That was actually a solid list by Mad Dog. I was shocked he didn’t include any of his Yankees players. Alanna’s list was ROUGH. Ranking SS Corey Seager over OF Mike Trout because she thinks Trout gets injured too much; Seager has a lengthy injury history himself. Then she put in C Salvador Perez at #10, & OF Aaron Judge at #11 despite him debuting way later than 2009.
If Freeman is a lock then Goldschmidt is a lock. There’s not much of a difference if at all between them. If anything Goldschmidt should be more of a lock because he came up later than Freeman yet the counting stats and hardware all around are pretty close,and Goldschmidt’s MVP was in a full season.
What do people keep saying wasting mookie’s arm? You can make him the deepest cut off man. Put Ohtani or anyone who can’t throw as far in right field and you have a soft toss into a cannon.
Posey have 3 World Series, an mvp and a batting title as a catcher. But is 1500 hit, 150 home runs less than 400 doubles and not even 1000 rbi really a hof?
Yes cause he played in the most pitching friendly ball park in the league without great offensive teams around him and is a catcher who got the most out of his pitchers and was the power in big games...you have to watch him play to understand why he is a first ballot hofer
Perez shout out...also seager at 6 is wild with no paul
Miggy and pujols were still great early on during this run...i might slide one in at 10th and the other at 11...just me personally
Is Mad Dog possible of talking about baseball without mentioning Joe DiMaggio?
That was actually a solid list by Mad Dog. I was shocked he didn’t include any of his Yankees players.
Alanna’s list was ROUGH. Ranking SS Corey Seager over OF Mike Trout because she thinks Trout gets injured too much; Seager has a lengthy injury history himself. Then she put in C Salvador Perez at #10, & OF Aaron Judge at #11 despite him debuting way later than 2009.
Lol mad dog hates the Yankees
Her list was absolutely horrid. She also didn't penalize Harper for missing games but him and Trout have almost identical games played
Bryce Harper was on the cover of SI when he was 16 not 19.
Mookie at 9 is ridiculous
I think he was 2
@@kcmoosedong6471the list starts from 10-1 like how most list do for anticipation
Did mad dog have 10 i counted 9
Well..Machado has been victims of the system, he is a mvp caliber player and a gold glove too.
How is Freddie a HOF lock and Goldschmidt borderline?
Alana Rizzo's list may be the worst list of all time
Naw she’s valid
@@Daniel.dariz65you are tweaking
@@DanielDowlingNo😐
@@Daniel.dariz65 justify this list
@@DanielDowlingnaw I’m watching the laker game
Why does he say Anaheim when it's clearly LA
If Freeman is a lock then Goldschmidt is a lock. There’s not much of a difference if at all between them. If anything Goldschmidt should be more of a lock because he came up later than Freeman yet the counting stats and hardware all around are pretty close,and Goldschmidt’s MVP was in a full season.
What do people keep saying wasting mookie’s arm? You can make him the deepest cut off man. Put Ohtani or anyone who can’t throw as far in right field and you have a soft toss into a cannon.
Lmao Freeman at 1. Mad dog easily won this list
Posey have 3 World Series, an mvp and a batting title as a catcher. But is 1500 hit, 150 home runs less than 400 doubles and not even 1000 rbi really a hof?
Yes cause he played in the most pitching friendly ball park in the league without great offensive teams around him and is a catcher who got the most out of his pitchers and was the power in big games...you have to watch him play to understand why he is a first ballot hofer
Betts, Judge, Ohtani, Freddie, Harper and Altuve over trout any day of the week.
How tf trout is at first? What so good about him? The guy can’t even stay healthy
Alanna burner account
@@nathanaelhelder573 didn’t even deserve to win them MVPs
@@user-vx5qg7hj5t sure.
@@user-vx5qg7hj5ttrolling
Trout is not the best player anymore. Her list absolutely sucks
judge sucks
@@matthewwang1075 they both suck
true😂