- 94
- 618 775
Archaeology Tube
United States
เข้าร่วมเมื่อ 4 มิ.ย. 2021
Join Dr. Bill Farley for an exploration of archaeology, ancient history, and media criticism.
Flint Dibble, Joe Rogan, Graham Hancock, and What Comes Next
#realarchaeology #GrahamHancock #joerogan #archaeology
A candid discussion with Dr. Flint Dibble about how he prepared for and carried out his debate with Graham Hancock on the Joe Rogan Experience. We also discuss what's happened since the debate, our feelings about guys like Dan Dedunker, and where we go from here to promote quality science communication.
Apologies parts of the footage of my video were corrupted, so some long shots on Flint listening to me talk because of it. You didn't miss much, I promise.
th-cam.com/users/flintdibble
www.sapiens.org/archaeology/graham-hancock-joe-rogan-archaeology/
th-cam.com/video/z6kgvhG3AkI/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/-DL1_EMIw6w/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/dC1P6PPgxtc/w-d-xo.htmlsi=jjfyczFcaCojhf-8
grahamhancock.com/skinnerhl2/
A candid discussion with Dr. Flint Dibble about how he prepared for and carried out his debate with Graham Hancock on the Joe Rogan Experience. We also discuss what's happened since the debate, our feelings about guys like Dan Dedunker, and where we go from here to promote quality science communication.
Apologies parts of the footage of my video were corrupted, so some long shots on Flint listening to me talk because of it. You didn't miss much, I promise.
th-cam.com/users/flintdibble
www.sapiens.org/archaeology/graham-hancock-joe-rogan-archaeology/
th-cam.com/video/z6kgvhG3AkI/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/-DL1_EMIw6w/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/dC1P6PPgxtc/w-d-xo.htmlsi=jjfyczFcaCojhf-8
grahamhancock.com/skinnerhl2/
มุมมอง: 4 160
วีดีโอ
Bright Insight Lied
มุมมอง 1.9K2 หลายเดือนก่อน
#realarchaeology #BrightInsight #Archaeology Let's talk about Jimmy Corsetti's (Bright Insight) tweet for nearly twenty minutes. Why what he says about funding and Göbekli Tepe doesn't make sense, and the real story of where archaeologists get their funding. www.aslinda.com/prof-dr-necmi-karul-gobeklitepede-kazilar-durmadi x.com/mattsibson/status/1817673832313892954?s=46
Graham Hancock and Flint Dibble Debate: An Archaeologist's Thoughts
มุมมอง 11K6 หลายเดือนก่อน
#realarchaeology #archaeology Just some quick thoughts and unpacking of the debate and discussion between Flint Dibble and Graham Hancock on Joe Rogan's podcast. References www.sapiens.org/archaeology/graham-hancock-joe-rogan-archaeology/ ArchaeologyGame/status/1780377203647152161 th-cam.com/video/-DL1_EMIw6w/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/z6kgvhG3AkI/w-d-xo.html www.thedailybeast.com...
Graham Hancock UNvindicated? Gunung Padang Paper Retracted #archaeology #gunungpadang #archeology
มุมมอง 3.8K7 หลายเดือนก่อน
#realarchaeology #archaeology #grahamhancock #ancientapocalypse #Indonesia #gunungpadang #archeology Last year's paper claiming the existence of a 20,000 year old underground pyramid in Indonesia has been retracted by Archaeological Prospection. Let's explore the context, the paper, the retraction, and why it does (and sort of doesn't) matter. th-cam.com/video/1lcXrF9GvwA/w-d-xo.html www.youtub...
Don't Be Like James Somerton: Advice on Citations and Plagiarism #plagiarism #citation #youtube
มุมมอง 58K10 หลายเดือนก่อน
An introduction to the basics of citations, works cited, footnotes, endnotes, parenthetical citations, and more. A discussion of how to use these tools in academic writing and how to apply these ideas to making online content on places like TH-cam. Building on the excellent essay by @hbomberguy Additional Resources Including Examples and Guides Northern Illinois University www.niu.edu/academic-...
Is the Oldest Pyramid in Indonesia? Analyzing Gunung Padang #archaeology #gunungpadang #archeology
มุมมอง 10K11 หลายเดือนก่อน
Is the Oldest Pyramid in Indonesia? Analyzing Gunung Padang #archaeology #gunungpadang #archeology
How Do I get a Doctorate? Walking through the PhD process #gradschool #college #university
มุมมอง 575ปีที่แล้ว
How Do I get a Doctorate? Walking through the PhD process #gradschool #college #university
Were people in America 130,000 years ago? An archaeologist discusses the Cerutti Mastodon site
มุมมอง 29Kปีที่แล้ว
Were people in America 130,000 years ago? An archaeologist discusses the Cerutti Mastodon site
Where do archaeological sites come from?
มุมมอง 667ปีที่แล้ว
Where do archaeological sites come from?
The Oldest Stone Tools Ever? Update from Kenya!
มุมมอง 1.8Kปีที่แล้ว
The Oldest Stone Tools Ever? Update from Kenya!
The World's First Graphic Novel: 11,000 Years Old, New Discoveries!
มุมมอง 3.4Kปีที่แล้ว
The World's First Graphic Novel: 11,000 Years Old, New Discoveries!
Graham Hancock and Ancient Apocalypse: Debunking Myths About the Netflix Show
มุมมอง 57Kปีที่แล้ว
Graham Hancock and Ancient Apocalypse: Debunking Myths About the Netflix Show
Graham Hancock is the Jordan Peterson of Archaeology: A Response to Netflix's Ancient Apocalypse
มุมมอง 46Kปีที่แล้ว
Graham Hancock is the Jordan Peterson of Archaeology: A Response to Netflix's Ancient Apocalypse
Top 10 Fictional Archaeologists of All Time
มุมมอง 7162 ปีที่แล้ว
Top 10 Fictional Archaeologists of All Time
Archaeology Painting Tutorial: How to Draw and Paint a Stone Tool
มุมมอง 4372 ปีที่แล้ว
Archaeology Painting Tutorial: How to Draw and Paint a Stone Tool
An Archaeologist Reacts to Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom
มุมมอง 5662 ปีที่แล้ว
An Archaeologist Reacts to Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom
An Archaeologist Plays Elden Ring: Leyndell Royal Capital
มุมมอง 5162 ปีที่แล้ว
An Archaeologist Plays Elden Ring: Leyndell Royal Capital
Archaeology! 19th Century Walkway Revealed
มุมมอง 3322 ปีที่แล้ว
Archaeology! 19th Century Walkway Revealed
Why do we preserve things? Final Fantasy 7 Remake, Nostalgia, and historical preservation
มุมมอง 1.4K2 ปีที่แล้ว
Why do we preserve things? Final Fantasy 7 Remake, Nostalgia, and historical preservation
"Don't Let the Door Hit Your Butt On the Way Out, Vargas": Playing and Reading FF6 (PIXEL REMASTER)
มุมมอง 902 ปีที่แล้ว
"Don't Let the Door Hit Your Butt On the Way Out, Vargas": Playing and Reading FF6 (PIXEL REMASTER)
"This is Trypophobia Hell": My Partner Plays Elden Ring
มุมมอง 3442 ปีที่แล้ว
"This is Trypophobia Hell": My Partner Plays Elden Ring
Is Outer Wilds the Best Archaeology Game Ever?
มุมมอง 8K2 ปีที่แล้ว
Is Outer Wilds the Best Archaeology Game Ever?
Playing Your First Fromsoft Game is Hard!
มุมมอง 1742 ปีที่แล้ว
Playing Your First Fromsoft Game is Hard!
How to Get to the Bottom of the Subterranean Shunning Grounds in Elden Ring
มุมมอง 115K2 ปีที่แล้ว
How to Get to the Bottom of the Subterranean Shunning Grounds in Elden Ring
An Archaeologist Plays Elden Ring: Beyond Stormveil
มุมมอง 2422 ปีที่แล้ว
An Archaeologist Plays Elden Ring: Beyond Stormveil
Spirit Jellyfish is the Key to Bosses in Early Elden Ring
มุมมอง 1.4K2 ปีที่แล้ว
Spirit Jellyfish is the Key to Bosses in Early Elden Ring
An Archaeologist Plays Elden Ring (FIRST IMPRESSIONS)
มุมมอง 7102 ปีที่แล้ว
An Archaeologist Plays Elden Ring (FIRST IMPRESSIONS)
We our nearer than ever to discovering evidence that Atlantis is in fact very real . Then negative people like Flint will have egg on there faces.
Call me when you have evidence
After watching this entire video I have came to the conclusion that you are very focused on trying to disprove the paper but not focused enough on answering serious questions raised from this site as I can one say after traveling there that it is most definitely NOT natural. Hancock might be full of shit but who cares whats really going on in this site and how can we get answers
It being natural is not my opinion it is the conclusion of every legitimate geologist who has analyzed the site. This video is a critique of the archaeology, something I can actually speak on and which I can assure you is quite bad
A fascinating video, also amusing, but we worry that this "National Trust policy" comment at 11:50 might ignite Hancock fandom. The problem only ever is private ownership of everyone's legacy. Corporatism feeds conspiracy thinking.
You’re talking about data privacy stuff here? There are times when there are legal restrictions about when and how data can be released. This rarely if ever is because of private or corporate concerns. More often it’s related to governmental restrictions, and ones that are usually pretty reasonable. Like when sites are located in or around military locations or important infrastructure. I promise you this is not used maliciously. Sometimes exact site locations - not site data - but locations are restricted to prevent looting. This I can tell you is very important. Like sometimes there are rules about how big the dot on your map needs to be so that readers can tell where a site is located within a few square kilometers, but not close enough so someone could grab a shovel and go dig it up.
@@ArchaeologyTube Interesting! And that makes perfect sense - the need for certain privacies as related to site security. But what I thought I heard being described, because I am culturally conditioned to hear in this way, was of some sort of IP situation standing between the people and their own data. It's exactly that kind of corporatist gatekeeping (and not the necessary limitations you describe above) that creates the cultural voids in which conspiracy theories run riot. So kudos for opening up this informative (and entertaining) line of discussion, and please keep it going! What urgently needs examining by #RealArchaeology (please!) is the situation at Barabar. Because there we are informed of ancient precision on a massive scale: the human-made chambers are, we are told, leagues of difficulty beyond vases, statuary, and sarcophagi. Of course, my source on Barabar is the unabashed fabulists at "BAM" (Builders of the Ancient Mysteries). Still. How'd the ancestors do that? "Over generations, by hand" - is as unsatisfying an answer as aliens or sound waves.
@@ArchaeologyTube No, I misunderstood you. What you describe here makes perfect sense. I was thinking of science journal paywalls, IP, and other forms of institutional corruption by money profit. A mishearing, but it just goes to show the miserable wavelength one is tuned to under capitalism. In his conjuration of a lost high-tech civilization Hancock does at least speak to the need for moderns to radically rethink our nonexistent sense of a spiritual life. Then again, it is rather bizarre to suggest that there is some missing bit of tech that might make our souls whole. This is an excellent channel. Please discuss Barabar in northeastern India and the claims made about it by the BAM folk. Thank you!
Bright Insight is hysterical and creating content for views. Conspiracies will always get views from people who can’t think critically. I hope Jimmy has the resilience to withstand criticism, he seems to have good support around him.
From my experience, he unfortunately does not have that resilience
Everyone makes it look so easy 😭 but if I could beat Malenia, I can definitely beat this stupid tree
You can do it!
@ArchaeologyTube I did end up doing it lol
I love the fact Dibble is basking in some kind of “victory” because Graham H didn’t respond after the debate. Meanwhile Grahams been invited back on Rogan where they rubbished Flint for 2 hrs 🙈🙈🙈
No surprise that Joe would retreat to his adoration of Hancock. Neither are known for their rationality.
@@Eyes_Open rationality ? Dibble came across as a dick, who can’t he leave other people do their thing ? There’s a reason Rogan and Hancock are so popular - they’re likeable and talk about interesting stuff. Don’t like it - switch over 🤷♂️
Guess Graham needs safe spaces
I’d love more videos! Just riffing and sharing your current thoughts. I saw that Graham is being newly promoted on huge channels (Alex Friedman) and has his new video about “I’m a victim of Flint Dibble’s master manipulation” on his channel. It’s frustrating to me as a former fan of his who felt like I was leaving a cult when I discovered real archeologists and historians. I was literally saving up money to go on a tour with UnchartedX, I’d purchased most of Hancock’s books and even given them out as gifts! I feel like I discovered real archeologists by a sort of miracle (a random reply to a comment on an UnchartedX video, about 100 responses down, saying simply “check out sacred geometry decoded to see how it was done.” The comment intrigued me, so I did, and my mind was blown. That led me to many legitimate channels including yours. That one comment was removed from UnchartedX’s video within a couple days, that’s how tightly he keeps his comments in check, so his fans don’t see any sort of pushback. It’s like a cult! This is what cult leaders do. And it’s kind of heartbreaking to see now whole new groups of young people just discovering Graham and “realizing” suddenly that Big Archeology is the evil of the world. Graham used to have a ton of older fans, my step father in his 70s for example. But now he’s being paraded out by incredibly large platforms with ZERO PUSHBACK and getting young generations in the tens or hundreds of thousands. I guess I just feel sad. I’m 35, I thought I was the last and youngest of his followers, but it’s like a never ending conspiracy loop. And it’s doing real damage in the world. It’s promoting and insulating racists. I’m sure you feel more frustrated than I do. Anyway, thanks and please more videos!
2024 thanks a lot it worked u are the best 😎
dishonest flint dribble the degrass tyson of archaeology
You are not afraid to publicize your ignorance on the matter.
@@Eyes_Open eyes open bah ha ha ha talk about delusional . You're a massive professor Dave fanboy aren't you ?
@@Eyes_Open the fact dribble has to "pre bunk" the new season of ancient apocalypse is proof people like you (brain dead sheep) have no interest in even listening to alternate narratives . I honestly feel sorry for you how many times do you need to see we have been lied to about almost everything for you to wake up ?
@@jakebarns8247Why are you still responding? You want to believe that THEY are lying to you. You have trapped yourself in a mental prison with many other sheep who refuse to engage in actual study.
@@Eyes_Open your taking the piss rite ? Do you watch Flint exclusively ? Take the time to watch Graham's response and you will see Flint DIbble is dishonest tactically persuasive not to mention arrogant and smug to boot . Greyham may be wrong and he is the first to admit that if you took the time to actually watch his presentations . Anyway you have fun watching Dibble dribble if that's what turns you on 😘
Flint Diddle lied
Be the first human to prove your accusation. Dan the Deceiver failed.
DIBBLE YOU ARE A DRIBBLE ON YOUR UNDERWEAR. HANCOCK OWNS YOU!!!!!
Grow up.
Comparing the possible idea as congruent to Flat Earth is ridiculous Fred. No contact?? Graham wrote to you right after the debate did he not giving you kudos for your performance ? He’s also offered quite an interesting response to your baffling 3,000,000 shipwreck argument. And you ran with that as “proof”. Fred - you seem to gloat in a victory there in your mind. Nobody knew who you were before the debate ! I’m not a Hancock disciple - he merely offers interesting opinions and challenges a standard narrative that’s been wrong many times in the past !
Flint publicly acknowledged his mistake about the 3000000 number and explained how it happened. Hancock made a video while ignoring the explanation from Flint. Hancock the anti-hero.
Flint dibble is really unlikeable- he’s latching onto Graham Hancock as his giving him exposure.
Dibble is way too self satisfied and pompous. He is the epitome of why people question the narrative of people like Dibble. He is a very passive aggressive child. Super insecure.
Attack the person when you can't refute the evidence. Well done.
@@Eyes_Openit’s not like I attacked the way he looks. They are character observations. I’m definitely not wrong. He is off putting. And a prime example of Uber liberalism in academia.
@@suggadeg You and I do not personally know the man. However, I see someone who I think would easily fit in to a casual social gathering. I see intelligence and empathy. I also see many people who want to believe that academia is wrong and that people like Hancock are correct because reasons. I don't know what forms your viewpoint.
@@Eyes_OpenI think you and I have fundamentally different ideas about people. I don’t think anyone knows exactly what happened in antiquity. I don’t have any cemented opinion, one way or the other. I see dibble as a man who wants to be right more than anything else, and make people who disagree with him look foolish. Hence, pompous. Also, he has made social justice a part of his identity. History shouldn’t be attached to any ideology. So, yeah, I don’t think very highly of his character. I see someone who is trying very, very, very hard to be right and make others look foolish. I don’t see empathy at all. I see vanity.
@@suggadeg The goal of Flint is to open up knowledge to the public and demonstrate the illogical narrative of people like Hancock and the shady tactics of for-profit alternative gurus.
Yeah but u guys also get it wrong, ALOT. How many times have archaeologists have had to admit they're wrong, or don't admit it and get proven wrong? Also why do u dress like a wanna be indiana jones?
Sure. Archaeologists are wrong sometimes. They admit and work on finding the correct answer which is how science works. Not a common tactic on the pseudoarch side from my experience.
this still works btw if anyones wondering
flint is a liar, there are no 1 mil ship wrecks documented theres an est, byt it only goes back about 5000 yrs. hes also lied about everything else hes said about Mr Hancock. hes a bully trying to prove himself right rather than speak the truth. he showed a graph, that only goes back to about the time he did archaeology on animals. trying to make yourself relevant off someone else hard work by calling them a liar, a white supremacist and other nastiness will only make people not like you. dont give this jackoff anymore air time, i will make sure i never see another one of your videos
Love you!!
Thank you, Flint, for appearing on Rogan. I am a perfect example of the kind of person you were trying to reach. I'd listened to Hancock out of curiosity before, and seeing him fumble to respond to your clear evidence was incredibly revealing. Thank you again.
The rebuttle ......... th-cam.com/video/PEe72Nj-AW0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=_MtXtzS6bnFamqM2
@@slewcharles926 Thank you for taking the time to share that. I'm halfway through and Graham has already made some good points about Flint's arguments. I would definitely be interested in hearing them converse again.
@@nicholaslindley1982 if people take away the anger and attacks on each other , maybe they can see that we are all trying to learn the same thing ...... what really happened in our past .....
@@nicholaslindley1982 have you seen the response now Graham has had the time to fact check Dibbles fraudulent PROVABLY deceiving debate tactics ?? I suggest ya check it out before you credit Flint DIbble with anything it's a disgrace the other "real" archaeologists. I don't agree with all Graham's work but I won't stand by and watch this weezle mock somebody's hard work for views or whatever his drive is it's pathetic. Do you believe in the racist narrative? The attacks on this man shows he must be onto something a racist pseudo archioligist that's married to a black woman ha ha . Wake up FFS
1000 years from now, an “archeologist” will discover Washington DC, and will conclude it was built the Egyptians and the Greeks.
No they won’t lol
Hello, what is the second pencil you use?
Thanks!!!!!!!!!!❤
Bro, this shitty tips make me ruined my 30mín 😭😭😭
Dont work with me 😢
You very cool
Appreciate professioanls speaking up! Thank ya much.
Thank you both again for posting this interesting discussion, and the work you do. I had missed the tale-end of it and just rewatched now. The idea of an interdisciplinary and mutually supportive archaeological-content creator and educator “Fair” or “Circus” would likely gain considerable interest, support and viewership. Though, one thought regarding a “circus” reference. It flys too close to “circus clowns (🤡)”. And may open it up to relentless attacks by the pseudo-crowd, calling it a “clown-show” and referring to participants as “clowns”, etc., due to that. -As you both point out, these folks look for and go after the lowest hanging fruit in these discussions and attack it ad-nauseam.
trying to platform in this place with a broken analog on my controller is giving me madness irl
First try tysm ur a life saver
Still works haha Thanks a ton
is it not possible that the mastodons died 130,000 and were discovered by early hominids around 10-15,000 years ago and smashed using the hamerstones to then use them for bone tools Here on Quadra Island B.C. I have located many 12,000 year old sites when ocean levels were much higher I am puzzled by the large areas were lithics are seen usually waterworn and have strong evidence of use/wear I would appreciate a link to anyone that is exploring early sites on the Pacific coast .......and thanks for your critique of this paper I feel Nature is akin to Readers Digest ....all the best Paul
Not in this case, no. Spiral fracturing on the bones implies. They were broken while fresh meaning before or shortly after the death of the animal this is actually the only thing that’s viral fracturing shows for sure. It doesn’t actually prove human intervention can be a sign of it
@@ArchaeologyTube thanks
Clearly an herbivore. Not big enough to be deer or elk but not small either. Hard to accurately guess because I don’t know the logistics of the picture. For example: where in the world it was taken, the natural flora and fauna of the area, etc.
It’s proooobably sheep or goat
Its not modern humans aka Homo Sapiens..since modern humanos not yet existing. Another HOMINID Species most likely Homo Erectus Variety ! 😊
Oh yeah, I cover that in the video. It would need to be a different hominid, erectus perhaps, or some offshoot of erectus closely related to denisovans and Neanderthals.
@@ArchaeologyTube am in full agreement. Great video
Wrong
A powerful rebuttal
Just do a photogrammetry
Taking off armor seemed to help me. Don’t know if it as a legit reason
You lost me at white supremacy😒
Okay
Jimmy loves peddling nazi talking points! And his lovely viewers showing nazi talking points too
Damn, can't believe people like you are archeologists. No wonder western schools are dying.
A ton of people freaking out come across as trapped in misinformed echo chamber at best if not severely mentally or in some cases wildly hateful propeganda spewers at worst. If they really cared about archaeology they would attempt to become properly educated about how the field works but instead they just want the dopamine and unearned sense of importance from thinking they uncovered or are privy to some supressed information.
Why is jumping so janky in this game. Are they going to make me platform with this janky ass jump?
Probably should’ve shown when you hit that last step with the inescapable madness on it you can turn around and get back into another spot with a couple more items to grab
Is that true? News to me! I know there are some breakable stuff with items higher up but this was really just about how to get to the bottom without dying
There will always be idiots out there!What a shame on humankind!!
All lok to photo Gunung Padang its pyramid
It is my scientific opinion that it is not. It's a cool archaeological site though, no pyramid needed.
🪴
Care to elaborate?
I did it! It still works! 😂
Excellent!