- 101
- 82 562
Robert Chuckrow
United States
เข้าร่วมเมื่อ 11 ก.ค. 2009
Placement of the forward foot in a 100% stance
There is no one-size-fits-all answer other than the angling of the pelvis (which may vary from teacher to teacher and style to style) and finding the neutral orientation of the empty leg. This criterion agrees with the martial aspect, which is that the empty foot potentially kicks and does so most efficiently when that leg is neutrally aligned.
มุมมอง: 73
วีดีโอ
A clarification of Cheng Man-ch’ing’s admonition, “Don’t twist.”
มุมมอง 5664 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Twisting can occur passively or actively . This video provides examples and clarification of the distinction between these two modes.
What’s with “holding a ball” in Taiji?
มุมมอง 54012 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
In this video the idea is put forth that, instead of grasping a ball, it is the whole body that is always rounded and expanded as though the periphery were the surface of a ball.
The song/neijin paradox and its resolution
มุมมอง 430วันที่ผ่านมา
It is said that song (release of contractive muscular strength) is a prerequisite to the attainment of nei jin (expansive strength). Here is the paradox: Strength is required to do any movement. So if you don't already have nei jin, then that strength would be contractive, which contradicts being in a state of song. This video attempts to provide a solution.
Is Taiji becoming too diluted?
มุมมอง 82314 วันที่ผ่านมา
We see Tai Chi for seniors, easy Tai Chi, seated tai chi, Tai Chi for weight-loss, etc. To what degree
“When there is up there is down…”
มุมมอง 86414 วันที่ผ่านมา
This video examines a Taiji Classics saying attributed to Chang San-feng. He was a legendary Taoist who created Taijiquan, lived to an age of over 200 years, and had a pet ape whom he taught to do Taiji and collect and chop firewood.
Augmenting dong/dang through an understanding of potential energy and kinetic energy
มุมมอง 39721 วันที่ผ่านมา
This video explains an additional aspect of dang/dang not mentioned in my prior videos on that subject.
“The head is suspended from above; a weight pulls the tailbone down.”
มุมมอง 560หลายเดือนก่อน
Cheng Man-ch’ing emphasized the above idea in writing and to us, as students. I will attempt to clarify the meaning of this Taiji expression by (a) saying what it doesn’t mean; (b) by discussing the basic physical concept involved; and (c) explaining how to experience and practice what’s involved, namely extension of the space between each vertebra and the next along the entire spine and betwee...
Finding the centers of your feet: important for stability and rooting
มุมมอง 782หลายเดือนก่อน
This video combines information that I learned from studying Kinetic Awareness with Elaine Summers and I Liq Chuan with Sam Chin Fan-siong. A definition for the center of a foot is provided plus exercises that Sam Chin taught me by for finding the centers of the feet. Note that arch, ankle, and knee alignment can also benefit from having the center of the pressure distribution centered on the f...
Cheng Man-ch’ing’s and two other transitions from “Cloud Hands” to “Single Whip”
มุมมอง 368หลายเดือนก่อน
This video shows the difference between the transition from “Cloud Hands” to “Single Whip” in the Cheng Man-ch’ing short form and that in the Yang long form in which the motion of the hands of one movement more-naturally morph from “Cloud Hands” to “Single Whip.” A third transition is then shown that combines elements of both the Cheng Man-ch’ing and Yang versions.
Cheng Man-ch’ing on lifting the heel or toe when shifting forward or back in 70-30 stances
มุมมอง 516หลายเดือนก่อน
Professor Cheng corrected us whenever he saw us lift a toe or a heel when shifting forward or back in 70-30 stances or push-hands, claiming that these errors were precursors to falling. This video includes enlargements of this concept that were taught by later, martial-arts teachers of mine.
Taiji stepping: heel first, toe first, ball first, or something else?
มุมมอง 358หลายเดือนก่อน
This short video explores different alignments of the foot relative to the floor when stepping forward, backward, and to the side. Of course, I explain my personal preference for each of these three modes.
Taiji stepping internals and externals: natural swing and optimal timing
มุมมอง 1Kหลายเดือนก่อน
In this video, exercises are shown on how to release the knees to achieve free swing of the lower leg. Then “Ward Off Left,” “Brush Knee Left,” and “Repulse Monkey” are analyzed in terms of swing and optimal timing of stepping.
Macro and micro balancing of yin and yang in Cloud Hands stepping
มุมมอง 4192 หลายเดือนก่อน
This video is an adjunct to my recent video on the timing of Cloud Hands stepping. “Preparation” and “Cloud Hands” are the only two Taiji movements involving stepping to the side in the Cheng Man-ch’ing and Yang long forms. In this video, both of these movements are analyzed from the perspective of balancing yin/yang and use of nei jin (expansive strength).
Anxiety and depression: some causes and natural remedies
มุมมอง 2042 หลายเดือนก่อน
The various causes of anxiety and depression and suggested remedies mentioned in this video stem from my own experience and over four decades of observing and helping students when I taught physics on the high school and college levels. Elements discussed are the effects of caffeine, sugar, negative thinking, and lack of sunlight and proper breathing. As promised, here is a link to the article ...
Learning Taiji in-person, on zoom, or from a video: comparisons of modalities
มุมมอง 2122 หลายเดือนก่อน
Learning Taiji in-person, on zoom, or from a video: comparisons of modalities
Hidden tracing, stretching, and inner-washing of qi in Taiji movements
มุมมอง 5422 หลายเดือนก่อน
Hidden tracing, stretching, and inner-washing of qi in Taiji movements
Should Taiji practitioners do contractive exercises?
มุมมอง 3562 หลายเดือนก่อน
Should Taiji practitioners do contractive exercises?
Lapses in continuity of Taiji movement: reasons and remedy
มุมมอง 3902 หลายเดือนก่อน
Lapses in continuity of Taiji movement: reasons and remedy
Neck Nei Gong for extending and opening the seven cervical vertebrae
มุมมอง 6902 หลายเดือนก่อน
Neck Nei Gong for extending and opening the seven cervical vertebrae
Cheng Man-ch’ing’s Taiji “Cloud Hands” stepping and other alternatives
มุมมอง 1.1K2 หลายเดือนก่อน
Cheng Man-ch’ing’s Taiji “Cloud Hands” stepping and other alternatives
Exploring the Taiji-Classics saying, “When moving, there is no part that doesn’t move.”
มุมมอง 7962 หลายเดือนก่อน
Exploring the Taiji-Classics saying, “When moving, there is no part that doesn’t move.”
Making the most of the elasticity of bodily tissues in doing Taiji
มุมมอง 5403 หลายเดือนก่อน
Making the most of the elasticity of bodily tissues in doing Taiji
Cheng Man-ch’ing’s Taiji: “Four Corners” stepping
มุมมอง 8003 หลายเดือนก่อน
Cheng Man-ch’ing’s Taiji: “Four Corners” stepping
An examination of “Single Whip” footwork in Cheng Man-ch’ing’s Taiji short form
มุมมอง 1.4K3 หลายเดือนก่อน
An examination of “Single Whip” footwork in Cheng Man-ch’ing’s Taiji short form
Song and Nei jin in Taij-their intertwined, paradoxical, yin/yang relationship
มุมมอง 4383 หลายเดือนก่อน
Song and Nei jin in Taij-their intertwined, paradoxical, yin/yang relationship
An alternative transition from “Carry Tiger To Mountain” to “Roll Back and Press”
มุมมอง 4633 หลายเดือนก่อน
An alternative transition from “Carry Tiger To Mountain” to “Roll Back and Press”
Pelvis and sacrum-understanding and activating their independent movements
มุมมอง 8243 หลายเดือนก่อน
Pelvis and sacrum-understanding and activating their independent movements
My spine Nei Gong routine for better posture and balance and less pain
มุมมอง 7083 หลายเดือนก่อน
My spine Nei Gong routine for better posture and balance and less pain
My teacher says, “turn, don’t turn.”
*IVE ONLY FELT IT ONCE* about a week ago - it was very strange and wonderful. I was doing Taiji and suddenly it required NO movement of the muscles consciously My arms and legs became sort of weightless and effortless to move, all I had to do was think the move and by some force I cant explain [Chi presumably] they just did it. Time stopped and serenity descended, I continued for about an hour. After I was in a world of total calm, like a pearl floating on a perfectly still ocean. It was one of the most profound experiences of my life.
Whenever a new experience such as this one occurs, it is good to lock in the feeling and then recreate it later. Otherwise, a breakthrough can evaporate. Writing it down, as you have done, is also good. Thanks for relating this experience.
@@dsfgnk4 Oh thats good advice. I never thought of it evaporating. I had a little bit of it today in a more minor way. But I will try to encourage it to happen again.
Very interesting 😀 indeed. My father took me to see a painter in New York ages ago, it was master Cheng Man Ching, who did some very strange, for a western eye, paintings. Cheers
“X-ray, not X-rated.” … ed
Body no twist, energy twist.
*I JUST WANT TO SAY* Ive been doing TaiJi [badly] every day for 5 years - where I live I can't get tuition so it has been exclusively TH-cam videos. Your videos have been a revelation. I am finally starting to "get it" and to get something from it. No one else has ever explained the fundamental principles, they just show you a movement and you copy it, usually completely incorrectly - pushing with your body LOOKS like pushing with your arms to the novice. I just want to say a heartfelt THANK YOU, Im now really enjoying it and making progress.
Thank you so much for your appreciative comment. Taiji has given me so much that my goal at this point is to give back whatever I can to Taiji and those who practice it. Your appreciation spurs me on.
@@dsfgnk4 THANK YOU - I am genuinely grateful.
🙏
As my current teacher says, "There is no 'hold the ball' in Yang style taiji.".
Hi again. The late master Fong Ha, brought Master Yu peng shi over who was famous in Shanghai for his empty force ability. Whist in the states scientists at Stanford asked the master to stand inside the particle accelerator and be bombarded. To their astonishment he deflected the particles in an egg shape around his body. So we have to accept the presence of a very powerful Qi shi, ( Qi field) whatever this is in terms of western science is… l myself in 1991 witnessed the senior student of Ma yieh Liang manifest empty force when attacked powerfully. He was an old man who had practiced push hands for over seventy years. Again a palpable force field surrounded the masters body and it was like two opposing magnets with the burly young attacker just being thrown through the air. My wife who is a scientist stood with her mouth open in astonishment and came away a complete believer. I would say that this is a very rare ability that only some very experienced masters achieve, not something to be chased after. Something that science has yet to explain is going on, it is not just tactics, timing and phycology , there is a force / Qi field involved. I have photo’s capturing the above eplisode.
Thank you for posting such an interesting account.
yes another lesson I really knew intuitively but did not adapt or follow, maybe because of seeing other people move externally. thanks for a stark reminder, I look forward to putting this into practice
Thanks for posting this comment. Many teachers who manifest the nei jin (expansive strength) required for creating roundness find nei jin difficult to teach. So students have to get it by “osmosis.” Part of the problem is the widespread belief that muscles are unable to extend., so mystical explanations are utilized, which can hold students back.
The ‘power’ starts from the earth, is controlled by the center and is expressed in the limbs. This is the basis of all movement, including holding the ball. So this needs to occur naturally, as you demonstrated. Everything is round, no sharp curves. As you showed in the beginning, most people hold it like an actual small ball, palms facing each other. When you look at the forming of ward of left from the starting position, the arms never stop. The left arm follows the body to the right and just before the body moves again to the left and forward, there is a brief moment where the left hand and right hand could be considered to be in a hold a ball position before moving to ward off left position. As the classics say, when one part of the body moves, everything moves; upper and lower body, left and right. When one part stops, everything stops. Like ward off left is only briefly there because the body keeps on turning left and therefore takes the hand with it , while causing the right hand to move left. When the body is at highest extension to the left it causes to go back to the right again and briefly position both hands in a hold the ball position again on the left side. The hands are in both ‘ball’ situations either at shoulder height and center height. Having both hands on one side helps with the balance of stepping with the opposite foot. The movement of the body helps shifting the balance in the feet, freeing a foot for the stepping. This is of course my opinion, and the way that I feel in my whole body the logical progression in the movement and balance. It s a constant shifting in Yin and Yang. There is already so much to explore and discover in these few positions. Still keep discovering new layers .
Myth busting in Tai Chi!
Very helpful. But now I have to start all over again.
I'm glad that it was helpful, and thanks for saying so!
Your opinion is the truth.
BE the ball - genius.
Great video! I would love to see these differences expressed in a partner's reaction.
In push-hands practice, having your body expanded and whatever your partner touches feeling like the surface of a ball, it is easy to roll him/her off. Thanks for your suggestion, and I’ll try to make a video of that.
@@dsfgnk4 Looking forward to it 🙂
Excellent description.
another great video, thank you.
Thanks for watching and appreciating.
🙏🙏🙏
🙏🙏🙏
*IF YOU WATCH THIS VIDEO* " Stuart Hameroff: Orch OR, Penrose, Fractal Consciousness" You will find information on the backwards time effect of consciousness in the microtubules of the brain cells. They have about 450m/s of backwards time effect. When a neuron is activated it takes about 500m/s of electrical activation but they trigger in 30m/s. If you give them 400m/s they DONT trigger after 30m/s but if you give them 500m/s of stimulation they trigger after 30m/s. So they know after 30m/s if they are to get 400 or 500 m/s of stimulus. They are a quantum system.
It's a bit like what I call 'menu' Chinese medicine which seems to focus on symptoms rather than causes. Acupuncture formulae/herbal remedies for.. followed by a long list of common ailments. It may be a way of attracting western patients into the real, wholistic, traditional Chinese medicine diagnosis of illness and imbalance, and educating them once they are 'in the door.'
It don’t mean a thing if it ain’t got that swing😂 Good one!
Thank You…Sir….
According to Wu I Shiang tradition ( who wrote a high percentage of the Tai ji classics) song is the compete relaxation of the big muscles downwards but not the bones. This called separating the muscle (yin) and the bones (yang) muscle down, bone up, The jing rises up through the body through 9 joints from ankle to wrist /hand as the big muscles on the outer surfaces. Muscles down and bones down is a form of double heavy. This information is from Master Liu ji Shun 5th generation direct lineage from the writers of the classics. The Cheng man jing tradition appears not to understand this,but maybe I am wrong.
Previous posting should have read ‘ from ankle to wrist /hand as the big muscles on the outer surfaces relax downwards in direct counterbalance’ This needs to be clear as this information is not widely known now and needs to be!
Thank you for watching and for providing the above detailed comment and the added clarification.
Another outstanding video! I cannot thank you enough for sharing your deep knowledge and experiences with us. You are truly a treasure… Be well.
I am so grateful to hear that my videos are enhancing others. My purpose is to add to an art from which I have attained so much benefit.
Thank you🩷
You’re welcome.
I'm loving this... prehaps you could talk about the weight shifting on the bottom of the feet? Sometimes I'm not sure about it.
Thanks for watching and expressing your appreciation. I think that the following video on finding the centers of the feet th-cam.com/video/pLN-lIKuVRY/w-d-xo.html may help with this question.
*YEARS AGO I USED TO DO A LOT OF FENCING* as in with a bendy sward. The instructor used to do a one-a-month session where novices would come in and thrash the living daylights out of each other for an hour - it was NOT fencing, it was hitting each other with a pointy stick, but out of every class of 30, 5 people would go on to learn it as a sport / hobby Thats how I started, everyone has to start a new thing in an accessible way.
Thank you so much for posting this relevant anecdote and cogent conclusion.
Yes tai chi has gotten off to a slow start in America due to the vast # of poor (inexperienced) teachers….
My teacher also emphasised awareness that everyone could come away from class with different understanding simply based on where you were standing in the room. Every senior instructor seemed to have a different flavour of the same system. It was always my job to try to make sense and integrate any teaching with my own current level of understanding.
Thank you for articulating this view. I have had the same experience with differences in teachers and senior instructors. And unraveling the differences was a strong developmental stimulus-especially in my having to sort out what seemed to be or what were contradictions.
Thank you
You're welcome
Reminds me of Hermetic Philosphies law of Coorespondance. "As above, so below." Interestingly when I started walking with a cane for stability (in my early 30s but hava a chronic pain condition.) I felt that concept of the root for the first time. My condition makes me buckle, but adding a stick makes me firm and in control as though I'm fully able.
Thank you!!!❤
Thanks for watching and appreciating.
As one of my teachers told us, when you understand yin and Yang, you understand taiji and other forms.
This is a controversial subject. Yun Shou commonly called cloud hands means to move something heavy from one side of the body to the other side and pack it downwards with the AN force. If you turn away at the end like you are doing you don’t express this, and miss the point of this movement. Hidden within Yun shou are the four directions of Peng Lu Ji An. Happy to discuss this with you. 50 years of practise .
I’ve been trying to incorporate abdominal breathing while doing these exercises. I really appreciate this video, as I do all of them, because it allows me access to your Taiji expertise. I wish I could make it to class. I’m sorry I don’t. By the time you have class I’ve already practiced an hour and am into the rest of the day. Thank you so much for this TH-cam channel you created. One of the best. … ed
Thanks for watching and commenting appreciatively.
Thank you for sharing, Mr. Chuckrow
Thanks for watching and appreciating.
Breathing is everything. Bill P.
Wonderful presentation! Thanks as always.
Thanks for watching, commenting, and appreciating.
🙏
Thanks, as a tai chi player it's really nice to be remembered and pointed to these ideas.
Thanks for expressing your appreciation.
Hello…i am french…and i dont speak english…not enough to understand your mots…but i undesrstand par ce que vous êtes ( by You are) …thank You Sir…. I pratique qi gong and taï Ji …un qi gong interne…depuis 1995…i pratique all the days…Norbert
Merci beaucoup d'avoir regardé et commenté même si vous ne parlez pas couramment l'anglais. (English translation: Thank you very much for watching and commenting even though you are not fluent in English.)
I get a great deal out of your videos and books. But on this question of side stepping I focused on this with my teacher recently with cloud hands, and he pointed out something that made sense once I could feel it in action. He had us try side stepping quickly multiple times moving in one direction, with the heal, with the flat foot, and with the ball of the foot. With the heal or the foot flat, we ended up clomping down and not feeling sure footed in the steps when done quickly, as opposed to when we briefly touch the ground first with the ball of the foot and softly securing the step. With the ball of the foot, we could side step far more quickly. It's not an exaggerated ball of the foot fist step, like a flowery ballerina, but rather a very natural subtle like a half inch touch down of the ball of the foot first to quickly secure the landing. It's about agility in being able to side step rapidly when we need to.
Thanks for introducing the subject of doing Taiji movement at different rates. I totally agree that there are differences in doing the form slowly and fast. Fast movement has much more linear and angular momentum and more energy. Also, the inertia of the legs makes stepping different. Such differences are why it is of value to do the form at different rates, and doing so brings out revelatory questions. For example, in doing the alternate left and right versions of “Brush Knee” slowly, we shift back (emptying the forward foot), turn and preset the forward foot outward, and then step forward with the rear foot. If you try to do alternate “Brush Knees” very fast, you will find that it is almost impossible to shift back before presetting the forward foot. Instead, it is now natural to turn and preset the forward foot with 70% of the weight on that foot, that is, without shifting back first. My view is that there are different elements that can be learned from different rates of movement. In daily life, for example, the dynamics of walking leisurely is quite different from that of running at maximum speed. That doesn’t mean that we should try to do both the same way.
A gem of a video Doc! I think Damo Mitchell has written as to changing the weight (rocking forwards and backwards from heel to toe also.Master Luke Chan recommends internal rotation via the 3 Dan Tien's (externally at, first) see method ....
Thanks for watching and appreciating.
Have you come across Dr Alis ultimate back book where he covers similar ideas
I am not familiar with this book. Does Dr. Alis emphasize the idea of extending muscles/tissues rather than contracting muscles to elongate the spine?
@@dsfgnk4 Yes, he talks about the anti gravitational work of muscles maintaining good posture. He goes into a lot of anatomy and physiology and exercise routines for healthy spine maintenance. He has an holistic approach and reinforces a lot of what you seem to teach. I remember in one of my early tai chi lessons, a senior instructor came up to me and simply ran his hand up and down my back. I don't think he said much but he was giving me a lesson.
Indeed! In particular, learning to open the spine means '(re-)finding' and using the erector spinae and multifidus muscle groups. I too have gained much improvement by suspending the headtop as a practice.
😊 thanks
You are welcome.
Great video thank you! this is something ive been working on. I have a question and would be grateful for any tips - i have flat feet and rolling in arches and knees that naturally point inward. When i do the knees inward/outward excersise, to maintain correct ‘hip knee foot’ alignment, i need to push my knees outward to as wide as i can go. When i do this, my arch does raise and there is a torque on my feet (toes wanting to rotate outward) that is resisted by the friction of my shoes on the ground. Any tips for this would be appreciated, thank you
Thanks for appreciating and commenting. Changing a life-long habit of alignment is not easy and takes repeated effort over time. Habitual patterns of incorrect alignment may feel natural, but the body eventually recognize that what it thought was natural is not so. It is important not to overdo such changes but, instead, try for small, incremental amounts. Perhaps the following two videos will help: Extending your adductor muscles-learn the importance and ability: th-cam.com/video/3uLf4bMx2_A/w-d-xo.html and Knee, Ankle, Arch Alignment: th-cam.com/video/bvobQW_Lfzc/w-d-xo.html.n
Thank you, this is really helpfull. Maybe you could do a Video for the use of the pelvis in Tai Chi? If it should be pushed Forward or just be in a natural state. That would be very interesting 😊
Thanks for asking this excellent question. I do have a youtube video th-cam.com/video/ovX9Z_zFyoM/w-d-xo.html showing the physiological relationships of the pelvis and sacrum. In that video, I make the point the the pelvis naturally opens and closes during breathing. In my view, other than opening and closing with breathing and the opening and closing movements of the form. the pelvis should rest in its neutral orientation (not tilted forward or back) when doing the Taiji form. Some students are told to tuck the tailbone, and I disagree with that idea. To make things worse, some students, instead, tilt the pelvis. Doing so can result from an inability to distinguish between a movement of the pelvis and that of the spine (that anatomy is shown in the linked video). It is important to know/feel when the alignment of the pelvis strays from neutral. Such straying may be appropriate depending on the movement of the rest of the body in different situations. In my view, the spine should be extended along its length. The reaction to such upward expansion produces a downward pressure on the sacrum and a resulting slight rotational movement of the tailbone and pelvis.
@@dsfgnk4 thank you for your detailed answer. That's exactly my problem, tucking the tailbone feels to tensed, but when i relax my pelvis it feels like my lower back is curving and my tailbone goes in the outward direction. But that's the fun about Taiji, to feel and experiment until we found out whats the problem. I'm looking forward to watch your Video and get more details.
@@Fudoshinmatsu I just uploaded a video that might shed some light on the lower back and tailbone: “The head is suspended from above; a weight pulls the tailbone down.” th-cam.com/video/dh0FrhX_EJE/w-d-xo.html
@@dsfgnk4 thank you very much, you are so kind 🙂