RM openly admitting how he would come out of his studio alone, after crying a lot while writing black swan, louder than bomb, and we are bulletproof: the eternal because of remembering the past
@@madpleasure I remember there was a vote on Run BTS asking ARMYs what song they want to hear live and they were all surprised Louder than Bombs was so high, it might have been number one?
The Black swan event is not being able to dance anymore which is a dancers "first death" the pain of not being able to do what you love anymore can be a catastrophe. as a dancer I dread the day when I'll have to stop
Their Official MV has the eng subs already. You just need to click the CC button. Most BTS Official MVs have Eng Subs. As long as they don't say "Auto-Generated" they should be correct.
The Black Swan art film mv (which were released prior to this mv) which feature the orchestral instrumentation provided the context to this song. BTS does not appear in the mv n everyone were scratching their heads trying to figure out who did which parts because of the use of autotune. But in actual performances, they do not use autotune and their real voices shone through.
The best thing about this song is how the beat is basically a heart beat changing frequency over and over again, likes its not beating like it should do
'A dancer dies twice, once when they can no longer dance, and this first death is the more painful.’ - Martha Graham. While you have the gist of what they are singing about, it is based on the above quote.
Black Swan comes in the “shadow” part of the Map of the Soul concept. This is a psychological philosophy by Carl Jung. The persona - the outside part of ourselves that we show the world. The shadow - the part of ourselves that we try to bury. The worry, the temptation, etc. The ego - the conscious mind, memories etc All of which we need to equally embrace to reach individuation or self-actualization. Here the black swan event is the moment when music doesn’t mean the same to bts. It’s their fear. It’s their shadow.
RM said in his live stream about the album that he cried while writing 3 of the songs in their album MOTS:7 and black swan was one of them. The others are Louder than bombs and We are bulletproof: the eternal. Hope you can react to them as well.
Thank you for deciding to take your time diving into bts because I do really think it’s hard to try to look past their popularity to see why they’re as great as they are. Not to say it isn’t easy, but just that the numbers and the fans and all that does tend to influence a bias. I would’ve had your same approach. I’ve been fortunate to have been following them since they started, but I do think I’d be able to identify what sets them apart from the rest. They’re such great guys and such good artists. 💖
5:55 you’re correct, it was a hard song to write.. RM (the leader, and THE songwriter of our generation) said he cried a lot while writing it, as well as a lot of the songs on the album this is on
I think you'll find that they're all very expressive in their own ways. A couple of them through dance or performance. Some of them more through their voices. This song's choreo was more contemporary so Jimin was a great choice to bring out the emotion there as it's his specific forte. But BTS has been known since the beginning (2013) and the group that delivers sincerity through their music and performances. I'm sure you'll recognize that as you move further into their discography.
I had to come back to this video after they announced about their break in their music. This song I heard for the first time but did not understand the lyrics till I saw your video. And this just makes so much sense.
i really love it here. you're an intellectual. the way you easily grasp the messages of bts songs is outstanding. many miss out on the first try. 💜 more power! bts write songs based on their life journey, that's why it's personal and relatable. that's why their albums are thematic. it's nice to experience the message entirely by listening to the b-side tracks and how the track list goes as well. ☺️
You should listen to Outro: Tear :((( It was during the time they announced they almost disbanded in 2018. Suga wrote it and when he played it for the other members they all cried ㅜ___ㅜ
Part of Jimin's style comes from his martial arts background. I've always assumed he started martial arts before dance, but I don't know for sure. He has a black belt in Taekwondo, and studied Kendo for 8 years. The explosive moves, flexibility and power, sharp isolations, and mental focus, I think were all trained up in the martial arts work. His personal ethos, too, seems to have been influenced by Taekwondo. But before all that, I think he's a proprioception genius. He's also a storyteller, with both his movements and voice. Also, he's very receptive to other people's humanity. That kind of receptiveness seems to be part of every moment of his life that I've seen. He's not afraid of others' emotions or souls. Here is behind-scenes footage for Jimin's part in this MV. th-cam.com/video/xMfp2jcK52M/w-d-xo.html Ericka Goss, a ballerina who is also a longtime Army, does breakdowns of choreography. Talking about Jimin recently, she said, and I'm paraphrasing, that one of the things that he does that is pretty unique is he will move fast and then stop hard, move fast and then stop hard. She said it is exhausting, that it takes more energy to stop momentum than it does to execute the move. She did a breakdown of the behind-scenes footage that I've linked to above. th-cam.com/video/QN-yrLk-weg/w-d-xo.html
You were spot on!!! This song is about artistic burnout and their fear of falling out of love with their craft and music. It is influenced by the quote "A dancer dies twice - once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful.” This track is in the Map of the Soul album which is based on Carl Jung's psychological theory of human personas; humans have three personas namely the one they hide from the world, the one they show to the world and the ego which balances them out. As this song is about their fears, it relates to the persona which they hide from the world. The entire album is a masterpiece and explores each of these personas on different tracks.
Black Swan is what BTS fear they will become when they no longer love music or feel anything for music. Music has always been their passion and when tht passion is lost, what drives them is no longer there, it feels like you died. Beautiful!
I really appreciated your reaction. So spot on! Thank you so much for taking the time to react to our boys! 💜 I only have one remark... it might be better to watch their videos on the official channel "Big Hit Labels". All the videos (except the songs from their first / second album) have EN Subs. I just dont want you to get in trouble with strikes. But anyway - thanks a lot 🤗💜
Of all the BTS songs, this holds the deepest meaning and spot in my heart. Leaving my last job, which had been defining and empowering time for me, was immeasurably painful. I would play Black Swan every day to calm my anxieties. It was the reminder that this my "first death" but life would come back. Months later I'm in a healthier, happier work environment and this song took on a new meaning. Thanks for reacting to it and giving it such a level of respect that it literally almost made me cry 💜
Man I am binge watching your reaction videos to BTS and your outlook on their music is so well put together. You have a genuine love towards music and I respect that so much. BTS music is so deep and their attention to details is amazing. They are a 100% authentic and talented musicians, dancers, singers and performers. They are complete arrists💜💜
Bro I appreciate your true desire to know them for who they really are and not be lazy to stick to the hype, you'll love them even more ! Black Swan is so deep, it's a masterpiece
We all dread the day when things will stop. When normalities cease to exist and actions that spark unexplainable contentment can no longer be done. It is scary, and yet inevitable. Death can defined in a thousand different ways. My last breath will not be my end, but rather my epilogue. The day I must give into the cruel twist of time and relinquish to it all that I love will be my first.
Thanks Linton .... I appreciate the shout out to me thankss ... Now the next song for is your eyes tell u wanna do a lyric video bec it does not have MV so whenever next time thankss
there was a time in 2018 when they were so terrified of, and overwhelmed by, their success that they almost disbanded. everyone knows they went through hard times at the beginning of their career but it didn't end just because they got big. BTS has never hidden the highs and lows from their fans.
if you feel familiar to this mv it's because black swan as the ballet "swan lake" and the film black swan, notice when at the begining they're in white and they go trasitioning in black to the end, the scene 6:33 Jin in the mirror is not moving, same thing happend in the film black swan (more theory explained better by other people xD )
I’ve watched other reactions to BTS that only touched on surface things. You seem to actually get what they are trying to convey. I really enjoy your comments. Please keep it up!
you mentioned something about ballerina with the the hand movements and yes you were right !!!! jimin took ballet and you were absolutely right !! that dance was jimin
I really appreciate you appreciating the meaning of the songs you listen to and especially the lyrics . You observe things I also see and that’s very cool that you talk about the details 🫶🏻🫶🏻
The Shadow contains all those things that isn't acceptable and you try to repress, this fear of Martha Graham's "first death" lingers in the background and in this video they dive into their shadows to face these fears and rejected parts of self. Everyone has moments of creative block, and we have to work through them in order to continue to function and perform, especially to create.
It's nice that you can see how they love their music, I think that's because they do their own music, they have influence over the creative process. They have a voice and they use it. That's why their music is SOOOO GOOD.
just binged through all you BTS reactions (as well as a few other songs I find interesting) - I really like your thoughts! I’m glad you see the artistry in their music and videos. Hope to see more BTS reactions from you sooner rather than later :)
Wow, you're the first person besides me who knew what a black swan event. I first came across the term when I used to read Scientific American. A black swan event can be good, too. I confirmed with a Google search, which gave this as the top result "A negative Black Swan is one where the downside of the event is unbounded while the upside is capped. Positive Black Swans are just the opposite - those unpredictable, highly impactful events where the upside of the event is unlimited while the downside is capped." I figured this was a Namjoon, and other BTS members', inside joke, that BTS are a Black Swan event. That aligns with their effect on me. I wrote the above before I listened to your reaction. So happy to have found your channel, because you get it right away. They commissioned an art film MV, which is choreographic and danced by a contemporary company, not BTS, for this track. Since you pick up on symbolism so exquisitely and quickly, I recommend it to you. It was released before this MV.
The first death line always got to me because for many people with their talents or their careers or doing what they love their "first death" in life is when that feeling of passion for what they do is gone. BTS has such a passion for music and I think this song really does explain how much they love what they do and how if it was ever taken away from them they would feel as if they are dying which is so powerful
official subtitles are worded better than fan subs, so i suggest you watch the official videos and turn the captions on. Love your reactions tho, i love how you take time to actually read and analyze the lyrics and the mv.
You can watch the making of Jimins Black Swan solo. Yes at point they thought about disbanding. Hence this song. Them being afraid of losing their passion. BLOOD SWEAT AND TESRS is the video that goes with this one. It's about choices. By the way you didn't notice the shadows not moving with them
When I listened to your intro to this reaction, I actually agreed with you. I just recently followed BTS but I'm taking my time studying their lyrics, cinematography, choreography. This pulled me down the BTS vortex but I love my pace. Not joining the hype of those jumping into the boat just because. 💜
I’m enjoying your reactions and feel like you decipher the meaning and intent very well. Also, I love the way you speak. Finally a channel with some serious intelligence involved! It’s refreshing. 💜
ooh bts!! this song is in my opinion the best bts song and it’s insanely beautiful and deep. whenever you have time, i suggest you watch the art film. it gives such great artistic depth to the song and just makes it that much more of a masterpiece. the instrumental is also orchestral so it’s definitely worth the listen.
1st Death, If A Dancer Loses His Passion To Dance 💜 Shadow: "You Are Me, I Am You {acceptance} 💜 Concept taken from the book by Murray Stein "Map Of The Soul" [Jung's Theory] 💜 Watch "Bookish Theories Explanation" video for meaning & understanding of "Black Swan" 💜 Jimin/BTS is doing Contemporary Dancing 💜
More than autotune they layer the voices a lot and then they use reverse. You can hear the slight echo in their voices that’s why it sounds like subtle autotune.
Idk how u r sooo incredibly genius and full of knowledge..The way u interpret their music u have to have knowledge of things..for me always finding the meaning of songs isn’t easy just because i can't always tell the depth of the lyrics..but how u've been understanding those things in ur reaction videos It's truly awesome...
I may be a little late in seein this video but I just wanted to say that this song, when RM was making this, it was one of the few songs that made him cry while he was in the process of making it. And I think that speaks so much of how they really value their music and their song. This is why I stayed because BTS treat their craft so passionately and genuinely that they really feel like it's their death when they no longer feel the same enthusiasm wih music, which has become their life at some point.
love how u react bc u rlly take time to try to understand them and their music! a lot of reactors dont even care abt the lyrics n just look at surface level it’s so disappointing. i think you will really like and appreciate their track Tear. it’s only the rappers no singing but it’s a tear-jerker when you know (they revealed) that it was when they were considering breaking up as a band, so Tear is about them and not a relationship break up song. (They went through some tough times privately in 2017-2018)
Best way to learn them individually is solos yes, but bts run episodes. Ive watched all episodes 4 times now since last summer. 🤣🤦♀️ they are my favorite hobby.
They launched a fully funded global art exhibition together with the song. I think there were tough situation and almost disband back in 2016 and If I’m not mistaken RM said he got his inspiration in music from other form of art and the purpose of launching the exhibition and made it free is to share with the fans their passion and to help other artists there were African, European, South American and Asian artists involve with the project
In BTS live performance of Fake Love MMA 2018 and No More Dream with dance break MOTS ONE the camera shows Jimin showing him hitting every beat as he dances.
To appreciate them as individuals you should watch Who is BTS? The seven members of Bangtan. It talks a little bit about each of their personal struggles as well as a little bit about each of their personal strengths, and gives you an idea of where they are coming from. The black swan event they talk about here is their greatest fear, that the day will come that they will stop loving what they are doing, performing and making music.
This is not kpop, it is BTS. They are their own genre. This was filmed in an old theater in L. A., just like On, Kinetic Manifesto, and J hope’s Chicken Noodle Soup.
Jimin used to do mostly interpretive and ballet dancing before he became a part of BTS so they took ballet lessons and decided to incorporate some of that style in this.
Great reaction! You just get it! Some of my other recommendations: Idol, Mic Drop, Baepsae, Silverspoon, Whalien 52, Ddeang, Cypher series (1-4), Outro: Tear. Bonus: Spring Day explained will blow your mind!
Please react to "BTS - Black Swan Performance (@2020 MMA)" and also BTS (방탄소년단) Black Swan Perf. + ON + Life Goes On + Dynamite @ 2020 MMA. MMA performances are in another huge level.
![Warhammer 40k: Space Marine 2 | เพื่อจักรพรรดิ ! [ตอนเดียวจบ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4M0ckYMA4-U/mqdefault.jpg)
RM openly admitting how he would come out of his studio alone, after crying a lot while writing black swan, louder than bomb, and we are bulletproof: the eternal because of remembering the past
when he said that? i wanna watch.. do you have a link?
@@Funtan_Sonyeondan MOTS7 global press conference th-cam.com/video/_RT5eOGZ5gQ/w-d-xo.html he starts talking about it at minute 46:50-ish
@@yourbibillyhills thank you 😊
I wish Louder Than Bombs would get more love, so under-rated.
@@madpleasure I remember there was a vote on Run BTS asking ARMYs what song they want to hear live and they were all surprised Louder than Bombs was so high, it might have been number one?
Jimin literally is the embodiment of dance and art
I'll drink to that 🍷👌
The Black swan event is not being able to dance anymore which is a dancers "first death" the pain of not being able to do what you love anymore can be a catastrophe. as a dancer I dread the day when I'll have to stop
Their Official MV has the eng subs already. You just need to click the CC button. Most BTS Official MVs have Eng Subs.
As long as they don't say "Auto-Generated" they should be correct.
The Black Swan art film mv (which were released prior to this mv) which feature the orchestral instrumentation provided the context to this song. BTS does not appear in the mv n everyone were scratching their heads trying to figure out who did which parts because of the use of autotune. But in actual performances, they do not use autotune and their real voices shone through.
The best thing about this song is how the beat is basically a heart beat changing frequency over and over again, likes its not beating like it should do
Never recognized that💜
didn't know that 👁️👄👁️
Oh wow!!!!
'A dancer dies twice, once when they can no longer dance, and this first death is the more painful.’ - Martha Graham.
While you have the gist of what they are singing about, it is based on the above quote.
Black Swan comes in the “shadow” part of the Map of the Soul concept. This is a psychological philosophy by Carl Jung. The persona - the outside part of ourselves that we show the world. The shadow - the part of ourselves that we try to bury. The worry, the temptation, etc. The ego - the conscious mind, memories etc All of which we need to equally embrace to reach individuation or self-actualization. Here the black swan event is the moment when music doesn’t mean the same to bts. It’s their fear. It’s their shadow.
RM said in his live stream about the album that he cried while writing 3 of the songs in their album MOTS:7 and black swan was one of them. The others are Louder than bombs and We are bulletproof: the eternal. Hope you can react to them as well.
First time I heard about that I was like Ughh Joonie don't cry. That's what's so amazing that they pour so much emotion into their songs.
was it his recent live?
@@Funtan_Sonyeondan it was last year in his mots7 behind live stream
Thank you for deciding to take your time diving into bts because I do really think it’s hard to try to look past their popularity to see why they’re as great as they are. Not to say it isn’t easy, but just that the numbers and the fans and all that does tend to influence a bias. I would’ve had your same approach.
I’ve been fortunate to have been following them since they started, but I do think I’d be able to identify what sets them apart from the rest. They’re such great guys and such good artists. 💖
Can I just ask why is that? I'm genuinely curious.
@@user-ds6qf8un8d like, why I think I’m able to identify what sets them apart?
@@passionable90 hi do you have twitter? i'd love to follow you there ;--;
5:55 you’re correct, it was a hard song to write.. RM (the leader, and THE songwriter of our generation) said he cried a lot while writing it, as well as a lot of the songs on the album this is on
6:33 jin's reflections didn't move
woah I never noticed that before
I never noticed
ALL MEN IN THIS WORLD LOVE JIMIN 🖤😏
I think you'll find that they're all very expressive in their own ways. A couple of them through dance or performance. Some of them more through their voices. This song's choreo was more contemporary so Jimin was a great choice to bring out the emotion there as it's his specific forte. But BTS has been known since the beginning (2013) and the group that delivers sincerity through their music and performances. I'm sure you'll recognize that as you move further into their discography.
I had to come back to this video after they announced about their break in their music. This song I heard for the first time but did not understand the lyrics till I saw your video. And this just makes so much sense.
I love this song, especially the classical version, but next time watch the official mv it has subtitles too
i really love it here. you're an intellectual. the way you easily grasp the messages of bts songs is outstanding. many miss out on the first try. 💜 more power! bts write songs based on their life journey, that's why it's personal and relatable. that's why their albums are thematic. it's nice to experience the message entirely by listening to the b-side tracks and how the track list goes as well. ☺️
You should listen to Outro: Tear :((( It was during the time they announced they almost disbanded in 2018. Suga wrote it and when he played it for the other members they all cried ㅜ___ㅜ
Part of Jimin's style comes from his martial arts background. I've always assumed he started martial arts before dance, but I don't know for sure. He has a black belt in Taekwondo, and studied Kendo for 8 years. The explosive moves, flexibility and power, sharp isolations, and mental focus, I think were all trained up in the martial arts work. His personal ethos, too, seems to have been influenced by Taekwondo. But before all that, I think he's a proprioception genius. He's also a storyteller, with both his movements and voice. Also, he's very receptive to other people's humanity. That kind of receptiveness seems to be part of every moment of his life that I've seen. He's not afraid of others' emotions or souls.
Here is behind-scenes footage for Jimin's part in this MV.
th-cam.com/video/xMfp2jcK52M/w-d-xo.html
Ericka Goss, a ballerina who is also a longtime Army, does breakdowns of choreography. Talking about Jimin recently, she said, and I'm paraphrasing, that one of the things that he does that is pretty unique is he will move fast and then stop hard, move fast and then stop hard. She said it is exhausting, that it takes more energy to stop momentum than it does to execute the move. She did a breakdown of the behind-scenes footage that I've linked to above.
th-cam.com/video/QN-yrLk-weg/w-d-xo.html
You were spot on!!! This song is about artistic burnout and their fear of falling out of love with their craft and music. It is influenced by the quote "A dancer dies twice - once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful.” This track is in the Map of the Soul album which is based on Carl Jung's psychological theory of human personas; humans have three personas namely the one they hide from the world, the one they show to the world and the ego which balances them out. As this song is about their fears, it relates to the persona which they hide from the world. The entire album is a masterpiece and explores each of these personas on different tracks.
Black Swan is what BTS fear they will become when they no longer love music or feel anything for music. Music has always been their passion and when tht passion is lost, what drives them is no longer there, it feels like you died.
Beautiful!
I really appreciated your reaction. So spot on! Thank you so much for taking the time to react to our boys! 💜
I only have one remark... it might be better to watch their videos on the official channel "Big Hit Labels". All the videos (except the songs from their first / second album) have EN Subs. I just dont want you to get in trouble with strikes.
But anyway - thanks a lot 🤗💜
Your input on your journey through BTS's music is so on point. I was just talking about it today... there's only one first time watching their art!
I read somewhere that RM said he cried writing this song so you know this did mean a lot to not just him but all 7 of them! Loved the reaction!
The orchestral version of this is so magical! Makes you feel some kind of way 🙏
Of all the BTS songs, this holds the deepest meaning and spot in my heart. Leaving my last job, which had been defining and empowering time for me, was immeasurably painful. I would play Black Swan every day to calm my anxieties. It was the reminder that this my "first death" but life would come back. Months later I'm in a healthier, happier work environment and this song took on a new meaning. Thanks for reacting to it and giving it such a level of respect that it literally almost made me cry 💜
Man I am binge watching your reaction videos to BTS and your outlook on their music is so well put together. You have a genuine love towards music and I respect that so much. BTS music is so deep and their attention to details is amazing. They are a 100% authentic and talented musicians, dancers, singers and performers. They are complete arrists💜💜
Bro I appreciate your true desire to know them for who they really are and not be lazy to stick to the hype, you'll love them even more ! Black Swan is so deep, it's a masterpiece
The meaning of this is so deep ..it's about stopping music for them would be like death 💔💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💔
We all dread the day when things will stop. When normalities cease to exist and actions that spark unexplainable contentment can no longer be done. It is scary, and yet inevitable. Death can defined in a thousand different ways. My last breath will not be my end, but rather my epilogue. The day I must give into the cruel twist of time and relinquish to it all that I love will be my first.
Thanks Linton .... I appreciate the shout out to me thankss ... Now the next song for is your eyes tell u wanna do a lyric video bec it does not have MV so whenever next time thankss
thank you for reacting to BTS!!! their lyricism is top-notch thats why i love them. 💜
there was a time in 2018 when they were so terrified of, and overwhelmed by, their success that they almost disbanded. everyone knows they went through hard times at the beginning of their career but it didn't end just because they got big. BTS has never hidden the highs and lows from their fans.
if you feel familiar to this mv it's because black swan as the ballet "swan lake" and the film black swan, notice when at the begining they're in white and they go trasitioning in black to the end, the scene 6:33 Jin in the mirror is not moving, same thing happend in the film black swan (more theory explained better by other people xD )
I'm binge-watching your BTS reactions and can I just say how much I love your mind! Like for real.
Their lyrics are so meaning and it truly shows how passion they have for music!
I’ve watched other reactions to BTS that only touched on surface things. You seem to actually get what they are trying to convey. I really enjoy your comments. Please keep it up!
you mentioned something about ballerina with the the hand movements and yes you were right !!!! jimin took ballet and you were absolutely right !! that dance was jimin
Yes Jimin is the best ❤️
Hmmm, I'm 49 and had never heard that about the term black swan! Thank you for teaching me something today!
Thank you for the reaction, looking forward for euphoria,and cypher
I really appreciate you appreciating the meaning of the songs you listen to and especially the lyrics . You observe things I also see and that’s very cool that you talk about the details 🫶🏻🫶🏻
Fun fact: the theater they recorded this MV in is the same one where Metro Station recorded the MV for Shake It :)
bts lyrical genius
I really enjoyed this reaction! I wish for more about BTS, I feel like your reaction is very genuine.
Please get into more BTS please. Their songs are very meaningful
I saw Aerosmith at Wembley stadium years ago Stephen has amazing stage presence. 🎉😊
Linton you have so much wisdom, thank you for sharing your thoughts and taking your time with BTS 💜
The Shadow contains all those things that isn't acceptable and you try to repress, this fear of Martha Graham's "first death" lingers in the background and in this video they dive into their shadows to face these fears and rejected parts of self. Everyone has moments of creative block, and we have to work through them in order to continue to function and perform, especially to create.
I totally get you!! after realising how deep they are i took my time as well, it took me a year to listen their whole stuff
It's nice that you can see how they love their music, I think that's because they do their own music, they have influence over the creative process. They have a voice and they use it. That's why their music is SOOOO GOOD.
You just made me cry...
just binged through all you BTS reactions (as well as a few other songs I find interesting) - I really like your thoughts! I’m glad you see the artistry in their music and videos. Hope to see more BTS reactions from you sooner rather than later :)
You’re one of the very little reactor to succesfully catch their true message through this song. Good job fam
I'm enjoying how you connect the dots and share your insights on the MV. I'm here for it!
Wow, you're the first person besides me who knew what a black swan event. I first came across the term when I used to read Scientific American. A black swan event can be good, too. I confirmed with a Google search, which gave this as the top result
"A negative Black Swan is one where the downside of the event is unbounded while the upside is capped. Positive Black Swans are just the opposite - those unpredictable, highly impactful events where the upside of the event is unlimited while the downside is capped."
I figured this was a Namjoon, and other BTS members', inside joke, that BTS are a Black Swan event. That aligns with their effect on me.
I wrote the above before I listened to your reaction. So happy to have found your channel, because you get it right away.
They commissioned an art film MV, which is choreographic and danced by a contemporary company, not BTS, for this track. Since you pick up on symbolism so exquisitely and quickly, I recommend it to you. It was released before this MV.
The first death line always got to me because for many people with their talents or their careers or doing what they love their "first death" in life is when that feeling of passion for what they do is gone. BTS has such a passion for music and I think this song really does explain how much they love what they do and how if it was ever taken away from them they would feel as if they are dying which is so powerful
official subtitles are worded better than fan subs, so i suggest you watch the official videos and turn the captions on. Love your reactions tho, i love how you take time to actually read and analyze the lyrics and the mv.
Agreed, a lot of these subs weren't correct or they were paraphrased which removed a lot of the deeper meaning in some sections
You can watch the making of Jimins Black Swan solo. Yes at point they thought about disbanding. Hence this song. Them being afraid of losing their passion. BLOOD SWEAT AND TESRS is the video that goes with this one. It's about choices. By the way you didn't notice the shadows not moving with them
Esto es ARTE 🎶🎼🎵💜
Gracias por tu reacción 💜🇲🇽😉
“A dancer dies twice-once when they stop dancing, and this first death is more painful.”Martha Graham
When I listened to your intro to this reaction, I actually agreed with you. I just recently followed BTS but I'm taking my time studying their lyrics, cinematography, choreography. This pulled me down the BTS vortex but I love my pace. Not joining the hype of those jumping into the boat just because. 💜
I’m enjoying your reactions and feel like you decipher the meaning and intent very well. Also, I love the way you speak. Finally a channel with some serious intelligence involved! It’s refreshing. 💜
WOW! you really got it right off the bat!!!
This MV is so Amazing on many levels!!!!
Thank you 💜
PS: take your time- we're on the journey with you
BTS always have captions in al songs u can just watch right away in the official HYBE chanbel
Bro why are you so big brained!!! Btw love all of your BTS reactions esp the analysis parts 💜
ooh bts!! this song is in my opinion the best bts song and it’s insanely beautiful and deep. whenever you have time, i suggest you watch the art film. it gives such great artistic depth to the song and just makes it that much more of a masterpiece. the instrumental is also orchestral so it’s definitely worth the listen.
Bts always make music that reflects everything they are at the present!
1st Death, If A Dancer Loses His Passion To Dance 💜 Shadow: "You Are Me, I Am You {acceptance} 💜 Concept taken from the book by Murray Stein "Map Of The Soul" [Jung's Theory] 💜 Watch "Bookish Theories Explanation" video for meaning & understanding of "Black Swan" 💜 Jimin/BTS is doing Contemporary Dancing 💜
It’s a deep song
More than autotune they layer the voices a lot and then they use reverse. You can hear the slight echo in their voices that’s why it sounds like subtle autotune.
Idk how u r sooo incredibly genius and full of knowledge..The way u interpret their music u have to have knowledge of things..for me always finding the meaning of songs isn’t easy just because i can't always tell the depth of the lyrics..but how u've been understanding those things in ur reaction videos It's truly awesome...
Its getting into you 😁😁borahae💜💜
Just want to say your voice sound so nice...😊
Yessss you know when it's Jimiiiin bc those MOVES. No one else could. I hold my breath every time hahaha. This was so fun to see you react to.
I may be a little late in seein this video but I just wanted to say that this song, when RM was making this, it was one of the few songs that made him cry while he was in the process of making it. And I think that speaks so much of how they really value their music and their song. This is why I stayed because BTS treat their craft so passionately and genuinely that they really feel like it's their death when they no longer feel the same enthusiasm wih music, which has become their life at some point.
Really like your reaction...💐💐
We need more people like you who can appreciate the artist. Your the best🔥
I love your reaction...
Please react to "who is bts the seven member of bangtan" so you will know them more.
-love your reaction-
yeahh, we need more BTS here!!! 💜
love how u react bc u rlly take time to try to understand them and their music! a lot of reactors dont even care abt the lyrics n just look at surface level it’s so disappointing.
i think you will really like and appreciate their track Tear. it’s only the rappers no singing but it’s a tear-jerker when you know (they revealed) that it was when they were considering breaking up as a band, so Tear is about them and not a relationship break up song. (They went through some tough times privately in 2017-2018)
Thank you for always doing your research and sharing more about what you are reacting too!!!!👏👏👏
Best way to learn them individually is solos yes, but bts run episodes. Ive watched all episodes 4 times now since last summer. 🤣🤦♀️ they are my favorite hobby.
They launched a fully funded global art exhibition together with the song. I think there were tough situation and almost disband back in 2016 and If I’m not mistaken RM said he got his inspiration in music from other form of art and the purpose of launching the exhibition and made it free is to share with the fans their passion and to help other artists there were African, European, South American and Asian artists involve with the project
In BTS live performance of Fake Love MMA 2018 and No More Dream with dance break MOTS ONE the camera shows Jimin showing him hitting every beat as he dances.
To appreciate them as individuals you should watch Who is BTS? The seven members of Bangtan. It talks a little bit about each of their personal struggles as well as a little bit about each of their personal strengths, and gives you an idea of where they are coming from. The black swan event they talk about here is their greatest fear, that the day will come that they will stop loving what they are doing, performing and making music.
Love your honest and intelligent remarks
you should look at bangtan bombs behind the scenes
This is not kpop, it is BTS. They are their own genre. This was filmed in an old theater in L. A., just like On, Kinetic Manifesto, and J hope’s Chicken Noodle Soup.
Jimin used to do mostly interpretive and ballet dancing before he became a part of BTS so they took ballet lessons and decided to incorporate some of that style in this.
Wohoee linton THANKS 😍😍😍
it’s a very deep song, you so good in understanding.
Take you time we love your reactionssssss
I love the idea of how ur venturing into BTS
Great reaction! You just get it! Some of my other recommendations:
Idol, Mic Drop, Baepsae, Silverspoon, Whalien 52, Ddeang, Cypher series (1-4), Outro: Tear.
Bonus: Spring Day explained will blow your mind!
Nice
Next, FAKE LOVE and NOT TODAY, plz. You will love it! I really enjoyed your reaction to BLACK SWAN and want to see another one, too 💜😆
Appreciated your reaction!!
Please react to "BTS - Black Swan Performance (@2020 MMA)" and also BTS (방탄소년단) Black Swan Perf. + ON + Life Goes On + Dynamite @ 2020 MMA.
MMA performances are in another huge level.
I had no clue that Black Swan meant what you said. lol
Thank you 💕 for reaction BTS again. From J-ARMY 🇯🇵