I was in Love with Stephin's own version But I absolutely adore the way Mercier have interpreted and delivered this genius masterpiece, which specially a genius songwriter as he is, realizes it and appreciates in its much organic inner works. You realize how much expert caring to each strophe, word and syllables Mercer spells them with long rich capability. Yes, not same baritone, tenor or bass voice _just his, as bare and honest as Merritt's, no tricks or added games to but clear lines delivered to cause their magic.
Love the Magnetic Fields and my fave of theirs. However I love this even more, especially the vocals. It makes me feel elated. There's another delicious version by Ludvig Moon. I wish I could hear Ludvig Moons backing but with The Shins vocals.
I've been looking for this version for years!... there used to be a video version of this, right? I used to watch it in loop 9-10 years ago.. then I forgot about it and for the past 2-3 years I've been craving to find it... pretty sure this is it... albeit I'm most certain the video had "FM" in the title.. anyhoo... thanks Quango!
nah... it's not it.. Radio 101.7 or 107.1.. something along those lines and I think "FM" also was in the title. "Phantom Limb by the Shins Acoustic on Radio FM 107.1" .. something like thath. Any hints are very much appreciated!
I love the idea of paying tribute to The Magnetic Fields (and, in particular, Stephin Merritt), but I'm afraid this just didn't work for me. I just need Stephin's voice and the churning (yet lilting) rhythm of the original. On the other hand, who would I like to see cover this track... ? Nick Drake would've been interesting... (Then again, I'd love to hear Stephin cover "Pink Moon" or "Fly". For some reason, I sort've hold Stephin and Nick Drake in the same artistic space... however valid or invalid that might be.)
Joe Shmoe I'm fine with other bands paying tribute to Magnetic Fields (or any other band they choose), I just wasn't enthusiastic about the way this track fleshed out. Having said that, your comment about "gagging on a cock" reveals much about you. Anger propelled by fear and ignorance is rarely a good jumping-off point for critical commentary. If you have a problem with Stephin Merritt (or anyone else - including myself) being gay, then I guess we all know what that makes you, don't we, Mr. Schmoe?
OMG... Seriously?? They covered and DESTROYED The Magnetic Fields' classic "Strange Powers"??!?? Wow, is this ever bad. Shame on you pathetic shins... shame, shame shame... stick to your own crap, please... don't even touch Stephin Merritt's work.
I like both bands on their respective merits (haha), but I really don't like this cover. I find Mercer's breath pauses to be totally weird and not working with the song. Just an opinion.
I also prefer magnetic fields version but the fact that Shins choose to cover it and do such a nice job affirms their unique greatness I think. Love the Shins and can't wait for their new CD (with Simple Song on it)
@BreakzTerrorist the only thing more annoying than yuppy shins fans are annoying yuppy stephin merritt fans, like you. people need to stfu and enjoy the music. no one likes a fanboy.
@LindaDynamite Best cover maybe, although Plenty is never Enough was superb too! Their best was and will be New Slang followed by Caring is creepy and Split Needles.
I love the Shins, but I'm not a fan of this cover. The Magnetic Fields are a difficult band the cover, Stephin has such a unique and mesmerizing voice.
Algorithm brought me back 😮
🖤
Awesome cover!
This is GENIUS. Imagine a world without Merritt. Nope.
This version is so sweet and nostalgic sounding! I wish it were on iTunes!!!
I was in Love with Stephin's own version But I absolutely adore the way Mercier have interpreted and delivered this genius masterpiece, which specially a genius songwriter as he is, realizes it and appreciates in its much organic inner works. You realize how much expert caring to each strophe, word and syllables Mercer spells them with long rich capability. Yes, not same baritone, tenor or bass voice _just his, as bare and honest as Merritt's, no tricks or added games to but clear lines delivered to cause their magic.
Pretty good cover
Love the Magnetic Fields and my fave of theirs. However I love this even more, especially the vocals. It makes me feel elated. There's another delicious version by Ludvig Moon. I wish I could hear Ludvig Moons backing but with The Shins vocals.
Criminally underrated song
this is what covers are supposed to be like. a really good song can be done in many ways
I'm gonna say it, this is better than the original. I need this on spotify.
The next time that you like a song- leave it alone
I've been looking for this version for years!... there used to be a video version of this, right? I used to watch it in loop 9-10 years ago.. then I forgot about it and for the past 2-3 years I've been craving to find it... pretty sure this is it... albeit I'm most certain the video had "FM" in the title.. anyhoo... thanks Quango!
nah... it's not it.. Radio 101.7 or 107.1.. something along those lines and I think "FM" also was in the title. "Phantom Limb by the Shins Acoustic on Radio FM 107.1" .. something like thath. Any hints are very much appreciated!
Capos totales, que suerte que hicieron un cover de esto.
Awesome
i like the shins but this is no good
This song is so fucking good a dog could sing it acapella and as long as somehow lyric and melody held true it would maintain its masterpiece
Set up would require quite the woofer
Sorry not sorry,mI prefer this version!
decent Cover... does the original justice ... both Bands are Legends in their own right.. No need for hatin
escalatorfrenzy his vocal bends and peaks are sharp and shinnni it’s a good cov.
Me too! soundcloud.com/calamusk/magnetic-fields-strange-powers
I love the idea of paying tribute to The Magnetic Fields (and, in particular, Stephin Merritt), but I'm afraid this just didn't work for me. I just need Stephin's voice and the churning (yet lilting) rhythm of the original. On the other hand, who would I like to see cover this track... ? Nick Drake would've been interesting... (Then again, I'd love to hear Stephin cover "Pink Moon" or "Fly". For some reason, I sort've hold Stephin and Nick Drake in the same artistic space... however valid or invalid that might be.)
Joe Shmoe I'm fine with other bands paying tribute to Magnetic Fields (or any other band they choose), I just wasn't enthusiastic about the way this track fleshed out. Having said that, your comment about "gagging on a cock" reveals much about you. Anger propelled by fear and ignorance is rarely a good jumping-off point for critical commentary. If you have a problem with Stephin Merritt (or anyone else - including myself) being gay, then I guess we all know what that makes you, don't we, Mr. Schmoe?
Your comment here and your comment from two years seems to contradict itself a little.
Do you have ANY idea how much cremant, cava, and prosecco I've downed over the past 2 years? (and the comments were more like 1 year apart.)
The consumer is king And unhappiness is treason Amazingly insightful Mr Merritt.
This guys has no balls to sing a word like "prostitutes". Poor Merritt, what a shameful cover.
This cover isnt as good as the original but the Shins cover of We Will Become Silhouettes by the Postal Service is amazing!
I think it's excellent and only natural that it should be done. I could think of a ton of Magnetic Fields songs that the Shins could've written.
It's a Magnetic Fields song. Just in case you don't know :) I'm a fan of both bands and I really like this version.
This is a fucking horrendous.
Yes indeed, and it would be the first time Jens Lekman sings a song with good lyrics.
OMG... Seriously?? They covered and DESTROYED The Magnetic Fields' classic "Strange Powers"??!?? Wow, is this ever bad. Shame on you pathetic shins... shame, shame shame... stick to your own crap, please... don't even touch Stephin Merritt's work.
chill😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
isnt all of jens lekman just attempts at magnetic fields but in a not bad way
Have you heard the original? You should listen to it if not, it's great.
I'll have what you're smoking.
its a cover
It's a good cover, but Merritt's voice is more memorable
I like both bands on their respective merits (haha), but I really don't like this cover. I find Mercer's breath pauses to be totally weird and not working with the song. Just an opinion.
@Romeoette666 A lot... apparently ha
I also prefer magnetic fields version but the fact that Shins choose to cover it and do such a nice job affirms their unique greatness I think. Love the Shins and can't wait for their new CD (with Simple Song on it)
It's good, but it's half the original.
@1991stacy yeah the voice needs to be deeper, or at least have a lower harmony
jens lekman should cover it
This doesn't work at all
@BreakzTerrorist the only thing more annoying than yuppy shins fans are annoying yuppy stephin merritt fans, like you. people need to stfu and enjoy the music. no one likes a fanboy.
it's a piece of shit. Original song was decapitated...
@LindaDynamite Best cover maybe, although Plenty is never Enough was superb too! Their best was and will be New Slang followed by Caring is creepy and Split Needles.
I love the Shins, but I'm not a fan of this cover. The Magnetic Fields are a difficult band the cover, Stephin has such a unique and mesmerizing voice.
Before him, it was originally Aan Conway leading the band vocals and their deliveries through her voice were something silvery above this planet
Fabulous cover!! i have been trying to get the Strange Powers song from Magnetic Fields without any success...
best thing the shins have done in my opinion
finally someone uploaded this
@pauliskewl21 - posting things in Yoda English has also been done too,
Hmmm, like the vocals. Not a fan of the backing instruments. But nothing beats Merritt's voice.