrainian and russian refugees became a significant portion of european population in two years.
Karaganov is literally a Video Game Villain
He makes Makarov from COD look sane in compression!🤣
may be, but he is 100% right that West created instability in recent years, for squeezing money from young economies like Russia, India, China which have better workforce
@@LaplacianDalembertianThey didn’t squeeze anything out of those economies…
@@LaplacianDalembertian Total nonsense on the economies of those countries, those countries are having problems due to the fact that they're over-regulated, corrupt, and hostile towards entrepreneurialship and innovation unless you're wealthy and well-connected towards those in power. When it comes to what this crank is proposing for the world problems, The cure is far worse than the disease, he accuses the west of creating for some of the world's problems, and that's true to an extent. But what he proposes is pretty much the stuff he accuses the West of doing, but on a fat greater scale and even more destructive. What's even more terrifying is that this person isn't just some crank posting anonymously on Reddit, he is a high ranking official in the Russian government. Putin and others may believe this nonsense, but what this guy is proposing is very much adjacent to what Putin's rhetoric has been saying, it is very indicative of the type of thinking that's going on within the Russian elite.
@@LaplacianDalembertianRussia beats world records in capital outflows. Russian oligarchy wastes money on yachts and possesions in London instead of investing in Russia and creating the wealth there. 140mln slaves willing to die for the benefit of their tsar. Stupidity of the people is so depressing.
Russia: *threatens nuclear apocalypse*
Tiktok activists: "Why is the west so aggressive :("
It's just sabre-rattling
West isn't good, but that's no excuse for anyone else
Tiktok is pretty much a CCP propaganda app, so its not surprise that the people using it would align with despots aboard
@@Josep_Hernandez_Lujan aka being aggressive.
It’s to keep NATO out. You think 30 countries attacking one country is fair?
24:26 "my plan works because i personally believe that my opponent will behave opposite to all publicly avalable information about their intended behavior"
Oh yeah and btw if im wrong and they behave as they themselves have said, all of humanity dies in nuclear hellfire.
Truly one of the geopolitical takes of time
The fact that you had to read the toilet paper that Karaganov published and then made a video about it deserves our sincere empathy. I am sorry you had to go through this, but we thank you for making us aware of what kind of nonsensical and conflicting garbage is filing all of the Russian elite's brains.
u poor potato
Thank goodness the video has the fine Polish I've come to o expect.
* 3:22 - Correction: And so there are plenty of reasons to look at the world * through the eyes of Karaganov*
Taraganov’s entire outlook is contingent upon Russias enemies doing nothing..
That’s a pretty shortsighted baseline to hinge his reality on..
Russia's elite, and the rest of the population in general, have a sort of "bunker mentality" combined with the idea that their hardships have made them tougher and stronger. Combined with their disregard for life (which everyone else knows too) gives them the assumption that they can bluff their way out of problems. They do this under the assumption that the West, who value peace and the lives and wellbeing of their citizens, would rather just let Russia have what it wants instead of risking a war.
Thats wy Russia is putting more resources to demobilise its opponents than to attack them through combination of intimidation and toxic propaganda. Propaganda has always been as important to Russia as its military.
The title could read "Karaganov's Bellicose Ode to the Axis of Envious Resentment".
Or "The Russian struggle against the Germanic threat (Anglo-Saxons, Germans. Franks, Normans and other Western rabble)."
@@donrumata2274 Or the paranoid megalomaniacal Ruscian inability to learn from its manifest failures.
did your ancestors got rick-rolled by the russians? or the evil nazi germans? if yes, do you hold resentment on the treatment of your ancestors by them?
get* sry
@@donrumata2274 Envy, much?
Lets gloss over the fact the ruriks, founder of rus, were of some darn, "western" viking descent...
"preemptive retialiatory strike"
lmao orwellian to the bone
it’s literal gaslighting and projection lmao.
I hope you guys know that Russia legally cna only launch its nukes as a defensive action.
@@oliverwortley3822 Germany is a "revisionist power"? Jesus H. fucking Christ!
@@attilamarics3374 What does this even mean? Will the legality of any "preemptive retialiatory nuclear strike" be litigated afterwards, and is the president is found guilty, he goes to jail?
Using nuclear weapons in defense only is russian doctrin, but this can change if they feel like it. Of course, there are strong deterrants to doing so (like skyrocketing western pressure which is likely to be flanked by pressure from China as well, because who likes a country that declares offensive use of nuclear weapons as justified?), but it is not cast in stone. Especially if lunatics like this Karaganov guy have any say in foreigns affairs.
Thanks!
"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men in a society, over the course of time they create for themselves a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that glorifies it." -- Frederic Bastiat, Economic Sophisms (1848)
Fermi Paradox: Great Filter - Russia
USA is more of a great filter
@@crhu319 cope harder, bot
@@crhu319 You are using TH-cam an American website/company and have the gall to complain about the very country that has allowed you the freedom to bitch about it 😂
@@crhu319yeah, all the genocidal countries don't make it pass America to destroy the world.
@@dytiscusmarginalis8443 Well who is pushing Russia ? West ofc? WHy nato needs to be on borders with Russia? Did Russia expand to western world or what? You can just write cope like 99% western bots you dont give real reasons why is nato keep pushing for war with Russia.
This voice is fundamental for the BRANDING in this channel
YOU BROUGHT BACK OUR POLISH GUY🙏🏻
I was impressed as I saw myself at the end of the video😳
Literally like reading mein kampf
Is that even more agressive?
@@mathew9508 it basically calls for everyone west of Berlin to be turned into Dust lol. It's not just mein Kampf, like Himmler wrote doctrinal essays to explain the ideology for the SS and like this is basically the same thing
this is my country's elite and it's mindset. I wonder how US thinkers thinks such a Russia is their future ally against China, they (american strategists) seems absolutely insane to me
The problem is these guys have way to many mass destruction weapons by the push of one button.. he basicly says lets play nuclear roulette.. there is nothing i can imagin that is more psychopath mode than this..
You have never read it so how would you know?
one of the most depressing videos. How to reason with someone who lives on an entirely different planet?
You don't.
Wait
USA view of the world is much more insane.
Article 5 and MIRVs
And that’s why they call it the second world (third world being all other countries that are not the west or Russia)
yay old narrator, finally i can watch these videos again
Thank you for bringing him back. Now i can watch and enojy
Karaganov reminds me of the simpsons meme "old man yells at cloud" - Fitting, really.
Karaganov is a world class mental gymnastics champion based on the stuff he writes
He's a damn nutjob... "we did the world a disservice by not threatening to nuke the West at the outset of the war", and implying that nuclear strikes on the West would not be returned in-kind...
HES BACK!!!!! 🦅🦅🦅🟥⬜
Russian fever dreams be like...
Karaganov very conveniently points out the cancer of consumerism from the West but very conveniently leaves out the oligarchy who are themselves heavy consumers and part of the system. Interesting.
Especially since his boss putin lives in a secret bunker with strip studio and golden toilet brushes.
It is dangerous waters we find ourselves in.
Preemptive Retaliatiatory Strike? 😂
Preemptive contradicts retaliatory 😂😂
Welcome to russia where intelligence and logic has no place existing. Bunch of thugs acting like statesmen
Acountry with 75%of it's population in 2 cities shouldn't threaten nukes!!!!
Ya it's actually great as if you take away those 2 cities the native people of the Asian north would outnumber these white Russians and you can only imagine the prison compounds they could put those who remain inti
Why not? They know about MAD already. Also 75% of people do not live in Saint Petersburg and Moscow lmfao
@@Theodosius1999did they say moscow and saint petersburg only, or did they say cities? Stop being disingenuous
In metropolitan area of this cities lives around 30mil so more like 25%, but counting that there are lots of minorities in Russia and a lot of people live in remote areas making them insignificant in globalised world, then you have around 50 million of Russians left. So not that far...
Well not you, but the original reply did and you should’ve saw it. I’m not being disingenuous
Karaganov sounds like more of a propagandist than an actual strategist
Hes making sense
"Preemptive retribution nuclear strike"
That guy is batshit crazy :D
HE'S BACK!
Who?
God help us from idealogues. This is the craziet shit since Himmler.
Woke Culture and Political Correctness are insane ideologies
There is som kind of grand illussion in "Russian thinkers". It is like listning to the madest person in the assylum.
Go on and listen to USA or British ones. But i dont think you would hear some from your delusion
@@sirex9244 Did you watch the episode? I mean dude, he wanted to use Nuclear weapons, as to deliver a message from God.. if that is not language in the assylum i have never heard about it before.
@@larswhitt1549 "episode" How is avdiivka going , thats what i wanna hear from you, why we no longer see abruhms and leopards on the battlefield
@@sirex9244 What does that have to do with "Grand illussion in Russian thinkers"?
And yes was a setback, but only because Russias leaders have no value for human life, and did throw what -10-15000 thousand russian soldiers life away there. So, yea there is that also. Stay on topic or dont talk plz, otherwise it just get pathetic.
@@larswhitt1549 "no value for human life", another delusional bs that only proves my statement
Thank you for coming back, your community appreciates and loves your perspectives!
This scares the living hell out of me. We really got to put a stop to this Russian lunacy!
Who's we? You and western multibillionaires?
@@matejlesjak3072 you are wrong. It's western oligarchs vs Rus oligarchs.
I'd much rather keep living under the devil I know that under Putins boot.
Russian living standards are medival
I started following your channel during the first weeks of the Ukrainian conflict because of your great focus on verifiable facts, and your ability to contextualize the chaos. Your voice reminded me of Caspian Report, which was very well enunciated and easy to understand.
I'm sorry that everyone got so heated in the comments when you tried switching it up, but I think we were all afraid that you wouldn't be our narrator anymore, and that was a sad thought.
I'm glad that you are willing to continue being the voice of the channel, as we all appreciate you and your team's hard work, as well as your presentation of that work. Thank you so much for making this great geopolitics channel.
Stammering Pole is my favorite Pole
Glad to have you back Hubert!
The moment he realizes that nuclear war is not one sided he will see his big mouth shut.
Thank you for the two videos Alex, you have a great voice, it just isn’t what we expect from this channel. Gaining a new friend does not repair the damage of losing an old one. And gaining a new narrator, even an excellent one, is not the same as keeping the old one who we know and love.
So the Russian point of view is in a nutshell, violence is justified, even expected if it advances Russian objects, but no one else should take this perspective. Glad by accident of birth I don't live in Russia or its periphery.
Even their "rational" point of view is mad. They have a severe lack of irony as well as they fail to understand that Russia is in a state of severe decline. They presume that the CCP is their ally, but the reality is that they're nothing more than a client state of the party.
It seems like a trend for every person living in a dictatorship to project their own situation onto Western countries, then act as if they're somehow better off because of it.
@lif6737 Because there are emerging countries that have prospects for dynamic development. The share of GDP of Western countries will fall, as well as their ability to influence the rest of the world. A couple of centuries ago, the West had colonies all over the world, which it could plunder. The accumulated potential and the industrial revolution, even the opportunity for the West to dominate the world. Now that dominance is beginning to decline. The world financial system revolves around Western countries, large Western corporations have the ability to extract resources cheaply from poor countries. Together with the historical memory of colonies, this gives these countries a reason for resentment. Based on your question I conclude that you don't even realize it.
@@NameRiioz resenting in a hut doesn't change the world. the reality is that western technology is required for any sort of advancement to a state that could challenge the west, china in all its power cannot technologically challenge the west and they know it, its why they go back and forth. russia cannot operate its gas and oil fields without western technology either. the reality is if you want to be bitter and resentful for things that happened hundreds of years ago you are welcome to, it will be in a corrupt shithole though, or you can actually work with the west and develop your economy, create a deliberative democracy and advance your society. the west is happy to do it too, look at how much of the world has become developed and become important partners and equals. the reality is this resentment is stoked by despots who wish to distract from the plundering they are doing. you can get big mad about that reality or you can accept it.
@@NameRiioz Given your one-dimensional text wall, you don't even realise ru. still is essentially a colon. empire.
To this very day.
Griefing hard over it's formerly lost "dominions".
So good job.
@@alfisti93 Get your thoughts in order, then write.
Excellent episode.
Unhinged is an understatement. Total megalomaniac
That is NATO also Total megalomaniac with endless expansion and goals waht will lead direct war with Russia sooner or later.
Wonderful to have the Pole back.
I like any narrator you guys use, the information is what is most valuable, tone deaf youtube comments be damned
Alex was good. Don't ignore the good comments and just focus on the bad. Take the compliments not for granted that he got.
"Legendary Russian patience" lol what
This guy is a lunatic.
Patient with putting up with oligarchs, poverty, corruption, dictators, stolen natural resources, no civil rights.....etc...
I think he means the willingness to sacrifice whoever is available no matter if it makes sense or not.
Top 3 exports of soviet Russia- vodka,the AK 47,and books by SUICIDAL NOVELISTS.
Na he right
What drugs is karaganov on?
Western...
@@cte4dota Krokodil
I understand the historic desire for the Russian State to establish land buffers between itself and its historic enemies, but why is this argument still used in a modern context where Russia is in possession of the World's largest stockpile of nuclear weapons?
Because that's just excuse for imperialistic, terrorist aspirations of russian state. Allofvthe russia's "enemies” are just former victims which they all have to be constantly on guard 😞
Because there might once come a day again when nuclear weapons can be almost perfectly countered. At that time, they'd not want a bunch of powerful enemies right on their borders.
@@Tomislavr7 what powerful enemies? Georgia? Lithuania? Finland? The only powerful neighbor that can crush Russia is China and Putin behaves like Xi's puppet
How do you counter hundreds of trident2-s or bulava missiles? Those are being launched from submarines, and each missile carries 10+ warheads.
That’s what a fascist state does
He's back!!!!
Hallelujah! Praise the Lord, my prayers are heard!
I came.
I'm sorry to hear about harsh comments about Alex. He's a great narrator. But, well, I guess most of us are just used to your calm and rational voice.
Well .. France has a nuclear warning shot policy ... So .. maybe US won't respond but France might ... Just might shoot a warning shot 😂
That's an important fact most people don't know.
France will become a nuclear wasteland, all of europe in fact, if they continue to provoke Russia
All is well, welcome back.
Alex is not a bad narrator by any means, quite the opposite. Alex' presentation and narration is just great. The problem, I think, is that he just isn't Hubert. I don't really know how to describe it, but it kinda feels like Hubert's voiceover gives the channel it's character, in a way. It's just something nice about hearing Hubert introduce the episode with
"Welcome to The 20's Report." - It's the same as the introduction to ColdFusion, where the AI says "You are watching ColdFusion TV"
And again, I cannot stress this enough, Alex is a great narrator. We don't hate/dislike him at all, we've just "grown up" for lack of a better term, with Hubert.
GTBT I think what happened is that you filled in the wrong part of your work flow. You're the super star now. You should try and fill in for researchers and writers and remain our beloved host. The other orator was great, but your voice is the identity of the channel. Please stay healthy!
Agree
i suspect the natural flow comes from the same guy speaking as writing tho. he understands every intonation of the text as written
yes, I said that. If he needs help, he should seek it in other parts of his video creation process. The narration and voice over must be the easiest part of the process by far.
Yes, I agree, the other narrator was very good, but so much the same as in many other channels. I stopped subscribing, but with return of "stammering Pole" (I never noticed any stammering though...) I'm back too. Have a great weekend everyone! 🙂
Yes!!!!! Thanks for bringing back the original narrator!! Yay from New Zealand 🇳🇿 ❤
I love you Polish Guy! My absolute favorite channel, all categories included. I can't help to feel bad for Alex, however. He's a great narrator. But imagine having Sir David Attenborough replaced with Samuel L Jackson for a BBC Nature Documentary. Samuel L Jackson have done other documentaries, and he's done a great job. But there's a special feel with SDA in BBC's doc's, that can't be replaced.
I've been following you since the beginning of the 2022 Ukrian invasion, just wanted to leave this comment to push up your engagement because I relly think it's important what you do. Also Alex did a great job as well, people hate change :)
I only began to understand the Russian psique after learning about their history: their paranoia, centralization of power and corrupt bureaucracy predates the USSR by centuries. Their nearly annihilation and occupation under the Mongols shaped how Russian see the rest of the world and what is needed to survive. Napoleon and Hitler only reaffirmed their convictions.
I still condemn all their military incursions since the fall of the USSR, but now I understand why they believe they are justified, as reprehensible as we in the West mind find them (as we should).
It's a bad neighborhood for sure. Geocide seems to be their go to method for dealing with perceived threats. I find it odd they perceived Ukraine more of a threat than the Islamic countries to the South. Europeans in general no longer have conquest in mind from what I see. They (Russia) were profiting nicely from selling NG and oil to the West. The Islamic ideology certainly still has conquest in mind. And has no issue with terrorism to achieve it. As recently has been shown in Russia itself.
That's the main problem of the western countries. They understand only themselves-western mentality. It's the same with their values which they consider as universal values. That's why this is the end of the unipolar world where the US, EU and Australia are done.
Nop! ruZia today is last colonial empire!!! Just it's colonies are it's nabers and not over sees like in case of European colonial empires of the past! There for ruZians today are reciving pleasure when they think that they are the top dog. NOBODY in ruZia remembers their history cause its all fake!!! they lie and lie and lie some more. Revriting hisoty is a ruZian national sports practiced by it's ppl hating elites! The devil is walking the Earth and after he was finished with Germany - he went to ruZia!!!
No, you do not fully understand it. There is a really no way to understand russians unless you have been brought up by them. They are evil beyond your comprehension
Thank you for commenting rationally on the alarming content of the video, rather than the narrator. (NB I'm glad to hear Hubert) The truth really ought to win, but it's an ongoing battle.
It was funny for me to see most comments on one video talking about the voiceover and not the actual video. But I still enjoyed it.
Trzymajcie tak dalej
Yes!!!! So glad the old voice is back!! LOVE IT!!
WELCOME BACK SHIRVAN!😊
So happy to have the original narrator back.
An excellent episode.
Wao! Brilliant Analysis! Revealing the Motives & Ethics of Oligarchs 👍🏼
I didn't have any issues with the other narrator but I was used to the original one. Very good episode. I've been planning on reading this guys articles but i think this sufficiently covers it. Thanks!
Happy to hear the original narrator again!
The statement at the end is not true. Most of the Russian population lives in cities, where basic needs are good. Many villages are also in good condition, but there it is more difficult. The problem is that there is a tendency for people to leave villages for cities, so many villages are abandoned and the infrastructure is not developing.
Of course, you can find troubled places in Russia and take photographs, but making loud statements is very reckless.
Thank you for coming back and hope the other narrator wasnt offended, its just that your voice is the voice of the channel
Performance below average has been a widespread issue, many are suffering burnout at the hands of the information wars and the garbage being thrown at us by the Chinese & Russian bots.
As for the harsh comments on the other narrator, just another example of how toxic the social media environment is. Thanks for the great report. Looking forward to the next one.
I really appreciated the way you put their points and presented the counterarguments.
Where does the kremlin find these guys?
I prefer this narrators accent. Either way, been watching this channel for a long while. Love the content!
welcome back dude
we missed you :)
It is a testament to Hubert's use of language as a tool that his voice was missed when absent. But it's the content of this youtube channel that makes it an exemplary analysis. Perhaps it's also a testament to the the fact that 1st-language English speakers don't often hear quality discussion in a American or British accent anymore, and have come to regard a such an accent as suspect, or frivolous.
Bring back Alex, at least sometimes.
Why did I listen to this. It's like a star wars episode set in russia.
I just discovered this Chanel. Great content, I disagree with the general assessment of the geopolitical situation in the world and the current developments, but the intellectual quality of the content of this channel is to be taken into account, therefore I subscribe, it's always good to listen at what those who think different than me, and when they do in this inteligent manner is even necessary to do so.
Not to get on the “Polish train” or anything but seriously…Poland NEEDS to take a lead in Europe. They’re one of the few who haven’t completely lost their minds and are still big enough to make a difference!🇵🇱👌🏼
Polish elites are buying homes in Spain and America.
Polish proles will be cannon fodder.
Except the corruption is pretty bad there
They just regained their mind a few years ago. They were considered the crazy and corrupt ones not that long ago.
@@syedabishosainrizvi7817 what? No absolutely not. What the fuck?
With the new "democrat" government in Poland the chances of taking the lead are lower than 0%.
I still "watched" the previous videos but i really "listen" to Hubert.
You're an amazing narrator. Like David Attenborough has his distinctive voice, so do you. Every time you release a video i can't wait to listen to it.
So glad to hear you back again.
Yesss finaly our Polski is back 😊
33:40 - 35:40 is so well-said & a much important series of hard truths
Karaganov sounds ... unhinged.
7:54 Hello blazers, it is your boy Roman, your favorite neighborhood Russian!
Oh come on, don't tell me you didn't think that.
A review of Russian Fanfiction :P
i like this speaker far better, the polish accent gives this show the seriousness needed
Thanks for sharing the polish point of view.
Polish Guy's Back 🇵🇱
Czech.
Welcome back Poland bro. And no hard feelings to the previous narrator(Alex) he did a good job but your accent is just so unique :)
* wonders what the weather is like on the author's planet - maybe too hot? Ya gotta stay hydrated! *
Happy to see (hear) you back!
im happy the polish narrator is back, no disrepect to the other guy.
You're both pretty good at narrating. All the best & best of luck going forward.