First song by Joe I found. I was like “something about this voice gives me the same vibe as the guy from Hawaii Part ii” didn’t find out it was all connected until later.
LOL that's how i felt listening to "Sad" and being like "yo this guy kinda sound like the Art is dead guy" 💀 bo burnham is one of my favorites to this day
That happened with Tally Hall and Miracle Musical lol I won’t forget it was hilarious I was jump scared by the piano from the beginning of Murders bc Spotify thought it would be funny & I was like Wait this guy sounds like… TALLY HALL OH MY GOD lmao greatest discovery ever Then I got obsessed with Hawaii pt II & haven’t stopped lmao
If I had a nickel for everytime Joe Hawley created a song that spoke to me personally in a way no other piece of media ever had before, I’d have two nickels which isn’t a lot but it’s weird that it happened twice
Yeah that’s what I’m doing right now. I’ve known of Tally Hall for less than a year by now, and they’ve already become my favorite band and latest long running hyper fixation. Everyday feels like I spin a wheel of how I feel about the band. Will I be hopeful for the band’s future, will I grieve over a band I might never have the chance to hear new songs of, or will I just be happy with the music I have and jam out to Welcome to Tally Hall and Turn the Lights Off, etc. ? Obviously you know which of those days it was for me, but it is never 2 of the same days in a row, so tomorrow let’s just be grateful that we have such easy access to so much content that may have gone lost if it weren’t for fans’ dedication to preserve the work Five college boys with a few too many ties to chose from.
Joe Hawley’s my favourite tally hall member, I am really worried about his sanity recently and they way he’s going. I don’t think he needs therapy, the best thing will be to meet up with the others and stay out of the public light for a bit
This song relates to me so much and that's what I believe will make a good artpiece, whether it's a movie, show, song, painting or anything else. As long as you can connect to both the art, the artist and yourself in something you like, it's good. That's why your favorite song is your favorite song. You might just relate to it in someway you didn't expect, or you just like the way it sounds.
I like this song, im glad people reposted it, because Joe or a Hacker, took it down both on Spotify & TH-cam. I looked a long time for this on spotify, (probably on other streaming platforms aswell.) and I realised it was gone. thanks for this!
@@number2869 Joe is a strange man, He did the same thing with "Variations in a cloud" a few years ago, or maybe it has to do with the controversy he had this year, as far as I know, nothing is confirmed.
ive always found such a dramatic irony in all of that, especially knowing what we do now about him. i remember reading this interview from back when the band was just starting, that at one point contrasted the band members outlook on their future. they mentioned that it was likely temporary, with rob specifically saying they were open to things not panning out, returning to their regularly scheduled careers. and yet.. "But Hawley is optimistic: “We’re feeling like we’re onto something.” that quote stuck with me bad; hawley is optimistic. so many fans have pointed out (and correctly imo) that he seems to miss the band the most, though it's also been said that his own struggles led to the hiatus in the first place. life is unfair (the sky is blue) but. ouch
@@veravye It makes me so sad to think about that, literally everbody now has their own family's, careers and own personal projects, and Joe seems to be the only one who never moved on... It's sad because right now he's alone, doesn't have any support from anyone and he's still in denial that he has a mental problem, which makes it way worse, I really want him to get help and for him to feel better
@@AoiUsagiOtoko I think some people disliked Labyrinth mostly for its vast change in music style. A rap didn't really match the feel of all the other songs. Personally I love it though. All of the Hawaii pt ii songs are awesome
so there was a guy who basically hacked his way into joe's spotify account and then posted lots of trash music with controversial titles and it seems like he also removed this song and aristotle's denial
You could cut out the rap section and this song would be perfection. Maybe add more for the length I'm no pro. Average rap added or not this song is great and i wish all his stuff had this sound. The tunes the lyrics the voice all of it spot on!!
@@Quirksville guy who hacked joe hawley's distrokid (basically spotify) account and deleted sum shit like yes please &/or weird bed, yelwah eoj yelwah eoj, and special, i think special used to be the song with the most views idk
![Tally Hall but it's actually out of context [improved and expanded version] | Tally Hall](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/D_WBPeKvovM/mqdefault.jpg)
*SOBBING* YES YOU ARE SPECIAL JOE!
First song by Joe I found. I was like “something about this voice gives me the same vibe as the guy from Hawaii Part ii” didn’t find out it was all connected until later.
LOL that's how i felt listening to "Sad" and being like "yo this guy kinda sound like the Art is dead guy" 💀 bo burnham is one of my favorites to this day
That happened with Tally Hall and Miracle Musical lol
I won’t forget it was hilarious I was jump scared by the piano from the beginning of Murders bc Spotify thought it would be funny & I was like Wait this guy sounds like… TALLY HALL OH MY GOD lmao greatest discovery ever
Then I got obsessed with Hawaii pt II & haven’t stopped lmao
@@dimwittedecho HMMMMMM SAME HERE
@@Googol_0 LMAO NO WAY
@@dimwittedecho i see myself in the YT Music recap next year, only having hawaii p2 mmmm and good and evil
SO THAT'S WHERE "AN ABJECT HACKNEYED GAME" COMES FROM
?
OH SHIT I DIDNT REALISE THAT UNTIL YOU POINT IT OUT
correct
@@misscandy2873 do you realize I'm abject?
yo, im so confused 😭💀
If I had a nickel for everytime Joe Hawley created a song that spoke to me personally in a way no other piece of media ever had before, I’d have two nickels which isn’t a lot but it’s weird that it happened twice
PHINEAS AND FERB REFERENCE??!
🎼😎
What was the other one?? 👀👀
@@RainyyFlash
Spring and a storm 🙏🏼🙏🏼
@@Space_Prince That's so real honestly
damn i wish tally hall was one of those mainstream bands where even the most obscure videos relating to them had millions of views
too bad
@@PhantomLeaf what
they deserve it but would ruin the fun with a big fandom
@@thepinksantahat4739 would make it "good"
tally hall's fandom is just unfunny band kids
fr
@Moonwaltz9
I know we’re all here because it got taken off Spotify
And yt music
Yeah it sucks ngl
Yep.
I could agre, this song was spe-cial, You could agree this song was spe-cial, DO WE AGREE, THIS SONG WAS SPE-CIAL
nope, I just hate spotify, so I listen to music on youtube
this is probably my favorite song of all time
This is definitely my favorite song of all time
this is definitely one of the songs of all time
I FUCKING LOVE THIS SONG IT MAKES ME WANNA CRY JOE HALEY IS LITERALLY A LYRICAL GENIOUS 🩷🩷
fr bro best side projects of all the members
love him
Don’t know if this is the right word, but this song feels so homemade
that is literally what i felt when i first listened to this.
Yup
I wish he made more songs like this one, his other ones seem like the ramblings of a mad man.
I agree, but sometimes I need some madman ramblings too.
I mean... most of his other songs *are* ramblings of a mad man
Weird bed &/pr yes please?
2:20 goes back to the classic Joe "mad man" style for a moment
thats what makes them so great!
ur lyric videos really show me how many lyrics I just make up in my head
as a non-native english speaker i can relate in a deep level
i do this with songs i only hear on the radio and 99% of the time my lyrics are better than the original 💀 or maybe I just believe im special
whenever i feel bad about tally hall being gone i come back to this video and cry- it always helps me for some reason
Yeah that’s what I’m doing right now. I’ve known of Tally Hall for less than a year by now, and they’ve already become my favorite band and latest long running hyper fixation. Everyday feels like I spin a wheel of how I feel about the band. Will I be hopeful for the band’s future, will I grieve over a band I might never have the chance to hear new songs of, or will I just be happy with the music I have and jam out to Welcome to Tally Hall and Turn the Lights Off, etc. ?
Obviously you know which of those days it was for me, but it is never 2 of the same days in a row, so tomorrow let’s just be grateful that we have such easy access to so much content that may have gone lost if it weren’t for fans’ dedication to preserve the work Five college boys with a few too many ties to chose from.
You do not know them buddy
the proud loud guy we adore
is my amp too high?
@@scarlettetheroseno turn it up more
So grey in the back sippin gnac in here
@@rapvelasco1932 He's knocking down shots like bill laimbeer
Send home the locksmith, green's got keys
This song is so underrated and it makes me sad it was removed from Spotify
I agree
fr i was so sad when i saw it got taken off
Joe Hawley’s my favourite tally hall member, I am really worried about his sanity recently and they way he’s going. I don’t think he needs therapy, the best thing will be to meet up with the others and stay out of the public light for a bit
real though he needs to meet up with the guys and stuff
Every week I discover atleast one tally hall related song 🙏🏼
Joe you are very special :')
This song relates to me so much and that's what I believe will make a good artpiece, whether it's a movie, show, song, painting or anything else. As long as you can connect to both the art, the artist and yourself in something you like, it's good. That's why your favorite song is your favorite song. You might just relate to it in someway you didn't expect, or you just like the way it sounds.
I like this song, im glad people reposted it, because Joe or a Hacker, took it down both on Spotify & TH-cam. I looked a long time for this on spotify, (probably on other streaming platforms aswell.)
and I realised it was gone. thanks for this!
He is very special
Only three comments for this song? It's so good!
I'm sad that this got taken off Spotify.. ;(
SOME IDIOT JUST GOT ON JOE HAWLEY'S DISTROKID ACOUNT AND JUST FUCKING DELETED IT (why.... WHY?!?!?)
I just discovered that today and I'm very sad, it was one of my favorite songs and now I can't listen to it there anymore :(
Is it still?
Nvm, but do you guys know why it was removed?
@@number2869 Joe is a strange man, He did the same thing with "Variations in a cloud" a few years ago, or maybe it has to do with the controversy he had this year, as far as I know, nothing is confirmed.
i love this song that joe made ITS SO GOOD AND IT LOWKEY MAKES ME SAD
Thanks for keeping this song up!
Yup, I'm crying now
joe hawley pls bring this back on spotify pls
Good soup
This being removed from spotify was unfortunate. I wouldn't really care about YEYE if it weren't for Aristotle's denial.
It has been removed from all streaming platforms :(
Why?
@@person3134 I'd like to know too
@@Guerradossantos10 some script kiddie got into his account and messed with it probably.
When you realise this song is about how Joe misses Tally Hall
SOBBING
CRYING
how so?
LITERALLY BAWLING RN
I AM BECOME SADNESS
Let's be real here:
Do You Agree Tally Hall Was *Special?*
Yes, very much
yeah
Yes
yes
y*s
this is the most beautiful song i've heard tonight
I’m pretty sure this song is about how Joe misses Tally Hall :( so sad
It’s so obvious that he want to reunite with them like how we want them too
it genuinely makes me sad cause you can tell he misses it but everyone else moved on
@@sleepy_parrot omg who towel
@@sleepy_parrotEverybody moved on... Help I'm still at the restaurant...
ive always found such a dramatic irony in all of that, especially knowing what we do now about him. i remember reading this interview from back when the band was just starting, that at one point contrasted the band members outlook on their future. they mentioned that it was likely temporary, with rob specifically saying they were open to things not panning out, returning to their regularly scheduled careers. and yet.. "But Hawley is optimistic: “We’re feeling like we’re onto something.” that quote stuck with me bad; hawley is optimistic. so many fans have pointed out (and correctly imo) that he seems to miss the band the most, though it's also been said that his own struggles led to the hiatus in the first place. life is unfair (the sky is blue) but. ouch
@@veravye It makes me so sad to think about that, literally everbody now has their own family's, careers and own personal projects, and Joe seems to be the only one who never moved on... It's sad because right now he's alone, doesn't have any support from anyone and he's still in denial that he has a mental problem, which makes it way worse, I really want him to get help and for him to feel better
I didn't like the second part, but the is song so good in general
yes!!!
yeah, i do agree
Who's here after this song was removed from spotify
me
Hope this returns to spotify
see when i read these comments i was expecting the rap to be yk. bad. it’s not that bad guys 💀
i like it tbh! never understood why people were so weird about it (or the rap in labyrinth for that matter, that one's good!)
I really like the rap part idk why people don’t like it but it’s their opinion I guess
@@AoiUsagiOtoko I think some people disliked Labyrinth mostly for its vast change in music style. A rap didn't really match the feel of all the other songs. Personally I love it though. All of the Hawaii pt ii songs are awesome
it’s just so annoying because i think it’s ever so slightly off beat, i don’t care that it’s rap
this song reminds me of summer 2016
i think this is a song about day dreaming. because i day dream alot and the lyrics are pretty accurate
if this ever comes back on spotify id listen to it on repeat
why was this song removed (I just found out abt this song and that it’s been removed from like, every platform)?
so there was a guy who basically hacked his way into joe's spotify account and then posted lots of trash music with controversial titles and it seems like he also removed this song and aristotle's denial
The ending lick is the same as the Just Apathy 2005 version
So unfortunate that this song is not in Spotify... Is so lovely
No longer on Spotify, nor the original video, this my favorite song ever 'cause I too wonder if I'm special
You could cut out the rap section and this song would be perfection. Maybe add more for the length I'm no pro. Average rap added or not this song is great and i wish all his stuff had this sound. The tunes the lyrics the voice all of it spot on!!
hahaha why would you upload this im crying so hard WHY PLEASE I LOVE & HATE THIS HELP
Reading these lyrics while remembering the tally hall music videos just makes me sad cause he just misses them a loy
am i the only one who really likes the rap part
yes
I like it too man 😔
what is it with tally hall fans and hating rap, like actually
@@sillyabluble_fr
@@sillyabluble_ its not just tally hall fans, ive seen other communities where most of them dislike rap in songs
is the album cover Strichy?
looks more like a fish to me
I want this on Spotify
it was but got deleted by the jay mason situation
@@CatMew54 Who tf is Jay Mason
@@Quirksville guy who hacked joe hawley's distrokid (basically spotify) account and deleted sum shit like yes please &/or weird bed, yelwah eoj yelwah eoj, and special, i think special used to be the song with the most views idk
@@CatMew54 Honestly didn't know anyone even actually knew the name of the person who did that
@@Quirksville yea idk how they figured it out either, maybe jason said that himself?
why was this removed from spotify
He got hacked (and Spotify took it down but I have no idea about that)
@@Noodles_Poodle what is so bad about this that Spotify took it down 💀
@@BlueCanaryNightLight I have no idea
Sad song
GODDAMN this is good
Bro it disappeared from his profile
Yeah it did. It’s a shame, that song was so good too 😢
I wonder if he’ll bring it back to his profile he does that sometimes like with his twitter
@@Heartsfornoneyeah there's also a chance he got hacked again
do u guys know why it was removed from like every platform?
@@number2869someone hacked his distrokid account, deleted a bunch of songs, and added some weird stuff, and i think locked him out of his account :c
I could absolutely see this as a duet sung between Fionna and Cake
Mfw the boss is Joe Hawley: 😮
It does fit lol
Or maybe a Simon and Betty idk
@@BlueCanaryNightLight simon... haven't i heard that name before?
@@carsicclResident Simon (Mind Electric (i forgot what demo))
Oh Frick. You're right. It gives adventure time vibes, and now I won't unhear it
I feel better now :)
Nevermind
I swear this has got to be the most relatable song ever
@@BeanKallyIT IS!!!
Special come back noooo...
He doesnt sound ok...
I mean, considering… you know… he DEFINITELY wasn’t
his voice quivers in this song more than usual, it usually does when he sings live though
Struggling schizophrenic pretending to be a struggling artist is my favorite genre
💀
ouch
Dawg 💀😭😭
chonny jash
Mr. Jash lol
This song reminds of 'stupid stupid world' from the talking kitty cat series.
Rip Steve Cash.. :(
it sounds like a christmas song not gonna lie
so sad this is off Spotify
* guys I have a character who’s voice claim is joe Hawley and this song just reminds me why I love the character so much 💀
I feel so bad for you in hindsite
"faker than pro wrestling" LMAOOOO
I honestly don't know how to feel about this song anymore...
why’s that?
@@gnomeyrmmThe Joe Hawley Doc
@@theguywhobashedhishead3times that’s why you separate the art from the artist :D
@@gnomeyrmm i already did; i love them the same way before i saw the joe Hawley doc
@@gnomeyrmm It's pretty hard to do that with this song, since it's directly talking about tally hall
I cry everytime i listen to this song, this is so dumb
what the labyrinth is that rap
What the scallop!!
Justice for the rap part it’s god tier
@@TheHadrian naur
There is no way this song was made including a Homestuck composer
wait hold on really
Homestuck mentioned.
Yep! Marcy Nabors is a big Tally Hall fan, and so is Michael Guy Bowman. Also Andrew Hussie did the art for the Cojum Dip album booklet.
Does anyone else hear “It’s you I like” from Mr. Roger’s Neighborhood? I think that might be intentional.
REAL
Mornuh
.
Why was this taken off of Spotify?
His account got hacked
@@dankm3m3s66 Let’s hope it goes back, it’s on one of my most listened to playlists! Tally Hall/ Joe Hawley make amazing music.
Why tf did he even remove this on spotify?
Was he feelin guilty to the point he blieves he's not so special...
No, he's deleted it BEFORE the allegations
The allegations have nothing to do with this though he was hacked
I dunno this feels like a demo to chonny jash's cover
everything sounds like a chonny jash cover demo he changes the songs so much
Shut up bro, Chonny is so overrated
@@callampas i agree
@callampas I do agree chonny jash is overrated but you don't have to be rude about it
@@callampas💔
I feel like this song could have been so much better without the rap part
Imagine if kanye did the vocals though😉
hoemstcuk
homestuck??????????????????
HOMESTUCK!
homestuck🙂