You can say that again! 😊 She's my bias. Thanks to Psycho, I met these guys haha. sorry I dont usually do this fangirly thingy. But when I watched the video, everything changed. The first person I noticed was Wendy. I dunno but her presence is just sooo different. She always gives me butterflies in my stomach haha
Maggie Wang because their stylists keep giving Wendy bad styling and Wendy keeps getting bangs because she’s prob insecure with her forehead:/ They’re all beautiful.
I have arrived at the same conclusion...with the same girls! I am adding Winter to that list, and Seulgi. I love SM Vocal style! I also read a while back, that they compose music and songs to suit the vocal skills of particular artists.....They put it, "They want to maximize their talents....we can see that with Wendy here....I mean "holy smokes!!!"
And I thought wendy was overrated or something cuz she's a visual and main vocal but daaaaam I hate myself for thinking that, and here I am a big fan of her
@@angecore_yt not necessarily? Lol even RV themselves lip synch in music shows/some festivals. Everything’s just over-perfect and overproduced with Kpop these days.
If RV's clothes represent Hogwarts houses then their color really suits them -Irene, Gryffindor. Even though she's a bit of a shy type, she definitely got that leader courage and fair judgement in the bag. -Wendy, Ravenclaw. We all know Wannie got a wide variety of skills, right?Even in school Wan had good grades and involved in a lot of activities -Seulgi, Hufflepuff. Definitely have that patience, loyalty and hardwork nailed down. 7 YEARS of training?A lot of people would've gave up by that point. -Joy, of course the evil maknae goes Slytherin. Clever, up-front, ambitious (Joy did say she wants to film a CF with Lee Sooman LMAO). This girl is just a bag of mischief (along with Yeri now). Do i need to say more??
@@monstrua-k4c well Wendy did say some ignorant things about black people so yeah she isn’t the same as before but then again she could have always been ignorant.
Foxglove then Damn I run into bad post then, most of the time I run into post always talking about Irene and joy and seulgi! And ignoring Wendy and yeri! I feel like the very recents have been good but some older videos haven’t ! As a Wendyluv it sucks seeing your bias get ignored and hate and yeri my bias wrecker!
@Foxglove Pfff. Yeah she only gets noticed these days on the rare days they let her bangs shine (is it only me that finds her pretty either way? Though I especially like her Psycho hairstyle) and when it's a singing based video. Other wise most mention usually go The top comments are: Irene/Joy/Seulgi Or Seulgi/Irene Or Seulgi/Joy Or Joy And then there's Yeri/Wendy Or Yeri And then Wendy or Wendy and the Yeri
@@wia752 I agree, ppl project themselves onto their idols and take it way too personally-it seems. To expand on your point- many, not all, kPop fans seem make it about themselves. Example, there will be a thread in the comments that flows like a conversation and focuses on one topic or about a member. Someone will break topic with a post like: Why isn’t anyone talking about how {insert adjectives} (Insert Member Name) is? followed by large quantities of emojis to really nail your point. Like your whole job is to be the PR rep/agent for your bias?. Where is the fun in that? Why turn what is supposed to be entertainment into something so tedious?
보다가 생각나는건데 에펙스부터 엑소 럭키원(2016)까지는 진짜 에셈틱하게 노래를 잘 구성한듯 약간 공상적이게? 아무리 레벨 샤이니 에펙 엑소가 다 컨셉이 다르다 해도 거기 녹아있는 톡톡 튀고 기묘하지만 깔끔한 느낌이 있었음.... 막 데뷔한 에스파는 옛날 선배들 느낌은 확실히 안 나는듯.. 그러나 아무리 말 많아도 스엠은 못잃는다 돌아와줘요 이수만
In this i thought that Wendy was the visual, she look so beautiful, gorgeous and with charisma. I miss this look, I miss this era when Wendy has black hair andand without bang.
I miss this era 😢😢 it's sad that yeri couldn't join RV from the start. Now that she in the group,RV is completeeee ahhh can't wait for their comeback!!!who is watching this is 2016??
@@user-gs5nn7sm2c ㄹㅇ SM이 괜히 스엠이 아님 뚝딱이도 메댄으로 만들어버리는 정보력, 기술력 끝났지 ㅁㅓ...⭐️ 실력은 보장되구 비주얼도 믿음감 아이린이 수박상이라 그렇지 모두 다른 그룹에 가면 비주얼에 코어 단단한 포지션들 꺄아 언니!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2007: we got wonder girls 2008: we got girls generation 2009: we got 2ne1 2010: we got sistar 2011: we got fx 2012: we got 4minute 2013: we got dreamcatcher 2014: we got red velvet 2015: we got twice 2016: we got blackpink 2017: we got weki meki 2018: we got g idle 2019: we got itzy 2020: we got aespa 2021: we got ive 2022: we got billlie
NO BUT ARE WE NOT GONNA TALK ABOUT THE CAMERA WORK i mean 1. The intense zoom ins and outs 2. The hand fancams 3. The leg fancams 4. And the earhtquake at 3:19 EVERTHING ABOUT THIS WAS A MASTERPIECE
Exotics00423, you should give crayon pop a bigger chance. The twins ( ChoA and Way ) and Soyul all have 4 octaves. They can actual sing extremely well. Guess they're just hiding their potential and waiting to show it later in the future. You should see "I am beautiful" performance by them. But please don't compare crayon pop and red velvet. They're both from different companies, and have different concepts/styles, etc. They're both amazing.
Omayghad idk why I cried when Wendy hit those high notes. I'm not even a fan of RV but I watch their performances and listen to their songs from time to time.
All those screams during Wendy's solo tho... I totally love Wendy and Joy's parts!! Wendy kills 'em with them vocals and Joy.... DAMN Joys is just one bag packed of adorable-ness 💜
*Keep coming back here because this is wendy's era she really shined her and i miss her hair, her confidence and the time when people call her the visual member even thought its irene*
+Kayla Sloan LOL nope U can go see their weekly idol episode. They said Seulgi was in charge of dance in red velvet so that means she's the best Dancer
![[Red Velvet - Ice Cream Cake] Summer Special | M COUNTDOWN 200625 EP.671](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WXF5vhcJVq0/mqdefault.jpg)
that "shine on me" part always giving me goosebumps.
legendary
I really don't get why they don't give her more solos like that, it's effing amazin
I was shooketh to say the least. Baby's got vocalsssss.
SAMMMMMMME
God, that voice...
WENDY'S "SHINE ONE ME" PART IS SO POWERFUL I FEEL LIKE BOWING DOWN TO QUEEN WENDY EVERY TIME
FR THOUGH, IM JUST LIKE NO, YOU ALREADY SHINING GIRL
Same watchin this again make me appreciate the part more i got goosebumps
star_inmyheart same
queen ♥♥
I tried to sing that part. I sounded like a frog trying to sing rock.
Wendy's hairstyle, make up and everything in happiness era... She is the prettiest seriously
forealyes for me she's the prettiest even now,but all of them are visuals
Agreed! Her smile is so cute....and she does not stop smiling ever...i wish they could stay this age forever...
Aashka J
Yes
You can say that again! 😊 She's my bias. Thanks to Psycho, I met these guys haha. sorry I dont usually do this fangirly thingy. But when I watched the video, everything changed. The first person I noticed was Wendy. I dunno but her presence is just sooo different. She always gives me butterflies in my stomach haha
Joanna Michelle Yu samee
이때 조이 처음 봤을 때 충격을 잊지 못함 진짜 세상에 저렇게 사랑스러운 사람 처음 봄
아이돌 되고나서 처음 웃어봤다네욤...
너무 않웃어서 엄마아빠가 웃으니까 뭔일 있냐고 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@연두부-l5g 진짜요?!! 뭔가 조이 웃음상?이여서 원래부터 웃음 많은줄..ㅋㅋ
연두부 그것도 있지 않ㄴ나요 집이랑 너무 달라서 동생인가 누가 기겁했다고 ㅋㅋㅋㅅㅋㅎㅋㅎㅋ
조이라는 이름도 잘 웃으라고 지은 거래여
최한울 처음부터 끝까지 계속 웃고 있음 ㅠㅠㅋㅋㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱ 아 너무 예뻐
Wendy looks the prettiest in this era ( if compared to other era of hers)
agree...
true
👍
So true. I still find it baffling that some say Wendy's not pretty. Those people need to get their eyes checked! LOL!
Yeah I really agree
wow joy looks like a baby she is soooo cute
i miss this wendy.
I miss when they werent as skinny 😥
Same !!
Why?
peekassboo TV She changed so much 😭😭😭
Ayam Alonso Yup 😭😭
예전에 케이팝스타였나 거기서 박진영이 매 무대마다 돋보이는 멤버가 다르면 그건 팀으로서 가능성이 있다는거라고 했는데 레벨을 보면 딱 그 말이 떠오른다
No entiendí pero te doy like uwuuwuwuwuwu
한국어를 몰라 스페인어 번역가입니다
다 다르겠지만 개인적으로 전 웬디는 행복 아이린은 빨간맛 예리는 음파음파 조이는 피카부 슬기는 배드보이 때인 것 같아요ㅠㅠㅠ직캠들 보면 진짜 미쳐버릴 것 같아요ㅠㅠㅠ흑흑
한국어를 모르겠어요 번역가입니다
송예림 저 진짜 조이 피카부 직캠 볼 때마다 눈물 광광이에요
머리색은 진짜 신의 한 수였음... 멤버 구분도 잘 되고
상큼했죠 머리색깔로 불리던 시절
저 머리색 너무 잘 빠져서 애들 머리 아랫 부분만 빗자루 됐다고 하네요
ㄹㅇ 아직도 슬기 하면 주황색 웬디 하면 파란색 이런식으로 은연중에 색깔 이미지가 떠오름
여신 =핑크
고음=파랑
김연아선수=노랑
김유정=초록. 이렇게 외웠음ㅋㅋ그때
@@신부경-l2w ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
개인적으로 이때 웬디가 너무 이쁨
ㅇㅈ...
쿨톤공주,,, 우리 웬디 쿨톤인데 쿨톤메컵해줘요ㅠㅠ 아이린보다도 하얀데 왜 웜톤메컵해줘요ㅠㅜ
그니까 저런 하이틴 화장 한 번만 해 주세요...... 웬디우주뿌셔
왜저래 웬디 봄웜이래요 아이린 여쿨이고
@@말이안통하네트-r9i 하얗다고 다 쿨톤은 아니지..
i miss wendy in this hairstyle
Who doesn't?
o đ Ii b n
lulistyles k ur not the only one
Carat 디노오빠바라기 Instead of prettier, I think it's more towards fresh. Wendy looks so refreshing with this hairstyle
sameeeeeee
2:57 요때가 웬디의 시원한 고음 나오면서 제대로 기분업되는 구간이라 생각함......약간 sm 특유의 색깔의 고음 같이 느껴지기도 하고 말이죠...
더운 여름에 파도 맞은 기분 ..행벅해..
이때 웬디밖에 눈에 안들어왔음
제일 리즈시절
성녀파트..
데뷔때 레벨은 진짜 다 하나하나 이뻐서 소름이었음 에스엠이 걸그룹을 급하게 낸다 말 많았는데 급하게 낸거치고 멤버들이 다 너무 완성형 미모 실력이었음ㅋㅋㅋ
인정이요 ㅋㅋㅋ
그런데 갑자기 이제와서 무슨 아오
둥둥이제 ? 무슨 말이에요?
@@아이스아머라카노-b5t 유지민만 유지민인가...
@@도우너어서오고-v7g 에셈에서 그나마 제일 나은 애들이래요...ㅎㅎㅎ (스엠 관계자 피셜.)
Wendy's hair goal was Happiness era. Please grow her bangs. She looks gorgeous without bangs. Joy looks like a actress girl who kim....
the actresses name is Kim Yoo Jung maybe! I see their resemblence here
she needs to grow out her bangs, not cut them
@@yansoph4809 true. If she cuts it, it won't look good.
LMAO if she cut them she'd have bald spots in the front💀💀
*She looks gorgeous without bangs* exactly.
지금 들으니 가사가 진짜 교훈적이다,, 이런 가사는 가요계에선 다신 안 나올듯
@@nililiaa 비유ㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋ
유영진 그 자체
이 때는 유영진 자본치료 완성도 한 20% 였어서 세상을 용서하지 않았을 때
세상을 용서하지 않았댘ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
조이 풋사과 그 자체...ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 그리고 이 시절의 웬디 냉한 분위기 넘 좋아함ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I love Seulgi and Wendy's voices
This!
Desert Rose
same
I love joys
Same
Keep in mind that sungjae was one of the viewers
right
IKFR XDDDDDD
WAIT REALLY
OMG YES haha I remember that now
btob sungjae aka joy's wgm hubby
I CANNOT BELIEVE THAT WENDYS VOCALS ARE THAT STRONG AFTER 3 MINUTES OF SINGING *A N D* DANCING!!??????
You should see their performance of this song at the end of the Redmare concert. Two hours of performances and they still nail it.
karrie anna chaparian it’s in her DNA. She was meant to be a star
Talent.
You should see her performance in la rouge. She did high notes after high notes (you better know-hit that drum-zimzalabim) and still stable af
대체 저때 조이보고 살빼라 한 인간들은 뭐냐 진짜 ....너무 귀엽고 사랑스럽다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 저렇게 상큼하고 완벽한 데뷔무대는 레벨이 정말 처음이자 마지막이다..다들 사랑해
조이가 타멤버들에 비해 키랑 골격이 커서... 깡마른게 아니면 덩치가 커보여서 살쪘다고 말한 것 같아요 그리고 저때는 조이 얼굴에 젖살 있었을때라
ㅇㅈ 뺄 살이 어디있다공
살빼서 더 이뻐진건 팩트
저 때 아닌데,,, 살 빼라고 얘기 나온 건 비내추럴, 덤덤 때였음 그래서 7월 7일 때 확 빼서 나온 거고
@@빈계정-l1t 저때도 그런 얘기 조금씩 나오긴 했어요 살빼라는 얘기 많이 나온건 님이 말씀하신 때가 맞구용
Miss the days when ppl are stuck to choose between wendy and irene for the visual
Sehunnie's Bol too bad theyre all pretty lol
seulgi too, actually.
lol i still remember that.
Why not anymore?
Maggie Wang because their stylists keep giving Wendy bad styling and Wendy keeps getting bangs because she’s prob insecure with her forehead:/ They’re all beautiful.
지금이랑 데뷔때 이미지 새삼 다르다ㅠㅠ 웬디 지금은 순둥이인데 저때는 교포느낌+메보 카리스마까지 있어보였음 아이린만큼 눈에 띄었지.. 조이는 진짜 막내에 사랑스럽고ㅠㅠ 지금 같이 치명+섹시 이미지 상상도 못함...
This comment has 666 likes... ( 𝕀𝕄 𝕋𝔼ℝℝ𝕀𝔽𝕀𝔼𝔻 )
SM Main Vocalists are so damn good, Taeyon, Jessica, Wendy, NingNing, gosh there are so many, rigorous training indeed... powerful voices.
Luna and Bada also
I have arrived at the same conclusion...with the same girls! I am adding Winter to that list, and Seulgi. I love SM Vocal style! I also read a while back, that they compose music and songs to suit the vocal skills of particular artists.....They put it, "They want to maximize their talents....we can see that with Wendy here....I mean "holy smokes!!!"
Winter! Too
@@jkjcord762 she’s not the main vocal. we’re hyping only the main’s.
Luna Victoria are good too
it’s almost their 2021 comeback yet NO ONE can top wendy’s ‘SHINE ON ME’. WOW
TRUE
진짜 데뷔 때 웬디 개이쁘다..
저 유학파스러운 느낌이 너무 젛았음
let's just admit it... we all thought wendy was visual, joy was a rapper, irene was main dancer, and seulgi was main vocalist in the start.
Well they were right about seulgi and joy lmfao plus Wendy's bridge literally screams main vocal
And I thought wendy was overrated or something cuz she's a visual and main vocal but daaaaam I hate myself for thinking that, and here I am a big fan of her
Wendy is my favourite and she’s so pretty but Irène being the visual was as clear as ice
How could you think Wendy wasn’t a vocalist with her “shine on me” :(
i thought seul was their main vocalist
EHM JOYS MOVE THINGY AT 2:32 IS MY FAV IT LOOKS SO COOL
+Aida omg thought i was the only oneee
+Mae Lu it's just so sassy, fierce, sexy and cute at the same time
i knowwwww
+Aida yasss
Mae Lu
I missed kpop with raw vocals like this
HELPP THE SHADE TOWARDS WONYOUNG AND LEESEO'S LIP SYNC IM CRYING 😭🤚
@@angecore_yt ?? i dont think it was shade..
@@angecore_yt not necessarily? Lol even RV themselves lip synch in music shows/some festivals. Everything’s just over-perfect and overproduced with Kpop these days.
@@angecore_yt I'm not shading anyone tho, why did you assume I'm shading specific idols? 😀
you're embarrassing
레드벨벳 아직도 신인같이 느껴지는데... 5년전이라니..ㅠㅜㅠ 시간 너무 빨라
아직도 신인같다고 느끼신다는건 당신 생각에 레드벨벳의 실력향상이 전혀 없었다는 뜻이네요.
@@신승훈-g9b 그만큼 시간이 빠르다고 하는겁니다! 마지막 말에 나와있어요!!
강민현 그만큼 다양한 컨셉을 들고 나오고 매 무대에 열심히 했으니까죠
@@신승훈-g9b 최근 댓글 단 꼬랒 보소 ㅋㅋ
@@신승훈-g9b 지나간 시간이 실감이 안 나신다는 말이겠죠.. 왜 이렇게 꼬투리를 잡으려고 난리에요 과거를 추억하고 있는 분한테
Irene : Mature
Joy: Light
Wendy: Powerful
Seulgi: Soulful
Elysia Faith yeri???
Yeri: Baby
Yeri: Joyful
Joy:literally Joy
@@jomersontan7332 lol
are we going to ignore the fact that during wendy’s shine on me part there’s a missing spot just for yeri
And I just noticed that Yeri was on their MV🤔
Squirrel Hoseok it’s really in the beginning if you look at the bottom of the screen
With other SM trainees too
Damm I forgot about Yeri, shame on me, don't deserve being a fan of these perfect band.
Also Irene is wearing purple socks maybe giving the sign that yeri was coming
웬디 눈썹 돌려내ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ교포느낌 최고였는데 어느순간부터 일자눈썹으로 바뀌더니 순한인상 되버렸어,, 행복때 진짜 최애였는데 다시 돌아와줘ㅜㅜㅜㅜ그리고 쾌차하길
In 2014: i got red velvet
In 2015: i got twice
In 2016: i got blackpink
Thx to god for tht 3y straight
In 2018 : We Got (G)-Idle
In 2019 : We Got ITZY
Wiktor Rogala how about 2017
I prefer 2013 with BTS, 2014 with Red Velvet and 2015 with TWICE
Fuck gaypop shittest music
@It's Paydaypie! Wonder girls, snsd, 2ne1, bigbang, Miss A not 2013
I prefer this hairstyle is better than now....wendy's no bangs slay!...
Angela Roque I know Wendy looks so nice without bangs... that damn stylist
Yes she looks so muchas better
Sungjae saw this stage! WGM
Mariel Rodríguez yeah and his cute BOOYAH!
Mariel Rodríguez YESSSS!!!!!~ THE SHOW WE GOT MARRIED!!!
BOOYAH!! 😂😂❤️
Mariel Rodríguez
BOOYAH!!!
HAPPINESS!!
Sungjoy for life lol
their live vocals sounded so good
If RV's clothes represent Hogwarts houses then their color really suits them
-Irene, Gryffindor. Even though she's a bit of a shy type, she definitely got that leader courage and fair judgement in the bag.
-Wendy, Ravenclaw. We all know Wannie got a wide variety of skills, right?Even in school Wan had good grades and involved in a lot of activities
-Seulgi, Hufflepuff. Definitely have that patience, loyalty and hardwork nailed down. 7 YEARS of training?A lot of people would've gave up by that point.
-Joy, of course the evil maknae goes Slytherin. Clever, up-front, ambitious (Joy did say she wants to film a CF with Lee Sooman LMAO). This girl is just a bag of mischief (along with Yeri now). Do i need to say more??
harry potter huh 😏😁
And joy slytherin
+chocoKookie What about Yeri? Hehe.
+snowysnowwish cant think of😅😅😂
+snowysnowwish Yeri is a muggle
Why is no one talking about how cuTE JOY IS HERE
Yes.She is my cutest bias.
she cutie
Definitelyyy she's soo cute 😭❤️
this name kinda sucks She is sooo cuteeee ❤️
His voice too
Like/dislike ratio gets better day by day. Haters are feeling the happiness.
Love this comment :)
Red velvet the best💛💛💛💛💛💛💛
Raymond Liang 3 years later only 1.2 dislikes
행복 무대때 웬디 딱 눈에 들어왔는데 ..진짜 잊을 수 없다
the era when most of us thought Wendy was the visual
Really?? I never knew that omg i thought everyone loved irene and Joy
when they debut i already knEW IRENE IS THE MAIN VISUAL BECAUSE WHEN SHE IS YOUNG SHE IS ULZZANG KID.
I AM REVELUV SINCE DEBUT.♥♥♥
XIAOYI YUQI YINLIN most people thought it was Wendy or Irene.
Google says seulgi is the visual
Ikr.. when they debuted i really thought wendy was the visual.
Imagine if Wnedy was sick and could not perform live i wonder who will sing the Shine On Me part 😂
omg
I feel like Joy would, Wendy and joys voices are more alike than Wendy and Seulgi.
Kpop RedVel yup but seulgi has better vocals
I think is seulgi cos sm say seulgi has a vocal level similar to taeyeon
Pearlyn Tan similar but like not as good as Taeyeon but a good vocalist still
i love wendy's and irene's outfits . i want them!!!!!!!
Same here
신인 아이돌들 자신감 넘치는 청량 무대 국룰 아니냐구요... 그중에서도 레벨이 가장 선명하게 기억남 카스 프사 전부 레드벨벳에다가 여자애들 투톤 머리 따라하고 특정 멤버만 인기많인게 아니라 전부 인기가 많아서 특히나 놀랬던 그룹...
Wendy looked so pretty;; I miss her dark hair without bangs
2:57 - 3:05 wendy sings very best, WOW !!!
Trang Trang get your grammar fixed it’s Wendy sings very good
Or to fix your grammar
“Wendy sings very good, I like her vocal color”
First person that caught my eyes is 💚💚💚Joy💚💚💚 Her voice is so cute .Totally obsessed wif her😍
Same Here!!♥
I'm obsessed with joy to she so adorable and he voice is adorable too
Her**
yes so true *^* ♥
👍
Can we bring this old Wendy back.. She was just sparkling brightly during this era.. She had this spark on her that I don't see anymore these days..
what 😐
stfu
agreed
@@monstrua-k4c well Wendy did say some ignorant things about black people so yeah she isn’t the same as before but then again she could have always been ignorant.
Nothing changed 😐
This song make me attracted to Wendy. I like her part from 2:57 - 3:13.
She was glowing.
근데 이때 아라 진짜 찌인하게 그렸는데도 소화하는 레드벨벳은..ㄷㄷ 존나 이쁘네 걍 다 이뻐 맴버가 이쁜얼굴 맴버들 다 100위 안에 들던데 진짜 엑썰런트~
ㄹㅇ 하나같이 죄다 비주얼멤 심지어는 나중에 들어온 예리 마저도 비주얼
Back to when Wendy still got most of the screen time :( She's so underrated now. I feel bad because I love her so much!
Me 2 and the fact half of the fandom ignores her
Foxglove then Damn I run into bad post then, most of the time I run into post always talking about Irene and joy and seulgi! And ignoring Wendy and yeri!
I feel like the very recents have been good but some older videos haven’t ! As a Wendyluv it sucks seeing your bias get ignored and hate and yeri my bias wrecker!
@Foxglove Pfff. Yeah she only gets noticed these days on the rare days they let her bangs shine (is it only me that finds her pretty either way? Though I especially like her Psycho hairstyle) and when it's a singing based video.
Other wise most mention usually go
The top comments are:
Irene/Joy/Seulgi
Or
Seulgi/Irene
Or
Seulgi/Joy
Or
Joy
And then there's
Yeri/Wendy
Or Yeri
And then Wendy or
Wendy and the Yeri
I really hate the fact that ppl throws the word "underrated" just because their idols didn't get enough recognition they wanted (¬_¬)
@@wia752 I agree, ppl project themselves onto their idols and take it way too personally-it seems. To expand on your point- many, not all, kPop fans seem make it about themselves. Example, there will be a thread in the comments that flows like a conversation and focuses on one topic or about a member. Someone will break topic with a post like: Why isn’t anyone talking about how {insert adjectives} (Insert Member Name) is? followed by large quantities of emojis to really nail your point. Like your whole job is to be the PR rep/agent for your bias?. Where is the fun in that? Why turn what is supposed to be entertainment into something so tedious?
보다가 생각나는건데 에펙스부터 엑소 럭키원(2016)까지는 진짜 에셈틱하게 노래를 잘 구성한듯 약간 공상적이게? 아무리 레벨 샤이니 에펙 엑소가 다 컨셉이 다르다 해도 거기 녹아있는 톡톡 튀고 기묘하지만 깔끔한 느낌이 있었음.... 막 데뷔한 에스파는 옛날 선배들 느낌은 확실히 안 나는듯.. 그러나 아무리 말 많아도 스엠은 못잃는다 돌아와줘요 이수만
Irene : Gryffindor
Seulgi : Hufflepuff
Wendy : Ravenclaw
Joy : Slytherin
Lmao😂
Yeri??????
쁘니 yeri wasn’t in rv during the happiness era so I’m not sure what color they would designate her
쁘니 If yeri had been in the group, i feel like theyd have done purple
@@smileyface8434 purple is actually her official color, used in her welcome video and in everything related to her :)
In this i thought that Wendy was the visual, she look so beautiful, gorgeous and with charisma. I miss this look, I miss this era when Wendy has black hair andand without bang.
2022....and this still blows me away!!!! Wendy's "Shine on me" and the choreo....is just FUN!!! Love this live show!!!
It's 2024 and I'm back to experience this iconic debut. Damn, Wendy! You are too good even then.
*Red Velvet Before:* SO CUTE!!
*Red Velvet Now:* THEY KNOW HOW TO MAKE THE DEVIL CRY!!!
Wendy's "Let it shine on me" part is one of my favorite parts in the song omg I stan a queen
마 이게 신인의 패기고 열정이다
오오오...!!!
웬디 데뷔때가 레죤드인듯 이때 넘예뻐 이미지가 달라진것같은데 뭐가 달라진거지ㅇㅅㅇ
눈썹이 달라졌어요! 데뷔때는 외국느낌 나는 아치형이었는데 지금은 일자눈썹...
I miss this era 😢😢 it's sad that yeri couldn't join RV from the start. Now that she in the group,RV is completeeee ahhh can't wait for their comeback!!!who is watching this is 2016??
me
meee!!
+sm. rkieus they had comback already
+Annie Hannie September
I am
웬디 눈썹좀 제발 저렇게 해줘
색만 좀 연하게 하면될거같은데
저 눈썹이 안답답하고세련돼보이는데
왜 일자를 고집하는거지
난줄
웬디는 데뷔초 행복때나 비내츄럴때처럼 스타일링하는게 더 개성있고 예쁜듯
진짜 웬디 너무 이쁨ㅠㅠㅜㅜㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 세상 상큼하고 웬디나라세우자
진짜 이때 해외교포 해외유학생 느낌 엄청 나고 이뻤는데 지금 너무 흔한 스타일링 해서...
이때 너무 욕많이 먹어서 스탈링 바꾼거자나요.... 대중 기준에 맞춰놓으면 전이 좋았다 이러는거 참..
난 이때 웬디가 비주얼멤 담당인줄 알았음
저두여...
어차피 다 비주얼..
아이린 얼굴이 황금비율에 넘사벽이라서 그렇지 아이린 옆에서 다른 멤버들 안 꿀리는 거 보면 다 비주얼멤임 레벨 얼굴은 걍 취향차이일뿐 ...
@@user-gs5nn7sm2c ㄹㅇ SM이 괜히 스엠이 아님
뚝딱이도 메댄으로 만들어버리는 정보력, 기술력 끝났지 ㅁㅓ...⭐️
실력은 보장되구 비주얼도 믿음감
아이린이 수박상이라 그렇지 모두 다른 그룹에 가면 비주얼에 코어 단단한 포지션들
꺄아 언니!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
저두용 아이린이랑 웬디
이땐 몰랐지 라이브도 출중 하고 댄스실력도 좋고 다들 이쁘고...요즘 걸그룹들 보면 이때 왜 레드벨벳의 진가를 몰랐을까 후회 하게됨.
2007: we got wonder girls
2008: we got girls generation
2009: we got 2ne1
2010: we got sistar
2011: we got fx
2012: we got 4minute
2013: we got dreamcatcher
2014: we got red velvet
2015: we got twice
2016: we got blackpink
2017: we got weki meki
2018: we got g idle
2019: we got itzy
2020: we got aespa
2021: we got ive
2022: we got billlie
Also for 2014 we got Mamamoo
No hate intended 💜💜😀
true
2013 we got Dreamcatcher
2012 we got 4minute
2011 we got fx
2010 we got sistar
2009 we got 2ne1
2008 we got wonder girls
2007 we got girls generation
2020: we got cignature
@@esiol2546 everglow debuted in 2019 :))
개인적으로 웬디 첨보고 너무 예뻐서 충격받았음....
Who wear Blue skirt i think she is very pretty.
๋ZackFai2 Temeeyasoot Wendy
Thank you.
Wendy
Gail Playz Roblox!!!! First guy already said that
Seungwaniiee
7 Years later, Wendy is still hitting high notes and as energetic as ever 💙
Sungjae Was here!!!!!!!!!
Lmao, he saw this stage.
He's one of the views ♡o♡
Irene looked so much happier and expressive back then.
_I can hear Sungjae’s voice after RV saying “happiness” 😂❤️_
웬디 유학해서 그런가 하이틴 느낌 나는거 같아 그 오디션? 기타치면서 노래하는거 대박임 알아서 찾아 보삼
예전에 가족들이랑 뮤뱅 데뷔무대 본방으로 보고 저 핑크머리 누구냐고 와 이쁘다하고 봤는데 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 물론 이건 음중이지만... 아이린 개이쁘다
2:32 I fucking love this part
Me, too!
Oh my god yeah especially in the video when it's quiet then loud and I love Wendy's solo
YES !
saaaaame
Rocío M ikr but for me and my sister we yell out "PEW PEW PEW"
벌써 6년차라는게 믿기지가않는다,,
NO BUT ARE WE NOT GONNA TALK ABOUT THE CAMERA WORK
i mean
1. The intense zoom ins and outs
2. The hand fancams
3. The leg fancams
4. And the earhtquake at 3:19
EVERTHING ABOUT THIS WAS A MASTERPIECE
My baby Sooyoung was such a baby back then........ 아이구구구구구구ㅜㅜㅜ뚜영아언니따랑해
The one in green.
늘그막에 이노래를 만든 유영진은 정말 노래만드는 신이다..인간아님
참 대단한사람
*Meanwhile, Sungjae watch this vid in the corner*
Also Sungjae: HAPPINESS!!
"BOYAH"
😂😂😂
Nobody:
Sungjae:"sOmEtIMeS YoU GoTtA bE BOLD jUsT RoCk tHe WoRlD BOYAH"
Who is it?
킬링보이스 보고 생각나서 보러옴ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 다들 너무 풋풋하다
RED VELVET WILL ALWAYS BE MY BEST FEMALE GROUP!!!!!!
0:42 When Joy was still Irene’s daughter. Good old times :))
That's funny because at that exact time, the lyrics said "Aigoo my daughter"
:')
Im really liking them so far
I see you commenting a lot on Crayon Pop videos, I'm not surprised you like Red Velvet :) [in a good way]
xposum lol Happiness is better than Crayon Pop alot. No offense but I think Happiness's vocal are much better than Crayon Pop
exotics00423 You do realise the song is called Happiness not the group right? Just saying
exotics00423 Could you stop comparing? Lol.
Exotics00423, you should give crayon pop a bigger chance. The twins ( ChoA and Way ) and Soyul all have 4 octaves. They can actual sing extremely well. Guess they're just hiding their potential and waiting to show it later in the future. You should see "I am beautiful" performance by them. But please don't compare crayon pop and red velvet. They're both from different companies, and have different concepts/styles, etc. They're both amazing.
Omayghad idk why I cried when Wendy hit those high notes. I'm not even a fan of RV but I watch their performances and listen to their songs from time to time.
All the comments: *all about wendy*
Me: OMORBSJS MAH GIRL IS GETTING NOTICEDDD
ME:
@Chidima Amadi ok. you blind.
아 무대 보니까 이수만 응원석에서 응원봉으로 먼지털이 들고 있던 거 생각남 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
링크좀 ㅜ
@@띨빵이-e3p 행사 때 들고 갔던 거라서 영상은 잘 모르겠고 이수만 먼지털이 구글에 검색하면 들고 있는 모습은 나와용
omg joy is sooo beautiful. LOVE HER BODY!!
나는 조이 보고 그 처음 느낌을 잊지 못함 저렇게 무대에서 행보과게 웃고 반짝반짝 빛나는 사람 처음봄
rv is such a cute group! wendy is my fave
You predicted the future.
WENDY'S VOCALS
That's all. That's the comment.
I miss Wendy’s forehead ❤️
Shine on me, Wendy’s forehead!!!
W h a t
조이 음색은 진짜 ㄹㅈㄷ다
All those screams during Wendy's solo tho...
I totally love Wendy and Joy's parts!! Wendy kills 'em with them vocals and Joy.... DAMN Joys is just one bag packed of adorable-ness 💜
*Keep coming back here because this is wendy's era she really shined her and i miss her hair, her confidence and the time when people call her the visual member even thought its irene*
Wendy: Shine on me !!!
People in the backstage: * Turns off lights *
2:14 아이린 파트때 팬이 배주현 배주현 소리 지르니까 파트끝나고 웃는거 왜이리 귀엽지ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 저게 배주현이라고 하는 거였구나
@@syo8158 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ네
강슬기도 따라서 씨익 웃는 거 개발린다......
완전 풋풋하다... 이거 처음 나왔을 때 그 충격을 잊지 못한다... 초6땐가 5때나 왔던거 같은데
Irene=Best Dancer
Seulgi= Prettiest
Wendy=Best Singer
Joy=Cheerful Maknae
Irene is the prettiest and seulgi is the best dancer
+Wey Reun actually, Irene is the prettiest and the best dancer. She's better than seulgi.
+Kayla Sloan LOL nope U can go see their weekly idol episode. They said Seulgi was in charge of dance in red velvet so that means she's the best Dancer
+Silvia Cruz everyone,seulgi is too pretty and best dancer while irene is the prettiest and the best rapper
+DIrectioner 4ever :P exactly
다들 아이린 웬디를 외칠때 나혼자 조이를 외쳤음 존예존긔존나상큼해
행복 나왔을 때 댄스 동아리 애들이 난 파랑색 초록색하면서 파트 정했던 거 생각나네 ㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 저 투톤은 혁명이었어