Mate, good video. One very important point though, at 4:46 you say that when a CU is placed under a General who doesnt have CUs, the general is displaced. You should say "enemy" general. If you put a friendly CUs under your general without CU, your general doesnt get displaced. Small but essential difference.
Thanks. Excellent work, but I think there's a little mistake. During the political isolation phase "Friendly PC" doesn't count for tracing another "Friendly PC" (unless it's also a friendly port or it has a friendly CU). Rules 19.4: ...A PC marker is isolated if the player cannot trace a path of spaces from the PC marker to a friendly CU or a friendly controlled Walled City, Tribe or port.
Thank you very much. I've been looking for it all day because in several examples I've seen it being played incorrectly even though the rules said otherwise. I finally have it confirmed. You wrote your comment 5 years ago, but it is helpful.
Thank you for making these videotutorials, they're simply great!! A couple of things I am afraid are not correct: 1) baleares in the setup are chartaginian and not roman as shown in the slide of the setup video (not this one I have commented on) 2) during the reinforcement phase if the roman player doesn't have two 5 CU spaces, he/she must place the two consuls in the same 5 CU space (at least one space with 5 CU will always be available by definition) considering one of the two consuls as subordinate to the other.
There are restrictions on putting a reinforcement with 3 ops cards. Raise Troops (3 OP card only). If you played a 3 OP card, you may place 1 CU from the supply with one of your Generals who is in a friendly controlled space in a friendly controlled Province. You may not place this CU into a Walled City that is under Siege.
Sketch error/ animation error: the two previous cousls are drawn from the cup, not the two new generals, is Theis intentional? 10:42 Ps Can you select to keep YOUR previous proconsul?
@@harsh-rules Yeah because I do think it would be really really interesting to hear what are your top games of all time as of this moment, I have a feeling you have an interesting heavier longer games taste :)
Great work on this Ben! While not that complicated, the game is fairly difficult to learn and the rulebooks in the new edition do not help. The playbook is essentially useless.
![เป็นไปได้ไหม - WanMai [Performance Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Eh5hItD4Mr0/mqdefault.jpg)
![เปิดบ้าน โคตรสวย ป๋องกพล รู้จักตั้งนาน เพิ่งรู้ว่ารวย!!! l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tmgCF_2HfYI/mqdefault.jpg)
Mate, good video. One very important point though, at 4:46 you say that when a CU is placed under a General who doesnt have CUs, the general is displaced. You should say "enemy" general. If you put a friendly CUs under your general without CU, your general doesnt get displaced. Small but essential difference.
Thanks. Excellent work, but I think there's a little mistake. During the political isolation phase "Friendly PC" doesn't count for tracing another "Friendly PC" (unless it's also a friendly port or it has a friendly CU).
Rules 19.4:
...A PC marker is isolated if the player cannot trace a path of spaces from the PC marker to a friendly CU or a friendly controlled Walled City, Tribe or port.
Yes I think this is correct, friendly PC doesn't count for isolation check.
Thank you very much. I've been looking for it all day because in several examples I've seen it being played incorrectly even though the rules said otherwise. I finally have it confirmed. You wrote your comment 5 years ago, but it is helpful.
Great stuff! Can't wait to see the next episode of this. Excellent quality of work.
Thank you for making these videotutorials, they're simply great!!
A couple of things I am afraid are not correct:
1) baleares in the setup are chartaginian and not roman as shown in the slide of the setup video (not this one I have commented on)
2) during the reinforcement phase if the roman player doesn't have two 5 CU spaces, he/she must place the two consuls in the same 5 CU space (at least one space with 5 CU will always be available by definition) considering one of the two consuls as subordinate to the other.
Thanks for the clarification, Stefano.
Thank u, your work is much appreciated.
There are restrictions on putting a reinforcement with 3 ops cards. Raise Troops (3 OP card only). If you played a 3 OP card, you may place 1 CU from the supply with one of your Generals who is in a friendly controlled space in a friendly controlled Province. You may not place this CU into a Walled City that is under Siege.
Thank you for the Video. It's very easy professional... I am waiting for the rest...
Great job, excellent tutorial, awesome game
Amazing
Nice and clear.
Sketch error/ animation error: the two previous cousls are drawn from the cup, not the two new generals, is Theis intentional? 10:42
Ps Can you select to keep YOUR previous proconsul?
Hum the YOUR in Capital letters beacuse foreign autocorrect
This is the punic war version of the game twilight struggle.
Ben, so amazing that you put this one out. One quick question, is there any chance you may do Falling Sky one in near future?
I probably will eventually, but it won't be for a while. I've got a number of games to finish first.
@@harsh-rules Just knowing you actually will is amazing in itself Ben! Really a big thank you!
@@harsh-rules Also one additional question. Will you be making some kind of best games for you personally list? :)
@@lokihve6591, I've thought about doing some lists. This may be a feature that appears on the channel.
@@harsh-rules Yeah because I do think it would be really really interesting to hear what are your top games of all time as of this moment, I have a feeling you have an interesting heavier longer games taste :)
Great work on this Ben!
While not that complicated, the game is fairly difficult to learn and the rulebooks in the new edition do not help.
The playbook is essentially useless.
Yeah. Worst rulebook I ever read. I learned the game but had to search for every little rule and exception all around for no reason.
When dos the next epesod come out na d when Will you teach US hamilcar or the frist punic war
This weekend, Jorun. Hamilcar will follow the weekend after that.
When exactly Will it come out tomorow? That sould be realy exiting if it came tomorow
I have seen totoriols on the prewios Hannibal edition and the only chance i see is what africa which wasent in the previes edesions
When dos the next epesod come out anseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerrrrrrrrrrrrrer
Anser some of your coments
Thanks for the anser but Call me Christian pleas