The biggest challenge with IIA institute will be building a reputation with the industry that its pass outs have the knowledge that is required to compete with CAs. Doing this is no piece of cake and will take decades even if they end up cracking everything perfectly.
Are sir kitnaa pyar se samjha hai aapne... Dusre faculty are not much concerned about it... Vo to bol rhe hai ki accounting knowledge Or competition badhegi.. India me...
Sir just one question...just like today many corporates ask for first attempt CA or rankholders...what will happen if these corporates start mentioning that only CPA from IIA can apply.Then it will be a huge disparity na Sir ....
Sir IIA will become reputable as IIT and IIM becoz they would be set up by government and it will make a big change in finance education in India . Definitely it would be better then ICAI becoz collage is always better in all aspect if you compare it with any corespondents courses ✅✅✅✅
*KYA IIT, IIM K KI KOI VALUE NAHI H KYA ???* *CA STUDENTS DISTANCE EDUCATION S PADAI HOTI HAI* *KOI TIME LIMIT NAHI* *KOI AGE LIMIT NAHI* *BAS ATTEMPT ATTEMPT ATTEMPT DO* *10 - 15 YEARS TAK AUR 50 - 80 TAK K OLD MAN PAPER DEIN TOH UNKI JOB LAGEGI KYA ???* *IIT IIM PEOPLE GET MORE PACKAGE THAN CA, CMA, CS* *IIT, IIM ONLY TOPPERS GET ADMISSION* *ICAI, ICMAI ICSI ALL SHEEP GOATS*
We are doing CA, so we not only need to think about this logically but also rationally. Setting up the colleges will come later but before that it could take around 5 to 10 years just for this IIA to set up under the act of parliament.
*KYA IIT, IIM K KI KOI VALUE NAHI H KYA ???* *CA STUDENTS DISTANCE EDUCATION S PADAI HOTI HAI* *KOI TIME LIMIT NAHI* *KOI AGE LIMIT NAHI* *BAS ATTEMPT ATTEMPT ATTEMPT DO* *10 - 15 YEARS TAK AUR 50 - 80 TAK K OLD MAN PAPER DEIN TOH UNKI JOB LAGEGI KYA ???* *IIT IIM PEOPLE GET MORE PACKAGE THAN CA, CMA, CS* *IIT, IIM ONLY TOPPERS GET ADMISSION* *ICAI, ICMAI ICSI ALL SHEEP GOATS*
70 years... Use ye mukam tk phochne me time to lagna hi hai Lekin seniority CAs ki hi rahegi The course designing of CA is absolutely full of complexity.. Nothing can compete it
One of the reasons why CAs are valued and respected is because it is centralised.Every candidate gets the same question paper (resulting in same difficulty),gets the same environment and appear at the same time for the exams.All the candidates go through the same curriculum. Unlike engineers (I am from IIT/NIT),MBAs (I am from IIM, XLRI, FMS),Doctors (I am from AIIMS) or lawyers (I am from X,Y,Z law college which is among the top 5/10 law colleges),no CA has to say from where they are (I am not talking about people who are unaware about this course).The tag CA itself is sufficient. By bringing in IIA, it will dilute the prestige of the course and profession as a whole. What needs to be done is Council Members should be made more accountable and course should be properly structured like international courses (CFA, CPA, CIMA,FRM, etc.). Mugging up laws (taxation, companies and economic laws) should be done away with and be replaced by open book real life scenario case studies as if students are not appearing for exams but cracking the case for the clients (give them 4 hours because exam is not a contest for writing speed).Other practical papers should be structured similar way. Reduce articleship period as apart from top 10 firms,no other firms make students ready for industry or big 4.Articleship for 3 years from small firms are useless. One year is enough and if probably another year of mandatory industrial training.Council members should be grilled as to why they think that 3 years of articleship is necessary.I am sure they won't be able to come up with a concrete answer because let's face the truth,articleship is an excuse to provide cheap labour to CA firms (the partners of which play important role in the administration of ICAI and hence misuse their power to get cheap labour). Along with ITT and GMCS,career related workshops should be held by ICAI by inviting stalwarts of various fields like Taxation,Finance, etc.
I agree with you but it's cheap labour just for 3 years and that too those which is learning period I met a person who was from a small firm but have knowledge at par of big 4 , he worked hard and ca is all about hard work and agar aap kaho ki practicing ca ko permanent labour cheap p nhi mil skte toh koi bhi practice nhi start kr payega because start m sb firms small hi hoti h, all they can do is improve quality, and bs 3 years ki baat h uske baad you would be in need of those cheap labours, why you are treated yourself as cheap labour when you can be their boss
@@sushil6509 jo hona hai ho ke rahega. Aaj tak koi ruka hai kya ?? GST , demonitization ye bhi hone do. Result dikj jayega jab ban jayega tum CA pe dhyaan do .
If someone is MBA, Doctor or Engineer then companies are not sure if the person is really knowledge and capable or not. But if someone is CA then there's no concept like aacha CA bura CA, if the person can crack this exam then others are cakewalk!
So why does ranker CA's are offered extremely high packages in MNC's compared to other normal passed out CA's? Why does articleship firm matters for getting a good job in an MNC?
@@karanagarwal9256 mba from top 6 iim is just 2 years. Takes only entrence and interview , 100% gets degree after cracking. Just by cracking the entrence and getting addmission , the 3.5 lakh CTC guy is now earning 30 lakh CTC . Yeh iim ne 2 saal me " SKILL" SIKHAYA H KYA? IIA me bhi yahi hoga , skill will baad me . 1 lakh logo me 1000 baccho me aaoge , top job milegi
@@zeegamesandtech2002 so do you think that the big MNC's are fools to offer the 3.5 lakh guy CTC a package of 30 lakhs? I'm myself a CA aspirant, and i have some friends from IIM as well..they are way better than us when it comes to interpersonal skills, managerial skills, communication skills. Everything in this world is not about bookish knowledge
@@karanagarwal9256 i m not saying mnc are fools , they never are. Just saying that an entrence is sufficient for them to give 30lpa ,soft skills are a plus anyway
Thanks a lot sir for guiding us I was so worried after watching CPA news I thought there is no value of Ca degree other TH-cam channels were also saying it..But now I'm happy that the only thing matters is "Knowledge"..
Sir thank you so much for the video. I've been in CA INTER for 2 years and will give both grps in Nov exam. This news have been eating me from inside. I've come a long way in this course and have gained so much knowledge even after failing 2 times in inter. And am proud to say I'm glad I failed just because I failed I gained the importance on CA course and the importance of having the knowledge in respect of every field. This is my dream, is, was and will be. When this new bill was passed I was so broken. But your video saved me. Thank you so much sir.
This country doesn't have enough medical College for which students are going to country like Ukraine who keeps them as hostage in war but the government is more interested in building IIA than medical College.😔🇮🇳🇮🇳
Sir sach bata rha hu ye news mili thi or youtubers galat tarike se news spread kar rahe thee or bahut tension ho rhi but muje baishvri se apke video ka wait thaa because aap logic ke sath topic explain karte ho
@@_PranayW i know but you people also think about the struggle of general Every genral is not rich Bhagwan kare ye kabhi na bane iise ca ki value hi kam padegi
@@_PranayW sorry sir with all due respect, nowadays more than the deserving candidates reservation is utilised by people who don't even deserve it and on top of it they do it for generations altogether. Our profession is still unstained and shall remain so !
Sir maine toh itna hi socha ki CA ki monopoly khatam karni hai, accountancy to khatam nahi hone wali,DT-IDT to khatam nahi hone wali. Muje to account,tax padhna hai, expert Banna hai So this in no chance carry a threat to me ❣️
Balki ab icai Or improve krega syllabus ko or jyada practical knowledge dene ki kosis krega... Thnk uh sir... Is wjh se boht dara hua tha m ki mere efforts waste to ni ho jaege ca m pr ab apne acche se smjha dia... 😁😁❤
Good evening sir.I am a big fan of ur teaching.Now I am in CA inter but I have taken the classes 2 month ago but in CA final I'll be here ,from ur coating centre 🥰🥰🥰
I think you need to start writing everything in law language, otherwise it's difficult to even clear intermediate. I am also in intermediate. All the best.
yes sir exactly what i was feeling, not being a supremacist but CAs will always be superior over college graduates.. hard work and efforts never go unrecognised and disregarded.
Icai president ka message dekho sb dar wahi se nikal jayega, koi bhi president apne time p aisa hone nhi dena chahega, or unki eyes m bohot saari baate thi, or wo jo pride h wo bhi or dard bhi
Since CA is a correspondence course, the major problem with the students is lack of communication and interpersonal skills. Most of the articles work in small and medium-sized firms, where they seldom get chance to fully apply their skills and knowledge. They have the knowledge, but they don't know how to apply the same. Also, articleship can be skipped by taking a dummy. On the other hand, if we say that IIAs will be like IITs and IIMs, we can expect lush green campus, world class infrastructure and reputed professors from across the globe taking lectures in IIA. In IITs, students work on making drones and electric cars while pursuing their B.Tech degree. In IIMs, students work on real life case studies, projects and assignments and learn from the same. Also students from both IITs and IIMs visit foreign universities as a part of cultural exchange program and get to learn a lot of things. But in CA course, practical exposure can be skipped by taking a dummy articleship or doing articleship in a firm where there's no scope of exposure. Its presumed that IIAs will have all those facilities that IITs and IIMs are having and that'll definitely be an edge over the present CA course. Gone are the days when CAs were hired only for audit and signing Balance sheets. Now corporates need people who are all-rounders. They need solutions to corporate business problems. They need advisors, consultants and experts.
Articled students may opt industrial training in big companies if they wish explore industrial environment. So under CA course there is no bar for getting exposure. And further CA is one of the most prestigious cost effective course. And it's a correspondence nature also, becoz of that a hard working student may pursue the course at his village itself. And In further if Govt need to introduce High quality on accounting profession may start IIA, and admission may be limited to CA/CS/CMA. For them the cost of world class facilities, world famous tutors etc can afford.
Sir jab pata chala ki CA ke liye yeh college system aaraha hai to main bahut darr gaya tha. I am in class 10th and want to be a CA one day. Thank you for clearing this doubt. I will take classes from you and I will be a CA one day
Thank u so much sir I don't comment often under videos but your way of explaining this matter was so good and relaxing, you gave me the confidence I needed desperately, thank you very much sir ❤️❤️
@@maithilisharma8301 CA's are themselves post graduates and it is not too difficult for them pursue PhD. When one says they are CA's he doesn't mean they don't hold any other qualifications. And there are many post graduate professors in many IIT's and IIM's. Infact most of the professional courses are at post graduate level and not doctorate level. Even simple post graduate from a streetshitter college can probably apply for PhD but as you know completing it properly and having the ability to gain something out of it is altogether a different thing.
@@maithilisharma8301 Is every doctorate degree holder eligible or I should say capable to qualify and become a professor at IIM's, IIT's and your so-called upcoming IIA's ? I would bluntly say NO ! Absolutely not ! When it comes to our core areas mind me CA's, CS's and CMA's will dominate your IIA. Who knows CA students will pursue graduation from IIA and then continue with CA and after that go for PhD at IIA. The only objection I have with IIA's is introduction of reservation and attacking the autonomy of ICAI, ICSI and ICMAI. It's fantastic to hear that Govt. is planning to build world class colleges for commerce students just like they do for law, engineering and medical students. I suggest they should sign an MoU with ICAI and work together to build a fantastic integrated course. One can apply for it right after his 10 th boards and he will pursue his diploma, graduation and post graduation from IIA and post that he will get licence and membership of ICAI. Just imagine this will be an 8 year integrated course and if they adjust 3 year articleship smartly in thier course then it will be a wonderful success story. And yeah high fees is a problem but 8 year is a too long term investment which can be adjusted provided you get such a wonderful ROI and tell me who would not grant loan to a student like you ?
@@madhavbarde9644 *KYA IIT, IIM K KI KOI VALUE NAHI H KYA ???* *CA STUDENTS DISTANCE EDUCATION S PADAI HOTI HAI* *KOI TIME LIMIT NAHI* *KOI AGE LIMIT NAHI* *BAS ATTEMPT ATTEMPT ATTEMPT DO* *10 - 15 YEARS TAK AUR 50 - 80 TAK K OLD MAN PAPER DEIN TOH UNKI JOB LAGEGI KYA ???* *IIT IIM PEOPLE GET MORE PACKAGE THAN CA, CMA, CS* *IIT, IIM ONLY TOPPERS GET ADMISSION* *ICAI, ICMAI ICSI ALL SHEEP GOATS* *FOR INTERNSHIP / ARTICLESSHIP YOU HAVE TO GO TO MUMBAI DELHI* *IIM AHMEMDABAD HAS 60 PAPERS AND YOU HAVE TO CLEAR IT IN 2 YEARS* *CA 20 PAPERS AND NO TIME LIMIT TO PASS* *IF IIM, IIT IS INCOMPETENT THEN WHO ARE SUNDAR PICHAI AND RAGHURAM RAJAN*
Salute hai sirji aapko. Bcz aapne jitna detailed me explain kiya hai utna kisine bhi nahi kiya. Even bahit sare CA sir ne bhi direct IIA pe bat ki hai. But aapne ekdum root me jake bat ki hai. Jaise ki IIA ke college etc. Love You Sirji..
it will make difference if IIA helps students to get higher and higher package. if they are able to create strong brand like iit and iim , companies will be willing to pay higher package just for brand name. And intelligent and hardworking students will ultimately go where there is more money. And these intelligent student will be willing to keep on doing hardwork for rest of their college life for getting best package. There were many older engineering colleges in india providing good education before establishing IIT. but now compare to IIT their value is now diluted.
Sir even in medical profession students go to college where entrance is tough but exit is comparatively easy but we can't say that doctors don't study or they don't have practical exposure. When we go to a doctor we always trust their knowledge therefore it can be said that iia professional would be worth nothing.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 doctors are worthy Jo doctors sach m padhte h unki fees poor people afford nhi kr skte because padhne k liye usne time or money dono lagaye h, or jo padhte nhi ya responsible hi nhi h unke hath bohot log maare jaate h
Who said you doctors don't study.. The curriculum of MBBS is designed in such a manner that it's entrance and exit both are tough to crack and they also have practical knowledge because they also do internship..
@@anishsharma6427 that's what my point is doctors who really studied well are really expensive poor or middle class people can never afford them, so they can't have a good doctor and die because they don't have money But situation is exactly different with CA's poor or middle class people don't need CA , only upper class and rich people need them, so for the point achhe doctors hote h wo bhi padhte h ye india m majority of population k liye matter nhi krta because achhe doctors unke liye nhi h, bs bure hi j
Thank you so very much, sir...I was so confused and frightened before seeing this as Every other CA on youtube was also talking kind of in favor of accepting or welcoming IIA or related stuff which was forcing me to think even more such stuff...but now after seeing your video I am relaxed and can focus more on studies. THANK YOU THANK YOU SO VERY MUCH, SIR.
IIA should adopt semester patter rather than attempt pe attempt model followed by ICAI which has ruined lives of many Aspiring CA students. This will automatically breack ICAIs dominance. At the same time it should be given same powers as that of a PCA
Dude, it's probably the best policy because it puts the fear of getting failed and wasting 6 months for the next attempt and CA is a course which requires knowledge and IQ at average level and High discipline and at the end without discipline no one has accomplished anything. I too am a CA inter student and my father is also a Charted Account so I know
@@kunalpokharankar2096 *IIT, IIM mein FAIL HONE PAR RESTIGATE KARTE DETE HAIN* *DON'T MISINTERPRET WORDS* *50 YEARS TAK PAPER DENA AND 60 YEARS MEIN INTERNSHIP AND 70 MEIN PLACEMENT*
> Vaha koi padta nahi hai 100%. Maine engineering me accounting ka optional course liya tha. Bahut boring hai. CA ka kaam karne keliye ek dedicated insaan chahiye.
Exactly I had a frnd from IIM. he studied Finance in last 6months. & he used to ask me for help although then i was just cleared IPCC. CA course is super robust. No other college or course can ace it.
A healthy argument, a tough entrance exam test the work ethics of a person rather than knowledge, moreover there are higher chances that a person who has cleared a tough entrance is likely to gain a good Knowledge over the course? What do you say guys?
I landed randomly on your Channel..... always curious what is CA who can do it.... not only i got answer but loved your confidence man.....u'hv the true temperament of CA..🔥
Arey bhai abhi to pehli baar pata chala hai ki IIA karke kuch ban sakta hai kabhi future mein. Aur tumne aaj hi comparison video bhi daal diya. Dhanya ho
I'm not sure what's going to happen. But we can't challenge the Govt. policy to create these institutions. ICAI must introspect why the Govt. is thinking of such moves.
Bhai m binance P2P merchant hu or m daily 50-60 upi payments krta hu small amount m or isliye mene 8 bank account khole hue h 0 balance k or 1 bank m mera deposit 6 lakh pohoch gya h total bat kru to 8-9 lakh or mene 7000 ko hi bar bar buy sell krke itna balance kra h or profit only 5k h To income tax se notice aayega
First how can one assume that the students wont study much after clearing the entrance exam. In IITs, IIMs, AIIMS, etc students study hard even after clearing the entrance exams.
1 more point Agr ditto same bhi ho Main usme jana prefer krunga jhaan reservation na ho as mere hardwork ko proper reward vahi milega Agr bs ICAI ek baar checking pr transparency le aye It is unbeatable
As a chartered accountant i personally feel the recommendation given to government by the committee is waste of time and i don't know why government is wasting it's resources
Sir i am always support our central government.. so i am Giving very warm welcome to central government in creating new iia.. cpa ... equal to ca ..🕺🕺🕺🕺🕺🕺🕺🕺💃💃💃💃💃💃💃💃jaihind. ..🕺🕺🕺🕺🕺💃💃🕺🙏
IIA aanhi chaiye as IIM Wale within 3 days of Exam , suggested answers release karte hai. Abhi tak Dec 21 ki suggested answers nahi hai to kis basis pe paper check hue ?? ICAI me fair checking nahi hai. Paper checker word to word check karke marks dete hai, Dumb. ICAI ke samne kuch nai bol sakte kyuki wo results withheld kar dete hai Baki articleship kya horaha hai wo sabko pata hi hai. Many more issues as ICAI enjoying Monopoly IIA is Ram for students against RAVAN
one thing we need to understand is, what the market needs. CA course fulfills the need of the market. Government cannot spend billions just to break the monopoly of a course when the course is fulfilling the need.
IIA me smart students honge jo kam age me ache IIA banege IIA vs CA like ghoda and godha Or CA me jo time barbad hota hai uski value crores me hai ek hi baat kam kharcha kam kharcha Usme strategy bilkul sahi hai jo layak nahi hoga sidha or kahi or time lagayga iit karke ias bhi ban jate hai CA nahi bante knowledge jaye bhad me Paisa aana chahiye final balo se pucho jo na ghar ke na ghat kuch to jaldi ban jate hai baki sabki aisi taisi hoti raheti
The biggest challenge with IIA institute will be building a reputation with the industry that its pass outs have the knowledge that is required to compete with CAs. Doing this is no piece of cake and will take decades even if they end up cracking everything perfectly.
True ☺️
What a video now icai expands
Are sir kitnaa pyar se samjha hai aapne...
Dusre faculty are not much concerned about it... Vo to bol rhe hai ki accounting knowledge Or competition badhegi.. India me...
Sir just one question...just like today many corporates ask for first attempt CA or rankholders...what will happen if these corporates start mentioning that only CPA from IIA can apply.Then it will be a huge disparity na Sir ....
Sir IIA will become reputable as IIT and IIM becoz they would be set up by government and it will make a big change in finance education in India . Definitely it would be better then ICAI becoz collage is always better in all aspect if you compare it with any corespondents courses ✅✅✅✅
A man who proposed this bill was definitely CA dropout after multiple attempts😅
*KYA IIT, IIM K KI KOI VALUE NAHI H KYA ???*
*CA STUDENTS DISTANCE EDUCATION S PADAI HOTI HAI*
*KOI TIME LIMIT NAHI*
*KOI AGE LIMIT NAHI*
*BAS ATTEMPT ATTEMPT ATTEMPT DO*
*10 - 15 YEARS TAK AUR 50 - 80 TAK K OLD MAN PAPER DEIN TOH UNKI JOB LAGEGI KYA ???*
*IIT IIM PEOPLE GET MORE PACKAGE THAN CA, CMA, CS*
*IIT, IIM ONLY TOPPERS GET ADMISSION*
*ICAI, ICMAI ICSI ALL SHEEP GOATS*
*THEY ARE BEAURACRATS, THEY RUN THE COUNTRY AND ASSIST PM*
@@anuragtamta6563 Dard Jhalak raha hai pura pura..... 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Haha... Even I thought like that
@@Anonymous-us6je
*I DON'T HAVE ANYTHING TO LOOSE OR GAIN*
*I AM NOT A STAKEHOLDER*
*ICMAI , ICSI ARE IN SUPPORT OF THIS*
We are doing CA, so we not only need to think about this logically but also rationally. Setting up the colleges will come later but before that it could take around 5 to 10 years just for this IIA to set up under the act of parliament.
hi...ye sir taxation intermediate aur final ke liye bhi youtube pe video dalte hai kya?
*KYA IIT, IIM K KI KOI VALUE NAHI H KYA ???*
*CA STUDENTS DISTANCE EDUCATION S PADAI HOTI HAI*
*KOI TIME LIMIT NAHI*
*KOI AGE LIMIT NAHI*
*BAS ATTEMPT ATTEMPT ATTEMPT DO*
*10 - 15 YEARS TAK AUR 50 - 80 TAK K OLD MAN PAPER DEIN TOH UNKI JOB LAGEGI KYA ???*
*IIT IIM PEOPLE GET MORE PACKAGE THAN CA, CMA, CS*
*IIT, IIM ONLY TOPPERS GET ADMISSION*
*ICAI, ICMAI ICSI ALL SHEEP GOATS*
It's not happening. Because it's just a propaganda.
70 years...
Use ye mukam tk phochne me time to lagna hi hai
Lekin seniority CAs ki hi rahegi
The course designing of CA is absolutely full of complexity..
Nothing can compete it
Pure logic, no bullshit- reason why we love Sahil sir! ❤️
Best video till date!!
Well explained sir!!
Really feeling relaxed 😌
One of the reasons why CAs are valued and respected is because it is centralised.Every candidate gets the same question paper (resulting in same difficulty),gets the same environment and appear at the same time for the exams.All the candidates go through the same curriculum.
Unlike engineers (I am from IIT/NIT),MBAs (I am from IIM, XLRI, FMS),Doctors (I am from AIIMS) or lawyers (I am from X,Y,Z law college which is among the top 5/10 law colleges),no CA has to say from where they are (I am not talking about people who are unaware about this course).The tag CA itself is sufficient.
By bringing in IIA, it will dilute the prestige of the course and profession as a whole.
What needs to be done is Council Members should be made more accountable and course should be properly structured like international courses (CFA, CPA, CIMA,FRM, etc.).
Mugging up laws (taxation, companies and economic laws) should be done away with and be replaced by open book real life scenario case studies as if students are not appearing for exams but cracking the case for the clients (give them 4 hours because exam is not a contest for writing speed).Other practical papers should be structured similar way.
Reduce articleship period as apart from top 10 firms,no other firms make students ready for industry or big 4.Articleship for 3 years from small firms are useless. One year is enough and if probably another year of mandatory industrial training.Council members should be grilled as to why they think that 3 years of articleship is necessary.I am sure they won't be able to come up with a concrete answer because let's face the truth,articleship is an excuse to provide cheap labour to CA firms (the partners of which play important role in the administration of ICAI and hence misuse their power to get cheap labour).
Along with ITT and GMCS,career related workshops should be held by ICAI by inviting stalwarts of various fields like Taxation,Finance, etc.
I agree with you but it's cheap labour just for 3 years and that too those which is learning period I met a person who was from a small firm but have knowledge at par of big 4 , he worked hard and ca is all about hard work and agar aap kaho ki practicing ca ko permanent labour cheap p nhi mil skte toh koi bhi practice nhi start kr payega because start m sb firms small hi hoti h, all they can do is improve quality, and bs 3 years ki baat h uske baad you would be in need of those cheap labours, why you are treated yourself as cheap labour when you can be their boss
Article ship definitely should be reduced.. 3 years is very huge
Bruh
@@athribhat2243 what the hell you talking about man first start article ship you felt 3 years is comparatively lower for experience
@@suyashpandey5504 3 years to huge.. Maximum 1-1.5 years enough..
IIA need just one policy to gain student base, "Direct entry to IIA for semi qualified CAs"
True. This can be One option which still mentions that CA is better.
@@Suraj-_-Sood Better toh ofc hai
But fair nhi hai jispe IIA capitalize kr skti hai
@@sushil6509 jo hona hai ho ke rahega. Aaj tak koi ruka hai kya ?? GST , demonitization ye bhi hone do. Result dikj jayega jab ban jayega tum CA pe dhyaan do .
th-cam.com/users/shortscVdIpYMRGjg?feature=share IIA kya hai 😂😂😂 ca meme, ICAI meme
This can be good
Thank you sir ❤
Feeling so relaxed after watching this!
If someone is MBA, Doctor or Engineer then companies are not sure if the person is really knowledge and capable or not. But if someone is CA then there's no concept like aacha CA bura CA, if the person can crack this exam then others are cakewalk!
So why does ranker CA's are offered extremely high packages in MNC's compared to other normal passed out CA's?
Why does articleship firm matters for getting a good job in an MNC?
Stupid comparison, i am myself a CA aspirant, but comparing a Doctor with a CA is the last thing we should be resorting to do
@@karanagarwal9256 mba from top 6 iim is just 2 years. Takes only entrence and interview , 100% gets degree after cracking.
Just by cracking the entrence and getting addmission , the 3.5 lakh CTC guy is now earning 30 lakh CTC .
Yeh iim ne 2 saal me " SKILL" SIKHAYA H KYA?
IIA me bhi yahi hoga , skill will baad me . 1 lakh logo me 1000 baccho me aaoge , top job milegi
@@zeegamesandtech2002 so do you think that the big MNC's are fools to offer the 3.5 lakh guy CTC a package of 30 lakhs?
I'm myself a CA aspirant, and i have some friends from IIM as well..they are way better than us when it comes to interpersonal skills, managerial skills, communication skills.
Everything in this world is not about bookish knowledge
@@karanagarwal9256 i m not saying mnc are fools , they never are.
Just saying that an entrence is sufficient for them to give 30lpa ,soft skills are a plus anyway
Maybe mentally, CA will perform better due to competition threat.
Coaching teachers ki to win-win hai 😂
Kaise kar lete ho sir aap itna ache se analysis. Itni zyada negatively fali hui thi k pucho mat but u solved it. Huge huge fans of urs.😊
By taking homophone of IIT IIM, IIA sounds gimmick. ICAI and MPs being CA should oppose this bill with full force.
Thanks a lot sir for guiding us I was so worried after watching CPA news I thought there is no value of Ca degree other TH-cam channels were also saying it..But now I'm happy that the only thing matters is "Knowledge"..
Sir thank you so much for the video. I've been in CA INTER for 2 years and will give both grps in Nov exam. This news have been eating me from inside. I've come a long way in this course and have gained so much knowledge even after failing 2 times in inter. And am proud to say I'm glad I failed just because I failed I gained the importance on CA course and the importance of having the knowledge in respect of every field. This is my dream, is, was and will be. When this new bill was passed I was so broken. But your video saved me. Thank you so much sir.
Bill is still not passed.. Hope it doesn't pass
No bill has been passed its just a "suggestion " by parliament committee.
@@athribhat2243 aur pass hone mein bhi bohot saal lagenge and sab kuch hone mein bhi 5-6 saal
Padhai karo bhai.. kaha ye sab news me time waste kar rahe ho
@@europenri Padhai toh saab karte hain but aise chizon ka news atta hai na toh focus karna thoda mushkil ho jata hai
This country doesn't have enough medical College for which students are going to country like Ukraine who keeps them as hostage in war but the government is more interested in building IIA than medical College.😔🇮🇳🇮🇳
Koi bhi topic ho, aapka analysis aur explanation itna mast hota hai na sir, ki ek baar me hi samj aa jata hai.
Thank you sir
Sir. I want to learn critical thinking from you. You have always crisp points to communicate.
Agr koi CPA se puchega aap kya kaam karte ho
CPA - MAI CPA HO
UNCLE - WOH KYA HOTA H ?
CPA - CA jaisa hota h 😹😹
CPA is incomplete without CA 😹😹😺😹
Hn bhai 🤣🤣
Op
Just waiting for this video and now relaxed regarding these monopoly issues. Thankyou sir for such videos ❤️❤️.
hi...ye sir taxation intermediate aur final ke liye bhi youtube pe video dalte hai kya?
@@sonupawar3883 only demo videos .
What is he saying ? I can't understand Hindi .. translate in English
Sir sach bata rha hu ye news mili thi or youtubers galat tarike se news spread kar rahe thee or bahut tension ho rhi but muje baishvri se apke video ka wait thaa because aap logic ke sath topic explain karte ho
Ig main problem is reservation. Reservation will be there in IIA's and that's not good. Many of us do professional courses to avoid reservation
😅. You read about reservation first..
Why reservation is given..
Watch reservation by Drishti IAS
@@_PranayW i know but you people also think about the struggle of general
Every genral is not rich
Bhagwan kare ye kabhi na bane iise ca ki value hi kam padegi
Right bro
@@_PranayW sorry sir with all due respect, nowadays more than the deserving candidates reservation is utilised by people who don't even deserve it and on top of it they do it for generations altogether. Our profession is still unstained and shall remain so !
@@_PranayW so there is reservation in alnost every field atleast leave one area wherr people compete based on skill.
Sir maine toh itna hi socha ki CA ki monopoly khatam karni hai, accountancy to khatam nahi hone wali,DT-IDT to khatam nahi hone wali.
Muje to account,tax padhna hai, expert Banna hai
So this in no chance carry a threat to me ❣️
Sir aap best ho❤️👍🏻no one can explain better than u I'm glad that I'm doing my intermediate taxation with You😁
Yes sir. Even for the first institution to come up and give up CPAs, even if they start now it will take 10 years. That's a BIG IF.
Most awaited topic❤️Thanks a lot sir!
Balki ab icai Or improve krega syllabus ko or jyada practical knowledge dene ki kosis krega... Thnk uh sir... Is wjh se boht dara hua tha m ki mere efforts waste to ni ho jaege ca m pr ab apne acche se smjha dia... 😁😁❤
Good evening sir.I am a big fan of ur teaching.Now I am in CA inter but I have taken the classes 2 month ago but in CA final I'll be here ,from ur coating centre 🥰🥰🥰
I think you need to start writing everything in law language, otherwise it's difficult to even clear intermediate.
I am also in intermediate.
All the best.
bestest video watched till dated no any other drama like others simple cut to cut point and the effective one sir hats off to you what an examination
Evolution + Revolution..
Fighting against the govt the technology and now a brand new CPA (mechanical) in itself
yes sir exactly what i was feeling, not being a supremacist but CAs will always be superior over college graduates.. hard work and efforts never go unrecognised and disregarded.
Eren what happened to your surname?😂
@@rudrasah23 look closely.
@@erenneager4820 :')
You just removed my fear for decreasing reputations of CAs after IIAs
Thank you sir😃😃😃
Now i can study without any stress
Icai president ka message dekho sb dar wahi se nikal jayega, koi bhi president apne time p aisa hone nhi dena chahega, or unki eyes m bohot saari baate thi, or wo jo pride h wo bhi or dard bhi
@@maithilisharma8301 kehna kya chahti ho?
@@sasukeuchiha-bp3jp it's an emotional rollercoaster
So, you are studying for reputation & that is your real motivation behind becoming a CA💁🏼♂️👌
What he is saying ? Can you translate in Hindi
Since CA is a correspondence course, the major problem with the students is lack of communication and interpersonal skills. Most of the articles work in small and medium-sized firms, where they seldom get chance to fully apply their skills and knowledge. They have the knowledge, but they don't know how to apply the same. Also, articleship can be skipped by taking a dummy. On the other hand, if we say that IIAs will be like IITs and IIMs, we can expect lush green campus, world class infrastructure and reputed professors from across the globe taking lectures in IIA. In IITs, students work on making drones and electric cars while pursuing their B.Tech degree. In IIMs, students work on real life case studies, projects and assignments and learn from the same. Also students from both IITs and IIMs visit foreign universities as a part of cultural exchange program and get to learn a lot of things. But in CA course, practical exposure can be skipped by taking a dummy articleship or doing articleship in a firm where there's no scope of exposure. Its presumed that IIAs will have all those facilities that IITs and IIMs are having and that'll definitely be an edge over the present CA course. Gone are the days when CAs were hired only for audit and signing Balance sheets. Now corporates need people who are all-rounders. They need solutions to corporate business problems. They need advisors, consultants and experts.
Articled students may opt industrial training in big companies if they wish explore industrial environment. So under CA course there is no bar for getting exposure. And further CA is one of the most prestigious cost effective course. And it's a correspondence nature also, becoz of that a hard working student may pursue the course at his village itself. And In further if Govt need to introduce High quality on accounting profession may start IIA, and admission may be limited to CA/CS/CMA. For them the cost of world class facilities, world famous tutors etc can afford.
Wow.... thanks a lot sir for putting the things in so logical way...CA always rocks 🔥🔥
Your way of explaining is awesome sir. you explain every single thing with so much clarity and always clear all the doubts.
Sir jab pata chala ki CA ke liye yeh college system aaraha hai to main bahut darr gaya tha. I am in class 10th and want to be a CA one day. Thank you for clearing this doubt. I will take classes from you and I will be a CA one day
Superb Logical interpretation on collages topic.
Thank u so much sir I don't comment often under videos but your way of explaining this matter was so good and relaxing, you gave me the confidence I needed desperately, thank you very much sir ❤️❤️
The way u explain just mesmerizing.. Sir i want to take coaching from u but i cant afford ur fees....
How much is it??😅
@@Kajalll1 14k shayad
Correct 14k.
Sir I think the professor in these colleges for the Auditing and Taxation are CAs...
How could it be dear they can be guest lecturer or their tution teacher but for being a professor in college you need PhD
@@maithilisharma8301 please wake up from ur dream world
@@maithilisharma8301 CA's are themselves post graduates and it is not too difficult for them pursue PhD. When one says they are CA's he doesn't mean they don't hold any other qualifications. And there are many post graduate professors in many IIT's and IIM's. Infact most of the professional courses are at post graduate level and not doctorate level. Even simple post graduate from a streetshitter college can probably apply for PhD but as you know completing it properly and having the ability to gain something out of it is altogether a different thing.
@@maithilisharma8301 Is every doctorate degree holder eligible or I should say capable to qualify and become a professor at IIM's, IIT's and your so-called upcoming IIA's ? I would bluntly say NO ! Absolutely not ! When it comes to our core areas mind me CA's, CS's and CMA's will dominate your IIA. Who knows CA students will pursue graduation from IIA and then continue with CA and after that go for PhD at IIA. The only objection I have with IIA's is introduction of reservation and attacking the autonomy of ICAI, ICSI and ICMAI. It's fantastic to hear that Govt. is planning to build world class colleges for commerce students just like they do for law, engineering and medical students. I suggest they should sign an MoU with ICAI and work together to build a fantastic integrated course. One can apply for it right after his 10 th boards and he will pursue his diploma, graduation and post graduation from IIA and post that he will get licence and membership of ICAI. Just imagine this will be an 8 year integrated course and if they adjust 3 year articleship smartly in thier course then it will be a wonderful success story. And yeah high fees is a problem but 8 year is a too long term investment which can be adjusted provided you get such a wonderful ROI and tell me who would not grant loan to a student like you ?
@@madhavbarde9644
*KYA IIT, IIM K KI KOI VALUE NAHI H KYA ???*
*CA STUDENTS DISTANCE EDUCATION S PADAI HOTI HAI*
*KOI TIME LIMIT NAHI*
*KOI AGE LIMIT NAHI*
*BAS ATTEMPT ATTEMPT ATTEMPT DO*
*10 - 15 YEARS TAK AUR 50 - 80 TAK K OLD MAN PAPER DEIN TOH UNKI JOB LAGEGI KYA ???*
*IIT IIM PEOPLE GET MORE PACKAGE THAN CA, CMA, CS*
*IIT, IIM ONLY TOPPERS GET ADMISSION*
*ICAI, ICMAI ICSI ALL SHEEP GOATS*
*FOR INTERNSHIP / ARTICLESSHIP YOU HAVE TO GO TO MUMBAI DELHI*
*IIM AHMEMDABAD HAS 60 PAPERS AND YOU HAVE TO CLEAR IT IN 2 YEARS*
*CA 20 PAPERS AND NO TIME LIMIT TO PASS*
*IF IIM, IIT IS INCOMPETENT THEN WHO ARE SUNDAR PICHAI AND RAGHURAM RAJAN*
A much needed video sir ❤️
Thank you so much for making such a beautiful video with the professional students 👍❤️
Thank you so much sir, sach me bohot anxiety ho rhi thi 😁
Salute hai sirji aapko. Bcz aapne jitna detailed me explain kiya hai utna kisine bhi nahi kiya. Even bahit sare CA sir ne bhi direct IIA pe bat ki hai. But aapne ekdum root me jake bat ki hai. Jaise ki IIA ke college etc. Love You Sirji..
it will make difference if IIA helps students to get higher and higher package. if they are able to create strong brand like iit and iim , companies will be willing to pay higher package just for brand name. And intelligent and hardworking students will ultimately go where there is more money. And these intelligent student will be willing to keep on doing hardwork for rest of their college life for getting best package.
There were many older engineering colleges in india providing good education before establishing IIT. but now compare to IIT their value is now diluted.
but i feel government should open more medical colleges than accounting colleges. we have seen what has happened during covid and ukrain crisis
sabko payta hai college me kitni pdhia hogi
@@parmoksha agreed on this point
IIA must come
I m one of those CA stud who is welcoming IIA..
Arey mastersaaaaab💗
Aapko meri trf sey ek phool🌹
(Bas CA paas aur krna h😅)
Thanks sir . 👍🙏🙏🙏
Ab jakar chain Mila he sir.
Sir even in medical profession students go to college where entrance is tough but exit is comparatively easy but we can't say that doctors don't study or they don't have practical exposure. When we go to a doctor we always trust their knowledge therefore it can be said that iia professional would be worth nothing.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 doctors are worthy
Jo doctors sach m padhte h unki fees poor people afford nhi kr skte because padhne k liye usne time or money dono lagaye h, or jo padhte nhi ya responsible hi nhi h unke hath bohot log maare jaate h
Who said you doctors don't study.. The curriculum of MBBS is designed in such a manner that it's entrance and exit both are tough to crack and they also have practical knowledge because they also do internship..
Exactly,almost all the questions and points could've been applied to any field but reality is far from the truth.
@@anishsharma6427 that's what my point is doctors who really studied well are really expensive poor or middle class people can never afford them, so they can't have a good doctor and die because they don't have money
But situation is exactly different with CA's poor or middle class people don't need CA , only upper class and rich people need them, so for the point achhe doctors hote h wo bhi padhte h ye india m majority of population k liye matter nhi krta because achhe doctors unke liye nhi h, bs bure hi j
That is the main point .
Literally, your explanation is gajab sir😊😊😊😊😊😄
Thank you so very much, sir...I was so confused and frightened before seeing this as Every other CA on youtube was also talking kind of in favor of accepting or welcoming IIA or related stuff which was forcing me to think even more such stuff...but now after seeing your video I am relaxed and can focus more on studies. THANK YOU THANK YOU SO VERY MUCH, SIR.
thank you sir,IIA ki news se bohot Darren tha...aur pashai bhi nahi ho pa rahi thi....thanks for clearing the air....somebody truly a CA
I am really fan of your sir . specially the soft voice with such easy communication . bar bar sun skte apka video
IIA should adopt semester patter rather than attempt pe attempt model followed by ICAI which has ruined lives of many Aspiring CA students. This will automatically breack ICAIs dominance. At the same time it should be given same powers as that of a PCA
Dude, it's probably the best policy because it puts the fear of getting failed and wasting 6 months for the next attempt and CA is a course which requires knowledge and IQ at average level and High discipline and at the end without discipline no one has accomplished anything.
I too am a CA inter student and my father is also a Charted Account so I know
toh kya aise hi pass karade ??
@@kunalpokharankar2096 Tu phate reh puri umar
@@kunalvarshney9927 toh tujhse nahi hota ca toh tu mat kar , tere jaise sab nahi hai .
@@kunalpokharankar2096
*IIT, IIM mein FAIL HONE PAR RESTIGATE KARTE DETE HAIN*
*DON'T MISINTERPRET WORDS*
*50 YEARS TAK PAPER DENA AND 60 YEARS MEIN INTERNSHIP AND 70 MEIN PLACEMENT*
> Vaha koi padta nahi hai
100%. Maine engineering me accounting ka optional course liya tha. Bahut boring hai. CA ka kaam karne keliye ek dedicated insaan chahiye.
Achha lgta hai sir jab to the point baatein hoti hai vedio me
Such a great logic 💡 🔥🔥🔥
You are a legend sir ❤️
Sir apane bohat wait karavaya hain video ke liye ...sorry but please aap videos Jada dala karo na bahut acchi information dete ho aap ❤️
Exactly I had a frnd from IIM. he studied Finance in last 6months. & he used to ask me for help although then i was just cleared IPCC. CA course is super robust. No other college or course can ace it.
Your voice is so calm..words are so wise..I am willing to see your other videos for Nov 22
this is bestest explanation with logic.......finally sukun mila.
A healthy argument, a tough entrance exam test the work ethics of a person rather than knowledge, moreover there are higher chances that a person who has cleared a tough entrance is likely to gain a good Knowledge over the course?
What do you say guys?
Just loved your views sir❤
Now i am relaxed....other teachers were just mugging things up instead of providing solutions .
That's why we choose sir sahil jain as he is full of knowledge and not just a degree holder
I landed randomly on your Channel..... always curious what is CA who can do it.... not only i got answer but loved your confidence man.....u'hv the true temperament of CA..🔥
Arey bhai abhi to pehli baar pata chala hai ki IIA karke kuch ban sakta hai kabhi future mein. Aur tumne aaj hi comparison video bhi daal diya.
Dhanya ho
Edkm correct sir!!
Nd thankyou sir for clearing all the doubts.
😊
The audacity of government to end monopoly 🙌
Thank you sir for making this video Iam in class 12th and was worried about cpa
This videos help me
And my respect for CA increase more
CA is not a degree 🎓 it's a hard work , knowledge and experties of a student. No one can relace it.
I'm not sure what's going to happen. But we can't challenge the Govt. policy to create these institutions. ICAI must introspect why the Govt. is thinking of such moves.
Government ko paisa chaiye aur kuch nahi
Well explaination sir 😊☺️👍👍, thanku so much .
Make a video on how to report inherited gold in ITR filing, if we don’t have purchase receipt
Bhai m binance P2P merchant hu or m daily 50-60 upi payments krta hu small amount m or isliye mene 8 bank account khole hue h 0 balance k or 1 bank m mera deposit 6 lakh pohoch gya h total bat kru to 8-9 lakh or mene 7000 ko hi bar bar buy sell krke itna balance kra h or profit only 5k h
To income tax se notice aayega
Degree ki value khatam nhi hoggi... Haan jo CA ki power hai Audit krne ki, Woh power distribute ho jayegi
Sir thank you very much...
You bought my confidence back...
Now I can prepare for my May exams...
Thank you very much sir❤️😊
Sir this is the most reasonable and relevant reply to IIA doubt.
The best video on this topic sir
Rightly pointed about the tough entrance exams
Most Awaited... Is here!
Sir ek baat Dave ke sath keh sakhte hu ki Agar IIA aya tha toh sab wahi jayenge kyuki unko IIM aur IIT wali tarj milegi
True words, when one got the ample of knowledge why to worry about any thing like that.....😬😬
Thank u so much for giving the sigh of relief, was in so much anxiety since then...Thanks for making it crystal clear...Hanji
Sir , you fetched out all my fears realted to this issue. Thank you so much sir
God promise sir, egarly waiting for this video
First how can one assume that the students wont study much after clearing the entrance exam. In IITs, IIMs, AIIMS, etc students study hard even after clearing the entrance exams.
1 more point
Agr ditto same bhi ho
Main usme jana prefer krunga jhaan reservation na ho as mere hardwork ko proper reward vahi milega
Agr bs ICAI ek baar checking pr transparency le aye
It is unbeatable
A sigh of relief. Thank you sir.🙏💐
As a chartered accountant i personally feel the recommendation given to government by the committee is waste of time and i don't know why government is wasting it's resources
Because they want to destroy ca
As ca feeling really disgusting with this government
Govt loves that job😂
Thank you so much sir for clarification on this point ..
sab teachers ne sirf news batai thi aapne kya analysis bataya hai sir
Sir i am always support our central government.. so i am Giving very warm welcome to central government in creating new iia.. cpa ... equal to ca
..🕺🕺🕺🕺🕺🕺🕺🕺💃💃💃💃💃💃💃💃jaihind.
..🕺🕺🕺🕺🕺💃💃🕺🙏
If we are good in our field why should we worried about changes.
We should be confident of our skills, knowledge.
Tysm sir... For such a thoughtful clarification 💕
Explained with the ease!! All anxiety gone!! Respect sir🙏🏽
Sir you are the best teacher. Now I'm really relaxed.thank you so much sir ❤️❤️
IIA aanhi chaiye as IIM Wale within 3 days of Exam , suggested answers release karte hai. Abhi tak Dec 21 ki suggested answers nahi hai to kis basis pe paper check hue ??
ICAI me fair checking nahi hai.
Paper checker word to word check karke marks dete hai, Dumb.
ICAI ke samne kuch nai bol sakte kyuki wo results withheld kar dete hai
Baki articleship kya horaha hai wo sabko pata hi hai.
Many more issues as ICAI enjoying Monopoly
IIA is Ram for students against RAVAN
Thank you sir❤ Big relief
one thing we need to understand is, what the market needs. CA course fulfills the need of the market. Government cannot spend billions just to break the monopoly of a course when the course is fulfilling the need.
That's our strength 6:51 💪👏🙏 Kay baath Hai.....
IIA me smart students honge jo kam age me ache IIA banege IIA vs CA like ghoda and godha
Or CA me jo time barbad hota hai uski value crores me hai ek hi baat kam kharcha kam kharcha
Usme strategy bilkul sahi hai jo layak nahi hoga sidha or kahi or time lagayga iit karke ias bhi ban jate hai CA nahi bante knowledge jaye bhad me Paisa aana chahiye final balo se pucho jo na ghar ke na ghat kuch to jaldi ban jate hai baki sabki aisi taisi hoti raheti
Sir me CA k barey me sochri thi but jb Yh suna ki IIA Ara h fir Maine socha ah kya hi faida krne ka but thnku sir Yh information Dene k liye
Thank You Sir I Am eagerly waiting for Your video on AAI VS CA 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺