Appears to be a mix. The “solo” parts seem to lack the self-layered harmonies, but the chorus has the layering. Only the sound engineer knows for sure!
Its prerecorded, not the studio version that you hear in the album but they record their voices in a studio and mix it so it sounds live (with less effects and pitch correction than the studio version), it has some correction but it is the closest to live vocals we can get nowadays. Nobody sings live in these concerts. Red Velvet still has many live singing performances that we can watch but as the industry has been moving away from live singing, Red Velvet live vocals have become more difficult to find even though they are one of the most talented singing group still active in Kpop.
![181220 NCT × WANNA ONE REACTION RED VELVET - BUTTERFLIES, POWER UP [KOREAN POPULAR MUSIC AWARDS]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4zZy8QAORQI/mqdefault.jpg)
![เจ็บที่ยังฮัก - ม่อน วรวิทย์ [ Official Mv ] จอนนี่มิวสิค](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KALIGSRSjFs/mqdefault.jpg)
![ร้อยพ่อพันแม่ - WanMai [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XY2pNYASEbg/mqdefault.jpg)
They are so slayful, people always complain about their stage presence but their stages are the most enjoyable for me
Same.
They literally one of the group that have great stage presence individually
literally never got that criticism, they always eat, doesnt even matter the concept
@@MineralTownthey ALWAYS get that criticism, especially irene and yeri. you must not listen to ppls opinions unless they absolutely love rv
@@user-oi9ej8bk4v lol what i just acknowledged that criticism in my comment. my opinion is that i disagree..
Wendy looks stunning
Irene so good, so beautiful ❤
Yeri look so pretty oh my gosh 😍😍😍 my heart ❤️❤️❤️😍😘
They look so good all in black 😍 so chic, so classy
Yeri looks so cool!°
What a SHOW!
RV rarely has the most technical choreo, but it is always so well matched with the music and thus, breathtaking.
Seulgi can match the vibe of any outfit she wore this whole concert💯👑🎉
Wendy was owning every stage! My girls always slay 💖💛💎💚💜
ur here again i love it
@@ginger325 Hello 👋
Irene and Seulgi looks like Gen 4 idols in their 20s they barely age.
BAEJOOHYUN Look so amazing
Joy looks so beautiful and hot 🔥 😍😍
WENDY💖💖💖💖💖💖
Joy so cute
Joy can do no wrong 💚💚💚
Yeriii beautifulllll❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Seulgiiii ❤
My queens.
Seulgi looks so pretty in this fit 😍😍😍
Seulgi so cute in this styling
I wonder why this is not uploaded by the official account like the other performances:(
Their outfit so beautiful
Seulgi must be very tired. Got the beat, Kai-Seulgi-Karina-Jeno Performance and her group and her solo 😓❤️ We love you and i hope you are okay💛
they are so prettyy. they look like a collection of dolls in these outfits 🥹
"RED VELVET" I LOOVEE YOU....KISSES
Wendy
The queens!!
Irene❤
아이린 무대 참 잘한다💗
Irene looks so pretty
que bonitos outfits. se ven bien bonitas
Love joohyun
My baby girl joohyun
💖💛💙💚💜🎉🎊
I like their clothes
te quiero mucho lucy
Their outfits are so cute but not cohesive. In love with Seulgi’s dress ❤
Yeaah it's almost like they're all dressing in different aesthetics but in black
My Birthday Dance Cover is out now: th-cam.com/video/RQF5VYYfI8s/w-d-xo.html
🎁🎈🎉🍺🎂🎊
Akhirnya joy bajunya tertutup
what is their fandom name?
Reveluv/Luvies
You are still here nice
what is yeri wearing 😣😣😣😣 give her a decent costume please
Did they sing live or lip sync? cuz there is a difference in they voice with the other stage voice
I think they were live
Appears to be a mix. The “solo” parts seem to lack the self-layered harmonies, but the chorus has the layering.
Only the sound engineer knows for sure!
Its prerecorded, not the studio version that you hear in the album but they record their voices in a studio and mix it so it sounds live (with less effects and pitch correction than the studio version), it has some correction but it is the closest to live vocals we can get nowadays. Nobody sings live in these concerts. Red Velvet still has many live singing performances that we can watch but as the industry has been moving away from live singing, Red Velvet live vocals have become more difficult to find even though they are one of the most talented singing group still active in Kpop.
@@claudiooyarce wendy confirmed it on her bubble that they sang it live thus, the breakdance is a bit lacking
@@koppamida nope, wendy said they sang it live
Red velvet with worst coreography dance
okay, but your group's vocals and discography are in the slums
Yet you're here to watch it. Are you an M?
anyway i'am a reveluv but really don't like this choreography, so annoying
With time you’ll be dancing to it too
@@bram8886 stfu, it's already 2023 be true to yourself and admit that you're not a reveluve lmao