대형기획사에서 데뷔 = 대기업 취직 같은 느낌이라 생각함 그만큼 경쟁률도 비정상적으로 높고 결과물도 비정상적으로 퀄리티가 높음 중소기획사 아티스트들이 실력이 없는건 아닌데(오히려 실력이 뛰어난 아티스트들도 생각보다 많죠) 곡,무대,안무,홍보,플랫폼,메이크업에 쓸 자본이 없으니 상대적으로 결과물의 퀄리티가 낮을 수 밖에 없는데 이게 불합리하고 잘못된 부분은 아님. 자본주의 사회에서 자본이 많은 쪽이 유리한건 당연한 이치임 ㅇㅇ 근데 난 SM 싫어함
Lol Giselle fix her mic is such a cutie, also Karina pose is perfectly stunning, Winter voice is unexpected Ningning highnote just got me a goosebump. Guys we really have a full package girls here, lets continued support them
0:45- Karina steps forward, tilts head on trigger sound then drops on the floor. If that ain't the most flawless and iconic move of a rookie debut, I don't know what else is. 🔥🔥🔥
Look at the synchronicity. It's top notch for a rookie group. It doesn't like it's their first time performing live because on how they project in the camera. All of them can sing and dance which you don't see often in girl groups. I've been a casual listener of Kpop right after SNSD, but I think I'm gonna stan Aespa from now on. Keep working hard girls and show them what you got. You girls are going to be on top.
*Winter* is on another level, the way she sings and dances and her charisma & stage presence. What a monster rookie, I can't stop focusing on her! Plus her visuals are insanely pretty, she looks like a real life fairy!
There's no wonder why Karina is the center. Shes really the complete packages. I can't wait to see how these girls grow in the future. They're definitely a force to look out for.
ningning's stage presence is outstanding. she's a total entertainer, her vocals and body control when dancing are insane. not to mention her expressions! she's gonna go far and i'm excited to see her succeed
@@anandagemilang22 she was training with sm for almost 5 years, i"m pretty sure her korean is somewhat fluent by now but knowing how knetz act towards chinese idols sm better protect her and aespa at all cost
@@aimeelee3682 My eyes are just fixated on her the whole time. Didn't even bother to see the rest. I hope SM promotes her well because it looks like all they care about promoting now is Karina..she isn't even that great.
Karina is so mesmerising, she dances well, her stage presence is strong. She has really nice body. love the outfit! (Disclaimer: Totally not complimenting myself)
Ningning has good facial expressions while dancing, it makes her interesting to watch, she really feels the song. Also LOVE her voice Karina kills the black mamba dance move, it's like she's an actual snake. She's a super good dancer in the opinion of someone who can't dance at all. Winter looks like a veteran kpop member, like she's been performing on stage for years and it just comes naturally. Giselle has such a cool vibe to her it's hard to explain, like she's super pretty but there is this "girl crush" coolness to her that's very really charming. Your eyes naturally float to her while watching the performance.
Idk why my eyes always goes to Karina. She's so charismatic and eye catching. From vocal, dance, expression, stage presence, she's just a full package! SM is just SM, that's why they push her so hard as the center and main dancer. Hope that people stop hating her 🥺💗
Karina is like a complete package. She clearly can dance, rap, sing and that voice is so addicting... not to forget she's gorgeous and her expression is like a pro. I just can't stop from looking at her
저렇게 하는 동작은 흔하게 사용되는건 맞음 근데 이 안무가 좋아보이는 포인트는 단순히 저동작이 아니라 싸비로 바뀌는 부분에서 동시에 땅! 하고 떨어지는 부분에서 나오는 쾌감같음 저렇게 동작 하나하나 따져보면 가수든 춤 다 거기서 거기임 그 동작을 어떻게 의도하냐가 중요한거지
Let me just praise the choreography again: This is why SM's choreographies are my favorite, the leg drop part fits so well to how the beat drops and that is so creative and iconic, I just can't- And the girls slayed this so well too, especially our main dancer, people who have called Karina stiff before must feel like clowns now, she shines so much in this choreo! ♡
From this video it became quite apparent why Karina is the main dancer. She has great technique and her dancing is much cleaner than the rest. Also, great lower body control and angles.
why on earth are you already comparing the members.😂 if someone is the main dancer, we already know she is a little more skilled in dance, why are we pointing out the already obvious? there's no need.
I see no one talking about Giselle. To me out of all of them she has the best stage presence. She seems like the Yuna of Itzy to me. Like the others (Karina and Ning Ning) might look more fierce, but she definitely looks like the one who is whole heartedly enjoying the performance. I couldn't keep my eyes off her
No wonder why Karina is the main dancer, i mean LOOK AT HER. Perfect for the center and her moves are so sharp. So pretty, charismatic and barbie like. Im inlove
@@marie.857 actually sometimes no matter how long someone trained, they still can be stuff and awkward while dancing, I’m sure the way she dances is the result of the natural sense of the rhythm+ trainings
They all are good and so talented. This is only their debut stage, but they have shown their potentials, and they are a rookie monster indeed. I know why SM chose Karina as the main dancer and FTOG, because she is enjoying their performance the most and she has that center's charm. So, you guys should stop questioning sm's decision. I'm gladthat music bank showed us equal screen times.
Even though Winter is my bias. I agreed that Karina should be the center and face of the group. Just look at her face, her dance, her expression. She’s born to be an idol and to those people who judge her because of her dancing skills, open your eyes and look how smooth she dance... and she fits to be the leader of this group!!
@@eliminjeong_ah788 how come visual became a position when all of them looks beautiful? Also Karina and Giselle can sing too. The four are all total package. Winter is not the ace
Yes true that. SM n their promotional picks are always sparkling. For their female esp some might dislike at first but u can see most of their picks as Face or Center always attract many n they truly charismatic
@s n a k e are you blind? When someone dances in the center one member dances behind the center so it looks like 3. They do have a center and its Karina.
Karina is so pretty.She can easily be an Actress,a Beauty Queen. I am not biased but Giselle is also fire whereas NingNing is charismatic and Winter is showing Confident smile.
I can see that SM does not go for “easy, cutesy, tik-tok” choreo that everyone can follow for aespa debut song because they want the highlight the members’ dance skills.
무대가 너무 답답해보이는 이유를 알았어. 멤버들 동선이 너무 중심에만 있어서 그런 것 같다.... 멤버들이 적으면 적은대로 무대를 잘 활용해야 하는데 거기서 거기로 머무르니까 답답해보이는 듯. 그래서 에스파는 나야, 윈터가 센터에서 조금씩 옮겨갈 때 그 부분이 아주 조금 해소가 되는데 그 부분 뺴면 계속 중앙에서만 안무를 하네.
I remember seeing this for first time thinking this is the most visual group in general,karina look like the dream girl of every person and she should be wonderwoman bcs she has everything
![[K-Choreo 8K] 에스파 직캠 'Armageddon' (aespa Choreography) @MusicBank 240531](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LvzafrmPQXU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[K-Choreo 8K] 에스파 직캠 'Armageddon' (aespa Choreography) @MusicBank 240531](/img/tr.png)
![[Watch Party] RoV Pro League 2024 Winter | ( Bacon Time Vs PSG )](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zM25REvnJW4/mqdefault.jpg)
![[UNCUT] The Loyal Pin ปิ่นภักดิ์ EP.6 (1/4)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/m05kZ2GDKXg/mqdefault.jpg)
대형의 장점: 엠넷 채널이나 다른 아이돌 콘텐츠 제작사에서 뿌리는 양산형 콘텐츠에 나갈 필요 없이 무대영상 자체가 화제가 됨
오 맞아
반면에 논란도 큼 하지만 다 덮어버리지
근데 그러는 만큼 무대에 돈을 오지게 쏟아부은 느낌이 남.. 이게 대형만이 할 수 있는 거겠지
그래서 다들 대형이 되려는거지
대형의 장점이라기보단 능력이다.
대형기획사에서 데뷔 = 대기업 취직
같은 느낌이라 생각함
그만큼 경쟁률도 비정상적으로 높고 결과물도 비정상적으로 퀄리티가 높음
중소기획사 아티스트들이 실력이 없는건 아닌데(오히려 실력이 뛰어난 아티스트들도 생각보다 많죠) 곡,무대,안무,홍보,플랫폼,메이크업에 쓸 자본이 없으니 상대적으로 결과물의 퀄리티가 낮을 수 밖에 없는데 이게 불합리하고 잘못된 부분은 아님. 자본주의 사회에서 자본이 많은 쪽이 유리한건 당연한 이치임 ㅇㅇ
근데 난 SM 싫어함
Lol Giselle fix her mic is such a cutie, also Karina pose is perfectly stunning, Winter voice is unexpected Ningning highnote just got me a goosebump. Guys we really have a full package girls here, lets continued support them
They are so perfect, all of them ace!!! This is first time i found a group that all of them all rounder tho 😭😭😭
@@mahae5634 ME TOO, after RV now I found another girl group that worth and deserve all the love and support 😭
When?
I think its a prerecorded stage
So i dont surprised by the high note
2:47 이부분 안무하다가 머리카락 얼굴에 걸리니까 마지막 엔딩 포즈 잡기전에 재빨리 정리하고 포즈 취하는거 지린다... 쾌감 쩔음
애들이 스엠돌이라 그런지 다 예쁘다 카리나는 cg처럼 생겼고 닝닝은 걍 귀여운데 예쁨 윈터는 순정 만화 첫사랑이고 지젤은 소설 여우 상인 여주임
에스파 넥스트레벨 신곡 만관부!
0:45- Karina steps forward, tilts head on trigger sound then drops on the floor.
If that ain't the most flawless and iconic move of a rookie debut, I don't know what else is. 🔥🔥🔥
Look at the synchronicity. It's top notch for a rookie group. It doesn't like it's their first time performing live because on how they project in the camera. All of them can sing and dance which you don't see often in girl groups. I've been a casual listener of Kpop right after SNSD, but I think I'm gonna stan Aespa from now on. Keep working hard girls and show them what you got. You girls are going to be on top.
Karina and nining's posture when leg drop start was exellence and perfect as for my observation..😊
yess I think that both of them are the best at doing the leg drop and can control their expresions.
Yes I loved there drops
*ningning
Is karina the main dancer?
@@Acsv122 yes she is
저 날은 카리나의 날이지 진짜 의상 헤어 다 합쳐서 빠지는 게 하나도 없었음 개인적으로 너무 이뻤다고 생각한 무대
이 날이랑 인기가요는 정말 레잔드..
이 날이 첫 무대였는데 그동안 카리나 논란있던거 다 사그라짐ㅋㅋㅋ
@@liod324 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@liod324 지금 다시 떠오르고 있는데 성형 때문에ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@thebiguncutone 근데 ㄹㅇ 궁금한 게 아이돌들 성형한 걸로 왤케 까대는 거임? 아니 아이돌이면 당연히 성형하는 게 정상이지 오히려 안 하는 게 이상함 하다못해 시술이라도 하고 나와야지 얘넨 외적인 걸로 벌고 먹고 사는 직업인데 일반인도 아니고 ㅋㅋㅋ
*Winter* is on another level, the way she sings and dances and her charisma & stage presence. What a monster rookie, I can't stop focusing on her! Plus her visuals are insanely pretty, she looks like a real life fairy!
i've noticed that in all of there fancams, Giselle looks like she's having a really great time. love it
There's no wonder why Karina is the center. Shes really the complete packages. I can't wait to see how these girls grow in the future. They're definitely a force to look out for.
up!
AGREE!
yes, karina it girl
진짜 카리나 헤드뱅잉 오진다 쾌감 쩜ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ningning's stage presence is outstanding. she's a total entertainer, her vocals and body control when dancing are insane. not to mention her expressions! she's gonna go far and i'm excited to see her succeed
Ikr I feel like she can also slay as a solo artist
She reminds me of Victoria! 💖
i just wish she is now way more fluent in korean. Because if she’s not, that will be hard on her. Especially knetz will hunt her down
@@anandagemilang22 she was training with sm for almost 5 years, i"m pretty sure her korean is somewhat fluent by now but knowing how knetz act towards chinese idols sm better protect her and aespa at all cost
@@aimeelee3682 My eyes are just fixated on her the whole time. Didn't even bother to see the rest. I hope SM promotes her well because it looks like all they care about promoting now is Karina..she isn't even that great.
They doesn't look like rookie group, the charisma and stage presence is out of the world..
Love æspa
wow nicing
Yep. It seems that they came to eat the world
That’s exactly what I was thinking
Giselle's hairflips during the chorus are addicting
Yes this. Especially on aya ya ya ya ya part
Trueee
Another hairflip queen 😍
Karina is so mesmerising, she dances well, her stage presence is strong. She has really nice body. love the outfit!
(Disclaimer: Totally not complimenting myself)
Ningning has good facial expressions while dancing, it makes her interesting to watch, she really feels the song. Also LOVE her voice
Karina kills the black mamba dance move, it's like she's an actual snake. She's a super good dancer in the opinion of someone who can't dance at all.
Winter looks like a veteran kpop member, like she's been performing on stage for years and it just comes naturally.
Giselle has such a cool vibe to her it's hard to explain, like she's super pretty but there is this "girl crush" coolness to her that's very really charming. Your eyes naturally float to her while watching the performance.
Giselle couldn't stop smiling during the performance, I loved that.
yasss! ningning really has great stage presence.
Is ningning got injured on her knee?
@@biell3057 why? how do you know?
@@cheeselova9252 her right knee is bleeding, you can see it clearly on her fancam
Idk why my eyes always goes to Karina. She's so charismatic and eye catching. From vocal, dance, expression, stage presence, she's just a full package! SM is just SM, that's why they push her so hard as the center and main dancer. Hope that people stop hating her 🥺💗
Same
I hope she will be future queen of kpop
same😍
She's symbol the power of women
@@ksatriabajahitam1169 you're right
Ryujin: break ur shoulder
Shotaro: break ur neck
Aespa : break ur leg
Seulrene: Breaks your hands and fingers
the most iconic dances of 2020
@@qxrrrr5993 yess!
Cravity : Break the rules
So true
전설의 데뷔직캠 사랑해 에스파 짱스파 갓스파
ningning's charisma and facial expressions while slaying dance and vocals? A BIG YES. 🙌
She reminds me of Joy and Jennie😍
Ningning is my bias she is the prettiest to me she is like a doll
I need blonde ningning 😭
She’s the prettiest and she’s from my hometown
Its prerecorded btw
이 의상 한건 블랙맘바 나타나기전 모습 표현하려고 저 의상 입힌거 같은데 뮤비보면 밝은 분위기에서 블랙맘바 나타난후 어두워지는데
이 무대 다음 인가 에서 한무대보면 분위기바꼈잖
Karina is like a complete package. She clearly can dance, rap, sing and that voice is so addicting... not to forget she's gorgeous and her expression is like a pro. I just can't stop from looking at her
And tall like a badass model
Up , her face also have actress vibes
if she sing with that deep voice it'll kill everything
Yesss
@@tyadailydose4863 not jut actress she is out of this world. I think she should be the most beautiful girl in the world
0:44 이 부분 춤 여태껏 걸그룹 춤 중에서 너무 멋있어서 가장 충격먹은 춤인듯 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
있지 워너비에도있음
@@user-bw6xj9yr1e 그냥 저 동작이 흔함 소시 더보이즈 안무에도 있음
저렇게 하는 동작은 흔하게 사용되는건 맞음 근데 이 안무가 좋아보이는 포인트는 단순히 저동작이 아니라 싸비로 바뀌는 부분에서 동시에 땅! 하고 떨어지는 부분에서 나오는 쾌감같음 저렇게 동작 하나하나 따져보면 가수든 춤 다 거기서 거기임 그 동작을 어떻게 의도하냐가 중요한거지
가요대축제 에스파분들만 라이브로 불렀음....다른가수들 다 엠알깔고불렀는데 에스파는 저 춤에 생라이브로 부름...괜히 스엠이 아니여...너무 잘해서 충격적이였다
@@user-iv2ut4vw1l 가요대축제때 유일하게 생라이브였어요
@@user-iv2ut4vw1l 생라이브 맞아용!!
@@user-iv2ut4vw1l 어디 mr 제거 보신건가요?전 라이브로 알고있어서 잘은 모르겠네요ㅠㅠ
@@user-iv2ut4vw1l mr제거는 만드는 사람에 따라 결과가 다 다름
이때 에스파 쌩라이브 맞았구요. 그래서 팬들이 엄청 뿌듯해 했던거 기억납니다.그리고 지금 반박댓 다신분들중에 두분 스엠안티임ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ나랑 전에싸운적 있잖아 ㅋㅅ 님
Let me just praise the choreography again:
This is why SM's choreographies are my favorite, the leg drop part fits so well to how the beat drops and that is so creative and iconic, I just can't-
And the girls slayed this so well too, especially our main dancer, people who have called Karina stiff before must feel like clowns now, she shines so much in this choreo! ♡
SM's leg drop choreo always get ppl excited😭😭 rlly happy to see that again after snsd the boys now with aespa🥰
It really do fits and it looks good with or without camera work which is good for a 4 member group.
@@heylala1336 yes same here, The Boys was the first K-Pop song I've ever listened to so seeing the leg drop in BM feels so nostalgic 🥺💕
@@mikaela4804 yess, agreed!^^
I don't know why but Karina has that looks that makes you only look at her. She's so gorgeous!!! Plus her smile kills me!
i agree
Feel the same
Right?!!
Agree!
true! prolly one of the reasons why shes the center. her charisma is umatched 💕
카리나 이 옷 너무 이쁘다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 긴 머리도 너무 잘 어울린다 ㅜㅜㅜㅜ 진짜 이 무대 너무 좋다 ㅠㅠㅜㅜㅜㅜ
why is nobody talking about giselle? she killed that chorus 😭
Yeah she is.
She is more perfect at rap. I bet no one is like her.
Fr she’s amazing.
1:08 무대보다가 에어컨 켜지는 소린줄 알고 놀랬엌ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ개웃곀ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㄱㅋㄲㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㅋ
시밬ㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
From this video it became quite apparent why Karina is the main dancer. She has great technique and her dancing is much cleaner than the rest. Also, great lower body control and angles.
why on earth are you already comparing the members.😂 if someone is the main dancer, we already know she is a little more skilled in dance, why are we pointing out the already obvious? there's no need.
@@rhens8088 because there are people questioning why Karina is the main dancer.
울 짱스파 여기 댓글 안 봤으면 좋겠다... 노래도 너무 좋고 중독성 있고 라이브도 세상 잘하고 춤도 잘추고 얼굴도 다들 너무 예쁜데😭💖 알지도 못하는 사람들이 안 좋은 말들을 많이 남기지만 울 에둥이들 성공해서 꼭 보여주자 사롱해🤍🤍🤍
this fancam made me realize why karina is their center... THEY'RE ALL SO CONFIDENT AND CHARISMATIC OH GOSH
yeah soo charismatic
Yes
@s n a k e Karina is the official center. Deal with it .^_^
@s n a k e stay pressed ✨
@s n a k e nah, it's you being so immature, if you don't like her then stay away ✨ i guess you're an adult too, act like one 😊 again, stay pressed ✨
Guys Karina is unreal. How can some people hate her she is literally talented
yeh toxic people
they’re jealous
She's a total packagee
Because she is really talented every one jealous
thats why they hate her ...because she's literally perfect....like how yeji of itzy is getting all the hate
THEY DANCING ON HEELS??? WITH THAT CHOREO??? QUEENS!! PERIODT!!!
yeah that's why it looks weak cause it's hiphop, and I don't really get it why they used heels
They have 3cm heels at best I feel like you’ve never tried dancing in heels because it’s not hard at all, especially with such a short heel.
@@pennymikk its hard to me. Lol. :(
PERIOD LOVE OUR QUEENS ARE JUST SO TALENTED THEY ARE OUT OF THIS WORLD!
I'm who seeing was worried
그래도 노래 한번 들었는데도 자꾸 생각나던뎅....은근 중독....
맞아요.. 나도 모르게 흥얼거리는 내가 싫다..ㅠ
!#$%^&%$%!#!&*^%@ 아야야야야야야 !@#$# %^*!#@#$!%!^ 아야야야야야야
후배 에스파의 노래에 중독된 아이린선배?
@@kinako_kiko ㅇㄴㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ배주현 뭔데
@@ayayayaya1320 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I see no one talking about Giselle. To me out of all of them she has the best stage presence. She seems like the Yuna of Itzy to me. Like the others (Karina and Ning Ning) might look more fierce, but she definitely looks like the one who is whole heartedly enjoying the performance. I couldn't keep my eyes off her
her fancam is so satisfying to watch!
I love her so much, she’s like she show us how enjoy and proud she is
I agree! I'm Yuna biased and they both look like they're not performing for the camera but for themselves!
Now I know why SM’s so proud to present Karina as a main dancer, no wonder
And tall like baddas
@@hey....2483 ikr. Like her legs are kinda longer than my life
Yes
No wonder why Karina is the main dancer, i mean LOOK AT HER. Perfect for the center and her moves are so sharp. So pretty, charismatic and barbie like. Im inlove
Up
와... 카메라 각도가 굴욕각도인데도 불구하고 전혀 굴욕적이지 않은 네명 ㅎㄷㄷ
윈터가 비주얼이길래 보컬 좀 딸릴 줄 알았는데 음색도 좋고 리보 역량 제대로 내서 젤 보기 좋음
ㅇㅈ 얼굴도 제일 스엠 태연계열에 보컬도 좋고 긴장해서 끼를 못 부리는 거 같은데 제일 나음 김민정이 에스파를 지배한다 갓 윈터
윈터너무좋음...
The way Karina with her dance is just so pleasing to watch. Perfect execution!!!! POWER Aespa.
노래,안무랑 의상이 안맞다는 생각은 나만 드는건가...차라리 가죽바지나 좀 섹시한 의상이 더 잘 어울렸을것 같은데...의상은 핑크큐티뽕짝인데 노래랑 안무가 큐티는 아닌것 같아서...개인적인 생각입니다...
마자요 의상은 좀 귀엽고 우아한 느낌인데 노래는 쎈 느낌
의상 청순 우아 몽환 이런 느낌인데 노래는 군복이나 검정색이 잘어울린다고 생각해ㅛ
맞아요.. 저도 공감
약간 미지의 신비함(?)을 추구하는거 같은데
너무 모르겠음...
얘네 레드벨벳 대체품이자나.....
@@xxx-qg8pz 카리나 인성 모르냐... 대체품 쟤 일상용어잖아 ㅋㅋ 지 친구한테 카이 지민 랩몬 엔시티등등 못생겼다고 하고 친구 반응 별로닌까 너말고 내말 들어줄 대체품은 많아 ㅇㅈㄹ 했자나 ㅋ
캬...부티난다
난 스엠이게 좋아
뭔가 스엠만 할수있을것같은 이런거
부팈ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ아 진짜 뭔지 한번에 알겠음
Ningning’s body control is on other level, she’s literally dancing on the level of the pro dancers
She's the longest one who trained in aespa so yeah SM locked her in the basement for so long to master dancing
@Gourab Mukherjee him?
@Gourab Mukherjee who do you talking about? Him who?
@@marie.857 actually sometimes no matter how long someone trained, they still can be stuff and awkward while dancing, I’m sure the way she dances is the result of the natural sense of the rhythm+ trainings
Streaming aespa on kbs world supaya dapet first win
SM ent to their artists: Whatever your position is, your vocals should be great and stable.
Sooo trueee😂😂😂
wendy and taeyeon smiling at this comment at the corner
@@anandagemilang22 lol
Pretty sure vocals in here a pre recorded
@@eecolme but pre recorded are the actual vocals with no effect, they are only recorded before the performance, many artists on their debut use
They all are good and so talented. This is only their debut stage, but they have shown their potentials, and they are a rookie monster indeed. I know why SM chose Karina as the main dancer and FTOG, because she is enjoying their performance the most and she has that center's charm. So, you guys should stop questioning sm's decision. I'm gladthat music bank showed us equal screen times.
Yoona’s daughter!!!
truuuuu!!
Agree
누가 머래도 난 짱스파 좋아 사랑해 공주들아...ㅠㅠ
1:08 딴건 모르겠구 에어컨 끄는 소리는 왜 넣은거여
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
이게 젤 개에바
미쳤나 진짜 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
아 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ나만 그 생각한게 아니였네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ이거 음원이었음? ㅈㄴ웃었네
Even though Winter is my bias. I agreed that Karina should be the center and face of the group. Just look at her face, her dance, her expression. She’s born to be an idol and to those people who judge her because of her dancing skills, open your eyes and look how smooth she dance... and she fits to be the leader of this group!!
Yesss
@@eliminjeong_ah788 how come visual became a position when all of them looks beautiful? Also Karina and Giselle can sing too. The four are all total package. Winter is not the ace
Yes true that. SM n their promotional picks are always sparkling. For their female esp some might dislike at first but u can see most of their picks as Face or Center always attract many n they truly charismatic
@@eliminjeong_ah788 It’s kinda annoying when you keep calling Winter “the ace” because all members are so talented and are all aces
@s n a k e are you blind? When someone dances in the center one member dances behind the center so it looks like 3. They do have a center and its Karina.
No doubt Karina is the center and the face of the group! Her charisma is overflowing. Plus her powerful dance.
she's too overpowered
Shes too powerful
Karina is so pretty.She can easily be an Actress,a Beauty Queen.
I am not biased but Giselle is also fire whereas NingNing is charismatic and Winter is showing Confident smile.
And what about winter she is so BEAUTIFUL
나쁘진 않은데 핑크색 두명만 보인다 그 중에서 카리나가 제일 튀는 느낌이고 데뷔 전부터 몰랐으면 에셈 그룹인지 몰랐을듯..
나만 그렇게 생각한게 아니었군
윈터는 스타일링 다르게 해서 보이는거지 완전 포스없음. 무대에서 카리나빼고 눈에 띄는 멤버 아무도 없음. 특히 윈터랑 지젤은 춤에 힘이 하나도 없네.. 네명으로 나온거치곤 카리스마가 너무 부족하다.. 카리나 혼자 1인분 이상하네
그렇긴 함.. 카리나 빼고 너무 인스타스럽기도 하고
개성이 안 보임 일반적인 걸그룹 느낌
아 외국 댓 이거 왜케 웃기냐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
류진: 네 어깨를 조져라
쇼타로: 네 목을 조져라
에스파: 네 무릎을 조져라
근데 진짜 맞는말ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
쇼타로 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
앜ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
winter, ningning, karina and giselle's body control is in another level
이 스타일링 너무너무너무 이쁘다 인스타에서 우연히 보고 풀영상 찾으러옴ㅜㅜ
BRUH did anyone see Karina fix her hair right at the end for the ending pose? That was so professional
yessss she did that
OMG!! SO COOL!
smooth af
right OMGG SO QUICK
THISSS
Karina really deserved the center position. She's so good
true
Agreee
My opinion, i think winter suits center position more ..
In my opinion I think other members stand out more and have more charisma than Karina
yesss, karina is the best
All are good in dancing but Karina dances so gracefully among them. The Visual of this group is DAEBAK. Love and support for these girls!
winter is the definition of being stunningly, beautiful, and talented
ningning expressions are on point, she radiates confidence omgggg
I feel like crying seeing all the love Karina is getting in the comments. It's so refreshing after everything. OT4 FIGHTING!!!
Karina's perfect right?
It's about time they acknowledged Karina's talents.
They didn’t wanna admit it because she is the real threat to everyone this girl has EVERYTHING BEST BODY TALL TALENTED AND IMMENSE BEAUTY
She is perfect! And she literally standout on this performance
Karina remains an ace and they can keep being mad about it
Karina really cathing my eyes...She so charisma and gorgeous
Same! Can’t keep my eyes off her!
스엠은 좋겠다 진짜수십명의 연습생중에 골라서 다이아몬드원석만 골라서 이리저리 다듬을수 있으니까 고르는것도 능력이고
YALL can hate KARINA just because she’s eye catching and attractive! But you guys can’t Lie about her talent!
Karina is the best leader, radiating from her aura and face, she is a good leader, she must take care of the members well. Uri main dancer 🥰
yess
Ning Yizhuo, you made us so proud. It's so rare to have Chinese main vocalist, and you really slay it.
Renjun?chenle?
Xiaojun 😊
In girl group, there's not much Chinese main vocalist
Karinaaa is so gorgeous 🤗
Nigning is everything. Her vocal and dance are so powerful
Not to mention her beauty stands out the most for me
Yessss NINGNING FIGHTING!!!
these outfits are just wow they look sooo prettyyyy
No offense but Karina looks literally perfect everything about her is just!!! Her presence too!!! I CANT
Im ready to throw hand when I read your first sentence.
really... winter's my bias but I can't take my eyes off her. her charisma is overflowing plus those long legs
agreeee
Im offended because im ugly and untalented.
Ikr i think she's my bias in aespa. So pretty and magnetic
Karina fixing her hair so fast-
2:48
SM rlly didnt disappoint with this group, vocals visuals and dance skills are insanneeee
I can see that SM does not go for “easy, cutesy, tik-tok” choreo that everyone can follow for aespa debut song because they want the highlight the members’ dance skills.
this stage feels like not a debut stage, aespa is a rookie monster indeed.
Not rllY only rookie
Ikr it doesn't even feel like it's a debut performance like the talent and *confidence* is out of the roof
Because it's SM ENTERTAINMENT duuh.
IKRRR their confidence it's immaculate
@@mitzypooh4643 get out
Karina can be a beauty queen. With that height, looks and body.
Semi perfect
She is actually isn't tall.. She is average height
167 cm is above average in K-pop, not super tall.. but Karina's proportions made that work, like how Seulgi looks tall but is actually only 161 cm.
@@karussoul 167 was when she was 15, she's definitely taller now
@@Error-qt4lu she is 5'6 tho... Isn't that tall for a female?
Don't get me wrong, im not trashing any kpop company, but wow this is the very definition of quality and SM knows how to deliver
Because SM founder of kpop
SM always did the best! Quality on another level!
Karina is an amazing centre. Her moves are effortless.
PREACH
And her dancing is just stunning to watch
i agree
Yeeeessss
AGREE
Karina was born to be a STAR! Look at her stage presence, her dancing skills & her visual!
한줄평 : 스엠이 세상과 동상이몽을 시작한거 같다.
ㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
사실 새삼 하루이틀은 아님...
Ngl But Karina Literally Looks like an Real Avatar !! She doesn't even need one
True
She is just like a drawing so unreal just like Taeyong
WINTER had me bewitched. Cause she's you know, Elsa's cousin? Magical af.
의상 좀 예쁘게 입혀 주지... 곡 분위기 보니까 제복 같은 거 입었어도 잘 어울릴 것 같은데
직캠 백만, 몇백만씩 나오는 그룹이 어디 있나. 서너그룹 뿐이지. 그것도 신인인데..
이미 글로벌한 그룹의 길로 들어섰음
I don't even understand why people hate them. Like seriously though, they are stunning!
I think its more of a dissatisfaction than hate. But yeah I actually love the song and everything else)))
This is how it almost always is when a new group debuts
Haters gonna hate
@@cklambo Players gon’ play
They will stan them later! Its always the same situation with SM groups
i still refuse to believe that they are humans. Karina's visual and charisma is on another level srsly
Ikr, she didn't look like human, look like a character😍😍
it's called make-up and graphics. I think ningning would be gorgeous even without make-up tho
@@jen5138 you clearly haven't seen Jimin's predebut pics
Tbh, those high heels are so hard to balance on especially for this kind of choreo
what did you expect? they are SNSD's daughters 😂
Theyre 3cm heels....... you can barely feel them lmao
@@pennymikk for someone like me who feels uncomfortable wearing high heels, i find it hard to dance with that
@@pennymikk i never wear heels, so idk lol but if wear them i’d probably fall lol
As someone who always use heels. Yes I can dance with heels. When someone always use it and comfortable with it, you can even run with heels
Most visual group
무대가 너무 답답해보이는 이유를 알았어. 멤버들 동선이 너무 중심에만 있어서 그런 것 같다.... 멤버들이 적으면 적은대로 무대를 잘 활용해야 하는데 거기서 거기로 머무르니까 답답해보이는 듯. 그래서 에스파는 나야, 윈터가 센터에서 조금씩 옮겨갈 때 그 부분이 아주 조금 해소가 되는데 그 부분 뺴면 계속 중앙에서만 안무를 하네.
아 어쩐지 이거였구만
백댄서를 줄이거나 없애고 동선 크게해도 될듯 ㅠ
ㄹㅇ,,, 거기에 백댄서까지 추가돼서 너무 산만함 진짜
Wow........ 파악을 잘하시네요.... 어쩐지
뭔가 시원시원한것 같지가 않고 답답해보인다더니........
댄서하고 구분되라고그런거같긴한데 그렇다고 댄서하고 구분이 잘되지도않음
다만세 라차타 행복 보고 나면 절대 이건 데뷔곡이 될 수 없어 이건 아니야 내 슴여돌데뷔곡 돌려놔 제발 ....
에스파가 소녀시대만큼 간지나진않지만 그래도 볼만함
ㅇㅈ 쎈척하는 중소돌느낌 지울수없음.....슴여돌데뷔곡은 한끝발이 있었음....
니보다 이쁜 애들 인데
@@user-rx7lf8nx7f 뭐래 ㅋ 나보다 이쁘겠지 ㅋㅋ 누가 뭐라고 하던 효서야 ???
라차타랑 행복이 그렇게 띵곡은 아니었는데..? 다만세는 지금도 회자되지만
Those outfits are gorgeous
Super pretty karina.super blessed of body proportions too..
Winter is like the combination of Taeyeon and Jessica’s visuals
Indeed, and Ningning is a combination of Chunga and Jennie especially on Black Mamba's MV
Idk why but when she smiles she looks a little like yuqi??
I think she look likes Taeyeon and Jungwoo NCT combined
YESSS, AGREE
@@dindadewi6679 this!!!!
their dancing is no joke, their voices are unique and have distinctive features, SM is so far superior for now.
Hi, can you watch my full dance cover AESPA “Black Mamba”?! Thanks!
totally agree with you
Aespa has NO weak link like they all have great stage presence SM trains their artists the best in my opinion
I remember seeing this for first time thinking this is the most visual group in general,karina look like the dream girl of every person and she should be wonderwoman bcs she has everything
omg so trueee
Karina dance really powerful and her charisma another level
에~스파는나양 이부분 전나 에스엠같음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ영진슨배릠 또 여기다 클론 심어놓고가셧네.....
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅆㅇㅈㅠㅠㅠㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그부분 중독성 오짐ㄹㅇ ㅋ
처음에 드를때 좀 스엠이랑 다르다고 느껴는데... 닝닝 랑 윈터 파트 는 스엠뿐인 아니고 걍 유영진이였어 😂
ㄹㅇ 여기 중독됌ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
거꾸로재생해서 들어도 유영진곡일듯
WHY IS NO ONE TALKING ABOUT GISELLE?? IM SO PROUD OF YOUU AERI ❣️
RIGHTTT I LOVE HER SM 💕✨
@@rey-mn2qi I LOVE HER BODY PROPORTIONS. SHE’S NOT THIN, SHE HAS A LITTLE BIT OF FATS AND I HOPE SM WONT FORCE HER TO LOSE WEIGHT
@@chickenlittle4052 YES THEY BETTER NOT, SHES SUCH A CRACKHEAD TOO LMAO THATS ONE OF THE REASONS SHE MY BIAS 😭😂
She's mine hahahhahaha
BRUHH NO GISELLE IS MY BIAS I LOVE HER THIIS MUCH
Karina's body proportion and Visuals wow stunning