วีดีโอ

What done is done. But stopping it to repeat is mandatory

I could not get inside my father's mind, but I knew what he did to me. He was happy to leave a blasted entity. Hope this is not considered irrelevant. Occupations occur at different levels. Having some Jewish genes from my Mother's side I very much appreciate Dr Snyder's perspective & very great understanding.

I don't understand why Ukrainian authorities refuse to exhume the victims of the Slaughter of Volyn and publicly apologise to the Polish victims' relatives as demanded by the government of Poland. That way Ukraine would finally put behind this shameful page in its history. Refusing to acknowledge the act of genocide makes the wound ever-festering.

I don't understand why Ukrainian authorities refuse to exhume the victims of the Slaughter of Volyn and publicly apologise to the Polish victims' relatives as demanded by the government of Poland. That way Ukraine would finally put behind this shameful page in its history. Refusing to acknowledge the act of genocide makes the wound ever-festering.

Add Turkish subtitle please. Thank you❤🙏

Davis Donald Robinson Anthony Wilson Mary

Giving weapons is, in this case, decency

GIVE WEAPONS

Thomas Donna Thomas Maria Thomas Anna

Wilson Betty Young Patricia Lewis Mark

Lotta parallels between Der Führer And Der Vlad ✅

Phobia for the truth..

Remarkable lecture, for sure; am wondering how this step by step clarification would fit what is happening between Israel and Palestine under Netanyahu and Co.

Starts at 7:08

wow what a blunt start for Snyder talk...man!

!

th-cam.com/video/IW0FrgSd80k/w-d-xo.htmlsi=uQ39Kj4eIxrM8UZn

Much of Snyder’s work on Ukraine is Revisionist or Wokeness - I watched the entire series of the Making of Modern Ukraine - Lectures 1-23. The War in Ukraine is not a War of Genocide but a question of Security for the Russian Federation; one must be aware that most of the Donbas region is Russian and not Ukrainian. Ukraine has been a state since 1922 and Russia has no intention of occupying the nation or recreating the Soviet Union and this is a false narrative designed to scare the rest of Eastern Europe and is propagated by US neocons and the Servant of the Peoples Party. Israel does not consider itself fighting a war of Genocide in Palestine but a War for the security of the State of Israel. The question of Crimea is not a question of Genocide, as Crimea has been Russian since the 17th Century. There are more Russians in Crimea than in Ukrainian, or Tatars. The Crimean Khanate is not Eastern Slavic or Ukrainian and was essentially a region left over in the aftermath of the Golden Horde and the Ottoman Empire. So, the War in Ukraine is not about eliminating Ukrainians but securing the Strategic interests of Russia. According to the UN, 25,000 Civilians have perished in the entire war, so I don't know where he gets his 100,000 Civilians in Mariupol alone. So Snyder is compromised as and Historian as Ukraine pays him to rewrite the History of Ukraine in Ukraine’s vision, so he is a Political Commissar. Ukraine has never brought a successful case in the International Criminal Court or the International Court of Justice against Russia and is not even a signature to the Treaty of Rome. One of his examples of misrepresentations in his Ukrainian Series is during the Lifting of the Siege of Vienna by the Polish Lithuanian Commonwealth; he states that “5000 Ukrainian Cossacks assisted Poland in lifting the Siege of Vienna by the Ottoman Empire.” Firstly, Ukraine never existed in the 17th Century, and the correct term would be the 5000 Cossacks of the Zaporizhzia Cossack Hermanate, which were neither Ukrainian, Polish, or Russian, but a tribal entity that existed in the region of the Dnipro River between Poland, the Ottoman Empire, Russian Empire, and Crimean Khanate. Ukraine never existed as a Nation or even a region until 1922. So, he undermines his integrity as a Historian. The only standard reference for the development of the Ukrainian Nation was the Historian Robert Paul Mogosic of the University of Toronto, an American of Hungarian heritage. So, the Russian Federation will never allow a hostile Ukraine to control the Crimean Peninsular and, in this case, control Russian access to the Sea of Azov and hence the access to the Don River Delta and subsequently the access to the Caspian Sea via the Volga-Don Canal. It is simple as that! Imagine if Ukraine leased Sevastopol to NATO; the Black Sea would be a hotbed of fighting in which the Region would be in constant turmoil. This is not in the interests of Turkey, which, under the Treaty of Montreux, regulates Naval access through the Straights. Imagine if Cuba leased or allowed China or the Russian Navy to have a significant presence in Cuba, and these Navies harass US shipping in the region; there would be a war between Cuba and the US. So Snyder is a political operator and not a historian. He is paid by the Ukrainian government, the Levin Endowment at Yale University, to rewire the History of Ukraine in the vision of Zalenskyy, and he infuses Ukrainiasium into his writings from 800 CE to 2022. In addition, he is trying to infuse Ukraine and Judaism as a central theme, and this is not the case and is a dangerous notion. He tries to make out that Ukraine is the center of Judaism in Europe, which is not the case. I cannot find any reference to the word Ukraine in the Treaty of Lubin, the Treaty of Pereiaslav, or any other Agreement that mentions “Ukraine.” The only mention of Ukraine is in the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk 1918 between the Central Powers, Poland, Hungary, Ottoman Empire, and Bolsheviks to respect the newly formed Ukrainian Peoples Republic (1918-1921) The Ukrainian People's Republic was not signatory to the Treaty. However, the Treaty was superseded by the Treaty of Versailles, which ended the Great War. The Bolskiviks of Kharkiv defeated the Ukrainian People's Republic and White Armies, and the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic was established in 1922. and that was the first time it was recognized as a state The Bolsheviks combined Russian Empire regions and cities, Odesa, Mykolaiv, Kherson, Melitipol, Berdynask, Donekst, Luhansk, as well as Bessarabia into the Ukrainian SSR. Later, Polish East Galicia and Volhynia were annexed by the Soviets in 1939 and placed under the jurisdiction of the Ukrainian SSR. In 1954, the Crimea Autonomous region of Crimea was transferred to the Ukrainian SSR on the Anniversary of the Treaty of Pereiaslav, which was a treaty between The Zaporizhzian Cossack Hetmanate and the Tsar of Russia. Ukraine had no relationship with Crimea since the beginning of time Snyder never mentions this at all in his series at all. When a Historian allows himself to be paid by a Nation or projects himself into History, he is not a Historian but a Political Commissar like Nikita Khrushchev. (Sorry, the comparison sounds absurd but true) One of the great things about Robert Mogocsi is that he lays out the data, maps, geographical and political boundaries, and population demographics at various historical events and never gets into active revisionist History.

Talk begins 6:59

I am so thankful to Prof Snyder to throwing light on the history of Ukraine and Putin’s Russia. I wish more people will hear and read such analysis instead of talking crap about Ukraine and somehow finding logical reason for this invasion by Putin.

That's what you get when you bring NATO at Russia's border - no rocket science

One and only GOD of us all told us in Quran about reason of sending Quran which tells us Quran is a reminder for those who where previously send the messages from GOD and a guidance and mercy for its followers, and there is several times Quran directly addressed to people of book to compare and correct there believes and that is the reason all those stories where shared, Basic purpose of Quran is to identify the reason of this life and to give all the answers which human beings searching to find the truth. Only thing in Quran is superior and respectful is one and only GOD of us all and all the prophets of GOD tell there people that we are not asking any rewards from you, our rewards are with one and only GOD of us all and HE will reward us. So there is no question about anyone superiority and all prophets are equal with same one message to worship one and only GOD of us all. All those references other then message send by one and only GOD of us all ALLAH Rabul Allamin, is rejected by Quran and only Quran is the religion, Sunnah is the prophet life which was tell us about how our belove prophet Muhammad Peace be upon him live his life so we can follow accordingly and there is nothing other than Quran or any extra revolution, total message is in Quran and the very last to the humanity till near end. Causing corruption and making stories is human nature and this is what happened to all previously send messages, so GOD make Quran protected and can't be changed but humans don't give up and create things like fake clams and new stories which had nothing to do with GOD and his message. And for me I find everything in Quran even what's going on and what had already happened and what's to come and it's word by word the only truth I find on this earth a guidance which calm me down and give peace and hope and believe that make me strong and show me the light in my dark soul. May ALLAH Rabul Allamin one and only GOD of us all guide us all and send mercy and blessings

Start...30:32 ( very sobering.😔 ) ends 31:10. Thank you for uploading and sharing.

There is a moral aspect that becomes clear when put into perspective from a Christian point of view. Every sinner has a right and a dury to oppose sin whether or not he has ever committed that same sin. So, yes, there is nothing immoral about the West opposing the atrocities perpetrated in Ukraine.

I cant believe the jewish center gave word to this neo-nazi who equates Hitler - the scum behind holocaust and Stalin - the man who saved the worlds from Hitler. Disgusting.

A very deep seated Russophobia. The exceptionalism and exceptional nation was the works of art of USA. Russia today is challenging that dangerous notion. Prayers for lasting peace in Ukraine and all over the world.

Professors with German last names are used to speak up on these subjects. After the fall of communism, the desire on the part of members of the deep state and American tourists travelling in East Europe, stems from the American veterans of Iraq wars who committed war crimes. Some veterans of Iraq wars between 2003 and 2009 who had massacred 400,000 to 500,000 Iraqi Arabs fought. roughly from 2003 to 2009. President Obama withdrew the troops as more information emerged of massacre of Iraqi veterans. So modern American administrations only want to send troops to Europe. Average human being who indulges in mass murders such as American veterans of Iraq wars had a built in desire to commit another mass murder. Mass shooters become permanently mass murderers, if not persecuted. Veterans of Iraq wars were never persecuted, as President Obama withdrew these troops. Average Iraq veteran when speaking to lawmakers on the Hill say something like, "I would like to commit massacre after the fall of communism in this peaceful era after the Iraq wars. Average official in Washington replies to Veterans of Iraq wars: during the period from 210 to 2021 replies," My dear Veterans of Iraq wars. Please delay your desires to indulge in mass shootings in the western hemisphere. Please go to Kyiv. We will charter flights for you to go to Kyiv, as city contested between ethnic Russians and ethnic Ukrainians. Kill some ethnic Russians in Russian neighborhoods there and in East Ukraine."

الحادثه ليست صحيحه ليست حقيقيه فمعظم الروايات في السيره لابن اسحق وابن هشام هي غير صحيحه وتم صنعها بعد موت النبي بقرنين وبثلاث قرون فهي مجموعه اكاذيب وايضا الاحاديث كلها اكاذيب تم صنعها بعد موت النبي ب 200سنه و 300سنه و 400سنه ليتم السيطره علي الناس من الحكام بعد موت النبي ولو قمنا بتفكيك ماقولتيه عن قراءه عمر للتوراه امام النبي فهذا ليس صحيح لان عمر يقرا والنبي يسمع ويفهم؟فهل الاثنان يعرفان لغه التوراه ؟ام ان التوراه مكتوبه بالعربيه؟ النبي وجهه احمر من الغضب؟ فهل من لاحظ ذلك رأي وعرف وفهم؟ النبي يعلمنا في كتاب الله ان الدين واحد فكل الانبياء ابراهيم ويعقوب وادريس وموسيوو وو وو علموا نفس ماعلمنا محمد فهل سيغضب محمد لان موسي يعلم بما يعلم به محمد؟ موسي وهارون كانا في وقت واحد ابراهيم ولوط كانا في وقت واحد سليمان وداوود كانا في وقت واحد وكلهم علموا بنفس التعليم وهو الاسلام فلو كانت الحادثه سيدتي صحيحه ماغضب محمد فهو من علمنا ان كلهم من عند الله واننا لايجب ان نفرق بين احد من رسله

Pipe dream. Open up NATO countries like US to genocide trials. Like drone strikes.

This is how we know that the Quran is not from Allah. Just look at these 4 contradictory versions of Moses and the burning bush. In surah 19:50-53 Allah calls to Moses from the whole of the mountainside, and which area is holy is not mentioned. But in surah 20:9-36 Allah's voice comes from the fire, not the side of the mountain, not from the side of the mountain and the whole valley is said to be holy. In Surah 27:7-14 the voice of Allah comes from the fire and only those in and around the fire are blessed or holy: an In Surah 28:29-31 Allah's voice seems to come from a different tree and only the ground around the tree is holy or sacred Also Allah changes both his own words and those of Moses - it seems that Allah has memory problems - though this is not perhaps as bad as forgetting the whole order and duration of creation as Allah does between surah 7:54 and Surah 41:9-12.

Very interesting....well researched....but Greenberg deserved a better audio...

I hope for the health of our respective nations that ours leaders watched this.

Started listening to Dr. Snyder's lecture and caught myself that my mind was constantly wandering away with the thoughts of my own town and people currently living there now as I am not there right now. Also was thinking of my long gone relatives who perished in Lida Ghetto in 1942. Tears started rolling. Forgot to mention...I am from Bucha. СЛАВА УКРАИНЕ

It was so good to hear Dr Walker lecture again! Thank you for sharing this fascinating talk, and for letting me learn from her once more.

Thank you Dr Shari Lowin for giving a lecture on Moses in the Qu'ran and the Early Muslim Isra'iliyyat as part of the Elie Wiesel Memorial Lecture Series 2020: Finding Moses at the Elie Wiesel Center for Jewish Studies.

The Allah in the Quran ultimately says don’t be like the children of Israel or you will share their future. Obey me and you will be blessed . Disobey me and you will be cursed.

What we really need to know is that Moses is a great prophet of Allah , in the other hand his people, the children of Israel were not . At the end of his life Moses , asked Allah to separate and distance him from these disobedient people. Moses peace be upon him because of them never was allowed in the holy land . 40 years of desert roaming was punishment for the worship of the golden calf.

The story of Moses peace be upon him is that he told the prophet Mohamed, my people were ordered less prayer but they failed in completing them .

Israeliyates are stories of foreign origin to Islam but attributed to it falsely and unfortunately believed by some Muslims as part of their authentic heritage. The real origin of theses text are Jewish converts or so they claimed who implanted these stories and lies in the purpose to spread rumors and shake up the Muslim’s believes.

The Jews of Arabia at the time of the prophet Muhammad refused to accept his message because he was not a Jew. They could not accept that Allah change the line of the prophecy from the descendants of Isaac to those of Ishmael.

Daneial 9:24-27 The only time in history that the abomination build over the temple is year 135 (( temple of Jupiter)) add 70 weeks= 490 lunar years= 475 solar years )) 135+475=610 CE that is the year that prophet Muhammad pbuh start to receive revelation from arch angel Gabriel pbuh Remember the letter of Mimonide to the Yeminite Jews he told them that the Muslim hearts reject naturally all the forms of idolatry and paganism Prophet Muhammad pbuh was your Massaiah who gave the Gentiles (( I am included)) the knowledge of Allah SWT

How much crystal clear is this!! But jews have to accept it.

Snyder, what we are interested in is which branch of your ancestors mixed with monkeys? And yours intellectual regurgitation about Europeans and, above all, about Russians and the Slavic world is of no interest to anyone.

Words in the Quran like Awhayna or other derivatives can have several meanings. So, when ALLAH talks about Wahi with regard to Moses peace be upon him it is not the same meaning when used with regard to his mother. So, Inspiration can mean direct revelation through Angle Gabriel in the case of prophets and can be directly into the mind of the person most often comes as a vision while sleeping. So, the mother of Moses peace be upon him didn't have the kind or revelation like other prophets. However, angle Gabriel talked to Mariam directly in a human form and told her that he was a messenger from ALLAH. Even prophet Muhammad peace be upon him, most often Gabriel came in a human form. Only twice that prophet Muhammad peace be upon him saw Angle Gabriel in his real form. Unlike other scriptures, Muslims considers ONLY the Arabic Quran as the word of ALLAH and not any translation. Most often, translations do not convey the complete meaning of the Quran. So, please don’t forget, don’t refer to the English translation as the Quran because its not.

Pepe le pew

The hadith of Angel Gabriel washing the heart of prophet Muhammad in arabic sources ..talks about the use of zemzem water in a golden vessel not with ice 😮

Isn't #7 exactly what America always uses as excuse to do bad shit. We're special, we have superior morals, we're democrats, so of course that justifies invading Iraq. Or destroy Iranian democracy or that of Chile. Or...take Cali.. fing .. fornia.

Crimean Tatars are not the indigenous inhabitants of Crimea. They only got there centuries ago. Unfortunately, people lived there for thousands of years. So how exactly would they be indigenous to it?

Amazing thesis, sad only that he applies it to others and not his own nations genocides. Apparently there's no moral obligation to make anything right for the NAN.

Mr. Snyder has become the conscience of democracy.