I think Gnarls is the only one I like on amber island more, it had a more soothing sound, it didn't overpower most of the monsters in its verse, and had a nice ring to it.
Some monsters(for example; Flum Ox) are still good on amber island, but the expansion just gave these underrated quads and quints the life they were looking for!😅
@@MushStogg some monsters weren’t bad, no, but they still had room for improvement solely because of how limited their roles were at the time… now they feel special on their new forever-homes!!!
For y’all complaining about amber island, it’s such a big island that if every monster played more than once and had multiple tracks the island would sound way too crowded unless they made the song really really long and it’s already like the second longest song after continent which also had to limit the fire monsters for the same reason, hence why most of these monsters seemed underused until this update
Before the Fire Expansion people were like "These Rares don't really fit on Amber Island tho" Now, with the Fire Expansion, we can see perfectly how every Rare Quad fits really well with their respect Magical Island
For the circumstances of yelmut obviously expansion is better but what i wonder is what would it be like if dave was there for it. Light yelmut will forever be my favorite because of the fact that they made a yelling screaching monster sound calm
Do you mean light instead of bone? And I agree with your thoughts on it. I do wish they had someone else to do it on amber so it wasn't just continent again.
Bowheads redemption started on phsycic island! (I'm not saying it was bad before phsycic island) I hope it will continue to redeem itself in dawn of fire!
yelmut - fire expansion flum ox -fire expansion krillby-Amber Island edamimi-Amber Island pongping- Amber Island tiawa- fire expansion bisonorus-Amber Island Incisaur- Fire Expansion Candelavra-Fire Expansion Bowhead-Fire Expansion Drummidary-Fire Expansion Tuskski-Amber Island Gnarls- Fire Expansion
I find it interesting how if fire replaced the cold element on the natural islands, Edamimi would be on plant Island, Flum Ox would be on air island, Tring would be on earth Island, and the only island without the fire element is water Island. I didn't include Bisonorus because it doesn't relate to fire/cold as much as Edamimi relates to plant
It’s “interesting” that replacing cold with fire makes a pattern of quads on the natural islands that match the island elements even though it actually doesn’t because Bisonorus and Flum ox have no relation (in design) to their elements and it excludes an island. P.S. floating does not make a connection to air, that is dumb.
Fire expansion was aa miracle for msm last year. Light island was the worst now its in my top 3 fav islands and the monsters have a time to shine on different island🎉🎉🎉😊
My picks are Yelmut: Both Flum-Ox: Bone Krillby: Amber Edamimi: Both Pongping: Both Tiawa: Light Bisonorus: Psychic Incisaur: Both Candelavra: Amber Bowhead: Psychic Drummidary: Amber Tuskski: Both Gnarls: Both
Kinda weird how Gnarls went from saying "Yayayaya" in Amber Island to "Nyanyanyanya" in Bone Island I mean, it's probably supposed to say "Nya" (because that's the way you pronounce Gnarls, it's "Nyarls" not "Yarls"), but still, kinda weird that they did it that way on Amber Island
Imma go down a line Fire is Fire Expansion amber is amber island Yelmut: Fire Amber Flum ox:Fire Amber Krillby:Fire Edamimi:Fire Fishchamp:Fire Tiawa:Amber Incisaur:Fire Bisonsaurus: Fire Amber Candelarva:Fire Amber Bowhead: 100% Fire Drummidary: Amber Tuskski: Fire cause it duets well with its Cloud island sound Gnarls: Amber island for sure
This feels like that baby vs. hydrogen bomb meme, except Amber Island is the baby and Fire Expansion is the hydrogen bomb. Amber island literally cannot win in this case.
My Ratings for Fire Expansion and Amber Yelmut: Fire Expansion Flum Ox: Fire Expansion Krillby: Fire Expansion Edamimi: Fire Expansion Pongping: Amber Tiawa: Amber Bisonorus: Amber Incisaur: Fire Expansion Candelavra: Fire Expansion Bowhead: Fire Expansion Drummidary: Fire Expansion Tuskski: Amber Gnarls: Fire Expansion Fire Expansion: 9 Amber: 4 Fire Expansion Wins 🎉
Fire Expansion or Amber Island? 🔥
Fire expansion
Amber, loved to see it progress slower than just a clump of surprises
Amber
Amber... Is what I would have said if I had lost my mind, fire expansion everyday! (Well except for Gnarls, I like him on an Amber better)
Why not both?
I think Gnarls is the only one I like on amber island more, it had a more soothing sound, it didn't overpower most of the monsters in its verse, and had a nice ring to it.
Agreed
Indeed
Same
Totally
DIDN’T overpower?
Some monsters(for example; Flum Ox) are still good on amber island, but the expansion just gave these underrated quads and quints the life they were looking for!😅
Come on they weren’t that bad
@@MushStogg some monsters weren’t bad, no, but they still had room for improvement solely because of how limited their roles were at the time… now they feel special on their new forever-homes!!!
They most definitely Bowhead an improvement in psychic island 😄
The monster handlers gave us our wish
Same with candelavra on fire haven
For y’all complaining about amber island, it’s such a big island that if every monster played more than once and had multiple tracks the island would sound way too crowded unless they made the song really really long and it’s already like the second longest song after continent which also had to limit the fire monsters for the same reason, hence why most of these monsters seemed underused until this update
While I agree about this but my counterpoint is, Continent exists and is more crowded and more better than Amber Island
Then they made magical nexus and proved they can 100% make it work
@@etheron1235 the Continent isn't crowded because it has so many parts to it imo.
Gold island and continent exist and are way better?????
@@M0rtalated you’d be surprised how little some monsters play if you really payed attention
Bowhead is beautiful in psychic island
He even plays through the whole song
Yeah cause in amber island it's so short
Before the Fire Expansion people were like "These Rares don't really fit on Amber Island tho"
Now, with the Fire Expansion, we can see perfectly how every Rare Quad fits really well with their respect Magical Island
Rare Krillby doesnt really fit faerie tho
@@kaidayuri5526Imo it does
@@kaidayuri5526wdym yes he does
@@kaidayuri5526hes green which could fit cloverspell and the light blue color matches with the floor
@@kaidayuri5526 It does imo
Fire expansion is so much better
You betcha!
Some times
@@Nike-dm8yi*every single time
The exception is flum ox, who I think sounds better on amber island
@@GOOSEBUMPS_FOR_DUMMIES 😊
The best part from the Fire Expansion is obviously the quints, they sound amazing in Magical Islands
It’s still weird hearing Yelmut like this on Light Island. It’s good but still getting used to it.
Fire expansion improved the magical islands and the monsters so much
For the circumstances of yelmut obviously expansion is better but what i wonder is what would it be like if dave was there for it. Light yelmut will forever be my favorite because of the fact that they made a yelling screaching monster sound calm
Do you mean light instead of bone? And I agree with your thoughts on it. I do wish they had someone else to do it on amber so it wasn't just continent again.
@@JustAnAcorn yeah light
fr! i love fire expansion yelmut
Gnarls Amber Island Sound 6:25 is the only one that is better than it’s fire expansion counterpart.
Bowheads redemption started on phsycic island! (I'm not saying it was bad before phsycic island) I hope it will continue to redeem itself in dawn of fire!
I like the idea of giving one off monsters another chance to shine
Same riff raff, let's them show that they're better than they seem
Some of the naturals need more chances too, like entbrat, riff, and shellbeat
I agree
@@ThatOneRedBoithey also have 2 islands, exception is deedge on shugabush
#werememberwhatyoudidriff
0:32 I always thought she was saying Hellllllll yeaaaaaaah
I feel like he yells/sounds more like a boy but monsters don’t have genders
How it should go
Bisonorus Yelmut Flum Ox krillby Edamimi Pongping Incisaur Tiawa Candelavra Drummidary Bowhead Tuskski Gnarls
What do you mean?
yelmut - fire expansion
flum ox -fire expansion
krillby-Amber Island
edamimi-Amber Island
pongping- Amber Island
tiawa- fire expansion
bisonorus-Amber Island
Incisaur- Fire Expansion
Candelavra-Fire Expansion
Bowhead-Fire Expansion
Drummidary-Fire Expansion
Tuskski-Amber Island
Gnarls- Fire Expansion
Your crazy for thinking tuskski is better on amber island, the fire expansion helped tuskski so much.
lol
@@prolouis
Drummidarys hop is so cute
DRUMMIDARY AND BOWHEAD RULE LIGHT AND PSYCHIC ISLANDS SO HARD🔥🔥🔥👍👍🦀🐋
Fire Expansion > Amber Island
Truuuuue
I love this update!
I love Amber but the fire quads and quints on the magical island just sound better. Tho some are better on Amber.
I find it interesting how if fire replaced the cold element on the natural islands, Edamimi would be on plant Island, Flum Ox would be on air island, Tring would be on earth Island, and the only island without the fire element is water Island. I didn't include Bisonorus because it doesn't relate to fire/cold as much as Edamimi relates to plant
Also gnarls
@@AskAuyong Drummidary is technically the earth quint and can be bred with Quarrister and Kayna
It’s “interesting” that replacing cold with fire makes a pattern of quads on the natural islands that match the island elements even though it actually doesn’t because Bisonorus and Flum ox have no relation (in design) to their elements and it excludes an island.
P.S. floating does not make a connection to air, that is dumb.
They redeemed themselves for the atrocity that Amber island caused.
Exaggeration at its finest
Least dramatic MSM fan
Poopy.
Keep up the great work 👍
I actually like amber more. Hear me out, I love expansion. But some monsters don’t fit on the island they’re on. Everyone fits on amber island.
Bowhead playing through the full song of psychic is so cool
Fire expansion was aa miracle for msm last year. Light island was the worst now its in my top 3 fav islands and the monsters have a time to shine on different island🎉🎉🎉😊
It’s the fact they used Yelmut’s Continent Track and made it sound worse.
Light Island is so much better for him.
While I love Amber Island’s song more than the magical islands, I prefer the sounds from Fire Expansion a bit more.
I would ask gnarls to shut up!
Fire expansion definitely has better sounds because of the bigger variety
1:50 2:53 3:49 5:36
Boskus sounds catchy in Amber Island! The “bzzlubbzzlubbubbubBUBAbut.” Is so good but also funny and goofy!
6:29 Just hits different
I can’t decide which island incisaur sounds best on? Both are very unique and different! 🤔
Judging from the animations, I would say the Bone one.
MPG can you do more MSM the lost landscape pls❤
It's shut down
I really like Krillby's little dance on the fairy island
wait i didnt realize im early
hi msmpokergamer
Good video dude
AAAAAA
Who wins? (My opinion)
Yelmut: Amber
Flum ox: Amber
Krillby: Expansion
Edamimi: Amber
Pong ping: Amber
Tiawa: Expansion
Bisonorus: Expansion
Incisaur: Amber
Candelavra: Expansion
Bowhead: Expansion
Drummidary: Expansion
Tuskski: Amber
Gnarls: Expansion
Expansion: 7 points
Amber: 6 points
Expansion wins!
Tbh when tuskski first released I didn't think it was real cause it looked so out of place to me
Same but for me with Gnarls. I saw a YT short and I thought it was fanmade.
Same, I thought it was fan made
Yeyeyeyeye
My picks are
Yelmut: Both
Flum-Ox: Bone
Krillby: Amber
Edamimi: Both
Pongping: Both
Tiawa: Light
Bisonorus: Psychic
Incisaur: Both
Candelavra: Amber
Bowhead: Psychic
Drummidary: Amber
Tuskski: Both
Gnarls: Both
Bone?
Kinda weird how Gnarls went from saying "Yayayaya" in Amber Island to "Nyanyanyanya" in Bone Island
I mean, it's probably supposed to say "Nya" (because that's the way you pronounce Gnarls, it's "Nyarls" not "Yarls"), but still, kinda weird that they did it that way on Amber Island
Is yelmut an enchandling monster?
Bowhead on amber: 😑
Bowhead on Expansion: 🫨
Yelmut hit puberty on the way to light island
Fire E. Amber
Yelmut yes
Flum Ox yes
Krillby yes
Edamimi yes
PongPing yes
Tiawa yes
Bisonourus yes
İncisaur yes
Candalevra yes
Bowhead yes
Drummidary yes
Tuskski yes
Gnarls yes
Totals 8 5
Winner: Fire Expansion
Imma go down a line
Fire is Fire Expansion amber is amber island
Yelmut: Fire Amber
Flum ox:Fire Amber
Krillby:Fire
Edamimi:Fire
Fishchamp:Fire
Tiawa:Amber
Incisaur:Fire
Bisonsaurus: Fire Amber
Candelarva:Fire Amber
Bowhead: 100% Fire
Drummidary: Amber
Tuskski: Fire cause it duets well with its Cloud island sound
Gnarls: Amber island for sure
Why is mpg still doing fire expansion content
Cuz he can
ur my childhood
And I’m the cheese orb
Noice
YEEEEEEEESS
Yelmut: amber +1
Flum ox: amber +1
Krillby: fairy +1
Edamimi: amber +1
Pongping: fairy +1
Tiawa: light +1
Bisonorus: amber +1
Incisaur: bone (duh lol) +1
Candelavra: haven +1
Bowhead: psychic (duh again lol) +1
Drummidary: amber +1
Tuskski: fairy (duh part 3) +1
Gnarls: amber (biggest "duh" of the century) +1
Amber= 6
Fire expansion= 7
In *MY* opinion they're both equally good
here before fish champ🤫🧏🥺🔥
This feels like that baby vs. hydrogen bomb meme, except Amber Island is the baby and Fire Expansion is the hydrogen bomb. Amber island literally cannot win in this case.
I think Amber Island Flum Ox is way better than Bone Island
Light yelmuth exploding amber
W MPG AND FIRE EXPANSION 4:30 4:35.
yelmut sounds nice, it finally takes a rest on the voice
Which is better (IMO);
Yelmut - Amber
Flum Ox - Amber
Krillby - Expansion
Edamimi - Expansion
PongPing - Expansion
Tiawa - Amber
Bisinorous - Amber
Incisor - Expansion
Candelavara - Expansion
Bowhead - Expansion
Drummidary - Expansion
Tuskskiki - Expansion
Gnarls - Amber
Amber < Expansion
5 8
Yelmut makes Light island 100% Better
0:47 the best in the universe
It’s crazy how much every single monster improved with Fire Expansion
I like drummidarys first track on amber island better, it’s so mythical and is s tier in sound
Gnarls goes hard on bone i love it
the video was one minute ago when this comment existed
Everyone is singing sick
I swear I heard a trumpet in gnarls sound
Drummidary is my favorite quint
I Like amber Island
(My opinion Dont attack me)
Ethereal workshop in composer please but composer island
1:20 reminds of snail bob
Amber def my fav island
Top 10 rap battles of history 🔥🔥🔥🔥🗣🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🗣🗣🗣
I'm getting yelmut tomorrow on light island 😎
Now i have it 😎
Time for bowhead on psychic island.
Flum Ox is the avatar!
If gnarls has shrub arms vivine bush entbrat horns and flowah heads is he the plant king?
Yes sir
Fire expansion ❤
YO KRILLBY GOT THOSE MOVES
Fire expainsion!!!!!!!!! ❤🔥🔥
My Ratings for Fire Expansion and Amber
Yelmut: Fire Expansion
Flum Ox: Fire Expansion
Krillby: Fire Expansion
Edamimi: Fire Expansion
Pongping: Amber
Tiawa: Amber
Bisonorus: Amber
Incisaur: Fire Expansion
Candelavra: Fire Expansion
Bowhead: Fire Expansion
Drummidary: Fire Expansion
Tuskski: Amber
Gnarls: Fire Expansion
Fire Expansion: 9
Amber: 4
Fire Expansion Wins 🎉
Rating each :))
Amber Yelmut: 2/10
Light Yelmut: 10/10
Amber Tiawa: 8/10
Light Tiawa: 10/10
Amber Drummidary: 5/10
Light Drummidary: 10/10
Amber Edamimi: 7/10
Psychic Edamimi: 9/10
Amber Bisonorus: 10/10
Psychic Bisonorus: 8/10
Amber Bowhead: 5/10
Psychic Bowhead: 10/10
Amber Pongping: 4/10
Faerie Pongping: 8/10
Amber Krillby: 8.5/10
Faerie Krillby: 10/10
Amber Tuskski: 9/10
Faerie Tuskski: 10/10
Bone Incisaur: 7/10
Amber Incisaur: 2/10
Bone Flum Ox: 10/10
Amber Flum Ox: 10/10
Amber Gnarls: 10/10
Bone Gnarls: 9/10
Haven Candelavra: 10/10
Amber Candelavra: 3/10
Tiawa
My Favorite is Tuskski And Krillby
🔥 this is fire
for how many likes this comment gets the fire gets bigger
But what if I said "Nuh uh"
This was not a comp
They took my idea for rare Tuskiski
My opnion is 11 x 8 11 is a Equespashon of Fire 8 is a Amber Island❤❤🔥
Amber island was fine but Fire expansion, it has fire in the name for a reason, just let me say that.
Amber for sure
why is this video like 2 months late lol
FIRE EXPANSION: INFINITE FIRE
HEYYYYYYYYYY AHHH HAEYYYYy!!!!
Yelmut light island = That one cup of water at 3AM☠️😭
WoW
msm favours Faerie island🤯
MSMpokegGamer ITS MY YOU FRIEND IN DOF