I think Fergus could handle it but not so much his wife.. she is wonderful but it might freak her out and I don't think that Fergus would want to keep things from her.
In the books, when Ian comes back Ian tells them how the Mohawk believe in time travel. They tell Ian because Ian has a bit of a grasp on it and a belief. That’s the only reason why they tell him. Fergus never believed in this yet have a clue about it. He may think she was crazy if she told him that. Same with Marsali....look at how quick she was to ask her if she was a witch when Claire brought her in and showed her the autopsy she was performing.
@@launabanauna496 .....ive not read any of the books but does anyone know if we find out what happened to young Ian with the Mohawks and why he can't go back to live with them. When he comes back he just seems so lost and withdrawn and has a hard time getting used to being around Jamie and Claire and wont talk to Jamie.
@@TXplayneJayne Yes. You get the entire, sad story in the books. The books are also SO much better. The series is fun, but it’s a bad preview in comparison with the books.
@UThink UCan My thoughts exactly. I always thought that Jenny wouldn't understand and would end up having some kind of innate bias toward Claire if she found out, but she would be smart enough to know that it would explain everything and smart enough to understand why to keep it secret. I feel like it'd be a fun internal struggle for her character to go through because at the end of the day, she regards Claire like a sister, would help protect her if for Jaime's sake, but maybe wouldn't quite be able to come to terms with the truth. Chance to see more layers to Claire and Jenny's relationship develop.
@@beaka63 you...do...realize...I'm talking about a tv show / book from the literary standpoint of a reader and writer? Not actual people? Sorry for my poor choice of wording. Which would you prefer I use instead; "compelling," "layered," "fleshed out," "intriguing exploration of the human condition to see someone who - as her own brother describes her - has never left her village work through a truth that was considered heathenistic in her time?"
He asked her back at the cathouse if she was a fairie and did she live in a dunn. No, but she did come from Craig na Dunn. He was never far off the mark.
Blue Yes, Ian always knew that there was something “special” about his Auntie Claire. I almost wish that she’s let him think that she was a fairy, and not correct him on it.
@@TheTardisDreamer I always wait for the whole season to be aired and then i go watch it all in like 2 sittings. the waiting each episode makes it loose its excitement to me.
Yes!! I think due to the whole pandemic situation I just lost track of time, no pun intended. Now that the whole season is available I will have to binge it.
Ian is the best nephew ever. There's no mindblowing confusion or accusations of witchcraft, just validation of the special way he's always seen his beloved auntie.
same whit Jamie and Murtagh, and some conversation between Geillis and Claire about the future like (which time, if they miss anything from the future etc)
Everyone in my family loves Ian. He so deserved to know the truth. And can I just say that when we all got to see him fight in the finale we all cheered him.
After Claire tells him it was written in ball point pen and Ian questions her, she gives a look to Jamie as if to say, "Well, the gig is up". I think Fergus and Marsali will be next.
We have already seen so much from these actors and story, I am looking forward to more to come. Ian has really grown into a man right before our eyes and Murtagh will be nearly missed. This whole season was awesome, ranks right there with season 1. Have a great day.
One of the very few if not only tv adaptation of books that is equally good! What a production, what acting, and let's not forget the amazing works of Bear McCreary...
Also the costumes are outstanding! 1st I watch 4story, about 3rd or 4th time for background characters, scenery, settings, costumes, music, lighting ,etc. Each time I see something new. I love the books so much
The only really false note so far is the big house. It is supposed to be on the ridge in the woods. AND keeps the logs would be hand hewn , not huge few small windows.(glass panes each taxed) no porch all around. It's a modern house they show. The white sow lived under the house too
One of the best scenes in the entire show. There will always be extraordinary people who walk among us, unexplained. Know them, cherish them. Not everything is as we see it.
I’ve been waiting for this moment since Young Ian joined the cast. Wasn’t sure if it was going to be done after he came back and it wasn’t done then but it was written well into the story (of course by the author herself).
@@pens8766 Murtagh was more of an open minded individual for the time. And plus he took an oath to protect Jamie and be there for him no matter what. After he sat down and wrote out all those years on paper and he asked Claire " you've lived through all these years "
@@williamtetrault1300 she wrote a beautiful story which I have read several times but she is not responsible for what we see on the screen. Bringing that story to life is another challenge all together and the writers, actors, production should be given credit for that. My opinion
@Karen Ranallo Yep, I read the entire Outlander series in the paperback copies (talk about thick volumes!), liked it so much that I decided to purchase hardbound copies, and have read them through twice more! Heck of a good yarn!
The story of Otter Tooth is one of the most tragic and haunting in the series. And Claire meeting him in rain in the forest was Ghost Story level, and one of my favorites. I've never watched the tv show. But I wanted to see how they dealt with this.
@@speedytypermananswers5551 I agree with you 100% I normally don't watch violent content but I decided to hang in there but during the rape and torture scene with poor Jamie which I fast forwarded just to get past it but I could still see what was happening, I stuck with it until Claire boarded the English ship to care for the crew with Typhoid it was then that I gave it up and removed it from my que when Claire once again put Jamie's life in danger due to her refusal to listen to him when he begged her not to go with the young captain but her duty as a doctor called and off she went, I stopped watching right then and there. Oh and the scene when Jamie offered to sleep with the guy in exchange for him agreeing to watch over his son in his absence really did a head job on me, I loved Jamie, remained constantly annoyed with Claire, I guess you can say I had a love hate thing for this movie.
@@speedytypermananswers5551 That’s how life used to be back then, a tremendous amount of violence, and sexual abuse. If a person has to stick their head in the sand, because they can’t handle it, well then, they shouldn’t watch the show. I suspect that it was far worse than they even portray in this program.
I think Ian had a pretty good idea before he even came back to the Ridge. He may not have had the chance for a university education as Jamie did, but his was just as effective.
@Dulcineia 19 .....and I wonder what happened to the Mohawks and what he learned about Otter Tooth and the fact that the Mohawks beleive in time travel as he just said in season 5
Yes. When he was first introduced when Jamie was in his print shop , I thought "Og God, noooo." Just too goofy ect. Now, he as such a strength of character and emotion. He is wonderful. Has made him into such a strong man.
Me too! Especially when he swam to get the jewels. I thought: this pale, skinny kid is going on be out of the show in about 10 minutes! Now my favorite guy!
They all know the tales of people stolen away by the fairies at the standing stones. Just remind them of the old songs and tales and then tell them it's true. Might be easier to wrap their heads around the idea then. I'm not a fairie. I'm the one stolen by the fairies.
Great point. Their belief in fairies does open them up to the possibility of something magical. The fact that there was a well-known song that describes the event is proof that Highlanders would accept it. The only reason not to divulge to most people would be for safety reasons.
I think Ian also had some idea because he said that the old women of Lallybroch used to say that when Claire didn’t return with Jamie that she had “gone back to where she came from, back to the fairies”.
When Jamie closes the door so they could talk about Claire being a time traveler, I wanted so bad for the camera to be in that room so we could listen in on the discussion!!
gettting ready for season 6..... damn - i just watched this clip and was reminded just how awesome this show is!!!! Such great characters, great actors.... sets, filming, etc..... wow!!!!!!
I also think Fergus should be told the truth as he has been very loyal. I hope Ian will tell about his life with the Mohawk and the sad secret he is keeping .I cannot wait to watch this continuing story ,I for one am obsessed with Outlander, I have watched it so many times and every time I see something that I overlooked .❤❤🏴🏴
right? at this point i think they can deal with that info perfectly fine, specially marsali who is dealing with learning medical info that didn't even exist in that time and adapts just fine. besides if they all know there could be some conversations about how things are in the future etc, i think that could be interesting too, they could even show them the photos of brianna (unless they have been lost in the shipwreck) .
@@flatandsplat i don't think so, that was a long time ago and marsali has been claire's apprentice now for a long time and has seen even helped watch the moho for penicilin without even asking anymore why does claire know that, she just goes with the flow now.
I really appriciate and love how John Bell changed the way he acts and talks since the S3. Defnitely looks a lot more mature but not too much, exactly as Ian's age should be.
I think some other people who deserve to know the truth are Fergus and Marsali, and maybe even Lord John Grey. They know Jaime and Claire too well to ever think they were lying or gone crazy.
FERGUS, MARSALI, AND LORD JOHN GRAY NEEDS TO KNOW TOO.....THIS IS MY FAVORITE SCENE IN THIS EPISODE..........AND WHO ARE THE 50 PEOPLE THAT PUT A THUMBS DOWN, THEY MUST NOT WATCH OUTLANDER AT ALL
It makes sense for this scene. You know the Mohawk had tons of questions for him. I would have told Fergus as well but no one outside the family as Claire, Bree and Roger could have all been rounded up for a burning at the stake.
I adore this series...I know there is only one season left in STARZ plans, but I hope they go further. The actors selected could not have better Dianna Gabaldon’s characters in the Outlander series. Even for those who watch the programs, the books are still worth the read. No one does sexual descriptions like DGabaldon, who used class not trash in difficult scenes. I knew what was coming at the end of season 5, but it spurred me to give back to the book to review before episode, and was glad to be prepared. I didn’t know the actors playing Roger and Ian, but now, I cannot see anyone else in the roles.
There's 2 seasons coming,thank the powers that be. I hope they do Lord John's story from The Brotherhood of the Blade. Jamie is still at helwater and they interact occasionally. Good read!
I started watching Outlander a few days ago, and I couldn’t stop watching. It is hands down the best television show I have ever seen. The acting is so beautiful. I have no words…
Is anyone else mad that the final episode only lasted 42 min? It said 110 min when you began watching it and then you get some whole other show that came on!
Book Nine clears up a lot about who knows about the time travelers. Fergus says at one point he often heard Jamie and Claire speaking privately when they were in Paris together when he was a boy so …….
Loved this scene. And I agree Fergus and Marsali should know. I also find it very interesting that Outlander fans have seasons they didn't like it versus others. I think we all love season 1, but some really didn't like 3, I liked 3 a lot. Some didn't like the France story line, but I liked that as well. Imo, something got lost as they stationed in the Colonies, seasons 4-5 don't compare well to 1-3. But I'm curious to know if fans prefer 5 to 4 or vice versa.
I was so bored by the France storyline. I liked season 3 well enough but seasons 4 and 5 have have several hit and miss episodes and storylines for me. I agree about something getting lost after they moved to the colonies.
In the Moonlight, understandable about France. Yes 4-5 had several hit and miss episodes, very choppy and out of place. Hopefully with season 6 things improve.
Oh, I certainly, love the 1st episodes. Hated Wentworth. Loved, love, love France series. OMG! THE Clothes....Versailles... European History.....The King !!
Some viewers just wanted the romantic stuff. BUT this story is about them facing life's hard cruelties and building their life together. And they didn't have near the money to live on that it seems. He's still paying damn laoghaire alimony.. it's basically a barter economy then. Whiskey paid for almost everything.( Whiskey Rebellion)
Ian is one of my favourite characters! He's so underrated. I'm so glad he came back from the Mohawk 💗💗 Btw, I've written an Outlander inspired soundtrack called "Great Expectations". Listen to it on my channel and let me know what you think! I hope it bring a smile to your face and joy to your heart in these tough times. 🌞
*Spoiler Alert* If I remeber correctly from the books, he has problems with conceiving a child with a woman he met in the native american tribe that he was a part of, And she blames him for the reason of her not to be able to bear a child with him since she's already had one prior to meeting Ian... pleasssssse correct me if I'm wrong lol this is based off my memory 🤣
I don't know if anyone remembers but Ian had said when he came back that he had been married and he had a wife and a child but they were gone he never said they were dead he just said they were gone and if you remember back that's the same thing that Jamie said to Lord Grey... he said to Jamie "your dead wife..." and Jamie said I never said she was dead I just said she was gone! So I think his wife and child were also Time Travelers now that would be cool
Yes! I was wondering, could that be the girl in season 1 ep. 1 who goes back to pick up her jewelry after that ritual dance scene that Claire and Frank was secretly watching from a distance... I know, that was in Scotland, but still ... She could have made her way to America somehow.... 🤔😁
I had wondered the same thing about Young Ian's time with the Mohawk, wondered if he met a time traveler and if she might have been with the group that ottertooth and the guy in s5 that asked Claire if the name ringo Starr meant anything to her. He goes on to explain that he came with a group of Native Americans to tell the Mohawk about their fate as a tribe. If you look closely at the Native American sitting on 5he bench reading the paper whilec2 small children are running around playing, he's ottertooth.
To watchers who haven't read the books. You're grasping straws. His wife was Works with her Hands. They probably had an Rh factor difference caused their babies to die.
Ian: Are we going to talk about what happened? Jamie: There's not much we can say about the Browns; they do as they please. Ian: Not the Browns, uncle... the opal. The Mohawk told us that Ottertooth's ghost appears to the one that has the stone. You found the opal. You said he appeared to you. Claire: Yes. But... Ian: The Mohawk think that the one who has the stone has the power to see what will come to pass. They asked about you, after you left. Jamie: What did you tell them? Ian: The truth. There isn't anyone like my aunty Claire. Aunt is true. The way you speak; your medicines; that you came to uncle Jamie so suddenly after 20 years apart. Then there's Brianna and Roger, who came from... ah dinnae ken ('I do not know') where. As I told you once, I learnt not to ask questions, but I have some for you now. The Mohawk said this belonged to Ottertooth. I can understand some, but it's in Latin. Does it mean anything to you? Jamie: "I am. I still exist. Do I, in that place between. I do not know exactly when I am nor can I find out. These people do not measure time by any scale I know, nor do I have the tongue to find out. I know I am too late." Claire: My God, he wrote with a ballpoint pen. Ian: What's a ballpoint pen?..... Who or what are you? Claire: Ian, I come from another time. Where I come - from the future. 200 years from now. Ian: I.... I knew you were a fairy, aunty. Claire: I'm not a fairy. Ian: Then you, Roger and Brianna... it's all of you. And you, you kent ('knew') all this time, uncle? Jamie: Not many people would understand, so we kept it between ourselves. Ian: Did Murtagh ken? Jamie: Aye ('yes'). Aye, he did. Now so do you.
@@mikecombe7130 Thank you so much for writing down all this dialogue. Understanding English is one thing, but understanding English with a Scottish accent is another thing for non native English speakers ! lol. Thank you !
Everyone in every century has wondered if time travel exists. I'm sure it has occurred to Ian at one time or another (or rather his character). If I knew someone who had time traveled, and if they could prove it (another possible problem) I would believe them with enough proof.
I think Fergus deserves to know too. His unwavering and absolute loyalty to Jaime has been proven time and time again.
fergus > ian
I also think Fergus should stop calling them milord and milady! They’ve been ‘family’ for decades.
I think these days he uses those names in place of 'mum' and 'dad'. It wasn't the case initially, but for him, it came to have that meaning.
I think Fergus could handle it but not so much his wife.. she is wonderful but it might freak her out and I don't think that Fergus would want to keep things from her.
In the books, when Ian comes back Ian tells them how the Mohawk believe in time travel. They tell Ian because Ian has a bit of a grasp on it and a belief. That’s the only reason why they tell him. Fergus never believed in this yet have a clue about it. He may think she was crazy if she told him that. Same with Marsali....look at how quick she was to ask her if she was a witch when Claire brought her in and showed her the autopsy she was performing.
My favorite line in this scene.
"I always knew you were a fairy Auntie."
Who doesn't love and admire, Young Ian. He's the best in all of us. ;0)
@@launabanauna496 .....ive not read any of the books but does anyone know if we find out what happened to young Ian with the Mohawks and why he can't go back to live with them. When he comes back he just seems so lost and withdrawn and has a hard time getting used to being around Jamie and Claire and wont talk to Jamie.
In the book he says he knew she WASN’T a fairy. The fae in Scottish folklore don’t time travel.
@@TXplayneJayne Yes. You get the entire, sad story in the books. The books are also SO much better. The series is fun, but it’s a bad preview in comparison with the books.
@@TXplayneJayne Yes in the books, there is a reason, very sad. But I won't say because I don't know what the tv series may do in the future.
I also thought that jenny deserved to know. You could see how heart broken she was when Claire returned and she didn't understand why
Same she should have been told her
I don’t think Jenny would understand, like what Jaime said, she’s never left lallybroch and she’s lived a pretty traditional life.
@UThink UCan My thoughts exactly. I always thought that Jenny wouldn't understand and would end up having some kind of innate bias toward Claire if she found out, but she would be smart enough to know that it would explain everything and smart enough to understand why to keep it secret. I feel like it'd be a fun internal struggle for her character to go through because at the end of the day, she regards Claire like a sister, would help protect her if for Jaime's sake, but maybe wouldn't quite be able to come to terms with the truth. Chance to see more layers to Claire and Jenny's relationship develop.
@@amberkeys5201 "a fun internal struggle"? With her husband dying, it turned out not to be so much fun after all, didn't it?
@@beaka63 you...do...realize...I'm talking about a tv show / book from the literary standpoint of a reader and writer? Not actual people? Sorry for my poor choice of wording. Which would you prefer I use instead; "compelling," "layered," "fleshed out," "intriguing exploration of the human condition to see someone who - as her own brother describes her - has never left her village work through a truth that was considered heathenistic in her time?"
He thought she was a fairy 😂 that was adorable
perfectly imperfect23 Ian is an adorable character
He asked her back at the cathouse if she was a fairie and did she live in a dunn. No, but she did come from Craig na Dunn. He was never far off the mark.
Blue Yes, Ian always knew that there was something “special” about his Auntie Claire. I almost wish that she’s let him think that she was a fairy, and not correct him on it.
Well given his education that probably the most logical he explain Claire situation.
I freaking love Ian, he's so open minded and sweet.
I just love Young Ian’s first reaction when Claire told him the truth. Most people wouldn’t believe it and he just smiled and called her a fairy 🥲
when you havent watched this season yet but like.. you cant resist that title.
My situation as well!
Ugh, same! Still getting through season 4 with Mum.
@@TheTardisDreamer I always wait for the whole season to be aired and then i go watch it all in like 2 sittings. the waiting each episode makes it loose its excitement to me.
Watch it, it’s so good!
Yes!! I think due to the whole pandemic situation I just lost track of time, no pun intended. Now that the whole season is available I will have to binge it.
Ian is the best nephew ever. There's no mindblowing confusion or accusations of witchcraft, just validation of the special way he's always seen his beloved auntie.
Ian is such a great character, a sweetheart but also not one to be messed with.
I wish they had written more scenes with Ian asking questions about the future. Those are my favourite bits.
same whit Jamie and Murtagh, and some conversation between Geillis and Claire about the future like (which time, if they miss anything from the future etc)
Listen, if I was in this time and Claire told me she was from the future she would never have a moments pace without me in her ear, asking about it 🤣
Just love Ian....his smile and loyalty back to the family again....hope he fines love and happiness....
He does.
Opps I’m telling you the future.
Ian's like, "I KNEW I had the coolest aunt ever!"
My only questions is when are they finally going to tell poor Fergus! Like he's been here since season2 and he still doesn't know!!!😒😂
He's been since season one 😩😩
@@yunushafeez5438 2*
Dani1803 S Fergus doesn’t question.
honestly if anyone aside from Fergus deserved to be told the truth it was Jenny
@@NWCountryGirl17 exactly
Always thought "Young Ian" was special- he has proven it many times 💜
Please just keep these series going.....best series ever....they have become part of my life....
How can you not Love that "young Ian" boy!? Awww, I just adore him! He was always on Claire's side, calling her "auntie" all the time. ❤
Everyone in my family loves Ian. He so deserved to know the truth.
And can I just say that when we all got to see him fight in the finale we all cheered him.
Right?!! I'd really luv to see them flesh out his character more and give him a meatier role to play.
Read the books to find out more in Ian. Great character.
I wish they told Jenny. It broke my heart when she thought that Claire had abandoned them.
Give them time 😉
After Claire tells him it was written in ball point pen and Ian questions her, she gives a look to Jamie as if to say, "Well, the gig is up". I think Fergus and Marsali will be next.
"I knew you were a fairy, auntie"😂 what a sweet boy Ian ♡♡
We have already seen so much from these actors and story, I am looking forward to more to come. Ian has really grown into a man right before our eyes and Murtagh will be nearly missed. This whole season was awesome, ranks right there with season 1. Have a great day.
imo every season except 3 was awesome
One of the very few if not only tv adaptation of books that is equally good!
What a production, what acting, and let's not forget the amazing works of Bear McCreary...
Also the costumes are outstanding! 1st I watch 4story, about 3rd or 4th time for background characters, scenery, settings, costumes, music, lighting ,etc. Each time I see something new. I love the books so much
The only really false note so far is the big house. It is supposed to be on the ridge in the woods. AND keeps the logs would be hand hewn , not huge few small windows.(glass panes each taxed) no porch all around. It's a modern house they show. The white sow lived under the house too
One of the best scenes in the entire show. There will always be extraordinary people who walk among us, unexplained. Know them, cherish them. Not everything is as we see it.
I’ve been waiting for this moment since Young Ian joined the cast. Wasn’t sure if it was going to be done after he came back and it wasn’t done then but it was written well into the story (of course by the author herself).
I LOVE Young Ian! John Bell was magnificent in this scene.
Excellent season5, hate to see it end. Thank you all who are part of making this story so special.
Its always cool when someone else finds out. I loved it when they told murtagh and he understood it.
@@pens8766 Murtagh was more of an open minded individual for the time. And plus he took an oath to protect Jamie and be there for him no matter what. After he sat down and wrote out all those years on paper and he asked Claire " you've lived through all these years "
Make sure that your gratitude for such a great series includes Diana Gabaldon, she who conceived such a magnificent story!
@@williamtetrault1300 she wrote a beautiful story which I have read several times but she is not responsible for what we see on the screen. Bringing that story to life is another challenge all together and the writers, actors, production should be given credit for that. My opinion
@Karen Ranallo Yep, I read the entire Outlander series in the paperback copies (talk about thick volumes!), liked it so much that I decided to purchase hardbound copies, and have read them through twice more! Heck of a good yarn!
Beautiful, awesome scene! I love young Ian!
This is my favorite scene in S5. Ian is precious and his story is magnificent. Loved this!
The story of Otter Tooth is one of the most tragic and haunting in the series. And Claire meeting him in rain in the forest was Ghost Story level, and one of my favorites. I've never watched the tv show. But I wanted to see how they dealt with this.
@@speedytypermananswers5551 True...Jaime, Claire, Brianna, Ian & Fergus.
@@speedytypermananswers5551 Isn't that why one watches a TV drama? If there are no disturbing things happening there wouldn't be any drama.
@@speedytypermananswers5551 I agree with you 100% I normally don't watch violent content but I decided to hang in there but during the rape and torture scene with poor Jamie which I fast forwarded just to get past it but I could still see what was happening, I stuck with it until Claire boarded the English ship to care for the crew with Typhoid it was then that I gave it up and removed it from my que when Claire once again put Jamie's life in danger due to her refusal to listen to him when he begged her not to go with the young captain but her duty as a doctor called and off she went, I stopped watching right then and there. Oh and the scene when Jamie offered to sleep with the guy in exchange for him agreeing to watch over his son in his absence really did a head job on me, I loved Jamie, remained constantly annoyed with Claire, I guess you can say I had a love hate thing for this movie.
@@speedytypermananswers5551
That’s how life used to be back then, a tremendous amount of violence, and sexual abuse. If a person has to stick their head in the sand, because they can’t handle it, well then, they shouldn’t watch the show. I suspect that it was far worse than they even portray in this program.
@@micca903 I think they went too far with it, I quit watching for a long time after one of those disgusting rapes
Iain is such a pure soul
I was holding my breath at the start of this scene.
Young Ian my 2nd favorite character in this show. Love his character.
I'm curious now who your 1st favorite character is...! Please share.
I think Ian had a pretty good idea before he even came back to the Ridge. He may not have had the chance for a university education as Jamie did, but his was just as effective.
@Dulcineia 19 .....and I wonder what happened to the Mohawks and what he learned about Otter Tooth and the fact that the Mohawks beleive in time travel as he just said in season 5
At first, I thought John Bell was a terrible choice, and completely miscast as Young Ian. Boy, was I wrong.
Yes. When he was first introduced when Jamie was in his print shop , I thought "Og God, noooo." Just too goofy ect. Now, he as such a strength of character and emotion. He is wonderful. Has made him into such a strong man.
I actually liked him a lot since the beginning LOL. But I didn't read the books so I wouldn't have anything to compare it to.
Me too! Especially when he swam to get the jewels. I thought: this pale, skinny kid is going on be out of the show in about 10 minutes! Now my favorite guy!
I love his character so much. Yes to the spin off!!
They all know the tales of people stolen away by the fairies at the standing stones. Just remind them of the old songs and tales and then tell them it's true. Might be easier to wrap their heads around the idea then. I'm not a fairie. I'm the one stolen by the fairies.
There were time travel themed books. It would be easier to wrap their heads around it if any of them had time to read LOL
Great point. Their belief in fairies does open them up to the possibility of something magical. The fact that there was a well-known song that describes the event is proof that Highlanders would accept it. The only reason not to divulge to most people would be for safety reasons.
So glad Ian knows!
I think Ian also had some idea because he said that the old women of Lallybroch used to say that when Claire didn’t return with Jamie that she had “gone back to where she came from, back to the fairies”.
I adore his line”I always knew you was a fairie, auntie”
Hello dear, how are you doing today
It's my greatest honor to have you as a fan 😍
@@samheughan5525 I am ok. So nice to meet you
@@almajeansmith3328 you are welcome
@@almajeansmith3328 so how long. have you been following me as a fans, and which for my work do you find interesting!!!
@@almajeansmith3328 hello dear
When Jamie closes the door so they could talk about Claire being a time traveler, I wanted so bad for the camera to be in that room so we could listen in on the discussion!!
I really hope they touch more on Native American and their culture, i always love it.
Young Ian is a great character in this serie. Is very real.
One of my favourite scenes John bell is so good as young Ian .
gettting ready for season 6..... damn - i just watched this clip and was reminded just how awesome this show is!!!! Such great characters, great actors.... sets, filming, etc..... wow!!!!!!
He looks like Macklemore
😂🤣😂
THAT'S IT! Young Ian's been poppin' tags
Plsss 😭😭😭
@@lizzleonard7256
Okay, that's friggin funny, right there!
That was a wonderful scene, so well acted by all.
I would have loved to hear Ian's questions.
Ian is the best. I want Fergus and Marsali to find out in Season 7! Can you imagine Marsali's reaction? It would be priceless.
John Bell's acting became so strong in season 6. He grew to become the heart of the show.
Loved it... Bring ON the new Season!!!!
I really enjoy this show every season gets more interesting the stories have carried on well and I love the characters
I LOVE YOUNG IAN.
and he was wearing glasses ... to show that time had passed
How is Young Ian?? Another beautiful job. I've missed all the people we've come to love. Pamela so good.
Oh I love Ian he’s my favorite character
I also think Fergus should be told the truth as he has been very loyal. I hope Ian will tell about his life with the Mohawk and the sad secret he is keeping .I cannot wait to watch this continuing story ,I for one am obsessed with Outlander, I have watched it so many times and every time I see something that I overlooked .❤❤🏴🏴
Now tell fergus and marsali
right? at this point i think they can deal with that info perfectly fine, specially marsali who is dealing with learning medical info that didn't even exist in that time and adapts just fine. besides if they all know there could be some conversations about how things are in the future etc, i think that could be interesting too, they could even show them the photos of brianna (unless they have been lost in the shipwreck) .
I don't believe Marsali would understand. She still thought Claire could be a witch when doing that autopsy
@@flatandsplat i don't think so, that was a long time ago and marsali has been claire's apprentice now for a long time and has seen even helped watch the moho for penicilin without even asking anymore why does claire know that, she just goes with the flow now.
I really appriciate and love how John Bell changed the way he acts and talks since the S3. Defnitely looks a lot more mature but not too much, exactly as Ian's age should be.
I love how Young Ian is immediately like “Oh yeah okay 👍🏻”
A fairy 💕 she kind of is though, we love auntie Claire.
Young Ian is such a good natured lad, he’s definitely a favorite of mine. 💕
I think Claire should have told Jenny
She would have thought Claire was a witch
@@dasbell7916 to be honest 🤣🤣🤣
Spoiler!!!!!
She does in 8th book
Maybe she will someday.
@@dasbell7916 aye. And she would have many questions that Claire wouldn’t be able to answer (she might even tell others and get Clarie killed for it).
I think some other people who deserve to know the truth are Fergus and Marsali, and maybe even Lord John Grey. They know Jaime and Claire too well to ever think they were lying or gone crazy.
Claire and Brianna both tell LJG, but he doesn't believe them.
FERGUS, MARSALI, AND LORD JOHN GRAY NEEDS TO KNOW TOO.....THIS IS MY FAVORITE SCENE IN THIS EPISODE..........AND WHO ARE THE 50 PEOPLE THAT PUT A THUMBS DOWN, THEY MUST NOT WATCH OUTLANDER AT ALL
Wahhh, I want that conversation to go on much longer! 😉
It makes sense for this scene. You know the Mohawk had tons of questions for him. I would have told Fergus as well but no one outside the family as Claire, Bree and Roger could have all been rounded up for a burning at the stake.
Everyone loves Jamie so much but Young Ian is my favorite character.
Ian’s arc in this show is one of the best character arcs of any show.
Que excelente escena!!! Me encanta la expresión de quienes se enteran de la verdad de Clare!!! 😁😁😁
I adore this series...I know there is only one season left in STARZ plans, but I hope they go further. The actors selected could not have better Dianna Gabaldon’s characters in the Outlander series. Even for those who watch the programs, the books are still worth the read. No one does sexual descriptions like DGabaldon, who used class not trash in difficult scenes. I knew what was coming at the end of season 5, but it spurred me to give back to the book to review before episode, and was glad to be prepared.
I didn’t know the actors playing Roger and Ian, but now, I cannot see anyone else in the roles.
There's 2 seasons coming,thank the powers that be. I hope they do Lord John's story from The Brotherhood of the Blade. Jamie is still at helwater and they interact occasionally. Good read!
I started watching Outlander a few days ago, and I couldn’t stop watching. It is hands down the best television show I have ever seen. The acting is so beautiful. I have no words…
He really did deserve to know the truth. He is loyal to his family. I laughed when he said he knew his aunt was a fairy lol
This story has to be true...so amazing
Kind of curious how young Ian would fair in the swinging 60's.
He himself wanted to know.
Not that young.
He's "Ind-Ian" now.
lol jajaja let's call him that from now on
that's Terrible... I love it
This is the worst type of humour and I love it!
Gold. Pure gold. Excellent pun, my friend.
Wow. That's really funny, lol
Enough so that I had to stop and type this to let you know
Is anyone else mad that the final episode only lasted 42 min? It said 110 min when you began watching it and then you get some whole other show that came on!
I was so mad about that too! I was fully expecting a double episode or something like that.
Book Nine clears up a lot about who knows about the time travelers. Fergus says at one point he often heard Jamie and Claire speaking privately when they were in Paris together when he was a boy so …….
I love this scene.
John Bell is a good actor!
He is so cute!!
Loved this scene. And I agree Fergus and Marsali should know. I also find it very interesting that Outlander fans have seasons they didn't like it versus others. I think we all love season 1, but some really didn't like 3, I liked 3 a lot. Some didn't like the France story line, but I liked that as well. Imo, something got lost as they stationed in the Colonies, seasons 4-5 don't compare well to 1-3. But I'm curious to know if fans prefer 5 to 4 or vice versa.
I was so bored by the France storyline. I liked season 3 well enough but seasons 4 and 5 have have several hit and miss episodes and storylines for me.
I agree about something getting lost after they moved to the colonies.
In the Moonlight, understandable about France. Yes 4-5 had several hit and miss episodes, very choppy and out of place. Hopefully with season 6 things improve.
Oh, I certainly, love the 1st episodes. Hated Wentworth.
Loved, love, love France series. OMG! THE Clothes....Versailles... European History.....The King !!
Some viewers just wanted the romantic stuff. BUT this story is about them facing life's hard cruelties and building their life together. And they didn't have near the money to live on that it seems. He's still paying damn laoghaire alimony.. it's basically a barter economy then. Whiskey paid for almost everything.( Whiskey Rebellion)
Ian I love him
I always wished they had more of future stuff in the episodes
Ian is one of my favourite characters! He's so underrated. I'm so glad he came back from the Mohawk 💗💗
Btw, I've written an Outlander inspired soundtrack called "Great Expectations". Listen to it on my channel and let me know what you think! I hope it bring a smile to your face and joy to your heart in these tough times. 🌞
how I love this spectacular series outollander ❤️ ♥ ️
Hello dear, how are you doing today
It's my greatest honor to have you as a fan 😍
Love ian
I honestly forgot he didn't know.
Finally. Now just please tell Fergus, Marsalii, Jenny, AND LORD JOHN. All four would totally get it.
They do tell Jenny at some point but she doesn't really believe it and just wants Claire's medical help in the books
Me patiently waiting for them to tell us what happened to Ian like 👀
*Spoiler Alert*
If I remeber correctly from the books, he has problems with conceiving a child with a woman he met in the native american tribe that he was a part of,
And she blames him for the reason of her not to be able to bear a child with him since she's already had one prior to meeting Ian... pleasssssse correct me if I'm wrong lol this is based off my memory 🤣
Again, READ THE BOOKS.!! Then you'll Really be hooked!
Escena muy bella.Los amo👌👌👌👏👏👏💙
Gutted they didn’t get to continue this conversation for the fans xx
beautiful scene!!!
I don't know if anyone remembers but Ian had said when he came back that he had been married and he had a wife and a child but they were gone he never said they were dead he just said they were gone and if you remember back that's the same thing that Jamie said to Lord Grey... he said to Jamie "your dead wife..." and Jamie said I never said she was dead I just said she was gone!
So I think his wife and child were also Time Travelers now that would be cool
Yes!
I was wondering, could that be the girl in season 1 ep. 1 who goes back to pick up her jewelry after that ritual dance scene that Claire and Frank was secretly watching from a distance... I know, that was in Scotland, but still ... She could have made her way to America somehow.... 🤔😁
Have you read the books??
I had wondered the same thing about Young Ian's time with the Mohawk, wondered if he met a time traveler and if she might have been with the group that ottertooth and the guy in s5 that asked Claire if the name ringo Starr meant anything to her. He goes on to explain that he came with a group of Native Americans to tell the Mohawk about their fate as a tribe. If you look closely at the Native American sitting on 5he bench reading the paper whilec2 small children are running around playing, he's ottertooth.
@@carolreid1609 no Ive not read the books only book 1 and trying to read 2
To watchers who haven't read the books. You're grasping straws. His wife was Works with her Hands. They probably had an Rh factor difference caused their babies to die.
You mean, Young Ian learns the trrrruth. (roll those r's man!)
Born and raised in middle America. Rolling r's is beyond my abilities. When I try I just hurt myself.
I love this so much
Superbe scène !
Hermosa serie, ojalá nos lleguen los episodios siguientes solo nos llegaron hasta el 4o episodio
Pobrecito Ian el tambien a pasado muchas cosas se merece saber de donde viene su Tia el presentia algo
Please, put subtitles because for those of us who are not English speakers it is very difficult to understand all the words. Pleaseeeeeee
Ian: Are we going to talk about what happened?
Jamie: There's not much we can say about the Browns; they do as they please.
Ian: Not the Browns, uncle... the opal. The Mohawk told us that Ottertooth's ghost appears to the one that has the stone. You found the opal. You said he appeared to you.
Claire: Yes. But...
Ian: The Mohawk think that the one who has the stone has the power to see what will come to pass. They asked about you, after you left.
Jamie: What did you tell them?
Ian: The truth. There isn't anyone like my aunty Claire. Aunt is true. The way you speak; your medicines; that you came to uncle Jamie so suddenly after 20 years apart. Then there's Brianna and Roger, who came from... ah dinnae ken ('I do not know') where. As I told you once, I learnt not to ask questions, but I have some for you now. The Mohawk said this belonged to Ottertooth. I can understand some, but it's in Latin. Does it mean anything to you?
Jamie: "I am. I still exist. Do I, in that place between. I do not know exactly when I am nor can I find out. These people do not measure time by any scale I know, nor do I have the tongue to find out. I know I am too late."
Claire: My God, he wrote with a ballpoint pen.
Ian: What's a ballpoint pen?..... Who or what are you?
Claire: Ian, I come from another time. Where I come - from the future. 200 years from now.
Ian: I.... I knew you were a fairy, aunty.
Claire: I'm not a fairy.
Ian: Then you, Roger and Brianna... it's all of you. And you, you kent ('knew') all this time, uncle?
Jamie: Not many people would understand, so we kept it between ourselves.
Ian: Did Murtagh ken?
Jamie: Aye ('yes'). Aye, he did. Now so do you.
@@mikecombe7130 What a kindness! I can understand it fine but am grateful for those who cannot. Thank you!
@@mikecombe7130 Thank you so much for writing down all this dialogue. Understanding English is one thing, but understanding English with a Scottish accent is another thing for non native English speakers ! lol. Thank you !
@@mikecombe7130 l have understood many words, but not all. Thank you.
@@3indignada You (and the other ladies who responded) are very welcome. :-)
The right way they should have written the script was “ I always knew you were of the fae auntie!”
Ohh Young Ian soo cute
Everyone in every century has wondered if time travel exists. I'm sure it has occurred to Ian at one time or another (or rather his character). If I knew someone who had time traveled, and if they could prove it (another possible problem) I would believe them with enough proof.
It would of been nice to hear all what was said to Ian behind closed doors.