On the Outs with the In-Law

The plaintiff says the defendant has dated his sister for 12 years, but it’s a rocky relationship. He claims the defendant ran into his vehicle after he intervened in an altercation between the defendant and his sister, so he’s suing him for the car damages. The defendant says the plaintiff is a heavy drinker who stuck his nose where it didn’t belong. He insists the plaintiff should pay him for his car damages.