วีดีโอ

Between measure 23 and the begening of 24 don't you consider it as an episode? I thought that in fugue or you have subject/countersubject or you have an episode. I'm not daring you, I'm really asking because I am studying for an Analysis test. Thank you!

5:59

Very good analysis. I think it would be more engaging with more examples played after each description of a section!

In measure 47 and others, you missed the entry of the roughly 1.5-times augmentation of the subject. So, Bach used two augmentations of the subject.

Can you do the Fugue in E Minor, BWV 548?

Thank you for this great explanation! This video should deserve soo much more attention...but I think it is more important that you stand behind what you are doing. I think you mastered this in a great way. Just as Bach as a composer in his life. Thank you!

There is no audio

It would be (I think) more helpful to do this type of analysis by playing the examples being discussed as they are being discussed. Otherwise it ends up functionally more like a theory lecture from a course at Yale University.. I agree with the other commentor who suggests that a playback at 75% is closer to the note values given as well as the way it is usually played. Kimiko is uncharacteristically pressured sounding in this performance. I love Smalins upload of bwv 849 with a "chorus of space aliens". th-cam.com/video/aLoMsi54-nI/w-d-xo.htmlsi=xKY6CedIPGoJqEyA. There is another analysis of this piece by Richard Atkinson which is quite lovely, th-cam.com/video/lP-8C1UF1mE/w-d-xo.htmlsi=aAxv61YVs_sI-Yoi

BIZGA SHU FUGANI OʻZBEKCHA TARJIMASI KERAK EDI MUMKINMI YOZIB TUSHINTIRSEZ BIZ BUNI OʻZBEKCHAGA TARJIMA QILARDIK

Excellent

There is one point discussed at the end of Measure 19 to the start of Measure 21: This part should end at A Minor, instead of A Major

Quite a few of Bach's fugues are hard to follow, but once you can follow them, they are in a league of their own. Thank you a lot this analysis!

Thx bro❤

nothing in Bach is "coincidence"

Have you seen smalin's visualisation of the BWV 867? See the final stretto with all five voices coming together... th-cam.com/video/k2d-s8U1tfM/w-d-xo.html

What a lovely Fugue, Good Analysis!

Thank you very much! This is the fugue I asked some time ago. I really like the theme. It makes me think of loneliness and cold, like being alone in the middle of the snow. I find it beautifull how at the end it finishes with major chord. Now with this analysis I can understand it better, in a more rational point of view. Thanks again for the hard work!

Love this analysis! Helps my playing tremendously.

I just posted this Prelude and Fugue, then I see the notification from your channel! Another awesome analysis, thank you! The theme from the Fugue has something very sinister about it, it makes me think of a ghost wandering in an empty hallway. P. S. I always thought the theme to be slightly longer, including (in the first appearance) the notes C, D-flat, E-flat and F. Don't you think this could be the case too? For most appearances of the theme, this upward moving melody is included.

great video !!

Very enjoyable, thank you. I'll have to see if I remember any of it when I'm practicing the piece!

You didn't talk about the altered subjects? Those in G minor.

Great analysis! Could you explain what stretto is?

i really love classical music and i have just discover you; im exited great job

Bach invented many beautiful melodies (subjects) for his fugues - this ain’t one of ‘em. As always his supreme skill turns this straw into gold at times but parts of this piece are pretty abrasive and lack his usual flow of peaceful modulations.

Thank you, wonderful and concise analysis! Looking forward to the next one

It is no second countersubject, it is a second theme.

This hidden gem channel deserves much more views and subs. Thank you for analysis.

Hi, I have a question, why did you mark the main voice in two different colors at first in pink and after that when he enters the third bar again in purple?

Amazing work! Would you like to make a video on the Bb minor from book 1 aswell?

There is one inversion subject from Measure 45 to Measure 48 in Soprano (Only 2 Beats After the inversion subject from Measure 44 to Measure 47) and this one is left out

Awesome analysis, but I wished you talked more about the harmonic modulations that Bach uses because they are quite insane.

Yay! I'm happy again.

Thank you!

I'm studying that one rn

Fascinating and really useful analysis - thank you!

Very nice fugue! Thank you for the great analysis and clear explanation :)

4:16 - Let's listen to the fugue.

yo toke esta

esta es muy facil y muy simple

Great video, thank you for sharing.

Thank you for your analysis and the excellent performance by Kimiko Ishizaka

I recorded this piece on my channel (I learned it for an exam). This video was really eye opening.

will you give us also beethovem 4?

Great analysis!