Neil deGrasse Tyson on Tesla's Wireless Power & Energy Transfer
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ก.ย. 2024
- Nikola Tesla's most famous invention was arguably the Tesla coil. This was the first known system that could wireless transmit electricity
#nikolatesla #teslacoil #WardenclyffeTower #freeenergy
Subscribe Now to stay updated with Interesting videos like this.
SUBSCRIBE! : cutt.ly/5yaVpaf
“Reflecting off your scalp,” yes he really did say that to joe
Better than “bald 👨🏻🦲 dome”
Tyson would kill him hold on wrong Tyson whoops
@@JeffJeffJeffJeff33
he planned that shit
Does he ever really answer a question I've not seen him do it 😂
He literally answered the question you just understand what he's saying
@@pandarick9337 he didnt. Joe asked him about wireless energy transmission and Neil answered “well, there are no much energy in photons”. Who asked that?
@@glexe5033 that’s literally the answer to the question
@@glexe5033 just because you don't understand what he said doesn't mean he didn't answer the question. He did. If your going to do wireless energy photons would be the way to try it but there isn't enough energy carried over from photons. It's cool if you don't understand the science.
@@pandarick9337 ha I love when young people who watched a vsauce video or two think they know everything. A photon is just the particle behavior of em waves which are already used in commercial settings to wirelessly transmit power. The fact Neil starts condescending Joe on what a photon is shows that he probably should stick to talking science to middle schoolers and Steven Colbert's audience (not mutually exclusive)
Damn he got called out for having no hair
*s c a l p*
Then saved it by making fun of his nose
Ahaha I’m glad I’m not the only one who noticed the scalp remark and the nose save try ahahah
Pro tip: pubes receive more electromagnetic energy than any other kind of hair.
@@iwishiwasthomasshelby idk, I would think they were moister in general.. wouldn't that mean they're subjected to less friction?
Would LOVE to see Nikola respond.
ummm or you can just step back and think.
there's wireless phone chargers, they're not even expensive.
wirelessly transmitting power to your device.
do you really think that's not using the phenomena identified by Tesla?
gotta love how people can simultaneously own things and be led to believe those things are impossible.
@@likwidmocean they used his idea. But I believe Tesla would’ve been more superior. Plus they’re still charging you, Tesla would’ve made it free
@@likwidmocean wireless chargers works with electromagnetic induction, you need a magnet for that, i think its not the same
@@anthonymeier628 yeah but how? Who's gonna install the towers? Who's gonna build the devices that charges on thin air? How you gonna convince all those people involved in building those stuff to work for free? Cuz tesla said so?
@@anthonymeier628 sun light is the closest we can get for “free energy” but you still gonna need “money” to extract and store it
"I've got a big nose you've got a big head" 🤣😂
"You have a big bald shiny head."
Is what I got from that answer.
Tesla was leagues above this goof
Not really. Tesla made a good engine, but somebody else did almost the same thing independently a couple years before that, and just about the entire scientific community agrees that his energy transmission ideas were BS.
And Edison didn't sabotage him either.
Nikola Tesla is Croatian 🇭🇷🇭🇷
Most people are... this man is insufferable.
@@boosta3094 Croatia wasn't it's own country until 1941 when the collaborated with Hitler, long after Tesla was born. According to your logic he was Astro-Hungarian. Lol. We both know Nikola Telsa is Serbian. But nice try.
@ivan barrama if you've ever worked with tesla coils you'd know that to get a bolt to travel around the earth, you'd need a coil orders of magnitude larger than any one we've ever built. And if you studied Tesla's work, you'd see he was a bit of a nutjob.
I think he works for the government
Govern = to Rule/Control
Ment = Mind
"To rule/control the mind"
Controlling the flow of information, what you think and/or believe - and thereby influence how citizens behave.....
Yeah, that checks out.
Right !?
The why has nobody recreated A SINGLE ONE OF TESLA'S EXPERIMENTS EXACTLY EVER!?!?
All the evidence in the world isn't enough for contrarians to get behind widely believed things, but the mere shadow of a question is enough to get behind conspiracy or contrarian ideas. But it's all talk...if they really believed it, they would just build the thing.
Henry S. You sir are correct...thank u
Nichola Tesla was an absolute undeniable genius!! And if he said it would work, Then it would work.. i believe Tesla over Neil degrase any day of the week.
I believe this man I've never met and not that man I've never met!
Blinks eyes in Morse code...."Joe, they will detonate the chip in my brain if I answer that question honestly".
For real
Dodged that question skillful with a mouth full of words 😂
He actually answer it... Pay attention next time and maybe you will get it.😪
@@franciscolima1762 nah I don't believe he did
@@viciousmindzentertainment9307 it's not about what you believe, the video is still available to watch.
@@franciscolima1762 it's not a belief it's difference in definitions of which the a means for Sciencific Theory...you made a choice of one and I another so our perspectives differ and that the greatest part of life...is it a 6 or a 9 ? Lol
He said the energy in visible light isn't powerful enough to power things.
Tyson loves the sound of his own pompous voice.
It's okay if you don't understand his answer.
@@leonfrancis3418 huh?
@@leonfrancis3418
You just responded to a question never asked... defending a man who did not answer the question he was asked. Does anyone else see the irony here?
His answer was completely trash. Joe was talking about electricity this mf started talking about visible light. He wasn't talking about solar. Umm ionosphere...
@@leonfrancis3418 Says the midwit to a genius IQ.
No monetization, so the investors pulled out. So no free energy...
Either that or certain death by transmitting electricity through the air. 1 of them 2 things is correct
So you called him bald without calling him bald
The did it on that history show by having a copper wire going through the ground as well. As long as they were grounded the electricity worked.
Leedskalnin said to just put a huge pole in the ground, the higher and deeper, the better
There are many ways to obtain electricity but not all of them are practical. my grandfather built an apparatus like a giant crystal radio set to receive electricity from the AM broadcast antenna next door. He had 40 amp service to begin with which was typical 80 years ago. This ran 100% of his electrical devices but they weren't many. He used over 1000 lbs of copper wiring to set it up. I attempted to duplicate his results. There is an AM radio broadcast antenna across the street from me and I spent a few thousand dollars building a scaled down version of his apparatus and it runs all my lights. But I have high efficiency LED lights which combined total no more than about 80 watts. I rarely use more than 20 watts at a time. However, my system isn't practical as an alternative energy source as it cost more to build than I would save in electric cost. Solar would have been more cost effective. I did this to see if it could be done. But if you have access to a huge amount of copper wire then you could make it practical.
Likewise, obtaining electrical current from the ground or a great many sources. You can hook up some wires to various fruits and vegetables and get a current that will turn on an LED. To run your air conditioner you would need thousands of dollars worth of material to build something that would be able to suck enough juice out of the Earth to keep it going.
I charge my smart phone with a portable solar charger. It does take time to charge but it also works. If you really want a practical alternative source of electricity I suggest a generator hooked up to a bicycle with a storage battery and then just run D.C. devices.
@@nunyabiznez6381 They didn't use a ton of copper. They built 2 Tesla coils and then ran about a 12 awg wire along the ground between them and then about 30 ft away. They were able to power light bulbs and run a toy boat with wireless power. They just had to be grounded and within range. It could be cost effective if the research and money was invested. It would be the same concept as cell towers but with power.
Niel is the most professional bullshitter I've seen
"If you can't dazzle them with brilliance, baffle them with bullshit"
Neil can't touch Tesla's genius.
I now know less than I did before he asked the question
Tyson being Tyson
The impedance of air prevents the practical broadcast of energy. Think of it as a giant resistor. Almost all of the energy is lost as heat.
@@klocke5247 what is a resistor?
@@franciscolima1762 Be much faster to type that into a search engine. I'll answer any questions you still have after, if you like.
@@klocke5247 to bad Neil can't just ask people to: "type it on a search engine" uh!
The point of what he does is too make something that seems complex into something communicable and easy to understand with less technical term possible that's why his answers seems half-assed, specially to someone who knows the technical term he is trying to put into common day to day words.
You know the saying: if you can't explain it to a seven year old, you don't understand it enough. (Something like that)
Seven year old probably don't know what a "resistor" is.😪
@@franciscolima1762 I seriously doubt he completely understands the concept as he was sputtering around it with haphazard stops and starts. And most telling, lightwaves bouncing off surfaces has zip to do with radio waves being impractical for the transmission of power. Mine was the one any EE would use as their primary explanation.
In person, speaking to someone, I wouldn't have them look up the definition of a resistor. They were already on the net. It's about efficiency. I don't know about 7 year olds, but I'd use whatever explanation is mostly likely to be understood by the level of knowledge assumed to be held by the specific individual. To a child, I may use the analogy of the brake on his bicycle, and expand on that. To others, a short discussion on the conductive properties of materials.
Sorry bro. You're not going to catch me out on this subject.
“And it’s reflecting off of my nose back at you, that’s because I have hair Joe”.
Uh, hi Neil... I'd like to introduce you to lightning. ⚡
imagine just randomly strikeing people with lightinging when they are trying to charge their phones. or like a massive contant arc from a tower to your house. idk man wires work just fine.
@@nick4506 I'm not saying we need lighting strikes, you goof.
He made it sound like the air we breath is the medium Tesla was proposing to push power through and that it was impossible to carry that much juice.
@@xmarine73 the thing is between radio waves and lightning there is nothing. you can either transmit almost no power offer long distances or you can arc. there is not middle ground.
of you are working on high power radio towers you will get white burns all over you from the power, but backaway like 20 ft and you will get nothing. and you cant get power from the radio. they create so much power that they are dangerous to be around but still aren't powerful enough to transmit energy at any scale.
tesla was a genius that made lots of contributions to science but this was a bad idea.
@@nick4506 once again... I'm only disputing what NDT said in this clip.
I'm not debating Tesla's ideas, the Tesla coil, radio transmission, or electricity sent through the ground.
Fing exactly!
He only talked about one specific narrow band wave… You can transmit large amounts of energy.
Just take microwaves for example. Not the oven. But power can be transmitted this way
@@Nashy76 if it was actually that easy, the military would already be using it. They have heat rays, so if it were a viable means of transmitting energy they quite certainly would be using it for that purpose.
Just like electric cars the problem is range . Alternating current through a wire can run much longer distances without losing power .
@@Dr.Westside finally somebody who actually knows how it works and isn't just fawning over a crazy man
@@Dr.Westside That's actually completely wrong. DC has a lot less power loss on long distance than AC. That's why NordLink runs on DC and has about 90% of efficiency on hundreds of kilometers. Try that with AC.
The light is reflecting off bald ass head back to me.. it’s science Joe
wtf did neil even understand the question
He did , he literally explained why it's bad idea 💀
Dude he literally explains it doesn’t work to the scale that Tesla believed it would
Sounds like you just didn't understand the answer.
He understood it and actually answered it. Maybe watched a few times and then you'll understand
You’re correct. Neil derailed and started talking about photons. Tesla was describing the aether, not the same thing as photons.
There's more than enough energy, we just don't know how to harness it. Tesla knew.
You have no clue what you are talking about lmao😭
@@jakeadams3149 Correction: 'You' have no clue what iam talking about. 😂
@@Enoch9500bc average energy level of any given radio wave: 2 x 10^-24 J… tell me what that will power plz.
@@Enoch9500bc also a level of electro magnetism that would cause any sort of high J level would cause many bad side effects. Another reason why this idea of Tesla is not possible. A myth in history to support this mythical legacy
@@Enoch9500bc electromagnetism is well documented and one of the most understood forces in the universe. It has no purpose in Teslas impossible plan, and it’s only real purpose is to transmit information VIA waves.
I hate when smart ppl don't know something... you get this.
Yeah. It's even worse with dumb people because you just get this all the time.
This is what?
Just look up inverse square, FFS
Why is there 3 anime girls posting on my comment? Listen here "Gaymers" it was just a slick comment on the internet. It's not that serious, the man babbles when he talks about stuff he doesn't quite understand and is afraid to say "I don't know". It's pretty common knowledge by the thousands of other ppl who also notice the same thing. Is this guy your crush or what?
@@graybushgamer130 you sound mad bro
_”Reflecting off your... (bald 👨🏻🦲 dome) scalp!”_
Whenever he gets asked a question it looks like some edited in footage from another video. It's like he's having his own conversation.
He's trying to condense his thoughts down to the essence of it. He could just say "no". But, again.. do you think all Neil degrease Tyson would only have the word "no" to say to almost anything science related?
@@DrJellyFanguzzz I'd expect someone who understands a concept really well would be able to efficiently and easily convey the main point to another person. He goes on a long rant and rarely, if ever, goes "so to answer your question: no, that's not how that works".
@@Taison77 he goes on a long rant because he's a science educator. He's not trying to answer the question, his entire goal is to make you understand the whole concept better than before so you can answer your own question. Tyson explained how electromagnetic energy transmits, and using a tiny bit of intelligence, you can infer that what he's saying also applies to the electromagnetic energy that would have been released by Tesla's invention.
A company in Singapore has already done it...
This dude is full of hot air.
So you didn't understand his answer, huh?
@@newprofilesowhat1339 he doesn't understand lol he changes his mind constantly. How high up until you see the curve? First it's 30 miles then 60 miles now over 90 miles up c'mon. Do you actually pay attention to the answers he spews
@@drewmow, so you're a flat earth fruit loop?🤦♂️
@@newprofilesowhat1339 so you believe the moon landing is real? You would believe anything.
@@newprofilesowhat1339 research Eric dubay and change your profile picture to you. Like actually your face so you aren't hiding behind a wall so much. Lets have a Convo after you watch maybe an hour tops of Eric. I love a good discussion
Neil deGrasse "the ass" Tyson doing what he does....
That's right.
That's right.
Way to not answer, he could have a future in politics
Schill for the government.
Paranoia is a mental health issue....
Short 55 of neil degrass tyson not answering the question he was asked
Go back and watch them again because he answered this one and you missed it in your bitter counting.🤣
Neil stands on the shoulders of great men and acts like he’s flying. In this case, however, he falls off… and still acts like he’s flying.
I don't like him. He's a snobby pseudo-intellectual
NDT seems pretty smart if he's like your grade 3 science teacher
It’s not a smartness contest. He’s a teacher.
Random question to deGrasse.
Him: "Well, that's not the point of it, the point is..."
Just side stepped the hell out of that question
No, he didn't? He was saying that Tesla's idea could, in theory, do that, but it wouldn't necessarily be a viable solution. He said that what we use Tesla's idea now for(radio waves, essentially), is a far more practical iteration(literally wireless communication) then what was originally proposed
Let me not answer the question so people don't catch on
I see you didn't understand the answer....
@@newprofilesowhat1339 No I think Neil doesn't answer questions really he kind of talks around questions and Tesla was on the right track look at 5g
Off ya scalp👈🤣💀
You noticed that!!!
Degrassi: I dont know and dont understand it, but heres my opinion
Reflecting off your scalp that was a low blow😂😂
Imagine seeing a kid pulling electricty out of the sky to charge their phone for tiktoks
Einstein was asked
How does it feel to be the smartest man in the world?
: I don't know ask Nikola Tesla
How to tell a shill in 10 seconds
Perfect example of how Academics are captured by the military industrial complex
Yes, but Tesla was referring to tapping the Ionosphere, not gathering photons or radio waves.
Tf have i just watched hahaha. Talking all that shxt nobody asked that
For everyone who thinks Neil didn't answer the question, he actually did answer it! Tesla's wireless energy transmission is how we transmit information it just isn't enough to transmit energy that's exactly what Tyson explained!!!
Love how he just sidestepped the question
No he doesn't, the clip is cut short.
Even Einstein didn't know everything.
Joe: What do you think about Elon Musk's hyperloop?
NDT: The thing is, there is light bouncing off your scalp into my nose and back at you, keeping you warm...
He's certainly no Tesla
His response was basically “I’m not gonna answer that, but you should be satisfied to transmit sounds/images”😂.
*"Shut up baldy, stop pesky questions I have no clue/answer to!"* 🤣
Einstein is to Nikola Tesla
What Tyson is to Carl Sagan
Tesla new ancient technology
You guys took it for your advantage
Tesla didn’t try to get electricity from photons, but from higher atmosphere, there is so much electricity up there that it needs release execess - hence the lightning strike.
“when you control the mail…”
Hello, nnnNewman!!
To anyone thinking he did not answer the question, he did. Electromagnetic waves may be too weak to run an electric car or any high power device. However, they are good at transmitting information.
I do think it could have uses in charging something like cell phones.
Joe really wanted to know if you could pull DMT from the air
💀
I'm pretty sure photons and electrons are not the same thing
I can't stand Neil or the way he "explains" things he never actually answers a question it's always somthing else
He is not fit to sniff Carl Sagan's wind
He was saying that Tesla had the idea of the Internet back then
When you start to realize you don't know anything, you start to talk without assurance.
@@saulverastegui9147 someone with some decent intellect, I’ve searched far and wide for you in this comment section. 💀
Except he always does he just made his answers too simple for for because he believes in what Einstein said: "if you can't explain it to a seven year old, you don't know it enough"
Neil explain the question in a painfully low and dragged level that's all.
Asking Tyson about electricity is like asking a fish how to fly.
this just in! smug man claims to understand god like intellect and the ideas born from it…
He figured a way to transfer knowledge and information thru thin air, only to be received by humans directly thru their frequency, ultimately changing the way we learn and evolve.
He doesnt know how bro, otherwise hed be dead too
💯
Very True!!!
In this episode, Neil Tyson basically goes on to say that “broadcasting” electricity in the way Joe is implying is basically impossible -it would kill/fry everything within the space in which it would be “broadcasted.”
Right, everyone's saying he avoided the question, but to me it was clear that he was explaining that according to science, it couldn't work like that. He's not lying. According to what mainstream science knows, it can't work like that. Give the poor guy (NDT) a break. You guys probably don't know how to make it work either.
... he is part of the "dark side" ! A Gatekeaper! ... N.Tesla was God kissed! Peace
He answered the question if you listened. He said that it wouldn't work because there wouldn't be enough energy, in that form, to run anything.
Which we all know is a bs answer
@@oneioda1982 how is it a bs answer?
Ok then, get close to one of them big ass coils and tell me if there's more information or more energy.
Congratulation. Not only have you answered your own question, you also explained why Teslas bogus idea is nonsense.
The question now is, are you bright enough to realise yourself?
@@Dennis19901 what about wireless phone chargers, bogus nonsense?
Another question, if there is no energy in light how do solar panels work? I don't see any wires hanging from the sky for all the things in space.
@@painkey1189 How much energy do they require vs how much do they transfer?
And remind me again how close a phone has to be for it to have any effect.
You have a brain, use it for once.
@@painkey1189 who says theres no energy in light?
And you know what light also does, especially when carrying large amounts of energy? Destroy anything between it and where it wants to go, ie. Lasers
Also convenient way to transfer energy, something harmful which gets blocked by solid materials.and dissipates over distances.
Do me a favour, next time you comment, actuslly use your brain. Likely for the first tme in your life.
You don't have a clue wtf you are talking about, yet here you are spewing bullshit all over this comment section.
At least mane ONE fucking attempt next time
He wasn't broadcasting information, he had already done that. This invention was a powerhouse. Wireless bumper cars and beyond.
Neil the CIA created scientist
Dr. deGrasse Tyson with the background head joke, drums please 🥁🥁🥁🤣🤣🤣💯💯💯💯💯
He did not understand the question i think ?
Remember when they said the internet was going to be free Tesla was hated because he wasn't making any money from his work
What had Neil ever invented?
Nothing he just regurgitates information he read of scientist before him Lmao
No one believes that energy of quantity can be transmitted. However, tapping energy is a completely different thing. By mixing the two people will always confuse the tower with his free energy research. This is a great way to keep people from looking elsewhere.
All i heard was that Joe has a big dome and Niel has a big nose.
What tesla wanted to do was transmit power through the earth. If you transmit it at the right frequency, the earth is your power cable. You only need to build a receptacle station to relocate power to homes, businesses and so forth. Imagine nearly zero black outs, power stations hundreds of miles away from cities. You could go all nuclear, solar and wind easily.
Don’t believe anything that comes out of that dudes mouth…bought and paid for.
Why do you people dislike Tyson. ?
Tyson is one of the nicest and intelligent people in media.
This dude has always left me unimpressed with his intellect.
Hes more like a glorified text book rather than an intellectual.
What Neil was trying to say is, that If one wanted to harvest electricity from "air", the amount of energy required would make it glow.
*Tyson will never admit to longitudinal electricity.*
He knows better than to answer that question honestly
This actor knows nothing
That's a great point Neil! It's not energy we need to transmit, it's the information. To quote a great press secretary, "That matters, Peter. It really matters.
If he had just said, "visible light photons aren't powerful enough to power things" everyone would call him boring. Can't win I guess 🤷🏻♂️
He doesn't know shit about Tesla
The best part of this was Joe's shiny dome reference.
Rogan just got scalped by Tyson
(while he’s got half an Afro going on)
🤣Rrrraaaahhhhhhhaha
“I have no idea” would have been a much better answer.
... Scalp 😏
That’s the best way to tell a person he’s bald without offending him!!! Kudos. I see your energy!!!!
Aether is Limitless & This Guys Sus👀
We picture is wrong.. The tesla coil needs competly different settings
Paid actor for the state….
Nikola Tesla did run a 1931 Pierce Arrow with 6ft antenna.
I may have to add that radio waves also produce a small amount of energy so it doesn't just have to be waves of light. Photons are not the only wave that floats through our skies.
Bro straight up called JR bald
That's a real scientific way to burn a bald guy 🤣
Joe: Explain Tesla's Electric energy transfer
Neil: Photons and Radio waves..