There's one thing I don't understand. Arent all subjects of ymir descendants of Maria, Rose and Sina? So, shouldn't they all be descendants with royal bloodline aka part of the royal family(like Dina Fritz and Historia)?
They are technically royal bloodline, but royal bloodline specifically refers to the blood line that came from whichever daughter inherited the founding titan. Obviously we know that only one of the daughters inherited the founder, and so her descendants would be considered royal blood while the descendants of the other 2 are just subjects of ymir
The majority of Eldians are only distant relatives of Ymir, meaning they can still turn into titans but don’t have the royal powers that only direct descendants of Ymir have. In real life, most people with British ancestry are indirectly related to the monarchy but obviously only direct descents and their spouses are considered actual royalty. Same thing in AOT.
Across multiple of your videos you call someone "direct" descendants to Ymir. But they all come from Ymir? It's a pretty big detail to just gloss over. The way I see it, all subjects of Ymir should be "of the royal bloodline" and it's never really explained why that's not the case.
One little detail but to me important : it is not the fact that the source (hallucigenia worm) was separated from Eren that causes Jean Connie and other to become again regular humans but it was rather Ymir's will to end the curse. After Eren has been separated from the worm and Zeke, Eren had no more FT power. However, paths and Ymir still existed. So it would have been even possible that after Eren's death, Ymir continues to act in paths and titans still continue to exist. However, after seeing Mikasa killin Eren (what Ymir has not be able to do with King Fritz), she and only her decided to end the curse. This has nothing to do with Eren being dead directly or the worm being separated.
That makes a lot of sense! It has nothing to do with Erenand the "hallucigenia" being separated, it's Ymir's free will. That's why the tree where Eren was buried grew gigantic. It probably still has parts of the "hallucigenia" within it and it affects the anatomy of that tree. The "hallucigenia" survived with or without a human host. It's new host is probably that boy with a scarf in the after credit scene of the series finale.
I don't think Ymir was in love with the King. I think she was just a mindless slave that didn't know what to do so she went back to him and did what he said
@MRHIMDOWNSTAIRS12 I didn't want the final final episode yet so maybe there's something I missed because when they showed how she got the titans power it didn't show any love
Ymir was desperate for someone to love her. Once she has her Titan powers, King Fritz started praising her for all of the good work she did for the Eldian Empire. Ymir interprets his praise as love.
@@AlithAnarlet me add on to it. If they really were from the founders bloodline, that would mean that whoever inherited the founder, must've had children as the founder. If that's the case, we'd have to know uri and rods age. If uri was less than 13 when he got the founder that would make sense. If rod was older than 13 when uri got the founder, that would mean that his father had rod before he got the founder and wouldn't be of the founders children. Which would then also make Frida not of the founder.
Ymir probably had family like a brother or sister maybe cousins. So they would be in her blood line but not royal blood. Maybe back then there was incest and that adds to why she has issues along with the rest of her village. Just a thought
In order for the popular opinion to be valid then we'd have to know uris age. Because its saying that in order for the bloodline to considered royalty, the person with the founder has to have children during that 13 years. We know rod is older than 13 when uri got it because hes old when historia is there, so that means his dad did not bear him during his time as the founder. Frida for that matter is in the same boat. If thats the case, the inherentors of the founder are just as diluted as the other eldians and if thats the case, it doesn't hold up.
Subjects of Ymir were once the nobles of the Eldian Empire. The nobles in Paradis were not Subjectsof Ymir hence why they cannot be mind controlled, yet most of the subjects of ymir in paradis were of low-ranking except for the hidden royal family.
If all subjects of Yimir aredescendants of Maria, Rose and Sina, all Subjects of Yimir have Royal blood, no? They may not be officially Fritz (uhh, just ike Historia) but have the blood of the king in them, no? Plot-hole?
There's one thing I don't understand. Arent all subjects of ymir descendants of Maria, Rose and Sina? So, shouldn't they all be descendants with royal bloodline aka part of the royal family(like Dina Fritz and Historia)?
this is the one plot point i've been tryna to build justification and evidence for to understand, but have always come up short lol
They are technically royal bloodline, but royal bloodline specifically refers to the blood line that came from whichever daughter inherited the founding titan. Obviously we know that only one of the daughters inherited the founder, and so her descendants would be considered royal blood while the descendants of the other 2 are just subjects of ymir
The majority of Eldians are only distant relatives of Ymir, meaning they can still turn into titans but don’t have the royal powers that only direct descendants of Ymir have.
In real life, most people with British ancestry are indirectly related to the monarchy but obviously only direct descents and their spouses are considered actual royalty. Same thing in AOT.
@@williamteng5924I doubt dinas portion of the family that left was the founding titan section and yet Zeke has the royal blood required
I've been wondering the exact same thing for ages now and also haven't found an answer
Across multiple of your videos you call someone "direct" descendants to Ymir.
But they all come from Ymir?
It's a pretty big detail to just gloss over.
The way I see it, all subjects of Ymir should be "of the royal bloodline" and it's never really explained why that's not the case.
One little detail but to me important : it is not the fact that the source (hallucigenia worm) was separated from Eren that causes Jean Connie and other to become again regular humans but it was rather Ymir's will to end the curse. After Eren has been separated from the worm and Zeke, Eren had no more FT power. However, paths and Ymir still existed. So it would have been even possible that after Eren's death, Ymir continues to act in paths and titans still continue to exist. However, after seeing Mikasa killin Eren (what Ymir has not be able to do with King Fritz), she and only her decided to end the curse. This has nothing to do with Eren being dead directly or the worm being separated.
You’re kinda wrong lol. The curse ended because Ymir found peace. The lessons she learned from Eren, Armin and mikasa is what helped her pass on
@@MRHIMDOWNSTAIRS12 this is what I'm saying it's Ymir who ended the curse not the fact Eren died or the worm being separated
You’re on point
That makes a lot of sense! It has nothing to do with Erenand the "hallucigenia" being separated, it's Ymir's free will. That's why the tree where Eren was buried grew gigantic. It probably still has parts of the "hallucigenia" within it and it affects the anatomy of that tree. The "hallucigenia" survived with or without a human host. It's new host is probably that boy with a scarf in the after credit scene of the series finale.
@@gravel9270 technically all titan shifters had hallucinogenia in their genes(spinal fluid)
I don't think Ymir was in love with the King. I think she was just a mindless slave that didn't know what to do so she went back to him and did what he said
She literally was in love with the king and wanted him to love her back lol
@MRHIMDOWNSTAIRS12 I didn't want the final final episode yet so maybe there's something I missed because when they showed how she got the titans power it didn't show any love
Ymir was desperate for someone to love her. Once she has her Titan powers, King Fritz started praising her for all of the good work she did for the Eldian Empire. Ymir interprets his praise as love.
@@anthonychum9999 Stockholm syndrome
@@JaketheMovieGeek Pretty much love bombing which is a real manipulation tactic by abusers.
here is my question, how are all subjects of ymir not royal blood since they all would come from her and the king?
True that doesn’t really make sense. Unless the actual royal family have a higher percentage of King Fritz blood due to inbreeding.
The one who inherited the founding titan is where the royal family comes from...
@AlithAnar if that's the case then once eren inherited it, he's royalty.
It's a plot hole until proven otherwise.
@@AlithAnarlet me add on to it. If they really were from the founders bloodline, that would mean that whoever inherited the founder, must've had children as the founder. If that's the case, we'd have to know uri and rods age.
If uri was less than 13 when he got the founder that would make sense. If rod was older than 13 when uri got the founder, that would mean that his father had rod before he got the founder and wouldn't be of the founders children.
Which would then also make Frida not of the founder.
@@davidobregon5787y’all are making this shit more complicated than it already is lol uri and rod are not that far apart
ima need you to stop saying rosè like yo its just rose there is no apostrophe for her wall give it up already
Ymir probably had family like a brother or sister maybe cousins. So they would be in her blood line but not royal blood. Maybe back then there was incest and that adds to why she has issues along with the rest of her village. Just a thought
Thats my guess as to why everyone isn’t royal blood
I think her family were killed and enslaved also most of her surviving slaves got their tongues removed...
Binary Domain, Vagrant Story and DragonBall Fusions are the sequels I’ll continue to prolong my life for
Yes
In order for the popular opinion to be valid then we'd have to know uris age. Because its saying that in order for the bloodline to considered royalty, the person with the founder has to have children during that 13 years. We know rod is older than 13 when uri got it because hes old when historia is there, so that means his dad did not bear him during his time as the founder. Frida for that matter is in the same boat. If thats the case, the inherentors of the founder are just as diluted as the other eldians and if thats the case, it doesn't hold up.
First
I can’t be the only one that sees the AOT inspiration in Elden Ring??? The tree?? The paths/land between??? ELDEN Ring?? ELDIAN?? Liiiiike
Fourth lol
Yo whats the song at the beginning
Subjects of Ymir were once the nobles of the Eldian Empire. The nobles in Paradis were not Subjectsof Ymir hence why they cannot be mind controlled, yet most of the subjects of ymir in paradis were of low-ranking except for the hidden royal family.
Third
Second
If all subjects of Yimir aredescendants of Maria, Rose and Sina, all Subjects of Yimir have Royal blood, no? They may not be officially Fritz (uhh, just ike Historia) but have the blood of the king in them, no? Plot-hole?