The one thing i dislike about Jenette is that she's so naive. Athy is an intelligent girl. She knows what to do. And what is wrong or right. Even though she knew that Jenette could potentially hurt her future with her dad, yet she initiated their further relationship. While Jenette, as we all know about in the first life of athy, she didn't even do anything when athy was being discriminated or was executed. And lived a happy life with ijekiel. That's why I'll always prefer athy. ♡♡♡
It's just how her character was written.... Like athy is only intelligent because she is aware of the story line. Jeanette is basically the typical main character in a Web novel which is partly why she's so naive... I like both of them equally
I read somewhere that in lovely princess after athy was killed and claude died, she started doing black magic and she did a spell thing where athy was reincarnated back to when she was born and so claude could love her. Because that was what athy always wanted, but because of this everyone but athy lost their memories. One of the side affects of her black magic was that clause would never love her though, he would only ever think that athy was her daughter and he wouldn't ever think of jennette as someone he could love... so basically she gave athy and everyone another chance to re live their life and to correct themselves even though it meant she would loose everything she loved.
Athy is reincarnated and had had a lot of reincarnations in the past. Since she was a grown woman in this timeline, it would be normal for her to be smarter
I wish there is a way to bring back Athy's mother its heartbreaking to see Claude sad and happy when he look at Athy because she look so much like her mother T_T
I really love this father and daughter duo until he lost his memories. I know that he would regret the decision to kill his own lovely daughter when he regain memories
@@k14_0405 yeah, I mean, Unless I read it wrong, Clause never did anything with Penolpe (Jenette's mother) that could've resulted into a child so he probably think Jenette's his brother's child or something.
come to think of it, caulde is actually really pityful, he didnt have a happy childhood, and his lover died becoz of giving birth to athy, he lost soo many things throughout his life,thats why he became so cruel, cold and heartless in order to become stronger an killed his brother ( but his brother isnt dead) its just kinda sad, but im sure athy will melten his cold heart and the father and daugther relationship will strengthen, THIS IS JUST MY THOUGHTS AFTER WAITING THE NEW CHP TO UPLOAD XD
To add to that, during his youth he was engaged to Jennette's mother. Then what happened? He walks into a room and sees his betrothed sleeping with his evil brother, smirking. So eventually he moved on and found the life of his life, but then that person died.
I Hate Jeanette. Although I Am Not Supposed To Put The Blame On Her I Am Always On The Verge Of Crying Everytime I See CLAUDE And JEANETTE Together While Athy Just Watches In The Distance That Chapter Hurt Me The Most In The Whole Novel/Manhwa- Since Athy Took Years To Build An Affectionate Relationship With Claude And He Forgot It Easily To Save Athy And JEANETTE Just Came Trying To Steal Claude From Athy Although She Didn't Know It..
I feel extremely sorry for Jeanette. She never and a loving family, and you can see that she really loves and cares about Athanasia and Claude. And as she was conceived by dark magic, like the old man in the shop said, she will never be able to find true happiness. Although she has never done something wrong.
I hate this comment. She's just a little girl who wants to have a family much like athy... The only reason you guys like athy and hate Jeanette is because that we see things from athys perspective. If this was the original story however and Jeanette was the main character we'd all be rooting for her
blue blues no I dislike her because she get love trough BLACK MAGIC, beauty and being naive she didn't even have to try and everybody loves her. I hate all characters like that, is just like that in real life too, the difference is that in real life not everything is flowers and just with a serious mental problem to be so dump at the point of some characters, really is just not realistic at the point of empathy, to me she is or a poorly constructed character or a really twisted chimera with really mental problems, in the second case (what the writer already got clearly for me that is the truth) I could feel something but for now she is just annoying
@@LIAHAKEL it's not jennete's fault nor did she got all the love just by doing nothing, if you look closely Jennete was doomed for unhappiness in both timeliness. In the first she was only "cared" by claude since her manifested love eased him, while ezekiel only married her because of his father command whose main purpose was power. In the second one she literally has no one, like no one to care for her truly. Even when she drowned in the lake claude could not even know who "Jennete" was when athanasia told him to save her. He only calls for her since her presence eases his headache and pain, for him she's just a figure. Even ezekiel is now rude to her at points. I know this is my opinion but I personally like her character cuz even after all that she's still optimistic and hopes for the best, she tries her best not to get dishearted and finds happiness in the tinniest things.
@@nurkhairunnisaatirah3014 I've been reading the novel and I advice for you to not read it if you really want a good first reaction. Something will happen on the festival.
@@jaricasi3463 I read the novel but I dont notice it. I will wait for it. thank youu. but may I ask u? Claude wont kill athy and he starts treating athy well is it? then lucas bring ..... and claude remembers everything right?
@@Vocalist_-wp5we I... I don't know...? I can't even remember when and why I wrote/typed this XD I guess... it's the similar settings and the relationship between Claude and his daughter, Athanasia and the MC... I don't know XD
Maybe because previous Athy is like Len, wholely devoted to Claude, the tyrant like rin. The only difference is Len and Rin are separated siblings while they are father and daughter.
i think the only reason why athy come back to the life because for her mother's wish she want to her daughter to be alive the way she choose athanasia name of our lovely princess
I currently read this manhwa and it's even sadder to read all the happy scenes while knowing that this won't last and he will eventually forget her T^T But this song just fits perfectly...I couldn't stop rewatching TwT
I Hate Jeanette. Although I Am Not Supposed To Put The Blame On Her I Am Always On The Verge Of Crying Everytime I See CLAUDE And JEANETTE Together While Athy Just Watches In The Distance That Chapter Hurt Me The Most In The Whole Novel- Since Athy Took Years To Build An Affectionate Relationship With Claude And He Forgot It Easily To Save Athy And JEANETTE Just Came Trying To Steal Claude From Athy Although She Didn't Know It-
I loathe novel jennet because not only did she took a blind eye when athy was being discriminated by her father in front of the kingdom but also took her place as the princess of the kingdom and live the life of a princess/like a princess that athy tought her how to act, dance etc. As a princess
So..Am I the only one who came to love this manga solely for their fatherly bond Claude and Athanasia?(Cause just judging from the title and the cover..)She was given another chance.Even though shes not actually Athanasia,shes an orphan which mixes well with how things are. The point is,I cant even ship anyone in this manhwa.
Thought Jennette is innocent I HATE HER Edit: update yall, since season three is coming soon. Jennette really just wants happiness:D i kinds get it. She’s just sweet and naive, she doesn’t know how Athy felt when she started to “take” claude. I kinda like Jennette now I just hope she gets the family shes been wanting
I feel like Jenette didn’t truly love Claude and Athy when she thought they were her family, she only loved the idea of having a family. **SPOILER** When the past emperor/claudes brother comes back and admits that Jenette is his daughter, she basically stopped caring for Claude and Athy and started to fully trust Claudes brother/her father. I mean I get it, he’s her dad but she had only knew him for a short time and gained more love for him than she ever loved Claude, whom she had thought was her dad FOR YEARS. Jenette is so easily manipulated and is the perfect pawn and puppet. If she were to ever be emperor/empress she would run the king down to the gound, whereas Athy is smart and uses her brain. She won’t let anyone take advantage of her or the people she loves. ATHY FOR THE WIN
Listen....I'M TOO SAD ALREADY OKAY!! 😭😭😭😍😍🥰🥰💜💜💚💚 WMMAP is the best seriously I'm in love !!! And this song....ugh my heart can you not please ?? Well I'm glad Lucas came back, LUCAAAAAASS !!! 😍😍😭😭😭🥰🥰💜💜💚💚 I MISSED YOU SO MUCH LUCAAAS PLEASE ALWAYS STAY WITH OUR LITTLE PRINCESS ATHY !!! 😭🥰😍💜💚 Thanks for your amazing editing btw, it's a great AMV Haha!
Ooooh so the song is from Gero !!! Ah now I understand why it felt like i had heard this voice and maybe even song before Haha, Gero is such an amazing singer seriously this is so great thanks a lot for uploading this wonderfulness haha !!!
I have no idea but I think it was an year ago and at that time I just randomly clicked on this video. I watched this and I was touched and I somehow cried while watching this. I decided to read my first Manhwa(Wmmap) I was amazed by it. And now I’m a big fan of Manhwas. I’ve read too much that I think I’m obsessed 🗿
I just really wanna hug Claude rn... his brother killed his mother, his fiancée made love w his brother, when he thought he finally found the one he truly love, she died, leaving behind Athy who looks exactly like his lover and the fact that his brother’s daughter, born from dark magic is mistaking him as her dad!! Poor Claude 🤧😭
Eu sou seu servo leal e você é a rainha do nosso país I am your loyal servant and you're our country's queen Nós, dois gêmeos lamentáveis sobrecarregados por nosso destino Us, pair of pitied twins burdened by our destiny Deixe o fogo do inferno me consumir se isso é o que deve ser feito Let hellfire consume me if that's what must be done Terei prazer em desempenhar o papel para que você possa brilhar, meu sol I will gladly play the part so that you may shine, my sun No dia em que nós dois fomos trazidos a este mundo On the day the two of us were brought into this world Os sinos deram suas bênçãos a nós gêmeos, um menino e uma menina The bells gave their blessings to us twins, a boy and girl Mas por razões que éramos muito jovens para entender But for reasons that we were too young to understand Nos separamos We were separated Eu não conseguia mais segurar sua mão I could no longer hold your hand Se o mundo inteiro planejar apagar sua luz If the whole world plots to extinguish your light Se eles encontrarem a necessidade de fazer você quebrar e chorar If they find the need to make you break and cry Não se preocupe querida, estou bem ao seu lado Don't you worry, dear, I am right by your side Então apenas sorria para mim, vai ficar tudo bem So just smile for me, it'll be alright Eu sou seu servo leal e você é a rainha do nosso país I am your loyal servant and you're our country's queen Nós, um par de gêmeos lamentáveis sobrecarregados por nosso destino Us, A pair of pitied twins burdened by our destiny Deixe o fogo do inferno me consumir se isso é o que deve ser feito Let hellfire consume me if that's what must be done Terei prazer em desempenhar o papel para que você possa brilhar, meu sol I will gladly play the part so that you may shine, my sun Enquanto fazia recados no país ao leste While running errands in the country to the east Encontrei uma bela donzela com cabelo de um verde profundo I ran into a fair maiden with hair of deep green Seu sorriso e sua voz, para mim, foram enviados de cima Her smile and her voice, to me, were sent from up above Algo se moveu no meu peito Something moved in my chest Você pode até chamar isso de amor You might even call it love Mas sabemos que todas as coisas boas têm um fim But we know all good things must come to an end São ordens da minha rainha que a menina deve se arrepender It is my queen's orders the girl must repent Eu vou conceder seus desejos se isso é tudo para o que eu vivo I will grant your wishes if that's all I live for Então me diga, meu sol exatamente o que causou essas chuvas So then tell me, my sun just what caused these rains to pour Eu sou seu servo leal e você é a rainha do nosso país I am your loyal servant and you're our country's queen Nós, um par de gêmeos amaldiçoados ligados ao destino sangrento Us, a pair of cursed twins bound to bloody destiny "Alteza, brioche "Your highness, brioche Acompanhará o seu chá. " Will accompany your tea." E você bateu palmas de alegria, tão inocente e doce And you clapped your hands with glee, so innocent and sweet Parece que em breve este país encontrará seu destino It appears that soon this country will meet its fate Rasgado em pedaços por seu povo desmoronou sob seu ódio Torn to pieces by its people crumbled under their hate As massas afirmam que a justiça será trazida sobre nós hoje The masses claim that justice will be brought on us today Mas eu não vou ver isso até o fim, eles não vão conseguir o que querem But I won't see it through, they will not get their way "Ouça agora, minha querida, dê sua roupa para mim. "Listen now, my dear give your clothing to me. Você e eu mudaremos e você deve fugir. You and I will switch and away you must flee. Você vai ficar bem, nós somos gêmeos, você não vê You will be okay, we are twins, don't you see Eles não saberão, agora querida, não olhe para trás e apenas vá embora. " They won't know, now dear, don't look back and just leave." Eu sou apenas o duplo, a verdadeira rainha corre livre I am only the double, the true queen runs free Nós, um par de gêmeos quebrados, condenados pelo destino cruel Us, a pair of broken twins, damned by cruel destiny Se o diabo é o seu senhor, como as massas amaldiçoam o seu nome If the devil's your lord, as the masses curse your name Então, eu também sou um demônio, pelo nosso sangue é o mesmo Then, I'm a demon too, for our blood's one and the same Há muito tempo, havia um reino governado por uma rainha Long ago, there was a kingdom ruled by a queen Naquela época, nós dois mal tínhamos catorze anos At that time the two of us were barely aged fourteen Uma "filha do mal" governou o reino de dentro A "daughter of evil" ruled the kingdom from within Mas as histórias mentem, pois ela era minha preciosa gêmea But the stories lie, for she was my precious little twin Se o mundo inteiro planejar apagar sua luz If the whole world plots to extinguish your light (Finalmente, os sinos anunciam essa hora) (Finally, the bells are announcing that time) Se eles encontrarem a necessidade de fazer você quebrar e chorar If they find the need to make you break and cry (Posso sentir meu coração se partir a cada toque que passa.) (I can feel my heart break with each passing chime.) Não se preocupe querida, estou bem ao seu lado Don't you worry, dear, I am right by your side (Com os olhos desviados, você olha para o céu.) (With your eyes averted, you look to the sky.) Então apenas sorria para mim, vai ficar tudo bem So just smile for me it'll be alright (E a lâmina assobia quando você chama minha fala.) (And the blade whistles down as you call out my line.) "Oh, eu acredito que é hora do chá" "Oh, i believe it's tea time" Eu sou seu servo leal e você é minha preciosa rainha I am your loyal servant and you're my precious queen Nós, um par de gêmeos lamentáveis sobrecarregados por nosso destino Us, a pair of pitied twins burdened by our destiny Deixe o fogo do inferno me consumir se isso é o que deve ser feito Let hellfire consume me if that's what must be done Eu alegremente fiz minha parte para que você pudesse brilhar, meu sol I have gladly played my part so that you may shine, my sun Se chegar o dia em que renasceremos mais uma vez If the day comes that we are reborn once again Seria bom brincar com você. It'd be nice play with you. Então eu vou esperar por você até então So I'll wait for you 'til then
the lyrics of the song is enough to break my heart i just remember len's sacrifice for rin😭... and knowing what happened to claude and athy doesn't help 🥺
I know the ending of this manhwa was in the novel, but what if this was an alternate ending? Like, Athy was accused of poisoning Jeannette, then Claude tries to kill her of course, he dies. But then, while he watched Athy die slowly, he suddenly remembers that Athy was his beloved daughter. Then he became depressed again, but this time he was REALLY depressed bc he killed his daughter with his own hands, and he kept the pictures that Athy drew for him and everything. What if that happend? What if in the end of the manhwa Claude actually found out that Jeannette was his brother's child and not his? Would he feel even more guilty for killing his own daughter, knowing that she was the only family he had left? I think about that alternate ending a lot :)
From the foreshadowing of the manhwa, which I don't know if the artist scrapped, Claude had an idea of Jannet's origin. Not exactly but an 'idea'. So I dunno what happened to the artist. Claude was really really tamed in the manwha for someone who lost his memory. He's supposed to be someone with trust issue. And from the novel, Claude kinda knew. He is closer to the truth from the start and so sure about it even before the revelation. That's why he said that Jannet is a 'filthy girl'. Jannet, just like athy, really looks like her mother. And when Jannet revealed herself as Claude's daughter, it was actually Claude that dropped the bomb.
Let me just clarify Jeanette doesn’t deserve HATE that’s far too strong I know she’s naive but think about it she doesn’t even know she was born from black magic or her real family
I really don’t understand why so many people hate Jenette. Sure she’s naive, and can sometimes come out as selfish. But it’s because of her upbringing that made her this way. She had no parents to guide her, she was taken under the wing of a man that saw her more as a tool than a daughter, and she only seeks to be part of a family to be loved. I don’t think that her being loved/cared for by Athy and Claude will harm Claude and Athy’s relationship as well. At the same time, however, I don’t believe that her being part of Claude and Athy’s family will make her as happy as she believes it will. She is still the daughter of the former emperor and Claude’s ex fiancé. This fact alone is probably the one of the main reasons why Claude cannot fully trust her. In the original story as well, it is hinted that Claude kept Jeannette by his side because the curse’s symptoms alleviated his pain when Jeannette was by him. In the original story, he didn’t love Athy because she was the one who killed his beloved(Athy’s mom during child birth). In conclusion, although Jennette is mostly recognized as a character that separates Athy and Claude, she is still a character that was always treated as a special tool by her guardians and who’s main objective is to be loved and PART of Athy and Claude’s circle of loved ones. I believe that she has the chance to grow and figure out what she truly wants and the best way to achieve her goals. Please be mindful of the characters and their backgrounds and personalities. The authors most likely did not create Jennette as the evil villainess(at least as far as I am aware). I really love all the aspects this story has, and I am excited to see how it will proceed in the future. Also does anyone know how often the manhwa’s episodes will be released? I am aware that the manhwa is coming back on the 30th, but I want to know how often they will be released after the 30th. Thanks!
Does anyone know really good manhwa like this. Or anything that just makes you cry and throw your phone in frustration I already read: The abandoned Empress The monster Duchess and contract Princess The emperors daughter
Lady to Queen, Remmaried Empress, Surviving As A Maid I think would work. Everytime I read those I feel my blood pressure was increase 😂 I'm full of anger and want to kill the villainess for sure. Read them! (Though most of them because of third-wheel tho 👉👈). You will know it once you read. Hope it helps 😉
Nadia MA SURVIVING AS A MAID!!! That one really got me!!! I found another good one that came out recently called “Throw me Away” AHSCSKSOGSCSJIAV MY BLOOD BOILLSSSSS
So here goes my appreciation post for jennette, some people might be irritated with jennette and I can't blame them but please try to understand jennette more T^T. When Lucas,Athy and Kiel was enjoying the world outside, there she was, who can't go outside because was prevented to do so. Do you all remember when Athy was banned from the castle when Claude forgotten her? She taught that jennette was the one who cursed her so she came to her household and saw a crying jennette. Jennette was not permitted by mr. White to attend her auntie's funeral and he just gave the flower to ejikiel so that it will reach her auntie's funeral. Jennete who was grieving from her auntie's death had welcome Athy in her room with a smile even though she has been in pain. Jennete was also the one that was bravw enought to ask if Claude misses Athy. She never experience having a family that's why she's craving for love even if she may have Mr. White and Kiel but she tries to be family with them but couldn't. Another, when she saw athy's reaction towards her telling that what if she's her real sister, she was hurt but tries to understand Athy, she just thought that maybe Athy was just shocked/suprised. When Kiel told her that he likes Athy, she quickly understood even if she was actually hurt. The time that Athy didn't greet her back and has a weird expression, she understanda that there was something going on and didn't hate Athy for that. Lastly, do you remember when Athy told her that she knew her identity from the start but didn't tell jennette because she's afraid? Instead of being angry at Athy, she cried, she was sad and angry at herself because she didn't know what Athy was going through. She blames herself for being inconsiderate of Athy and Claude. Athy then realize that she couldn't hate Jennette because of her kind and understanding personality . I LOVE HER AND ATHY SO MUCHHH!!!! T^T Copied
Spoiler; so Athy was just messing around with claude (after he got his memories back) And then athy expected him to say “none sense” or “Keep dreaming” but instead he said “No matter what anyone says, you’re my daughter” “Until the day I die... no, even after I die, that fact that you’re my daughter will never change”
Yeppp... I.. I don't blame jeanette but.. it's just that she's so naive jeanette is so naive that it seems she tries to steal Claude and like he tried to kill athy.. and if he gains his memories back then he would be suffer in great lose of sadness..!
![[MMV] Suddenly I Became a Princess | Who Made Me a Princess "Servant of Evil" Athy×Jennete Sub Indo](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PsyQ7TOFQLg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MMV] Suddenly I Became a Princess | Who Made Me a Princess "Servant of Evil" Athy×Jennete Sub Indo](/img/tr.png)
The one thing i dislike about Jenette is that she's so naive. Athy is an intelligent girl. She knows what to do. And what is wrong or right. Even though she knew that Jenette could potentially hurt her future with her dad, yet she initiated their further relationship. While Jenette, as we all know about in the first life of athy, she didn't even do anything when athy was being discriminated or was executed. And lived a happy life with ijekiel.
That's why I'll always prefer athy. ♡♡♡
It's just how her character was written.... Like athy is only intelligent because she is aware of the story line. Jeanette is basically the typical main character in a Web novel which is partly why she's so naive... I like both of them equally
me too i love athy because She’s so Smart and a girl How knows What around her, and i Hate Jenette because She’s so naive and Indifferent😐
I read somewhere that in lovely princess after athy was killed and claude died, she started doing black magic and she did a spell thing where athy was reincarnated back to when she was born and so claude could love her. Because that was what athy always wanted, but because of this everyone but athy lost their memories. One of the side affects of her black magic was that clause would never love her though, he would only ever think that athy was her daughter and he wouldn't ever think of jennette as someone he could love... so basically she gave athy and everyone another chance to re live their life and to correct themselves even though it meant she would loose everything she loved.
Athy is reincarnated and had had a lot of reincarnations in the past. Since she was a grown woman in this timeline, it would be normal for her to be smarter
@@chloeng09 omg, where did you read that?!
I wish there is a way to bring back Athy's mother its heartbreaking to see Claude sad and happy when he look at Athy because she look so much like her mother T_T
Dark Arisha Yeah if Athy’s mother was still alive maybe they would have been a happy family.
@@michellejiang9666 yea only if she was here none of this would've happened
@@_celes_5057 Not really even with her being dead she still fixed the problems between Claude and Athy
I really love this father and daughter duo until he lost his memories. I know that he would regret the decision to kill his own lovely daughter when he regain memories
but i honestly wonder how the claude from the first story would've reacted after learning the truth behind jennette..
@Silver Phoenix whatttt? well damn
@@k14_0405 yeah, I mean, Unless I read it wrong, Clause never did anything with Penolpe (Jenette's mother) that could've resulted into a child so he probably think Jenette's his brother's child or something.
@Silver Phoenix oohhh wow i forgot about that. thank you!!!
@@Lina_rush yeah, i forgot about that. thanks!
@@k14_0405 Claude knew from the beginning, but he still accepted her yet he did not accept Athanasia, his own daughter, which is seriously messed up.
He lost his memories to save his daughter and now he tries to kill her with her own hands 😭😭😭😓
Ashmita Sarkar he would be crying in despair and even sadder than he was before
That's Soo confusing
I really don't understand why do that girl need to come back
She lived thankfully
What episode did he forget about her?
come to think of it, caulde is actually really pityful, he didnt have a happy childhood, and his lover died becoz of giving birth to athy, he lost soo many things throughout his life,thats why he became so cruel, cold and heartless in order to become stronger an killed his brother ( but his brother isnt dead) its just kinda sad, but im sure athy will melten his cold heart and the father and daugther relationship will strengthen, THIS IS JUST MY THOUGHTS AFTER WAITING THE NEW CHP TO UPLOAD XD
And he survives this time instead of *whatever happens*
To add to that, during his youth he was engaged to Jennette's mother. Then what happened? He walks into a room and sees his betrothed sleeping with his evil brother, smirking. So eventually he moved on and found the life of his life, but then that person died.
His brother died someone just using his brother corpse.
I Hate Jeanette. Although I Am Not Supposed To Put The Blame On Her I Am Always On The Verge Of Crying Everytime I See CLAUDE And JEANETTE Together While Athy Just Watches In The Distance That Chapter Hurt Me The Most In The Whole Novel/Manhwa- Since Athy Took Years To Build An Affectionate Relationship With Claude And He Forgot It Easily To Save Athy And JEANETTE Just Came Trying To Steal Claude From Athy Although She Didn't Know It..
I feel youuuu T^T I mean, I know Jeanette is innocent but I don't want Athy to be in pain>< Jeannette is not even Claude's daughter, so why T^T
I feel extremely sorry for Jeanette. She never and a loving family, and you can see that she really loves and cares about Athanasia and Claude. And as she was conceived by dark magic, like the old man in the shop said, she will never be able to find true happiness. Although she has never done something wrong.
I hate this comment. She's just a little girl who wants to have a family much like athy... The only reason you guys like athy and hate Jeanette is because that we see things from athys perspective. If this was the original story however and Jeanette was the main character we'd all be rooting for her
blue blues no I dislike her because she get love trough BLACK MAGIC, beauty and being naive she didn't even have to try and everybody loves her. I hate all characters like that, is just like that in real life too, the difference is that in real life not everything is flowers and just with a serious mental problem to be so dump at the point of some characters, really is just not realistic at the point of empathy, to me she is or a poorly constructed character or a really twisted chimera with really mental problems, in the second case (what the writer already got clearly for me that is the truth) I could feel something but for now she is just annoying
@@LIAHAKEL it's not jennete's fault nor did she got all the love just by doing nothing, if you look closely Jennete was doomed for unhappiness in both timeliness. In the first she was only "cared" by claude since her manifested love eased him, while ezekiel only married her because of his father command whose main purpose was power.
In the second one she literally has no one, like no one to care for her truly. Even when she drowned in the lake claude could not even know who "Jennete" was when athanasia told him to save her. He only calls for her since her presence eases his headache and pain, for him she's just a figure. Even ezekiel is now rude to her at points.
I know this is my opinion but I personally like her character cuz even after all that she's still optimistic and hopes for the best, she tries her best not to get dishearted and finds happiness in the tinniest things.
Lucas please come back has fast has you could.. I can't take it anymore...😭😭 Athanasia please be strong ,..wuahhhhh..😭😭😭😭 lucas..
Just you wait... even if Lucas still hasn't came back yet. You'll LOVE the up coming chapters.
@@jaricasi3463 what do you mean?
@@nurkhairunnisaatirah3014 I've been reading the novel and I advice for you to not read it if you really want a good first reaction. Something will happen on the festival.
@@jaricasi3463 I read the novel but I dont notice it. I will wait for it. thank youu. but may I ask u? Claude wont kill athy and he starts treating athy well is it? then lucas bring ..... and claude remembers everything right?
@@nurkhairunnisaatirah3014 its hard to say spoilers here. But let's just say that its impossible for the protagonist to die. 😅
*notices how similar Servant of Evil and this is*
Me: CLAUDE DON'T KILL HER!!! AGAIN!!!
How they similar???
@@Vocalist_-wp5we I... I don't know...? I can't even remember when and why I wrote/typed this XD
I guess... it's the similar settings and the relationship between Claude and his daughter, Athanasia and the MC... I don't know XD
@@neruneru9713 I suppose you meant the feeling of tragedy
Lmao the same feeling of angst
Maybe because previous Athy is like Len, wholely devoted to Claude, the tyrant like rin. The only difference is Len and Rin are separated siblings while they are father and daughter.
When seeing the part where claude has this flower on his ear that athy placed really made me cry....😢😢😢
i think the only reason why athy come back to the life because for her mother's wish she want to her daughter to be alive the way she choose athanasia name of our lovely princess
I currently read this manhwa and it's even sadder to read all the happy scenes while knowing that this won't last and he will eventually forget her T^T
But this song just fits perfectly...I couldn't stop rewatching TwT
Why did he forget her? What happened??
@@FirstTimeCatMom after saving her he lost his memory
Update: he has remembered and not only that he has evolved
I know Jennette wasn't to blame cause she didn't know anything 😐 But I just don't like her 😐😐 Claude's love should only be for Athy!!!
He likes her ?? I thought that he’s just using her he’s frickin head ache 🧐🧐
@@breannarawrror5920 yes but my heartache because she could get close to Claude while Athy can't
I Hate Jeanette. Although I Am Not Supposed To Put The Blame On Her I Am Always On The Verge Of Crying Everytime I See CLAUDE And JEANETTE Together While Athy Just Watches In The Distance That Chapter Hurt Me The Most In The Whole Novel- Since Athy Took Years To Build An Affectionate Relationship With Claude And He Forgot It Easily To Save Athy And JEANETTE Just Came Trying To Steal Claude From Athy Although She Didn't Know It-
I loathe novel jennet because not only did she took a blind eye when athy was being discriminated by her father in front of the kingdom but also took her place as the princess of the kingdom and live the life of a princess/like a princess that athy tought her how to act, dance etc. As a princess
me too When i see Claude and Jennete together i Feel Like i just Wants to kill her 😬
So..Am I the only one who came to love this manga solely for their fatherly bond Claude and Athanasia?(Cause just judging from the title and the cover..)She was given another chance.Even though shes not actually Athanasia,shes an orphan which mixes well with how things are.
The point is,I cant even ship anyone in this manhwa.
@Sparks Gaming in the novel?thats pretty cool!
@Sparks Gaming OH! i stopped reading to wait for it completed (._. )7
No we can actually ship athy and Lucas
Yes you can
Athy x lucus
Claude x Diana
athy x lucas &
Claude x DIana is there...
Props to you for using one of the most well loved Vocaloid songs ever. Servant Evil will forever be a classic!! Love it ❤❤
お父さんいくつなんだろ…
全然老けてないよね…うらやま
そ れ な！！
側近含めて老けない設定の為絵師さんが主人公のアティが幼くしか描けず苦労したそうです。
This moment was sooo saddd i started tearing uppp because u did it sooo nicely then the story fits perfectly
Remember ..REMEMBER!!
just ReMeMbEr.....😢
Ow shi* the story of servant of evil hit me in the heart plus the story when Claude forgot Athanasia... MAH HART CAN'T TAKE IT ANYMORE (TT^TT)
Thought Jennette is innocent I HATE HER
Edit: update yall, since season three is coming soon. Jennette really just wants happiness:D i kinds get it. She’s just sweet and naive, she doesn’t know how Athy felt when she started to “take” claude. I kinda like Jennette now I just hope she gets the family shes been wanting
Me too i Hate her soooo much WHY is she so bad Athy is so good and Sweet so Why did this happened to her 😭
Thankfully you realise that, cause I really want to screem on Jeanette's haters
AAAAAA THE KAGAMINE TWINS AND MY FAV MANHWA IN THE SAME VIDEO??
I LOVE U
I like thise moment betwen father and dauther day but it's very sad and full of sad moment betwen antanasia and claudy
I feel like Jenette didn’t truly love Claude and Athy when she thought they were her family, she only loved the idea of having a family.
**SPOILER**
When the past emperor/claudes brother comes back and admits that Jenette is his daughter, she basically stopped caring for Claude and Athy and started to fully trust Claudes brother/her father. I mean I get it, he’s her dad but she had only knew him for a short time and gained more love for him than she ever loved Claude, whom she had thought was her dad FOR YEARS.
Jenette is so easily manipulated and is the perfect pawn and puppet. If she were to ever be emperor/empress she would run the king down to the gound, whereas Athy is smart and uses her brain. She won’t let anyone take advantage of her or the people she loves.
ATHY FOR THE WIN
I wish this can be anime..
ikr
Could be not good idea... GILGAMESH vs Ilya anyone?
th-cam.com/video/8gagv2a7TUQ/w-d-xo.html
😅
ㅜㅜ어공주랑 악의하인 노래 너무 잘 어울리는거 아닌가요ㅠㅠ
*the beginning...*
me: ugh, I'm prepared for an emotional heart.
btw! it perfectly suited! the sadness of both princess.
I like this story very much now! Hope you make more!
Feel the heartbroken when i watch this, Athy be strong, fight it back
이렇게 유튜브 돌아다니다 보면 해외 독자분들도 어공주 좋아한다는게 보여서 너무 좋다 ㅎㅎㅎ 역시 해외에도 통하는 갓작
Listen....I'M TOO SAD ALREADY OKAY!! 😭😭😭😍😍🥰🥰💜💜💚💚
WMMAP is the best seriously I'm in love !!! And this song....ugh my heart can you not please ??
Well I'm glad Lucas came back, LUCAAAAAASS !!! 😍😍😭😭😭🥰🥰💜💜💚💚 I MISSED YOU SO MUCH LUCAAAS PLEASE ALWAYS STAY WITH OUR LITTLE PRINCESS ATHY !!! 😭🥰😍💜💚
Thanks for your amazing editing btw, it's a great AMV Haha!
Ooooh so the song is from Gero !!! Ah now I understand why it felt like i had heard this voice and maybe even song before Haha, Gero is such an amazing singer seriously this is so great thanks a lot for uploading this wonderfulness haha !!!
와/.. 연출이며... 이미지도 딱 적절한 타이밍에, 적절한 이미지... 심지어 노래도 여러가지 버젼중에 잘 어울리는 느낌으로 한것 같아서 소름돋아요...
홀린듯이 3-4번 막 돌려보게되네요,.... 굳이에요... ㄷㄷ
i choked up at the last picture it hurts damn it T_T
選曲がGeroさんってとこが分かってるね〜！
この漫画、めっちゃ好きでハマってたな〜
Ill have the courage to reread this all when season 2 finally has a happy ending.
Unfortunately, season 2 just ended and it still doesn’t have a happy ending. 🤣
歌詞何語か分からんかったけ、よく聴いとったら日本語やったわ〜アーティとパパめっちゃ好き😘
I hoped claude remembers athy
woow this was a very put together video. The scenes matched the music perfectly. Loved it!
i seriously love how this story focuses more on family love, and not just on romance.
ahhhh servant of evilll
the angsttt ～ 😭❤
泣ける
I have no idea but I think it was an year ago and at that time I just randomly clicked on this video. I watched this and I was touched and I somehow cried while watching this. I decided to read my first Manhwa(Wmmap) I was amazed by it. And now I’m a big fan of Manhwas. I’ve read too much that I think I’m obsessed 🗿
노래랑 장면 한 순간 한 순간이 정말 잘 어울린다~❤
Too much feels. Can't handle the feelssssss. 😭😭
I’m not crying, you are! ToT
와우 잘만들었네여!
I just really wanna hug Claude rn... his brother killed his mother, his fiancée made love w his brother, when he thought he finally found the one he truly love, she died, leaving behind Athy who looks exactly like his lover and the fact that his brother’s daughter, born from dark magic is mistaking him as her dad!! Poor Claude 🤧😭
I remember watching this 4 years ago and i was obsessed with this video also hated Jeannette until i finished reading the novel and the manwhaa😂
This is making me kind of emotional.
I like thise vidio becaus it's ful of love and romantick moment to betwen father and daugter
I love reading the parts when athy was young and all the times she spent with sane Claude.
aaahhh i miss their close relationship so much! TwT this had me in tears...
와 대박... 잘만들었다....
это прекрасно...
AHHHHHH *SHHHHHHHHHHH*
_THE SOUND OF MAH TEARSSSSS_
I Keep Listening To this Song 5 Times A Day Each Day! This Song Is To Good🥺
Me: *in my closet crying to this video*
Also me: *reading the manga from the start even tho I haven’t finished it yet*
simplemente hermoso !!!
Eu sou seu servo leal e você é a rainha do nosso país
I am your loyal servant and you're our country's queen
Nós, dois gêmeos lamentáveis sobrecarregados por nosso destino
Us, pair of pitied twins burdened by our destiny
Deixe o fogo do inferno me consumir se isso é o que deve ser feito
Let hellfire consume me if that's what must be done
Terei prazer em desempenhar o papel para que você possa brilhar, meu sol
I will gladly play the part so that you may shine, my sun
No dia em que nós dois fomos trazidos a este mundo
On the day the two of us were brought into this world
Os sinos deram suas bênçãos a nós gêmeos, um menino e uma menina
The bells gave their blessings to us twins, a boy and girl
Mas por razões que éramos muito jovens para entender
But for reasons that we were too young to understand
Nos separamos
We were separated
Eu não conseguia mais segurar sua mão
I could no longer hold your hand
Se o mundo inteiro planejar apagar sua luz
If the whole world plots to extinguish your light
Se eles encontrarem a necessidade de fazer você quebrar e chorar
If they find the need to make you break and cry
Não se preocupe querida, estou bem ao seu lado
Don't you worry, dear, I am right by your side
Então apenas sorria para mim, vai ficar tudo bem
So just smile for me, it'll be alright
Eu sou seu servo leal e você é a rainha do nosso país
I am your loyal servant and you're our country's queen
Nós, um par de gêmeos lamentáveis sobrecarregados por nosso destino
Us, A pair of pitied twins burdened by our destiny
Deixe o fogo do inferno me consumir se isso é o que deve ser feito
Let hellfire consume me if that's what must be done
Terei prazer em desempenhar o papel para que você possa brilhar, meu sol
I will gladly play the part so that you may shine, my sun
Enquanto fazia recados no país ao leste
While running errands in the country to the east
Encontrei uma bela donzela com cabelo de um verde profundo
I ran into a fair maiden with hair of deep green
Seu sorriso e sua voz, para mim, foram enviados de cima
Her smile and her voice, to me, were sent from up above
Algo se moveu no meu peito
Something moved in my chest
Você pode até chamar isso de amor
You might even call it love
Mas sabemos que todas as coisas boas têm um fim
But we know all good things must come to an end
São ordens da minha rainha que a menina deve se arrepender
It is my queen's orders the girl must repent
Eu vou conceder seus desejos se isso é tudo para o que eu vivo
I will grant your wishes if that's all I live for
Então me diga, meu sol exatamente o que causou essas chuvas
So then tell me, my sun just what caused these rains to pour
Eu sou seu servo leal e você é a rainha do nosso país
I am your loyal servant and you're our country's queen
Nós, um par de gêmeos amaldiçoados ligados ao destino sangrento
Us, a pair of cursed twins bound to bloody destiny
"Alteza, brioche
"Your highness, brioche
Acompanhará o seu chá. "
Will accompany your tea."
E você bateu palmas de alegria, tão inocente e doce
And you clapped your hands with glee, so innocent and sweet
Parece que em breve este país encontrará seu destino
It appears that soon this country will meet its fate
Rasgado em pedaços por seu povo desmoronou sob seu ódio
Torn to pieces by its people crumbled under their hate
As massas afirmam que a justiça será trazida sobre nós hoje
The masses claim that justice will be brought on us today
Mas eu não vou ver isso até o fim, eles não vão conseguir o que querem
But I won't see it through, they will not get their way
"Ouça agora, minha querida, dê sua roupa para mim.
"Listen now, my dear give your clothing to me.
Você e eu mudaremos e você deve fugir.
You and I will switch and away you must flee.
Você vai ficar bem, nós somos gêmeos, você não vê
You will be okay, we are twins, don't you see
Eles não saberão, agora querida, não olhe para trás e apenas vá embora. "
They won't know, now dear, don't look back and just leave."
Eu sou apenas o duplo, a verdadeira rainha corre livre
I am only the double, the true queen runs free
Nós, um par de gêmeos quebrados, condenados pelo destino cruel
Us, a pair of broken twins, damned by cruel destiny
Se o diabo é o seu senhor, como as massas amaldiçoam o seu nome
If the devil's your lord, as the masses curse your name
Então, eu também sou um demônio, pelo nosso sangue é o mesmo
Then, I'm a demon too, for our blood's one and the same
Há muito tempo, havia um reino governado por uma rainha
Long ago, there was a kingdom ruled by a queen
Naquela época, nós dois mal tínhamos catorze anos
At that time the two of us were barely aged fourteen
Uma "filha do mal" governou o reino de dentro
A "daughter of evil" ruled the kingdom from within
Mas as histórias mentem, pois ela era minha preciosa gêmea
But the stories lie, for she was my precious little twin
Se o mundo inteiro planejar apagar sua luz
If the whole world plots to extinguish your light
(Finalmente, os sinos anunciam essa hora)
(Finally, the bells are announcing that time)
Se eles encontrarem a necessidade de fazer você quebrar e chorar
If they find the need to make you break and cry
(Posso sentir meu coração se partir a cada toque que passa.)
(I can feel my heart break with each passing chime.)
Não se preocupe querida, estou bem ao seu lado
Don't you worry, dear, I am right by your side
(Com os olhos desviados, você olha para o céu.)
(With your eyes averted, you look to the sky.)
Então apenas sorria para mim, vai ficar tudo bem
So just smile for me it'll be alright
(E a lâmina assobia quando você chama minha fala.)
(And the blade whistles down as you call out my line.)
"Oh, eu acredito que é hora do chá"
"Oh, i believe it's tea time"
Eu sou seu servo leal e você é minha preciosa rainha
I am your loyal servant and you're my precious queen
Nós, um par de gêmeos lamentáveis sobrecarregados por nosso destino
Us, a pair of pitied twins burdened by our destiny
Deixe o fogo do inferno me consumir se isso é o que deve ser feito
Let hellfire consume me if that's what must be done
Eu alegremente fiz minha parte para que você pudesse brilhar, meu sol
I have gladly played my part so that you may shine, my sun
Se chegar o dia em que renasceremos mais uma vez
If the day comes that we are reborn once again
Seria bom brincar com você.
It'd be nice play with you.
Então eu vou esperar por você até então
So I'll wait for you 'til then
the lyrics of the song is enough to break my heart i just remember len's sacrifice for rin😭... and knowing what happened to claude and athy doesn't help 🥺
I know the ending of this manhwa was in the novel, but what if this was an alternate ending?
Like, Athy was accused of poisoning Jeannette, then Claude tries to kill her of course, he dies. But then, while he watched Athy die slowly, he suddenly remembers that Athy was his beloved daughter. Then he became depressed again, but this time he was REALLY depressed bc he killed his daughter with his own hands, and he kept the pictures that Athy drew for him and everything.
What if that happend?
What if in the end of the manhwa Claude actually found out that Jeannette was his brother's child and not his?
Would he feel even more guilty for killing his own daughter, knowing that she was the only family he had left?
I think about that alternate ending a lot :)
Do you mind telling where we can read the novel?
@@aicilaatam3192 i don't really know actually, my friend read the novel and gave me spoilers but i don't know where they read it-
From the foreshadowing of the manhwa, which I don't know if the artist scrapped, Claude had an idea of Jannet's origin. Not exactly but an 'idea'. So I dunno what happened to the artist. Claude was really really tamed in the manwha for someone who lost his memory. He's supposed to be someone with trust issue.
And from the novel, Claude kinda knew. He is closer to the truth from the start and so sure about it even before the revelation. That's why he said that Jannet is a 'filthy girl'. Jannet, just like athy, really looks like her mother. And when Jannet revealed herself as Claude's daughter, it was actually Claude that dropped the bomb.
So cute at the end of the video when the father and daughter is sleeping in the bed together.
I always feel like I want to cry I miss the old claude
え、この曲って「悪の召し使い」よね！？びびったぁ
เฮ้อ! ดูทีไรก็เศร้าทุกที
Wow this is so cool 👏👏
와 누가 이 띵작노래를 이렇게 사용할 생각 했냐!!! 졸라 존경한다
Love it!!! 💜💜
I love this
Came here to say that I'm 100% sure that original Ijekiel had already fallen in love with Athy
IKR!!
Great idea to use this song for this manhwa
This song really fit WMMAP i can feel the emotion😢😭
According to the video it seems like Athanasia is the queen and Jennete is the servent. I just liked it ,lol.
Let me just clarify Jeanette doesn’t deserve HATE that’s far too strong I know she’s naive but think about it she doesn’t even know she was born from black magic or her real family
I love this video
ใช่แย้ววว
روووووووووععععععععةةةةةةجججججججججججدددددددداااااا اأاااااسسسسسستتتتتتمرررررريئيييييييي
헐악의하인미쳣내미쳣서댑악사랑해요샘
I just miss every feeling this manga gave me😭😭❤️❤️
Has it finished?
nwär hare nope
nwär hare or, season 1 has ended but season 2 has just started
@@constellation5534 yep. i checked yesterday and cried when Claude tried to kill athy hhhhhhhhahahahha good times
nwär hare good times, good times, *sad crying*
when you can't accept the fact that in the first place athy almost die in claude hands but now athy's risking her life just to save claude
I really want to know what happened before wmmap in lovely princess in a detail and what happened after the book ended.
Realmente hay que decir respecto al rey, parece mas el hermano mayor de la princesa que el padre, es que es muy lindo!!!!!!
Cool
懐かしい曲だなぁ
なんて言う曲名ですか？
@@MK-ee9ur
悪ノ召使って言う曲名ですよ
I was wondering if a part of Diana's soul stayed in Claude's subconsciousness in the first time line
Will claudy love antanasia with all her heart and nice too
I cant wait for the 3d season. I really hope he remembers.
Raelmente adoro este manga🥰♥️
Me puedes decir orfavor como se llama pliis
@@kaguyateorias lo puedes buscar como "un día me convertí en una princesa" o también como "princesa encantadora"
I wish this is not be sad ending. Why my heart is hurt too. Sorry i cry 😭
I really don’t understand why so many people hate Jenette. Sure she’s naive, and can sometimes come out as selfish. But it’s because of her upbringing that made her this way. She had no parents to guide her, she was taken under the wing of a man that saw her more as a tool than a daughter, and she only seeks to be part of a family to be loved. I don’t think that her being loved/cared for by Athy and Claude will harm Claude and Athy’s relationship as well.
At the same time, however, I don’t believe that her being part of Claude and Athy’s family will make her as happy as she believes it will. She is still the daughter of the former emperor and Claude’s ex fiancé. This fact alone is probably the one of the main reasons why Claude cannot fully trust her. In the original story as well, it is hinted that Claude kept Jeannette by his side because the curse’s symptoms alleviated his pain when Jeannette was by him. In the original story, he didn’t love Athy because she was the one who killed his beloved(Athy’s mom during child birth).
In conclusion, although Jennette is mostly recognized as a character that separates Athy and Claude, she is still a character that was always treated as a special tool by her guardians and who’s main objective is to be loved and PART of Athy and Claude’s circle of loved ones. I believe that she has the chance to grow and figure out what she truly wants and the best way to achieve her goals. Please be mindful of the characters and their backgrounds and personalities. The authors most likely did not create Jennette as the evil villainess(at least as far as I am aware).
I really love all the aspects this story has, and I am excited to see how it will proceed in the future. Also does anyone know how often the manhwa’s episodes will be released? I am aware that the manhwa is coming back on the 30th, but I want to know how often they will be released after the 30th.
Thanks!
Does anyone know really good manhwa like this. Or anything that just makes you cry and throw your phone in frustration
I already read:
The abandoned Empress
The monster Duchess and contract Princess
The emperors daughter
Lady to Queen, Remmaried Empress, Surviving As A Maid I think would work. Everytime I read those I feel my blood pressure was increase 😂 I'm full of anger and want to kill the villainess for sure. Read them! (Though most of them because of third-wheel tho 👉👈). You will know it once you read. Hope it helps 😉
Sparks Gaming ITSS SOO GOOD I’m reading it rn 😍😍
Nadia MA SURVIVING AS A MAID!!! That one really got me!!! I found another good one that came out recently called “Throw me Away” AHSCSKSOGSCSJIAV MY BLOOD BOILLSSSSS
@@1594L-c9z yes I also read it. Damn the duke is aagskdjaldhjs
The villianess turns the hourglass ITS SOO GOOD
Claude 😍y su hija tan lindos😍
ซึ้งมว๊ากกกก
So here goes my appreciation post for jennette, some people might be irritated with jennette and I can't blame them but please try to understand jennette more T^T. When Lucas,Athy and Kiel was enjoying the world outside, there she was, who can't go outside because was prevented to do so. Do you all remember when Athy was banned from the castle when Claude forgotten her? She taught that jennette was the one who cursed her so she came to her household and saw a crying jennette. Jennette was not permitted by mr. White to attend her auntie's funeral and he just gave the flower to ejikiel so that it will reach her auntie's funeral. Jennete who was grieving from her auntie's death had welcome Athy in her room with a smile even though she has been in pain. Jennete was also the one that was bravw enought to ask if Claude misses Athy. She never experience having a family that's why she's craving for love even if she may have Mr. White and Kiel but she tries to be family with them but couldn't. Another, when she saw athy's reaction towards her telling that what if she's her real sister, she was hurt but tries to understand Athy, she just thought that maybe Athy was just shocked/suprised. When Kiel told her that he likes Athy, she quickly understood even if she was actually hurt. The time that Athy didn't greet her back and has a weird expression, she understanda that there was something going on and didn't hate Athy for that. Lastly, do you remember when Athy told her that she knew her identity from the start but didn't tell jennette because she's afraid? Instead of being angry at Athy, she cried, she was sad and angry at herself because she didn't know what Athy was going through. She blames herself for being inconsiderate of Athy and Claude. Athy then realize that she couldn't hate Jennette because of her kind and understanding personality . I LOVE HER AND ATHY SO MUCHHH!!!! T^T
Copied
So cute at the end they sleep together my head went Sparkle
Spoiler;
so Athy was just messing around with claude (after he got his memories back) And then athy expected him to say “none sense” or “Keep dreaming” but instead he said
“No matter what anyone says, you’re my daughter” “Until the day I die... no, even after I die, that fact that you’re my daughter will never change”
ಥ⌣ಥ i hope we get these moment soon
Jeanette's innonce and naive way of thinking is also the same form as ignorance
If she truly cared for athy, she should try to be on her shoes
I cry 😭😭😭
BRING BACK PAPA CLAUDE’S MEMORIES 😭
Yeppp... I.. I don't blame jeanette but.. it's just that she's so naive jeanette is so naive that it seems she tries to steal Claude and like he tried to kill athy.. and if he gains his memories back then he would be suffer in great lose of sadness..!
I just wish that jeanette be with her true family and atty can be with claude forever and ever.....😩