Lena Park version - sweet and it feels like someone telling a story of her first love Park bom version - powerful and conveying superiority over the past love and regrets nothing at all because she give it all Iu version- calm and felt she is now ready to finally move on. I love the 3 versions these ladies done, what a great singers they are ❤
What i like about psy is he doesn’t rap too fast or try to make a unique voice. His own voice sounds really chill and he spells every word clearly. I can easily sing/rap his part without knowing too much korean. Sth some rappers try to hard to read everything fast or try to make a unique voice/flow that can be quiet/very hard for me and for anyone who doesn’t know/know a little bit of korean to catch on and to hear what they were rapping.
What a great collab, PSY's doing a rap part while IU's singing an angelic yet smooth R&B voice... I hope they will have a recorded version of that song...😍😍😍😍
@@mcbrynofficial8320 So sya pa nga walang original amp,, Sample tawag dun, marami naring gumagawa ng ganung kanta kagaya sa Mulawin Vs Revena,, and then eto pa yung gumawa Ng kanta, sample Lang tawag dun,, th-cam.com/video/HeK1zQFJtXE/w-d-xo.html
내가 그때 널 잡았더라면 너와 나 지금보다 행복했을까 마지막에 널 안아줬다면 어땠을까 나의 옛사랑 옛사람 가끔 난 너의 안부를 속으로 묻는다 그리고는 혼자 씩 웃는다 희미해진 그때의 기억을 빈 잔에 붓는다 잔이 차고 넘친다 기억을 마신다 그 기억은 쓰지만 맛있다 그 시절 우리의 도수는 거의 웬만한 독주보다 높았어 보고 또 봐도 보고팠어 사랑을 해도 해도 서로에게 고팠어 목말랐어 참 우리 좋았었는데 헤어질 일이 없었는데 왜 그랬을까 그땐 사랑이 뭔지 몰라서 사랑이 사랑인줄 몰랐어 혼자서 그려본다 헤어지지 않았더라면 어땠을까 (내가 그때 널) 어땠을까 (잡았더라면) 어땠을까 (너와 나 지금보다 행복했을까) 어땠을까 (마지막에 널) 어땠을까 (안아줬다면) 어땠을까 (너와 나 지금까지 함께 했을까) 둘이 같이 꼴딱 밤새 맞이한 아침 홀딱 잠 깨 창문을 닫지 우리는 마치 창 밖의 참새처럼 잠들기 싫어하는 애처럼 초등학생처럼 아무도 없는데 아무도 모르게 아무도 못 듣게 귓속에 말을 해 그 시절 우리의 온도는 거의 저 밑에 적도 보다 높았어 성났어 감기도 아닌 것이 열났어 온몸의 어디든 귀를 갖다 대면은 맥박소리가 귓가에 그날의 너의 소리가 왜 그랬을까 그땐 사랑이 뭔지 몰라서 사랑이 사랑인 줄 몰랐어 혼자서 그려본다 헤어지지 않았더라면 어땠을까 (내가 그때 널) 어땠을까 (잡았더라면) 어땠을까 (너와 나 지금보다 행복했을까) 어땠을까 (마지막에 널) 어땠을까 (안아줬다면) 어땠을까 (너와 나 지금까지 함께 했을까) 눈앞에서 살진 않지만 눈감으면 살고 있다 다른 사람 품 안에서 같은 추억 하면서 내 곁에 있진 않지만 내 몸이 기억하고 있다 다른 사람 품 안에서 같은 추억 하면서 왜 그랬을까 그땐 사랑이 뭔지 몰라서 사랑이 사랑인 줄 몰랐어 혼자서 그려본다 헤어지지 않았더라면 어땠을까 (내가 그때 널) 어땠을까 (잡았더라면) 어땠을까 (너와 나 지금보다 행복했을까) 어땠을까 (마지막에 널) 어땠을까 (안아줬다면) 어땠을까 (너와 나 지금까지 함께 했을까)
I draw you out by myself --> I try to imgine what it would've been like '그려본다' has indeed as the first meaning 'to draw' but here it means 'to imagine, to picture'. Thanks for the beautiful video!
MinKyunghoon X IU collab please. You know Kyunghoon is good at duets like he'll definitely adjust and make the song really beautiful more than your expectations.
English lyrics: Back then if I... I held onto you Would we have been happier than right now? On the last day (If I hugged you) What would it have been like?
My past love, my past person Sometimes, I ask how you’re doing to myself Then I smile by myself. I pour out the faded memories of back then in this empty glass. The glass fills and overflows. Drink my memories. Those memories are bitter but delicious.
We were stronger than most strong liquors back then Even after seeing you and seeing you, I missed you. Even after loving you and loving you, we were hungry for each other I was thirsty We were so good, there was no reason for us to break up
Why did we do that? We didn’t know love back then. We didn’t know that love was love. I draw you out by myself If only we didn’t break up What would it have been like (back then if) What would it have been like (I held onto you) What would it have been like (would we have been happier than right now) What would it have been like (on the last day) What would it have been like (if I hugged you) What would it have been like (would we have been together till now?)
The morning after we stayed up all night I jolted awake and closed the window As if we were the birds out the window. Children who don’t want to go to sleep, like elementary students. Even though no one was there, we whispered to each other without anyone knowing So no one can hear us
Back then, our temperature was hotter than the equator down below. We got angry, we burned up even though it wasn’t a cold. If I place my ears on any part of your body, I hear your pulse I still hear your sound of that day
Why did we do that? We didn’t know love back then. We didn’t know that love was love. I draw you out by myself If only we didn’t break up What would it have been like (back then if) What would it have been like (I held onto you) What would it have been like (would we have been happier than right now?) What would it have been like (on the last day) What would it have been like (if I hugged you) What would it have been like (would we have been together till now?)
You don’t live before my eyes, but You live when I close them. In another person’s arms, Thinking the same memories. You’re not by my side, but My body remembers you. In another person’s arms, Thinking the same memories.
What would it have been like? We didn’t know love back then. We didn’t know that love was love. I draw you out by myself If only we didn’t break up What would it have been like (back then if) What would it have been like (I held onto you) What would it have been like (would we have been happier than right now) What would it have been like (on the last day) What would it have been like (if I hugged you) What would it have been like (would we have been together till now?
I love this one! No one does duets as well as IU. Also check out her sweet singing with Jang Pil Soon from 2014, "When My Loneliness Calls Out" Many years later they met up again on Hyori's Bed and Breakfast show. Listen to IU with Kim Chang-Wan singing 'Meaning Of You". She really has done a lot of great duets, someone should make a compilation video of them all.
damn both are amazing singer. I just found it from Fantastic Duo when i marathon all video on youtube. Its feel great. I love PSY voice since im a man. IU voice make my heart glowing with love 😂
Ahahhha... I knew it ahahha same sa tono Yung kanta ni skusta clee hahahah... First ko pa narinig kanta ni skusta ito agad nasa isip ko ahahha. Itong kanta na to...ahahha
Sample Lang ho tawag dun, marami narin gumagawa ng ganyang kanta, meron din sa GMA, and then sample Lang talaga tawag dun, Guitar kase ginagamit sa paggawa Ng beat and flow kaya maraming magkakatono na ganun,, pakinggan mo maigi,, yung sa Lagi,, sample Lang tawag dun,, tulad Neto,, Hahanapan nyo pa ng butas si Skusta Clee para mag Ka issue th-cam.com/video/HeK1zQFJtXE/w-d-xo.html
@@sonnyy4807 di ko Naman hinahanapan ng butas si skusta. Sinabi ko lang Naman na Yung first time ko narinig Yung kanta ni skusta, ito agad nasa isip ko. Yun lang po.
Marami nang gumagawa ng ganyang kanta buddy,, sample Lang tawag dun, pakinggan mo maigi,, hahanapan nyu pa Ng butas si Skusta Clee para mag ka issue,, th-cam.com/video/HeK1zQFJtXE/w-d-xo.html
![PSY & IU (싸이 & 아이유) 'WHAT WOULD HAVE BEEN' (어땠을까) [Color Coded Lyrics Eng/Rom/Han/가사]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xbTKZ8IlqLY/mqdefault.jpg)
박정현 버전 : 그래 잘 헤어졌다 라고 말로는 하지만 마음속은 힘들때
아이유 버전 : 헤어지고 난 바로 뒤 마음이 무너질것 같을때
ㅇㅈ..
진짜그래요요세매일들어요봄타는건지윈지외로위요..
박정현: 그랬었지..ㅠㅠ ( 드링크 )
아이유: 왜…도대체 왜!!… ( 눈물 )
@@Goati-h3d 나중에 보면 흑역사
@@三島えりかㄹㅇㅋㄱㅋㄱㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㅋㄱㅋㄱㄱ
Lena Park version - sweet and it feels like someone telling a story of her first love
Park bom version - powerful and conveying superiority over the past love and regrets nothing at all because she give it all
Iu version- calm and felt she is now ready to finally move on.
I love the 3 versions these ladies done, what a great singers they are ❤
Apink's version is also good
@@teteikholhringkholhring9361 yes, the harmonization is undeniably good, they complimented each others voice.
true
여름밤에 산책하면서 듣기에 너무 편안한 노래 ㅠㅠ!!
싸이 특유의 흥이 너무 좋아요 ㅠㅠ
개인적으로
박정현은 그땐 그랬었지~ 하면서 밝은 느낌이면
아이유는 그때 왜 그랬었지 하는 아쉬움이 많이 느껴지는거 같음
박정현은 밝고 경쾌한 느낌이고
아이유는 절절이 아쉬움이 느껴지는 느낌
박정현이 못한다는건 아니고 아이유가 나한테는 더 듣기 좋은거 같음
상황이 다르게 생각됌
ㄴㄷ
싸이 특유의 가사에 넣는 라임들 너무좋다
this is so underrated this song deserves to get hyped
Nurul Hanisah Abdul Hamid true❤️❤️❤️
Udah liat apink cover blm?
Have you watch apink cover for this song?
m.th-cam.com/video/kEM82Sbay6U/w-d-xo.html
What i like about psy is he doesn’t rap too fast or try to make a unique voice. His own voice sounds really chill and he spells every word clearly. I can easily sing/rap his part without knowing too much korean. Sth some rappers try to hard to read everything fast or try to make a unique voice/flow that can be quiet/very hard for me and for anyone who doesn’t know/know a little bit of korean to catch on and to hear what they were rapping.
What a great collab, PSY's doing a rap part while IU's singing an angelic yet smooth R&B voice... I hope they will have a recorded version of that song...😍😍😍😍
Her voice. ❤
You mean IU? Yah she's my favorite singer too!
Her voice is very good
Soothing. Angelic. Soulful. Can’t get enough of her songs. 🥰
i cannot get over at this song when I heard it randomly. it is such amazing
IU and PSY is a Good combination❤
Queen of Collab IU!!!!!! 😍
🇰🇷Haelyo is so enriching - so glad I came across this song. Both IU and PSY are amazing artists.
Why does this song makes me feel so inlove, but also breaks my heart at the same time? ❤️💔
*the magic of psy and iu*
I got a goosebump when IU sang the high note btw it's a beautiful song
IU voice is so amazing
The melody is so... Ugh! She's really sounds Nina of Philippines ❤️ I'm glad I bumped to this amazing song! Love from PH 🇵🇭❤️
Why do I have this feeling that I'm listening to angels voice ?
Iu 💜💜
아이유: 엄청 깔끔함 듣기 매우 편함.
박정현: 애잔 혹은 노련하고 더욱 감정이입됨.
정반대 아님?
인정ㅋㅋㅋ
오 나도 이 의견이랑 같은 생각인데,, 다들 반대로 생각하시는구나 아이유는 산뜻하고 깔끔한 느낌이있어서 애잔함이 안느껴지는건 아니지만 아무래도 노련함에서는 박정현 목소리에서 도 우러나는 것 같은뎅,,
지금들어도 ㅈㄴ좋다.
"basta ngumiti ka lang pa lagi lagi lagi oh lagi ngumiti ka lang sakin akin akin" yawaaaaa bat yun naririnig ko
Dito pla ginaya ni skusta clee bago nyang kanta haha
Wala talagang originality yun 🤦♂️
@@mcbrynofficial8320 So sya pa nga walang original amp,, Sample tawag dun, marami naring gumagawa ng ganung kanta kagaya sa Mulawin Vs Revena,, and then eto pa yung gumawa Ng kanta, sample Lang tawag dun,, th-cam.com/video/HeK1zQFJtXE/w-d-xo.html
@@sonnyy4807 no this is the 3rd time he did it lol stop defending that problematic ass shit
@@sjsksjsjsjjsksjsjsksk4962 hahajaja true magkaiba ang sampling sa panggagagaya hahahahahaha
아이유는 많은 아티스트들이랑 작업을 했는데 특히 yg소속사 분들이랑 많이 작업했네
ㄹㅇ 전설들의 만남이다...
내가 그때 널
잡았더라면
너와 나 지금보다 행복했을까
마지막에 널
안아줬다면
어땠을까
나의 옛사랑 옛사람
가끔 난 너의 안부를 속으로 묻는다
그리고는 혼자 씩 웃는다
희미해진 그때의 기억을 빈 잔에 붓는다
잔이 차고 넘친다
기억을 마신다
그 기억은 쓰지만 맛있다
그 시절 우리의 도수는 거의 웬만한 독주보다 높았어
보고 또 봐도 보고팠어
사랑을 해도 해도 서로에게 고팠어
목말랐어
참 우리 좋았었는데 헤어질 일이 없었는데
왜 그랬을까 그땐 사랑이 뭔지 몰라서
사랑이 사랑인줄 몰랐어
혼자서 그려본다
헤어지지 않았더라면
어땠을까 (내가 그때 널)
어땠을까 (잡았더라면)
어땠을까 (너와 나 지금보다 행복했을까)
어땠을까 (마지막에 널)
어땠을까 (안아줬다면)
어땠을까 (너와 나 지금까지 함께 했을까)
둘이 같이 꼴딱 밤새 맞이한 아침
홀딱 잠 깨 창문을 닫지
우리는 마치 창 밖의 참새처럼
잠들기 싫어하는 애처럼 초등학생처럼
아무도 없는데 아무도 모르게 아무도 못 듣게 귓속에 말을 해
그 시절 우리의 온도는 거의 저 밑에 적도 보다 높았어
성났어 감기도 아닌 것이 열났어
온몸의 어디든 귀를 갖다 대면은 맥박소리가
귓가에 그날의 너의 소리가
왜 그랬을까 그땐 사랑이 뭔지 몰라서
사랑이 사랑인 줄 몰랐어
혼자서 그려본다
헤어지지 않았더라면
어땠을까 (내가 그때 널)
어땠을까 (잡았더라면)
어땠을까 (너와 나 지금보다 행복했을까)
어땠을까 (마지막에 널)
어땠을까 (안아줬다면)
어땠을까 (너와 나 지금까지 함께 했을까)
눈앞에서 살진 않지만
눈감으면 살고 있다
다른 사람 품 안에서
같은 추억 하면서
내 곁에 있진 않지만
내 몸이 기억하고 있다
다른 사람 품 안에서
같은 추억 하면서
왜 그랬을까 그땐 사랑이 뭔지 몰라서
사랑이 사랑인 줄 몰랐어
혼자서 그려본다
헤어지지 않았더라면
어땠을까 (내가 그때 널)
어땠을까 (잡았더라면)
어땠을까 (너와 나 지금보다 행복했을까)
어땠을까 (마지막에 널)
어땠을까 (안아줬다면)
어땠을까 (너와 나 지금까지 함께 했을까)
I draw you out by myself --> I try to imgine what it would've been like
'그려본다' has indeed as the first meaning 'to draw' but here it means 'to imagine, to picture'. Thanks for the beautiful video!
wow..awesome collaboration by PSY and IU!!!!
more please
I just heard this song in Facebook yesterday, this song is so pretty 😍
The lyric hits my heart
0:59 2:15 아이유 나오는 부분❤
+2:10 맥박소리💞
I thought I'm already fine, but after listening to this song ... arghhhh demn! 😢
Be strong!
Stay strong and keep going!
So relaxing., i love also psy and park bom version.,
IU's voice really matched with this kind of song
MinKyunghoon X IU collab please. You know Kyunghoon is good at duets like he'll definitely adjust and make the song really beautiful more than your expectations.
잘지내니? 너도 이노래 꼭 들었음 좋겠다...
I was surprised to see IU here because Lena Park is also one of my favorites and I learn she be featured here :D
This version makes me chill 💕
..왜 그랬을까 부터가 ..할말이 없다..
Imagine this song being covered by GD and Dara unnie 😻
When you alone listen this song vere nice song
IU and PSY💜💜💜💜
My jieunie is so amazing shes a living legend😍😍😍😍
Amazing lyrics. This song saved me after my breakup.. ❤❤
IU😍❤️
아이유 음색 너무좋다....
*Heroes flashback of IU interviewing Psy*
어땠을까♡♡♡잘지내요 아프지말고
Parang same beat ng new song ni Skusta na "Lagi"
Ahhaa yah... Ito agad na isip ko hahaha sa kanta ni skusta
PAPANO MAGIGING SAME EH PURO NAKAW BEAT YANG BASURA NA SKUSTASHT FEELING RAPPER NG PINAS
Loveyou IU
하루종일 공부하고 학원차타고 집갈때 듣는너래ㅐ...😍😍
이거 2학년때 많이 들었는데 엉엉 오늘 엄ㅁ마랑 차에서 라디오 틀다가 나와서 보러와ㅛ단 ..
2:10 맥박소리 들으러 왔슴다
Thank you Disguised Toast for telling me about this masterpiece ❤
노래가 조타..
좋다
크으 역시 싸이노래는 다좋아
Thank you so much for the romanization!!! 💖💖💖
첫사랑 생각나는 노래..
Fallin love for this version💕💕 damn such a blessfull song😭😭😭
I like the version that sang with Park Bom
i like this too but Bom gave justice in this song.
아이유 애절하고 진짜 아쉬워하는 것 같아서 ㅠㅠ
2:09 귀르가즘...
목소리 좋타❤
this should be in a main album for real..
I prefer this version
English lyrics:
Back then if I...
I held onto you
Would we have been happier than right now?
On the last day
(If I hugged you)
What would it have been like?
My past love, my past person
Sometimes, I ask how you’re doing to myself
Then I smile by myself.
I pour out the faded memories of back then in this empty glass.
The glass fills and overflows.
Drink my memories.
Those memories are bitter but delicious.
We were stronger than most strong liquors back then
Even after seeing you and seeing you, I missed you.
Even after loving you and loving you, we were hungry for each other
I was thirsty
We were so good, there was no reason for us to break up
Why did we do that? We didn’t know love back then.
We didn’t know that love was love.
I draw you out by myself
If only we didn’t break up
What would it have been like (back then if)
What would it have been like (I held onto you)
What would it have been like (would we have been happier than right now)
What would it have been like (on the last day)
What would it have been like (if I hugged you)
What would it have been like (would we have been together till now?)
The morning after we stayed up all night
I jolted awake and closed the window
As if we were the birds out the window.
Children who don’t want to go to sleep, like elementary students.
Even though no one was there, we whispered to each other without anyone knowing
So no one can hear us
Back then, our temperature was hotter than the equator down below.
We got angry, we burned up even though it wasn’t a cold.
If I place my ears on any part of your body, I hear your pulse
I still hear your sound of that day
Why did we do that? We didn’t know love back then.
We didn’t know that love was love.
I draw you out by myself
If only we didn’t break up
What would it have been like (back then if)
What would it have been like (I held onto you)
What would it have been like (would we have been happier than right now?)
What would it have been like (on the last day)
What would it have been like (if I hugged you)
What would it have been like (would we have been together till now?)
You don’t live before my eyes, but
You live when I close them.
In another person’s arms,
Thinking the same memories.
You’re not by my side, but
My body remembers you.
In another person’s arms,
Thinking the same memories.
What would it have been like?
We didn’t know love back then.
We didn’t know that love was love.
I draw you out by myself
If only we didn’t break up
What would it have been like (back then if)
What would it have been like (I held onto you)
What would it have been like (would we have been happier than right now)
What would it have been like (on the last day)
What would it have been like (if I hugged you)
What would it have been like (would we have been together till now?
This song is so CUTE I cannot
이 노래도 좋지만 개인적으로 원곡이 남자 목소리랑 여자 목소리가 나이가 비슷한거같아서 더 좋게 느껴지는거같음
ㅃ
원곡을 뛰어넘는건 힘들제 ㅋㅋㅋ
아닌데 이 둘의 노래가 더 감성적이고 더 마음이 촉촉하게 젖는 명곡인데
@@황성빈-t2n 아님 이노래가 더 좋음
이 버전의 둘의 노래가 레전드 재해석이 멋진곡
i
love
this
why didnt i find this earlier
Same 😍
이 노래 딱 내 스타일
I love this one! No one does duets as well as IU. Also check out her sweet singing with Jang Pil Soon from 2014, "When My Loneliness Calls Out" Many years later they met up again on Hyori's Bed and Breakfast show. Listen to IU with Kim Chang-Wan singing 'Meaning Of You". She really has done a lot of great duets, someone should make a compilation video of them all.
Russ Online love IU
It's like kdrama theme song 😍
That sounds great
다시들어도 좋네..이노랜
damn both are amazing singer. I just found it from Fantastic Duo when i marathon all video on youtube. Its feel great. I love PSY voice since im a man. IU voice make my heart glowing with love 😂
Who's here to cry? 😢
Missing...
Another song of psy i really like it ..... damn with iu
I love the one with bom
싸이is뭔들
역시 아이유누나
It's amazing. Good
방구탄
love IU
I'm here because of *Apink*
Apink version is in my heart... 💖
amazing song ....
So amazing!!!
PSYU 너므좋아ㅜㅜ
진짜 아이유 음색 쥑여ㅠㅠ
If not because of fantastic duo. Very good duet 👌🏻
IU😍😍😍
Ahahhha... I knew it ahahha same sa tono Yung kanta ni skusta clee hahahah... First ko pa narinig kanta ni skusta ito agad nasa isip ko ahahha. Itong kanta na to...ahahha
Sample Lang ho tawag dun, marami narin gumagawa ng ganyang kanta, meron din sa GMA, and then sample Lang talaga tawag dun, Guitar kase ginagamit sa paggawa Ng beat and flow kaya maraming magkakatono na ganun,, pakinggan mo maigi,, yung sa Lagi,, sample Lang tawag dun,, tulad Neto,, Hahanapan nyo pa ng butas si Skusta Clee para mag Ka issue
th-cam.com/video/HeK1zQFJtXE/w-d-xo.html
@@sonnyy4807 di ko Naman hinahanapan ng butas si skusta. Sinabi ko lang Naman na Yung first time ko narinig Yung kanta ni skusta, ito agad nasa isip ko. Yun lang po.
아이유언니꺄!~~♡
Very very good!!!
3:50 너와나 지금까지 행..께했을까
아이유..드물게 이쁜미모와 가창력중 서로 묻히지 않음
The best ❤️
Skusta Clee is using the music same guitar strokes. Same. 🥺
안 잡아줘서 고맙죠
잡으면 2020년도에
코로나19 심각 할 때
엄청 싸우고 헤어지고
그려겠죠?😢😢😢
하늘이 도와 주셨죠
언제나 꼭 만날 운명같아요
Her voice is really truly an angel 🥰❤️
싸이님은멋있고아이유님은예뻐용~~
Ito pla yung pinag gayahan ni skusta clee ng bago nyang kanta.
Marami nang gumagawa ng ganyang kanta buddy,, sample Lang tawag dun, pakinggan mo maigi,, hahanapan nyu pa Ng butas si Skusta Clee para mag ka issue,,
th-cam.com/video/HeK1zQFJtXE/w-d-xo.html
NAKAW BEAT SKUSTASHT BASURA FEELING RAPPER NG PINAS