I personally would put the birdwatcher in the good teir. Being able to hear and see through walls is a giant asset because you basically counter every single play the ducks make. You also are able to learn people’s roles just by them telling it to someone else. Though it is a fairly map-dependent and proxy heavy role, especially with it being able to see through the dark on JT and the Basement. Good video tho, and I do agree with the placement of most of these :)
Thank you! I greatly appreciate the feedback. This video came out before Mayan Temple, so Birdwatcher didn’t have the map buffs it does now. I agree with your points though. Wish we talked to you when we were making the list.
Yeah. We debated between a single usage or a long cooldown. We went with the long cooldown for the door closing (which in hindsight sounds pretty OP), but having it for door opening makes sense too. Once per round as you say would probably be the ideal. Thank you for the input!
I disagree, Most the time Doors is used to keep people out from a section for a moment. If you add a bit of a delay or a charm to do such. It could work well.
Thank you! We offer ways to fix Mortician (as well as all the other low tiers) in the follow-up video. We are hoping at least one of the developers sees that video to possibly get some of those roles improved one way or another. Lets see what happens!
Mortician is what I like to call a “proxy limited” role, it’s really good in proximity lobbies with friends, but falls behind in, say, a non-voice public lobby because you can’t grab a mortician if you can’t talk.
Completely agree. I will add; however that Mortician is way better on the Basement map due to Vulture not being available on that map. It does beg the question that should have been in this video on why can’t a mortician study blown up feet? But hey, hindsight is 2020. 🤷🏻
Mechanic,Snoop and Technician are now in 1 role in the Engineer role also Engineer can't be forever in vents unless if there in a map that can hide in a closet and they always have the Technician's ability.
Birdwatcher got buffed luckily, Snoop got better. (But Engineer got worse) Detective is more useful the more you understand it. Not as good as it use to be tho. Mortician is okay but needs a small Tweek. I kinda wish it had something like the Vulture but like a 30 second-1 min timer before it starts lighting up. Or just not take so long to know. Politician and Locksmith need more tho.
And for the new neutral role : woodpeacker They have two target that need to get voted out to win . If one of the target of the woodpeacker is a dodo the dodo and woodpeacker won
3:35 I think Silencer in particular should remove the one they silence button as well. Most the time the Silenced is one you did so cause you accidentally murdered infront of them. Then you pray to god your internet connection is better so you can kill them before they hit the button.
MAYBE (if enough people request it) but I won’t have time to make it until summer. I also haven’t played this game in over a year so I have no idea what it is like now.
Sorry. I have no plans to make an updated list any time soon since I haven’t played this game in over a year. Maybe sometime in the future, but not this summer- especially since the Elden Ring DLC just dropped. 😆
Veteran goose role you can alert if you are on alert anyone that's tries to use a skill on you will die and it can kill goose who can use others skills on players cooldown will be very long cause it's very good role like 30 and alert last for 8 seconds and if someone try to kill you while on alert and another you can kill both of them
![[구스구스덕] 킬 모션 모음 (Goose Goose Duck kill motion/animation compilation)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MczlDyUQ_cg/mqdefault.jpg)
I personally would put the birdwatcher in the good teir. Being able to hear and see through walls is a giant asset because you basically counter every single play the ducks make. You also are able to learn people’s roles just by them telling it to someone else. Though it is a fairly map-dependent and proxy heavy role, especially with it being able to see through the dark on JT and the Basement. Good video tho, and I do agree with the placement of most of these :)
Thank you! I greatly appreciate the feedback. This video came out before Mayan Temple, so Birdwatcher didn’t have the map buffs it does now. I agree with your points though. Wish we talked to you when we were making the list.
Locksmith would be overpowered if it could open closed doors because of sab (unless they had a limit per round)
Yeah. We debated between a single usage or a long cooldown. We went with the long cooldown for the door closing (which in hindsight sounds pretty OP), but having it for door opening makes sense too. Once per round as you say would probably be the ideal.
Thank you for the input!
I disagree, Most the time Doors is used to keep people out from a section for a moment. If you add a bit of a delay or a charm to do such. It could work well.
Finally an updated one of these!
Nice video!! Definitely agree with at least 90% of these. I personally like mortician but that role does suck. Will be watching more of these!
Thank you! We offer ways to fix Mortician (as well as all the other low tiers) in the follow-up video. We are hoping at least one of the developers sees that video to possibly get some of those roles improved one way or another. Lets see what happens!
Mortician is what I like to call a “proxy limited” role, it’s really good in proximity lobbies with friends, but falls behind in, say, a non-voice public lobby because you can’t grab a mortician if you can’t talk.
Completely agree. I will add; however that Mortician is way better on the Basement map due to Vulture not being available on that map.
It does beg the question that should have been in this video on why can’t a mortician study blown up feet? But hey, hindsight is 2020. 🤷🏻
Falcon here is basically a mafia serial killer role
Mechanic,Snoop and Technician are now in 1 role in the Engineer role also Engineer can't be forever in vents unless if there in a map that can hide in a closet and they always have the Technician's ability.
Oh wow! That’s awesome! I am so glad they did that to those roles! Thank you for informing me.
Birdwatcher got buffed luckily, Snoop got better. (But Engineer got worse) Detective is more useful the more you understand it. Not as good as it use to be tho.
Mortician is okay but needs a small Tweek. I kinda wish it had something like the Vulture but like a 30 second-1 min timer before it starts lighting up. Or just not take so long to know.
Politician and Locksmith need more tho.
We do offer suggestions on how to fix some roles in the follow-up video to this one.
Nice tier list
Thank you!
Thank you sm, pigeon is da besttt roleeeee 😊
Good tier list ! I love it! I have an ideea on detective role and an ideea on a new neutral role
If the detective find who the killer is then he can kill one player per game
And for the new neutral role : woodpeacker
They have two target that need to get voted out to win . If one of the target of the woodpeacker is a dodo the dodo and woodpeacker won
The woodpeacker is available only on next colony , the carnaval, bloodven and jungle temple
is anyone not going To question about why the sherrif comits suicide
Balance so they don’t go around doming all birds they see
i think top is shapeshfiter
Dodo bird is my dream
Definitely one of the more fun roles in the game!
Okay
@@CyberGeminiOfficial I know you love goose goose duck
3:35 I think Silencer in particular should remove the one they silence button as well. Most the time the Silenced is one you did so cause you accidentally murdered infront of them. Then you pray to god your internet connection is better so you can kill them before they hit the button.
Not a bad idea. Some may call that broken, but hey- it would make the ability better than an annoying gimmick.
Can you add the pelican and the crow roles in the tier list well you play the game
MAYBE (if enough people request it) but I won’t have time to make it until summer.
I also haven’t played this game in over a year so I have no idea what it is like now.
Assassin + spy = death
Agreed. The OG Duck combo.
I agree with most of them
Guys try to reach this guy to 5.1K subscribers
I appreciate the notion!
I always laugh when someone got partied.
Can you make a new tier list?
Sorry. I have no plans to make an updated list any time soon since I haven’t played this game in over a year.
Maybe sometime in the future, but not this summer- especially since the Elden Ring DLC just dropped. 😆
@@CyberGeminiOfficial ok
can you link me to this particular update tierlist?
Hello. Can you message us on discord about it?
How you make classic+?
Should be in the main menu.
What if there was a veteran role that maybe is coming soon
It's an old role
Veteran goose role you can alert if you are on alert anyone that's tries to use a skill on you will die and it can kill goose who can use others skills on players cooldown will be very long cause it's very good role like 30 and alert last for 8 seconds and if someone try to kill you while on alert and another you can kill both of them
Veteran is a very good if there was a role in this game where you put this role on tier list?
You can watch this role on among us veteran role
Morphling is op
Imo hitman and bodyguard should be on bottom
Yeah. They almost were. This list went through a few revisions.
@@CyberGeminiOfficial wow your still replying after a year? Wow
@@CyberGeminiOfficial I generally hate both hitman and bodyguard but that’s just me
As do I. We even have a follow-up video where we propose a way to fix them since we consider them bad roles.
Hey, you took the time to comment, I don’t mind taking a minute or two to reply. Thank you for watching the video.
WHERE IS THE PELICAN AND OTHER ROLES??!?
They didn’t exist yet. This video was made back when Dueling Dodos had just debuted.
You forgot the pelican
It didn’t exist yet when this video was made.
The pelican is op he
can swallow other players
But they do not die
Until a meeting
Is called and they
Have to be the last one alive
@@CyberGeminiOfficial pelican is in top
There is a video in my GGD playlist that has me playing as the Pelican.
I agree it is a really good role and very fun as well.
@@CyberGeminiOfficial make another tier list with new roles like esper and warlock so I can sub to you
astral is left
That role wasn’t out yet when this video was made.