Yes its meant to have a 70’s vibe since she died in that time.. Gaga is singing to her and playing her at the same time. Even though they never met, she has always felt a connection to her and remembers her death to be a big conversation in her family growing up and the reason her dad was always sad. Joanne is also Stefani’s (Gaga’s) middle name and the middle part of who she is, she also wrote this song for her dad and grandmother from their perspective as if they are saying those words.
Gosh this version of this song came out during my grandfathers last days. Id arranged to meet friends and spend some time alone during the day. I knew one thing. I couldn’t bring myself to listen to the song because I knew I would break down in public. I sat outside a bar alone smoking a cigarette, took a big breath and pressed play. I sobbed
The song can be analyzed in many perspectives. The first one is Jo, Gaga’s father singing to his sister, Joanne. Another way to look at is gaga singing to herself. Gaga’s name is also Joanne.
The Gaga in pink can be Gaga’s aunt lookin out for her (Gaga in black, nowadays) and Gaga’s sister, Natalie, who appears in the video having fun with Gaga.
If you want* you could react to Lady Gaga - Bang Bang (Live in Concord, CA).this is one of her best performances bc her classical training shines so well
I think you're right about Gaga trying to recreate who her aunt would have been when she was alive with this video. Gaga was named after her (Joanne Stefani Germanotta >> Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta) and when she was born her family basically saw her as second chance after all the loss and grief. I think the whole album was Gaga's way of channeling the woman who came before her. Also, fun fact, these vocals were all recorded in one take. Same with I'll Never Love Again off ASIB :)
I’m so in love with the way you break down a video, lyrics, visuals. Makes me see things in another light. I broke the subscribe button, Lady Gaga brought me here. Thank you
I would definitely recommend you watch her documentary on Netflix. It gives you a bigger insight into the creation of this album and is generally a great documentary. You seem to have a great understanding and love of film so I think you’d enjoy it if you’re liking what you see of Gaga.
i also think she is talking to herself in this song besides her aunt she is speaking to every woman in her life that influenced her life in a way i cry everytime i hear this song because of those 2 main reasons...it's about me as a woman or becoming one and about the women in my life I instantly think about my dead grandmother my mother and me when I listen to it Such a gem, I will forever cherish it :)
You should watch the Netflix documentary about her “five foot two”, it was made during the recording of the “Joanne” album and talks about a movie that Bradley Cooper wants her to be, and talks about this song, she can relate to her aunt in many ways and one of her names is Joanne as well, you should watch it. Please react to “the Edge of Glory” that song she wrote it for her grand father and the moment of his passing , it’s beautiful.
I just watched all the gaga reactions and bloody mary twice you're so clever and you clearly understand and appreciate art, looking forward to see more videos. I personally recommend you to watch marry the night MV. I also have a question. Since you have nintendo theme on your channel do you play animal crossing or any other titles besides mario maker 2? If you do pls make a video 😭❤️
oh my gosh thanks for watching! yeah it's just a generic 8 bit background since my son and i like a lot of old games lol, i've never really played animal crossing but i am thinking about doing more gaming content as the youtube and twitch grows :)
even if youre religious and believe that youre gonna see that person again, its still very hard to lose them in this lifetime, and not be able to be with them for the rest of your earthly life you know?
Please react to the Netflix documentary Gaga: Five Foot Two, which chronicles the making of the Joanne album, her battle with Fibromyalgia, struggling with her best friend’s (who she eventually lost) battle with Cancer, and the preparation and lead up to the Superbowl performance.
If you're religious, you mourn because you only know your earthly life and self, and what we have here, while it's only a fraction of our entire existence, feels like an eternity. When you lose somebody it's because you don't get to see them or be with them for the rest of your own life, which can feel like an eternity. As a religious person, however, you're constantly reminded that you will see them again, you just have to wait. I don't necessarily think we even mourn the loss, we mourn the waiting.
I think the mourning part is that we simply won’t see them again. At least not for a while. Even if someone has died and gone to heaven it’s not like we can call them up or FaceTime. Someone you might’ve loved for a long time and has always been in your life will no longer be there.
Also recommend Gaga’s duet with Sting “King of Pain” and her duets with Tony Bennett “The Lady is a Tramp” as well as her duet with Elton John “Artpop”
She has lupus too. And she had to end the born this way ball early because of a hip fracture. If you see her sitting in her music videos or performances it is because of that.
You should listen to the album version, it’s more folky and in my opinion, better. I think the piano version is good but.it’s a little bit too melodramatic for my taste.
You needs to react a live performance of her ... She is absolutely crazy but so phenomenal Please please react Lady Gaga live on AMA ..bad romance / speechless.... Thanks so much
I always felt that when loved ones die the ones left behind are sad that they won't be able to see that person again. So the grief, at least partly, is a selfish feeling.
How could you be so smart?! Kkk I’m chocked!! Intold you in another video! But its great to see what you thonk about the videos at first time, and you can feeeeeel
Great reaction... New sub! Seen all you're lady gaga reactions and I would really LOVE for you to react to Venus by lady gaga... TRUST ME ITS A FKING WEIRD SONG but in my opinion its her best song. crossing my finger for a reaction :D
REACT TO GAGA'S TILL IT HAPPENS TO YOU OSCARS PERFORMANCE !! FOR SURE! AND TO SOME OTHER LIVE ONES, SHE OUT OF THIS WORLD. IN EVERY MUSIC STYLE SHE DOES.
New subscriber! Love your Gaga reactions. Please more of her. React to her cover of Bang Bang(my baby shot me Down), Marry the Night, Alejandro, Judas and many more. Thanks :)
i always type the same thing hehe but if you really want to be shacked down react to bjork's mjusic, that shit is both musically and lyricly very different from everything, i think you'll really dig into it
I recommend you reacting to songs like Mind Brand, Perfectionist Complex, Rolling Girl, Unknown Mother Goose, they are Vocaloid songs, which already is a weird topic, but the lyrics and music are quite impactful... Songs like Lost one's weeping, Unhappy Refrain, Deep sea girl... they are pure human emotion put into music, just look for it with subtitls cuz it's in japanese (? I doubt my suggestion can be heard, just wanted to type in (?
Constantly bringing up the fact that it's a 70's vibe is really pissing me off. Like honestly JUST WATCH THE VIDEO! their is so much going on your not only supposed look at the "vibe"
if saying my thoughts out loud as i'm thinking them pisses you off this may not be the channel for you, kinda my thing when i'm reacting is to react. if you mean literally describe 'she's holding a guitar, she's looking out a window, she's writing songs on paper' i don't do that. the fact that you think i'm 'supposed' to do anything maybe set you up to be disappointed before even hitting play, where did you get this idea of what i'm supposed to do?
REACT TO LADY GAGA PERFECT ILLUSION BY GAGA OR MILLION REASONS LIVE ON THE HOWARD STERN SHOW POKER FACE HEAL ME HAIR BODY FACE ANY OF THOSE YOU WANT WOULD BE FINE PLZ AND THX ☺
Fun fact: this is a Grammy winning song.
i still can't believe it
Well deserved
Still cant believe it 😁 she did that
I believe it was her performance of it the won (technically) but this version is so amazing
NoTellHotel um no.
This was the last thing she put out for this album, her signing off “xoxo Joanne” was powerful way to send off the era
We miss her! R.i.p Joanne xoxo
I won’t stop! Marry the night!! 😅😅❤️
Fact: This Piano version was recorded in one take and won a Grammy for best pop solo performance
Definitely with the video
Haha we are such little monsters ❤️
ohhh yeesss 💙
Yes its meant to have a 70’s vibe since she died in that time.. Gaga is singing to her and playing her at the same time. Even though they never met, she has always felt a connection to her and remembers her death to be a big conversation in her family growing up and the reason her dad was always sad. Joanne is also Stefani’s (Gaga’s) middle name and the middle part of who she is, she also wrote this song for her dad and grandmother from their perspective as if they are saying those words.
Well done....beautifully very well done. Perfect ways to explain this beautiful song & this song made me cry. ❤✌🏾
Thank you for reacting to this song! This version of Joanne won a Grammy for Best Pop Solo Performance!
yass omg you're here too !! i love how we all stalk his channel for new gaga reactions 😂
That was so deserved but they should have given out in the main program along with Shallow
I recommend Perfect Illusion, Million Reasons, and John Wayn ( a trilogy in that order from Joanne album)
Gosh this version of this song came out during my grandfathers last days. Id arranged to meet friends and spend some time alone during the day. I knew one thing. I couldn’t bring myself to listen to the song because I knew I would break down in public. I sat outside a bar alone smoking a cigarette, took a big breath and pressed play. I sobbed
thx for sharing and condolences for your loss 🙂
The song can be analyzed in many perspectives. The first one is Jo, Gaga’s father singing to his sister, Joanne. Another way to look at is gaga singing to herself. Gaga’s name is also Joanne.
The Gaga in pink can be Gaga’s aunt lookin out for her (Gaga in black, nowadays) and Gaga’s sister, Natalie, who appears in the video having fun with Gaga.
Also Jo talking to her sister when she was passing away and talking to Gaga when she left to pursue her dream
If you want* you could react to Lady Gaga - Bang Bang (Live in Concord, CA).this is one of her best performances bc her classical training shines so well
This song actually won a Grammy!
I think you're right about Gaga trying to recreate who her aunt would have been when she was alive with this video. Gaga was named after her (Joanne Stefani Germanotta >> Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta) and when she was born her family basically saw her as second chance after all the loss and grief. I think the whole album was Gaga's way of channeling the woman who came before her.
Also, fun fact, these vocals were all recorded in one take. Same with I'll Never Love Again off ASIB :)
Always cry with this song
I’m so in love with the way you break down a video, lyrics, visuals. Makes me see things in another light. I broke the subscribe button, Lady Gaga brought me here. Thank you
thx so much!
SuperJersh YW. You should react to Lana Del Rey RIDE. stay safe.
Please do Marry The Night man! Long version, its a whole ass experience
React to alejandro by gaga
up
Joanne is actually one of her names, too! Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta
honestly i can't wait for you to react to more lady gaga music videos
I would definitely recommend you watch her documentary on Netflix. It gives you a bigger insight into the creation of this album and is generally a great documentary. You seem to have a great understanding and love of film so I think you’d enjoy it if you’re liking what you see of Gaga.
React to the Alejandro video that was so controversial back when it was released
This song makes me cry every time 😢
My favorite song by Gaga. To me it seems like she is imagining what a day would be like spent with her Aunt Joanne. ❤️
i also think she is talking to herself in this song besides her aunt
she is speaking to every woman in her life that influenced her life in a way
i cry everytime i hear this song because of those 2 main reasons...it's about me as a woman or becoming one and about the women in my life
I instantly think about my dead grandmother my mother and me when I listen to it
Such a gem, I will forever cherish it :)
this is my third Gaga video watching of yours... i love your intake. you helped me understand Judas lol
You should watch the Netflix documentary about her “five foot two”, it was made during the recording of the “Joanne” album and talks about a movie that Bradley Cooper wants her to be, and talks about this song, she can relate to her aunt in many ways and one of her names is Joanne as well, you should watch it. Please react to “the Edge of Glory” that song she wrote it for her grand father and the moment of his passing , it’s beautiful.
Please React "TILL IT HAPPENS TO YOU LIVE OSCARS 2016" Best Live voice performance of her 👌👌
R.I.P to Joanne. This song always hurts to listen to
Lady Gag's real name is Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta. Her first middle name is in honour if her aunt.
Do “Hey Girl ft. Florence Welch” no music video, but probably the best song off of Joanne imo!
I just watched all the gaga reactions and bloody mary twice you're so clever and you clearly understand and appreciate art, looking forward to see more videos. I personally recommend you to watch marry the night MV. I also have a question. Since you have nintendo theme on your channel do you play animal crossing or any other titles besides mario maker 2? If you do pls make a video 😭❤️
oh my gosh thanks for watching! yeah it's just a generic 8 bit background since my son and i like a lot of old games lol, i've never really played animal crossing but i am thinking about doing more gaming content as the youtube and twitch grows :)
Another great song from the earlier days ( Fame Monster) is Speechless. Shows great vocal and piano skills.
she's also named Joanne, after her aunt, Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta
I love this version of the song.
I love this song, gets me emotional
This is actual the second version of the song, the first one is on her album title “Joanne”.
even if youre religious and believe that youre gonna see that person again, its still very hard to lose them in this lifetime, and not be able to be with them for the rest of your earthly life you know?
Please react to the Netflix documentary Gaga: Five Foot Two, which chronicles the making of the Joanne album, her battle with Fibromyalgia, struggling with her best friend’s (who she eventually lost) battle with Cancer, and the preparation and lead up to the Superbowl performance.
Thank u. So Much..for reacting this
If you want to get a feel of Gaga, you should watch "5ft2" on Netflix.
If you're religious, you mourn because you only know your earthly life and self, and what we have here, while it's only a fraction of our entire existence, feels like an eternity. When you lose somebody it's because you don't get to see them or be with them for the rest of your own life, which can feel like an eternity. As a religious person, however, you're constantly reminded that you will see them again, you just have to wait. I don't necessarily think we even mourn the loss, we mourn the waiting.
I think the mourning part is that we simply won’t see them again. At least not for a while. Even if someone has died and gone to heaven it’s not like we can call them up or FaceTime. Someone you might’ve loved for a long time and has always been in your life will no longer be there.
Most fans enjoy Gaga for all of her many facets including her earlier pop music - not just her piano playing / A Star Is Born era.....
Also recommend Gaga’s duet with Sting “King of Pain” and her duets with Tony Bennett “The Lady is a Tramp” as well as her duet with Elton John “Artpop”
Watching from the Philippines.
react to the marry the night music video!
She has lupus too. And she had to end the born this way ball early because of a hip fracture. If you see her sitting in her music videos or performances it is because of that.
You should listen to the album version, it’s more folky and in my opinion, better. I think the piano version is good but.it’s a little bit too melodramatic for my taste.
I saw Gaga, I clicked. It's that easy.
Great reactions! Don't know if you have been told but Danny Carey tool pnuema live drum cam just dropped last week and it is incredible.
Pls react to gagas million reasons
You needs to react a live performance of her ...
She is absolutely crazy but so phenomenal
Please please react Lady Gaga live on AMA ..bad romance / speechless....
Thanks so much
I always felt that when loved ones die the ones left behind are sad that they won't be able to see that person again. So the grief, at least partly, is a selfish feeling.
Bro you should react to Judas, Alejandro, G.U.Y. Those are very cool music videos and songs too, please keep reacting to her music and videos!
How could you be so smart?! Kkk I’m chocked!! Intold you in another video! But its great to see what you thonk about the videos at first time, and you can feeeeeel
Marry the night and guy music videos ...are Essential to get in her persona and history / career
You know, if you want to here a fun song from the Joanne album, check out her SNL performance of A-Yo! I promise you won't be disappointed 😉
Please react to Judas. I want to hear your commentaries. 😊
Sarah Blasko - All I Want
I'm obsessed with your reacts. Please react to G.U.Y (another gaga music video). There's A LOT of nice references. Love your channel 💕
Great reaction... New sub! Seen all you're lady gaga reactions and I would really LOVE for you to react to Venus by lady gaga... TRUST ME ITS A FKING WEIRD SONG but in my opinion its her best song. crossing my finger for a reaction :D
This is my favorite song from her, I personally think the album version is better but both are great.
REACT TO GAGA'S TILL IT HAPPENS TO YOU OSCARS PERFORMANCE !! FOR SURE! AND TO SOME OTHER LIVE ONES, SHE OUT OF THIS WORLD. IN EVERY MUSIC STYLE SHE DOES.
Lissie - Hero
What about Million Reasons?
Can you please react to marry the night by lady gaga
If u like asib u gonna like the Album Joanne .. million reasons for exemple 👌🏻
Please react to Applause and born this way
You got three videos on private, are those gaga videos that you have already upload?
🤫🤐😉
You should react to Judas 👌🏻
Please do Perfect Illusion
Please react to Born This Way by Lady Gaga
You should react to the live performance at the Oscars of Til It Happens to You
Listen to Angel Down
Rumors are saying that Gaga scrapped the Telephone part 2. 😩
Kimbra - Two Way Street
You should watch Lady Gaga - Judas the video and the lyrics are good
New subscriber! Love your Gaga reactions. Please more of her. React to her cover of Bang Bang(my baby shot me Down), Marry the Night, Alejandro, Judas and many more. Thanks :)
You should check out a decade of Gaga and emotional tribute x
React to New York, New York (cover) by Lady Gaga
React to a million reasons by lady Gaga
Hello sir jersh I'm from Philippines,,plsss react gaga's oscar performance TILL IT HAPPENS TO YOU
Delerium - Innocente
React to Perfect illusion- million reasons- John Wayne music videos from the Joanne Era
i always type the same thing hehe but if you really want to be shacked down react to bjork's mjusic, that shit is both musically and lyricly very different from everything, i think you'll really dig into it
Tove lo sweettalk my heart :3
Please react to Lady Gaga - Perfect Illusion Live in Tokyo Piano version
or Gypsy by Lady Gaga
I recommend you reacting to songs like Mind Brand, Perfectionist Complex, Rolling Girl, Unknown Mother Goose, they are Vocaloid songs, which already is a weird topic, but the lyrics and music are quite impactful... Songs like Lost one's weeping, Unhappy Refrain, Deep sea girl... they are pure human emotion put into music, just look for it with subtitls cuz it's in japanese (?
I doubt my suggestion can be heard, just wanted to type in (?
Yesss!! React to ALLIE X - Regulars
React to Lady Gaga's Born This Way, please
soy tu fan 🤣
Judas By Lady Gaga
React to Lady Gaga Angel down and til it happens to you
react to FKA twigs cellophane!!!!!!
You should react to John Wayne by lady gaga
Also react to Allie X
React to Poppy🌷
React to 1999 by Charli XCX and Troy Sivan!
Please React To Speechless VEVO
HINO VOCAL.
Constantly bringing up the fact that it's a 70's vibe is really pissing me off. Like honestly JUST WATCH THE VIDEO! their is so much going on your not only supposed look at the "vibe"
if saying my thoughts out loud as i'm thinking them pisses you off this may not be the channel for you, kinda my thing when i'm reacting is to react. if you mean literally describe 'she's holding a guitar, she's looking out a window, she's writing songs on paper' i don't do that. the fact that you think i'm 'supposed' to do anything maybe set you up to be disappointed before even hitting play, where did you get this idea of what i'm supposed to do?
REACT TO LADY GAGA PERFECT ILLUSION BY GAGA OR MILLION REASONS LIVE ON THE HOWARD STERN SHOW POKER FACE HEAL ME HAIR BODY FACE ANY OF THOSE YOU WANT WOULD BE FINE PLZ AND THX ☺