วีดีโอ

I really like your video.

I guess this doesn't applied to every composer? And I though Chopin only applied rubato to the right hand, keeping the left hand with a stable rythm.

💪

I love how he emphasizes bass note in the end of passage

What is the tuning ?

Awesome tutorial, thank you so much. I am beginner and the foot work on this is not quite clear to me. How are the pedals used in this piece?

Thank you for sharing this, Josh.

please elaborate about the bottom of page 26.Horowitz, Janis, Pletnev, Gilels and Rodriguez play different chords than is written. beginning at 6:17

uhm so i just found your channel and i wanna first say it is amazing and has so much great information for music nerds like me. second i wanna ask from you to do a similar analysis series but for rach 2 which i love the most

This piece of video is awesome!!!

Great to see this!

What's the rush??? You are not going to be a master of this until it's memorised and it takes more than a week to remember all the differences between the repetitions of the material. Then there's getting it up to the right tempo and putting some interpretation in...

His music lives on. My favourite composer.

This video was so touching, and very respectful to the memory of an eternal master. It inspires me to make the trip from NJ up to Valhalla myself one day :) Thank you!

Medtner ended up becoming my fave for years now

The main piece in this opus is definitely number 3. The psychological value of this moment…

Fantastic!! Love the fingering discussion. It was YEARS before I finally accepted that the best fingering was not necessarily the one given in the particular edition. When closely studied it is not "hard" compared to the etude tableau, sonatas or concertos. LOTS of repetition in both hands but the secret is the marking. "Presto" is truly the real challenge.

This sounds beautiful

I think different pianos can offer different perspectives as they bring out different elements of sound.

Well that's sad to hear. This was best analysis of rachmaninoff's third piano concerto I've ever seen. I hope you can finish it someday and don't despair, even the master himself made a few bucks playing piano gigs. 🙂

Again this is brilliant. I would like to get college credit for attending this class please. 🙂

Thank you. This is brilliant.

Thank You so much for making this tutorial, you're amazing peep!! :D

I have been looking for a tut on this version of the song for so long, thank you. This was an amazing tutorial, ive been playing piano for 9 months and i can now play this song, thank you.

an imperial B on stage! got quite the practice room!

I'm saying this for the first time in 2024 Sep, wondoring if you have a finished version now?

Excellent work!!

@josh.v.music: In the first section of bar 306 the last three notes (at the end of the first descending part) are written C#, D, A and they are written as this in Rachmaninoff's original score as well. But everyone seems to play them C#, E, A instead. And I do think E sounds better than D. Is there just a widespread agreement to change the score here or am I reading it wrong?

I'm musically illiterate even if I've always been just a casual but a life-long fan of classical music particularly the piano. This presentation gives me a better appreciation of the magnificence of Rachmaninoff and the genius of musicians like you who can play, dissect the work and make it so entertaining inspite of the immense complexity of it all. Its comaprable to us being in awe of astronauts doing a space walk and never having even dared to ride a rollercoaster... But I do love watching the ride from a vantage point. Keep on Raching 'cause you rock Mr. Josh V.

Very good workshop, thank you for this. Be able to play the notes correctly is already a great start but listening/watching the harmonies as much as you can from great pianists will bring you to the next level like Seong Jin Cho for example who plsys it very romantic and and with a lot of feeling.

great!

Singers cant resist vibrato. Instrumentalist tie themselves in knots to make their line clear and strait, but like the flashing light on an ambulance the vocalist feels the need to warble away.

What upsets me is the beauty of his first moment musicaux and last are overshadowed by the fourth just because it SOUNDS difficult. Yes rhe fourth is absolutely beautiful, but the 6th is to die for. And the fourth isn’t too bad, just gotta have the endurance

I am new to piano I am a very beginner and I am very much desperate in learning this cornfield chase music can someone help me by giving the notes of the first part part with alphabet and number ( eg a4e4

What stereo angle are you using on the M5s?

Hello, comment ca va, still in Texas ?

Commenting for the algorithm. We miss you.

10:49 I think R2 is still neo-romantic whereas R3 has more modern/American influences, i.e. both feet in the twentieth century or as i once learned in music school, dynamism - the vibrancy, technology, etc. of the new century. Re R3 international performance, i dont think you had Yunchan Lim's Cliburn performance in mind🤣

희빈 장씨(禧嬪 張氏 1659∼1701) : 조선 19대왕 숙종의 후궁. 본관은 인동(仁同)이다. 역관 장현(張炫)의 종질녀이다. 어머니의 정부(情夫)였던 조사석(趙師錫)과 종친인 동평군 이항(東平君 李杭)의 주선으로 궁녀로 들어가 숙종의 총애를 독차지했다. 1686년(숙종 12) 숙원(淑媛)이 되었다. 1688년 소의(昭儀)로 승진하고 왕자 이윤(李昀: 뒤의 景宗)을 낳았다. 왕은 기뻐하여 세자로 봉하려 했다. 그러나 송시열(宋時烈) 등 당시 정권을 잡고 있던 서인이 지지하지 않으므로 남인들의 원조를 얻어 책봉하려 했다. 이에 서인의 노론·소론은 모두 왕비 민씨(閔氏)가 나이가 많지 않으니 후일을 기다리자고 주장하였다. 숙종은 듣지 않고 1689년 정월에 이윤을 세자로 봉하고, 장소의는 희빈으로 승격했다. 이 때 송시열이 세자로 봉하는 것이 아직 이르다고 상소하였다. 왕은 이미 명호(名號)가 결정된 다음에 이런 의견을 말하는 것은 무슨 일이냐고 진노했다. 이에 남인 이현기(李玄紀)·남치훈(南致薰)·윤빈(尹彬) 등이 송시열의 상소를 논박하며 파직시켜 제주도로 유배하게 하고 다시 사사(賜死)하게 하였다. 그러나 송시열은 중로 정읍으로 이배(移配)되었다가 사약을 받았다. 이 밖에 서인의 영수들도 파직 또는 유배를 면하지 못했다. 반면에 남인의 권대운(權大運)·김덕원(金德遠) 등이 등용되었다. 이 정권의 교체를 기사환국 또는 기사사화라고 한다. 이 해 5월에 민비를 폐하고 장희빈을 왕비로 삼으려 할 때 서인 오두인(吳斗寅)·박태보(朴泰輔) 등 80여 명이 상소하여 이를 반대했다. 그러나 이들은 참혹한 형문을 받게 되니 이후 정국은 남인의 세상이 되었다. 기사환국 후 시간이 흐르면서 숙종은 폐비사건을 후회하게 되었다. 그러던 중 1694년 서인의 김춘택(金春澤)·한중혁(韓重爀) 등이 폐비 복위운동을 꾀하다가 고발되었다. 이 때 남인의 영수요 당시 우의정이었던 민암(閔黯) 등이 이 기회에 반대당 서인을 완전히 제거하려고 김춘택 등 수십 명을 하옥하고 범위를 넓혀 일대 옥사를 일으켰다. 이 때 숙종은 폐비에 대한 반성으로 옥사를 다스리던 민암을 파직하고 사사했으며, 권대운·목내선(睦來善)·김덕원 등을 유배했다. 이어 소론 남구만(南九萬)·박세채(朴世采)·윤지완(尹趾完) 등을 등용하고 장씨를 희빈으로 내렸는데 이것을 갑술옥사라고 한다. 또한, 이미 죽은 송시열·김수항(金壽恒) 등은 복작(復爵)되고 남인은 정계에서 물러나게 되었다. 소론이 들어서고 남인이 물러날 때 장희빈의 오빠 장희재(張希載)가 희빈에게 보낸 서장(書狀) 속에 폐비 민씨에 관련된 문구가 있어 논쟁이 벌어졌다. 여러 사람이 장희재를 죽이자고 했으나 세자에게 화가 미칠까 염려하여 남구만·윤지완 등이 용서하게 했다. 그런데 왕비 민씨가 죽은 다음에, 장희빈이 취선당(就善堂) 서쪽에 신당(神堂)을 설치하고 민비가 죽기를 기도한 일이 발각되었다. 이 일에 관련된 희빈과 장희재는 처형되고 궁인(宮人)·무녀와 그 족당(族黨)도 화를 입었다. 이것을 무고(巫蠱)의 옥(獄)이라고 한다. 이 때 장희빈에 대해 관대한 태도를 취한 남구만·최석정(崔錫鼎)·유상운(柳尙運) 등 소론의 선비들도 몰락하고 다시 노론이 득세하였다. 숙종은 이후 빈(嬪)을 후비(后妃)로 승격하는 일을 없애는 법을 만들었다.

Learning the later section with the waltz and all the hemiolas is driving me crazy.

op 16 no 4 is literally just a remix of winter wind lol.

Thanks a lots.

Hey, great vid! As i russian i ve never actually heard the melody of russian church thats sounds similar to the main theme. Can you give me recording on youtube or maybe give me russian name, because i cant find it myself.

The theme in 1:04 is reminding me of Medtner's 2nd piano concerto

This is so superb, your technique is great and Medtner's music is legendary!

any tips on how to play the piano with a flow like you .. and really fast. any exercises? or just elarning how to read notes and practice and also i cant press hard with my finger between pinky and middle any tips?

i actually cant believe how underrated you are i swear you are the best piano content creator out there❤

Bravo! 🎉 PS. And some of them listen "relaxing" piano when they studie or to help them sleep (I get insomnia from classical music, MAKES ME THINK ABOUT HOW MUCH I HAVE TO PRACTISE 😵

What’s the name of this piece?