I was a little skeptical when I saw she was singing this song but boy did she prove me wrong. She killed it!! Her raspy voice added so much to the song. Loved it!!
Her voice is like a motorcycle. It doesn't hit the real power until it gets up around the red line. Then it sounds soooo great it gives you goose bumps.
She has such an amazing tone, and after I heard this, I had no doubt that she was AMAZING. When she sang it at her elimination, it was eve better than when she first performed it. She could still keep herself composed for that performance. She is my inspiration, and I often find myself subconsciously trying to sing like her (and failing). :) I love you Hailey! :)
I totally agree with you +IAmGoombaSniper, just loved her live performance on "American Idol", but you really can't find a good high quality version of it on TH-cam, and to boot that, songs on American Idol are cut way too short, so you never get a full version!
IAmGoombaSniper This is very, very good. Still, the live versions seem to have that extra something. I don't know whether it's the crowd reactions we see and hear, or perhaps Haley being fired up that wee bitty more by the crowd response, probably both. I prefer even this version to the versions by Elton John himself and his duets with Lady Gaga and especially the one with Christiana Aguilera which to me sounds shambolic.
@@gynack Her live performances were raw and natural and here it seems to me that producers just put auto-tune on her voice which makes it robotic and takes away her real tone. I personally can’t listen to that studio versions.
@@jupiterk-z1m Something seems to happen,.whether in the actual performances or the mixing room I don't know. I certainly don't trust people who do the mixing. They often seem to have a formulaic approach. A singer like Haley doesn't need anything done to her voice, not even pitch correction. She is that good, as her PMJ performances and other live recordings of her prove. In fact, weren't the Idol live performances done without pitch correction? I never knew of the programme at the time it was on air. I only came to it after initially hearing Haley with PMJ, and then looked up everything else I could about her on TH-cam. I don't know what tricks they might have used. The way Haley was treated on the show, I wouldn't be surprised at very much. The show was dishonest.
@@gynack all live performances on idol were live without any live auto-tune back then. Live autotune became a thing couple of years later. I remember their first or second group performance that season sounding a little weird so I checked it out and it turned out it was prerecorded and obviously autotuned because why not make them sound robotic. All idol studio versions do that and idn why but it’s normal now with all pop music which i don’t get still. That is why when I come back to watch idols performances I always watch live versions. Nowadays I don’t watch idol, the voice or anything like that but I’ve heard that on idol and other singing competitions they use some autotune and even voice doubing live. So people at home can’t hear any imperfections anymore. Not on the radio and not even in the singing COMPETITION. That is crazy.
aah. wow. how can you be this good and not have an international career going on. This girl makes my hair stand on end for all the right reasons. Im a huge Elton fan and I would nt mind betting he loves this version too. Haley, you are adorable and talented beyond words and your fans out here will not forget you or desert you. Come to the UK soon please.
Haley is one of the few artists whose live version of her INSANE voice can be preferred over the studio version. I could listen to her sing live all day, every day.
there is somebody out there with a recording studio who was watching her and saw that she didnt get the trophy in the end. Not the last time youll hear her. Promise. She's going places.
ok but no seriously. she needs to come out with an album ASAP lol im like addicted to all of her covers. im jammin. she was my fav n i wanted her to win..../: lol she could sing the phonebook and it would sound good.
I bought her AI-10 season cd way back then but she has really gotten AMAZING it’s hard to believe being so good then improving. She has a Jazzy Sultry sound. She just knocks it out the park. Love ya Haley.
Hey kids, shake it loose together The spotlight's hitting something That's been known to change the weather We'll kill the fatted calf tonight, so stick around You're gonna hear electric music Solid walls of sound Say, Candy and Ronnie, have you seen them yet? Ooh, but they're so spaced out, B-B-B-Bennie and the Jets Oh but they're weird and they're wonderful Oh Bennie she's really keen She's got electric boots, a mohair suit You know I read it in a magazine, ohh-oh B-B-B-Bennie and the Jets Hey kids, plug into the faithless Maybe they're blinded But Bennie makes them ageless We shall survive, let us take ourselves along Where we fight our parents out in the streets To find who's right and who's wrong Oh Candy and Ronnie, have you seen them yet? Oh but they're…
I gotta say, at first I figured it would end up as Lauren, James, Jacob and Pia in the finals...but after hearing this...well things might change. You're in my top three, Haley. Along with Casey and Paul. ;)
haley's voice iso unique but at the same time it's a cross between christina aguilera with her growl, and mariah carey with her hoarse raspy sound when it kinda has that awesome cracking sound when she shouts!! LOVE ITTTTTT.
This is the first time I find Haley's recorded version pale to her actual live performance. In the past, I loved her recorded version way better than her live performance. I liked her style and voice but I always found her live performance needs work until this round. She really stepped up her live performance standard. If she continues on this trajectory path, she can survive this competition to the end.
There is a possibility that Haley CAN win!! It's going to be difficult but we can do it!! If we all work together it will be easier! Everyone just has to VOTE!!!!
I love Haley!!!!! I voted for her like crazy and she still didn't win :( I hope she goes far in her career, I will definitley buy her albums!!! I hope her future records don't use this much auto-tune though...
SOMEBODY please sign this girl. Her voice is one of a kind and pure in a plastic industry. Just listen to this recording - doesn't it make you feel like you're at the BEST piano bar on earth, listening to this REALLY GREAT vocalist that's also easy on the eyes? Not often you find someone with a voice that distinctive and MATURE these days. In a plastic world of Gaga, Rihanna, Katy Perry, etc. this is SO refreshing! Alas, Jimmy Iovine will likely Gagafier her tho:(
Haley is amazing i hope she gets a record deal and this song should be free on itunes cause i really wanna buy it unless anyone knows any free sites to get the song;) anyways haley is one of my favorites;)
They took her cover off of Spotify and Apple and I’ve been pissed ever since. I freakin love how she sings this song!!!
rs
Me too like wth. I hope they let it back on.
I had a special Walmart CD with this and a couple other studio versions of her idol performances. Wish I kept it cause you can't even find it now
This girl truly was the winner of Idol. Obviously a popularity contest not about the best talent.
She could sing the alphabet for all I care, she's just a joy to listen to! The range of vocal ability is fckin impressive! Love from Estonia.. :)
Since she was a wee ba
I've never seen a singer like her.Her voice is so magic, reminds a mix of Jazz,Soul,R&B and kind of pop music,in other words she's so fuckin' amazing!
I was a little skeptical when I saw she was singing this song but boy did she prove me wrong. She killed it!! Her raspy voice added so much to the song. Loved it!!
I wanted Haley Reinhart to win so bad and she proved to be a fierce competitor I loved her voice and bought her debut album.
I love her! I'll never get tired of her voice.
Easily the best performance of the night. Studio version sounds really good too. She is very underrated, I hope she gets the votes.
my favorite american idol contestant ever!! Haley should have won!
Her voice is so refreshing!
I could listen to that key change all day. It's like opening a window on a breezy afternoon.
wowowow she has a sweet voice! can't stop listening!
Her voice gives me chills! It's so different! LOVE IT!
Her voice is like a motorcycle. It doesn't hit the real power until it gets up around the red line. Then it sounds soooo great it gives you goose bumps.
She has such an amazing tone, and after I heard this, I had no doubt that she was AMAZING. When she sang it at her elimination, it was eve better than when she first performed it. She could still keep herself composed for that performance. She is my inspiration, and I often find myself subconsciously trying to sing like her (and failing). :) I love you Hailey! :)
omg im so inlove with her voice and this song, its amazing!! love her muchoo!!
Haley is without one of the best singers in the world, her voice and her versatility is simply stunning
also Haley you have voice of an ANGEL 🤤, SO GOOD I COULD CRYYY 🥲🥴😍🤩🤯
still lovin' this.. I never knew the original song but I really love her version
I like her live version so much better!
I totally agree with you +IAmGoombaSniper, just loved her live performance on "American Idol", but you really can't find a good high quality version of it on TH-cam, and to boot that, songs on American Idol are cut way too short, so you never get a full version!
IAmGoombaSniper
This is very, very good. Still, the live versions seem to have that extra something. I don't know whether it's the crowd reactions we see and hear, or perhaps Haley being fired up that wee bitty more by the crowd response, probably both. I prefer even this version to the versions by Elton John himself and his duets with Lady Gaga and especially the one with Christiana Aguilera which to me sounds shambolic.
@@gynack Her live performances were raw and natural and here it seems to me that producers just put auto-tune on her voice which makes it robotic and takes away her real tone. I personally can’t listen to that studio versions.
@@jupiterk-z1m
Something seems to happen,.whether in the actual performances or the mixing room I don't know. I certainly don't trust people who do the mixing. They often seem to have a formulaic approach.
A singer like Haley doesn't need anything done to her voice, not even pitch correction. She is that good, as her PMJ performances and other live recordings of her prove. In fact, weren't the Idol live performances done without pitch correction?
I never knew of the programme at the time it was on air. I only came to it after initially hearing Haley with PMJ, and then looked up everything else I could about her on TH-cam. I don't know what tricks they might have used. The way Haley was treated on the show, I wouldn't be surprised at very much. The show was dishonest.
@@gynack all live performances on idol were live without any live auto-tune back then. Live autotune became a thing couple of years later. I remember their first or second group performance that season sounding a little weird so I checked it out and it turned out it was prerecorded and obviously autotuned because why not make them sound robotic. All idol studio versions do that and idn why but it’s normal now with all pop music which i don’t get still. That is why when I come back to watch idols performances I always watch live versions. Nowadays I don’t watch idol, the voice or anything like that but I’ve heard that on idol and other singing competitions they use some autotune and even voice doubing live. So people at home can’t hear any imperfections anymore. Not on the radio and not even in the singing COMPETITION. That is crazy.
I can't get enough of this chic!!!! love her voiceeee!!!!
aah. wow. how can you be this good and not have an international career going on. This girl makes my hair stand on end for all the right reasons. Im a huge Elton fan and I would nt mind betting he loves this version too. Haley, you are adorable and talented beyond words and your fans out here will not forget you or desert you. Come to the UK soon please.
Haley is one of the few artists whose live version of her INSANE voice can be preferred over the studio version. I could listen to her sing live all day, every day.
still my favourite rendition ever, she ate that down.
been listening to this nonstop
I cried when she was voted off....and listening to her now is making me tear up.
I love haley . She is the most bautiful girl and she has an amazing vioce.
there is somebody out there with a recording studio who was watching her and saw that she didnt get the trophy in the end. Not the last time youll hear her. Promise. She's going places.
This girl ROCKS this song....LOVE IT
i cant stop listening to this becuse you have a good voice
i agree...i love her growl...sucks they took it out. Same with the studio version of Rolling in the Deep
I was looking for a cover for this song, SOOOOOOOOOOOO glad I came across this!!!
I love her, I love her voice!
LOVE YOUR VOICE HAILEY!!! I CANT WAIT TO YOU COME OUT WITH A CD!!!!
she's amazing.
Still listening to this song......
love thisss! such a great version!
can't get enough of this song!
amazing 4 REALZ
love this song!!!!!
God!!! her voice is perfection.
Amazing voice!
Love the way she tears this up, growl nice nice nice..
Lovely voice!
I LOVE HALEY REINHART!!!!!!
ok but no seriously. she needs to come out with an album ASAP lol im like addicted to all of her covers. im jammin. she was my fav n i wanted her to win..../: lol she could sing the phonebook and it would sound good.
Cant find this anywhere else but here. Thanks!!
goosebumps every time :) new favorite song
Was amazing in 2011.
It's almost a year later.
Still amazing.
haley you have an AMAZING voice
LOVVEE THIS SONG!!!!!!!!
This is incredible, no doubt.
Could anyone possibly make a karaoke version of this version?
It's amazing :)
She's sounds greattt
I heard this yesterday and I thought it was amazing. I had no idea it was her, I love it!
Wow
I bought her AI-10 season cd way back then but she has really gotten AMAZING it’s hard to believe being so good then improving. She has a Jazzy Sultry sound. She just knocks it out the park. Love ya Haley.
Whoooo! Go Haley! Love this girl man.
Hey kids, shake it loose together
The spotlight's hitting something
That's been known to change the weather
We'll kill the fatted calf tonight, so stick around
You're gonna hear electric music
Solid walls of sound
Say, Candy and Ronnie, have you seen them yet?
Ooh, but they're so spaced out, B-B-B-Bennie and the Jets
Oh but they're weird and they're wonderful
Oh Bennie she's really keen
She's got electric boots, a mohair suit
You know I read it in a magazine, ohh-oh
B-B-B-Bennie and the Jets
Hey kids, plug into the faithless
Maybe they're blinded
But Bennie makes them ageless
We shall survive, let us take ourselves along
Where we fight our parents out in the streets
To find who's right and who's wrong
Oh Candy and Ronnie, have you seen them yet?
Oh but they're…
Yes!!! I LOVE you for putting this on :D you're awesome ^^
i love her voice.
Best version ever !.. =))
I gotta say, at first I figured it would end up as Lauren, James, Jacob and Pia in the finals...but after hearing this...well things might change. You're in my top three, Haley. Along with Casey and Paul. ;)
if you listen to this, and then listen to her live performance, they r pretty much exactly the same which means her voice is perfect how it is :)
great song!
OMFG why did she go home, shes beyond amazing
wonderful
haley's voice iso unique but at the same time it's a cross between christina aguilera with her growl, and mariah carey with her hoarse raspy sound when it kinda has that awesome cracking sound when she shouts!! LOVE ITTTTTT.
Haley your so beautiful, talented and sweet! I hope you make a CD, cause i am totally gonna buy it! =))
VOTE HALEY REINHART INTO THE TOP 3!!!
I love this!
I love her voice
Best performance/singer this season!!!!! Reminds me of Adam.
Goosebumps as big as warts
This clip replay button.
This is the first time I find Haley's recorded version pale to her actual live performance. In the past, I loved her recorded version way better than her live performance. I liked her style and voice but I always found her live performance needs work until this round. She really stepped up her live performance standard. If she continues on this trajectory path, she can survive this competition to the end.
Oh she's amaizing ! i'm a haley's super fan!
Why did they take this off of Apple Music?? This was my favorite song growing up ! I loved how she sang it!
this is her best ever
Everyone who reads this MUST vote for Haley 10-20 times.. That way she won't be in the bottom 3:D.. If ur a true fan u will do it..(: I do.. GO HALEY
Now 😍
Haley and Casey... that's what the top two should've been. :/
There is a possibility that Haley CAN win!! It's going to be difficult but we can do it!! If we all work together it will be easier! Everyone just has to VOTE!!!!
I love Haley!!!!! I voted for her like crazy and she still didn't win :( I hope she goes far in her career, I will definitley buy her albums!!!
I hope her future records don't use this much auto-tune though...
SOMEBODY please sign this girl. Her voice is one of a kind and pure in a plastic industry. Just listen to this recording - doesn't it make you feel like you're at the BEST piano bar on earth, listening to this REALLY GREAT vocalist that's also easy on the eyes? Not often you find someone with a voice that distinctive and MATURE these days. In a plastic world of Gaga, Rihanna, Katy Perry, etc. this is SO refreshing! Alas, Jimmy Iovine will likely Gagafier her tho:(
my ringtone!!
I think Haley is an underdog. Imagine if she won?!? It would be an AMAZING shock to everyone!!! GO HALEY!!!!
Lizzy: huh ?
( Amber singing sexy)
Still such a good version of the song.
Haley is amazing i hope she gets a record deal and this song should be free on itunes cause i really wanna buy it unless anyone knows any free sites to get the song;) anyways haley is one of my favorites;)
live version was even better lol. but studio is awesome too. Live version gave me chills and the urge to listen to it a couple times every day.
i was on the haley train since 'darlin' in millawkie
i miss all the growl that was i the live performance but i still like it!
love haley reinaherttt
I've to admit, Haley's improving by the week...
NICE VERSION !!!!
i love her. i liked her in the AUDITION! before like anyone.
i see haley with a grammy nominated song or album in the next few years
shes pretty much the only reason im watchin the show.
bought this today :)
Haley is awesum!!!! my fav girl by faaaar!!! growwl!! thats wut i like about her :) :)
Ellie Thomas
I cant stop my self from listennig to all of the songs that she sung... Even the Blues one haahaha
@20Gary21 i agree :) now i realized that i'm not alone who noticed that..