Indian Army और Government के रिश्ते कब-कब मुश्किल दौर से गुज़रे हैं? (BBC Hindi)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ส.ค. 2020
- अभी भी ये सवाल अक्सर पूछा जाता है कि एक विकासशील देश कैसे एक ऐसी सेना का निर्माण करे जिससे लोकतंत्र को कोई ख़तरा न हो? क्या असैनिक सरकार सेना पर नियंत्रण रखते हुए उसकी प्रभावशीलता को उच्चतम सीमा तक पहुंचा सकती है? इसको भारतीय लोकतंत्र की एक सफलता माना जाएगा कि दस लाख से भी अधिक बड़ी सेना होने, कई युद्धों में भाग लेने और कई आंतरिक मोर्चों पर इस्तेमाल किए जाने के बावजूद सेना ने ज़ाहिरी तौर पर कोई राजनीतिक महत्वाकांक्षा दिखाने से परहेज़ किया है. लेकिन इसका ये मतलब नहीं कि सरकार और सेना के संबंध हमेशा सौहार्दपूर्ण रहे हैं. विवेचना में रेहान फ़ज़ल बता रहे हैं सरकार और सेना के बीच विवादों का कहानी.
वीडियो: काशिफ़ सिद्दीक़ी
#IndianArmy #JawaharLalNehru #NarendraModi #Politics
Corona Virus से जुड़े और दिलचस्प वीडियो देखने के लिए यहां क्लिक करें : • Corona Virus ने दुनिया...
कोरोना वायरस से जुड़ी सारी प्रामाणिक ख़बरें पढ़ने के लिए क्लिक करें : www.bbc.com/hindi/internation...
ऐसे ही और दिलचस्प वीडियो देखने के लिए चैनल सब्सक्राइब ज़रूर करें-
/ @bbchindi
बीबीसी हिंदी से आप इन सोशल मीडिया चैनल्स पर भी जुड़ सकते हैं-
फ़ेसबुक- / bbcnewshindi
ट्विटर- / bbchindi
इंस्टाग्राम- / bbchindi
बीबीसी हिंदी का एंड्रॉयड ऐप डाउनलोड करने के लिए क्लिक करें- play.google.com/store/apps/de...
Indian army always respect democracy even some of our civilian government not much care about democracy...
It is wrong Gen Choudhary withdrew troops from river Beas. I belong to that area working for national defence helping army. Major Gen Bhatia was in Batala how daring was in forward area... It is story written in toilet or bedroom.
@Ajay Sati And you don't respect the grammar.
Nice joke
@@bachanlal3931 🤣🤣🤣 epic reply
भारत की सेना दुनिया की सबसे सही सेना है जिसने आजतक कोई भी ऐसा काम नही किया जो देश और देश के लोकतंत्र के लिए सही न हो ये हिंद की सेना है और इसका सिर्फ एक ही काम है देश की रक्षा करना।
दोगला नेता लोग मिलकर देश को बर्बाद कर दिया चाहे बीजेपी हो या कांग्रेस हो
@@syedashraf776 aur muslim party
हमारी आर्मी हमारा सम्मान है
जय हिंद
satta unhe ek baar hathiyane to do
@@viplovezoad5523 kbhi nhi karenge layde
@@viplovezoad5523 chup kar mulle yeh indian army he samje Pakistan army nhi
@@viplovezoad5523sanatan hai wo😂
Abraham terrorism ke vicharak nahi n
रसरी4fल्फ़्+@@Anirudh.thakur
सर आपकी आवाज सुनकर आपकी जो भी स्पीच है वह सुबह से लेकर शाम तक सुनने का मन करता है और बहुत आनंद आता है आपकी जबान से कोई भी चीज
Rehan is Great
एक आवाज जो हमें सुनने को मजबूर कर देती है
जब एक अहिंसक देश एक बडी सेना रखता है,तो हमेशा ऐसे विवाद होते है।सेनाका उपयोग आक्रमणके लिए है या सुरक्षाके लिए है (Offence or Defense) इसका फैसला अभीतक हुआ नहीं है।पाकिस्तान और चीन हमेशा हमारी सरहदके अंदर घुसनेका प्रयासमें लगे रहते है लेकिन हमारी सेनाको उनके सरहदमें घुसनेकी इजाजत नहीं दी जाती।अपेक्षा है की अब मोदी सरकारके कार्यकालमें ये परिस्थिती बदल जायेगी।
Right
First story proves that discipline is the integrity in Indian Army
Sir love your voice. It's signature voice of BBC..
माना कि नेहरू जी कुछ गलतीया हुईं जो एक मानवीय पहलू है । लेकिन जब देश आजाद हुआ तब नेहरू जी सुजबुझ व दूरदर्शीता के कारण ही पाकिस्तान की तरह भारत मे तख्ता पलट नही हो सका। इसलिए किसी की बुराइयों से ज्यादा उनकी अच्छाई पर ध्यान देना चाहिए ।
Nice joke
1 no. Ka ayyash tha. Suver.. Desh ko narak bna ke suver ki maut Mr gaya ..
😂😂😂
Hitler k case me bhi kar le 😂
आपकी आवाज ...आपकी हिंदी भाषा पर पकड और आपका नरेशन .... ऐसा है के रुची हो न हो विषय कोई भी हो गौर से सूनने का मन करता है और अपने आप रुची पैदा हो जाती है और सब समझने लग जाता है ..... ये अदभूत है ...
Now I will die in peace after seeing face behind delightful Voice❤️
90 k dasak mai jab apko radio par suna to apko dekhne ka man tha ab ye icha bhi puri ho gyi
Thank you 💖
हमे भारत की सेना पर गर्व है सरकार पर नहीं
Bilkul shi
Bilkul sahi Bhai
आपकी आवज बहुत सुन्दर है ।
मधुर है
I love my India ❤️❤️
Salute to the Indian army.
Jai Jawan Jai kisaan
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Hijron ki fouj hi Indian Army China tu qabo na asaka. Kia Jai Jai hi bakwass.
यही एक आवाज़ है जिसे सुनने की इच्छा होती है
No nom
Perfect speech on India
Not to capture Dhaka was an excellent strategy of manekshah. As it avoided Indian army of street fights which spared thousands of soldiers lives. General manekshah achieved much higher results than capture of Dhaka . Manekshah's strategy was the capture of a country and not of a city (Dhaka)which he excellently did. Mistakes are made in war but general manekshah made no mistakes in strategy. General jackob was no match in strategy and General hood to general manekshah. General manekshah was better strategist than general rommel of 2nd world War
Ohh.. finally aj pta chala who's behind this iconic voice...
Sir I'm listening you on BBC radio along with my father since my childhood. The way you speak is amazing. I am big fan of your voice and the depth analysis by you.
Apki abaz 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I see BBC documenataries for RFazal saab's presentation. One of the best.
मनमोहन सिंह कश्मीर, पाकिस्तान को तथा लद्दाख, चीन को देकर सारे विवाद खत्म करने वाले थे। मगर सेना ने ये होने न दिया। बीबीसी को इसका बडा अफसोस है।
😎
😜😜😜😜😜😜
😂
@@jattmoosewala83🦉 th-cam.com/video/VeKEHCg4DhE/w-d-xo.html
Gen JJ singh ki suno ager bakvas lagh rehi baat tu Kongessia ki 🐏🐑Deepak ku
Chutiya Feku ne galwan ghati chin ko de di h
1200 वर्ग किलोमीटर ज़मीन चीन ने कब्जा ली है
That's love my Indian army.... Who doesn't work under pressure of gov
वह मुख्यमंत्री कोई और नहीं बल्कि योगी था।
What a ballenced reporting! Other bbc reporters should learn from him.
Aawaz zabardast h
@@rashidahmad4984
0hmm
th-cam.com/video/pf0NEhYBs38/w-d-xo.html
BBc spying on Bharat and doing money laundering to protect assets and maintain Business in Shimla graves of billionaires in US UK .
@@ranbirchauhan96 ধন্যবাদ...
thanks
Respect sir,
I don't know how to thank you.
I have been your student on TH-cam for last 2 years....
You have helped me gain lots of knowledge on various topics....
I will always be grateful to you..
Y
Beautiful analysis and factually correct.
Our Indian army is too serve the country.. Salute to our Indian army.
Inspite of some spots here and there , our forces have been performing well away from politics and we are proud of them . Let’s hope everything goes well.
In 1965, Air Chief Sri Arjan Singh completely dominated the Pakistani skies
In 2002, Sri Arjan Singh Ji was made Marshal of Indian Air Force for his role in 1965 war
Agar saina nahi hoti to aaj hum yahan nahi hote salite our army
Bilkul shi
Tumhara haal jo hai, I guess usse bohut behtar hota 😂😂😂
indian military ek vote bank hai govt ke liye... unse kaise aur kyu rishte bigaadegi..
aur unke liye toh kaafi alag dhang ke vote ke liye present govt ke time mein..
politics hoti thi opposition party ki state ke CM apni state mein jahan jahan military base hai waha jaya krte the unko hosla bdhaane ke naam pr unke votes lekr jaate.. jo ki kaam aate lok sabha election mein..
.. apni present govt ke time mein sbhi navy,military, air force , bsf, itbp sbhi ke votes aur unki family ke votes present govt ko he milte hai lok sabha election mein..
@@daddy.3089 dubara mat dikh jaayeo beta nahin to martey kam hai ghasittey jyada hain hum.
@@daddy.3089 Abey O gavr ke bacche
14 lakh active military personnel 🤨
Hmri sena bhut acchi h hmri sena shaan h hmri jaan h
Gen Nathu Singh was from Dungarpur ( Rajasthan) who was offered the post of first COAS.
ज्ञानवर्द्धक विवेचना के लिए धन्यवाद
Excellent knowledge... beautiful spoken
Love your voice sir.. It feels like my grandpa is telling me stories.
legendary voice 'rehan fasal' 💪
बहुत ही शानदार और दमदार आवाज बेहतरीन विवेचना ! रेहान भाई
Rehan fazalji, thank you very much appreciated for your excellent information and analysis
Way of speaking 😍
सभि भाई बहन को गनेश चतुर्द्शी कि हारदिक बधाई ऐवम शुभकामना
Chaturthi not chaturdashi. Both differ by 10 days
I am Muslim all hindu bhayo ko ganesh chaturti Mubarak ho🙏
Bhaskar bharadawaj bhai apko dhanybad
@@northfact2146 thank u bhai apko bhi mubarak ho
सभी को शुभकामनाएं
We salute indian army
आपका घटनाओं को बयान करने का तरीका लाजवाब है, धन्यवाद।
Excellent. Live long Rehan ji
aapki aawaz ham shrotao ko mantrmugdha krti hai
सर् आपकी आवाज़ ही अलग है
Sir apki vivechnA dekhkar bhut aach lgta hai thanks for this
Your voice is so soothing. I can listen to it all day along for months n years
Sir aapki aawaj sunkar aisa lagta hai maano jo event aap samjhate hai usme hi ham kho gaye ho
Ek dam adventure jaisa feel hota hai sir
Amazing
Your voice is so calming
Isliye to hum Bhariye Sena par garv karte hai.....hume garv hai apne jawano pe jo veergati ko prat hue. .....ese Maa Bharti ke Sapooto ko sat sat naman🙏
jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳
Sweet voice
○ther documentory
Is best .... so Great....
This is the global standard of journalism. This is BBC.
The Real Gen. SHUBAG SINGH 💐💐🙏
Sir ,ur voice is awesome.🙏🙏🙏🙏
Sir your presentation is very impressive and simple also
Is there a playlist for all vivechna episodes?
What a great narration and information.
Thanks a lot Rehan Fazal Sir🇮🇳
आप आवाज हमें अतीत में ले जाता है रेहान फजल जी।।
Bbchindi samachar v Anya programs me Suna karta tha 1980 se 2000 tak. thanks Fajal ji.
Very compact feature.
Kaise straightforward aadmi ho aap sir, kisi ko nahi bakshte. Khari khari sunate ho sir aap.jai ho aap.
भारत की राजनीति ने सेना का बहुत बड़ा नुकसान कीया
आप की आवाज 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Credit should be given to Indian Army
रेहान फसल क्या शानदार आवाज है 🙏🙏🙏✨️✨️
Rehanji Thanks for broadcasting wonderful Vivechna about sensitive issue.. 👍👍👍👌👌🌷🌷
Beautiful voice! Big Fan
Wonderful presentation.
हम ऐसी अद्भुत रिपोर्ट केवल BBC से ही आशा कर सकते हैं.. BBC IS THE BEST NEWS AGENCY.....,👌👌
I just love your Voice sir and the way you explain..
Rehan fazal ,i know ,a truthful person .i know him from his days in bbc radio hindi session. I,m personally afan of Rehan fazal.i always longed for his voice when i used to listen to bbc news.
Indian Army more disciplined in the world
Maan gye sir❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️👍👍👍👍👍 solid reporting and stringent facts
Bahut shandar program hai aapka
Good,truthful information.Bravo.
Karriyappa was born soldier and he served to nation till end of his life . I think Nehru was not choice of people of India .
Nehru was the choice of India, he was the most popular leader after Gandhi, he was worried about the Army because he saw it as the same army that had fired at Jallianwala Bagh, fought against the INA and also Cariappa had refused to allow re-entry of INA soldiers into the Indian Army because it would look political, after what happened in Pakistan it was a reasonable precaution.
US Embassy staff had once asked Manickshaw when he was overthrowing the government.
There were reasons to be worried, eventually it might have led to bad military outcomes but due to that India is the only country in South Asia where the government has not been overthrown.
Agreed
Nehru won every Election till his death. Only leader who is famous in Both Region North and South India. It rearly happen.
He was a playboy
Nehru was a great leader
Sir Your Voice Is Nature Gifted 👍
Amazing voice
Thank u sir🙏🙏🙏
Amaging voice with glorious story 🙏🙏🙏
Sandar program sir
नेतृत्व अनुभवी होना चाहिये।
Poetic 🤩🤩🤩😍
rehan fagal story telling with modulated voice is experience like a movie .
Thanks Rehan Fazal Ji for providing us an insight about the tussle for supremacy between the civil & military powers. Thank God, India has been successful in maintaining a fine balance between the two, unlike our western neighbour. Your presentation is balanced, informative & praiseworthy.
Rehan fazal ji ki vivechna ka intzar mujhe bhut rhta h vivechna hr sptah ho apki style bhut hi ummda hai
बहुत अच्छा विश्लेषण किया है रैहान फ़ज़ल साहब जी
सरकारें अच्छे सलाहकारों की कमी से हमेशा जूझते रहती है यथार्थ।
Thanks God, Hitler Modi has made India a weak and divisive country, where Hindutva fanaticism was absorbed by indian Army under Bipin Rawat who danced to Modi's fascist tunes and ordered a fierce crack down against unarmed, starved Kashmiri Muslims, and it has reshaped indian Army as a Hindutva tool, that was unnecessarily deployed in such large numbers in Kashmir as 900,000 men on internal security or anti insurgency duties, consequently this Indian Army is now only fit for Cantonment duties, taking toll on its fitness to fight a war at the international borders. Anti insurgency duties also incur 7 times more costs than normal cantonment duties, which again is taking toll on Indian Army's ability to invest in its further development, procurement of modern equipment, improvement in its communications and logistics, human resource enhancement and development. Continuous anti insurgency duties have left indelible marks on the psych of the Indian soldiers, and frequent fratricides, suicides are reported. Bipin Rawat instead of keeping Indian Army as a national asset that could be efficiently used to protect and project India's national aims such as afford it safety and security at international borders, bogged it in the quagmire that is no less than an impending genocide of the innocent Kashmiris. Bipin Rawat was guilty of projecting a farcical impression that the Indian Army was capable of fighting a simultaneously two front war with China & Pakistan, this assumption proved totally frivolous, a Sand Castle made in the air which evaporated in the strong winds blown by an ever belligerent PLA at Gulwan debacle, leave alone a two pronged war that Bipin Rawat was claiming within the capability of the Indian Army. Modi has now come to his senses and is now suffering in silence, under a press blackout of the territorial losses, and is nursing his wounds and the defeat by an ever aggressive PLA. See for your self:
www.theguardian.com/profile/fatimabhutto+commentisfree/commentisfree
Modi and the incompetent Indian Generals have created an euphoria in the Indian public by Bollywood propaganda that Pakistan is a soft touch Militarily that can be defeated easily, this is again a childish whim and wish, the Abhi Nandan fiasco is plainly seen by the whole world's military strategists that Pakistan Military has teeth that can bite hard, and is no walkover for cross border strikes; no Scott Free brinkmanship, Mr.Modi, please note.
India lost its investments in Afghanistan when Ashraf Ghani abdicated within a fortnight, and a threat of two front war for Pakistan, simultaneously at its Eastern and Western border evaporated overnight, another failure of Modis aggressive policy against Pakistan, whose Army is held in very high esteem by the Pakistanis. Has any one enquired from the shortsighted Modi if why he rolled back the raising of the India's only Mountain Strike Corps, especially after spending Indian Rupees 65'000/- Crores on one of its divisions. India also failed in its aim under the tutelage of Fascist Modi to integrate its Army like other industrial nations such as USA and China, India failed since it is not an industrial state. Chinas Western Command, facing India, comprises of total 8 integrated divisions including two mountain tank divisions, a guided rocket division and 500 4th Generation aircraft (stationed 50 miles away at four airfields from Indian borders across the mountains), can India withstand this much of Sino fire power at Ladakh and Himanchal border? India's research and development projests for new technologies have missed their completion deadlines for decades, the end product were rejected by the would be users, the Indian Army and Air force, where as Pakistan's AESA capable block three JF17 has been handed over to PAF.
Is there no voice of sanity in India that can remind the prudent Indians to think over once again, over the dilemma faced by Indian Army under the helms of the Buthcher of Gujarat, the Fascist Hitler Modi!
Love ur voice.....
Rehan Fazal is love…what a voice and presentation ❤
Field marshal General cariappa is the foundation of Indian democracy.
We r proud of our army
शानदार विवेचना सर 👌🏻👌🏻🙏🏻
Amazing.........
DinSeeTalk
Sirf Aapke Faiyede ki Baat
Nic to see you and hear your voice
पाकिस्तान वाला wastullah और इंडिया में रेहान फजल दोनों की आवाज दिल चीर के अंदर तक उतर जाती है
PM Nehru believed that a nation can be run without army, that police is enough
Shaandaar veevechan fazal sahb...
You are a great broadcaster.I am fond of you.Rehan sahib your presentation is incomparable.