The 2013 line up was the strongest and the most iconic, their company should have really treated them better, they really had a chance to became popular, what a pity....
@@Sanas_Shy_Language sure! I love sojin husky voice and keumjo sweet voice, i mean, they carried 9muses for almost 5 years, but my childhood is with 2011-2013 9muses
How I wish music shows would go back to having their microphones sound louder than the bg music. Literally I prefer hearing idols breathe on the microphones rather than see them perform the same song over and over again but can’t really tell if they are singing or what
진짜 나뮤는 휘가로 이후로가 찐이다,, 스윗튠 곡 받고 확실히 그룹이랑 곡컨셉도 잘맞아떨어지고 그 전까지는 뭔가 세련된 느낌도 부족하고 피지컬 쩌는 애들 모아놓고 좀 이미지에 안맞는 옷 입혀놓고 죽쑤는 느낌이었는데 휘가로 이후로 확실히 세련되고 그룹이미지 자리잡은 느낌임,, 진짜 최고 ㅠㅠ
와일드 무대는 정말 너무 좋다. 가사를 보고 있으면 정말 무슨 시 쓴거 같이 멋지고, 파워풀한 랩, 멤버들 하나하나 가창력까지 다 쩌는듯. 드라이브 하면서 와일드 나오면 정말 신나게 따라부름. 뉴스 - 티켓 - 돌스 - 와일드 - 건 - 글루 - 드라마로 이어지는 라인업은 미친듯
Ladies and Figaro would have been the better choice for a debut song. No Playboy was a bside at best. I really thought a song as catchy as Ticket would have skyrocketed them. If that came out today, it would have done SO WELL!!
indeed. Ladies would be an amazing debut, and then comeback with Figaro as soon as possible to launch them even further. hm such a great missed opportunity by Star Empire. Nine Muses never had a bad song, served greatness everytime, i mean by this throwback lives showed how great they are. but i guess knetz wasn't and never gonna be ready for this conversation about Nine Muses. a fan for a long time and it hurt seeing them never won anything with such amazing discographies of all time ╥﹏╥
I started being a fan when they released Dolls, after that they quickly became my favorite group. Till this day I still follow members and try to catch up with them. I'm happy too see they are gaining some spotlight these days even if it is "too late" and Nine Muses are no longer together. I just hope that the members are happy about all this late recognition, they worked so hard and suffered a lot, the girls deserve so much
@@Crysync098 she was kicked out of the group because she wanted to have more freedom in making their music and more rights to the members, maybe because of her "disobedience" that the company decided to do so. I've heard of another reason for her lack of height compared to other members. so now I assume all graduated members were being kicked out of the group. Look how they put Ssem in the center of their debut song and later on, she was out to most of the screen time and lastly, being kicked out @@. I hate Star Empire so much
"ladies" should've been their debut song... it would've stood out back then too since most kpop songs were going the heavy electro route. and the members seemed to enjoy performing that song a lot more than they did "no playboy"
and its the perfect introduction and crowd hype song. Immagine meeting all the members with thecrowd cheers ladies with them. chills and they obviously enjoy it
I can’t help but feel sad watching these performances. It’s heartbreaking hearing how abusive their company was to the girls. I hope they are all doing much better now. It’s good to see Sera healing and coping with her time with 9muses and their company too.
You can clearly see how hard they worked to improve their stage skills from No Playboy (hesitant, lacking confidence...) to Figaro (powerful, amazing sinchronization...)
Thank you so much for doing this fantastic compilation, KBS!!! It gives me such joy to see anything related to 9Muses getting attention, and bringing more eyes onto this iconic group. They deserved so much more from the public who never gave them a win, from their company who treated them terribly, and from the K-Pop scene in general who always overlooked them... same with Rainbow too. I miss you so much 9Muses. Eunji was my bias in this group, with Minha as my bias wrecker. Short blonde haired Eunji destroyed me so much.
9Muses OT14member, please get back together again. Please release a new song once I beg of you 😢 I miss you so much Model idol Gen two that I love pro made my dream come true Bring back all the members who didn't show up with you today, Ryu Sera,Lee Sam,Sungah,Binnie and Eunji please 😥
Really started loving Erin since the song News. She was extra fierce or something.. I already loved Lee Sem and Eunji before that. So sad they never won a show reward. Ladies, Figaro, News, Ticket and Dolls. One of those songs should have at least won something. That was also their best formation years also. But this group has been one of my favorites till this date.
This is a seriously amazing ticket through all of their eras. I cried when I saw their recent MTMG performance - it was wonderful to dee them comeback if for one performance. Now going back in time and watching this all from the beginning all at once is surreal compared to seeing their changes and growth over time from debut to unfortunate or fortunate disbandment. I'll forever love 9Muses, precious women who deserved so much better.
They were so talented and improved so much since debut. Just wish Sera didn't leave 😕 I felt like their peak year was during dolls, wild, gun, glue era 😢
Figaro was the benchmark for me recognized them as 1 of group that very in sync on that era... Figaro also the 1st song that makes me followed their cb
We really should give many credits to Pyo Hyemi, she is there from 9muses created until it disbanded. She never leave and always stay. Thank you hyemi ❤
Im loving the love 9muses is getting from official channels. All these high quality reuploads of old stages are a blessing and I hope it brings new fans ✨❤️
Glue > Dolls > Gun > Wild are my favorite. To be honest, Sera was the face of the group before leaving. She's the only member I remembered at the first time watching 9muses. I can't understand why they had given her lots of line + screentime + center ending position but still fired her then?
Let me tell you. Sera really brought 9muses on her back during first half of their career . Respect.shes not even my bias but the group never the same after she left. Also the addition of Hyuna Sungah and Kyungri were one of the best decision came from a company in term of picking new line up. Letting sera go was one of THE worst ever
![[#가수모음zip] AOA 모음.zip (AOA Stage Compilation) | KBS 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ci32J9NDs2k/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Playlist] 그 시절, 우리가 좋아했던 나인뮤지스](/img/n.gif)
그땐몰랐는데 지금보니 이샘이 존나이쁘네
이때는 경리가 원탑인거 같은데 지금은 진짜 이샘이 리얼 이뻤네 ㅠㅠ 시대가 참 ㅠㅠ 이샘 지금이면 레전드 찍겠다
은근 명곡이 많은 나인뮤지스~~~
음색은 현아가 짱!!!
The 2013 line up was the strongest and the most iconic, their company should have really treated them better, they really had a chance to became popular, what a pity....
I do agree, but we do have to give credit to Sojin and Keumjo for being great performers and talented individuals who added a lot to the group.
@@Sanas_Shy_Language sure! I love sojin husky voice and keumjo sweet voice, i mean, they carried 9muses for almost 5 years, but my childhood is with 2011-2013 9muses
세라언니 솔로 무대까지 넣어주시다니,, 심지어는 탈퇴 이후인데도,,, 정말 감사합니다,,,🥲🥲♥️
심지어 영상 시작임
정말 감동 ㅜㅜㅜ
감동ㅠ
그러네요
나뮤팬들 리즈 잘 파악해서 좋아요
@@monino7238 리즈 -> 니즈 o
00:00 시작부터 댕예쁜 세라언니 나오네 ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ
플레이보이 3:28 ~ 9:28
Ladies 9:29 ~ 14:46
Figaro 14:53 ~ 21:07
News 21:16 ~ 27:46
Ticket 27:47 ~ 34:04
쳐다만봐 34:15 ~ 35:26
Dolls 35:27 ~ 41:56
Wild 42:05 ~ 48:27
intro Gun 48:37 ~ 49:43
Gun 49:44 ~ 55:34
Glue 55:35 ~ 58:45
이후로도 노래들 댕 좋지만 피곤함 이슈로 자러가야됨...
소속사한테 할말 진짜 많은데 .....진짜 멤버들 다 행복했음 좋겠따!!!!!
Thankuuuui❤
참고로 WILD 활동 막방은 뮤뱅이 2주 빨랐음
나인뮤지스 재결합+재컴백 기원 하는 사람 🖐
@강민호 맞음 세라랑 이유애린은 꼭있어야함
@@jwone-qf6eo 진짜 이유애린 엄청 좋아했는데
이유애린×이샘 크로스 랩하던 시절이 좋았는데 +은지
2022.12.24 재결합 하면 좋겠지만 앨범 하나라도… 희망합니다!
애린느ㅠ 그리워요
🖐️🖐️🖐️🖐️🖐️
가수가 갖춰야할 조건을 다 갖춤 노래 + 춤 + 랩 + 거기에 미친 비주얼까지 왜 안뜬거지?
시대를 잘못타고남.. 멤버가 너무많음..
나이가 너무많음..
뮤직뱅크에서 나뮤 많이 챙겨줬었지 수록곡 무대도 꼬박꼬박하게 해주고 해체한다 했을 때 스페셜로 영상도 만들어줬었음 ㅋㅋㅋ 케이가 영혼없는 목소리로 나인뮤지스 기억하겠다고 한 게 인상적이었는데 ㅋㅋㅋ
How I wish music shows would go back to having their microphones sound louder than the bg music. Literally I prefer hearing idols breathe on the microphones rather than see them perform the same song over and over again but can’t really tell if they are singing or what
Same!
Same
Indeed. 2nd gen era were literally gold! You can hear clearly their harsh breathing on the mic
진짜 와일드 못 잃는다 난....
사람들이 경리 노래 잘하는거 알아야 하는데
머중들 무시하지마셈 노래잘하는것 알고 있음 ㅋㅋ
ㄹㅇ 음색여신
이거보고 놀랐어요 ㅋㅋ 경리 음도정확하고 음색도 좋고 잘하네요
알고있음 나뮤 4대보컬
세라+현아+경리+혜미
스윗튠 전후로 나뉘는구나 진짜..
Dolls is charting again!
한창 근본 없는 비쥬얼 가요들 선입견 때문에 관심도 없었는데 유튜브에서 티켓 듣고 다른 곡들 찾아 들으며 밤샛던 기억이 있네요
곡들 퀄리티 소화력이 상당합니다
개인적으로 올타임
나인뮤지스 정체성은 세라지
Opening this compilation with Sera's Han River was a beautiful touch and consideration. Well done KBS editor! Ah 9Muses, we miss you!
Sera... the heart of Namyu
@@raeyni 😢ㄱㄱᆢㅣㆍㆍㅡㅡ3ㅡ3ㅡㅜㅡ고3ㅡㅡㅡㅑㄴ😢ㅣㅣㄱ7
Ryu Sera is definitely a pion of Nine Muses.
진짜 나뮤는 휘가로 이후로가 찐이다,, 스윗튠 곡 받고 확실히 그룹이랑 곡컨셉도 잘맞아떨어지고 그 전까지는 뭔가 세련된 느낌도 부족하고 피지컬 쩌는 애들 모아놓고 좀 이미지에 안맞는 옷 입혀놓고 죽쑤는 느낌이었는데 휘가로 이후로 확실히 세련되고 그룹이미지 자리잡은 느낌임,, 진짜 최고 ㅠㅠ
플레이보이는 충격 그자체였는데 박진영 작사작곡ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
와일드 무대는 정말 너무 좋다.
가사를 보고 있으면 정말 무슨 시 쓴거 같이 멋지고, 파워풀한 랩, 멤버들 하나하나 가창력까지 다 쩌는듯.
드라이브 하면서 와일드 나오면 정말 신나게 따라부름.
뉴스 - 티켓 - 돌스 - 와일드 - 건 - 글루 - 드라마로 이어지는 라인업은 미친듯
진짜 이샘이 예쁘긴예뻐..
42:22 다들 라이브 진짜 잘한다
나뮤는 또 못참지....
💜
3:25 No PlayBoy
6:43 No PlayBoy
9:30 Ladies
12:10 Ladies
14:51 Figaro
18:13 Intro + Figaro
21:16 Intro + News
24:49 News
27:48 TICKET
30:58 TICKET
34:14 Just Looking
35:28 Dolls
38:35 Dolls
42:04 Wild
45:27 Wild
48:38 Intro + GUN
52:41 GUN
55:36 Glue
1:02:22 September 17th
1:03:24 DRAMA
1:06:24 DRAMA
1:09:28 Hurt Locker
1:12:53 Hurt Locker
1:16:28 Sleppless Night
1:19:51 Sleepless Night
1:29:19 Hate Me
1:31:17 Remember
1:35:03 Remember
1:38:46 Love City
미모 실력 퍼포먼스 다 되는 그룹이었네// 왜 그땐 몰랐을까 1시간 48분 짜리 다 봤어요
세라 노래 진짜 잘하는구나.....대박
세라는 음색이 특이해서 좋음
경리도 그렇구
음색도 좋고 기본 실력까지 받쳐주니 완벽한 메보 그 자체였음
나뮤에 메보 겁나 많음
Ladies and Figaro would have been the better choice for a debut song. No Playboy was a bside at best. I really thought a song as catchy as Ticket would have skyrocketed them. If that came out today, it would have done SO WELL!!
indeed. Ladies would be an amazing debut, and then comeback with Figaro as soon as possible to launch them even further. hm such a great missed opportunity by Star Empire. Nine Muses never had a bad song, served greatness everytime, i mean by this throwback lives showed how great they are. but i guess knetz wasn't and never gonna be ready for this conversation about Nine Muses. a fan for a long time and it hurt seeing them never won anything with such amazing discographies of all time
╥﹏╥
ㄹㅇ 라이브 짱짱하네 특히 세라 와일드 마지막 파트에서 한음 높여부르는 거 쾌감쩐다
멤버 하나하나가 다 단비같이 중요하다..ㅠ
세라양 파트에.취한다..
2024년 출첵~ dolls는 진짜 명곡♡
moon hyuna has one the most unique voices ive heard in kpop, woah
부잣집 언니들이 취미로 아이돌하는것같네 부티보소..
경리언니도🩷🩷 2012년에 새멤버였구나🙊🙊 그동안 원년멤버인줄 알았는데 아니였다는게 너무 신기한데 뭔가 잘어울려서 그렇게 보였나봐ㅎㅎ😍😍
I wish one day all 11 members that made 9muses as a group would perform one day again
after school showed us how u gotta do!
@@raeyni i mean, 9muses performed with them (on the same show i mean) lol
조.😎
문특보고 여기까지 왓네 문현아 너무 좋아 어떡해 고화질 너무 좋아요 ㅠ...
다들 라이브도 잘하고, 거의 10년전인데 왜 안촌스럽냐 ㅠㅠ..넘예다
나뮤는 세라 있을 때랑 경리 있을 때 로 나뉨.
세라 때의 나뮤는 모델같은 느낌의 가수라는 이미지였다면
경리 따의 나뮤는 노래잘하는 모델같은 느낌..
갠적으론 세라 때의 나뮤가 나뮤 음악의 전성기라고 생각함
I started being a fan when they released Dolls, after that they quickly became my favorite group. Till this day I still follow members and try to catch up with them. I'm happy too see they are gaining some spotlight these days even if it is "too late" and Nine Muses are no longer together. I just hope that the members are happy about all this late recognition, they worked so hard and suffered a lot, the girls deserve so much
The exact same story me and my sister had with 9muses
What happened with Sera?
@@Crysync098 she was kicked out of the group because she wanted to have more freedom in making their music and more rights to the members, maybe because of her "disobedience" that the company decided to do so. I've heard of another reason for her lack of height compared to other members. so now I assume all graduated members were being kicked out of the group. Look how they put Ssem in the center of their debut song and later on, she was out to most of the screen time and lastly, being kicked out @@.
I hate Star Empire so much
"ladies" should've been their debut song... it would've stood out back then too since most kpop songs were going the heavy electro route. and the members seemed to enjoy performing that song a lot more than they did "no playboy"
Exactly. No Playboy was horrible.
i couldn't believe No Playboy was produced by JYP~
and its the perfect introduction and crowd hype song. Immagine meeting all the members with thecrowd cheers ladies with them. chills
and they obviously enjoy it
@@hfz428 and also the fact that "Bad Girl Good Girl" was going to be 9muses debut and "No Playboy" MissA debut 💀💀💀
Plus lee sem’s hair is so cute hehehe
I can’t help but feel sad watching these performances. It’s heartbreaking hearing how abusive their company was to the girls. I hope they are all doing much better now. It’s good to see Sera healing and coping with her time with 9muses and their company too.
Yeah it seems most of them are doing better. Sungah is married and has a kid so it seems she's also doing well.
I miss them every day....
첫 스타트 세라언니 좋구요 😍😍
They should’ve at least won 1win on each song starting from Figaro 🥺🥺
나인뮤지스 모음
1위를 못했을 뿐이지 분명히 다들 알고 있는 걸그룹...노래도 좋고 휘가로때 부터 좋았음
You can clearly see how hard they worked to improve their stage skills from No Playboy (hesitant, lacking confidence...) to Figaro (powerful, amazing sinchronization...)
yes! you can tell starting from Figaro they were getting more confident, after all the songs released after that are all dope!
Its even evident from No Playboy to Ladies-
Let's be honest, things were not the same after the 2013 line up fell apart
Yepp, i stop stanning new groups after 2016.. everything fell apart after 2013, its all girl crush after that and im getting sick of it..
Dolls and glue are my favorite songs by them they really shined in 2013
@@bansheelee51 Not falling apart in kpop as a whole, but for 9 Muses specifically. They lost 3 original members in 2014
The difference in confidence between No Playboy and Ladies is so evident. You can tell which song they felt more comfortable singing-
진짜 다 띵곡,, 글루가 진짜 세라 언니 앞머리 없애고 머리 흑발하고 외모 레전드 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 경리도 이때부터 예뻐졌고 그냥 이때 멤버들 외모가 다 레전드,,,,,,
세라님 노래 너무 잘해 진짜.
Thank you so much for doing this fantastic compilation, KBS!!! It gives me such joy to see anything related to 9Muses getting attention, and bringing more eyes onto this iconic group. They deserved so much more from the public who never gave them a win, from their company who treated them terribly, and from the K-Pop scene in general who always overlooked them... same with Rainbow too. I miss you so much 9Muses. Eunji was my bias in this group, with Minha as my bias wrecker. Short blonde haired Eunji destroyed me so much.
We cant really change the fact they were part of Kpop History
돌스 들으러 왔는데 한강 너무 좋다..
Oh how much I love Figaro even after a decade❤️
SAME!
9Muses OT14member, please get back together again. Please release a new song once I beg of you 😢 I miss you so much Model idol Gen two that I love pro made my dream come true Bring back all the members who didn't show up with you today, Ryu Sera,Lee Sam,Sungah,Binnie and Eunji please 😥
14:46
언니들 그립다
Really started loving Erin since the song News. She was extra fierce or something.. I already loved Lee Sem and Eunji before that.
So sad they never won a show reward. Ladies, Figaro, News, Ticket and Dolls. One of those songs should have at least won something.
That was also their best formation years also. But this group has been one of my favorites till this date.
11:06 문현아 맞죠?
귀에 꽂히네
When it comes to 9 Muses Ryu Sera always pop up on mind, she carried the group well!
이 언니들 어디계시나요? 행복하세요.
너무 늦게 보석들을 알아본 죄.
늦은앓이로 힘들어요. 컴백하시면 팬질할께요.
This is a seriously amazing ticket through all of their eras. I cried when I saw their recent MTMG performance - it was wonderful to dee them comeback if for one performance. Now going back in time and watching this all from the beginning all at once is surreal compared to seeing their changes and growth over time from debut to unfortunate or fortunate disbandment. I'll forever love 9Muses, precious women who deserved so much better.
진짜 독보적인 피지컬 압도적인 비주얼..그리고 수준급의 라이브실력까지 완벽했는데 1등한번 못한 이유를 모르겠네.
I’m addicted to Gun & Wild .. I start to admire them since then
Me too! I’ve been having these two on repeat for like 3 weeks now
I miss them TT. I wish for 9muses's comeback. It doesn't matter 2013 line, 2015 line or maybe ot 11. I will definitely cheer them up !! 🥰
와일드에서 세라보고 충격받았던기억이...진짜 에쁜데 노래도 진짜잘부르고 음색존재감이 쩔어서....
노래를 잘 하시네요, 저번에 공연 영상보았는데, 감동적이더라구요,
드라마는 지금 들어도 명곡이라고 생각함.
They were so talented and improved so much since debut. Just wish Sera didn't leave 😕 I felt like their peak year was during dolls, wild, gun, glue era 😢
라이브..지렷다....❤️
news는 지금들어도 딱 나인뮤지스랑어울리는
강한 여전사느낌임
돌 티켓 뉴스등 은근명곡많음
I want to believe there's an universe where they blew up right after Glue
노래가 처음엔 병맛이다가 점점 세련되어가네
Figaro was the benchmark for me recognized them as 1 of group that very in sync on that era... Figaro also the 1st song that makes me followed their cb
노래 왜 다 좋냐 ㅋㅋㅋ 아무생각없이 듣다가 1시간 반 순삭이넹
노플보 저 괴랄한 메이크업에서 혼자 살아남은 이샘갓…
무려 슈퍼모델 1위까지 하셨던 어마무시한 분이시라... (당시 나뮤에서 민낯이 가장 예쁜 분이셨습니다)
눈호강한다 진짜 비율 압도적이다
(9muses)나인뮤지스 노래모음이네요~내일은 너무 기대가 됩니다^^잘 볼께요~감사합니다^^😊😊😊😊💞💞💞💞❤❤❤❤
나뮤 재결성 보고싶따❤
Love 9muses, the were so underated. They have one of the greatest discography
We really should give many credits to Pyo Hyemi, she is there from 9muses created until it disbanded. She never leave and always stay. Thank you hyemi ❤
WE WANT ALL 11 MEMBERS TO GATHER TOGETHER ❤❤❤❤❤🙏🏻😍
Im loving the love 9muses is getting from official channels. All these high quality reuploads of old stages are a blessing and I hope it brings new fans ✨❤️
11년도 군번에겐 나뮤 뉴스 티켓 돌스 와일드 4연타는 레게노...추억 ㄷㄷ
Glue > Dolls > Gun > Wild are my favorite. To be honest, Sera was the face of the group before leaving. She's the only member I remembered at the first time watching 9muses. I can't understand why they had given her lots of line + screentime + center ending position but still fired her then?
I heard a rumor that it was because her height didn't match the other members and also her body type isn't considered 'good enough'.
헐 노플레이보이가 제와피였음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ??
당시에 중딩이였는데 ㄹㅇ 나혼자만 숨어서 들었어
I miss them so much.
The live vocals during those Wild stage were IMMACULATE
나뮤 재결합 했으면 좋겠다
Only if they got recognition early on in their career 🙁
Поющий подиум! Топ модели да еще и голосистые! Молодцы!
류세라님 음색이 애즈원 느낌 나네요
카메라보며 이쁜척 귀여운척 치명적인척 하면서 립싱크 + 퍼포먼스로 시간떼우는 요즘 걸그룹하고는 차원이 다름 ㅠㅠ 진짜 이런 그룹이 가수라고요
지보다 한참 어린 여자애들 까는거 창피하지도 않나 남돌도 여돌만 언급하는게 투리하노ㅜ
Let me tell you. Sera really brought 9muses on her back during first half of their career . Respect.shes not even my bias but the group never the same after she left. Also the addition of Hyuna Sungah and Kyungri were one of the best decision came from a company in term of picking new line up. Letting sera go was one of THE worst ever
데뷔곡은 진짜 다시들어봐도....어떻게 저걸로 데뷔할 생각을했지 스죄도 정말 대단해
that HUGE glow up from NO Playboy/Ladies to Figaro remains ICONIC! i miss them so muchT.T
문현아..♡
The upgrade of confidence when they performed no playboy to ladies 💕
티켓 인트로 듣고 과몰입 오타쿠 벅차오르자나...
박경리 어젯밤까지 오타쿠 울리는 케베스... 감사합니다.... 수신료의 가치...
김나뮤,,,,,
Ryu Sera unnie❤