วีดีโอ

21:18 😂😂

He’s all about lines. Nice.

Wow he’s asking her to totally change her style, but good suggestions. Her time isn’t clean.

Wow he’s asking her to totally change her style, but good suggestions. Her time isn’t clean. She does have some gutsy interpretation though. I know she wants to get onto the next part!😂

I had Andreas Schiff's CD and it was my most precious possession for a long time in my youth, he helped my brain develop and go through hard times. Literally. So happy to see this masterclass! This being said, the student is quite brilliant and picks up the improvements fast!

LAME.

It is refreshing to hear and watch Maestro Schiff explain the character of the work, its structure and narrative, including with graphic images, as in a painting with perspective- i.e., space and distance, which also modulates the degree of sound and nuance. The young lady is extremely gifted, and it was a pleasure to hear her performance as well as Schiff's analysis and recommendations. This was a thoroughly enjoyable master class.

Saw her live this year, truly such a pleasant touch and sublime phrasing

He's a great teacher! She's great too, but should be more patient and listen to the teacher always before playing. The language of the music and metaphors that he provides are longer lasting and more valuable than just this piece itself.

Wow what a performance

She deserves to have a lesson from somebody like Mr. Schiff.

Ignas is a talented pianist for sure, but, to me, he tends to bias too much on the exuberant, fast and loud side; and this detracts from the interest of the piece. His approach is more Liszt than Chopin.

Brilliant!!

"Like far away far away...."

What a wonderful player this young girl is! I think Mr Schiff did help her! Thanks for posting! 🌸🌹🥰🦄🎹🎶🌺😍😝💐🍀🦋👍😀

Simply something that cannot be “taught” - instinct. Frustating. The una corda should be stricken from the piano. It simply muffles the sound and too many pianists who lack listening use it. A pianist should be able to play a pianissimio that can he heard in any corner of a concert hall. Too few can. It is an offensive sound on any piano.

She's very responsive to his comments. Wonderful event!

Absolutely great responses from Karlis to the Maestro’s suggestions 👏

Without the teacher there cannot be a student.

Lol she was so nice to those singers although they're really quite boring.

Excelente 👌

It is astounding how many colors Yefim is able to produce.

I almost feel like they could be to fall in love, I honestly find women in clothes that cover their entire bodies, like Yulliana Avdeeva, very attractive.

the hugest artist I have ever seen.

The Baritone is actually a Tenor, his chest voice is really good, he needs more release. The soprano doesn't have developed chest voice, and I don't think Netrebko is a good example for a young singer, Sembrich, Callas, Zeani, Tetrazzini are far better examples.

Студент S SS играл очень хорошо c небольшими индивидуальным отклонениями ,которые делали Его интерпретацию очень Интересной. ЕФ. все Отнивелировал

cтуденту 1+++++

all the people here in the comments complain about Maisky's talking, and I think nobody got the real point. All he told was more useful than any tips on how ro play this piece. Maisky told simply that to play at a very artistic level one must have special heartfull features, and those features one has naturally or you cannot build them, no matter what kind of technic and school. He speaks at an incredibly high artistic and human level, but people wanted to hear "play like this, play like that".

피아노 피치가 너무 높다. 거의 반음을 올린것처럼… 레코딩때에 가끔 높이기도하지만…베토벤 피아노 소나타엔 이토록 높일 필요가없다. 베토벤이 이소나타를 듣는다면 기암하겠다…ㅠ.ㅠ

I think Andris needs to work on finding more warmth in his sound, but given the circumstances, nerves get in the way. And his pronunciation is good but there are things he can improve as well, like double consonants. The goal is vocal freedom to express the meaning of the words and intentions of the character, and sing beautifully.

We should be grateful to Leif Ove Andsnes and other world-class pianists who are willing to offer master classes. Its also noteworthy that in so many cases, the masters have to correct the mistakes done by students which involve the very basic principle or fundamentals of piano playing

1 Danills Kuzmis - questo bravo ragazzo non è baritono vero , è un tenore . 2 65 anni fa i giovani mettevano una moneta tra i denti per trovare la posizione giusta… Questa bellissima ragazza canta in modo assurdo , la Maestra non dice niente … La scuola moderna sta ignorando l’esistenza dei Trattati di canto come quello di Garcia dove un giovane può trovare tutte le indicazioni utili per cantare … Come cantavano i giovani 65 anni fa ?! Era molto semplice di cantare gli alunni avevano delle bellissime voci da giovani. Mi ricordo una ragazzina che a soli 18 anni interpretava Violetta sul palco, Germont aveva 20… no comment il vecchio

Bravo!!!Bravo!!!Bravo!!!🎉🎉🎉

That piano needs some tuning!!! 🎹🤬

Such a nice guy trying to communicate music to people with the musical warmth of a table.

Mischa is so skilled at managing to do so little with so much time💀

There are no more James Bond movies so the Bond girls retired too and I can see that at least one of them took up piano❤

Master András. Chill. Music also has a visual aspect.

You can clearly tell you’re dealing with an incredibly professional singer. Renee Fleming is giving her full attention and respect to the students. It is so rare to find a Masterclass where the coach, in this case Fleming, actually takes the time to work even on the smallest of nuances. She’s being so true to the art. I love this and these students are so fortunate!

ひまりさんの善き練習パートナーとして宜しくお願いします。

What the fuck has this dude to do in the Hammerklavier????😅😅😅

talented Daniils and Ilze!

beautiful!

He absolutely loves to hear himself talk. No way he calls a 38 minute monologe a "masterclass"

En fait, au final, ces chanteurs doivent réapprendre à chanter. Ils ont tout simplement une mauvaise technique. Une belle voix, de beaux vêtements mais une mauvaise technique… En plus ils n’articulent pas.

Burkhardt glazener played the flute style notes on his Mozart oboe concert. Why does nobody do that?

學生是奇才，導師滿臉歡愉，慈愛⋯⋯傾囊相授。很棒的視頻。旋律很優美清新。仿如清晨推開兩扇一塵不染的木窗，浸浴在山林好聞的空氣中，純白色柔軟的窗紗輕輕地揚起，舞動⋯⋯

I am the first to like and comment on this video! I hope not the last

Lovely play Pauls

It seems as if she is bothered by him teaching her ...she clenches her jaw and has facial expressions of a angry child at times. A bit more humility would do her well...though she just may be frustrated with herself