Amanat Ali Khan & Fateh Ali Khan : Miyan Ki Todi (Part 9a) - Audio Archives of Lutfullah Khan
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.พ. 2025
- Ustad Amanat Ali Khan & Ustad Fateh Ali Khan sings Raag "Miyan Ki Todi"
Sarangi : Nathoo Khan
Tabla : Talib Hussain
From Audio Archives of Lutfullah Khan
This is most likely Gujri Todi. This bandish is very famous that Ustad Fateh Ali Khan Sahib has sung elsewhere as Gujri Todi as well. I once asked Ustad ji that, ke tez taano mein Gujri aur Mian ki todi kaa faraq kaayam rakhnaa kayi baraa muskhil ho jaataa hae. To unhon ne usi waqt harmonium talab kiyaa aur phir aisaa gayaa ke, wah. Yeh wakya Lahore mein unke ghar kaa hae..1983 ke kareeb.
Please note the beautiful sarangi vaadan of Ustad Nathoo Khan, probably the most imaginative player after Bundoo Khan sahib, with the possible exception of Mian Ghulam Mohammad.
Isme Choti bandish k bol mil skte hai kya pls?
This is not raag Miyan ki malhar . It is Miyan ki Tori or Gujri Tori.
In your recent upload Ustad Salamat Ali khan sahib sang same durt bandish in raag Gujri Tori . But here the pancham swar can be heard as well which is varjya in Gujri Tori. So most probably it is Miyan ki Tori.
Can you please also explain why the same bandish is sang in two different raags ,if that is the case(this is not Gujri Tori)?
Thank you Sir for the valuable feedback. I am grateful
Sir I am just an ordinary student and you don't need to thank me.
We all should be thankful to you for the great work you are doing and providing us with these recording .
here are many bundashes which are sung by more than one raag. for example Piya ghar aye is sang in three raags .. Jaijwanti, Marwa , Malhar
@@سبرنگ-و5د
There may be such bandishes but the raags you mentioned are completely different from each other.In this case it doesn't matter that the lyrics are same or not, the style and notes will be completely different each time as these raags(which you mentioned above) are completely different.
But in case of this recording , these two raags are very similar . And major differences should be created to keep these raags separately identifiable.
بڑی مہربانی سرکار🙏🌹