@@poptopics1772 Why bring up if it was pre-recorded or not? The comment was about Momo's voice, and in both cases you can notice a clear improvement in her voice from their earlier songs
Never expected tzuyu to sound this clean and stable. But then again, she is an Idol, guess she's just doing what she is suppose to be doing. Damn I'm glad I stan this group so hard.
@@kanmanivn1475 true. To be honest only mina, dahyun and momo's voices used to strain a lot in some of their lives, but even them improved so much in the last years
3mix are so stable! and tzuyu and momo have improved so much (I already liked their voices and tzuyu has always been pretty stable but they're even better now)
Tzuyu is really stable considering the fact she was singing the last chorus which is have a little bit more energetic Choreo ( I mean she's an idol this is her job but that's for people always doubting her )
Their phonetics has one liquid phoneme /r/, realized usually as an apico-alveolar tap [ɾ] and sometimes as an alveolar lateral approximant [l] and this explains why not only momo even Sana or Mina and the others use the /r/ sound instead of /l/. It's just how their language is made.
this is prerecorded tho, not live. pre recorded means that they includes loads of small mistakes in the recording so everyone thinks it is live. And looking at this comment section, I guess its working.
Exactly! Some people really not believing them for singing live. Even if they sing in KBS coolfm live or music shows people will still say they're not singing live🤷🏻♀️
@@yv6ne You are right, but so many stans are delusional and want to believe that their faves sing flawlessly with no pitch issues or shakiness and it is just not realistic.
@@BuyJiafeiyassifiedpr0ducts true.. this means they sing live flawlessly than mamamoo and bts. twice definitely can sing live.. but this one is really not live
you guys saying this is pre-recorded are so weird, sana's vocals were clearly affected by her dancing in the chorus, and chaeyoung was late in sitting down on her "i guarantee i got you" and it made her say the line slightly later/in a slightly more stretched way than usual too
This is my fave live performance of Twice. It's so clear, made their sound amazing and sexy. I think even without MRremoved we can clearly hear their live vocals. Bcz the backtrack's volume is so low.
ignoring some of the comments, twice have proved they can sing live on different occasions. so i don't know why people keep debating if they can or can't.
Becase fans think this is their pure live vocals, and then they have high expectations, so when twice really does sing live, they slam them because their expectations are too high
Same same. I was thinking it was prerecorded but whatever, I enjoy it. And I do know they have beautiful voice, it's just hard to sing live while dancing. What matters is I love their song and their voice.
It _is_ live and you can clearly hear it in the original video. Sorry to say this, but that you question if it's really a live or pre recorded every time they sing so good, shows how little faith you have in them... I mean if you're a ONCE you'll easily know they could do this and much _more_ by seeing their live concerts
Sounds live to me, there are just enough minor "imperfections" that make it even more perfect. (Plus hearing the pauses for breaths.) Source for this opinion: was in choir for 5 years + musical theater.
Haters cant tell the difference between their voices here from the original track..haha The pronunciation is also different sometimes, obviously not prerecorded
@@d_game14 yeah I hate to break it to you, but this is pre-recorded live vocals and you can clearly hear it(at least if you’re not tone deaf). those vocals means that they either recorded vocals during rehearsal while standing and then lipsync to it during the actual performance, or just prerecorded it in studio with no editing to it, just a tuning effect. it’s just a production choice, we know damn well their vocals slay, but don’t be delusional!
@@clique7417 ?? Why would they be out of breathe while standing still? Clearly they were moving while singing- you can hear intakes of breath and breathlessness
@@clique7417 Completely agree, if you compare it with the billboard presentation you can see the difference when they actually sing live, I don't get why people feel this is hate towards the girls and it has nothing to do with that, it's just stating the obvious I love them and I loved this presentation, they look more confident
when other groupa sings so good: *Wow* *they* *absolutely* *can* *sing!* *TALENT* when TWICE sings so good: *I* *love* *them* *but* *there* *is* *no* *way* *this* *is* *live* The suspicion at it's most when it come to these girls lol Anyway the queens slayed with their vocals 🔥👏
…people are saying it because it literally isn’t live. Twice are talented singers, it’s not like we’re saying they chose to lip-sync (i’m sure most of them would prefer to sing live lmao) but you can tell from a mile away this is prerecorded
@@victjsofjsmdngor because it's so clear and just like the original video? Yeah ever thought that it's because the original video _IS_ 100% live..? (Just like their qoh live performance) This choreo' is very simple compared to their other one's so basically it's like standing still and singing with no strains what's surprising about a singer that can sing and -obviously- after hundreds of practice of the stage and extra effort since it's performed on a US show Also like i said, I promise if it was of another group no one would question it
@@jennielaish they literally prerecord a new set of vocals so it doesn’t sound like the studio version. And no, twice is not the only group, it’s the whole industry. Check their mcountdown performances for all their comebacks in the past, they “live” because the vocals aren’t the same as the studio version but then those “live” vocals sound the EXACT same for every single performance. There is no difference here. You guys have to understand that kpop is more of a business than a music genre by now. The companies want their idols to sound perfect without any mess ups. And while twice could easily perform their songs as long as they have a working mic (poor jihyo at billboards) they aren’t given the opportunity
They’re on the Kelly Clarkson show. Kelly is not just a host but a singer who often sings live on the show. They’re all singing live. If y’all notice Jihyo didn’t do her adlib after the bridge and it’s not on the backtrack either. It’s just them and the instrumental
@@thisisayemnew Lyma usually puts in the description if its live vocals in big caps. Also, Lyma has been hearting comments that say this is pre-recorded, which seems very strange to do if this wasn't pre recorded. there is a literally a comment saying this is live AR and a heart from Lyma. Besides, you can hear its pre recorded. No hate to twice, because they can sing well live, I'm just annoyed fans get tricked so easily
There’s a difference between pre-recording vocals and enhancing live vocals. The vocals are live, the audio team just fine tuned the vocals (like what they do with other performers.) It’s incredibly disappointing to see comments discrediting their talent with, “they aren’t usually this stable.” when the girls have proven otherwise (example: performances from their 4th World Tour in Seoul)
Theres a difference between hating and pointing out it isn't live though. a lot of onces in this comment section are getting very mad ppl are pointing out it isn't live.
that doesn't mean its live? pre-recording is literally when they record the song with selected mistakes so fans think its live. Loads of kpop groups do this
Can't believe people still be saying "this sounds too good, must be pre recorded" or "no way it's live, it's too stable" inmediatly after seeing these type of performances where they do amazing. This is their job and they will keep getting better at it, so it's natural they sound great compared to other previous ones referenced EVERY TIME by haters. Keep on hating and doubting.
Right? Like after 7 years I hope they don't sound bad haha but then again mess ups exist and also bad days but still I expect a level that they delivered here! Amazing as always
This was the first time during this promo I was like "oh they're for sure all using live vocals" Im a big doubter but I don't mind lipsyncing at all. I love sana, but if you hear her lines and think that's prerecorded damn.
yes, they are getting better and are really good but this performance is obviously pre-recorded. there's nothing wrong with twice lipsyncing here and there, its practically industry standard at this point lmfao
nayeon and jihyo slaying high notes, tzuyu and dahyun very cute voice, jeongyeon very powerful voice, chaeyoung low voice slaying the rap part, mina sana and momo having stable vocals. Twice vocals is no joke everyone!!!
I don't know about you guys, but I really think this should be a live performance because if you heard their previous concert it was really easy for Twice, so don't think as if Twice can't sing, their early debut was very stable in singing
@@victjsofjsmdngor I watched the original video from the Kelly Clarkson Show and it sounds more live than this MR removed video imo. if you go watch it, you can actually hear the vocals :)
saying easy is an overstatement, at the end of the song, some of the members are struggling. this is also why Nayeon and Jihyo gets most lines,. they're the most stable
@@otoh6387 I agree that they are most stable and I would also like to add Jeongyeon to that list as well because she also is very stable with her voice. I also agree that it is not easy for Twice to sing and dance at the same time in concerts. They were able to do it well, and they are for sure capable, but it's expected that at a certain point their vocal cords will become tired and it will be more of a struggle to control their voices.
you can hear that they are singing live completely even without removing anything. Jeongyeon especially sounded amazing to me. I just wish jihyo sang the adlibs at the end w nayeon
nah its not live. It's pre-recorded, thats why it sounds different to the studio version. Also the creator of this video has only liked comments that say its pre-recorded and they also add live in the title if the performance is actually live.
@@thatsclownshit3145 yes it can mean horse house but in this context it means persons voice not cracking, singing their lines without any breaks or having to stop for air, and no deep breaths in between words or phrases.
It’s very obvious they’re pre recorded on location or prior. It’s very common for tv shows that dont want to use the official backtrack so it seems live. Twice almost always use a backtrack except music bank encores.
It's really hard to be a Twice member. When you miss a note, the antis will hurriedly make a clip and mocking you non-stop, and keep dragging it for the longest time they want. But when you sing live and good with no problem, all those antis have sudden disabilities, suddenly being deaf and blind, or accuse you for lipsync or pre-recorded. Only their fave is the one who is able to do live while other groups, esp Twice, isnt allowed to do live stage. Wbk... 🥱🥱🥱
Kpop fans have been way to harsh on twice, they're probably jealous that their favs don't have twice's fame. but this is pre-recorded, so if someone say it isn't live then that isn't hating.
i think these are live vocals but pitch corrected/enhanced to make it sound smoother. other groups also do this so it’s pretty normal. they did so good here 🥰👏🏻
When it comes to TWICE everybody starts to act like they are professional singers and its always the haters acting that way Even if it is not live TWICE have already proven themselves they can sing in their concerts while dancing hard choreography..so just enjoy the vocals instead of complaining
As expected, 3mix ate. They all did pretty well, Sana a little out of breath but other than that, this performance is great. Also, Tzuyu sounds different here.
![[CLEAN MR REMOVED] TWICE (트와이스) - Strategy | The Seasons - Lee Young Ji's Rainbow KBS 241206 MR제거](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-jlqXylyfYI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR REMOVED] TWICE (트와이스) - Strategy | The Seasons - Lee Young Ji's Rainbow KBS 241206 MR제거](/img/tr.png)
I really love their live performance today, it’s so raw that you can already hear their vocal and know it’s live
So their vocal is live too?
@@JJstillwithyou yup
some members voices are prerecorded. Nayeon, Jihyo and Jeongyeon are completely live...
@@theMirandasnone of them are pre recorded
@@theMirandas i think its just the main dancers that are pre recorded, maybe Chaeyoung
Momo's voice really improved alot. Can you hear how stable her voice now is compare before? Im so proud of her!
Her parts were pre-recorded i think.
@@poptopics1772 really? why would they do that
@@poptopics1772
either all members are pre-recorded or none and they are all live. They never do some with live and some with pre-recorded.
@@poptopics1772 Why bring up if it was pre-recorded or not? The comment was about Momo's voice, and in both cases you can notice a clear improvement in her voice from their earlier songs
@@samshort5571 it is all prerecorded
Never expected tzuyu to sound this clean and stable. But then again, she is an Idol, guess she's just doing what she is suppose to be doing. Damn I'm glad I stan this group so hard.
She has improved a ton
She was always one of the most stable vocal in twice when it comes to live
while watching them live
Tzuyu live singing is always the most stable and not stage fright
continuous progress
Really good👍👏
@@kanmanivn1475 true. To be honest only mina, dahyun and momo's voices used to strain a lot in some of their lives, but even them improved so much in the last years
She always has really good and stable live vocals!
3mix are so stable! and tzuyu and momo have improved so much (I already liked their voices and tzuyu has always been pretty stable but they're even better now)
tzuyu so stable vocle ...soft tender and powerful
Tzuyu is really stable considering the fact she was singing the last chorus which is have a little bit more energetic Choreo ( I mean she's an idol this is her job but that's for people always doubting her )
Ahhhh Mina's sweet and soft voiceee what a pleasure in the ears
Chaeyoung slayed the rap and vocals 🔥
My bias!!
My ult ❤️
TZUYU'S VOICE HITS DIFFERENT.. 🥰💕
So goooood 😍😍
I literally levitated to the air when I heard her💓❤️🔥❤️🔥
Mina, Momo Tzuyu so stable😍🥰
Mina so stable, OMG 😭😍❤
Momo in chorus "Moonlight sunrise, Baby, let's do it OR NIGHT" 🤣 so cute her mistake is a sign that this is live vocals 🔥
it's not, she sings 'or' cuz for her it not that easy to sing 'all' because of korean (and japanese, since she's from there) phonetics.
Their phonetics has one liquid phoneme /r/, realized usually as an apico-alveolar tap [ɾ] and sometimes as an alveolar lateral approximant [l] and this explains why not only momo even Sana or Mina and the others use the /r/ sound instead of /l/. It's just how their language is made.
take a trip on the moonright
@@justinepaulotapil1512 Mina clearly said "All" not "Or"
this is prerecorded tho, not live. pre recorded means that they includes loads of small mistakes in the recording so everyone thinks it is live. And looking at this comment section, I guess its working.
Their live vocals are so damn good twice never disappoints🥰🥰
Exactly! Some people really not believing them for singing live.
Even if they sing in KBS coolfm live or music shows people will still say they're not singing live🤷🏻♀️
it's not live unfortunately :( but everyone knows that they are able to sing live and they sing very well!
@@yv6ne You are right, but so many stans are delusional and want to believe that their faves sing flawlessly with no pitch issues or shakiness and it is just not realistic.
@@BuyJiafeiyassifiedpr0ducts true.. this means they sing live flawlessly than mamamoo and bts. twice definitely can sing live.. but this one is really not live
@@theMirandas Exactly, a person with sense.
Proud of the girls for singing so well! Love Tzuyu, Mina, and Jihyo’s stable live vocals!
It's not live, go watch their billboard performance if you actually want to hear them live.
@@thatrandomperson5828that's not live either
외국쇼면 당연히 생라이브... 울 애들 미쳤다... 진짜 너무 잘해
you guys saying this is pre-recorded are so weird, sana's vocals were clearly affected by her dancing in the chorus, and chaeyoung was late in sitting down on her "i guarantee i got you" and it made her say the line slightly later/in a slightly more stretched way than usual too
They can pre-record vocals when she is dancing and tune it up.
@@sonofsarek its not pre-recorded, its live, but its ehanced
Tzuyu's voice is very stable and beautiful❤❤❤
jeongyeon, jihyo and nayeon's vocal are so stableee
yeah, thats cause its pre recorded lmao
I love Dahyun’s angelic voice so much
hope she had more lines😔
Momo's voice is so beautiful that i couldn't stop replaying it. ❤️❤️❤️❤️😍
It's addicting!! What a KWEEN!!
Mina sounds great
This is my fave live performance of Twice. It's so clear, made their sound amazing and sexy. I think even without MRremoved we can clearly hear their live vocals. Bcz the backtrack's volume is so low.
Its pre-recorded, if you want to listen to an actual live performance, watch their billboard performance.
Tzuyu is so stable tbh
ignoring some of the comments, twice have proved they can sing live on different occasions. so i don't know why people keep debating if they can or can't.
Some people don't want to accept it!
No frrrr
fr like they be saying they can't sing like they are not a contestants to a survival show during their debut???
Becase fans think this is their pure live vocals, and then they have high expectations, so when twice really does sing live, they slam them because their expectations are too high
Nayeons and Jihyo’s vocals are so beautiful and pleasing to hear. It’s like melting chocolate. Their tones is so smooth
Momo improved a lot she sounds great
you know what Im just gonna enjoy their angelic voices instead of trying to figure out if its live or not
Yeah. We all are enjoying
But this vid is really need for show how good Twice's vocal is
Same same. I was thinking it was prerecorded but whatever, I enjoy it. And I do know they have beautiful voice, it's just hard to sing live while dancing. What matters is I love their song and their voice.
It _is_ live and you can clearly hear it in the original video.
Sorry to say this, but that you question if it's really a live or pre recorded every time they sing so good, shows how little faith you have in them...
I mean if you're a ONCE you'll easily know they could do this and much _more_ by seeing their live concerts
@@id3389 more people need to hear this haha, you can still enjoy their performances regardless
Sounds live to me, there are just enough minor "imperfections" that make it even more perfect. (Plus hearing the pauses for breaths.)
Source for this opinion: was in choir for 5 years + musical theater.
why does people can’t accept the fact that twice can sing live for real, it’s obviously not pre-recorded, don’t be delusional 😑
Haters cant tell the difference between their voices here from the original track..haha The pronunciation is also different sometimes, obviously not prerecorded
@@d_game14 yeah I hate to break it to you, but this is pre-recorded live vocals and you can clearly hear it(at least if you’re not tone deaf). those vocals means that they either recorded vocals during rehearsal while standing and then lipsync to it during the actual performance, or just prerecorded it in studio with no editing to it, just a tuning effect.
it’s just a production choice, we know damn well their vocals slay, but don’t be delusional!
@@clique7417 yeah sure
@@clique7417 ?? Why would they be out of breathe while standing still? Clearly they were moving while singing- you can hear intakes of breath and breathlessness
@@clique7417 Completely agree, if you compare it with the billboard presentation you can see the difference when they actually sing live, I don't get why people feel this is hate towards the girls and it has nothing to do with that, it's just stating the obvious
I love them and I loved this presentation, they look more confident
when other groupa sings so good:
*Wow* *they* *absolutely* *can* *sing!* *TALENT*
when TWICE sings so good:
*I* *love* *them* *but* *there* *is* *no* *way* *this* *is* *live*
The suspicion at it's most when it come to these girls lol
Anyway the queens slayed with their vocals 🔥👏
Yess
…people are saying it because it literally isn’t live. Twice are talented singers, it’s not like we’re saying they chose to lip-sync (i’m sure most of them would prefer to sing live lmao) but you can tell from a mile away this is prerecorded
@@victjsofjsmdngor you can literally tell this is live without any backtrack but people are deaf
@@victjsofjsmdngor because it's so clear and just like the original video? Yeah ever thought that it's because the original video _IS_ 100% live..? (Just like their qoh live performance)
This choreo' is very simple compared to their other one's so basically it's like standing still and singing with no strains what's surprising about a singer that can sing and -obviously- after hundreds of practice of the stage and extra effort since it's performed on a US show
Also like i said, I promise if it was of another group no one would question it
@@jennielaish they literally prerecord a new set of vocals so it doesn’t sound like the studio version. And no, twice is not the only group, it’s the whole industry. Check their mcountdown performances for all their comebacks in the past, they “live” because the vocals aren’t the same as the studio version but then those “live” vocals sound the EXACT same for every single performance. There is no difference here.
You guys have to understand that kpop is more of a business than a music genre by now. The companies want their idols to sound perfect without any mess ups. And while twice could easily perform their songs as long as they have a working mic (poor jihyo at billboards) they aren’t given the opportunity
They’re on the Kelly Clarkson show. Kelly is not just a host but a singer who often sings live on the show. They’re all singing live. If y’all notice Jihyo didn’t do her adlib after the bridge and it’s not on the backtrack either. It’s just them and the instrumental
Its pre-recorded, thats why it sounds different from the studio version.
@@thatrandomperson5828you're in every comment, Lyma usually put an announcement if this were prerecorded, go check another videos
@@thisisayemnew Lyma usually puts in the description if its live vocals in big caps. Also, Lyma has been hearting comments that say this is pre-recorded, which seems very strange to do if this wasn't pre recorded. there is a literally a comment saying this is live AR and a heart from Lyma. Besides, you can hear its pre recorded. No hate to twice, because they can sing well live, I'm just annoyed fans get tricked so easily
There’s a difference between pre-recording vocals and enhancing live vocals. The vocals are live, the audio team just fine tuned the vocals (like what they do with other performers.)
It’s incredibly disappointing to see comments discrediting their talent with, “they aren’t usually this stable.” when the girls have proven otherwise (example: performances from their 4th World Tour in Seoul)
Onces don’t have a problem anyway. We see their concerts. They sing amazing live. It’s non stans and haters who are shocked and would never accept it
Theres a difference between hating and pointing out it isn't live though. a lot of onces in this comment section are getting very mad ppl are pointing out it isn't live.
you know its live when momo pronounce l and r interwinding the letter since in korea l and r are the same alphabet.And their breathy singing.
that doesn't mean its live? pre-recording is literally when they record the song with selected mistakes so fans think its live. Loads of kpop groups do this
Can't believe people still be saying "this sounds too good, must be pre recorded" or "no way it's live, it's too stable" inmediatly after seeing these type of performances where they do amazing.
This is their job and they will keep getting better at it, so it's natural they sound great compared to other previous ones referenced EVERY TIME by haters. Keep on hating and doubting.
Right? Like after 7 years I hope they don't sound bad haha but then again mess ups exist and also bad days but still I expect a level that they delivered here! Amazing as always
I love Twice, but these are pre-recorded vocals. They sound amazing (in the studio), but this isn't live.
This was the first time during this promo I was like "oh they're for sure all using live vocals" Im a big doubter but I don't mind lipsyncing at all. I love sana, but if you hear her lines and think that's prerecorded damn.
yes, they are getting better and are really good but this performance is obviously pre-recorded. there's nothing wrong with twice lipsyncing here and there, its practically industry standard at this point lmfao
there's no sign of fatigue in their voices while dancing. It's 100% pre-recorded which is okay, but pls stop lying to yourselves.
tzuyuuu
02:48 this vocal is so cute
Mina's vocals are so good
AHHHHH I'M INLOVE WITH CHAEYOUNG'S VOICE SO ANGELIC
ME TOO!!
nayeon and jihyo slaying high notes, tzuyu and dahyun very cute voice, jeongyeon very powerful voice, chaeyoung low voice slaying the rap part, mina sana and momo having stable vocals. Twice vocals is no joke everyone!!!
well this isn't live, but they're billboard performance was if you want to check it out!!
I don't know about you guys, but I really think this should be a live performance because if you heard their previous concert it was really easy for Twice, so don't think as if Twice can't sing, their early debut was very stable in singing
plus: the choreo for this song isn't too extreme so I thought it would be easier to do it while singing
Right, i wish they did it live because it’d still be amazing
@@victjsofjsmdngor I watched the original video from the Kelly Clarkson Show and it sounds more live than this MR removed video imo. if you go watch it, you can actually hear the vocals :)
saying easy is an overstatement, at the end of the song, some of the members are struggling. this is also why Nayeon and Jihyo gets most lines,. they're the most stable
@@otoh6387 I agree that they are most stable and I would also like to add Jeongyeon to that list as well because she also is very stable with her voice. I also agree that it is not easy for Twice to sing and dance at the same time in concerts. They were able to do it well, and they are for sure capable, but it's expected that at a certain point their vocal cords will become tired and it will be more of a struggle to control their voices.
언니들 진짜…못하는게 뭐야..?
라이브도 잘하고 춤도 잘 추고 미모 원탑이고…반했어❤
Tzuyu ❤
When I was watching the performance I was 100% sure it's live as you can listen their breath. They are literally queens
Hearing their breathe doesn't mean anything. Breathing is usually recorded in a pre-recorded performance.
97ers and 챙 slayed. 🔥
Mina was so stable and amazing, everyone was really stable here
yeah because they lipsynced to a pre-recording. Their billboard performance was live, so check that out if you wanna hear stable vocals!!
ももりんがこんなに上手くなってて嬉しい
みんな英語なのに生歌めっちゃうまい〜
Mina and tzuyu🍭💕
Momo has a unique voice..
Tzuyu & Mina got sweetest voice then the rest!😘😘😘
No matter much those haters hate on twice but twice have fans and people who love them beyond your cheap comments...
So proud of twice
Love you ❣️
you can hear that they are singing live completely even without removing anything. Jeongyeon especially sounded amazing to me. I just wish jihyo sang the adlibs at the end w nayeon
nah its not live. It's pre-recorded, thats why it sounds different to the studio version. Also the creator of this video has only liked comments that say its pre-recorded and they also add live in the title if the performance is actually live.
Jeongyeon queen of stability
Their voices are very stable, i can't🥲
THEYRE SO STABLE
Stable Queens 👸
stable? that's for horses 💀
@@thatsclownshit3145 yes it can mean horse house but in this context it means
persons voice not cracking, singing their lines without any breaks or having to stop for air, and no deep breaths in between words or phrases.
@@thatsclownshit3145 Respect their opinion sis
@@thatsclownshit3145 u thought that was funny
MOMO OMG ❤️
She improved allot. 👌💗
It’s very obvious they’re pre recorded on location or prior. It’s very common for tv shows that dont want to use the official backtrack so it seems live. Twice almost always use a backtrack except music bank encores.
Haters gonna depress after this slay
춤추면서 라이브 진짜 너무 잘한다~ 역시 트와이스 💗
WOW THEYVE ALL IMPROVED ITS INSANE
Stable queens
QUEENS
It's really hard to be a Twice member. When you miss a note, the antis will hurriedly make a clip and mocking you non-stop, and keep dragging it for the longest time they want. But when you sing live and good with no problem, all those antis have sudden disabilities, suddenly being deaf and blind, or accuse you for lipsync or pre-recorded. Only their fave is the one who is able to do live while other groups, esp Twice, isnt allowed to do live stage. Wbk... 🥱🥱🥱
Kpop fans have been way to harsh on twice, they're probably jealous that their favs don't have twice's fame. but this is pre-recorded, so if someone say it isn't live then that isn't hating.
지효 와
역시 메인 보컬
God Jihyo indeed and 3 Mixx here is showing off their vocal prowess in 3rd language basically that they have to sing.
jeongyeon so stable 😍 what happened to sana on her chorus tho 🥺
twice=talent
Im Nayeon is such a stable queen
Slay Queen twice❤❤❤
うますぎる😮
you can tell their voices getting breathier as the song progressed and they did very ell to smooth that out. their live vocals are amaizing
I mean you guys hear the audience screaming and singing along right!?? how is that not live?😭
i think these are live vocals but pitch corrected/enhanced to make it sound smoother. other groups also do this so it’s pretty normal. they did so good here 🥰👏🏻
When it comes to TWICE everybody starts to act like they are professional singers and its always the haters acting that way
Even if it is not live TWICE have already proven themselves they can sing in their concerts while dancing hard choreography..so just enjoy the vocals instead of complaining
Twice are Stable!!! Vocals, Dance, Visual, Fame, and Successful 3rd Gen QUEENS 👑
mina's and dahyun's voices are so smooth, sana's is so sultry and chaeyoung's is so cool i love twice sm
As expected, 3mix ate. They all did pretty well, Sana a little out of breath but other than that, this performance is great. Also, Tzuyu sounds different here.
They did all great omg!!!
they all really did good !!
You can really hear them breathing while singing I think is one on the best mr removal and we can really heard their voices singing live
Chae SLAYED
jeongyeon 💚 💚 💚 💚 💚
When twice are so stable haters think its pre-recorded 🤭🤣
It's not hating to recognise this is pre-recorded. Twice can sing live well and we got to see that for this song in the billboard performance
Aaaaaaa stableeee vocalsss
Nayeon aaaa i love you and so proud of to twice😖💐
JEONGYEON 🔥🔥🔥
jeongyeon 🔥❤❤❤
Vocals are really angelic
TZUYU WOW
THEY ARE SURELY THE 3RD GENERATION QUEENS
honey to my ears.
Omg MoMo`s Real Voice💖
ZYOZYOs voice really hits different. i could listen to her all day
finally a working microphone for god jihyo 🤩 also jeongyeon sounds so good at 1:45
How I wish the quality of the mics of the BILLBOARD WIM were like THIS-
twice deserves so much!!
みんなうますぎる！安定感すごい泣
この曲裏声使ったりフレーズ感難しいと思うのに素晴らしすぎる👏🏻👏🏻
Pretty good. They have improved a lot over the years.
El verdadero best gg.
Un grupo que tiene un buen talento
Reinas del kpop.
Y'all this is prerecorded and Lyma is undirectly confirming it as well. She literally put a heart only to a comment saying that this is prerecorded
LETS GOOO they sound incredible, so proud