Because Still Sanatan Culture exists. But it's in last stage after sanatan dharma will be destroyed by 2060 as planned. Then it will be replica of Pakistan courts.
@@gauravgupta548aap paida hi aise hue ho...ya baad me bimari lagi judgemental hone ki? Heartless and all....ye judge k emotions hai. And yes, the accused was running away and judges are not on the ground to face..
The case involves a serious issue of police misconduct where a woman, her 2.5-year-old child, and another minor child were allegedly detained by the police without an FIR for six days. According to the information provided, the police picked them up around 4 AM and kept them in custody without producing them before a magistrate, which is a violation of legal procedures and fundamental rights.After six days, the police filed an FIR naming the woman, possibly to justify the illegal detention retrospectively. The woman's brother then filed a habeas corpus plea at the Gauhati High Court, challenging the unlawful detention. A habeas corpus plea is a legal action that requires a person under arrest to be brought before a judge or into court, especially to secure the person's release unless lawful grounds are shown for their detention.
Honourable Justice, A physically challenged woman with her six years female child was admitted to the Government Hospital for Mental Care, Visakhapatnam without mental illness by the police intentionally causing her homelessness. I pray for Justice for the daughter of the democratic India.
@drramanand99 sir they won't check here pls either make a prayer in court filing a writ and engage a lawyer or there are many legal aid institutions which can help
@@iMahesh-ji1bq have u heard about squirrel killed by police in USA? It's fair as per their law, but stupid that's 1 f d reason Kamala lost d election.. 99.9% in India are criminal if u keep looking under the rug, India is a bureaucrats state, every thing is illegal in India.. That's why we are 3rd grade country.. Through away those stupid laws made by stupid bureaucrats.. It's called common sense..
@@iMahesh-ji1bq The court is abusing the power because they cannot suspend the whole police station for this mistake, because there are many lower officials there too, and they can not do anything infront of higher officials even if they want to
Sir please do realise the ground realities of catching a high profile rowdy it's not easy at all do you want to risk more peoples life by delaying to do anything . People like you comment salute to this and cry a river that police is not working and say arrest the rowdy asap when anything bad happens
@@memelover8448 Sir, with great powers come great responsibility. The police are cloaked with immense power. If tomorrow thay come to your house and arrest you or your family (god forbid) in the name of law and order, would you still argue on the same lines? The law is there for a reason. Upholding it doesnt make us weak or lets gangsters escape. On the contrary, one could argue, that the USA is such a power because it observes the law.
@@Huh67784 see what the justice system done to uttar pradesh it can't do nothing to Gunda/rowdy raj only yogi's bulldozers have stopped them and made the public life somewhat better
@@countryman5062 similarly I don't want to be attacked by rowdies either ,only rowdy houses are destroyed, saying that it's not more scary than a totally underdeveloped state with a fear of being killed.
I appreciate the boldness of the lady in defending her actions through her arguments. Her choice of the Defense Counsel is pathetic (he is totally unprepared). The Judge is doing the right thing to understand the urgency. Defense Counsel is a lame duck.
He is not a defence counsel. He is the state counsel and he is not lame. The questions of the court were addressed directly to the cop who appeared personally on being ordered to do so and there is nothing exceptional in what she said. If you had ever been to a court you would have known that senior police officials when summoned to the court, always defend the actions of their juniors. First understand the court proceedings and then start running your fingers on the keypad.
These bloody cops are so energetic buy while dealing with politicians they help the accused to run away. Look at Mumbai sena children case. That guy wad absconding foe 2 days
@@R..B ya do agree with you partially that lady is bold enough to terrorise a woman with an infant. She is sp and se don't know how to set the outer perimeter as a contingency plan. If she had Intel she could have set- up area isolation and waited for the first light . Secondly Paisa wasooli k liye to constable duty PE rehte hi hai highways pe . You know what I am saying.
@@govindraj28 it's not about the sharia law dear don't take it on wrong side. There is sharia law in gulf you can see the crime rates even less then our both democratic countries
@@hassamjarral1475 I agreed, crimes might controlled but delivery of justice is on one perticular religion can never provide a true justice. False blasphemy cases are killing the minorities in Pakistan. In India minorities are safer than the majority people. That's the beauty of our country. 🇮🇳
No matter how hard you work, if you do not work according to the prescribed protocol everything is "zero". Work hard but as per protocol and be ready to back all your actions only than your work will pay
There should be zero discrimination between men and women in front of the law. Although the judge is technically right in following the law, the law itself is discriminatory.
@@user_5670x bro ask any woman what they face everyday. Every eye on them is full of lust. Indians don't know not to stare and men's glare especially makes women feel unsafe.
Honest😂😂 lack of Crpc/ BNSS 2023 knowledge is considered honesty these days😂😂 arresting a woman along with bringing her minor child to the police station late at 4:15 a.m is 'honesty' in your eyes..wow
Only underdeveloped boy pussiess complaint about this things ..look back at Indian histories on how women faced persecution since medieval times to till now! Real men know they are built stronger and can take care of themselves they don't complain.💪
@@samson13ngpolice have both problems, if he tries to catch the murderer and so interrogates the wife then judges comes to protect a murderer & his family And if they follow all the rules and murderers escape then people ask the sanctity of police
What about the main crime and main accused? System is more bothered about officers making errors in investigation than in perpetrators of crimes like murder? 🙄
This is so depressing to watch. Indian judicial system is rotten to the core. Needs complete rehaul. These justices would not even be hired as office boys in a fair world.
@@hkphysics Dear moron compatriot. I paid more tax this year than your extended family's combined annual income. So shut the fuck up and get yourself a decent education.
@@hkphysics Dear moron compatriot. I paid more tax this year than your extended family's combined annual income. So desist from making comments about topics you are not competent enough to speak about and get yourself a decent education.
The judge himself is a prejudiced chap. He is trying to throw around his weight. I expect more level headed discussion from a judge. This guy is just theowing temper tantrums . If this matter affected HIM personally he would have been shouting at the officer "What were you doing? Why DIDN'T you arrest the lady?!"
There is no practicality in the court of law in India .. Either it's illegal or legal .. not right or wrong... Courts in India are Bound by the procedure established by law unlike the Courts in the USA which follows the Due Process of Law . So the Objectivity of the written laws are to be followed regardless of its consequences.
If you talk about practicality then court would not ask for proofs to punish someone they can just go by the practicality right? Or word of policemen? All big losers in the comment section here
5 o clock is after sunrise in😅 guwahati, the judge doesnt take that into account and dishes out civil justice😢 sad day for justice and indian time zones
@robindey2783 you are very much informed what judges do , should I tag your comments to one of my known judge . He will make you understand what court proceedings are .
@@gauravgupta548 tag me ... keep your colonial hangover limited to courts lawyer babu .. pathetic arrogant and full of self proclaimed moral high ground judiciary have 5 crore pending cases ..
@@pantomathlonda6746 The reasons for this backlog are complex and involve multiple reasons, lack of judicial infrastructure, lack of judges are one of those reasons, government is often the largest litigant which leads to slow process and backlogs . A lot more facts , i can discuss with you. Judges are not only a functional body in the judiciary it's you and me also . With deu respect sir , in that particular part of the court proceedings I felt it was negligence and instinctive decision making of the sp was somewhere wrong .
@@pantomathlonda6746 can your educated mind also comprehend that everytime a new government forms both in state and centre, the cases of those connected with ruling parties are closed off?? The infrastructure of our judiciary in grassroot level and also the cases sent to high court and supreme court cause the grassroots court's laws are rejected by the people involved in cases ...and it goes on ..don't blame the judges and courts only blame the whole system which we are a part of
If there is a murder or robbery at the judge's house, anyone can be called to the police station to catch the culprit, but poice must secure Accused within 24 hours. If police do that in the common man case, the judge immediately becomes a saint and acts like Gandhi 😂😂😂
Maybe you are a police officer. I think you do not understand why justice is angry.just listen carefully. I hope you will get this. Unlawful acts are also punishable.
What about the victim in the case....is he has no right to get justice...If every accused has so much back of the court..then how the justice will be delivered....
Accused is the husband, why was the spouse arrested along with a child ? What exactly were the charges against the wife? The police didn't have any grounds to justify their actions thats the truth.
This is why education is important in this Current India. The Spouse of the Accused is not Accused. Education from whatsapp university is very dangerous.
@@Aledgamingtamilshe was an accomplice to the murder. She hid the murder weapon. And they apparently did have testimony from locals and had enough evidence to detain her.
@@sriramr2437so picking up with a child to police station at night is very correct in your eyes right. Man at least see what the judge is asking an answer for. Are you a child not to understand that? Was there no alternatives present to avoid this situation? Was her husband a terrorist?
If it had been the judge's daughter's wedding jewels then he would have been questioning the police woman whether she was sleeping during duty hours at night and why wasn't action taken to detain people who are aware of the theft. Policing is a thankless job. How will these judges who take long vacations undrrstand the plight of the policewoman. She has to hunt and arrest the criminals and their collaborators at night when judges will be peacefully sleeping and then produce them in court before such kind of insensitive judges
The woman who was picked up at midnight was not the criminal for your information.Her husband was accused of a crime and the wife and the children were picked up by the police which is against the law. You must remember that Police is not the law, they are the enforcer of law. So they too come under the purview of Judiciary. As a former employee of Hon'ble Court, I have seen numerous case where police have intimidated innocent people and the only thing they fear is the Judiciary.
@@FuriousTalks2060she is capable u idiot that's why she didn't waste any time and bring the women to identify the thief these judges doesn't know how the real world work besides the law if she waited there is no way to catch the thief these kind of old judges just need to act cool in front of everyone by making police a joke this is the reason most of cops are never try their best because they know the courts will make them suffer there is a their on the loose and the judge are more worried about the horrors which the children gone through their mother was not brutaly beaten up by the police to have any horror on children it's a police station not a ghost house how delusional are these old judges seeing the world only through their eyes believing that is the right way
You watched the video? Women cant be arrested before and after sunrise and these cops picked the women at 4:15 AM as per their own report thats what the judge is concerned about. How dense can people be 🤦🏻♂️
The lady was arrested on 26th May along with her 2.5 year old child and FIR was filed on 30th May.. What did they do with that lady on that 4 days Isnt that enough to make someone’s mind?
@@rajvardhanthakare8648 thats a good question to ask. Then wait for the answer and then make a judgement. Else its called prejudiced. If everyone make up judgement based on newspaper article without going t through the facts and Khap Panchayats will do, no need for professional law degree and courts.
Now this is height, when police act then court suspend police. But the important point of murder is completely neglected. The law should also consider the circumstance and given that the wife will be completely aware some support to police is required. All respect to lordship, but he should also consider the place if police have waited for another 2 hours the wife may also escape. I stand with police in this case
It's not like... Accused is her husband. Wife is nowhere connected to this murder. She is just a family member of the suspected... That person can't be dragged to police station for the enquiry early morning and also report is clearly saying nobody was there to take care of kids in the home... Wife and the kids are innocents itself right... To source whereabouts of accused, family can't be harrased.
For doing duty sincerely and catching the criminal, this was the punishment given to honest officers and criminal with his 2nd wife and their relatives are let free, this is indian judiciary.
don't say rubbish. it is so obvious there is an apparent error from the side of the officers, they did not follow the basic procedure laid down in the crpc.
They are educated officers so they should know how to handle such situation. Everything should be judge by what we see and hear not by logics and by heart decisions. This things have laws. Even if they saw a suspicious man they should follow the protocol.
If accused female run away can judges able to gave justice to affected citizens? If a lady holding bomb in night time up to sun rises police wait? Gender equality is there in India? Delayed justice to affected persons No problem for justice, Court but justice immediately to murder accused persons VERY GOOD JUSTICE IN COURTS? THE WHOLE VILLAGE PEOPLE LIFE CAN BE IN DANGER BUT ONE OF WIVES OF CRIMINAL SAFETY, RIGHTS ARE MORE IMPORTANT FOR JUDGES & COURT? THIS CASE SHOULD HEAR BY A HIGHER BENCH OF THE COURT.
In this case women is not the accused, things work according to the law in court, this is not Bollywood masala movie, you should be happy that the judge is upholding our civil rights.
This is an extremely negative analogy. First of all women is not the accused, u didnt hear things clearly. This is what negative thoughts and judgements do to us. Realistic condition is, if such things would have been the case the cops would have raised an alarm when they were there at the venue itself and documented them and presented it in court, which the cops never had. They didn't even have a justified reason to Bring her to court. Buddy 95% of the people in the world are not criminals so we have to realistically look into a situation as per Law. Bcoz of 5% criminals 95% genuine citizens should not have a traumatic life experience especially when there are children involved. There has to be an evidental threat observed and verified instead of a cops random judgment.
The wife of a criminal is NOT a criminal. There's something called law. You just can't drag anyone to the police station. This is not a movie and she is not Singham.
If you hear the details of the case, it looks like the arrested lady was part of the criminal gang. Police did a clerical mistake. Agreed. They should have waited for couple of hours and recorded arrest.
The only mistake the officers made was bringing her to the police station at an unusual hour, but they were investigating a murder case. If the police had been late, it would have been seen as another instance of negligence. Why is the judge making such a big issue out of this minor detail? The only complexity he could point out is that she was brought in before sunrise. What kind of judgement is this?
Wow, it was a matter of just 2 hours. And when you expect police to do their work righteously, why you again blame them in case of their inability of catching a culprit? Law is law, but circumstances are more crucial. If a wife is fully aware about the misdeeds of her husband and still supporting him, what makes her less criminal then him? And if the society is seeking equality between men and women, how women can't be arrested in the night by the lady police? And last thing, criminal has no time duration for committing a crime against another human, doesn't it again oppose the notion of civil law?
Salute to the judge. Because of you sir Indian Judicial system is still surviving or else lawyers like this have killed indian judicial system for money
Judge to criminal ko cover fire de raha hai. aisa hoga to police criminal ko kaise pakdegi? Desh sirf kagaj pr likhi cheejo se nahi chalta hai😂 Think practically😂
Not only the A1 suspect have a family but also the police also have.🤔 They also have children, leaving them at night doing the job isn't a joke..🤷🏼 The judge have prejudice against the police act. but suspending them doing their and closing FIR of a m**der case is lame!!
They have to write another fir against A1 without mentioning his spouse and the consequences to her If they really need to get her to police station, she need to be called as a witness for questioning only ( no arrest)
Wife of the accused is arrested without any warrant and magistrate order and you're on the side of the police.? Police works under the law not above. Innocent until proven guilty is usually followed not guilty established before arrest. Accessory after the fact is supposed to be the reason for her arrest but after 5 days the order is issued. What incompetence is the police doing. Guilty party will walk free because of their incompetence.
My God! What an honourable judge! We live in this world breathing the air and drinking water that are God-given just because there are judges like him.
Whoever supporting Judge in this respect are absolutely wrong. IPS lady did her job, 5.30 am is not night in any clock of the world. On top the family she was inspecting is a purported criminal, and should not be given liniency. Thats the problem in our country, criminals enjoy law.
5.30 am if not night in any clock of the world then 4.15 am is the night of all clock in the world bro try to understand timing before giving comments.. if they suspect that lady thy have to wait up to 6 am then they can take her into custody... Our country law is good but some officer made it wrong way. Understood bro😊
Regular Criminals Neighbours.Lawyers are Very Brilliant. They Know How to Escape. How to Helps Criminals. They Shows Wife and Children and get the Sympathy from Aged Judges...😮
As a Bangladeshi, I am very impressed to see such practice where a judge is standing for civil rights, even for notorious criminal's wife. A citizen is citizen, right? No matter who they are. Actually, under Awalami league/Sheikh Hasina's era we didn't have any human rights. The country was like a jungle. Total system was corrupted by her (Hasina). The police, army, judicial systems and everything were under her control. That's why when we see such good practices like this, it feels starnge to us. Now that she has ran away from our country, we are hoping for a better future.
I'm a big critic of police. But the lady officer in video seems to be working very hard and sincerely to crack the murder case. Unfortunately the honorable Judge's action will discourage such sincere young officers in future also.
Judges like these make it impossible for police to do any investigation In Criminal cases. The judge knows very well that the criminal is a history sheeter, involved in multiple cases, his wife is refusing to divulge any information about the accused, and the judge here is more concerned about the time of police action. In this case the entire police station is put on suspension, so effectively the judge is saying to the police, regardless of the case, we expect you to walk on a tight rope and will punish you for every procedural lapse, and we don't care if you solve the case or not, but don't impinge on civil rights of the criminals. This is authoritarianism on the judges part.
Inshort court wants to say, keep copy of low book all sections and code of conduct with you. And don't do any thing out of that even if there is a need to for presence of mind. Sala crime rokne ke liye thoda dimag lagao to ye AC me baithe ke KALE coat vale Hume judge karte hai, fir ye officer issues Paisa khake daba dete hai...... . Good to see why police dont want to work at there optimal potential.
Judges should give this lecture to wife and children of those who were murdered by the accussed. Who will forever become widowed and be fatherless. Ask them what is judiciary and law enforcement was doing when despite the accused previous murder records, why was he granted bail by the court. I am pretty sure the judges who granted him bail would surely be like the judge passing comments. Hearing everything and previous murders committeed by the accussed, it is pretty clear that this is not one off incident but it's the accussed full time business. Regarding picking them up in morning, Dhubri is in Assam that is Northereast of India where government schools start at 5 to 5:30 AM as the sun rises very eary there. So, it can be forgiven when the SP apologized for it. It is because of woke judges like this that crime in our society is gonna increase. I know from the matter of fact, that what these type of judges have done to US and made it into a safe haven for criminals. A anti corruption inquiry should be initiated against the judge to examine his wealth and earnings. This woke judge system meeds to go. If a person has one off incident, you can treat him with hiw you are treating this case but if he/she is a repeat offender, such roghts cannot be extended to such psychopaths.
They only follow what law and order say's,,, if you need to work and night by your own then go to that lady collect information from her residential that's what law and order say,, you not call her to police station for your day and night rush running
Superb judgement. We (BHARAT) are a constitutional country. Rule of law should be prevailed. Unlawful activities and violation of law will not entertained at any cost.
यही अपराध अगर इन जज महोदय के साथ हो जाती तो ये कहते की पुलिस नकारा है और अभियुक्त से मिले हुए है।गजब के जज साहब है लगता है सिर्फ किताबी ज्ञान है व्यावहारिकता के बारे में कुछ भी नहीं जानते।
Wow judges seem so powerful when they come to the defence of civil rights. Nice. Excellent sir. Thank you CJI for making the proceedings live.
Yes Your Lord ship You have
taken right action
Small correction: this is not CJI
It's written 'HC' in the title
Defending who a wife of killer so shamed that after her husband kill ,
He is not showing ""SEEMS"" ITs his POWER bestowed by the Govt.Law of INDIA..He is the LAW and the Maker..
Because Still Sanatan Culture exists. But it's in last stage after sanatan dharma will be destroyed by 2060 as planned. Then it will be replica of Pakistan courts.
IPS lady should have applied her mind, she might be working hard but this didn’t give her right to break the law
Who khows tha you don't look like this . Her work can be bad or good because this is in her hand but looks are not .
Uniform, power mil Gaya khud ka desh ka constitution samjh li , Saab Paisa ka khel hai 😂 police 🚨 abhi contract basis pe kaam kr rahi hai 🎉
😮😮
This IPS is herself a woman and look what she has done ,she has power in hands to tackle the situation in some other way.
@@gauravgupta548aap paida hi aise hue ho...ya baad me bimari lagi judgemental hone ki?
Heartless and all....ye judge k emotions hai.
And yes, the accused was running away and judges are not on the ground to face..
Our judiciary is our Pride.... honorable Judge sir God bless you
Even in the sc ruling on maintenance for talaq victims.
No no. It was death of democracy @@reecosmicatomsb8576
What about talaq ,in that some radical muslim against that judgement, soo foolish
गांडू दोगले कश्मीर में तुम लोगों ने जज की हत्या करी है
Judge ko god bless krnrki jagah alha ke bhadvo ko samja ki 2-3 biwi bananan 10 -10 bache paida krna band kro to khun kharaba bhi kam hoga
Shameless lawyer saying "children were not in conflict with law".
Government lawer tomorrow he will be judge and expect his judgments.
@@habibullahu7460not with this kind of behaviour
😮
He shouldn't have been spared for having justified the police team that was slapped with suspension. I guess this is not Delhi High Court!
Dis is from Assam chourt I think so
The place they mentioned is in Assam
The case involves a serious issue of police misconduct where a woman, her 2.5-year-old child, and another minor child were allegedly detained by the police without an FIR for six days. According to the information provided, the police picked them up around 4 AM and kept them in custody without producing them before a magistrate, which is a violation of legal procedures and fundamental rights.After six days, the police filed an FIR naming the woman, possibly to justify the illegal detention retrospectively. The woman's brother then filed a habeas corpus plea at the Gauhati High Court, challenging the unlawful detention. A habeas corpus plea is a legal action that requires a person under arrest to be brought before a judge or into court, especially to secure the person's release unless lawful grounds are shown for their detention.
what's new , we all know indian police is getting degraded day by day
😢😢😢
Delete my comment. At the end you can see this is bad policing
Hon'ble Judge is doing well protecting the civil rights.
Thank you fir this information
Honourable Justice,
A physically challenged woman with her six years female child was admitted to the Government Hospital for Mental Care, Visakhapatnam without mental illness by the police intentionally causing her homelessness.
I pray for Justice for the daughter of the democratic India.
@drramanand99 sir they won't check here pls either make a prayer in court filing a writ and engage a lawyer or there are many legal aid institutions which can help
Either give her a home there needs to be good citizens among India to cure homelessness😢😢@@chetan7272
Police shows power to public and judges show power of law to Police !
Nope.. The court abuses the power..
@@prakashkr2214 Courts cant act outside their power, but Police can
@@iMahesh-ji1bq have u heard about squirrel killed by police in USA? It's fair as per their law, but stupid that's 1 f d reason Kamala lost d election.. 99.9% in India are criminal if u keep looking under the rug, India is a bureaucrats state, every thing is illegal in India.. That's why we are 3rd grade country.. Through away those stupid laws made by stupid bureaucrats.. It's called common sense..
@@iMahesh-ji1bq courts r d stupidest people ever existed, I respect sweeper than Indian judges and bureaucrats..
@@iMahesh-ji1bq
The court is abusing the power because they cannot suspend the whole police station for this mistake, because there are many lower officials there too, and they can not do anything infront of higher officials even if they want to
Salute to this court and the judges.
Sir please do realise the ground realities of catching a high profile rowdy it's not easy at all do you want to risk more peoples life by delaying to do anything . People like you comment salute to this and cry a river that police is not working and say arrest the rowdy asap when anything bad happens
@@memelover8448 Sir, with great powers come great responsibility. The police are cloaked with immense power. If tomorrow thay come to your house and arrest you or your family (god forbid) in the name of law and order, would you still argue on the same lines? The law is there for a reason. Upholding it doesnt make us weak or lets gangsters escape. On the contrary, one could argue, that the USA is such a power because it observes the law.
@@Huh67784 see what the justice system done to uttar pradesh it can't do nothing to Gunda/rowdy raj only yogi's bulldozers have stopped them and made the public life somewhat better
@@memelover8448 I am sure you won't want those bulldozers to come to your house and destroy them in front of your eyes.
@@countryman5062 similarly I don't want to be attacked by rowdies either ,only rowdy houses are destroyed, saying that it's not more scary than a totally underdeveloped state with a fear of being killed.
What ever the reason may be child is not suppose to be in the police statation.
India really needs such judges.
What is the age of that child ,I think 18year 1month.
@@strmstrm42875 years
@@strmstrm42872.5 years
No woman can be
1. questioned at night
2. brought to police station at night
2-5 year was @@strmstrm4287
I appreciate the boldness of the lady in defending her actions through her arguments. Her choice of the Defense Counsel is pathetic (he is totally unprepared). The Judge is doing the right thing to understand the urgency. Defense Counsel is a lame duck.
He is not a defence counsel. He is the state counsel and he is not lame. The questions of the court were addressed directly to the cop who appeared personally on being ordered to do so and there is nothing exceptional in what she said. If you had ever been to a court you would have known that senior police officials when summoned to the court, always defend the actions of their juniors. First understand the court proceedings and then start running your fingers on the keypad.
These bloody cops are so energetic buy while dealing with politicians they help the accused to run away. Look at Mumbai sena children case. That guy wad absconding foe 2 days
Mm😊😊 I'm in I.j😊 😅😅😅 and😅😊 16:12 16:12 😊 16:12 16:12 😊 16:12 16:12 16:12 16:12 😅😊.djmk I'll pm olll mm u😊 p meom
😊😊n0
.
In@@MrAshishmunna
Exactly.. Defence counsel was way underprepared and couldnt speak properly, whereas SP lady could put up the points much more better.
@@R..B ya do agree with you partially that lady is bold enough to terrorise a woman with an infant. She is sp and se don't know how to set the outer perimeter as a contingency plan. If she had Intel she could have set- up area isolation and waited for the first light . Secondly Paisa wasooli k liye to constable duty PE rehte hi hai highways pe . You know what I am saying.
As Pakistani We should proud on India because of such justice..
For what. 😮😮 this is like parayi shaadi mein Abdul deewana.
not parayi bhai.....apna hi bigada huva bachha hai 😂@@SoumikSikdar
Our judiciary system is not based on Sharia law that's why we have full faith in our judiciary. 🇮🇳
@@govindraj28 it's not about the sharia law dear don't take it on wrong side.
There is sharia law in gulf you can see the crime rates even less then our both democratic countries
@@hassamjarral1475 I agreed, crimes might controlled but delivery of justice is on one perticular religion can never provide a true justice. False blasphemy cases are killing the minorities in Pakistan. In India minorities are safer than the majority people. That's the beauty of our country. 🇮🇳
Law is there to protect the criminals and not for the sufferer of crime. No one is worried to give protection to the deceased's wife and family
That is a separate case
Salute to Honorable High Court
No matter how hard you work, if you do not work according to the prescribed protocol everything is "zero". Work hard but as per protocol and be ready to back all your actions only than your work will pay
There should be zero discrimination between men and women in front of the law. Although the judge is technically right in following the law, the law itself is discriminatory.
The fact that women go through multiple levels of exploitation at every aspect of life necessitate seperate laws for them to make things equal.
@@naveen4926 The weak get exploited which has nothing to do with gender
@@naveen4926also we know they are not as strong both physically and emotionally, thats why.
@@naveen4926 can you please list the exploitations that women suffer from that men don't?
@@user_5670x bro ask any woman what they face everyday. Every eye on them is full of lust. Indians don't know not to stare and men's glare especially makes women feel unsafe.
Kudos to lady officer. From her presentation, it seems she is honest and sincere to her duty to punish the criminals.
Yes but law should also be followed and that's why she is IPS
Honest😂😂 lack of Crpc/ BNSS 2023 knowledge is considered honesty these days😂😂 arresting a woman along with bringing her minor child to the police station late at 4:15 a.m is 'honesty' in your eyes..wow
Law for women and Lauda for men😢
Becoz men have Lauda 😂😂😂😂😂❤
That's our privilege buddy..
😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Only underdeveloped boy pussiess complaint about this things ..look back at Indian histories on how women faced persecution since medieval times to till now! Real men know they are built stronger and can take care of themselves they don't complain.💪
Now I understand why the police don't want to work day and night.
Even thieves work hard. Does not mean they are accepted. It's about breaking law.
@samson13ng Yeah, I agree with you
@@samson13ng How childish and immature statement lol
@@sai62789yep that's how you sound
@@samson13ngpolice have both problems, if he tries to catch the murderer and so interrogates the wife then judges comes to protect a murderer & his family
And if they follow all the rules and murderers escape then people ask the sanctity of police
What about the main crime and main accused? System is more bothered about officers making errors in investigation than in perpetrators of crimes like murder? 🙄
This is what I was looking for,
But bro judges will say ( hamare yaha Aisa hi hota hai )
There is law and procedure for everything.
This is not the trial of the murder accused.
The murder trial is different.
@@apnikavita6Even accused persons have their rights. Sidha encounter karde?
This is so depressing to watch. Indian judicial system is rotten to the core. Needs complete rehaul. These justices would not even be hired as office boys in a fair world.
Hey, don't be a keyboard warrior on TH-cam.
Wow another keyboard warrior
Bro is using phone and i ternet bought from father's money, and is comparing the chief justice to an office boy lol😂
@@hkphysics Dear moron compatriot. I paid more tax this year than your extended family's combined annual income. So shut the fuck up and get yourself a decent education.
@@hkphysics Dear moron compatriot. I paid more tax this year than your extended family's combined annual income. So desist from making comments about topics you are not competent enough to speak about and get yourself a decent education.
The judge himself is a prejudiced chap. He is trying to throw around his weight. I expect more level headed discussion from a judge. This guy is just theowing temper tantrums .
If this matter affected HIM personally he would have been shouting at the officer "What were you doing? Why DIDN'T you arrest the lady?!"
Agreed.
He isn't saying..don't arrest,he is saying why bring women and children before sunrise at 4:15AM.
He isn't saying..don't arrest,he is saying why bring women and children before sunrise at 4:15AM.
I want all families of the victims who lost their lives to listen the point of the argument
Meaning the murder can be justified and made understood to victims family?
@@mightyducks4035 u took it in whole wrong way
judges are not on practical sidee ... actual practical things aree differentt ...
There is no practicality in the court of law in India .. Either it's illegal or legal .. not right or wrong... Courts in India are Bound by the procedure established by law unlike the Courts in the USA which follows the Due Process of Law . So the Objectivity of the written laws are to be followed regardless of its consequences.
@@chhayakant8944due process is an integral part of Indian judiciary, man do some research then utter any bullshit
If you talk about practicality then court would not ask for proofs to punish someone they can just go by the practicality right? Or word of policemen? All big losers in the comment section here
Shielding a crime is as illegal as a crime@@youneverknow01
Mamla legal hai.....not practical
5 o clock is after sunrise in😅 guwahati, the judge doesnt take that into account and dishes out civil justice😢 sad day for justice and indian time zones
India has only one timezone and any time before 6AM is considered night,regardless of whether sun rises at 5AM in the northeast
Judges do s great job in protecting the dreaded criminals n demotivate the police who are working in such harsh conditions
@robindey2783 you are very much informed what judges do , should I tag your comments to one of my known judge . He will make you understand what court proceedings are .
@@gauravgupta548 tag me ... keep your colonial hangover limited to courts lawyer babu .. pathetic arrogant and full of self proclaimed moral high ground judiciary have 5 crore pending cases ..
@@pantomathlonda6746 The reasons for this backlog are complex and involve multiple reasons, lack of judicial infrastructure, lack of judges are one of those reasons, government is often the largest litigant which leads to slow process and backlogs . A lot more facts , i can discuss with you. Judges are not only a functional body in the judiciary it's you and me also . With deu respect sir , in that particular part of the court proceedings I felt it was negligence and instinctive decision making of the sp was somewhere wrong .
@@pantomathlonda6746 can your educated mind also comprehend that everytime a new government forms both in state and centre, the cases of those connected with ruling parties are closed off??
The infrastructure of our judiciary in grassroot level and also the cases sent to high court and supreme court cause the grassroots court's laws are rejected by the people involved in cases ...and it goes on ..don't blame the judges and courts only blame the whole system which we are a part of
Please stop arguing
If there is a murder or robbery at the judge's house, anyone can be called to the police station to catch the culprit, but poice must secure Accused within 24 hours. If police do that in the common man case, the judge immediately becomes a saint and acts like Gandhi 😂😂😂
Maybe you are a police officer. I think you do not understand why justice is angry.just listen carefully. I hope you will get this. Unlawful acts are also punishable.
You said it
@robinmirza8529 I am not a police officer and I see no reason for judge to get so angry. Suspending everyone in police station is too much
You're talking like an ignorant person. It's not about the judges personal opinion. It's according to what the lawmakers wrote in the parliament .
Idi*its like you can be as cruel as this. But the rule of law cannot.
Please take a look at what the IPS officer is saying.... Go through the complete case.
Jugde got arrogance 😂
Mr Majumdar was not at all prepared
Everyone forgot about the victim and his family
What about the victim in the case....is he has no right to get justice...If every accused has so much back of the court..then how the justice will be delivered....
His wife and children were not accused.
Accused is the husband, why was the spouse arrested along with a child ? What exactly were the charges against the wife? The police didn't have any grounds to justify their actions thats the truth.
This is why education is important in this Current India. The Spouse of the Accused is not Accused. Education from whatsapp university is very dangerous.
@@Aledgamingtamilshe was an accomplice to the murder. She hid the murder weapon. And they apparently did have testimony from locals and had enough evidence to detain her.
@@private808 if the accused is women thn law are different
Police sometimes use the power which they have not given by the state. Police can’t arrest wife for her husband crimes .
The witness clearly stated that the wife conspired with her husband in hiding the weapon so she could be arrested.
Correct. But shielding a criminal is a crime right?
@@sriramr2437but you have to proove it
It's not about women alone but only about 2.5 baby
@@sriramr2437so picking up with a child to police station at night is very correct in your eyes right. Man at least see what the judge is asking an answer for. Are you a child not to understand that? Was there no alternatives present to avoid this situation? Was her husband a terrorist?
Their lawyer coming to school without doing any homework
If it had been the judge's daughter's wedding jewels then he would have been questioning the police woman whether she was sleeping during duty hours at night and why wasn't action taken to detain people who are aware of the theft. Policing is a thankless job. How will these judges who take long vacations undrrstand the plight of the policewoman. She has to hunt and arrest the criminals and their collaborators at night when judges will be peacefully sleeping and then produce them in court before such kind of insensitive judges
The woman who was picked up at midnight was not the criminal for your information.Her husband was accused of a crime and the wife and the children were picked up by the police which is against the law. You must remember that Police is not the law, they are the enforcer of law. So they too come under the purview of Judiciary. As a former employee of Hon'ble Court, I have seen numerous case where police have intimidated innocent people and the only thing they fear is the Judiciary.
that is her choice to become police woman it is nothing to with judge... if she is not capable then...u know what i mean
@@FuriousTalks2060she is capable u idiot that's why she didn't waste any time and bring the women to identify the thief these judges doesn't know how the real world work besides the law if she waited there is no way to catch the thief these kind of old judges just need to act cool in front of everyone by making police a joke this is the reason most of cops are never try their best because they know the courts will make them suffer there is a their on the loose and the judge are more worried about the horrors which the children gone through their mother was not brutaly beaten up by the police to have any horror on children it's a police station not a ghost house how delusional are these old judges seeing the world only through their eyes believing that is the right way
Was the witness running away?
@@chaalbaaz429 If the accused is not kept tabs on, there is a possibility of her escaping.
Looks like the Judges have already made there mind. They seem to be not listening to lawyers.
You watched the video? Women cant be arrested before and after sunrise and these cops picked the women at 4:15 AM as per their own report thats what the judge is concerned about. How dense can people be 🤦🏻♂️
The lady was arrested on 26th May along with her 2.5 year old child and FIR was filed on 30th May..
What did they do with that lady on that 4 days
Isnt that enough to make someone’s mind?
@@rajvardhanthakare8648 thats a good question to ask. Then wait for the answer and then make a judgement. Else its called prejudiced. If everyone make up judgement based on newspaper article without going t through the facts and Khap Panchayats will do, no need for professional law degree and courts.
@@pnalagondau seems to be countering your 1st comment. The irony is overwhelming.
Now this is height, when police act then court suspend police. But the important point of murder is completely neglected. The law should also consider the circumstance and given that the wife will be completely aware some support to police is required. All respect to lordship, but he should also consider the place if police have waited for another 2 hours the wife may also escape. I stand with police in this case
This is what justice is kudos to the chief justice that is why the last words of every citizen in India is "I will see you in court".
Ghanta...., have you ever been to court, you will realize ,what a foolish organization judiciary , totally corrupt and illogical
Aise hi judges ki vajeh se criminal khule ghumte h aur bina dar ke crime krte h... Unko bachane ke liye aise judge baithe h...
It's not like... Accused is her husband.
Wife is nowhere connected to this murder.
She is just a family member of the suspected... That person can't be dragged to police station for the enquiry early morning and also report is clearly saying nobody was there to take care of kids in the home...
Wife and the kids are innocents itself right...
To source whereabouts of accused, family can't be harrased.
For doing duty sincerely and catching the criminal, this was the punishment given to honest officers and criminal with his 2nd wife and their relatives are let free, this is indian judiciary.
Agreed brother most of the people commenting here did not understand the fact that why was there an urgency to arrest the lady
don't say rubbish. it is so obvious there is an apparent error from the side of the officers, they did not follow the basic procedure laid down in the crpc.
They are educated officers so they should know how to handle such situation. Everything should be judge by what we see and hear not by logics and by heart decisions. This things have laws. Even if they saw a suspicious man they should follow the protocol.
Did that lady police have right to arrest a woman at night??
@@blacknife5532 what is lady or jents? Criminal is criminal
Hon'ble Judge is doing well protecting the civil rights.
Big salute to hon'ble high court and chief justice
So police should work day and night, but Criminals will work from 9 to 5.
And judge wants FIR to be lodged on police for working day n night.
😢
work as you like is not work.. you can't do anything u want.. there is constitution
Most of the police fellows do not perform what they are supposed to perform....only a few honest and sincere officers are there in police force..
It isn't work time, it's about the ehics and procedures
Police first should protect their job-As per law, do job- Everything comes later-
But many cheer encounters
Power comes with responsibility else with wrong hands innocent will suffer
If accused female run away can judges able to gave justice to affected citizens?
If a lady holding bomb in night time up to sun rises police wait?
Gender equality is there in India?
Delayed justice to affected persons No problem for justice, Court but justice immediately to murder accused persons VERY GOOD JUSTICE IN COURTS?
THE WHOLE VILLAGE PEOPLE LIFE CAN BE IN DANGER BUT ONE OF WIVES OF CRIMINAL SAFETY, RIGHTS ARE MORE IMPORTANT FOR JUDGES & COURT?
THIS CASE SHOULD HEAR BY A HIGHER BENCH OF THE COURT.
Exactly 💯💯💯
Disruption to children in name of investigation regardless of their parents' crime is horrible than the actual crime itself..
In this case women is not the accused, things work according to the law in court, this is not Bollywood masala movie, you should be happy that the judge is upholding our civil rights.
This is why describing the urgency is important
This is an extremely negative analogy. First of all women is not the accused, u didnt hear things clearly. This is what negative thoughts and judgements do to us. Realistic condition is, if such things would have been the case the cops would have raised an alarm when they were there at the venue itself and documented them and presented it in court, which the cops never had. They didn't even have a justified reason to Bring her to court. Buddy 95% of the people in the world are not criminals so we have to realistically look into a situation as per Law. Bcoz of 5% criminals 95% genuine citizens should not have a traumatic life experience especially when there are children involved. There has to be an evidental threat observed and verified instead of a cops random judgment.
Wow such a great judge India needs judges like you
So this is how every criminal shows their wife and kids and escape punishment. Nice.
This is indian judiciary at its best. Defending the civil rights of a women, even if she is a wife of a murderer. Even accused have rights.
The wife of a criminal is NOT a criminal. There's something called law. You just can't drag anyone to the police station. This is not a movie and she is not Singham.
@@samic7049 correct. That is what I'm saying too.
Bhai 6 baje baad pakad lete 2 Ghante m kya chala jata
If you hear the details of the case, it looks like the arrested lady was part of the criminal gang. Police did a clerical mistake. Agreed. They should have waited for couple of hours and recorded arrest.
That exactly is what the judge is saying.
The only mistake the officers made was bringing her to the police station at an unusual hour, but they were investigating a murder case. If the police had been late, it would have been seen as another instance of negligence. Why is the judge making such a big issue out of this minor detail? The only complexity he could point out is that she was brought in before sunrise. What kind of judgement is this?
Criminals will be so happy with the outcome of this ruling
Police are worst then Criminal
Exactly the concern
We need this kind of chief justice all around the world. With great chief justice like this will deliver the public peace
Wow, it was a matter of just 2 hours. And when you expect police to do their work righteously, why you again blame them in case of their inability of catching a culprit? Law is law, but circumstances are more crucial.
If a wife is fully aware about the misdeeds of her husband and still supporting him, what makes her less criminal then him? And if the society is seeking equality between men and women, how women can't be arrested in the night by the lady police?
And last thing, criminal has no time duration for committing a crime against another human, doesn't it again oppose the notion of civil law?
Exactly that's the whole point 💯💯💯💯💯💯
There's no proof that wife is fully aware about the deeds of her husband
And if laws can be bend based on the circumstances that paralyse the law itself
And lastly the wife and her kid is not the one accused here.
Accused,not guilty criminal yet
Salute to the judge. Because of you sir Indian Judicial system is still surviving or else lawyers like this have killed indian judicial system for money
Judge to criminal ko cover fire de raha hai. aisa hoga to police criminal ko kaise pakdegi? Desh sirf kagaj pr likhi cheejo se nahi chalta hai😂 Think practically😂
well then she’s also criminal ie the IAS officer which has been proven guilty ; and the suspect is still not proven guilty
Salute to you sir may God bless you,this police officers are running their own low we need to take action.🙏🏽👍🏽❤️
I don't like the judge the way he is talking to a lady who is sp.
Our law itself is discrimination...
HC Judge has more power than cabinet minister.
You should then see how ruling party politicians behave with all cops
True Honest Judge..... Rare and A Boon for a common man
Not only the A1 suspect have a family but also the police also have.🤔
They also have children, leaving them at night doing the job isn't a joke..🤷🏼
The judge have prejudice against the police act. but suspending them doing their and closing FIR of a m**der case is lame!!
Law is to be followed not judged.
They have to write another fir against A1 without mentioning his spouse and the consequences to her
If they really need to get her to police station, she need to be called as a witness for questioning only ( no arrest)
It’s their duty and they took this post in a condition that they would take this kind of jobs😂
Wife of the accused is arrested without any warrant and magistrate order and you're on the side of the police.? Police works under the law not above. Innocent until proven guilty is usually followed not guilty established before arrest. Accessory after the fact is supposed to be the reason for her arrest but after 5 days the order is issued. What incompetence is the police doing. Guilty party will walk free because of their incompetence.
My God! What an honourable judge! We live in this world breathing the air and drinking water that are God-given just because there are judges like him.
Real Truthful Judges in Kaliyug
Kudos
Bravo! well done to the judges for showing compassion and applying the principles of natural justice.
Wah.. Indians are proud of Judges
Very good decision.proud होल इंडिया. जज sahab ko salute.❤
Police when they are on the Road they think they are Above the law
We need more judges him who can make decisions quickly without delaying the process.
If this is the situation... Crime can't be controlled.... Judges are always on favour of accused..... We should look at the example of el Salvador...
Thank you honourable judge sir. You are truly a human being. ❤️
Whoever supporting Judge in this respect are absolutely wrong. IPS lady did her job, 5.30 am is not night in any clock of the world. On top the family she was inspecting is a purported criminal, and should not be given liniency. Thats the problem in our country, criminals enjoy law.
5.30 am if not night in any clock of the world then 4.15 am is the night of all clock in the world bro try to understand timing before giving comments.. if they suspect that lady thy have to wait up to 6 am then they can take her into custody... Our country law is good but some officer made it wrong way. Understood bro😊
Regular Criminals Neighbours.Lawyers are Very Brilliant. They Know How to Escape. How to Helps Criminals. They Shows Wife and Children and get the Sympathy from Aged Judges...😮
This the power of judge to defend the right of civilians....salute judge sahab 🎉
Salute to the indian judicial System
इसी जज लोगों की हत्या करी थी कश्मीर में मुसलमान ने
As a Bangladeshi, I am very impressed to see such practice where a judge is standing for civil rights, even for notorious criminal's wife. A citizen is citizen, right? No matter who they are. Actually, under Awalami league/Sheikh Hasina's era we didn't have any human rights. The country was like a jungle. Total system was corrupted by her (Hasina). The police, army, judicial systems and everything were under her control. That's why when we see such good practices like this, it feels starnge to us. Now that she has ran away from our country, we are hoping for a better future.
I'm a big critic of police. But the lady officer in video seems to be working very hard and sincerely to crack the murder case. Unfortunately the honorable Judge's action will discourage such sincere young officers in future also.
I have also visited Pakistani court for few time and after watching this im feeling why india is growing so fast I solute your justice system
क्या होगा हमारे देश का जहां न्यायालय में केसेस भी अंग्रेज़ी में लड़े जा रहे हैं!?
Are bhai ye assam ka HC h, waha hindi nhi boli jati jyada. English 2nd official language h isliye use kar re.
India me aade se jada log hindi nahi Bolte hai. Pure south India me Hindi nahi Bolte hai.
Court ki language english hoti hai
Salute this types of judges...law enforcement officials are to be educated on the basics of human rights
Judges like these make it impossible for police to do any investigation In Criminal cases. The judge knows very well that the criminal is a history sheeter, involved in multiple cases, his wife is refusing to divulge any information about the accused, and the judge here is more concerned about the time of police action.
In this case the entire police station is put on suspension, so effectively the judge is saying to the police, regardless of the case, we expect you to walk on a tight rope and will punish you for every procedural lapse, and we don't care if you solve the case or not, but don't impinge on civil rights of the criminals. This is authoritarianism on the judges part.
💯
Inshort court wants to say, keep copy of low book all sections and code of conduct with you. And don't do any thing out of that even if there is a need to for presence of mind.
Sala crime rokne ke liye thoda dimag lagao to ye AC me baithe ke KALE coat vale Hume judge karte hai, fir ye officer issues Paisa khake daba dete hai......
.
Good to see why police dont want to work at there optimal potential.
Very nice Honourable Judge.aise Judge ho jaye to sab thik ho jaye.
Most of the people are not aware of the actual case!
Kudos to the respected Judge who's trying to make a change in our bureaucracy. Jai Hind🇮🇳
Judges should give this lecture to wife and children of those who were murdered by the accussed. Who will forever become widowed and be fatherless. Ask them what is judiciary and law enforcement was doing when despite the accused previous murder records, why was he granted bail by the court. I am pretty sure the judges who granted him bail would surely be like the judge passing comments. Hearing everything and previous murders committeed by the accussed, it is pretty clear that this is not one off incident but it's the accussed full time business.
Regarding picking them up in morning, Dhubri is in Assam that is Northereast of India where government schools start at 5 to 5:30 AM as the sun rises very eary there. So, it can be forgiven when the SP apologized for it.
It is because of woke judges like this that crime in our society is gonna increase. I know from the matter of fact, that what these type of judges have done to US and made it into a safe haven for criminals. A anti corruption inquiry should be initiated against the judge to examine his wealth and earnings.
This woke judge system meeds to go. If a person has one off incident, you can treat him with hiw you are treating this case but if he/she is a repeat offender, such roghts cannot be extended to such psychopaths.
Absolutely 💯
The way that lawyer laughs when he said 4 :50 am is a morning i feel like he’s sarcastically laughing at the judge
Thank You very much for your judgement your Honour.. This is justice
She is from a peaceful community that's why the chief justice is so furious. Otherwise, he won't have even noticed! 😂
If police wants to work efficiently day and night , this happens.
They only follow what law and order say's,,, if you need to work and night by your own then go to that lady collect information from her residential that's what law and order say,, you not call her to police station for your day and night rush running
Day and night working doesn't mean harassing people
What a logic 😂
Hey bhagwan kya ajeeb log hai
Educate urself along with some humanity
All judges should be like him.
Judge lives in some utopian world it seems, where women don't commit crimes.
This case is not about committing crimes by a woman dammmmm....listen carefully
Superb judgement. We (BHARAT) are a constitutional country. Rule of law should be prevailed. Unlawful activities and violation of law will not entertained at any cost.
We Are Really Greatful To 🙏 Judiciary ! AMEN 🙏.
Thu muslim hai naam Hindu rakha hai aajit kumar khabi aamin naahi bolta thu aamir hai😂😂gajab jihad hai
यही अपराध अगर इन जज महोदय के साथ हो जाती तो ये कहते की पुलिस नकारा है और अभियुक्त से मिले हुए है।गजब के जज साहब है लगता है सिर्फ किताबी ज्ञान है व्यावहारिकता के बारे में कुछ भी नहीं जानते।
Isi law ke loop ki vajah se criminals bhag jate h
So unfortunate
Salute this judges
He has gave right respect to law
The Lady officer is constantly telling the court about her accomplice, yet he is ignoring the fact, becz she is a Muslim... Whether u deny or not
This is the reason India is far ahead of us.
The power of the judge
One true judge and powerful officer change the our politician within day...
Protection of Muslim community on peak 😂
Great judge we need this kind of judges
Judge did everything except talking on actual issue. Woke judge.
Awesome Judge. Law is blind. Good justice.