India Says Criminalising Marital Rape is "Excessively Harsh" | Vantage with Palki Sharma
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ต.ค. 2024
- India Says Criminalising Marital Rape is "Excessively Harsh" | Vantage with Palki Sharma
The Government of India has opposed marital rape criminalisation by calling it "excessively harsh". "Sexual acts by a man on his own wife" are not criminalised in India’s law. The government says that criminalising marital rape can disturb a marriage. While many support this stance in India, there is widespread criticism. 1 in 3 married women in India experience some kind of violence from their husbands and 1 in 25 face sexual violence. Should marital rape be criminalised? Where do other countries stand? Palki Sharma tells you.
---
India | Marital Rape | Government of India | Sexual Violence | Firstpost | World News | News Live | Vantage | Palki Sharma | News
#india #maritalrape #governmentofindia #sexualviolence #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.c...
You forgot to mention domestic violence & other laws are gender neutral in other countries...what about false allegations? Marital rape will be misused like 498a & other women centric laws
very true
@@kishorerayudu3421 according to her only women's are right not men it's pseudo thinking.
Biologically, men need sexuality of vmen.
Women need resources.
Women are ok to take resources of men with condition to marriage.
But they want choice in sexuality.
Biologically, men need scxuality of vmen.
Vmen need resources.
Vmen are ok to take resources of men with condition to marriage.
But they want choice in scxuality.
Absolutely 💯
To much democracy.. sometimes Communism is best on these cases. Remove Marriage law. Create a law for contracts which treats equally men and women. No dowry, no marriage no settlements..
Support
Biologically, men need scxuality of vmen.
Vmen need resources.
Vmen are ok to take resources of men with condition to marriage.
But they want choice in scxuality.
Lol maariage is marriage moron
In narriage you can do a contract that if divorce happen then
Wife or man will only get the ratio
Which they were worth before marriage
And then no humanity
communist countries clearly ban feminism and libralism supporting traditional family values...
She looks educated and intelligent but forgot to mention Women want another law to extort money from tgeir husbands after dowery and domestic violence for unsucessfull marriages.
Something which has no evidence and can not be proved if true or false.
Biologically, men need scxuality of vmen.
Vmen need resources.
Vmen are ok to take resources of men with condition to marriage.
But they want choice in scxuality.
That can be said about ANY oppression.
After all she is a woman
You mean "how dare women want compensation for ruining her career and life!"
@@BlackSakura33 you are blaming others for your own choice of marriage.
Okay.. you criminalise marital rape, but then introduce a SEX CONSENT FORM to be signed by both husband and wife (or atleast by wife) each time before they have intercourse.
seems a bit funny 😂😂😂
Wait till you get booked for the same funny thing😅 @@harsh-gs7kb
and how would you prove it was not forged ? So lets have a permit system which is taken from a welfare dept with witess from both the side, the govt, the police , having evidence by video recording from the time of signing, through the act and till a day after the act so as to ensure they dont claim violence after the act. A copy of all of the above can be stored in a central safehold which can be requistioned when the woman claims rape.
Keep a CCTV camera maybe!😅@@dthyagarajan39
It won't work because woman are LIARS, she will backtrack.
Marriage system is going to be a joke near future 😂 in india like western countries nowadays 😂
It already is
In neaur future Indian women are no longer raped every 17 minutes or sometimes gang raped and killed. Like in Western countries, they´ll be protected by law
Western countries marriages are dead no one wants them , yet they bash men on net.
If marriage is rape then better divorce it or complain as domestic violence.
True
Still better let them not marry and create hell for the boy amd their family!! I am aware girls who dont want to marry but agree to marriage only to enable their younger sibling to get married or pressures from family, relatives or being looked down by society.. They then turn into real monster after.
It is not that simple. Do you think women whose husbands sa them will allow them to leave?
@@shripadbhagwat6566in which world are you living😂?
If men are not allowing their wives to leave then how are false cases against husbands and their family members being filed?
Stop spreading baseless lies
@@shripadbhagwat6566then will thesw women will have the permission to go to court and say that my husband is a pervert?
Why does this news channel show only one side of the coin? Not even a single story on issues faced by men?
How to prove innocence if wife wants to misuse this law?
U know exactly why.
Biologically, men need scxuality of vmen.
Vmen need resources.
Vmen are ok to take resources of men with condition to marriage.
But they want choice in scxuality.
Their narrative is manipulative.
Just because you are being nonsense to understand it..
पुरषो का षड्यंत्र पुरुषो पे ही भरी पड़ा है, सदियों से। मैं ये नही कह रही की महिला गलत नही है पर मैं ये कह रही हूं कि जो बहुमत है। आप करना छोड़ दो, आपके साथ वो होगा नही। Stop looking at each other as material but look at human beings. Let you reduce your animalism and rest will be settled down' itself.
I think the government is right here, cause criminalizing marital rape can be used as a tool by the wife to intimidate the husband at convenience. If a wife really suffers from marital rape then she should simply file for a divorce straight away.
OR there is another way, the couple must fill out a consent form before having sex every time. 🤣🤣🤣
Wow rape is funny to u ?? Also divorce rate in india is 1 percent it's nit easy for women to file for divorce In patriarchal india. Though they should fill out a consent form maybe men will stop raping then?? You really thunk a rapist would care about a form
What about the trauma caused by rape wtfff
Typical north indian😂😂
@@anita2053-r1f Aint he right. Things have reached to a point that everything has become a contract😅😅😅
@@curiositylikeacat8119 What about falsely accusing men
Then allow legalizing of sex workers..or the cases of rape will increase ...
This will destroy the institution of marriage in india ..
Western influences on india.
I think Western influence is beneficial to India.
Legalization of sex workers ( men & women ) is a good idea. If a wife or husband denies sex or other fantasies of their partners then this partner can fulfill them somewhere rather than forcing your partner to fulfill it.
Marriage is already failing in India due to various reasons. Many educated & independent women in the current society, No one is ready to compromise, High expectations from partners, low wages & high inflation, so much dissatisfaction with the quality of lives, less love & understanding from partners, bored with routine lifestyles etc
Sex work is legal in India. Pimping is not.
@@mishidesu yes but it should be licensed
Without explo-itation of men, constitution don't work.
They need men support to exist.
Palki, before delving into the numbers of how many women in India are subjected to domestic violence and marital r*pe, how about you first mention that in India, crimes like rape, domestic violence, sexual harassment, stalking and voyerism aren't gender neutral. Thus, if a woman commits any of these crimes against a man, she will not be punished as there is no law which can punish her. Male victims don't get justice and they don't get included in statistics. Have you ever talked about making existing crimes gender neutral??? At least, women have consent, men don't.
First, let us make existing crimes gender-neutral and then we can discuss about marital rape.
Why not just get divorced if you are fine telling the whole world that your own hunband is a rapist. Keep this up and marriage will be destroyed like in the west.
Divorce is good option but not easy due to society (especially in rural and sub urban area). For many families divorce is like big 'kalank' to their 'pratistha'.
Have you seen how divorced women are treated in society?
India doesn't have that amount of freedom.
To be honest, the west's approach to marriage is better than ours.
@@bihariallenite3843 if that is so, will the pratishtha of the woman be pronounced in golden letters if she files a marital rape case against her husband?
@@bihariallenite3843 you are implying a woman is better off filing a false rape case against husband than just divorce him? nonsense
I was a virgin before marriage, and my wife was not. However, I still married thinking that she would love me for the rest of my life. However, she did arranged marriage with me to have a better life in America, have 2 kids and then move into a separate bedroom (I was 33) withholding any kind of intimate physical or emotional relationship with me. It's been 14 years+ with not even a kiss, and she makes sure I don't have any other relationship outside of this one-sided marriage, and when frustrations comes out she threatens me with Divorce Lawyers sending notices to my parents & siblings for inheritance money on top of my assets. WHAT DO I DO?
I have never crossed the line because like being loved by my wife.
Sorry to hear that..
Radical feminist Palki will say-
it's her choice
Idk she sounds similar to amber Heard?
Bro, take evidence of abandonment, cruelty and "sexual abandonment" for a period of months and talk to divorce lawyer and file a suit in court.
Talk to a damn lawyer first !!!
Bhai us me dv gender neutral hai complain kar
Palki, you seem to have no understanding of what it takes to build a successful family. You should not be talking about India issues anymore - because you seem to lack even foundational understanding of what keeps a society together - it is the family! And for the family to have its freedom to chart its own path through joys and sorrows, and gain strength, the law should not get into the bedroom to dictate what constitutes sex vs rape. if there are issues in the bedroom, get a divorce!
Marital rape will be so misused That men will stop marrying. Stop harassing men. Why does the law think it is only a woman at the receiving end.
Many are not even marrying it is like a gamble..
Marital rape is a real problem tho but i do agree that many women can misuse the law for their benefit.
Did people stop having kids when POCSO cover into existence? No? It's because people don't sexually abuse their kids. Rape charges still include "innocent until proven guilty".
I am a woman but I am human first and thus neutral. Yes, percentage wise many many rural women face marital rape than urban women and most of whom won’t be able to utilise if marital rape is criminalised. But sadly many urban educated women may misuse this law to penalise their husbands and extort money or blackmail as we see with other women centric laws. So it’s a very murky waters. Yes, percentage wise due to patriarchy men torture women more than women does that on men. But few bad apples will always spoil the ‘law’ in this case. If marital rape is criminalised then due to the demography of our country it would be misused than used properly.
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA) is an Indian law aiming to protect women from domestic violence. The Act provides:
Punishments for Domestic Violence:
1. Criminal proceedings: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Protection orders: Restraining orders against perpetrators (Section 18).
3. Monetary relief: Compensation for victims (Section 20).
4. Custody orders: Temporary custody of children (Section 21).
5. Residence orders: Right to reside in shared household (Section 19).
Punishable Offenses:
1. Physical abuse (Section 3(a)).
2. Sexual abuse (Section 3(b)).
3. Verbal and emotional abuse (Section 3(c)).
4. Economic abuse (Section 3(d)).
5. Harassment (Section 3(e)).
Search for domestic abuse. Even men are victims. Stop crying your patriarchy.
I also agree
"wife" has right over her body, but the "husband" does not have right over "his earned" money and inherited property, they belong to both. Sex is a requirement, for that "wife" is allowed to go overboard as to who she shares "her" body with, but husband is not allowed "extra marital" affair, if he does, wife can file for divorce under cruelty and mental harassment and claim for alimony, monthly expense "hafta" even if husband is not earning and send him to jail if he does not pay. The law is not balance.
😂😂 cope harder sach sabko pata hai
Women have protection under 498A, 377, and dowry acts , domestic acts . Currently women are punishing men 24*7 legally, our constitution is 99% in favour of women. This country belongs to men also. Men deserve equality from our constitution. No country has a law of arresting a men just based on the statement of women saying rape happened 10 years without any evidences sadly India has many laws which are against men by nature.
Expected comment from a narcissist Indian who is born by a woman & yet, thinks that women are not equal to men. Very sad & barbaric.
@@morat795do you even make sense? People like you are the reason feminist get trolled everywhere . Stop being stupid and utter something that makes you relevant
No other countries have as many rape cases as India.
@@morat795 lol stop you feminist
@@morat795 accepting reality is not possible for feminists, most of Indian men treat women with dignity and respect, crimes against women are less when compared to per capita statistics of other countries but I want zero crime against women, as a country we are moving towards that goal , situation is improving when compared to 75 years ago, it will be better than today when we look into our future 75 years. I am proud of mother how she raised me along with 2 of my siblings despite losing my father when I was 10 years old. My mother made me a successful doctor today. But fake cases are increasing day by day , even high courts and supreme courts are fed up with the raising fake cases .
498 A and existing rape laws are already favouring women a lot in india yet not sufficient? how many biased laws men has to face ?
😂stop simpin, stop promoting sexual things as many required,(required I said)
Then teach both genders about wisdom, health, and humanity then it'll become balance
Ofcourse women will be favored where majorly they're victims 😂
So now these feminist want us use to signed a legal document of consent every time we want to sex
😂😂😂
So now you don't respect you partner decision ,and forced "intimacy" When she continuously begging you to stop in pain and accept her to cook clean for you like nothing happened... Well yes feminists are against it
If you weren’t a rapist you’d not make such a foolish statement
lets include video evidence from the point of signing followed through till the end, otherwise its he says vs she says. The video evidence needs to be streamed, else she could claim it was all doctored
But these same feminists will disagree on prenuptial agreement.
As an Individual I would like to request Palki and her team to atleast study the existing laws to protect married women, understand the concerns of Government and men correctly instead of sensationalizing the whole issue.
As a woman, I would say these are grey areas and when existing legal provisions exist then why the need to sensationalize whole issue
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA) is an Indian law aiming to protect women from domestic violence. The Act provides:
Punishments for Domestic Violence:
1. Criminal proceedings: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Protection orders: Restraining orders against perpetrators (Section 18).
3. Monetary relief: Compensation for victims (Section 20).
4. Custody orders: Temporary custody of children (Section 21).
5. Residence orders: Right to reside in shared household (Section 19).
Punishable Offenses:
1. Physical abuse (Section 3(a)).
2. Sexual abuse (Section 3(b)).
3. Verbal and emotional abuse (Section 3(c)).
4. Economic abuse (Section 3(d)).
5. Harassment (Section 3(e)).
What about women who files false Rape case against husband for material gain or upper hand specially in divorce cases ? I wonder what's punishment for such cruel manipulation from wife?
My simple question is "how could he/she prove its martial rape" .
Just by a woman says to court?...if she lied to fullfill other benefits..what about innocent man??...
namaste
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA) is an Indian law aiming to protect women from domestic violence. The Act provides:
*Punishments for Domestic Violence:*
1. Criminal proceedings: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Protection orders: Restraining orders against perpetrators (Section 18).
3. Monetary relief: Compensation for victims (Section 20).
4. Custody orders: Temporary custody of children (Section 21).
5. Residence orders: Right to reside in shared household (Section 19).
*Punishable Offenses:*
1. Physical abuse (Section 3(a)).
2. Sexual abuse (Section 3(b)).
3. Verbal and emotional abuse (Section 3(c)).
4. Economic abuse (Section 3(d)).
5. Harassment (Section 3(e)).
*Penalties:*
1. Breach of protection order: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Non-compliance with monetary relief: Imprisonment up to 1 month (Section 20(4)).
3. Violation of custody orders: Imprisonment up to 1 month (Section 21(4)).
*Protection and Support:*
1. Protection officers (Section 8).
2. Shelter homes (Section 6).
3. Medical facilities (Section 7).
4. Counseling services
And Yes, under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act (PWDVA), 2005, there have been cases where criminals have been imprisoned for more than one year.
Some notable cases:
1. Rajesh Sharma vs. State of Uttar Pradesh (2017): The Supreme Court upheld a 2-year imprisonment sentence for the husband for subjecting his wife to cruelty and harassment.
1. Vijay Verma vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (2019): The Madhya Pradesh High Court sentenced a husband to 3 years' imprisonment for physically and mentally torturing his wife.
1. Sandeep Kumar vs. State of Haryana (2020): The Punjab and Haryana High Court sentenced a husband to 4 years' imprisonment for dowry harassment and domestic violence.
1. Ravi Agrawal vs. State of Maharashtra (2022): The Bombay High Court sentenced a husband to 5 years' imprisonment for severe physical and mental abuse.
These cases demonstrate that courts can impose stricter sentences considering the severity of the offense.
Factors influencing sentencing:
1. Severity of violence/abuse.
2. Repeat offenses.
3. Impact on victim's physical/mental health.
4. Evidence and witness
Men are simple beings. We study for 20 years for a respectable job, work 12 hours a day as wage labours, mostly in a toxic environment, providing everything for family, trying to meet parents expectations, under constant stress, and will still take a 10th pass woman as a wife. And when she files for a divorce and asks for half of my property because she didnt got what she expected, we still manage a fake smile.
lmao if you have any property.
Women are more simple then men. Women do indoor and outdoor works simultaneously for their home and children.Working women got less payment in private sector and Housewives literally don't get anything, still they sacrifice their lives for others' happiness... And I have seen many Women married less educated men and many men marry Women for her or her families' wealth.. +Domestic violence on Women and children continuously happening... Actually you should put yourself in Women's shoes than see the other side..
@@ICoco9808most of the women don't even know how to cook rather than eating husband hard earned money.No women wants a guy with lesser education and salary and most of the cases are fake filed by fake Feminists.
@@ICoco9808 type of woman you are talking about is 1 out of 10 on a good day.
My advice is "Don't get married at all"🥱.
Yeah marriage is overrated
@@Orion225 Evil institution to ruin people's mental peace and money!!!!!
@@Orion225 An evil institution to ruin a person mentally, physically and financially 🙂
Agree. Not one couple managed to impress the concept of marriage. Its more of a cult and risky.
😂😂 security problems for women after parents death will you see?
Palki & Firspost,
I truly value your work. However, I’d like you to take a step back and provide an objective overview of the matrimonial dispute landscape for men, especially considering how burdensome marriage can feel nowadays. To fully grasp the legal framework you mentioned, I suggest looking into three key statistics:
1. The total number of cases registered.
2. The number of cases that were settled and the grounds for those settlements.
3. If possible, a breakdown of how many cases were based on false or fabricated claims.
Specifically, consider the following laws:
- Section 498A
- The Domestic Violence Act
- Section 125 of the CrPC
It seems that journalism today often leans more towards activism than objective reporting, lacking thorough research and failing to present both sides of the story.
it is leaning towards activism because of the rampant cases we hear everyday, and what other side is to be presented, many women are afraid to report cases let alone fabricate, that doesn't mean there arent any but by an equivalency standpoint those cases which are reported are a small portion of total.
yes marriage due to overlooked mistakes in partner searching in India tend to be bothersome, but that's no open license to say that all of this isn't an issue
@@abhirajdeore1910 bro you need to learn more about the topics I have mentioned.
From an ACTUAL victim.
@@adarshg4286 well I have seen how it impacts the "actual victim" and it isn't reported believe it isn't pretty
@@abhirajdeore1910 shaadi karle bhai jaldi, ladki na mil rahi ho to kothe se le aao. Uski zindagi ko sawaro pehle.
Stop taking money after divorce.
India needs a better law
Stop taking money before marriage then. Also only 1 percent marriages divorce but 91 percent of men take dowry. Your math is not matching
Then stop taking dhage before marriage.
Stop asking money before marriage
@@sandhyahansda1096 it's already illegal. so stfu
Why did you marry your husband
Just for money and security
Either you don't know what a marriage is or you don't like your husband and like someone else so that you don't approve his efforts to have a normal relationship
It's not like he is torturing you or
Forcing you for unnatural sex which is illegal by law
Today's women don't know the reason behind marriage and get married forcefully by parents
It's not your or your husband's fault it's the families who are responsible for making such decisions without the consent of bride and groom
If one feel its rape, then option of quitting relationship is always open...
That's not solution
They are just giving one more reason to loot men
@@ganapathi-vignyan Avoid marriage. Problem solved.
@@chuckscott4661
What if I want to get married and have good family
I just shut up and say yes to everything my wife says or I go to jail?
Ha 😂😂😂😂
@@ganapathi-vignyan
If u get married in this day and age then u deserve what u get.
@@ganapathi-vignyan Don't get married. Problem solved.
Other countries has gender neutral laws too. Should we implement that too. I am in favor of this but othet 50 percent of population needs protection too.
we also need consequences for false cases
@@dthyagarajan39 true. I'm a woman ad I totally agree with this. Because of such people, real cases are suspected to be fake.
@@clob3896 Really glad that atleast a few of the women appreciate that false cases should stop.
As much as I like Firstpost, I have to disagree with palki on this marital rape matter. Host gave a biased view of feminists instead of understanding men concerns and providing a comprehensive view.👎
Consent is always assumed whether it's a love affair/Live-in or marriage. In a relationship, no guy ever asks to a girl can we have sex? It never happened in history nor it will happen in future. Same goes with women too.
When a girl wants to kiss his man, she'll just do it assuming his consent is positive as he'll love it. Why? Because it's a romantic relationship. Asking for consent before romance is super awkward and puts off the mood for the partner.
Why do we assume consent? Because we know this guy/girl completely. We know their moods/gestures as we are in sync with each other. We will know in an instant if it's a yes or no because their faces give it away.
Even in movies have you ever seen a guy/girl asking for consent before intercourse? No.. Because it just happens like magic. And have you ever seen a guy/girl in the audience complaining about consent that watched those romantic movies? No.. Because that's what happens in life too. They relate and enjoy those moments.
So as the consent is always assumed if both are in mutual understanding "yes" never comes out of the mouth. That's why saying "No" took prominence with the popular phrase "No means no".
Coming to the issue at hand, now we all can agree that Rape is rape when the girl clearly says no and the man still proceeds to act ignoring her consent which means it's important to say "No" first before you term it as rape. But, according to your analysis a section of women let's say 10% don't say "no" out of taboo. I don't care about the reason but, the point is that they don't say no. And you even went on to say 90% women don't see it as a problem to say no because they think it is a man's right. Again, I don't care about the reason. They just don't say no. That makes it 100% women don't say "no". When there is no establishing "No" what marital rape are you talking about, palki? Absolute feminist fantasy trash.
Now let's address your bullshit reasons. The lies and gaslighting you pulled there is disgusting, palki. You yourself said women struggle to say no feeling some taboo. But, you forgot to say women also struggle to say yes out of shyness because still most women are shy. And the other reason is most women don't say "No" because they don't see it as a problem in the first place. It's time you understand the reason they don't see it as a problem is because there is no problem at all. Respect women opinions, palki. Stop treating women as intellectually challenged people.
Speaking of facts, most husbands don't proceed to sex if their wife conveys through her eyes and facial expressions that they are just not ready like being angry/upset/dull etc; And the rest try to persuade their wives for a while and if they are not willing men will stop it. Some men try to kiss to bring their wives into romantic mood. But, if the ladies are firm men will stop. So, forced sex is out of question.
You want to bring a fantasy crime bill into reality. Let's put some facts about how this bill will impact and damage men lives if enforced? First of all the intention of this bill is malicious. It sees all husbands as potential rapists. Romance takes a backstep and trust issues form straining the relationship. Husbands will be afraid to take consent and possibly in constant stress doubting the consent. Husbands will be forced to use consent forms and possible recording of sexual act. Why? Because it's highly possible there will be a tsunami of false cases of marital rape and husbands might need those video recordings as evidence to prove their innocence. This ultimately leads to marriage breakdowns and faith in marriage system will be collapsed.
You know some women commonly say "no" to seduce their partners. In that case, only the partner can interpret what he/she means when they say no. Some couples even do BDSM fantasies mutually. Courts are ineffective here. Don't you think these are some legitimate serious tricky aspects of sex life? And you just want to bring a plain and simple woman favouring marital rape law ignoring the suffering it will cause men after it's implementation. That's cruel. Marital rape law is a draconian law. Period.
And you also talked about U.S and U.K have marital rape law. But, you conveniently left out that the marital rape law in those countries is gender neutral. Infact domestic law is gender neutral there. They don't have 10 other different women biased laws for the same crime. We don't have gender neutral laws. Let's make the existing laws gender neutral first. We can talk about marital rape later.
Is India ready for that discussion in prime time news channels? Are Indian women and feminists ready to address men rights issues?
Very well said
I used to like her style of presenting and content, with intellectual analysis. but she has proved that when it comes to her gender, nothig is considered, other than blindly advocating nonsense
Palki Ji, in your jest to champion the cause of female empowerment, you failed to ask one very basic question. How will the supposed victim (wife) will prove the offense of marital rape? Let's say the law recognizing marital rape gets passed, a wife files a case of marital rape against her husband, husband clearly denies these charges, but will anyone believe the husband, it's a word of a woman against a man, care to guess whose words will everyone including judiciary believe. Now let's talk about evidence of marital rape, the act of physical intimacy or marital rape happens within the confines of four walls in a bedroom with no witness. Who's going to testify whether rape happened or not, or are you suggesting a Consent Form that needs to be filled in and signed by both parties every time both parties indulges in physical intimacy? Yeah good luck with the consent form.
they didnt show that there are provisions within our laws to protect women in marital relationship
Namaste
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA) is an Indian law aiming to protect women from domestic violence. The Act provides:
*Punishments for Domestic Violence:*
1. Criminal proceedings: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Protection orders: Restraining orders against perpetrators (Section 18).
3. Monetary relief: Compensation for victims (Section 20).
4. Custody orders: Temporary custody of children (Section 21).
5. Residence orders: Right to reside in shared household (Section 19).
*Punishable Offenses:*
1. Physical abuse (Section 3(a)).
2. Sexual abuse (Section 3(b)).
3. Verbal and emotional abuse (Section 3(c)).
4. Economic abuse (Section 3(d)).
5. Harassment (Section 3(e)).
*Penalties:*
1. Breach of protection order: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Non-compliance with monetary relief: Imprisonment up to 1 month (Section 20(4)).
3. Violation of custody orders: Imprisonment up to 1 month (Section 21(4)).
*Protection and Support:*
1. Protection officers (Section 8).
2. Shelter homes (Section 6).
3. Medical facilities (Section 7).
4. Counseling services
And Yes, under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act (PWDVA), 2005, there have been cases where criminals have been imprisoned for more than one year.
Some notable cases:
1. Rajesh Sharma vs. State of Uttar Pradesh (2017): The Supreme Court upheld a 2-year imprisonment sentence for the husband for subjecting his wife to cruelty and harassment.
1. Vijay Verma vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (2019): The Madhya Pradesh High Court sentenced a husband to 3 years' imprisonment for physically and mentally torturing his wife.
1. Sandeep Kumar vs. State of Haryana (2020): The Punjab and Haryana High Court sentenced a husband to 4 years' imprisonment for dowry harassment and domestic violence.
1. Ravi Agrawal vs. State of Maharashtra (2022): The Bombay High Court sentenced a husband to 5 years' imprisonment for severe physical and mental abuse.
These cases demonstrate that courts can impose stricter sentences considering the severity of the offense.
Factors influencing sentencing:
1. Severity of violence/abuse.
2. Repeat offenses.
3. Impact on victim's physical/mental health.
4. Evidence and witness
She's spreading lies.
Please look at what happened with Shekhar Dhawan Divorce case exploiting current Indian broken foreign Constitution based Legal System.
Yes. Let's have a law.
This means every sex act will have to be under a CCTV camera which will be observed real time by the police station.
The man and woman should first scan their irises and finger prints.
Then they should read out legal statements of consent in front of the camera.
Then the footage should go to a special rape judge who will determine that there was no coercion.
Then the judge should grant permission for a date and duration.
The man should set up a stopwatch.
The man has to pull out and leave the bed after the stop watch buzzes and should not be seen in the same bedroom by the cops watching from the police station.
Only then can a man be safe.
So true 😹
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
why are you omiting the legislative? MLAs anyway have a lot of interest in safeguaring the weaker sect of their society 🤣
Yeah😂.
Intimacy as a service. IAAS.
The procedure for this kind of a service would definitely look like what you mentioned.
@@p-k98 on the cloud ? 🤣
You cannot wrap up such a complicated matter in a 5 min video criticizing the law of the country.
पति से अलग होने पर पत्नी को मिलने वाली maintenence/alimony को बंद करवाने की याचिका सुप्रीम कोर्ट में पुरुषो को लगानी चाहिए
पत्नियों के सारे फर्जी केस की जड़ है फ्री में मिलने वाला पैसा इसे शीघ्र बंद होना चाहिए
Palki ji- stop whining.
We’ve seen how 498A is being misused.
She already knows all that.. It is just that she is gender biased.
Palki emphasize on gender neutral criminal law. I don't agree on these. How you can prove when criminal minded women change her mind and turn consent sex to rape?
Palki is not neutral this time, she in unhappy with the decision of the government.
She's extremely sexist. Been watching her videos from day one.
When it comes to women she is always supportive ..
@@sm_91 she is not supportive she is gender biased.. Have u ever seen her talking about fake rape cases..
@@Bade_papa_ yeah I know even if the women are at fault she don't address about it
Women ☕☕
3:36 if women's touch husband or firce them bcz men not touching them by pressuring him mentally
She is also supposed to get arrested for that bcz marrital rape is not just physical mental also, and most importantly it happens with mens too
Palki doesn't seem to understand such a basic issue. Women are using this as a tool to blackmail men, and if this law is enacted, men might stop marrying in India. If there's already a law addressing this, why is another one necessary? In India, men are shamed by society even if they haven't done anything wrong. This could have serious consequences for men. With no laws currently protecting men, this would just add to their harassment.
She is gender biased...
More often than not, Palki has trash opinions 😂.
You dont have data to show how many men face violence by their wife?
What gender equality do you talk about?
If this law is passed then no one can save India
"A learned fool is more foolish than born fool"
Woke will eventually destroy this country...
Unsubscribe..
why are you stopping with county ? It has potential to destroy our civilisation. In the west the woke culture now demands that trans women be allowed to compete in womens sports, share womens prison. The claim that trans men can get pregnant. Also in some place even parents consent is not required and should not be informed if a kid was switch her gender. Even in India now many are going DINK to avoid the hassles of bringing up a child. Women no longer want to go through pregnancy.. I just hope all future generation go DINK across the globe. The impact is already being seen in scandanavian countries and Japan
The government is correct here. Marital Rape should not be criminalised. Because Sex generally involves parts of pain and pleasure.
You take the pain and feel pleasure why are you making wife feel the pain
@@anita2053-r1f one more dum radicalised feminist... Sorry sorry... Independent woman..
Oh my God
^^ what he said, I'm so done with this country, honestly just go fuck yourself, how could anyone say that with a straight face?
As a practicing advocate I agree with the government's stand of not criminalising marital rape. Sections 498A of the IPC that criminalizes the husband and his relatives for cruelty to the wife and 498B that crimanalizes seeking of dowry are the most misused laws. The new Bharatiya Nyaya Samhita has repeated the provisions. These sections plus the Domestic Violence Act are ample to protect women.
But if marital rape is made a separate offence by itself it would be used as a tool by unscrupulous wives to extort husbands. Imagine a couple having conensual sex one night but next morning the wife marches to the police station and alleges her husband has committed rape.
If women activists want marital rape to be made an offence by itself they should agree to two safeguards to protect innocent husbands (1) there should be a statutory presumption that the sexual act was consensual and burden of proof should be on the wife to show it was against her consent(2) the wife must be punished heavily for making false allegations.
If marital sex is
You said you will discuss about both the sides, from a man as well as woman's perspective. But only brought a woman's perspective & totally ignored a man's perspective and especially about fake cases. I had not seen you as someone who is biased on one particular part, but first time I saw this.
Then you must be new here. She's a massive feminist and an androgynist and never fails to lose her shit every time the word woman is mentioned.
You forgot to mention domestic violence & other laws are gender neutral in other countries.
You conviniently forgot to mention that there are already provisions within law to protect married women from sexual, physical mental violence.
what about false allegations? Marital rape will be misused like 498a & other women centric laws
What about changing all laws to gender neutral? Will you ever show your solidarity to this initiative ? NO
Till now I thought Palki Sharma showed good content but now I realise even she's biased.
Then the punishment for false rape claims match the sentence for rape, then the law should be passed.
it should be more than double and widely publicised. The day an allegation is made the man is all over the press, and if he is cleared of all the charges, not even a corner article by the same press
From any angle "Marriage' is a risky affair. One is forced to sign up for sex from day one as its implied. Saying no to sex or physical intimacy is a reason for divorce itsellf.Being pregnant is considred as a symbol of successful marriage.
In short, marriage is a legalised cult.
Now a days women do not believe in marriage and family as a sacred relation , but more believe in money, women will support women only, this will increase anger and hate among the family. This is why many peoples are not getting married. If you have problems in marriage do not get married. don't play a blame game over others, it's your right.
With due respect, I pity your mental level and your tendency to create drama out of nothing instead of having meaningful discussions.
I am a woman too, but I understand the concern of men and Central Government. When there are already provisions in Civil law to protect women from sexual abuse which includes marital rape, there needs to be maintained some sanctity of marriage as a relationship where sex is a basic need.
Please note : I am not supporting rape in any form whether in a marital relationship or in any relationship so don't get into unnecessary rant or out of context discussion with me.
😂😂😂 really frustrated misogynist women 🥴
Excessively harsh means "we have already given women enough laws to make a man's life hell so adding one more is not advisable at the moment"
Just one question miss palki
How can it prove that husband rpe wife scientifically?? How can she proof that it was rpe not consensual??? How can husband proof it wasnt rpe ?Are we just gonna blindly believe in wife or the cp gonna record every love on phone ????
If we gonna believe blindly women can u take responsibility that she isnt lying?
Its implicit. Indian women are raised to be submissive.so they cant speakup esp they fear husbands. Indian husbands never speak with wife as she is female. My dad never spole with my mom all they want is women has to do work everything.in such a submissive env husb dont encourage wife to give love too. No effection no love just abusive relation where husband is like a stranger. Insuch cases husb comes only for sex forces on her. So for these type of victim wife this law is created. Today every law is missued. Now can you prove that no right same.so law is important but that must be fairly dealt.
Note : not all
@@anita2053-r1f Hindu ladkiya bhi toh muslimo se shadi karlete hai...kisse muslim ladki ko dekha hai outside religion....inne ladkiyo ke sath jo ho humara kya rista......bas Hindu aur Jain boys ke wives ko protect karne ka law hai toh theek hai baakio ko nhi...
Problem with INDIA is they make too complicated laws which they cannot enforce. INDIA should just educate people properly to avoid these crimes. Make simple laws that's easy to enforce without exceptions
What if it is enforced against an innocent person?
Instead more courts should be setup for deciding the cases quickly.
Palki Madam, I am a regular viewer of your Vantage ( and was also of Gravitas). I have always appreciated you clarity of thought and expression and your style of delivery. As the Govt. of India rightly maintained, marital rape falls under domestic violence and can be dealt with by the appropriate laws in this regard. The only point that I agree with you is regarding the severity of punishment for any form of domestic violence. The present provisions seem to be very lenient. Most of the comments below are from men and rightly they have pointed out their side of a marital relationship. Present laws are highly tilted in favour of women so much so even appreciating a woman by patting her on her shoulder was construed as sexual abuse (a case was filed against an MP for patting a woman journalist for an intelligent remark made by her. Ironically, it was not she who filed the case but the MP's political opponents). While domestic violence is rampant, irrespective of societal hierarchy, and, as you had pointed out, this happens in one-third of the marriages, you should not ignore the emotional violence inflicted by a woman on her husband.
If you criminalise it, women will file fake cases against their husbands. Just like dowry cases.
This is one of the most Grey area topics.
If husband feel the need while wife doesn't..
If he forces his wife thats rape, if he goes to someone else that's cheating...
Also proving it is very difficult.
Probably the woman should just walk out of the marriage, if she feels abused in that marriage instead of sending the husband to jail..
Doesn't marriage itself means that you have given some sort of consent.
Someone who is in that place would know better.😅
Marriage doesn't mean having power of ur spouse's body lol. Likenif tomorrow smth happens amd ur wife takes all ur money forcefully would that be okay too. Cause ur married ?. But I do agree it'd be very hard to prove it.
@@noahgalvin803 well court allowed her to take half of the properties but not vice-a-versa SO STFU
@@noahgalvin803 Nobody is saying marriage means your partner's body is your property.
If you don't feel like getting sexually involved with your partner for a long time and can't understand his/her need , release your partner from the bondage of marriage.
It's simple, live and let live.
Demand and supply should meet.
Get divorced, don't get married, let me live in peace ... Simple remedy
@@mkt65361even if divorced, men is forced to pay alimony in the majority of the cases..
I don’t know whats her point and how it can be reflected in practicality. No one supports rape of any kind but you can’t solve every issue with law..
Indian laws are already biased against men and have many provisions that encourage and incentivise women to abuse them. The SC has already recognised this and directed investigating Officers not to take coercive steps like arrest of the accused without preliminary investigation. Ridiculous cases are being filed by some women against men and they are registered and acted upon by the Courts and Police. Classical examples are the Me Too cases filed by film personalities AFTER DECADES of the REPORTED ABUSE by Directors/Heroes etc. How can you remain Silent for 15 years and leisurely claim that a famous director abused you?. What legally acceptable evidence can you produce when there is such a long long gap of decades?. Should not these kind of cases be rejected outright or should not cases of Harassment or Extortion be filed against the complainants?. Law should have stringent penalties for filing false cases. Genuine cases of rape or sexual assault should be dealt with swiftly and fairly but we should not allow Publicity and money mongering women to abuse law in the name of anything.
American models or Porn stars like Monica Lewinsky and Stormy Daniel extracted their share of fame and money by filing cases against American Presidents when they were in power. Should we allow similar extortions here ?.
Let honest women be protected and rewarded but law should not penalise and punish innocent men
People should read about PWDVA 2005 FIRST BEFORE AND THEN UNDERSTAND THE NARRATIVE BEING SET HERE:
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA) is an Indian law aiming to protect women from domestic violence. The Act provides:
*Punishments for Domestic Violence:*
1. Criminal proceedings: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Protection orders: Restraining orders against perpetrators (Section 18).
3. Monetary relief: Compensation for victims (Section 20).
4. Custody orders: Temporary custody of children (Section 21).
5. Residence orders: Right to reside in shared household (Section 19).
*Punishable Offenses:*
1. Physical abuse (Section 3(a)).
2. Sexual abuse (Section 3(b)).
3. Verbal and emotional abuse (Section 3(c)).
4. Economic abuse (Section 3(d)).
5. Harassment (Section 3(e)).
*Penalties:*
1. Breach of protection order: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Non-compliance with monetary relief: Imprisonment up to 1 month (Section 20(4)).
3. Violation of custody orders: Imprisonment up to 1 month (Section 21(4)).
*Protection and Support:*
1. Protection officers (Section 8).
2. Shelter homes (Section 6).
3. Medical facilities (Section 7).
4. Counseling services
And Yes, under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act (PWDVA), 2005, there have been cases where criminals have been imprisoned for more than one year.
Some notable cases:
1. Rajesh Sharma vs. State of Uttar Pradesh (2017): The Supreme Court upheld a 2-year imprisonment sentence for the husband for subjecting his wife to cruelty and harassment.
1. Vijay Verma vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (2019): The Madhya Pradesh High Court sentenced a husband to 3 years' imprisonment for physically and mentally torturing his wife.
1. Sandeep Kumar vs. State of Haryana (2020): The Punjab and Haryana High Court sentenced a husband to 4 years' imprisonment for dowry harassment and domestic violence.
1. Ravi Agrawal vs. State of Maharashtra (2022): The Bombay High Court sentenced a husband to 5 years' imprisonment for severe physical and mental abuse.
These cases demonstrate that courts can impose stricter sentences considering the severity of the offense.
Factors influencing sentencing:
1. Severity of violence/abuse.
2. Repeat offenses.
3. Impact on victim's physical/mental health.
4. Evidence and witness
She's spreading lies.
There should be law in marriage act. Husband and wife have right to havel sex. if denied any one can go to brothel. There will be no criminal offense.
It's not a criminal offense but will lead to divorce which will strip of all of his wealth and possessions
Ever wonder why you see there is a growing number of bachelors in their 30s? Forget about this issue, the law favors you know who...
Better 😂 let ppl live they want too dont force marriage be it women or man
Are we fighting against Biology????
1. Working Women
Encouraging women in the workforce is positive, but with increased independence, some might delay or avoid marriage, potentially leading to a population decline. This could result in a future where an aging population puts strain on economic stability.
2. LGBTQ+ Rights
While LGBTQ+ rights are essential, if same-sex marriages significantly rise in proportion to traditional ones, it could impact population growth. This demographic shift may pose future challenges.
3. Women’s Rights and False Allegations
Marital rights are important, but the risk of false allegations in cases like marital rape can’t be ignored. Such accusations can harm men emotionally and legally. Balancing legal protection for both partners in a marriage is essential to ensure fairness.
No one want compromise neither men nor women. And now everything has become about woman were men build the world and is ready to bring their other significant part forward😅😅😅
Feminist dont understand there are more women filling false cases than real victim's
What about men? Women are misusing law in India and many men are now victims. They lost their life and in arrest for months until they proved not guilty. No action against false acquired woman. Now men need protection from women.
Palki Sharma, Firstpost stop spreading lies.
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA) is an Indian law aiming to protect women from domestic violence. The Act provides:
*Punishments for Domestic Violence:*
1. Criminal proceedings: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Protection orders: Restraining orders against perpetrators (Section 18).
3. Monetary relief: Compensation for victims (Section 20).
4. Custody orders: Temporary custody of children (Section 21).
5. Residence orders: Right to reside in shared household (Section 19).
*Punishable Offenses:*
1. Physical abuse (Section 3(a)).
2. Sexual abuse (Section 3(b)).
3. Verbal and emotional abuse (Section 3(c)).
4. Economic abuse (Section 3(d)).
5. Harassment (Section 3(e)).
*Penalties:*
1. Breach of protection order: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Non-compliance with monetary relief: Imprisonment up to 1 month (Section 20(4)).
3. Violation of custody orders: Imprisonment up to 1 month (Section 21(4)).
*Protection and Support:*
1. Protection officers (Section 8).
2. Shelter homes (Section 6).
3. Medical facilities (Section 7).
4. Counseling services
And Yes, under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act (PWDVA), 2005, there have been cases where criminals have been imprisoned for more than one year.
Some notable cases:
1. Rajesh Sharma vs. State of Uttar Pradesh (2017): The Supreme Court upheld a 2-year imprisonment sentence for the husband for subjecting his wife to cruelty and harassment.
1. Vijay Verma vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (2019): The Madhya Pradesh High Court sentenced a husband to 3 years' imprisonment for physically and mentally torturing his wife.
1. Sandeep Kumar vs. State of Haryana (2020): The Punjab and Haryana High Court sentenced a husband to 4 years' imprisonment for dowry harassment and domestic violence.
1. Ravi Agrawal vs. State of Maharashtra (2022): The Bombay High Court sentenced a husband to 5 years' imprisonment for severe physical and mental abuse.
These cases demonstrate that courts can impose stricter sentences considering the severity of the offense.
Factors influencing sentencing:
1. Severity of violence/abuse.
2. Repeat offenses.
3. Impact on victim's physical/mental health.
4. Evidence and witness
being a feminist is not wrong phoenix. our ancestor were also feminist by present-day definitions. lord ram was, pandavas were, sri krishna was also.
if innocent men are getting punished then it is a judicial problem. why is our justice system so inefficient? i agree, men also face domestic abuse and we need to protect them too but you cannot deny that india is a largely patriarchal society where rapes and crimes against women are far too disturbingly common. the statement by the govt is very irresponsible and insensitive. just see how uae govt talks about women safety. how up govt talks about women safety and how the central govt has spoken. we do have laws to protect women then tell me why are rapes common phonix?
instead of saying all this had you taken one second to condemn the govt for their insensitive remark or spoken against your fellow men for being so dismissive about a serious issue as marital rape it would have been considerate. yes, laws are not gender-neutral but can you say indian society is gender-neutral? can you say we are not patriarchal? men need to change other men and help other men reflect. also why do you bring up domestic abuse cases against men only when women's safety issues are being discussed? please reflect and contemplate. all that you have said is a good upsc answer and will give you good marks but please also understand that despite laws in books, the reality is far worse for women. and it's not just in india, everywhere it is. so such comments do nothing but only make you get brownie points from your male colleagues but don't really show the sensitivity the nuances one needs to put oneself is the others' shoes. I am willing to walk in your shoes in fact considering how skewed the world is in your favour I would love to but I want you to see the world through a woman's pov too.
Namaste.
Dude stop blabbering.
Instead of ranting here and theretry to grasp the facts and what other party is saying without emotional drama.
Do you know that there are already provisions within law to protect a married woman from sexual harassment ? Read ACT PWDVA 2005
Your rant says because the number of crime against women is higher we can't have gender neutral laws.
Wow, like because their are lesser crime against men, innocent men shouldn't be protected.
How and why is the law more gender neutral in other countries than Indian law?
Many can argue Countries like US, UK, Canada, France, Germany Australia are also patriarchal.
Do you know about this? If no, then it's time for you yo make proper research.
And tell me a valid reason for not making laws gender neutral? Just because india is a patriarchal nation, it doesn't mean MEN can't be victim.
Instead of taking the conversation to out of context track, try to understand that legal provisions already exist to protect marital rape
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA) is an Indian law aiming to protect women from domestic violence. The Act provides:
Punishments for Domestic Violence:
1. Criminal proceedings: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Protection orders: Restraining orders against perpetrators (Section 18).
3. Monetary relief: Compensation for victims (Section 20).
4. Custody orders: Temporary custody of children (Section 21).
5. Residence orders: Right to reside in shared household (Section 19).
Punishable Offenses:
1. Physical abuse (Section 3(a)).
2. Sexual abuse (Section 3(b)).
3. Verbal and emotional abuse (Section 3(c)).
4. Economic abuse (Section 3(d)).
5. Harassment (Section 3(e)).
Punishment of rape is 10 years minimum. And that's a criminal offence in itself, unlike whatever this is.
So yes, the punishment listed here is too low.
Please make a video about *"man rights".* Please make a video on *equality.* Women have been using laws for false cases, getting alimony and compensation while they are working as well on the same or more salary. *Imagine the number of false cases against men.* Talk about legalizing prenup agreements before taking about maritial rape.
Palki
Why do you want the marriage , don’t marry
If you feel man and women bounding is marital rape then don’t marry
And
If this kind of law implemented then I will tell clearly my kids don’t marry
Enjoy your life with your money , if you want to further sex then buy and live like Ronaldo that is better life than marriage life
No burden , no tension no property sharing no alimony, no case
Enjoy your life happily
Mera to ab shadi se vishvas hee uth gaya 😏
Mera bhi
@@anita2053-r1f 😂
You two should get married 😆
@@badbad-cat😂😂
Mat karo
I would suggest all men to adopt the life of a Sanyasi (Monkhood). Most indian men are virgins untill age of 26-33 years of there life. Next 30 years should not be difficult too. Frankly it's scary as a man to be in same room where a women is present because you never know when that same women would make false claims of rape and sexual violence against a man.
10/10
Why india? only about women marital rape/Sexual abuse what about men marital abuse. There are so many parameters needs to be considered from both the sides.
Ye log aise aise law bana denge ki ek din mans sadi karna hi band kar denge.
Also there is no benefit for man in marriage.
Jaisa ki western countries me ho raha hai ?
People need to realize that while bringing a law is good...its misuse doest attract harsh penalty. Which makes life hell for people who have been charged with fake rape
If martial rape is crime so should be the extra marital affairs should be criminalized.
If dowery is crime so should be Alimoney after divorce should be criminalized.
I think it's better to have prostitution company than being married 😅
Std's a bonus 😂
@@PreethiAparna hahaa have to buy bundles of condoms 😅
Instead of fixing the shit some mfs made who fully biased and overpowered laws against men, no one even thought of possibility of misuse of power. Still cry for more laws. Atleast now positions have to think twice coz they can also be put in jail simply by saying martial rape.
I am not a law expert so I want to know how it will be determined beyond doubt that it was marital rape
Go to bed, record wife's consent only then you are safe. The basic thing is that We each need to respect other that no school teaches and what you need incorporate in your character.
what do you do if she revokes the consent during the act ?
What about male rapes??
😂😂😂
Don't worry we can handle
We are MEN
Women are victims disproportionately infact in some of men also get raped by some other men majorly 😅😂
This is a complex matter. If in a relationship if one partner doesn't feel like once in a while, sad, mentally disturbed, sick - forcing sex during these must be called rape. If the husband forces his wife during these periods, doesn't deserve her, and must be divorced. However, consistent persuasion during normal time should not be called rape. But if one partner doesn't want sex at all - they should have a hard look at the relationship.
In near future husband will take a video consent from their wife that it is not rape ..😅😅
A law is created to protect people against a crime. The judiciary needs to work objectively on a case to case basis to provide justice to people.
at the same time it should not be without safegaurds, as in the case of all laws for women
This time the report seems one sided. The other side is not even mentioned. Please make the report balanced.
This whole belief of "sanctity of marriage" is doing more damage than good. Need to change that first. After that:
1) make tape gender neutral
2) Domestic Violence Gender neutral
3) Allow prenups
4) Criminalize marital tape
But I am pretty sure they'll never do this. 😊
If a mother hits their childen then she should be convicted?
Mother is not raping her children
@@sonireddy6696ok then please let husband get pleasure outside of marriage, if wife feels she's getting raped by husband
Don't Marry. Stay single forever. Problem solved 😂😂😂
Hmmm yes
The issue is of misuse of the act.🤔🤔🤔
Government should allow both husband and wife to have sexual relationship outside the marriage and still have it not a crime, so that there won't be a word as marital rape 😅😅😅😅😅😅
This is mentioned in Kamasutra chapter to understand when it is cheating and when it is not
We have thrown away all our laws and following american blindly 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Yep both genders should be able to have sex outside of marriage 😂
I totally agree with the third reason given by government,there are laws for domestic violence which include physical violence so women can approach court for physical violence and even take divorce on this behalf with high alumni... Criminalising forced sex after marriage may get things more worst..laws in India are already women centric so they left man with no choice 😢😢
just because somebody yells rape court wouldn't punish them there should be evidence .It is as tough as to prove guilty as not guilty.
Back then I thought she was a intellectually humble person. But after gaining popularity she has become arrogant and thinks that her opinion is what that constitute news
she has already talked about this issue few years ago is wion, she always like this
Namaste
@samosa007 The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA) is an Indian law aiming to protect women from domestic violence. The Act provides:
*Punishments for Domestic Violence:*
1. Criminal proceedings: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Protection orders: Restraining orders against perpetrators (Section 18).
3. Monetary relief: Compensation for victims (Section 20).
4. Custody orders: Temporary custody of children (Section 21).
5. Residence orders: Right to reside in shared household (Section 19).
*Punishable Offenses:*
1. Physical abuse (Section 3(a)).
2. Sexual abuse (Section 3(b)).
3. Verbal and emotional abuse (Section 3(c)).
4. Economic abuse (Section 3(d)).
5. Harassment (Section 3(e)).
*Penalties:*
1. Breach of protection order: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Non-compliance with monetary relief: Imprisonment up to 1 month (Section 20(4)).
3. Violation of custody orders: Imprisonment up to 1 month (Section 21(4)).
*Protection and Support:*
1. Protection officers (Section 8).
2. Shelter homes (Section 6).
3. Medical facilities (Section 7).
4. Counseling services
And Yes, under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act (PWDVA), 2005, there have been cases where criminals have been imprisoned for more than one year.
Some notable cases:
1. Rajesh Sharma vs. State of Uttar Pradesh (2017): The Supreme Court upheld a 2-year imprisonment sentence for the husband for subjecting his wife to cruelty and harassment.
1. Vijay Verma vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (2019): The Madhya Pradesh High Court sentenced a husband to 3 years' imprisonment for physically and mentally torturing his wife.
1. Sandeep Kumar vs. State of Haryana (2020): The Punjab and Haryana High Court sentenced a husband to 4 years' imprisonment for dowry harassment and domestic violence.
1. Ravi Agrawal vs. State of Maharashtra (2022): The Bombay High Court sentenced a husband to 5 years' imprisonment for severe physical and mental abuse.
These cases demonstrate that courts can impose stricter sentences considering the severity of the offense.
Factors influencing sentencing:
1. Severity of violence/abuse.
2. Repeat offenses.
3. Impact on victim's physical/mental health.
4. Evidence and witness
She's spreading lies.
when it comes to her gender its all forgotten, and the intellect goes to cold storage.
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA) is an Indian law aiming to protect women from domestic violence. The Act provides:
Punishments for Domestic Violence:
1. Criminal proceedings: minimum 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Protection orders: Restraining orders against perpetrators (Section 18).
3. Monetary relief: Compensation for victims (Section 20).
4. Custody orders: Temporary custody of children (Section 21).
5. Residence orders: Right to reside in shared household (Section 19).
Woman can claim divorce if the crime is proven. The quantum of punishment can be increased by the judge.
The bigger problem is:
Judiciary don't work as per evidence but testimony of women. Yes you heard it right, section 114A of the evidence act explicitly states if physical relationship is proved and woman says she didn't consent COURTS WILL PRESUME SHE DID NOT CONSENT!
The law being non bailable and cognizable man would be locked up until HE CAN PROVE THE WOMAN DID CONSENT
There's a reason why resistance against women centric laws is at all time high, maybe just maybe look up the law before pinning everything down on patriarchy
आईला , माझा तर वेगळाच प्रॉब्लेम होतोय. I mean नेमक उलट घडतं हो माझ्या घरी तर 😂 , कधी कधी तर कसं नाही म्हणायचं ते मला कळत नाही मित्रांनो 😂
I just know that an innocent being falsely accused and punished is worse than someone who actually did wrong not being punished...false accusations will be more in such cases than actual reports i feel
Namaste
Namaste
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA) is an Indian law aiming to protect women from domestic violence. The Act provides:
*Punishments for Domestic Violence:*
1. Criminal proceedings: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Protection orders: Restraining orders against perpetrators (Section 18).
3. Monetary relief: Compensation for victims (Section 20).
4. Custody orders: Temporary custody of children (Section 21).
5. Residence orders: Right to reside in shared household (Section 19).
*Punishable Offenses:*
1. Physical abuse (Section 3(a)).
2. Sexual abuse (Section 3(b)).
3. Verbal and emotional abuse (Section 3(c)).
4. Economic abuse (Section 3(d)).
5. Harassment (Section 3(e)).
*Penalties:*
1. Breach of protection order: Up to 1-year imprisonment and/or fine (Section 31).
2. Non-compliance with monetary relief: Imprisonment up to 1 month (Section 20(4)).
3. Violation of custody orders: Imprisonment up to 1 month (Section 21(4)).
*Protection and Support:*
1. Protection officers (Section 8).
2. Shelter homes (Section 6).
3. Medical facilities (Section 7).
4. Counseling services
And Yes, under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act (PWDVA), 2005, there have been cases where criminals have been imprisoned for more than one year.
Some notable cases:
1. Rajesh Sharma vs. State of Uttar Pradesh (2017): The Supreme Court upheld a 2-year imprisonment sentence for the husband for subjecting his wife to cruelty and harassment.
1. Vijay Verma vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (2019): The Madhya Pradesh High Court sentenced a husband to 3 years' imprisonment for physically and mentally torturing his wife.
1. Sandeep Kumar vs. State of Haryana (2020): The Punjab and Haryana High Court sentenced a husband to 4 years' imprisonment for dowry harassment and domestic violence.
1. Ravi Agrawal vs. State of Maharashtra (2022): The Bombay High Court sentenced a husband to 5 years' imprisonment for severe physical and mental abuse.
These cases demonstrate that courts can impose stricter sentences considering the severity of the offense.
Factors influencing sentencing:
1. Severity of violence/abuse.
2. Repeat offenses.
3. Impact on victim's physical/mental health.
4. Evidence and witness
She's spreading lies.
@@phoenix281287 thanks for sharing this
They should change the definition of rape also in india, a man forcefully sex with a woman is rape only. That's totally false. A woman can also force a man for sex or man can force another man for sex this should be the definition.
apart from emotional black mail to have a kid and exhort more
"belive a snake not A woman", government is slowly realising this. 😅😅😅
There should be punishment. But this law would be heavily abused.
What about who really suffering from this?
It’s honestly baffling how this entire comment section missed the point. She’s not making the law; she’s simply reporting on it. Marital rape is real, and proving rape-whether against a man or a woman-is already difficult enough. If you’re worried about women falsely accusing men, then maybe also think about the men and women who actually do commit these crimes and need to be held accountable. Why is everyone avoiding the real issue-marital rape-and veering off into irrelevant debates about alimony or turning this into a men vs. women argument? This is about marital rape, which can happen to anyone, regardless of gender. Stick to the facts. The data is what we should be concerned about, not sidetracking into nonsense. She presented facts; focus on that instead of making this about something it’s not.
Palki Ji, You say forced sex is rape whether committed by a family member, stranger or anyone.
Do you know sexual crimes committed by women are not recognised in India as a crime?
Do you know domestic violence committed by women is not recognised in India as a crime?
Have some shame, have some ethics before you talk on these topics.