The DUO Main Vocalist In aespa!

[@sayenka6093]

Winter's projection is insane and Ningning's musicality is incredible!

[@Pro_D5]

3.5k likes and no comments.
Let me fix that.

[@starlix_supernova]

W pfp

[@x..ninisepagito..x]

w pfp

[@starlix_supernova]

@@x..ninisepagito..x stole my comment fight me

[@x..ninisepagito..x]

@@starlix_supernova stole my comment fight me

[@Jenorationn]

Best 4th gen vocal duo WinNing !!

[@NagiReoBL]

WinNing winning our hearts ♥️

[@anemofungus]

Best is Lily Haewon but WinNing is also so talented and insaneee

[@ph0g275]

@@anemofungusnugu groups do not count!

[@Rosinante1829]

​@@anemofungusreal, and it's not even close

[@anemofungus]

@@ph0g275 nmixx is successful, even if they have less success than Aespa

[@tribetwice]

It's actually insane

[@Ann_Honney]

I got goosebumbs at ningning’s part

[@morkmeinyourheartt]

2 main vocals, 2 main rappers, 2 lead rappers, 2 lead vocals. AESPA!

[@Blueishhman]

Who are the 2 best dancers in aespa?

[@christiankenmoro112]

Karina and Winter ​@@Blueishhman

[@ariana_MY]

​@@christiankenmoro112I thought this was changed to Karina and Ningning?

[@aouboomsail]

in terms of techniques, Karina and Winter are the best but yeah Ningning can pass as one of the best dancer too​@@ariana_MY

[@MadeJk]

@@ariana_MY It has never been changed, since day 1 Karina and Winter are the dance line of aespa 🙌🏻

[@Azalea-lk6jk]

The way Winter's mic pop 🔥🔥🔥

[@clxra127]

So talented and pretty omg

[@world__2264]

Ningning reminded me of KARA damaged lady era with this outfit ❤

[@nisafadli3148]

Love KARA❤

[@arkana8313]

Exactly

[@bunbunnie21]

Yesssss

[@gaberoniexx]

CHILLLLSSSSS from Ning Ning wow

[@ft.wonwooo]

ok but winter in this outfit + the hairstyle 😍 INSAAAAANE!!!!✨

[@araliya7863]

WinNing both are main vocalists guys. Just look at their weverse profiles. and also, it's obvious that they're both main vocalists since they're always get the equal lines in singing verses, bridges, highnotes, adlibs, etc and how incredible they're both in technique or stability vocals. It's not strange to a group who have 2/3 main vocalists with different tiers/vocal tones. ❤

[@jiyoon_15]

Ningning's angelic voice>>>>>>>>

[@bichinaneonsolo272]

Winter look like killer fr ❤

[@Rhiot98]

Now this is live vocals 😍

[@allphotosallphotos4332]

They hit those high notes effortlessly, that's why people accused them for lipsync when their actually just being georgeous ❤

[@meryembel4670]

NINGNING IS A FREAKING QUEEN

[@fingergabut]

High note Ningning is really something

[@Its.me.688]

The vocal queens 🔥💗💗

[@nshaa_cactus]

Winter's voice ❤

[@shivaninagaraj4035]

Ningning winter 🤝 lily haewon

[@dareenabuhmeidan2286]

Winter ate 🔥🔥🔥those vocals

[@minniechu]

Queen of vocals!!!!

[@uchiangeI]

talented.

[@Helen-e6m6h]

That was beautiful the vocals, stage presentation, and dance formation 🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤

[@userj793]

Winter expressions and her vocal.She making Armegerddon as HER song😂
Once again her one of performance going viral in twitter and tiktok with many likes.

[@Chaithra-bp3is]

Yo That's SICK!

[@chensationexo-l3491]

Best vocals of 4th gen❤

[@Talent_more_than_popularity]

Lily and Haewon best duo in 4gen

[@markleeismylee1511]

Winter is soooo SM Main Vocal coded😭❄️🧚

[@love4dolls]

Well that's why she isss

[@elyvalo]

@@areentmshe’s main vocalist now !

[@thaogallego]

There's Wendy and Taeyeon before that...

[@elyvalo]

@@thaogallego they said main vocalist CODED for a reason

[@nicfdh]

​@@areentm she is main vocal

[@arb4481]

Ningning always no effort bgt kalo nyanyi, tpi kok bisaa stabil bgt 😍

[@Diaaazzz]

So stableee❤❤

[@Jennie_KimchiAmanita]

They're so stable omg best vocal duo imo 🤩🔥🌟

[@suchismitakar2154]

Best bridge of 2024

[@AsnulAimanMasmellah]

Ningning mouth not too openly but why'd her voice really 😭🤩🤩💕💯

[@CaptShane-sy7lr]

I probably get hate for this comment, but I think they are the best Kpop GG. Outshining even BP.

[@Pretty_gurl_mantra]

They slayed!!❤

[@doyelichakma3513]

Love this part ❣️

[@nævisparkles]

WINNING💥💥

[@radhikanaik1751]

Also aespa's lead vocalist duo ( KARINA, GISELLE) slayed ✨✨

[@leafleaf6575]

Winter slays both singing and dancing effortlessly + her expressions r perfect.my bias for a reason ❤

[@aouboomsail]

They look like they're about to perform The Boys 😂

[@zoey4148]

Ningning ate 🔥🔥

[@ShahramHama]

OUR MAKNAE NINGNING✨🤍🔗

[@12sniperbullet]

MICS ARE ON

[@Artiiu]

I cant explain how Winter has improved since debut 😭

[@byunbaekyoong]

there's a lot of akgaes in the comments omg
can't you just accept that there are two main vocalist in aespa. The latest profile update released by SM was in their weverse profiles, and it both states that WinNing are main vocalist.

[@Gadoorah]

They are WinNing in vocals! 👸👸

[@Yram123anch]

Our 2 main vocalists

[@dawonforme]

So many vocal experts here lol

[@alicehtart3146]

Winter voice so clear❤🔥

[@zoey4148]

Ningning voice 🔥😍

[@nadelineamary]

armegeddon is winter song!!!

[@konelyt7233]

Giselle and Ningning's song !

[@Yourfavmulti-stan]

Totally, i mean her vocals 😩

[@imdablyoodablyooeichuyonno]

IS NINGNING EVEN REAL?!?

[@coqaddvt]

queens

[@divinedaurapasaribu4118]

WinNing is literally WINNING at vocals

[@coqaddvt]

MICS ARE ONNN

[@yangyang-ij2qb]

aespa❤❤❤

[@yeskevz]

They can all sing well to be main vocalists though

[@aaugussto]

nah

[@Afoshy1]

winNing is winning❤

[@zai_arts]

Did anyone notice? If you put Winter + NingNing you get *WinNing* which sounds like winning 🏆 our queens for a reason

[@hugecake4178]

a group with 2 Main Vocals and 2 Lead Vocals

[@songyogagetjyo]

Winter still is lead vocal, nothing have to change and in sites of their positions, nothing has changed.

[@sunflowersyeppi]

Winning ❤

[@Hani-u9c]

But I saw in end lip synce
When camera comes back of ningning!

[@Yram123anch]

Winterrrrr

[@leadan5170]

We sometime forget winter is a Lead Vocalist 😭cause gril to be honest since all of them can sing the position le got doesn’t matter

[@nicfdh]

She introduce herself as main vocal too alongside Ningning

[@Yram123anch]

She's main vocalist po:)

[@fi6528]

Tehnik nya bagus ningning, tpi lebih stabil winter

[@novitaayu3842]

Karena lebih susah nada bagiannya ningning

[@fi6528]

@novitaayu3842 engga kok, dari dulu emang suara ningning tuh agak kedengeran ngos ngosan

[@novitaayu3842]

@@fi6528 karena dia dapat part yang sulit ningning ini kuat loh di nada rendah dan tinggi kalau winter di nada rendah agak lemah sebenarnya beberapa penampilan winter juga agak ngos-ngosan intinya emang ada di beberapa nada yang emang susah tapi aespa bagus kok karena ada beberapa grup yang fals juga saat nyanyi di bagian sulit

[@novitaayu3842]

@@fi6528 dan armaggendon ini bagian ningning emang sulit ada cengkoknya coba bandingin sama whipflash

[@Ndis02-n8b]

@@novitaayu3842 alesan Mulu. Klo gak bisa ngestabilin vocal minta aja yg gampang". Selama ini kan fans Ning selalu ngotot vocalnya lebih bagus dari winter sampe gak terima winter main vocal juga. Tp faktanya pas live performance vocal dia yg sering gk stabil.

[@jenlisa6356]

mingmingz😘

[@wontajjj]

Winter + ningning = winning

[@cutebunnyhops]

Since debut people were saying that Winter is tecniqually main vocalist, she had most high notes and difficult voice parts in multiple comebacks as her voice was the most fitting.

[@mypearlb5208]

Not in Armageddon though, specifically.

[@MonoCol-r1u]

Her voice is generally higher than the rest

[@jeonginee]

WiNning be winning

[@Hgffsh1]

Best vocalist dou

[@wtf1447]

When and where did they perform this

[@ikciv.j]

tiktok awards

[@Moizthevlogger-414]

Haely too

[@widyafebriana9666]

Ningning wasn't open her mouth too big for that highnote was everything. Hatters say she always do lypsinc cause of her mouth not open tht much

[@5446_yc]

AESPA OT4 ATEEEEE

[@kadeksatriawan6357]

There looks like 4 main vocalist

[@Enhalove12]

Bsst 4th gen female duo 😭❤️

[@Boomboomvoomvoom]

I need to know where this was please 😭

[@DiamondFluker]

Wait why does Ningning look so worried while singing in this clip, is she ok? 😢❤

[@Kavyalolol-kq5fl]

Which performance is this??

[@Nyamnyam_n]

Tiktok Awards

[@Fenitra_Fenitra]

I want to know too ❤

[@cutebunnyhops]

Winter is MAIN vocalist! She also the most stable in live performances. Her vocal tecnique, support and projection all make her one. She also the only one in aespa who was personally picked to be trained by YJJ best sm coach and singer. Winter had difficult parts as high notes and sung many lines since debut

[@marvel3734]

Although Ningning is still better, so you are referring to your personal preference

[@janoreivaj5991]

Both main vocalist now and karina lead

[@MdRajo-n7n]

​@@marvel3734who gaf about minor gap winter is also the official main vocalist so it's not only about personal preference

[@marvel3734]

@@MdRajo-n7n Ningning is better. I didn't say than Winter isn't also a main vocalist. At least she is also a great singer. In NCT haechan is main vocalist and he is a weak one.

[@mypearlb5208]

​@@MdRajo-n7n "Minor gap" when Winter's low and upper register are both underdeveloped, with lows underwhelming for a main vocalist. Mid range is the only thing saving her. At least Ningning's actually improving in mid range belting and live vocals.

[@My_monstiez47]

What performance is this

[@skittychuu]

Korean TikTok awards

[@uchiangeI]

kma 2024, i am not sure

[@skittychuu]

@@uchiangeI It’s the TikTok awards :D they don’t wear suits at the kgma and there’s a TikTok logo on the set.

[@princess.leia05]

❤

[@blackadze]

DUOLINGO MENTIONED?! j/

[@sarahdagher]

lol winter can’t see for shit with those bangs

[@samuell_c]

😮

[@hoangnhatlinh-k6p]

That "ohh" is something....

[@sieungirls]

which performance?

[@konelyt7233]

tiktok award or something

[@laazijoke1640]

I see several people saying that Lily and Heawon would make a better duo than Winter and Ningning.
I can understand but for me my problem is that when I listen to Nmixx music I feel like there will be random moments in the music with awesome vocal passages, but the music overall is more standard vocal level
While Aespa is carried on each music by Winter and Ningning, they have plenty of space to run wild (lots more lines too, together they do almost 2/3 of Aespa's lines)
and so I agree if we talk technical, Lily and Heawon would make a better duo, but when we listen to the music, I don't feel a duo that carries the group like Aespa
The concept of Nmixx's music leaves less spaces for Lily and Haewon i think

[@iheworld134]

i think lily, sullyon n haewon r better in skills compare aespa , n nmixx songs also not easy to sing.. i am sure they will covered aespa song beautifully as lily covered psycho rv still unbeatable till now, its just that aespa r more popular

[@iheworld134]

nmixx even still better than baemon technically , if u watch sullyon , lily n haewon performances , they r definitely a pro in singing ...reaching high notes is not the only score , but how u can sing effortlessly while belting the notes , thats the point

[@aimanman3647]

​@@iheworld134Please not bringing other group to praise your fav... NMIXX is talented but they r 7 of them so it's easy to hit higher note, meanwhile Aespa just 4 and like the other person said WinNing carried 3/4 of Aespa song lines.

[@uranium_xx]

​@@iheworld134 i love how u ruined the vibe by bringing nmixx and baemon, those group and aespa have all good vocals no need to make a whole paragraf yappin why their the best/comparing them

[@iheworld134]

@@aimanman3647 actually haewon , lily n sullyoon done some solo performances n singing by their own n still hit the notes perfectly

[@Moon-cy1rl]

Its pré recorded

[@uranium_xx]

Probally ur deaf

[@Navyacouldbefree]

Which member doesnt have good vocals in aespa? NOTANYONEE

[@eulalia3468]

Only Ningning is a main vocalist

[@xenon_7973]

Winter

[@cutebunnyhops]

Winter is main vocalist as well

[@Ndis02-n8b]

Winter too ❤

[@eulalia3468]

@@Ndis02-n8b I don't see it

[@eulalia3468]

@@cutebunnyhops not on the same level

[@Yujiniexz]

No hate at all but ningning looks like she is lip syncing 😭

[@Anurag-qg6np]

Never forgiving sm for not giving winter 2nd main vocalist position 😢

[@byunbaekyoong]

she's "main vocalist" too in their weverse profiles, as well as ningning

[@sunflowersyeppi]

She isss

[@eulalia3468]

​@@byunbaekyoongshe's not, made up by fans

[@cutebunnyhops]

She's main vocalist and technically was one since debut. Her vocal stability, projection, support and high notes all show her great level. She received vocal training from the best sm vocal couch yjj.

[@cutebunnyhops]

​@@eulalia3468She totally is! She was main vocalist since debut, her singing is on amazing level, she has the best stability in live performances and great projection. Her role in group was main vocalist and sm groups usually have several

[@Bliweis]

Guys please, ningning main vocalist winter lead 🙁 Ningning's vocal talent is more than Winter's please don't ignore it

[@BS-rr6uv]

Winter is a main vocalist and has been since Drama

[@SireveSM]

Winter is also named as main vocalist

[@Bliweis]

Winter tier is C and ning tier is C+/B. Winter level at main vocalist but not main vocalist, It's the fans who call him the main vocalist, SM already announced the group positions

[@SireveSM]

@@Bliweis Spotify named winter and Ningning at the same time as main vocalist during drama era

[@Bliweis]

yes Spotify but original positions annccounced by SM.

[@nuraziemahazmil5408]

Ningning looks bored

[@sanibunnii]

what's up with ningning's expression? she looks sad, bored, and she's barely opening her mouth :(

[@Morenmixx]

complex parts + tired.

[@blink_____jenniequeen6670]

They sang nonstop and all of their songs are difficult to sing live

[@priyamvadak6461]

Gurl pls💀🙏

[@Ning2_Yyds]

幽默😅

[@val.r.p]

Let's be honest, the last note from NNing was lipsync

[@uranium_xx]

Lets honest, nobody cares atleast shes singing before it

[@salinasultana9701]

U do realise they're lip singing?

[@lapisincognito]

You should see a doctor

[@laurareneea]

No they aren't

[@uranium_xx]

U do realise they're singing live?

[@Milliesook12]

The 4th gen icons are WinNing 😆🫶👏