@RealQuarkismGuy Your beliefs are yours, and my beliefs are mine. I respect your opinions because i was myself learned to never disrespect anybody as a person for their opinions. I may disagree with it, but i can never disrespect it.
Well it's more complicated.The fact is that every revanchist song are about Alsace and the Lorraine et revenge against Gerlan, so they are all looking like the other
« Vous avez pu germaniser la plaine, mais notre cœur vous ne l’aurez jamais » Mon Dieu… j’en pleure presque tellement c’est magnifique. Je t’aime France, longue et éternelle vie à toi 🇫🇷
Ben la plaine était déjà germanisée depuis le haut moyen-âge. La culture Française ne s'est développée ici que depuis la deuxième moitié du XXe siècle...
@@mwittmann68 arrete de dire des betises, la culture francaise date depuis des siecles voire des millenaires (Poussin, Chretien de Troyes, Clovis, Monet, Hugo, saints catholiques...), et est bien plus riche que la culture de nos voisins d'outre Rhin (je vois que tu viens de Suisse, inutile de dire que la culture francaise depasse la suisse). L'Allemagne aussi etait francisee quand Napoleon a conquis Berlin, et les nobles allemands, dont Frederic le Grand, parlaient le Francais dans le passe...
Les français sont germains eux-mêmes. Ils se sont juste romanisés. Nous, Bretons, sommes réellement les ennemis des germains, qu’ils soient Saxons ou Francs.
@RealQuarkismGuy bro what the hell dose that relate in anyway to the comment? Also im religious and I don’t care how you view religion like so sht u mouth
@RealQuarkismGuy First of all, this literally has NOTHING to do with the comment, and, even though I don’t believe in God, or any religion, you should still respect other religions.
@RealQuarkismGuy Oh goodness, you again I don't care about my faith, i only care about how you spam the same message over and over again. Also, Where the fuck you got a connection between a Revanchist Song and anything god related?
Long have i waited for that one, but George Thill’s version (one of the greatest tenor in history) is so magnificent ! :) (you can listen to it on youtube)
@RealQuarkismGuy shut the fuck up, this is a comment about someone liking a different version of a song more than the one posted, also, I'm religious and I still live a normal life and am not held back by said religion except for spending a hour or two at church once every week
@@IronWarrior57560 Just curious about the general ethnicity of the area because I have ancestors from the region who were German and I’m wondering if there still many Germans there.
@@ape1629 A sizeable proportion we’re probably ethnically cleansed and forced across the border at gunpoint. Coming from a family in which my great uncle was killed in the region by French nationalists due to beatings and violence, i find this to be a likely outcome sadly…
@@HansPeter_ No. 30 generations of my family have lived on the same land, it's just that three generations of my family were under Imperial German rule but were pro-French _at the time._ Not hard to see why considering how Prussia treated Alsatians. Of course, little did they know France would act similarly following the reannexations.
Vive le Kurdistan du Nord independante! Vive l’Artsakh independante! 🇦🇲 Vive la Chypre Grecque 🇬🇷 #TurkeyIsATerrorState #ArtsakhIsArmenia #CyprusIsGreece
Bientôt avec un peu d'espoir ce sera du kurdistan tout court! Nous prions pour les frères et soeurs qui se saignent pour leur liberté, longue vive le Kurdistan, et vive le Kurdistan libre!! 🇫🇷❤☀️
@SuperduperobergruppenstuppentruppensturmStuka So your arguments are false stereotypes and xenophobic thoughts about the French people lmao, you must have a really sad life
Other fun fact: one of our most successful generals in WW2 was from Alsace-Lorraine, his name was Marie-Pierre Kœnig and he led a successful campaign against Rommel and his allies in Bir-Hakeim.
Even though Czechoslovakia and France had complicated relations because of Munich betrayal, I personally admire French culture. Alsace-Lorraine is of course French and not German! 🇨🇿❤🇨🇵
Thanks you. I am alsacian and german nationalist that assume that we want to be german are annoying ... (At most some people want a special statue within France but nobody ever wanted to leave our country)
Munich betrayal ? You know that your country would never exist today without France right ? Czech and Slovak never rose against their Austrian masters. Not like the Serbs, the Poles, the Croatians, and even the Hungarians … What you are, it’s thanks to the French and allies blood during World War I . Even during the Napoleonic war, the Bohemians were happy to fulfil the Habsburg ranks and bring their slaves, even when Napoleon proposed to them their own nation. The wake up was in 1919, not before. You and your ancestors have no right to talk about any betrayal.
@@freewal You should learn something about Czechoslovak history before writing about it. Of course the Czechs fought against Austrian tyranny. Firstly during 1618, unfortunately we were defeated in 1620 in battle of White Mountain. Many members of Czech nobility fought against Austrians again in 1740. And during the Napoleonic wars we unfortunately didn't rise up, but it was because of almost 200 years of germanisation. We were still in early phases of our National Rebirth. And then we fought against Austrians in WW1. Have you ever heard about Czechoslovak legions? You should read something about them. They fought in Russia, Italy, France. Many Czechs fought in Serbian army and even in Greek army. And yes I was talking about Munich betrayal, because unfortunately French and British governments betrayed our country and gave Sudetenland to Germany. Even though France swore to defend Czechoslovakia from the Germans. That is definition of betrayal. (Of course I know that many French people wanted to fight against Germany, so I don't blame them, but I blame their government)
Il est important de comprendre la position de l’Alsace-Lorraine: Le Rhin est extrêmement utile à La Défense du pays, et c’est aussi une frontière historique séparant les Français des Allemands.
Le Rhin n'est pas la frontière historique entre français est allemand , l'Alsace est germanique de langue , la frontière* est plutôt au niveau des Vosges (signé un alsacien :) ) *au niveau culturel et linguistique
@@kinsou3865 bah après les francs sont certes arrivés en France mais ont adopté les coutumes locales, une langue latine, le christianisme. On est de culture majoritairement latine/gallo-romaine
Nice song I´m glad that this "Revanchism" and the "Erbfeindschaft" between our nations and people are over and that we are working together for a peacful Europe love from Germany Vive La France FR , Lang lebe Deutschland DE
@@mfc4987 on the other hand France has lost the Saar and Rhineland to Prussia . while France also lost belgium, netherlands , catalonia , italian states , illyria etc
As an Alsatian I really enjoy the fact that this song is now on this channel. Of course it needs to be stated that it reflects the propaganda of that time and that the sayings of the lyrics may not be historically accurate, for instance... Alsace and Lorraine weren't taken away by Germany by force, the annexion was agreed by both States, and France, which was held responsible for the war, offered these territories as a payment. But great song anyway, it's part of History after all ! @ingen I also really enjoy "La Strasbourgeoise", it's a bit similar to "Vous n'aurez pas l'Alsace et la Lorraine" but way more powerful in the way the story is told, you really should add it :D !
@VoltigeurFR I agree on the fact that Germany had interest in these territories. Yet, it's a current misconception that it was taken by force. Of course it wasn't France first intentions, but it ended up like that so France wouldn't have to pay for compensation... The "revanchist" ideas that spread up between 1871 and 1914 were mostly to cover up the fact that the french State gave it by itself, and willingly. If you're interested (I guess you are yourself French, but let's stick to English so other people can read us properly if you agree), here is a short text written by an Alsatian modern deputy about Alsace-Moselle and the French-German relations.
You obviously know nothing about alsace and lorraine. They were german until france annexed it. Their culture and language is german thats why france tries to eradicate it.
@@gokalzetop4183 You probably also say that austrias culture is austrian and bavarias culture is bavarian am I right? Oh, and saxonies culture is obviously saxon, not german.
@@andrewrussell9458 Vous pensez que la France aurait dû se laisser insulter par l'ambitieuse Allemagne ? Ce chant est totalement justifiable tout comme les chants francophobes de l'autre côté du Rhin.
Aujourd'hui l'Alsace est une terre de fort patriotisme français, mais à l'origine c'est un bout d'empire germanique de langue allemande (l'alsacien n'est qu'une mosaïque de dialectes allemands) arraché militairement par Louis XIV. En 1870 les Allemands pensaient par conséquent avoir récupéré un bout de la patrie, sans comprendre que les Alsaciens, au bout de deux siècles, étaient en voie d'assimilation par la France.
C'est assez faux que les allemands pensaient avoir récupéré un bout de la patrie : déjà les alsaciens étaient considérés comme des sous hommes par les prussiens ensuite même Bismarck dnas une lettre à l'impératrice Eugénie reconnaissait lui même que l'Alsace et la moselle étaient des terres Francaise et que l'occupation n'avait pour but que de se protéger de la France
Does anybody know why he pronunces his r's in a more Spanish or Italian way rather that the tipical french guttural r? Is it a regional thing or is it associated with songs like in german?
Its because it is a opera song I think. In Germany we have the french r, but in theater and opera they use the rolling r. Its because of the understanding. a french r is not so gut understandable, than the rolled r
It’s because it’s sang as opera pieces were all sang old fashion way up to decades ago. It is due to Italian overwhelming influence in opera, which used to require Rs to be pronounce this way no matter the language. It’s been fading for quite some time though.
@@friedrichengels4ever526 As a matter of fact, surprisingly no It was the accent in different parts pf the country but "regular" french was spoken with the guttural r, same as in german
May God be on our side brother cuz we are in the shits all the way to the neck ahah! May Russia win this war quick and without too many civilian casualties, and may she be kind to her ukrainian sister... and above all I pray that you don't fall into the fangs of China brother! 🇫🇷🇷🇺
Auf die deutsch französische Freundschaft, mögen die jetzigen Grenzen endgültig bleiben. Für ewigen Frieden zwischen unseren Nationen. Long live the Franco-German friendship, may the current borders remain final. For everlasting peace between our nations. 🇩🇪🕊🇫🇷
@@FriedrichBarb Verrat an wen? Der Irredentismus hat Deutschland wortwörtlich zerstört, somit bleiben die Nationalisten von damals die größten Verräter. edit: Patriotismus ≠ Nationalismus
@@YasserMaghribi nah not at all, when I mean people from Alsace-Lorraine I mean people with some 12-word long family names (that are definitely of Germanic origin), so your point doesn't stand: they just don't want to be German, that's all there is to it
Hey Ingen can you please bring Fischia Il Vento, I've been asking for a while and the Italian president just got re-elected too! Would be a nice way of celebrating wouldn't it?
Fischia il Vento is just Katyusha but in italian. Kinda lame too honestly. There are better italian communist or anarchist songs to cover on this channel.
@@roborbiettinoisgone392 I mean, sure, but I do think that the re-election of a man who wanted to just rest because our political class is totally inept is something to be celebrated...
@@XScorpionXful Kinda agree with you on this one, my man Mattarella just wanted to retire and be a grandad... But still, it'd fit Ingen's "perfect timing"
NOUS RESTERONS FRANÇAIS 🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷 Love to everyone in the comments that love France 🧡 Especially Polish, Greek, Russian, Czech and Romanian peoples 🧡🙏⚜
Even to this day, the majority of the last names in Elsaß in particular are German. The majority of the most beautiful churches, houses, city halls, castles, etc there were designed and built by Germans.
@@kosa9662 Pagan Slavs never had cities as we know them. They had minor settlements. The majority of the towns and cities in central, northern and eastern Germany were founded or entirely built into cities by Germans. There was also continual flows of German colonists to the east until 1918, later from 1939 to 1945. There were expulsions of certain Slavs, very little intermixing, and by now the population who has some Slavic ancestry would have little to none by now. It only takes 7 generations for a bloodline to become less than one percent provided the offspring continually have children with Germans, or with people who had less Slavic ancestry. Also, most of the actual eastern Germans now live in western and southern Germany, since after the expulsions of 1945.
@@whyareyoureadingthis1356 The people spoke German but were culturally and politically closer to France, just look up how the population liked German rule vs French rule.
In 1871, after their defeat in the Franco-Prussian War, France was forced to cede Alsace-Lorraine to Germany, which they did not gain back until 1919, following the Treaty of Versailles. Since the aftermath of World War II, the French-German border has been the Rhine River, which is not the true border. As my friend Dr. Ludwig pointed out in his Die Wacht Am Rhein video, on the left side of the Rhine there live German people too, and people of the same nationality belong in the same state. Apparently, the Vosges Mountains mark the true border between France and Germany, not the Rhine. The Vosges Mountains are in Alsace, but I never understood why Germany had to take over half of Lorraine as well, if that was always French.
Sounds like racialist Nazi crap. Apparently, true french natural bordel go way more to the east. As same people belong to same nation ; all while Americans should be boat back to Europe. All black Americans should be boat back to Africa. Or let's go colonize and share north america between Europe and Africa. Why not ? No seriously. Frank salían (installed west side of the Rhein) were fully Gallo romanized. When allamany tryed to invade Franci, they tried to genocide only the salían franks, not rheinan (as eastern part of the franks, the rheinan, weren't romanize at all). We can imagine France have a claim over Bavaria (& I agree that's ridiculous. But still, that could be possible. - Germans need to recognize their claim is ridiculous). That's the true border between France and Germany. Who were romanize, who weren't.
@@GwyyshsbakIzjsbsbszjzjzjhh thats dumb. Just because a city sounds oike it belongs to a country doesnt mean the citizens do. You even put strasbourg with the german S, doesnt matter though because you can dream as much as you want, but it will be spelt alsace lorraine and strasbourg forever. If that mentality was put into effect globally, the world would be much different, take the US for example, all of the former british colonial cities, new DELHI, new YORK, all named after english cities, they even sound english, but that doesnt make it english. You may keep dreaming mais vous n'aurez pas l'Alsace et la Lorraine
@@GeoNoob Et malgre vous, nous resterons Allemands. But even so, I don't understand why Bismarck wanted Lorraine as well as Alsace. Alsace may be considered German, but Lorraine is French, so why did Bismarck take it?
Nous avons peut être perdu la guerre de 1870 mais nous avons gagné la première guerre mondiale et empêché l'Allemagne de devenir un empire qui contrôle presque tout ces voisins même s'ils sont considérer comme libérateurs par leurs voisins et c'est peut être nous qui avons déclaré la guerre en 1870 mais c'est Bismarck qui voulait cette guerre en premier en nous attirant dans son piège. Nous sommes aussi responsable de la prise de pouvoir de Staline en Union Soviétique alors que Léon Trotski aurait été un meilleurs leader pour l'URSS et ne serait pas responsable de le mort de 33 millions de morts dont 21millions pendant la seconde guerre mondiale on aurait peut être sauvé des millions de russes qui nous aurait aidés pendant le deuxième guerre mondiale si on n'avait perdu la première mais on serait plus tard responsable de leurs morts et on vivrait peut être dans un monde fascistes et nous sommes aussi responsables de la prise au pouvoir des nazis en Allemagne mais c'était l'Allemagne ou la France qui devait devenir fasciste. Nous avons capitulé en 1940 mais tout les français ne ce sont pas rendu et ils sont eu raisons. Si on n'avait pas perdu la guerre de 1870, gagné la première guerre mondiale et la deuxième grâce à la résistance alors on vivrait malheureusement dans un monde fasciste qui aurait détruit le monde avec la troisième guerre mondiale. Vive notre pays la France qui à sauvé le monde avec l'aide des alliés bien sur! Je suis aussi entrain d'écrire un scénario ou les confédérés gagnent la guerre de Sécession et la France gagne la guerre de 1870. Il sera terminé pour Février après 1an de travaille normalement.
racist?!?!?! seems like a very quick and abrasive call to make when I said nothing perjorative - It's just well known that the concept of holy land and Israel despite being something that was lost for 2000 years was something that jewish people valued and have sacrificied many many lives over. Something I find admirable. Culture, values etc must be fought for and defended. Alsace lorraine is similarly part of the French entity.
![[CC]"Horst-Wessel-Lied" - National anthem of Nazi Germany (1933-1945) - German and Vietnamese lyrics](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/s1s3wqviX1E/mqdefault.jpg)
When the German kid steals your croissant :
@RealQuarkismGuy Yes King
@RealQuarkismGuy very convincing! Did you learn your tactics from neo fascists or a cult?
@Quark I 100% agree, I’m a Chinese and life is good for me
@@tupeuxdisposer8526 when the German kid steals Rhineland and saar from France in 1815
Vous n'aurez pas le Croixssant
Excellent version of the song, Ingen!
annoyingly not native french though
@RealQuarkismGuy Glad to see you here Shekelstein
@RealQuarkismGuy ok you're jewish, we get it
@RealQuarkismGuy are you 14?
@Renaud Beaulieu Why ur jewish since when Poland and Israel become one.
What a great song! Amazing one!
And I loved the editing Ingen made about France gaining Alsace and Lorraine during the refrain too!
That’s ingen for you
@@ColinTheFurryYT 🇫🇷❤️
Amour de la Grèce🇬🇷💙🇫🇷
🇫🇷🤝🇬🇷
🇦🇲❤️🇫🇷🇬🇷
On l'attendait depuis longtemps celle là !
@RealQuarkismGuy tu vas pas bien toi
@RealQuarkismGuy Bruh get the f away with your propaganda
@@leyoshivenere350 j'aime ce pseudo
As a French, I really love the nice detail you put for Alsace and Lorraine.
Also, I am grateful for you uploading this video.
Vive La France. 🇫🇷❣️
Sadly some other channel ended up stealing your comment, RIP
En tant que français tu devrais savoir que c'est L'Alsace et la Moselle
@@spacekaiser3063 En effet mais l'expression Alsace Lorraine est complètement acceptée
Rien que la chanson fait l'amalgame 😂
@@kadeis8912 ok?
@RealQuarkismGuy Your beliefs are yours, and my beliefs are mine.
I respect your opinions because i was myself learned to never disrespect anybody as a person for their opinions.
I may disagree with it, but i can never disrespect it.
Lyrics are obviously heavily inspired from La Strasbourgeoise ,french revanchist song
Well it's more complicated.The fact is that every revanchist song are about Alsace and the Lorraine et revenge against Gerlan, so they are all looking like the other
La Strasbourgeoise is a song from the army*
@@spacekaiser3063 indeed,but it’s message it still revanchist
@@Ravach0l_ oui
@RealQuarkismGuy Cringe
« Vous avez pu germaniser la plaine, mais notre cœur vous ne l’aurez jamais »
Mon Dieu… j’en pleure presque tellement c’est magnifique. Je t’aime France, longue et éternelle vie à toi 🇫🇷
Ben la plaine était déjà germanisée depuis le haut moyen-âge. La culture Française ne s'est développée ici que depuis la deuxième moitié du XXe siècle...
La France a conquise 1/3 des terres historiquement germanique, sans oublier la Bourgogne. La France a du se battre pour l’avoir
@@mwittmann68 arrete de dire des betises, la culture francaise date depuis des siecles voire des millenaires (Poussin, Chretien de Troyes, Clovis, Monet, Hugo, saints catholiques...), et est bien plus riche que la culture de nos voisins d'outre Rhin (je vois que tu viens de Suisse, inutile de dire que la culture francaise depasse la suisse). L'Allemagne aussi etait francisee quand Napoleon a conquis Berlin, et les nobles allemands, dont Frederic le Grand, parlaient le Francais dans le passe...
Vive la France ! Vive notre Peuple et Vive l'Empereur !
(et merci eugénie de Montijo pour avoir permi de récupérer l'alsace-Lorraine 😌😔)
Les français sont germains eux-mêmes. Ils se sont juste romanisés. Nous, Bretons, sommes réellement les ennemis des germains, qu’ils soient Saxons ou Francs.
Another French song, Vive France! 🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷
@RealQuarkismGuy bro what the hell dose that relate in anyway to the comment?
Also im religious and I don’t care how you view religion like so sht u mouth
@RealQuarkismGuy First of all, this literally has NOTHING to do with the comment, and, even though I don’t believe in God, or any religion, you should still respect other religions.
@RealQuarkismGuy Oh goodness, you again
I don't care about my faith, i only care about how you spam the same message over and over again. Also, Where the fuck you got a connection between a Revanchist Song and anything god related?
Et vive l'Ukraine !
Vive LA France, good pan;)
Long have i waited for that one, but George Thill’s version (one of the greatest tenor in history) is so magnificent ! :)
(you can listen to it on youtube)
@RealQuarkismGuy shut the fuck up, this is a comment about someone liking a different version of a song more than the one posted, also, I'm religious and I still live a normal life and am not held back by said religion except for spending a hour or two at church once every week
Trolol9llollo
@Renaud Beaulieu you give atheists a bad name, bot
I had found this song in a documentary about WWI and had completely forgotten about it.
Saluti ai fratelli d'Oltralpe!
🇮🇹🤝🇲🇫
Ave Duce! Ave Italia!
@@ruthenski I'll stop you right there, bro.
Thx for Savoy 🇫🇷🤝🇮🇹
@@itacom2199 i'm just joking
@@frenchexploiter9538 Thx for helping us in the Second Indipendence War
Salutations à république tchéque. À Austerlitz. Vive la France!
Austerlitz lol
🇫🇷❤🇨🇿
This is a certified revanchist classic
Longue vie à la France de vos frères🇮🇹❤🇫🇷
Ensemble contre l'empire d'Autriche et Espagnol. 🇨🇵🇮🇹
V.E.R.D.I
🇨🇵✝️🇮🇹
🇪🇸🇮🇹🇫🇷🇷🇴🇲🇩🇧🇷🇵🇹🇨🇦
S.P.Q.R. 🇫🇷❤️🇮🇹
Salutations et bien du respect aussi, de Grèce 🇬🇷🤝🇫🇷
salut
Nos frères grecques 🇬🇷❤️🇨🇵
@@Jehan-Descoteaux ah merci beaucoup, je suis vraiment ému ♥️
Je me sens la même pour les gens français 🤗
@@georgios_5342 Vive la grande Grèce !
@@sauronmordor7494 Vive la Rome orientale aussi 🇬🇷🇬🇷🇬🇷
Merci beaucoup pour ton soutien 🙂👍
Kinda ironic to call Alsace a plain, considering the rough terrain of it is what made it so strategically valuable
Alsace is a plain, it's being across the Rhin that was strategically valuable
Oh, and I live in Alsace ;)
@@niko68680 I doubt it
@@limeliciousmapping4652 Mdr
There is literally what is called "the plain of Alsace"
A quick google search and you're done.
@@niko68680 Are you talking about the Rhine valley?
@@limeliciousmapping4652 I m takling about the Alsace plain
Fantastic another beautiful French song, thank you. Keep up the great work mate.
The first painting there is “The Black Spot”, in case if you were wondering.
Merci mon gas !
West Africa could never fill the void that Alsace-Lorraine left.
I am Alsatian and i just love this song, thanks for uploading it. That would be great if you could do the anthem of Alsace next time! Thanks
Would you call yourself french or german? Just curious.
@@ape1629 we are french
@@IronWarrior57560 Just curious about the general ethnicity of the area because I have ancestors from the region who were German and I’m wondering if there still many Germans there.
@@ape1629
A sizeable proportion we’re probably ethnically cleansed and forced across the border at gunpoint. Coming from a family in which my great uncle was killed in the region by French nationalists due to beatings and violence, i find this to be a likely outcome sadly…
@@ape1629 a mix
Ah yes, the France three generations of my family held allegiance to, despite being under Imperial german rule...
So they settled on german land and then waited for france to annex it?
@@HansPeter_ No.
30 generations of my family have lived on the same land, it's just that three generations of my family were under Imperial German rule but were pro-French _at the time._
Not hard to see why considering how Prussia treated Alsatians.
Of course, little did they know France would act similarly following the reannexations.
@@11Survivor France would act worse. I cant remember germany making it illegal to speak alsacian.
@@HansPeter_ But they did make it illegal... You also couldn't name your own children.
@@11Survivor No. Im pretty sure that Germany didn't make it illegal to speak a german dialect.
Ey Ingen, good edit btw (from 1:50 until the end, it can see how Ingen put Alsace and Lorraine little by little)
La chanson est très significative et merveilleuse
Amour et respect du Kurdistan du Nord à la France
❤☀️💚🤝🇲🇫
☀️❤️🇫🇷
Vive le Kurdistan indépendant !
Le chemin sera long et semé
d'embûches, et il faudra se battre,
MAIS vous l'aurez votre indépendance !
🇫🇷❤️
Vive le Kurdistan, vive la France, vive l'Internationale !
Vive le Kurdistan du Nord independante!
Vive l’Artsakh independante! 🇦🇲
Vive la Chypre Grecque 🇬🇷
#TurkeyIsATerrorState
#ArtsakhIsArmenia
#CyprusIsGreece
Bientôt avec un peu d'espoir ce sera du kurdistan tout court! Nous prions pour les frères et soeurs qui se saignent pour leur liberté, longue vive le Kurdistan, et vive le Kurdistan libre!! 🇫🇷❤☀️
As a french born ,grew up and live in Lorraine, i will always remember the poilus for our delivrence from Germany
France is best western country!!
Love and respect to our caretaker from the little Entente!!🇫🇷❤️🇸🇮🇭🇷🇷🇸🇷🇴🇨🇿🇸🇰
germany wins
@@lysenkotheory3400 when?
@@lysenkotheory3400 Germany only knows how to kill people for no reason and than lose
@@lysenkotheory3400 Germany dramatically lost two world wars + in both they were doomed from the start
@@lysenkotheory3400 central powers was for the cool nations.
Imaginez chanter ça lors d’un match en coupe du monde France Allemagne
le culot mdr
Je le ferais😂
Wir kontern mit "Die Wacht am Rhein"😂
Vive la France Éternelle 🇨🇵✝️
@SuperduperobergruppenstuppentruppensturmStuka Can you remind me, who conquered more than half Europe in 19th century? ^^
@SuperduperobergruppenstuppentruppensturmStuka ta gueule
@SuperduperobergruppenstuppentruppensturmStuka So your arguments are false stereotypes and xenophobic thoughts about the French people lmao, you must have a really sad life
@SuperduperobergruppenstuppentruppensturmStuka interesting
@SuperduperobergruppenstuppentruppensturmStuka cringe
Other fun fact: one of our most successful generals in WW2 was from Alsace-Lorraine, his name was Marie-Pierre Kœnig and he led a successful campaign against Rommel and his allies in Bir-Hakeim.
Ukraine never surender!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
slava ukraini
In fact Pierre Koenig was born in Caen, Normandy. He was just the Member of Parliament for the Bas-Rhin(Alsace) constituency.
@@frankraich7844 hohol pigs are good for the farm
@@badpiggies988 slava cocaini
Even though Czechoslovakia and France had complicated relations because of Munich betrayal, I personally admire French culture. Alsace-Lorraine is of course French and not German! 🇨🇿❤🇨🇵
Thank you so much! Long live our friendship!!! 🇫🇷🇨🇿👍❤️
Thanks you. I am alsacian and german nationalist that assume that we want to be german are annoying ...
(At most some people want a special statue within France but nobody ever wanted to leave our country)
Munich betrayal ? You know that your country would never exist today without France right ? Czech and Slovak never rose against their Austrian masters. Not like the Serbs, the Poles, the Croatians, and even the Hungarians … What you are, it’s thanks to the French and allies blood during World War I . Even during the Napoleonic war, the Bohemians were happy to fulfil the Habsburg ranks and bring their slaves, even when Napoleon proposed to them their own nation. The wake up was in 1919, not before. You and your ancestors have no right to talk about any betrayal.
@@stadtrepublikmulhausen4121 what ?
@@freewal You should learn something about Czechoslovak history before writing about it. Of course the Czechs fought against Austrian tyranny. Firstly during 1618, unfortunately we were defeated in 1620 in battle of White Mountain. Many members of Czech nobility fought against Austrians again in 1740. And during the Napoleonic wars we unfortunately didn't rise up, but it was because of almost 200 years of germanisation. We were still in early phases of our National Rebirth. And then we fought against Austrians in WW1. Have you ever heard about Czechoslovak legions? You should read something about them. They fought in Russia, Italy, France. Many Czechs fought in Serbian army and even in Greek army. And yes I was talking about Munich betrayal, because unfortunately French and British governments betrayed our country and gave Sudetenland to Germany. Even though France swore to defend Czechoslovakia from the Germans. That is definition of betrayal. (Of course I know that many French people wanted to fight against Germany, so I don't blame them, but I blame their government)
I can just imagine some French history teachers start singing this in the middle of their discussion on the Franco-Prussian War
Il est important de comprendre la position de l’Alsace-Lorraine: Le Rhin est extrêmement utile à La Défense du pays, et c’est aussi une frontière historique séparant les Français des Allemands.
d'ou l'intéret de reprendre la rive gauche du Rhin
Le Rhin n'est pas la frontière historique entre français est allemand , l'Alsace est germanique de langue , la frontière* est plutôt au niveau des Vosges (signé un alsacien :) )
*au niveau culturel et linguistique
@@karlvi4040 oui et ? La France est le mix de culture franque ( germanique ) gauloise ( celte ) et romaine ( latine )
@@maskr5520 Une grosse partie franque a ne pas négliger, n'en déplaisent au gaullois.
@@kinsou3865 bah après les francs sont certes arrivés en France mais ont adopté les coutumes locales, une langue latine, le christianisme. On est de culture majoritairement latine/gallo-romaine
Perfect version!
When you take over most of Africa and they all still speak french decades later:
@RealQuarkismGuy stop dude
@RealQuarkismGuy Wtf are you talking about lmao, shut up with your marxist shit nobody cares. And i'm saying this as an anarcho-syndicalist
Why do you think most of the world speaks English ? Because English is such a pretty language?
@RealQuarkismGuy marxism only works on paper lmfao
@@unbonfrancophone1539 Une jolie langue construit avec une bonne part de francais
Et de nos jours, l’Alsace et la Lorraine ne sont ni germaniques, ni françaises, mais en voie d’islamisation avancée.
#savefrance
@@hansworthe #saveeurope (l'Allemagne est dans le même délire ...)
Great song big love to our best friends in history ☦🇬🇷♥️🇨🇵✝️👋🏻
Bruh, france was in alliance with turks
@@sleeker651 Because Ottoman empire owned Greece since the 19 century and then we left ottoman empire for going on Greece side
@@sleeker651 France was one of the major help during Greek independence.
They also saved the Ottoman Empire.
Both , yeah both is good.
❤❤
Hello from Russia
Yoo, i know this by heart, thanks for posting this version !
Notice how between 0:50 and 1:05 Alsace and Lorraine slowly come back to France...
Love France 🇨🇵 from Bharat🇮🇳
Much respect for Bharat from France.
You guys have a lot of potential to weigh on the future of the world.
Nice song I´m glad that this "Revanchism" and the "Erbfeindschaft" between our nations and people are over and that we are working together for a peacful Europe
love from Germany
Vive La France FR , Lang lebe Deutschland DE
Die Erbfeindschaft ist vorbei, weil Frankreich hat, was es wollte. Wäre Elsaß-Lothingen noch Teil Deutschlands, sähe die Beziehung ganz anders aus.
@@HansPeter_ en revanche l'Allemagne elle à perdu la prusse et c'est territoire de l'est
@@mfc4987 on the other hand France has lost the Saar and Rhineland to Prussia . while France also lost belgium, netherlands , catalonia , italian states , illyria etc
@@apo5895 But besides Wallonia and Romandie those territories were never french.
@@apo5895 most pf these region weren't core provinces of France but recently annexed ones.
So we don't really consider these territories as true loss.
Jamais entendu cette version, magnifique, merci.
Never heard that version, beautiful, thank you.
In a parallel universe where France won the Francoprussian war:
Du wirst kein Rheinland haben!
As an Alsatian I really enjoy the fact that this song is now on this channel.
Of course it needs to be stated that it reflects the propaganda of that time and that the sayings of the lyrics may not be historically accurate, for instance... Alsace and Lorraine weren't taken away by Germany by force, the annexion was agreed by both States, and France, which was held responsible for the war, offered these territories as a payment.
But great song anyway, it's part of History after all !
@ingen I also really enjoy "La Strasbourgeoise", it's a bit similar to "Vous n'aurez pas l'Alsace et la Lorraine" but way more powerful in the way the story is told, you really should add it :D !
Are you German? The way you structure your sentences..
I am German myself
@VoltigeurFR I agree on the fact that Germany had interest in these territories. Yet, it's a current misconception that it was taken by force. Of course it wasn't France first intentions, but it ended up like that so France wouldn't have to pay for compensation... The "revanchist" ideas that spread up between 1871 and 1914 were mostly to cover up the fact that the french State gave it by itself, and willingly.
If you're interested (I guess you are yourself French, but let's stick to English so other people can read us properly if you agree), here is a short text written by an Alsatian modern deputy about Alsace-Moselle and the French-German relations.
i wouldn't call this anexation without any force since france didn't have many choices as a loser in war
@@renecotynotreraisanous505 la France a dû payer de très lourdes indemnités de guerre telles que stipulées dans le traité de Frankfurt
Most people here are completely disregarding the fact that France declared the war not Prussia. I think that is what the commenter meant.
wonderful
Yeah !! 🇫🇷
Love for France from your eastern friends Poland 🇨🇵❤🇵🇱 Alsace and Lorraine will be French forever!
You obviously know nothing about alsace and lorraine. They were german until france annexed it. Their culture and language is german thats why france tries to eradicate it.
@@HansPeter_ Their culture is alsacian, not german
@@gokalzetop4183 You probably also say that austrias culture is austrian and bavarias culture is bavarian am I right? Oh, and saxonies culture is obviously saxon, not german.
@@HansPeter_ Austria is austrian, not german
@@gokalzetop4183 😂👍🏻
I haven't heard this song since I was banging out to WWI music when Battlefield 1 came out. What a weird nostalgia bomb lol.
Tg
this is before ww1 it's after Franco Prussian war 1870.
@@hjyglik5030 I know, but they certainly sang it during the war
C est beau le patriotisme j'en pleure et je ne suis pas Français.
Ce sentiment est le plus noble
Respect for Germany and all European country from France.
It’s nice that the disputes and hatred that create songs like this aren’t as common anymore.
@@andrewrussell9458 Vous pensez que la France aurait dû se laisser insulter par l'ambitieuse Allemagne ?
Ce chant est totalement justifiable tout comme les chants francophobes de l'autre côté du Rhin.
@@Lotharingie not saying that it wasn't justified just that the world is better with less conflict
@@andrewrussell9458 go to comment filters and select newest first
@@Lotharingie This song is wrong because alsace is german.
Aujourd'hui l'Alsace est une terre de fort patriotisme français, mais à l'origine c'est un bout d'empire germanique de langue allemande (l'alsacien n'est qu'une mosaïque de dialectes allemands) arraché militairement par Louis XIV. En 1870 les Allemands pensaient par conséquent avoir récupéré un bout de la patrie, sans comprendre que les Alsaciens, au bout de deux siècles, étaient en voie d'assimilation par la France.
C'est assez faux que les allemands pensaient avoir récupéré un bout de la patrie : déjà les alsaciens étaient considérés comme des sous hommes par les prussiens ensuite même Bismarck dnas une lettre à l'impératrice Eugénie reconnaissait lui même que l'Alsace et la moselle étaient des terres Francaise et que l'occupation n'avait pour but que de se protéger de la France
It took me four months to recognise Alsace-Lorraine being re-added to the flag map at 0:52 xD
When even Alsace tell Germany they aren't German but French :
J'habite en alsace❤️❤️
Nice take on the song ! Vive la France 🇫🇷 ! Ne vous ratez pour les Élections en Avril ! ZOZZ !
Malheureusement je pense que tu prêches des convaincus, faut aimer la France un minimum pour se retrouver ici ce qui exclut bien des personnes.
@@salam_les_khoyas Exactement ! C'est pour cela qu'on est tous réunis ici, on aime la france et vive la nouvelle République Insoumise !
@@KameroonEmperor ou la République marchante dependant de nos preferences :)
@@KameroonEmperor Moi plutôt la République Reconquise mais bon...
@@KameroonEmperor la République islamique du Frankistan tu veux dire ? Après si tu aimes la France, je t'apprécie quand même
Me when I see a German nationalist
Does anybody know why he pronunces his r's in a more Spanish or Italian way rather that the tipical french guttural r? Is it a regional thing or is it associated with songs like in german?
Its because it is a opera song I think. In Germany we have the french r, but in theater and opera they use the rolling r. Its because of the understanding. a french r is not so gut understandable, than the rolled r
@@anthemsofeurope2408 Thanks, I knew about that in German songs but I had never heard it being used in any french songs.
It’s because it’s sang as opera pieces were all sang old fashion way up to decades ago. It is due to Italian overwhelming influence in opera, which used to require Rs to be pronounce this way no matter the language. It’s been fading for quite some time though.
@RealQuarkismGuy You must be bored as hell man
@@rowanwild8445 imagine what must go through a guy's mind to decide to spend his days spamming ideological nonsense on the internet
Vive la France 🇬🇷❤️🇫🇷 Alsace and Lorraine was and will always be France 🟦🟦⬜⬜🟥🟥
I like how it was a popular thing back in the 60-80s to roll the "r"s the latin/slav way when singing, which wasn't/isn't done when commonly speaking
No it was the french accent till the 70's
@@friedrichengels4ever526 As a matter of fact, surprisingly no
It was the accent in different parts pf the country but "regular" french was spoken with the guttural r, same as in german
@@MUCM I I know it depended of the regions but if we consider the parisian accent as the french accent it's true
I don't think it was thrilled as in slavic languages, it's more like a tapped r like in some spanish words (para) and scottish english.
La défaite des Boches en 1918 est un des plus beaux moments de l'Histoire de France
Those “Boches” we’re the ones defending France and the rest of Europe from being engulfed by Bolshevik Asiatic hordes
Vive la France
🟦🟦🟦⬜⬜⬜🟥🟥🟥
🟦🟦🟦⬜⬜⬜🟥🟥🟥
🟦🟦🟦⬜⬜⬜🟥🟥🟥
🟦🟦🟦⬜⬜⬜🟥🟥🟥
gg
Brcae yourself for "Love to France from [country] 🏴🤝🇫🇷" comments!
@RealQuarkismGuy off your meds again?
@RealQuarkismGuy communism poo capitalism is cool
Long live France and French people
Your country and nation is awesome
Love from a Kurd 🇫🇷❤️☀️💚
🇨🇵🇹🇯❤
God may help the Kurds! 🇨🇷❤️ ☀️💚
To the French and Kurd friendship !
but Alsace it's not French
@@ankhaofficial4127 It is
VIVE LA FRANCE ÉTERNELLE
🇫🇷 🇷🇺
Well, no more alliance for now.
@@anakinwho8736 Swiss?
@@Sluchey LMAOOO good joke
@@cenprenonphyks8160 yes alliance for ever. Russia isn't limited to Putin like France isn't limited to nato and Macron
May God be on our side brother cuz we are in the shits all the way to the neck ahah! May Russia win this war quick and without too many civilian casualties, and may she be kind to her ukrainian sister... and above all I pray that you don't fall into the fangs of China brother! 🇫🇷🇷🇺
As a lorrainian i agree with this song
It looks very impressive how alasce et lorraine shows in refrain. The autor struggeled.
Awesome job finding this song
I love this song, remember my grand mother who died.
I'm glad you posted This one
Respect from Russia 🇷🇺
Vive L'Alsace-Lorraine et surtout Vive la France 🇨🇵
Elsass Deutsch
@@ankhaofficial4127 we are french and will always be
@@ankhaofficial4127 you lost it
@@chadofthexxthcentury4741 c'est un alsacien qui dit ça , faut avouer que c'est cocasso
@@chadofthexxthcentury4741 and France lost the Rhineland and saar to the Germans .
Treatre of Versailles wasn't enough
🤡
🤡
🤡
@@TheDiddler261 Anyting else? 🎤🗑️
Which peace deal would be good? A democratic peace without annexations and indemnities?
Vive la France, à jamais !! 🔵⚪🔴
French Revolutionaries when the king is not no more:
@RealQuarkismGuy +100000 social credit bing chilling
@@Farachou dont hate on a man for being based
@@el0quinn xie hua piao piao piao
@@Farachou being Chinese is cool
@Quark bing chilling moment
When the krupp gun destroys your beret:
L'Alsace et la Lorraine seront pour toujours français! Vive la France!
Auf die deutsch französische Freundschaft, mögen die jetzigen Grenzen endgültig bleiben. Für ewigen Frieden zwischen unseren Nationen.
Long live the Franco-German friendship, may the current borders remain final. For everlasting peace between our nations. 🇩🇪🕊🇫🇷
*V E R R Ä T E R*
@@FriedrichBarb Verrat an wen? Der Irredentismus hat Deutschland wortwörtlich zerstört, somit bleiben die Nationalisten von damals die größten Verräter.
edit: Patriotismus ≠ Nationalismus
@@geo1684 Es war ein Scherz. 🤣 Aber ja ich stimme, guter Kommentar
knirsch
@@FriedrichBarb Verzeihung für die Anschuldigung, der Sonntag war lang 🤦🏻♂️
Alsace and Lorraine is and will be always french! 🇫🇷
"Under France's occipation"
Okay but what was the inhabitants in 1870?
@@AJBNord honestly just ask people over there, no one wants to join Germany lol, not remotely close to an occupation
@@aa6dcc because they are descendants of french colons.
@@YasserMaghribi nah not at all, when I mean people from Alsace-Lorraine I mean people with some 12-word long family names (that are definitely of Germanic origin), so your point doesn't stand: they just don't want to be German, that's all there is to it
Fun fact: Alsace-Lorraine is one of the most nationalistic regions of France 🇫🇷
c'est Faux
@@ankhaofficial4127 c'est vrai
@@isyx7483 non non c'est faux
@@ankhaofficial4127 je t'assures prends une carte
Fun fact: Their regional language is german
Alsace lorraine will always be french
Et elles l'ont toujours été
@@chrisb9143 Amen
Vous avez pu islamiser la plaine, mais notre coeur il restera Français 🇨🇵🇨🇵🇨🇵
Vive France! 🇫🇷 ❤️🇷🇺
Entante 2.0?
@@lukaslee7380 il faut demandé a la perfide Albion
Love from Belarus.
Please, can the anthem of the Belarusian People's Republic 1918-1920 "Ваяцкі марш" or White Legion "Ліцвін".
Hey Ingen can you please bring Fischia Il Vento, I've been asking for a while and the Italian president just got re-elected too!
Would be a nice way of celebrating wouldn't it?
Fischia il Vento is just Katyusha but in italian. Kinda lame too honestly. There are better italian communist or anarchist songs to cover on this channel.
Pas compris tg un peu
@@XScorpionXful I mean... it would still be a nice addition to this channel IMO
@@roborbiettinoisgone392 I mean, sure, but I do think that the re-election of a man who wanted to just rest because our political class is totally inept is something to be celebrated...
@@XScorpionXful Kinda agree with you on this one, my man Mattarella just wanted to retire and be a grandad...
But still, it'd fit Ingen's "perfect timing"
What separates the man to the animal ?
The Rhin
the animal crossed the rhine to eat a part of the man in 1871
wait so who's jewing who now you guys don't even make sense anymore
@@x-a- ?
It's great when you can understand the french Lyrics
🇻🇳 ❤ 🇫🇷
NOUS RESTERONS FRANÇAIS 🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷
Love to everyone in the comments that love France 🧡
Especially Polish, Greek, Russian, Czech and Romanian peoples 🧡🙏⚜
So this was the song the gendarmes were singing in New York over the phone.
I’m French myself and the beginning of the song was good.
It’s crazy how obsessed france is with liberty
This happens when you are constantly under attack for a 1000 years. Fighting european coalition every 20 years or so.
"Patrie" means "Pays des pères" (Country of the fathers) so its closer to "Fatherland" than "Motherland"
It's "country" that makes it a feminine word, not "of the ...".
Mysogine va
No, it’s actually because France is a woman. The word « patrie » could be translated both by « motherland » or « fatherland » based on the country.
Car notre cœur lui restera Français !
@RealQuarkismGuy J'ai pas lu, dsl
Even to this day, the majority of the last names in Elsaß in particular are German. The majority of the most beautiful churches, houses, city halls, castles, etc there were designed and built by Germans.
They speak German but a culturally and politically French.
Same thing with modern day East Germany. Last Names are Slavic, cities have Slavic names, but inhabitats are Germanised..
@@whyareyoureadingthis1356 Then why Sorbs still exist? :)
@@kosa9662 Pagan Slavs never had cities as we know them. They had minor settlements. The majority of the towns and cities in central, northern and eastern Germany were founded or entirely built into cities by Germans. There was also continual flows of German colonists to the east until 1918, later from 1939 to 1945. There were expulsions of certain Slavs, very little intermixing, and by now the population who has some Slavic ancestry would have little to none by now. It only takes 7 generations for a bloodline to become less than one percent provided the offspring continually have children with Germans, or with people who had less Slavic ancestry.
Also, most of the actual eastern Germans now live in western and southern Germany, since after the expulsions of 1945.
@@basedkaiser5352 I mean before ww2.
Vive La France
From India 🇮🇳
French alsace lorraine
Indian kashmir
🇲🇫❤️🇮🇳
1:10 german empire seeing they also have a tricolor flag: "i agree"
In France we call our flag la tricolore.
Vive la France!
J'ai pleuré. Je suis ému par cette chanson de revanche.
GERMAN EMPIRE
born: versailles, with doing humiliation to the france
die: versailles, with humiliation by the france
TBH it's absurd how angry the french got over Alsace-Lorraine, honestly it's such a small piece of land
Le place where this piece of land is was strategic at that time
it’s pretty big in proportion, like how florida is to the us, and it had been french land a while and enjoyed that economically
@@whyareyoureadingthis1356 The people spoke German but were culturally and politically closer to France, just look up how the population liked German rule vs French rule.
@@whyareyoureadingthis1356 i never disagreed with that, but it had been french land for a while. nothing i said was wrong
I bet your country has as well
In 1871, after their defeat in the Franco-Prussian War, France was forced to cede Alsace-Lorraine to Germany, which they did not gain back until 1919, following the Treaty of Versailles. Since the aftermath of World War II, the French-German border has been the Rhine River, which is not the true border. As my friend Dr. Ludwig pointed out in his Die Wacht Am Rhein video, on the left side of the Rhine there live German people too, and people of the same nationality belong in the same state. Apparently, the Vosges Mountains mark the true border between France and Germany, not the Rhine. The Vosges Mountains are in Alsace, but I never understood why Germany had to take over half of Lorraine as well, if that was always French.
Sounds like racialist Nazi crap. Apparently, true french natural bordel go way more to the east.
As same people belong to same nation ; all while Americans should be boat back to Europe. All black Americans should be boat back to Africa. Or let's go colonize and share north america between Europe and Africa. Why not ?
No seriously. Frank salían (installed west side of the Rhein) were fully Gallo romanized. When allamany tryed to invade Franci, they tried to genocide only the salían franks, not rheinan (as eastern part of the franks, the rheinan, weren't romanize at all). We can imagine France have a claim over Bavaria (& I agree that's ridiculous. But still, that could be possible. - Germans need to recognize their claim is ridiculous).
That's the true border between France and Germany. Who were romanize, who weren't.
Metz is more French than German. Mulhausen and Straßburg are obviously more German than French.
@@GwyyshsbakIzjsbsbszjzjzjhh thats dumb. Just because a city sounds oike it belongs to a country doesnt mean the citizens do. You even put strasbourg with the german S, doesnt matter though because you can dream as much as you want, but it will be spelt alsace lorraine and strasbourg forever. If that mentality was put into effect globally, the world would be much different, take the US for example, all of the former british colonial cities, new DELHI, new YORK, all named after english cities, they even sound english, but that doesnt make it english.
You may keep dreaming mais vous n'aurez pas l'Alsace et la Lorraine
@@gringologie9302it’s Nazi crap to point out that France was the first one to start the expansion into German lands? Lmao
@@GeoNoob Et malgre vous, nous resterons Allemands. But even so, I don't understand why Bismarck wanted Lorraine as well as Alsace. Alsace may be considered German, but Lorraine is French, so why did Bismarck take it?
As an Alsatian, thank you for highlighting our history. Alsace is French !
Vive la France 💙🤍❤
Nope, Elsass ist deutsch
@RealQuarkismGuy you agree that Aslace is French though, right?
@@sator3946 false, Alsace and Lorraine are all French
en tant qu'Alsacien également tu dois être parigot Loïc, tout vrai Alsacien sait que l'Alsace n'est pas française
@@ankhaofficial4127 quand on aime tant l'allemagne il serait plus logique d'émigrer de l'autre côté du rhin
Nous avons peut être perdu la guerre de 1870 mais nous avons gagné la première guerre mondiale et empêché l'Allemagne de devenir un empire qui contrôle presque tout ces voisins même s'ils sont considérer comme libérateurs par leurs voisins et c'est peut être nous qui avons déclaré la guerre en 1870 mais c'est Bismarck qui voulait cette guerre en premier en nous attirant dans son piège.
Nous sommes aussi responsable de la prise de pouvoir de Staline en Union Soviétique alors que Léon Trotski aurait été un meilleurs leader pour l'URSS et ne serait pas responsable de le mort de 33 millions de morts dont 21millions pendant la seconde guerre mondiale on aurait peut être sauvé des millions de russes qui nous aurait aidés pendant le deuxième guerre mondiale si on n'avait perdu la première mais on serait plus tard responsable de leurs morts et on vivrait peut être dans un monde fascistes et nous sommes aussi responsables de la prise au pouvoir des nazis en Allemagne mais c'était l'Allemagne ou la France qui devait devenir fasciste.
Nous avons capitulé en 1940 mais tout les français ne ce sont pas rendu et ils sont eu raisons.
Si on n'avait pas perdu la guerre de 1870, gagné la première guerre mondiale et la deuxième grâce à la résistance alors on vivrait malheureusement dans un monde fasciste qui aurait détruit le monde avec la troisième guerre mondiale.
Vive notre pays la France qui à sauvé le monde avec l'aide des alliés bien sur!
Je suis aussi entrain d'écrire un scénario ou les confédérés gagnent la guerre de Sécession et la France gagne la guerre de 1870.
Il sera terminé pour Février après 1an de travaille normalement.
Was it worth it Revanchisme?! Tens of millions of dead for a piece of land?!
for someone with hebrew in your name that seems like an odd question- yes obviously it was.
@@AlexC-ou4ju
And for your comment, it seems a bit racist.
How the hell my ethnic origin is related to my political views?!
racist?!?!?! seems like a very quick and abrasive call to make when I said nothing perjorative - It's just well known that the concept of holy land and Israel despite being something that was lost for 2000 years was something that jewish people valued and have sacrificied many many lives over. Something I find admirable. Culture, values etc must be fought for and defended. Alsace lorraine is similarly part of the French entity.
Yes 😎
My fellow french people