CNA keep these programs coming and post them on TH-cam. The collective western media will never do programs like this especially of Chinese being unjustly deported, given the current narrative pushed by Washington and the West.
How can you call them unjustly deported? They were illegal immigrants! If you like illegal immigrants so much, why don't you put them up in your back gardens?
Mercia definitely didn’t die from malaria. While it was a contributor to her death, she died from the heartbreak of being forcefully separated from her husband
Why would he search eBay though? Did family/relatives of these deported seamen decide to sell their ID logbooks as "memento" or "souvenir"? That's just sad... Or desperation
For those unfamiliar with the White Australia Policy, the method they used to deny people of non European background was to give them a dictation test. Coming to an English speaking country you would assume the test would be given in English. Wrong assumption. It could be given in any European language. There was a case of a polygot who spoke 11 languages. They gave him the test on Gaelic to make sure he would fail.
Nan Young might not have been his real name. Nanyang means South Seas in Chinese. That's the region where a lot of the ancestors of today's 2nd-4th generation overseas born Chinese came from.
@@BradleyHewlettChina doesn’t have a history of global colonialism so not that many. But China is probably way more diverse than you actually know or think. Plus recently there’s been a lot of Africans and some from middle eastern countries like Pakistan going there, so the answer to your comment is still a lot more than your racist rhetorical question
@derek7762 the Han chinese invaded their neighbour's to create modern China, remember that kublai khan guy? And what about Tibet or the Uighers? Don't try you CCP propaganda on me wumao
it is pointless to find out the so-call "why"...and the pain...regardless of country...as long as there are politicians...this will continue to happen...
I disagree with your comment 'pointless' to find out why! It reflects how the Chinese were 'used' by the Brits and the Aussies during the 2nd WW. I suppose an anology of a used condom. Useful at the time but when finished gets tossed away. Since the 2019 fits in HK, accordinging to the British statistics, close to a million HK Chinese BNOers 'moved' to the UK under the Tory. Now with Labour in power and the UK collapsing the 5+1 looks somewhat on shady grounds.
No, not at all. The praxtice of discrimination of the Chinese still exist today all over the 'Western' world. That's one of the reason for the West's Stop-the-rise-of-China action today. But it will not succeed. Power to the Chinese!
There was an asian girl in our youth club in Bath I knew back in the early 1960's . I had thought that probably her father was white and mother form Asia perhaps Hong Kong but it could have been the other way around . Bristol wasonly 12 miles away and that was a busy port before and during the war .
I don't believe she had a choice. I remember hearing about her story prior to this watching this video. Because the children were not her current husband's children she was not allowed to take them with her by the government. Her Australian citizenship was also stripped from her.
@@margi9103 yeah, I just watched the part of the doc that looks at that story. What you say makes sense, especially when we know that in the other case of the documentary, citizenship was stripped from the women who married and they were classed as aliens. I highly doubt that the Australian government would let an “alien” leave the country with Australian children, especially if those children were white.
Because you are looking at the situation from today’s standards and norms. You are ignorant to tge norms or now not matching the norms of then, what else was she to do?
Doesn’t seem to be working as Australia has an East Asian population of almost 20%. No East Asian country has a Caucasian population anywhere near that
I assume the Chinese were seen as undesirable ghastly looking things compared to the fine chiselled features of the handsome Jamaican and the princely aromatic exotic Indian men.
@BarnzTT my point being why are western country's constantly being labeled racist when they have more racial diversity than every other country on the planet? On a side note China isn't doing as great as you may think
The Chinese population in Singapore 🇸🇬 is a *big problem* for Singaporean national security when they - connect with the authoritarian expansionist regime in China and - subscribe to their version of world views.
You have no understanding of consent issues. No-one, including groups if people, have to have others whom they don't want. You sound like a rapist, or a traitor. You should be prosecuted for treachery!
The program is disgusting and stirs things up for a sensitive topic in UK! The key question that is not answered in the program is whether they were illegal to be in UK in the 1st place! They seem to be illegal immigrants and deportation is an understanding and sad conclusion.
But if these people has helped the British war effort one would think it's reasonable to stay. Look what the weather did in Iraq and Afghanistan. Use locals as interpreters etc then abandon them when they leave only to be killed or locked up
@@jw-vx8im Given the right to stay in Britain is neither a right nor reasonable for them. It is through grace and favor. Another wokist UK-bashing piece. They were illegal immigrants! Had they been illegal immigrants in Singapore now, they would have been deported too!
@@jw-vx8im The Iraqi and Afghan locals ..... different story. They are in their homeland but if they had a risk of being killed by Islamic a-h0les, then they can apply to be refugees.
CNA keep these programs coming and post them on TH-cam. The collective western media will never do programs like this especially of Chinese being unjustly deported, given the current narrative pushed by Washington and the West.
How can you call them unjustly deported? They were illegal immigrants! If you like illegal immigrants so much, why don't you put them up in your back gardens?
same for the deportation of the Chagossians by the Brits for a u.s military base.
Western never do this n that, eughh, they did it so many, ure just ignorantly projecting
They'll try to brag to everybody about their human rights aka essentially their white right not your right. 😁😁
😂hypocrite
Thank you, CNA Insider for the precious knowledge.
Mercia definitely didn’t die from malaria. While it was a contributor to her death, she died from the heartbreak of being forcefully separated from her husband
jesus christ, the guy searched ebays for identification logs, and tracked it down?!?!
what a mad man
respect
Why would he search eBay though? Did family/relatives of these deported seamen decide to sell their ID logbooks as "memento" or "souvenir"? That's just sad... Or desperation
For those unfamiliar with the White Australia Policy, the method they used to deny people of non European background was to give them a dictation test. Coming to an English speaking country you would assume the test would be given in English. Wrong assumption. It could be given in any European language. There was a case of a polygot who spoke 11 languages. They gave him the test on Gaelic to make sure he would fail.
Who came up with that idea though, certainly another polyglot.
proof?
SIMILAR IN VOTING RIGHTS FOR AFRICAN AMERICANS
@@abfab2517It's in the immigration restriction Act 1901.
😢
Thank you for making this preview. I am going to watch the full documentry and forward it to my friends.
Amazing on the investigations.
I noticed a few Senior aged Chinese mixed people in Liverpool.
Nan Young might not have been his real name. Nanyang means South Seas in Chinese. That's the region where a lot of the ancestors of today's 2nd-4th generation overseas born Chinese came from.
That region is what's known today as Southeast Asia
Once a colonizer, always a colonizer.
Never knew Such thing happening.
I'm Chinese, never had a good impression of aglo-saxons as a whole people😊
How many white or black citizens does China have?
That is why China is where it is right now.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@BradleyHewlettChina doesn’t have a history of global colonialism so not that many. But China is probably way more diverse than you actually know or think. Plus recently there’s been a lot of Africans and some from middle eastern countries like Pakistan going there, so the answer to your comment is still a lot more than your racist rhetorical question
@derek7762 the Han chinese invaded their neighbour's to create modern China, remember that kublai khan guy? And what about Tibet or the Uighers? Don't try you CCP propaganda on me wumao
@derek7762 none of those Aficans or Pakistanis have citizenship
Wow, that sounds like a really interesting project! What kind of stories did they uncover?
th-cam.com/video/32UMEb8yCWY/w-d-xo.html
it is pointless to find out the so-call "why"...and the pain...regardless of country...as long as there are
politicians...this will continue to happen...
I disagree with your comment 'pointless' to find out why! It reflects how the Chinese were 'used' by the Brits and the Aussies during the 2nd WW. I suppose an anology of a used condom. Useful at the time but when finished gets tossed away. Since the 2019 fits in HK, accordinging to the British statistics, close to a million HK Chinese BNOers 'moved' to the UK under the Tory. Now with Labour in power and the UK collapsing the 5+1 looks somewhat on shady grounds.
Are we surprised?
No, not at all. The praxtice of discrimination of the Chinese still exist today all over the 'Western' world. That's one of the reason for the West's Stop-the-rise-of-China action today. But it will not succeed. Power to the Chinese!
No, but we might be now, sadly. But things are improving.
thank you it is really great history. don't find them in books
Great voice
And now , Racist still exists but under different expressions
How can you call that racist? Deportation is the logical conclusion for being illegal immigrants.
There was an asian girl in our youth club in Bath I knew back in the early 1960's . I had thought that probably her father was white and mother form Asia perhaps Hong Kong but it could have been the other way around . Bristol wasonly 12 miles away and that was a busy port before and during the war .
So did they sue the gov?
No, they have tried to get an apology from the government to no avail.
Why would you?
They were illegal immigrants! They broke English law!
These things happen quite often. Now revealed after these victims are long gone.
lucky for them to go to Singapore. now its No,1 passport
all because these men wanted wage equal to their hard work
I can’t believe Phyllis put her children in an orphanage to move away with her husband. I know she was in an awful situation but those were her kids.
I don't believe she had a choice. I remember hearing about her story prior to this watching this video. Because the children were not her current husband's children she was not allowed to take them with her by the government. Her Australian citizenship was also stripped from her.
@@margi9103 yeah, I just watched the part of the doc that looks at that story. What you say makes sense, especially when we know that in the other case of the documentary, citizenship was stripped from the women who married and they were classed as aliens. I highly doubt that the Australian government would let an “alien” leave the country with Australian children, especially if those children were white.
Because you are looking at the situation from today’s standards and norms. You are ignorant to tge norms or now not matching the norms of then, what else was she to do?
How racialy motivated hate will stop in our life time, if we do not learn from the past?
1901. NEW century
why?
why did it happen?
it is pointless to find out the so-call "why"...regardless of country...as long as there are
politicians...this will continue to happen...
shameful governments
Doesn’t seem to be working as Australia has an East Asian population of almost 20%. No East Asian country has a Caucasian population anywhere near that
@@mdee8784 exactly, they are the real xenophobes
How come the indians and jamacans could stay?
I assume the Chinese were seen as undesirable ghastly looking things compared to the fine chiselled features of the handsome Jamaican and the princely aromatic exotic
Indian men.
They were cheaper than the Chinese. The Chinese asked for more money and they got it,
another reason to get rid of them.
Beyond racist. Their reputations still live on to this day.
Never knew Asians were indigenous to the UK, what right do they have to he on someone elses ancestral land.
Wow.........
The correct term is Caucasian white is a colour. Caucasian including Europeans can range from ghost white to olive oil coloured.
Caucasians do exist..not all euros are caucasians
make Dna tests ! what about pensions from those in the war effort?
Ok
If I lived in China or Singapore and I was there illegally would I be deported if caught?
Nah you wouldn't be deported that is European mentality
Many were not illegal and were even married to the locals
@@neofils Even if you marry UK locals, it does not mean you are British Citizens! There are requirements that you have to fulfill.
@@jyap22continue this way, you’re SO close to become the best human being of this world.
@@MegaRanjee So you support illegal immigrants having rights to live anywhere in the World and anyone can come and live in UK?
phyllis was super irresponsible to leave her kids in an orphanage
If these men were deported to Singapore or elsewhere. None of them wrote to their families in the UK??
Mail was intercepted to prevent them from coming back.
Wheres the racial diversity in modern asian countrys?
Maybe there is a reason why that is? Look where UK and America is right now compared to China.
@BarnzTT my point being why are western country's constantly being labeled racist when they have more racial diversity than every other country on the planet? On a side note China isn't doing as great as you may think
West preach equal reality none
Same as Asia
Hong Kongers still move to the UK, ex-souverign country.
Stories don't talk. They are just about things. Don't say stories which talked about. Just say stories about.
The Chinese population in Singapore 🇸🇬 is a *big problem* for Singaporean national security when they
- connect with the authoritarian expansionist regime in China and
- subscribe to their version of world views.
Singapore is majority of Chinese lol
@@Vampybattie Not true!
One third speak Mandarin. Many are from Taiwan. So, Chinese are less than one third.
@@AhmetTekin101 no differemce
@@icet6665
@@AhmetTekin101 Tell me the difference? Taiwanese and mainland Chinese are Han Chinese
You have no understanding of consent issues. No-one, including groups if people, have to have others whom they don't want. You sound like a rapist, or a traitor. You should be prosecuted for treachery!
They have no issues with Asians, but just with the 🇨🇳Chinese.
so says the racist.
It's kinda true, Asians except Chinese are all following white Americans' orders, do whatever Americans ask, are obedient good boys and girls.
White Taiwan policy🤣🤣🤣
What does that mean?
@@steveg2479means, the Chinese men are undesirables.
During covid it was more white against white , I can;t recall any race based problems .
The program is disgusting and stirs things up for a sensitive topic in UK! The key question that is not answered in the program is whether they were illegal to be in UK in the 1st place! They seem to be illegal immigrants and deportation is an understanding and sad conclusion.
But if these people has helped the British war effort one would think it's reasonable to stay.
Look what the weather did in Iraq and Afghanistan. Use locals as interpreters etc then abandon them when they leave only to be killed or locked up
@@jw-vx8im Given the right to stay in Britain is neither a right nor reasonable for them. It is through grace and favor. Another wokist UK-bashing piece. They were illegal immigrants! Had they been illegal immigrants in Singapore now, they would have been deported too!
U are people without common sense , just bigotry
@@jw-vx8im No it is not "reasonable" to stay. Were they paid? Were they compensated? If so, their privilege to stay ends when the war ends.
@@jw-vx8im The Iraqi and Afghan locals ..... different story. They are in their homeland but if they had a risk of being killed by Islamic a-h0les, then they can apply to be refugees.
These men apparentky didnt matter.